IPR call reminder:
|
"I draw your attention to your
obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations' IPR policies. Every
Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner
Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the
Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become
essential to the work of 3GPP. Delegates are asked to take note that they
are thereby invited:
|
Antitrust policy Reminder:
|
"I
also draw your attention to the fact that 3GPP activities are subject to all
applicable antitrust and competition laws and that compliance with said laws
is therefore required of any participant of this TSG/WG meeting including the
Chairman and Vice Chairman. In case of question I recommend that you contact
your legal counsel. The
leadership shall conduct the present meeting with impartiality and in the
interests of 3GPP. Furthermore,
I would like to remind you that timely submission of work items in advance of
TSG/WG meetings is important to allow for full and fair consideration of such
matters." |
| AI | TD# | Type | Doc For | Subject | Source | Rel | Comments | e-mail_Discussion | Result |
| 0 | - | - | - | All Agenda Items | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 1.1 | - | - | - | Opening of the meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 2 | - | - | - | Agenda | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 2 | S2-2006780 | AGENDA | Approval | SA WG2 #141E Meeting Agenda | SA WG2 Chair | Approved | Approved | ||
| 3 | - | - | - | SA2#140E Meeting report | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 3 | S2-2006781 | REPORT | Approval | Auto-Generated Report of SA WG2 meeting #140E | SA WG2 Secretary | Approved | Approved | ||
| 4 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Common issues and Incoming LSs | - | - | Docs:=39 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Previously postponed | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006786 | LS In | Information | LS from 5G-ACIA (5G Alliance for Connected Industries and Automation): 5G capabilities exposure for factories of the future | 5G-ACIA (5G-ACIA_ LS_3GPP_Exposure_29062020) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2004788 from S2#140E. Noted | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006782 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3LI: LS on Location information for SMS over IMS | SA WG3LI (S3i200161) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004771 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008329. | George (Ericsson) would like to postpone this to next meeting We will have a CR and LS response Hannu (Nokia) supports George (Ericsson) to postpone as the LS requires SA2 action. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006789 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on maximum number of UP resources supported by NB-N1 mode UEs | CT WG1 (C1-204083) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004798 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008332. | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006794 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on SA5 Rel-17 work on SLA | SA WG5 (S5-203370) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004812 from S2#140E. Noted | Alessio(Nokia) suggests to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006787 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on mandate to provide any PLMN entry in the non-3GPP access node selection information | CT WG1 (C1-204034) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004796 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008331. | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2007289 | CR | Agreement | 23.501 CR2402R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting preventing of home routing due to 'any PLMN' requirement | BlackBerry UK Ltd., Rogers Communications Canada | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004947 from S2#140E. R01 Endorsed | Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments. Laurent (Nokia): objects for approval of a Rel17 CR at this meeting. And asks questions John-Luc (BlackBerry) provides responses to Sangsoo & Laurant. We suggest to focus on technical aspects before focussing on the release. Laurent (Nokia): to make it clear I OBJECT to any R17 CR for approval. Stefano (Qualcomm) support's Nokia position: we shall not approve Rel. 17 CRs and trigger the creation of Rel. 17 version of the TSs. Replying to Laurent, Stefano: the CR is for endorsement === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Endorsed |
| 4.1 | S2-2007290 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response to LS on the mandate to provide 'any PLMN' entry in the non-3GPP access node selection information | BlackBerry UK Ltd. | Response to S2-2004948 (Noted to at S2#140E). R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008009 | Laurent (Nokia): proposes r01 Provides r02. John-Luc (BlackBerry) provides r02. Laurent (Nokia): OBJECTS to r00; John-Luc (BlackBerry) prefers r02. Objects to r01 because of the missing attachment. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised | |
| 4.1 | S2-2008009 | LS OUT | Approval | Response to LS on the mandate to provide 'any PLMN' entry in the non-3GPP access node selection information | SA WG2 | - | Revision of S2-2007290. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006798 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on dynamic 5QIs | SA WG5 (S5-204443) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2005876 from S2#140E. Response drafted in S2-2006930. Final response in S2-2006930 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006930 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on dynamic 5QIs | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006798. Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | For action | - | - | Docs:=17 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006806 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on AUSF/UDM discovery based on SUCI information | CT WG4 (C4-204337) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2006906. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008337. | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to postpone the LS to next meeting... === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006906 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on AUSF/UDM discovery based on SUCI information | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2006806. Postponed | Verizon (Sudhakar Patil) proposes to postpone LSOUT to next meeting. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports proposal to postpone the LS out to next meeting... Devaki (Nokia) fine to postpone the response LS out. Yi (China Mobile) responds. LiMeng (Huawei) responds. Devaki (Nokia) is OK to send the LS out or to postpone. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2006905 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on AUSF/UDM discovery based on SUCI information. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2007159 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2478 (Rel-17, 'B'): AUSF/UDM discovery based SUCI information | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Antoine (Orange) : this Rel-17 pCR should be POSTPONED. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2007160 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2416 (Rel-17, 'B'): AUSF/UDM discovery based SUCI information | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Antoine (Orange) : this Rel-17 pCR should be POSTPONED. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2007161 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on AUSF/UDM discovery based on SUCI information | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Sudhakar Patil (Verizon) proposes to postpone LSOUT to next meeting. Sudhakar Patil (Verizon) proposes to postpone LSOUT to next meeting. Resubmitting to remove a space which was introduced by mistake. Devaki (Nokia) fine to postpone the response LS out. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2006813 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Response LS to TSG SA on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | RAN WG2 (R2-2008643) | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS Laurent (Nokia): questions the need of this CR Qian (Ericsson): Agrees with Nokia on the need of the CR and provide further info Qian (Ericsson): Agrees with Nokia on the need of the CR and provide further info on NGAP. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia), Qian (Ericsson) and give the reason for the CR Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR since it is incorrect and creates misalignment with stage-3 Laurent (Nokia) also objects to the CR for the reason indicated in this mail exchange (me, Qian and haris) Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia) and Qian (Ericsson) and give the reason for the CR is needed Haris (Qualcomm) comments and sustains objection Jianhua (OPPO) ask questions whether to mandate full data rate UPIP to NR-DC and NE-DC as informed by RAN2 LS? Wanqiang (Huawei) responds the question from OPPO. Guillaume (MediaTek) shares the views expressed by Ericsson, Nokia and Qualcomm. Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends the same handling as for 7178 (should be noted). Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports proposal to note this LS. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to the comments from Qualcomm and provide R01 Xiaowan(vivo) replies to the comments from Qualcomm and all. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2007178 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2480 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment changes on user plane Integrity Protection according to the LS(S2-2006813) | Vivo | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): questions the need of this CR Qian (Ericsson): Agrees with Nokia on the need of the CR and provide further info Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia), Qian (Ericsson) and give the reason for the CR Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR since it is incorrect and creates misalignment with stage-3 Laurent (Nokia) also objects to the CR for the reason indicated in this mail exchange (me, Qian and haris) Guillaume (MediaTek) shares the views expressed by Ericsson, Nokia and Qualcomm. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to the comments from Qualcomm and provide R01 Antoine (Orange) : r01 is a LATE document. Xiaowan replies to Antoine (Orange): r01 stick to the 'alignment changes on user plane Integrity Protection according to the LS(S2-2006813)' Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any revision of this CR as non FASMO as the feature is covered by RAN2 specs and previous SA2 CR Qian (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia and objects any revision of this CR Xiaowan(vivo) replies to request Laurent (Nokia) and disagree stage2 has aligned with stage3 Xiaowan (vivo) ask Qian (Ericsson) and Laurent (Nokia) to clarify how to fulfil 'avoid inconsistency' requested in the LS and why ignore the misalignment between stage2 and CT1 stage3. Laurent (Nokia) answers. Qian (Ericsson) responds. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia) answers. Xiaowan (vivo) responds to Qian (Ericsson) Qian (Ericsson) comments Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provide r02 for CC#2 Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r02 Qian (Ericsson) agrees with Haris and objects to r02 Laurent (Nokia): same view than E// and QC: we object as r02 removes some real stage 2 requirement Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Haris (Qualcomm) and requests clarification to the technical question === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2007179 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2417 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment changes on user plane Integrity Protection according to the LS(S2-2006813) | Vivo | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): questions the need of this CR Qian (Ericsson): Agrees with Nokia on the need of the CR and provide further info on NGAP. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR since it is incorrect and creates misalignment with stage-3 Laurent (Nokia) also objects to the CR for the reason indicated in this mail exchange (me, Qian and haris) Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia) and Qian (Ericsson) and give the reason for the CR is needed Haris (Qualcomm) comments and sustains objection Jianhua (OPPO) ask questions whether to mandate full data rate UPIP to NR-DC and NE-DC as informed by RAN2 LS? Wanqiang (Huawei) responds the question from OPPO. Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends the same handling as for 7178 (should be noted). Xiaowan(vivo) replies to the comments from Qualcomm and all. Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any revision of this CR as non FASMO as the feature is covered by RAN2 specs and previous SA2 CR Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Laurent (Nokia): there is no revision to this CR and the change has been revoked by the previous reply email === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006818 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on human-readable network name (HRNN) | SA WG1 (S1-203272) | Rel-16 | Noted | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006820 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS reply on AMF reallocation via RAN re-routing | SA WG3 (S3-201862) | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS Jinguo(ZTE) is ok to note this LS. The tdoc 7357 is related with this LS and to align R16 with R15. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006821 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Reply PAP/CHAP and other point-to-point protocols usage in 5GS | SA WG3 (S3-202190) | Postponed. Revised to S2-2008339. | Revised | ||
| 4.1 | S2-2006822 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on Reference point interface names for AKMA | SA WG3 (S3-202250) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2006932. Final response in S2-2008003 | Replied to | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006932 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on LS on Reference point interface names for AKMA | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006822. R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008003 | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): Ok with r01 of LS and r02 of the CR Wanqiang (Huawei) support the r01 of the LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2008003 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on LS on Reference point interface names for AKMA | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006932R01 . Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006931 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2457 (Rel-16, 'F'): Introduction of AKMA into the reference architecture | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Noted | Wanqiang (Huawei): Huawei support the notion of the paper and ask further question for clarification Stefan (Ericsson) comments that less is more Laurent (Nokia) provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 Antoine (Orange) asks why reference points are added and not SBI. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) request to document this same way as e.g. Location services, i.e. a revision of the CR is needed. Stefan (Ericsson) comments that this is for rel-17 and should not be approved. OK do endorse. Laurent (Nokia): the CR is for endorsement only Dieter (Deutsche Telekom): we can fix the CR this meeting and endorse or note it this meeting and fix it at the next meeting. Antoine (Orange) objects to all versions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006829 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG SA: LS on Rel-17 schedule | TSG SA (SP-200888) | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS Hannu (Nokia) proposes to revise the LS out. Hannu (Nokia) withdraws his previous comment on 6829. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | For information | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006802 | LS In | Information | LS on the stage 2 aspects of MINT | CT WG1 (C1-205332) | Rel-17 | Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the LS. Laurent (Nokia): proposes to note the LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006803 | LS In | Information | LS on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | CT WG1 (C1-205392) | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006804 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1#125e: LS on Media Feature Tag for IMS Data Channel | CT WG1 (C1-205509) | Rel-16 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006805 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG3#111e: LS Reply on Media Feature Tag for IMS Data Channel | CT WG3 (C3-204168) | Rel-16 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006810 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG1: LS on Latency of NR Positioning Protocols | RAN WG1 (R1-2007264) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006814 | LS In | Information | LS from RAN WG3: New service type of NR QoE | RAN WG3 (R3-205724) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2006823 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG5: Reply LS on application registration in relation to mgmt aspects | SA WG5 (S5-204117) | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS Magnus (Ericsson): Agree with Laurent, there's no action for SA2 so we can Note the LS === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006824 | LS In | Information | LS from : Reply LS to ETSI ISG ENI on mapping between ENI architecture and NWDAF/MDAF | SA WG5 (S5-204440) | Noted | Noted | ||
| 4.1 | S2-2006825 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG5: Reply LS from SA5 to GSMA on NG.116 support of different access types | SA WG5 (S5-204476) | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) suggests to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006826 | LS In | Information | LS from TSG SA: Reply LS on the stage 2 aspects of MINT | TSG SA (SP-200880) | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note the LS === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2006827 | LS In | Information | LS from TSG SA: LS on 5G GUTI re-allocation | TSG SA (SP-200883) | Rel-16 | Noted | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2007795 | LS In | Information | LS from GSMA 5GJA: LS from 5GJA to 3GPP CT4 | GSMA 5GJA (5GJA14_128r1) (5GJA14_128r1) | Noted | Noted | ||
| 4.2 | - | - | - | Late incoming LS and pending issues | - | - | Docs:=26 | - | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007793 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3LI: Clarification on the assumption of only one AMF region to a tracking area | SA WG3LI (S3i200496) (S3i200496) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2007796. Final response in S2-2007819 | Replied to | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007796 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to Clarification on the assumption of only one AMF region to a tracking area | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Created after CC#1. Response to S2-2007793. r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2007819. | Chris (Vodafone) provides a rev 1 in the drafts folder for CC#2 === CC#2 === Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. Alex (Rogers) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) comments, cannot accept r01 nor r03 as additional requirements/assumptions not stated in the spec. Qian (Ericsson) comments. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Alex (Rogers) provides comments on Nokia's response. Chris (Vodafone) comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. Chris (Vodafone) provides r06. Alex (Rogers) comments. Alex (Rogers) supports r06. Qian (Ericsson) comments and asks question and provides r07. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and supports R06/R07 with preference of r06. Chris (Vodafone) comments. In R07 '... or supported' should be deleted. Devaki (Nokia) provides r08 to address Chris comment on r07. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and is ok with r08. Wanqiang (Huawei) is ok with r08. Alex (Rogers) is fine with r08. Chris (Vodafone) is fine with r08 - but please restore the paragraph breaks during clean up. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007819 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS to Clarification on the assumption of only one AMF region to a tracking area | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007796R08. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007138 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2473 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correcting Xn handover at network sharing | Ericsson | Rel-15 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007135, to S2-2007822. | LiMeng (Huawei) objects to this CR. Paul (Ericsson) provides a response. LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Paul (Ericsson) replies and provides r01. LiMeng (Huawei) considers the changes are not necessary, therefore object to r01 as well. Paul (Ericsson) provides questions. Paul (Ericsson) suggest that this CR and its mirror in S2-2007139 are brought to CC#2. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hannu (Nokia) supports taking this to CC #2 and asks a question. === CC#2 === Chris (Vodafone) comments that this seems to be for inter-PLMN Xn handover (e.g. at the edge of a network sharing area). Hence this is likely to be inter-vendor Xn handover and therefore it is very important that the R15 specifications are clear. Hannu (Nokia) repeats the question on whether this CR can be agreed to be an alignment CR? Paul (Ericsson) provides comments and asks if the CRs can be agreed given they align stage 2 with RAN specifications. Paul (Ericsson) ask question for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) can accept r01 of this document to move forward, and object the original version. Paul (Ericsson) replies and provides r02. Paul (Ericsson) provides r02. LiMeng (Huawei) comments on r02. Paul (Ericsson) replies. LiMeng (Huawei) replies, and objects r00 and r02. Paul (Ericsson) replies and asks question. LiMeng (Huawei) replies and comments. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to agree r01. Haris (Qualcomm) prefers r01 and comments for r02 that in sentence 'shall provide the NG-RAN in the Mobility Restriction List with a prioritised list of permitted PLMNs' -- 'shall' is not essential, because in some scenarios, the UE only sees / uses one PLMN === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007822 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2473R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correcting Xn handover at network sharing | Ericsson | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2007138R01, merging S2-2007135. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007139 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2474 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correcting Xn handover at network sharing | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007823. | LiMeng (Huawei) objects to this CR. Paul (Ericsson) provides r01. LiMeng (Huawei) considers the changes are not necessary, therefore object to r01 as well. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Paul (Ericsson) provides r02. LiMeng (Huawei) objects r00 and r02. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to agree r01 of this Cat A CR (and proposed the same approach on the Cat F CR in in 7138) Haris (Qualcomm) prefers r01 and comments for r02 that in sentence 'shall provide the NG-RAN in the Mobility Restriction List with a prioritised list of permitted PLMNs' -- 'shall' is not essential, because in some scenarios, the UE only sees / uses one PLMN === Phase 2 final deadline === Paul (Ericsson>> replies. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Paul (Ericsson) why r01 is more accurate as it stands. Paul (Ericsson) replies. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007823 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2474R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correcting Xn handover at network sharing | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007139R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2006841 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2402 (Rel-15, 'F'): Removal of SMSF registration notification flag | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-15 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2007824. | George (Ericsson) rejects the CR. Please see comments Hannu (Nokia) replies to George (Ericsson) Haiyang(Huawei) has questions to George (Ericsson) Haiyang(Huawei) provides r01 Hannu (Nokia) supports the proposal and provides r02 George (Ericsson) this CR to be noted. Haiyang(Huawei) comments to George (Ericsson) Haiyang(Huawei) provides r03 George (Ericsson) We already provided an update to 7646. Then we can address Release 15. That's the rule George (Ericsson) Objects to r03, and provides a response Haiyang(Huawei) indicates that 6841 is related to 7646, but not 7457; and 7646 should not be the mirror of 6841 George (Ericsson). Yes I meant 7646. It is not a mirror either. If the chair agrees that we create the equivalent for Release 15 that mimics what we agreed on in 7646, I am Ok with that. Tao(Chair) it seems that you are approaching converge. I therefore mark this for CC#2. Please Haiyang prepare an update. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hannu (Nokia) supports this approach and comments. === CC#2 === George (Ericsson) provides r05. Haiyang(Huawei) changes the AI to 4.2 Hannu (Nokia) cleans up editorials in r06. George (Ericsson) accepts r06. Haiyang(Huawei) is ok with r06 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007824 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2402R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Removal of SMSF registration notification flag | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2006841R06. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007457 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2432 (Rel-16, 'F'): Redirection for EPS Fallback correction | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. This CR is already addressed in S2-2007739. Fenqin (Huawei) responds zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Devaki (Nokia) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments zhendong (ZTE) agree with fenqin response zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Fenqin (Huawei) comments. ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) comments. Chris J (T-Mobile USA) proposes noting this CR and moving forward with S2-2007739 zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. Fenqin (Huawei) update 7457 to add the change suggested by 7739r03 , provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02, r03. George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions. Fenqin (Huawei) ask for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Fenqin (Huawei) provides r04. George (Ericsson) objects to r04 George (Ericsson ) Responds. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. George (Ericsson) How is that different. Not even sure that this is allowed in normative spec. George (Ericsson) does not is almost the same like shall not. George (Ericsson) provides a response. The text that we would like as U see below. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 4.2 | S2-2007739 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2450 (Rel-16, 'F'): Fixing Redirection for EPS Fallback indication | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Verizon, Samsung, Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#3: r11 was agreed with objections from Huawei and ZTE and revised to S2-2007918 | Fenqin (Huawei) comments Devaki (Nokia) replies to Huawei. OPPO (Yang Xu) has similar comments as Huawei and provides comments. zhendong (ZTE) comments. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. Devaki (Nokia) replies. ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) comments Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 and r03. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r03 and suggests alternative wording Devaki (Nokia) responds to QCOM. Prefers r01. Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r04 Fenqin (Huawei) Comments and prefer r03. Fenqin (Huawei) comments and suggest to use the logic as r03. zhendong (ZTE) provides r05, and also can live with r03 Devaki (Nokia) provides r06. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 zhendong (ZTE) provides r07 Haris (Qualcomm) comments that r07 adds contradicting text zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Fenqin(Huawei) comments and provides r08. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with this version Devaki (Nokia) provides also r10. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides also r11, aligning the new NOTE 2 with the existing one updated. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r12,. Haris (Qualcomm) r11 is ok for us Fenqin (Huawei) propose to postpone this paper Devaki (Nokia) asks why this cannot be progressed now? Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung support r11. zhendong (ZTE) support r12 Yang Xu (OPPO) support r12 Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that r12 is incomplete and not acceptable zhendong (ZTE) agree with fenqin Chi (China Unicom): Supports r12 and agrees with Fenqin's supplement to r12. Biao (China Telecom) supports r12. George (Ericsson) Ericsson only accepts r11. As stated what is now proposed implies always support for Voice when N26 is supported which is incorrect. This will trigger false EPS FB. Aihua (China Mobile) supports r12 as a way forward. Devaki (Nokia) requests Chairman to consider this CR, the two variants (r11, r12+) for CC#2/Show of hands. Fenqin(Huawei) Reponds. George (Ericsson) Sorry I don't buy this EBI check as deterministic. This is implementation. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r13 in the draft box === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Fenqin (Huawei) require same treatment as 7457 Devaki (Nokia) comments. George (Ericsson) responds. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Devaki (Nokia) summarizes the two variants. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) Provides comments Fenqin (Huawei) Provides comments George (Ericsson) provides a comment on 7457rev04 vs 7739r13.. George (Ericsson) Variant 2 is a nightmare to manage in an operational network. Fenqin (Huawei) except r13 and object any revision of this paper. Chris Joul (T-Mobile USA) Can only accept rev11 === Phase 2 final deadline === Guillaume (MediaTek) comments === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007918 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2450R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Fixing Redirection for EPS Fallback indication | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Verizon, Samsung, Ericsson, T-Mobile USA, AT&T | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007739R11. Approved with objections from Huawei and ZTE. | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007405 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2228R3 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of Alternative QoS Profile handling | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005057 from S2#140E. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007820. | Paul (Ericsson) provides r01. We object to r0. Mirko (Huawei) responds and objects to r1. Paul (Ericsson) replies. Mirko (Huawei) responds. Mirko (Huawei) suggests to agree the original version. Chris (Vodafone) sees that the 3 clauses in 7405 are independent changes. There seems to be concensus on the changes to the 1st and 3rd clauses. Hence can we move forward with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Paul (Ericsson) provides r03 and objects to r02. Mirko (Huawei) is ok with r03. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r03 and happy about this outcome. ^__^ Chris (Vodafone) provides r04 as r03 is wrong but Chris still prefers r01. Mirko (Huawei) is ok with r04. Paul (Ericsson) accepts r04. Chris (Vodafone) does not object to r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007820 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2228R4 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of Alternative QoS Profile handling | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007405R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007230 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2052 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Trusted Non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.502!. Confirm Spec version used - CR states 16.6.0! Revised at CC#2 to S2-2007815. Will need to be merged into another 23.316 CR, or treated specially when a revision is agreed to get the correct CR number allocated | Revised | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007815 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2452 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Trusted Non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007230. Approved | Marco (Huawei) provides the revision changing the a correct CR number to 23.502. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 4.2 | S2-2006783 | LS In | Action | LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion | IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-TSN-support-in-3GPP-Release-16) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004782 from S2#140E. Response drafted in S2-2007105. Final response in S2-2007821. | Replied to | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007105 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006783. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007821. | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) responds. zhendong (ZTE) response György (Ericsson) responds. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r03 based on comments on another thread to ask some questions back to IEEE and requests to take this version r03 for approval. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007821 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007105R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2006785 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address | CT WG4 (C4-203452) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004786 from S2#140E. Responses drafted in S2-2007082 and S2-2007303. Final response in S2-2007826 | Replied to | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007303 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response on Clarification on AAA-Server address | Ericsson | Response to S2-2006785. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007826. | Patrice (Huawei) objects to original version, and for the sake of compromise provides r01 (see S2-2007300 for more details). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r01 and proposes a resolution at the CC. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as for CC. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 Patrice (Huawei) provides r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007826 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Response on Clarification on AAA-Server address | SA WG2 | - | Revision of S2-2007303R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007817 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Clarification on URLLC monitoring | Huawei | - | Created at CC#2. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007825. | Susan (Huawei) provides the first version of S2-2007817. Paul (Ericsson) provides r01. Susan (Huawei) provides r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007825 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Clarification on URLLC monitoring | SA WG2 | - | Revision of S2-2007817R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2007818 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on KI#2 Enable UE to simultaneously connect to both SNPN and PLMN | Futurewei | - | Created at CC#2. CC#4: r19 agreed. Revised to S2-2007827. | Amanda Xiang provide draft LS to RAN WGs to ask questions regarding dual radio UE support for simultaneous communication with NPN and PLMN. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for clarifications Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei) provide response to MediaTek Marco ( Huawei) asks clarification Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides response to Huawei and provide r01 Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) provide response to Future and suggest not to send the LS to RAN Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide response to MediaTek Lars (Sony) provide r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarification from Lars (Sony) Lars (Sony) responds to Guillaume Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provide response to Sony (Lars) Fei (OPPO) provides r04 Lars (Sony) provides r05 Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) provide r06 and objects to the original version, and other revisions (r01 to r05) Lars (Sony) comments on r06 Chia-Lin (MediaTek) respond to Sony (Lars) Lars (Sony) no need to send r06 Marco (Huawei) no need to send r06 Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to sending any LS on this topic except r06. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide r07 based on r05 Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r07 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r08 Lars (Sony) provides r09 Marco (Huawei) provides r09 Lars (Sony) provides r10 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r11 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question to MediaTek. Marco (Huawei) prefer r10 , but open to compromise adding some text from r11 if feasible and acceptable. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r12 in drafts folder Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r08; objects to all other versions Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides r13 in drafts folder and hope this can be used as way forward Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r14. r8 is not acceptable. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions on the new questions. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Peter (Ericsson) === Phase 2 final deadline === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r15 Guillaume (MediaTek): r15 is ok Lars (Sony): r15 is ok Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) : r15 is ok === CC#3 === Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide r16 to address Qualcomm concern Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r17 Guillaume (MediaTek): ok with r17 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question to new Q3. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Peter and provides r18 Lars (Sony) ask questions further questions on the feedback Lars (Sony) provides r19 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r19 === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2007827 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on questions to RAN WG2 on dual Radio UE (2Rx/2Tx or 2Rx/1Tx) support for simultaneous communication with both SNPN and PLMN | SA WG2 | - | Revision of S2-2007818R19. Approved | Approved | |
| 5 | - | - | - | Pre-Rel-17 Maintenance (excluding all 5G topics) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.1 | - | - | - | 3GPP Packet Access Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 5.1 | S2-2007628 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3615 (Rel-16, 'B'): Early UE capability retrieval support | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) objects to this CR in Rel-16. Qian (Ericsson) asks a question. Steve (Huawei) suggests noting the CR Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Qian Qian (Ericsson) responds to Miguel Hannu (Nokia) responds to Qian (Ericsson) responds to Miguel Noam (Sequans) responds to Qian Qian (Ericsson) responds to Noam Steve (Huawei) This CR's fate should be aligned with S2-2007631, which should be noted. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 5.2 | - | - | - | QoS and PCC Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.3 | - | - | - | Non-3GPP Access Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.4 | - | - | - | IMS and IMS-Related Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 5.4 | S2-2007609 | CR | Approval | 23.167 CR0358 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of reference for Sh interface | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008004 | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) supports r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 5.4 | S2-2008004 | CR | Approval | 23.167 CR0358R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of reference for Sh interface | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007609R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6 | - | - | - | Rel-15/Rel-16 Maintenance for 5G (only related to 5GS_Ph1 Work Item) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 6.1 | - | - | - | General aspects, concepts and reference models | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 6.1 | S2-2006996 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3614 (Rel-16, 'F'): Missing description of inter-RAT handover from NR to EN-DC | OPPO, China Telecom, China Unicom, Huawei | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008201 | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Yang Xu (OPPO) is ok to r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.1 | S2-2008201 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3614R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Missing description of inter-RAT handover from NR to EN-DC | OPPO, China Telecom, China Unicom, Huawei | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006996R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.1 | S2-2007083 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Clarification on S-NSSAI use in 5G MOCN single 5GC. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.1 | S2-2007084 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2471 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on S-NSSAI use in 5G MOCN single 5GC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Alessio (nokia) Nokia objects to this CR as it is not FASMO nor it is technically correct Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes to note the CR. Patrice (Huawei) comments back. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments and proposes to note the CR. Tricci (ZTE) shared the similar concern as Samsung and Nokia and would like to ask for clarifications. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects CR revisions that requires S-NSSAI value ranges to be coordinated between networks. Alessio(Nokia) objects CR revisions that requires S-NSSAI value ranges to be coordinated between networks. Patrice (Huawei) replies to Samsung that noting the CR does not make the restriction go away. Patrice (Huawei) replies to ZTE. Patrice (Huawei) answers Ericsson's misunderstandings. Patrice (Huawei) answers Nokia's misunderstandings. Alessio(Nokia) replies to a statement on 'operational gains' Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Patrice (Huawei). Patrice (Huawei) answers the question from Hoyeon (Samsung) Patrice (Huawei) indicates that the comments are not against the contribution, but against the specification. Alessio (Nokia) comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) asks Huawei to provide the references from the specifications that supports the Huawei opinion. Patrice (Huawei) answers Ericsson's comment. Alessio(Nokia ) comments Josep (DT) weighs in as an operator. Patrice (Huawei) replies to Josep (DT) Josep (DT) replies to Patrice (Huawei) and insists on documenting the current situation, whichever it is. Patrice (Huawei) comments further. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.1 | S2-2007307 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2485 (Rel-16, 'F'): Continuation of PDU sessions upon mobility to a target PLMN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008202 | Dan (China Mobile) provide r01 for clarification about mapped NSSAI Fei (OPPO) provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) agrees with rev02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.1 | S2-2008202 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2485R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Continuation of PDU sessions upon mobility to a target PLMN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007307R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.1 | S2-2007453 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2499 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI handling at the Inter PLMN mobility | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008203 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications as to how this is a FASMO and conditionally objects. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds Dan (China Mobile) provide a comment Alessio(Nokia) comments that the existing text already applies to both cases. So supports Stefano(Qualcomm) in objecting to this change Alessio(Nokia) makes further comments. Fenqin(Huawei) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and question whether the CR is FASMO. Stefano (Qualcomm) supports Ericsson suggestion and proposes to note 7453, and focus on the 23.502 CR in 7454. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01.. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.1 | S2-2008203 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2499R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI handling at the Inter PLMN mobility | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007453R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.1 | S2-2007454 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2430 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI handling at the Inter PLMN mobility | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008204 | Stefano (Qualcomm) Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 Fenqin (Huawei) ok with r01 alessio (Nokia) asks a question === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.1 | S2-2008204 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2430R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI handling at the Inter PLMN mobility | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007454R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | - | - | - | Common Access Control, RM and CM functions and procedure flows | - | - | Docs:=21 | - | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007148 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2415 (Rel-16, 'F'): UE Context in AMF Data | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the CR, address terminology issues as part of planned mega CR. Qian (Ericsson) provides responses to Devaki and indicate it's critical to handle the paper. Jinguo(ZTE) supports Ericsson view. Changhong (Intel) supports this paper. Tao (Chair) further check whether we can go with r00 in view of support from ZTE and Intel also. Devaki (Nokia) is fine with the CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 6.2 | S2-2007357 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2424 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Registration with AMF re-allocation | ZTE | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008205 | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 to add Nokia as cosigner. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r02. Jinguo(ZTE) is fine with r02 but want to clarify the NOTE 3 was copied from Rel-15. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Jinguo(ZTE). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Jinguo(ZTE) is fine with r03 Haris (Qualcomm) is ok with r03 but there is a typo 'regsitraiton' in summary of change in coversheet that needs to be corrected Hoyeon (Samsung) is ok with r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008205 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2424R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Registration with AMF re-allocation | ZTE, Nokia, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007357R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007358 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2489 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction on AMF discovery and selection | ZTE | Rel-15 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) wonders if there is an issue to be addressed at all? Dan (China Mobile) also concern about this update of removing slice information for AMF selection Jinguo(ZTE) response and provide r01 Fenqin (Huawei) Comments Jinguo (ZTE) Response to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for the clarification. Hoyeon (Samsung) shares the same view as Fenqin (Huawei). Jinguo(ZTE) is fine to note this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.2 | S2-2007359 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2490 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on AMF discovery and selection | ZTE | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008206 | Jinguo(ZTE) provides r01 based on discussion in 7358 Tao (Chair) reads r01 will be NOTED based on the results of 7358 Jinguo (ZTE) proposed to approve r01. Tao (Chair) reformulate the question can we approve r01? . === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008206 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2490R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on AMF discovery and selection | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007359R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007418 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2496 (Rel-16, 'F'): Change of E-UTRAN UE Capability | Apple | Rel-16 | Postponed | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) questions the need of the CR. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03 Krisztian (Apple) supports r03. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on the CR (all revisions) Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Haris comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) comments. Changhong (Intel) shares the same view with Qualcomm. Jianhua (OPPO) asks question for inter-system HO case Robert (Apple) responds to all and provides r06 Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Robert (Apple). Devaki (Nokia) responds to Robert (Apple). Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 Robert (Apple) responds to Mediatek and Qualcomm and provides r07 Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments on r07. Robert (Apple) responds to Oppo and Qualcomm Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r09 Chair (Tao): not seen clear convergence to r07 yet. Please further discuss and express your views clearly or suggest a way forward. Robert responds to Nokia and provides r08 Robert (Apple) responds to Qualcomm Robert (Apple) responds Qualcomm Chris (Vodafone) comments that the UMTS RAC shall not be stored in the AMF. But perhaps the 'NR SRVCC to 3G' work needs to be updated to document this? Robert (Apple) responds to Vodafone. Robert (Apple) proposes to return to r08 Guillaume (MediaTek): r03 is ok. r06, r07, r08, r09 are not acceptable. (Note there is no r04, r05 available) Tao (Chair): Can we approve r03? Any objection to r03? Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that prefers no changes but r03 is also acceptable but imprecise Ericsson (Qian) supports r03 or no change. Robert (Apple) indicates that he cannot accept r03 Jianhua (OPPO) can live with r08 or postpone to find a better wording in the next meeting. Chris (Vodafone) agrees with Apple that r03 seems wrong. r08 is OK and postponing is also OK. The key thing is that RAN implements SRVCC to 3G correctly. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 6.2 | S2-2007422 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2427 (Rel-16, 'F'): SOR check during mobility REGISTRATION | Apple | Rel-16 | Noted | Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification. Qian (Ericsson) asks questions. Fenqin (Huawei) comments Lalith (Samsung) comments Haris (Qualcomm) objects to this CR Hyunsook (LGE) comments Krisztian (Apple) responds to comments. ChrisJ ()T-Mobile USA) Agrees with Qualcomm Krisztian (Apple) responds to T-Mobile USA. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Devaki (Nokia) and provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for clarification Qian (Ericsson) propose to postpone the paper Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Krisztian (Apple) responds to Qian (Ericsson) and Fenqin (Huawei). Krisztian (Apple) responds to Haris (Qualcomm). === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.2 | S2-2007426 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2428 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of UE parameters update and Steering of Roaming procedure when UE is not reachable or when acknowledgement from UE is not received | Apple | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008207 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Fei (OPPO) provides r02. Qian (Ericsson) question the need of the paper. Fei (OPPO) comments Krisztian (Apple) responds to the comments and provides r03. Fei (OPPO) comments and can not accept r03 Qian (Ericsson) provide comments Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r03 Krisztian (Apple) can accept r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008207 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2428R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of UE parameters update and Steering of Roaming procedure when UE is not reachable or when acknowledgement from UE is not received | Apple | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007426R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007455 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2431 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Location Report | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008208 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r03. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and ask question. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Qian (Ericsson) supports r02. Tao(Chair) can we move with r02 then? Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for Qian === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Qian (Ericsson) prefer r02, but ok with r03 === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008208 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2431R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Location Report | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007455R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007456 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2500 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on mobility restriction | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 6.2 | S2-2007650 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2441 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on correction of UE Context Transfer payload in case of UE initial registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008209 | Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Atsushi(NTT Docomo) asks about r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Atsushi(NTT Docomo) is ok with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008209 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2441R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on correction of UE Context Transfer payload in case of UE initial registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2007650R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007651 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2442 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on correction of UE Context Transfer payload in case of UE initial registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Agreed as mirror of S2-2007650r01. revised to S2-2008210 | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008210 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2442R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on correction of UE Context Transfer payload in case of UE initial registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007651. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007654 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2445 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on clarification of Registration Status Update for PCF for UE Policy | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008211 | Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) agree with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008211 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2445R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on clarification of Registration Status Update for PCF for UE Policy | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2007654R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.2 | S2-2007655 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2446 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on clarification of Registration Status Update for PCF for UE Policy | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Agreed as mirror of S2-2007654r01. revised to S2-2008212 | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.2 | S2-2008212 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2446R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on clarification of Registration Status Update for PCF for UE Policy | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007655. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.3 | - | - | - | Session management and continuity functions and flows | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 6.3 | S2-2007036 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2463 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Ethernet Type PDU session and MAC address association | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) comments for clarification Stefan (Ericsson) comments and expresses concerns Laurent (Nokia) comments and expresses concerns Qianghua (Huawei) responds Laurent (Nokia): answers to qianghua Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Nokia and provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Qianghua and still has concerns with the CR Laurent (Nokia) replies to Qianghua and has more and more concerns with the CR: I object to any revision of the CR Stefan (Ericsson) also objects to any revision of this CR Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r02; Tao(Chair) can Stefan and Laurent further check r02? I see Qianghua tried hard to revise and response. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and cannot agree with r02 Laurent (Nokia): OBJECTS to any revision of this CR/Tdoc including r02 Qianghua (Huawei) OK to note this CR at this meeting But sincerely and honestly expects Nokia and Ericsson to further consider whether detection of MAC address on N6 works in this mobility scenario === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.3 | S2-2007037 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2409 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Ethernet Type PDU session and MAC address association | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to all revisions including original. Stefan (Ericsson) also objects to any revision of this CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.3 | S2-2007038 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0492 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Ethernet Type PDU session and MAC address association | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to all revisions including original. Stefan (Ericsson) also objects to any revision of this CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.3 | S2-2007070 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2469 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for PDU session transfer between 3GPP and non-3GPP access | Apple | Rel-16 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.502! R07 agreed. Revised to S2-2008213 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Fei (OPPO) comments. Robert (Apple): responds to Nokia and provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): comments and provides r03 Robert (Apple): responds to Oppo. Robert (Apple): in principle O.K. with r03, provides r04 Laurent (Nokia): supports Robert Fei (OPPO) responds to Nokia and Apple. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r05 Fei (OPPO) provides r06. Robert (Apple): responds to Oppo and provides r07. Fei (OPPO) can live with r07. Laurent (Nokia): OBJECTS to R00, R01 (known to be incomplete); I am OK with R07 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.3 | S2-2008213 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2453 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS parameter handling for PDU session transfer between 3GPP and non-3GPP access | Apple, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007070R07 with correction of TS and CR numbers. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.3 | S2-2007146 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2477 (Rel-16, 'F'): V-SMF selection | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 6.3 | S2-2007147 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2414 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS control in V-SMF | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008214 | Laurent (Nokia): asks clarifications Stefan (Ericsson) replies Laurent (Nokia): answers and objects to the CR Laurent (Nokia) replies: this is a non FASMO optimization Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Laurent and explains the FASMO aspect Fenqin (Huawei ) comments. Chris (Vodafone) comments that it is important that the 5GC provides equivalent capability to that in EPC (where the MME in the VPLMN can downgrade the default bearer's QoS from the value provided by the HSS). Farooq (AT&T) comments; agrees with Vodafone on providing functionality equivalent to EPC and considers this FASMO as current situation could lead to excessive rejections of sessions. ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) Provides comments Jinguo (ZTE) agrees with Huawei and Nokia and think this is not FASMO. Laurent (Nokia) Provides comments Laurent (Nokia) Provides updates the comments Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): provides comments Fenqin (Huawei): provides comments Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04 Jinguo (ZTE) is fine with r04 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.3 | S2-2008214 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2414R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS control in V-SMF | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007147R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.3 | S2-2007543 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2435 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections for PDU Session Release Procedure in 5GC | Ericsson, China Mobile, AT&T, T-Mobile USA | Rel-16 | R05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008215 | Runze (Huawei) comments. Stefan (Ericsson) replies and checks with Runze Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefen. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03 Laurent (Nokia): provides r04 Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 merging r03 and r04 (mail crossing) Runze (Huawei) accepts r03. Runze (Huawei) accept r05. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.3 | S2-2008215 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2435R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections for PDU Session Release Procedure in 5GC | Ericsson, China Mobile, AT&T, T-Mobile USA, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007543R05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.3 | S2-2007720 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2449 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to AN Release procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008216 | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Laurent (Nokia): answers to Stefan Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Laurent Fenqin (Huawei) comments and prefer r01. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.3 | S2-2008216 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2449R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to AN Release procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007720R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.4 | - | - | - | Security related functions and flows | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 6.5 | - | - | - | QoS concept and functionality | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 6.5 | S2-2007402 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2058R3 (Rel-16, 'F'): New QoS parameter Additional QoS Flow Information | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2002749 from S2#140E. Noted | Paul (Ericsson) provides r01 and objects to r0. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments, and propose to NOTE . Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. Ericsson support to note this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.5 | S2-2007403 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2494 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction of statement on ARP priority level | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-15 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the CR. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE. Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments of Devaki and Hong. ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) Agrees with Nokia Judy (Ericsson) provide r01 Mirko (Huawei) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) cannot accept r02; r01 is editorial, not FASMO either. Can we postpone r01 and consider for mega 23.501 CR? Judy (Ericsson) proposed to go for r01 and comments that the change in r01 is not editorial. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r01 since it is not FASMO Mirko (Huawei) suggests to agree either r02 or the original version. Judy (Ericsson) accept r01 and objects to other revisions. Devaki (Nokia) proposes that we consider removing 'level' as part of non-FASMO CR planned for TS 23.501. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.5 | S2-2007404 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2495 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction of statement on ARP priority level | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.6 | - | - | - | Policy and charging control | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 6.6 | S2-2006976 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0491 (Rel-16, 'F'): Location change (serving cell) for Policy Control Request Trigger | China Mobile | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008217 | Hong (Qualcomm) provide comments and asks for clarifications. Aihua(China Mobile) replies and provides clarifications. Apostolos (Nokia) does not agree with the CR. Aihua(China Mobile) replies and provides r01. Tao(Chair) Can Apostolos further check r01 and the clarifications, indicate your view? Apostolos (Nokia) comments Apostolos (Nokia) agrees with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.6 | S2-2008217 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0491R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Location change (serving cell) for Policy Control Request Trigger | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006976R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.6 | S2-2007398 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0496 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the QoS Flow binding with Alternative QoS Parameter Set(s) | OPPO | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008218 | Hong (Qualcomm) provide comments and propose to NOTE. Yali (OPPO) replies to Hong. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with the initial revision of the CR. Apostolos (Nokia) asks for clarification. Yali (OPPO) replies and provides r01, both ok to the initial revision and r01. Apostolos (Nokia) has concerns about both the original CR and r01. Yali (OPPO) replies. Apostolos (Nokia) replies and has still concerns about both the original CR and r01. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Yali. Yali (OPPO) replies to Apostolos and Hong, and provides r02 and r03. Apostolos (Nokia) replies to Yali and Hong and can accept only r03. Belen (Ericsson) is ok with r02 and r03 Haiyang (Huawei) can accept r03. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r03. Yali (OPPO) provides r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.6 | S2-2008218 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0496R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the QoS Flow binding with Alternative QoS Parameter Set(s) | OPPO, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007398R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.6 | S2-2007470 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0497 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of usage of URSP rule for DNS | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Noted | OPPO (Yang Xu) comments. Haiyang (Huawei) comments and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR with welcome back hug. ^__^ Dario (QC) replies to LaeYoung et al. and providers r02. Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision r03 Jinguo (ZTE) provides comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments on r02. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Jinguo. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments and shares the view from LaeYoung. Dario (QC) replies by providing r04 Belen (Ericsson) supports the proposal in the CR. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification on r04. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments and ask for clarification. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Sherry and LaeYoung Belen (Ericsson) ask QC to clarify if the example provided by LGE is correct. Belen (Ericsson) also comments. Dario (Qualcomm) clarifies and provides r05. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06. Yang (OPPO) raises comments and propose not to add a normative sentence. Yang (OPPO) provides r07. Haiyang (Huawei) comments and proposes to note this CR based on the discussion. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r05 and r06 Belen (Ericsson) comments. Haiyang (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r07. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r08. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Dario (Qualcomm) comments Jari (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Huawei. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports to go forward with the CR. LaeYoung (LGE) prefers to approve r06 or r08. Haiyang (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) & Jari (NTT DOCOMO), comments and provides r09. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r10. Lyu (vivo) agree with r07. Haiyang (Huawei) replies to Sherry(Xiaomi) and provides r11. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Haiyang (Huawei) Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies to Jari (NTT DOCOMO). Dario (Qualcomm) provides r12 Dan (China Mobile) make some comments Dan(China Mobile) do not agree with the paper and propose to NOTE Haiyang(Huawei) agrees with Dan (China Mobile) and clarify we are still OK to note this CR Yang Xu (OPPO) agrees with the previous comments (CMCC and Huawei). propose to put the sentence as a note. Dario (Qualcomm) prefers r12, but can accept r9 and r11. LaeYoung (LGE) also prefers r12, anyhow can accept r09 and r11. Yang Xu (OPPO) can only accept r09 and r11. And prefer r11. Dan (China Mobile) still suggest to NOTE this paper Sherry (Xiaomi) can accept r11 and r12. Dario (Qualcomm) explains why this CR is beneficial. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.6 | S2-2007613 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0500 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction of UE procedure for routing traffic using the URSP policies | Orange | Rel-15 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) comments. Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision r01. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Apostolos (Nokia) provides partial clarifications Haiyang (Huawei) comments on r01 and suggests not adding 'traffic' related description. Apostolos (Nokia) withdraws r01 and comments. Jicheol Lee (Samsung) proposes to note this paper. Sherry (Xiaomi) proposes to note this paper. Apostolos (Nokia) is ok with noting this paper and its mirror. Antoine (Orange) answers with some questions. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies to Antoine (Orange) Changhong (Intel) replies to Antoine. Apostolos (Nokia) replies to Antoine and asks Changhong for clarification. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) proposes to note this paper. Apostolos (Nokia) agrees with noting this paper but responds to Chia-Lin and asks for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) replies to Apostolos (Nokia). === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.6 | S2-2007614 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0501 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction of UE procedure for routing traffic using the URSP policies | Orange | Rel-16 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) comments. Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to also note this CR as it is a mirror of 7613. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.7 | - | - | - | 3GPP access specific functionality and flows | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 6.7 | S2-2007652 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2443 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction of Network Triggered Service Request for UE in CM-CONNECTED | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008219 | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and ask question (same as for S2-2007653). Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. Hannu (Nokia) comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides response to Atsushi (NTT Docomo) and Hannu (Nokia). Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r02 Atsushi (NTT Docomo) agrees r02 Hannu (Nokia) provides r03 and comments on earlier revisions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.7 | S2-2008219 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2443R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction of Network Triggered Service Request for UE in CM-CONNECTED | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2007652R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.7 | S2-2007653 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2444 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction of Network Triggered Service Request for UE in CM-CONNECTED | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Agreed as mirror of S2-2007652r03. revised to S2-2008220 | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and ask question. Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from Qian (Ericsson). Qian (Ericsson) response to Hannu (Nokia). Atsushi (NTT Docomo) asks a question to Tao. Tao (Chair) response. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.7 | S2-2008220 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2444R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction of Network Triggered Service Request for UE in CM-CONNECTED | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007653. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | - | - | - | Specific services support | - | - | Docs:=22 | - | |
| 6.8 | S2-2007646 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2439 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of SMSF registration notification flag | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006842, to S2-2008221 | George (Ericsson) objects to the CR. Please see comments Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r02 Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 George (Ericsson) provides response Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comment George (Ericsson) provides a response. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides a response. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r03. George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions including r03. Please see comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r04 and is also fine with r03. Haiyang (Huawei) comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r05 and is also fine with r03. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r06 as a cosigner. Hannu (Nokia) supports r06. Hannu (Nokia) replies to comments from George (Ericsson). George (Ericsson) provide r07. Ericsson provides comments Hannu (Nokia) supports r07 from George (Ericsson) and comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2008221 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2439R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of SMSF registration notification flag | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007646R07, merging S2-2006842. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | S2-2006809 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on SMSF Registration Notification Flag | CT WG4 (C4-204437) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2006840 and S2-2006948. Final response in S2-2007816 | Replied to | |
| 6.8 | S2-2006840 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on SMSF Registration Notification Flag | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006809. R05 agreed. Revised at CC#2 to S2-2007816. | George (Ericsson) objects to the LS. Please see comments Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from George (Ericsson) George (Ericsson) provides a response. Haiyang (Huawei) replies and provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Haiyang (Huawei) and George (Ericsson) and provides r02. George (Ericsson) provided r03 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r04. Hannu (Nokia) can't accept r03 or r04. Proposes to agree either r02 or to produce one more revision in CC George (Ericsson) I can accept r05. U can bring it up in the CC. Hannu (Nokia) agrees with George (Ericsson) on making r05 preferred version for CC #2. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2007816 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on SMSF Registration Notification Flag | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006840R05. Approved. Revised by MCC, to solve an inconsistency in the CRs, to S2-2007961. | Revised | |
| 6.8 | S2-2007961 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on SMSF Registration Notification Flag | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007816. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 6.8 | S2-2006948 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on SMSF Registration Notification Flag | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006809. Noted | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments Hannu (Nokia) can't agree to keep the SMSF Registration Notification Flag and prefers S2-2006840 instead. Haiyang (Huawei) agrees with Hannu(Nokia) and suggests to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.8 | S2-2006842 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2403 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of SMSF registration notification flag | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2008221 | George (Ericsson) rejects the CR. Please see comments Hannu (Nokia) proposes to do the Cat F CR first and leave Cat A later. Haiyang (Huawei): please mark this CR merged into 7646 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 6.8 | S2-2006853 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2404 (Rel-15, 'F'): Clarification on Emergency Services Fallback | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-15 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008222 | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 Robert (Perspecta Labs) provides comment on r01 Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2008222 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2404R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Clarification on Emergency Services Fallback | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2006853R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | S2-2006854 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2405 (Rel-16, 'A'): Clarification on Emergency Services Fallback | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008223 | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2008223 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2405R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Clarification on Emergency Services Fallback | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006854R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | S2-2007260 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2423 (Rel-16, 'F'): Transfer Procedure of PDU Session used for IMS voice from N3GPP to 3GPP | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2008225 | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to mark this CR as merged in S2-2007629 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 6.8 | S2-2007562 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2400R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to MME Emergency Configuration Data for enable the selection of diffrent emergency gateways based on UE capabilities | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005822 from S2#140E. R05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008224 | George (Ericsson) provides r01. See below for additional comments. Judy (Ericsson) asks to ignore r01 and provide r02. Judy (Ericsson) asks to ignore r01 and provide r02 (hyperlink corrected) Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 George (Ericsson) We are not OK with rev03. Please see comments. Judy (Ericsson) comments. Thomas (Nokia) provides r04 George (Ericsson) provides r05. Just one grammatical correction otherwise OK Thomas (Nokia) prefers r04 but can accept r05. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2008224 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2400R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to MME Emergency Configuration Data for enable the selection of diffrent emergency gateways based on UE capabilities | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007562R05. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | S2-2007629 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2438 (Rel-16, 'F'): Voice fallback triggered by PDU session resource setup | Qualcomm Incorprorated, T-Mobile | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007260, to S2-2008225 | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 George (Ericsson) provides r03 Thomas (Nokia) accepts r03 ChrisJ (T-Mobile USA) accepts r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.8 | S2-2008225 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2438R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Voice fallback triggered by PDU session resource setup | Qualcomm Incorprorated, T-Mobile, Ericsson, LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007629R03, merging S2-2007260. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.8 | S2-2007647 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on SMSF deactivation in case of UE initial registration and UE mobility registration. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) We are OK with alternative 1a as a resolution but not alternative 2. Hui (Huawei) supports alternative 1a. Atsushi(NTT Docomo) is fine with alternative 1a. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.8 | S2-2007648 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2508 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SMSF deactivation in case of UE initial registration and UE mobility registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. We are Ok with alterative 1a. Please see S2-2007647 George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. While we are Ok with the option 1a in S2-2007647, this CR does t follow the principles. Please see more comments Atsushi (NTT Docomo) is ok to Note this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.8 | S2-2007649 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2440 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SMSF deactivation in case of UE initial registration and UE mobility registration | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. We are Ok with alterative 1a. Please see S2-2007647 George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. While we are Ok with the option 1a in S2-2007647, this CR does not follow the principles. Please see more comments Atsushi (NTT Docomo) is ok to Note this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.8 | S2-2007656 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2509 (Rel-16, 'F'): NW triggered temporary UE's usage setting update | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. We are Ok with alterative 1a. Please see S2-2007647 Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. zhendong (ZTE) comments Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR since it is not FASMO and reason for change is misleading and incorrect George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. Sorry for the reason for objection before. The spec. is clear as to what is needed in such a case as mentioned . Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Myungjune (LGE) comments and objects r00 and r01. Jungshin (Samsung) objects to all versions of the CR. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) is fine to Note this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.8 | S2-2007657 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2447 (Rel-16, 'F'): NW triggered temporary UE's usage setting update | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | Noted | George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. We are Ok with alterative 1a. Please see S2-2007647 Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR since it is not FASMO and reason for change is misleading and incorrect George (Ericsson) Objects to the CR. Sorry for mentioning the wrong reasons. The spec defined what needs to be done. NO need for this CR. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Myungjune (LGE) comments and objects r00 and r01. Jungshin (Samsung) objects to all versions of the CR. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) is fine to Note this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.9 | - | - | - | Interworking and Migration | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 6.9 | S2-2006875 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2406 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback with emergency service | Samsung | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008226 | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01 Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments and r02. Devaki (Nokia) comments r02 masks some changes (i.e. changes done without track changes). Guillaume (MediaTek) questions this CR being FASMO Sangsoo (Samsung) is fine with r02, and asks if others can live with r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) can live with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yang (OPPO) asks Sangsoo to keep the track change when uploading documents. Sangsoo (Samsung) will apply track changes to the upload version. === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.9 | S2-2008226 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2406R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback with emergency service | Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006875R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.9 | S2-2006876 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2407 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback for voice service | Samsung | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008227 | Qian (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks to ignore the r01. Guillaume (MediaTek): r02 is ok Sangsoo (Samsung) is okay with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.9 | S2-2008227 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2407R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback for voice service | Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006876R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 6.9 | S2-2007419 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2497 (Rel-16, 'F'): Registration type in case of mobility from EPC to 5GC | Apple | Rel-16 | Noted | Myungjune (LGE) comments and proposes to note this CR. Krisztian (Apple) responds to LGE. Myungjune (LGE) comments and proposes to note this CR again. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.9 | S2-2007606 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2399R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): PDU SID handling in SMF for PDNs with IWK with 5GS | Cisco Systems | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005820 from S2#140E. Noted | Laurent (Nokia): comments and provides r01 and r02; Please consider only r02 (r01 has been loaded with a cover page issue) Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Laurent and provides r03 zhendong (ZTE) similar comment with Ericsson and nokia Irfan (Cisco) responds with consideration for Rel-15 UE. Myungjune (LGE) agrees with Irfan (Cisco) and supports original version. Laurent (Nokia): answers to Irfan Yang Xu (OPPO) provides question on r03. Irfan provides r04 Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung support r04. Laurent (Nokia): provides r05 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r06 Yang (OPPO) propose to adopt original version (r0) only Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to use r02 or r03 Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Stefan (Ericsson) on emergency PDN. Tao(Chair): the discussion not converge. I mark it as 'Noted?' for now. Any agreeable way forward? Laurent (Nokia): OBJECTS to R00, and suggest too to approve r03 Xiaowan (vivo) only live with the original version, with regard rel15 cell phone has been well sold and in use in the market. The solution in the revisions doesn't consider backwards compatibility and cannot be applied to rel15 UE. So it doesn't fix the issue. Laurent (Nokia): the conversation is not diverging: I was just proposing R03 (a text that covers the examples added by later revisions) Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Myungjune Myungjune (LGE) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and supports r00. Yang Xu (OPPO): we accept r0 and object other revisions. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Myungjune and objects to r00 Irfan (Cisco) provides comments. OK to go with r03 or r06 Myungjune (LGE) replies to Stefan (Ericsson). Tao(Chair) Does Irfan clarification works for Yang and can we go with r03? Myungjune (LGE) relies to Laurent (Nokia). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yang (OPPO) replies Yang (OPPO) further replies and can live with r03 with modifying the 'shall consider' to 'considers' === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 6.10 | - | - | - | Non-3GPP access specific functionality and flows | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 6.10 | S2-2007420 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2426 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of Registration procedure for untrusted non-3GPP access | Apple | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 6.11 | - | - | - | Framework functions | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 6.11 | S2-2007488 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2502 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of AF use of Internal Group Identifier | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008228 | Patrice (Huawei) provides r01 updating the coversheet. Hannu thanks Patrice for good update and provides r02 Patrice (Huawei) is OK with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 6.11 | S2-2008228 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2502R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of AF use of Internal Group Identifier | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007488R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7 | - | - | - | Rel-16 Maintenance for 5G (excluding 5GS_Ph1) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.1 | - | - | - | Architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services (eV2XARC) | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 7.1 | S2-2007169 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0152 (Rel-16, 'F'): Cleanup about V2X service type | LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.1 | S2-2007596 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0499 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC rule resource allocation outcome and its usage in AQP-based QoS Flow establishment | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008005 | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 and comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2008005 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0499R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC rule resource allocation outcome and its usage in AQP-based QoS Flow establishment | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007596R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.2 | - | - | - | Wireless and Wireline Convergence for the 5G system architecture (5WWC) | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 7.2 | S2-2006795 | LS In | Information | LS from BBF: Completion of WT-456 and WT-470 | BBF (LIAISE-411) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2004815 from S2#140E. Response drafted in S2-2006934. Final response in S2-2008001 | Replied to | |
| 7.2 | S2-2007783 | LS In | Information | LS from BBF: Your liaison S2-2005917 | BBF (LIAISE-423) | Postponed. Revised to S2-2008341. | Laurent (Nokia): as this is a late LS that requires some CR, I suggest to postpone it Marco (Huawei): supports to postpone the LS === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised | |
| 7.2 | S2-2006934 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Completion of WT-456 and WT-470 | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006795. Agreed. Revised to clean up in S2-2008001 | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2008001 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Completion of WT-456 and WT-470 | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006934. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.2 | S2-2006933 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2050 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment of 23.316 with TR-456 / TR-470 i.e. the BBF technical specifications | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | Marco (Huawei) supports and thanks Laurent === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2007229 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2051 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update RG-LWAC via UE context modification procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008006 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2008006 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2051R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update RG-LWAC via UE context modification procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007229R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.2 | S2-2007231 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2053 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UDM and UDR services in 5WWC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008007 | Stefan (Ericsson) comments Marco (Huawei) answers to Stefan (Ericsson) Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Marco and provides r01 Marco (Huawei) r01 is OK === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2008007 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2053R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UDM and UDR services in 5WWC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007231R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.2 | S2-2007232 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2054 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on 5WWC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2007661 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2510 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the construction of prioritized list of WLAN access networks for trusted access network selection | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2007663 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0502 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the UE procedure for selecting a WLAN access based on WLANSP rules | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008008 | Marco (Huawei) comments Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Marco (Huawei). Marco (Huawei) comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01 to address Marco's (Huawei) comments. Marco (Huawei) r01 is OK. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2008008 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0502R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the UE procedure for selecting a WLAN access based on WLANSP rules | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007663R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.3 | - | - | - | Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (ATSSS) | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 7.3 | S2-2007123 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0495 (Rel-16, 'F'): Policy subscription information extension to include ATSSS information | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008010 | Tricci (ZTE) requests for clarification on ATSSS information. Tricci (ZTE) requests for clarification on ATSSS support for critical GBR traffic flows. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also requests for clarification. Susan (Huawei) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) provides a proposal to check with ZTE and Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with the proposal to add a NOTE to explain what ATSSS information are. Tricci (ZTE) thanks Ericsson for clarification and it is okay with the revised change. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Marco (Huawei) comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei and provides an explanation. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Susan (Huawei) and asks Huawei who the speaking person from Huawei is. Apostolis (Lenovo) is fine with the proposed NOTE that refers to 23.502. Susan (Huawei) replies to Belen and is ok with r01. Marco (Huawei) ok with the clarification. Florin (Broadcom) is ok with the proposed Note and suggests small editorial updates in r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.3 | S2-2008010 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0495R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Policy subscription information extension to include ATSSS information | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007123R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.3 | S2-2007471 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2501 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of usage of Delay Critical GBR Flows in ATSSS | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Noted | Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification and provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01, cannot agree with initial version for the CR. Tricci (ZTE) corrects the wrong tdoc#. It should be S2-2007471 and NOT S2-2007123. Comment remains the same. Dario (QC) provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia does not see that r03 provided by LGE solves the issue. Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Yannick (Nokia). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to LGE. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Yannick (LGE). Apostolis (Lenovo) supports the comments made by Myungjune (LGE). Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports the comments made by Myungjune (LGE) and Apostolis. Florin (Broadcom) also supports the comments made by Myungjune, Apostolis and Dieter. He also wonders if the proposed CR is really needed. Dario (Qualcomm) replies and provides r04 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia does not see the need for r04. This is not a correction. Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Yannick Stefan (Ericsson) questions the need for any CR Dario (Qualcomm) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.4 | - | - | - | Cellular IoT support and evolution for the 5G System (5G_CIoT) + RAN Rel-16 alignment - MT-EDT | - | - | Docs:=25 | - | |
| 7.4 | S2-2006819 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on service area restriction for CIoT 5GS optimization | SA WG1 (S1-203274) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2007144. Final response in S2-2008011 | Lalith (Samsung) indicates S2-2007144 should be considered as reply LS for 6819. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Replied to |
| 7.4 | S2-2007144 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on exception data reporting in non-allowed area | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008011 | Lalith (Samsung) provides comments Qian (Ericsson) provides response to Lalith (Samsung) Hannu (Nokia) responds supporting Qian (Ericsson). Lalith(Samsung) responds to Qian(Ericsson) Hannu (Nokia) replies to Lalith(Samsung) Steve (Huawei) comments. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments Toon Norp (KPN) provides comments related to the discussion in SA1 Lalith (Samsung) provides comments. Hannu (Nokia) fully supports comments from Steve and Miguel. Miguel (Qualcomm) supports r01 provided by Hannu and ok with r00. Lalith(Samsung) confirm is OK with the LS === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2008011 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on exception data reporting in non-allowed area | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007144R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007145 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2476 (Rel-16, 'F'): Exception data reporting and connected state | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Steve regarding r01 Steve (Huawei) comments. Lalith (Samsung) provides r02 Hannu (Nokia) supports the original version, objects to r01 and r02. Ericsson (Nokia) supports original version and objects to r02/r01. Qian (Ericsson) supports original version and objects to r02/r01 (fixing the previous text 'Ericsson (Nokia)'). Hannu (Nokia) proposes to agree the original version. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2006799 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on early UE capability retrieval for eMTC | RAN WG2 (R2-2008238) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2006778 from S2#140E. Responses drafted in S2-2007209 and S2-2007665. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008336. | Revised | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007208 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on use of truncated 5G-S-TMSI to retrieve UE Capabilities. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2007630 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on early UE radio capability retrieval. | Qualcomm Inc, ZTE, Sanechips, Sierra Wireless, Thales, Turkcell, Aselsan, Sequans | Rel-16 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2007631 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2507 (Rel-16, 'B'): Truncated 5G S-TMSI for early UE capability retrieval | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) objects against the LTE-M part of this CR and asks a question Steve (Huawei) suggests noting the CR. Jinguo(ZTE) supports the 501 CR. Qian (Ericsson) comments Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Qian that SA2 must not add this new requirement for RAN2 in Rel-16. Qian (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE the paper. Jean Yves (Thales) supports the CR. Hannu (Nokia) still insists that we must note this CR as it is not part of the agreed Rel-16 contents. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007209 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on early UE capability retrieval for eMTC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006799. This was postponed. | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to revise the LS out. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Hannu (Nokia) that we should have technical discussion, regardless of Release, not OK with r00 or r01. Steve (Huawei) comments. Miguel (Qualcomm) replies to Steve Jinguo (ZTE) agrees with Miguel (Qualcomm) Noam (Sequans) agrees with QC and ZTE Hannu (Nokia) responds to comments. Miguel (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions, prefers S2-2007665 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Noam (Sequans) objects to all revisions, prefers S2-2007665 Steve (Sierra Wireless) objects to all revisions, prefers S2-2007665 === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007665 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} Reply LS on early UE capability retrieval for eMTC | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006799. This was postponed. | Steve (Huawei) suggests noting this LS. S2-2007209 should be sent instead. Miguel (Qualcomm) disagrees with Steve on noting this LS, does not agree with using S2-2007209 Jinguo (ZTE) agrees with Miguel (Qualcomm). Noam (Sequans) agrees with QC and ZTE Steve (Huawei) comments that RAN2 has said they won't address the technical concerns. Hannu (Nokia) supports Steve (Huawei) proposal to note. Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Steve that RAN2 did provide an answer to only SA2 valid concern. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r01 Noam (Sequans) comments on the LS revision Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02 with Noam's (Sequans) text. Qian (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE the paper. Jean Yves (Thales) comments and propose not to block regarding RAN2 discussions Hannu (Nokia) supports Qian (Ericsson) proposal to NOTE the paper. Steve (Huawei) objects to r00 and r02. Prefers S2-2007209. Miguel (Qualcomm) proposes r01 as way forward === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hannu (Nokia) can live with either 7665r01 or 7209r01. Let's pick one of these in CC #2. === CC#2 === Qian (Ericsson) is also ok with either 7209r01 or 7665r01, if the plan is to send a LS from this meeting. === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2006807 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Event Configuration Synchronization between 4G&5G | CT WG4 (C4-204338) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2007256. Final response in S2-2008002 | Replied to | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007256 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on 'Event Configuration Synchronization between | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006807. Agreed. Revised to clean up in S2-2008002 | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2008002 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on 'Event Configuration Synchronization between 4G&5G' | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007256. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007257 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2482 (Rel-16, 'F'): Event Configuration Synchronization between 4G&5G | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007258 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2421 (Rel-16, 'F'): Event Configuration Synchronization between 4G&5G | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2006791 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on AS RAI and optimization of release | RAN WG2 (R2-2005839) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004804 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008333. | Chris (Vodafone) asks to postpone this LS. We have the normal RAI questions on change of encryption keys and removal of subscription to address. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2007205 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2418 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to the downlink data notification with V-SMF and I-SMF | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Qian (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments. Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments and questions. Steve (Huawei) answers the questions. Qian (Ericsson) comments. Qian (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the paper. Steve (Huawei) replies with more details, hopes to change the thoughts about postponing. Qian (Ericsson) responds and considers postponing the paper is the correct choice at this stage. Steve (Huawei) ok, lets postpone for now and come back. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007206 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2481 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Enhanced Coverage Restriction | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | Qian (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments. Hannu (Nokia) responds to Steve (Huawei). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007207 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2419 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Enhanced Coverage Restriction | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008012 | Qian (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments on the 2 parameters Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments Steve (Huawei) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2008012 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2419R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Enhanced Coverage Restriction | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007207R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007259 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2422 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Network Configuration Parameter handling | Ericsson | Rel-16 | This was postponed. | Steve (Huawei) asks a questions about some aspects of the CR Judy (Ericsson) responds to Steve (Huawei). Steve (Huawei) checks the clarifications Judy (Ericsson) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) comments. Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless) comments. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Steve (Huawei) and Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless). Steve (Huawei) comments on the next steps, more thought required. Hannu (Nokia) asks whether this is stage 3 alignment? Steve (Huawei) no alignment required. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note the CR if the comment from Steve (Huawei) can be confirmed. Judy (Ericsson) comment that the argument (i.e. alignment with stage 3) of proposing to note the paper is not valid, and suggest to progress the paper otherwise stage 3 work will be affected. Hannu (Nokia) can agree the CR. Steve (Huawei) does not agree with the CR, it should be postponed. Judy (Ericsson) do not agree with Huawei to postpone the CR due to lack of technical reason, and asks to reconsider their position, otherwise we propose to bring the discussion to CC#2. Steve (Huawei) still suggests postpone. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2007484 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2433 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on header compression for CP Optimisation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008013 | Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. Hannu (Nokia) asks whether this is FASMO? Steve (Huawei) thinks it is a good clarification and provides r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2008013 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2433R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on header compression for CP Optimisation | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007484R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2007682 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2448 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications for GUTI re-allocation | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008014 | Lars (Sony) Ask questions Hannu (Nokia) answers to Lars (Sony) and provides revision r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions. Wanqiang (Huawei) supports the principle of the paper, and provides revision r02. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and revision r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r03 Hannu (Nokia) supports r03. Lars (Sony) is also ok with r03. Chris (Vodafone) asks whether we are making the periodic procedure too heavyweight? (Change should to may or can) Qian (Ericsson) provides r04 Wanqiang (Huawei) prefers r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) prefers r03 to keep alignment with TS 33.501 ('should' for GUTI reallocation during periodic registration); objects to r04 Hannu (Nokia) proposes to agree r03 to align with TS 33.501 Chris (Vodafone) does not object to r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2008014 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2448R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications for GUTI re-allocation | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007682R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | Enablers for Network Automation for 5G (eNA) | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2006800 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on New function for Network Slice PA and Management Charging | SA WG5 (S5-204593) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2006779 from S2#140E. Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggests to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.5 | S2-2006907 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0188 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications for Charging function as NWDAF consumer | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007382, to S2-2008015 | Xiaobo (Huawei) provide r01 by merging S2-2007382 into S2-2006907. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r03 to reword the NOTE2 a little bit. Andy (VC, Samsung) asks Ericsson if we can move forward with 6907. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r04 to reword the NOTE1 a little bit. Belen (Ericsson) can live with r02 provided by Ericsson, or r03 provided by Nokia (although this may require further references to SA5 TSs in our view). Belen (Ericsson) objects to r04. Gerald (Matrix) is suggesting a new rev5 to resolve inconsistencies. Belen (Ericsson) provides r06. Gerald (Matrixx) is asking for clarification on not covered inconsistency resolution in r06. Xiaobo (Huawei) can live with r06. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Gerald (Matrixx). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r06. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia supports going forward with r06. Gerald (Matrixx) the linkage of Nnwdaf services to CEF of TS 28.201 in clause 6.4 is provided in r07. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06 and objects to r07. Gerald (Matrixx) is asking for more clarification. Belen (Ericsson) clarifies as requested. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also supports r06. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2008015 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0188R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications for Charging function as NWDAF consumer | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006907R06, merging S2-2007382. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2007382 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0190 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding CEF as a new consumer of NWDAF service | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2008015 | Xiaobo (Huawei) propose to merge it into S2-2006907. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK to merge the CR into 6907. Andy (VC, Samsung) says will mark this as merged into 6907. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.5 | S2-2006852 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0187 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarificaton for data collection for NWDAF | China Telecom | Rel-16 | Noted | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Liu Liu (China Telecom) replies Jaehyu (LGE). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests clarification on what is the issue that needs to be solved in Rel-16. Liu Liu (China Telecom) replies Belen (Ericsson) and provides r02. Liu Liu (China Telecom) repliesYannick (Nokia). Liu Liu (China Telecom) replies Antoine (Orange). Jungshin (Samsung) provides r03 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia does not see a correction is needed. This is clearly not FASMO issue. Nokia objects to all versions. Liu Liu (China Telecom) replies Yannick (Nokia). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Telecom. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.5 | S2-2007224 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0189 (Rel-16, 'F'): NWDAF discovering Trusted AF from NRF | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests clarification on what is the issue that needs to be solved in Rel-16. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with this clarification provided in the initial version. Malla (NTT DOCOMO): Agrees with Nokia. Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes to continue the discussion in the 7225 thread Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agrees that S2-2007224 and S2-2007225 are linked together. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to this CR, this is non FASMO. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.5 | S2-2007225 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2420 (Rel-16, 'F'): NRF including an NF profile from a Trusted AF | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests clarification on what is the issue that needs to be solved in Rel-16. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with this clarification provided in the initial version. Ask one question. Antoine (Orange): not really FASMO. Malla (NTT DOCOMO): Agree with Nokia and Orange. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to comments from Malla, Yannick, Antoine, Belen Xiaobo (Huawei) support the clarification Yannick (Nokia): Nokia does not see this as FASMO, objects to this proposal. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 and clarifications why the proposal is not FASMO Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r01 and supports the proposal. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides further comments, objects to r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to r00 and r01, this is non FASMO. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.5 | S2-2007406 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2425 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications for the BDT policy negotiation procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Mirko (Huawei) responds. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.6 | - | - | - | Enhancement to the 5GC Location Services (5G_eLCS) | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 7.6 | S2-2006788 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on UE initiated Event Reporting Procedure for Low Power Event Reporting and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR | CT WG1 (C1-204046) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004797 from S2#140E. Noted | Runze (Huawei) proposes to NOTE the LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2007109 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response on Bulk operation of LCS-service | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004803 (Replied to at S2#140E in S2-2005921). Agreed. Revised to clean up in S2-2008229 | Runze (Huawei) supports the original version. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.6 | S2-2008229 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Response on Bulk operation of LCS-service | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007109. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.6 | S2-2007110 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0131 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Bulk Operation | Ericsson, CATT, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008230 | Sherry (Xiaomi) supports this CR and provides r01. Runze (Huawei) supports r01. Ake Busin (Ericsson) supports r01. Pallab (Nokia) also supports r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.6 | S2-2008230 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0131R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Bulk Operation | Ericsson, CATT, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Xiaomi | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007110R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.6 | S2-2007190 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0132 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of the usage of start time and stop time attributes | CATT | Rel-16 | Postponed | Stephen (Qualcomm) identifies various errors in the CR (r00) Pallab(Nokia) agrees with the comments from Stephen(Qualcomm) and questions the need for the CR Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects the CR Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Ake Busin (Ericsson) Respond to question from CATT and don't see need of CR. Yunjing (CATT) responds to Ericsson. Ake Busin (Ericsson) Further clarification to questions. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01. Runze (Huawei) proposes to postpone the CR. Yunjing (CATT) asks whether r0 is acceptable. Stephen (Qualcomm) also proposes to postpone the CR; r00 is also not acceptable Runze (Huawei) replies to Yunjing. Yunjing (CATT) is ok to postpone the CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.6 | S2-2007415 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0133 (Rel-16, 'F'): Support of service continuity for deferred location request | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Confirm CR Number - CR states XXXX! Noted | Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification Åke Busin (Ericsson) provides ro1 Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees r01 and sees no need for the r00 Pallab (Nokia) questions the need for the CR (both r00 and r01) Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to all versions of the CR Sherry (Xiaomi) questions the need for the CR, and asks for clarifications. Runze (Huawei) asks for clarification . Runze (Huawei ) asks clarification. Runze (Huawei) replies to Pallab. Runze (Huawei) replies to Leo. Runze (Huawei) replies to Ake. Runze (Huawei) provides r02 Pallab (Nokia) requests for further clarification and conditionally objects to the CR Åke Busin (Ericsson) Responds to reply from Runze Runze (Huawei) responds to Ake. Stephen (Qualcomm) can only agree r01 (not r00 or r02) Runze (Huawei) replies to Stephen. Ake Busin (Ericsson) will only agree r01 (not r00 or r02) Pallab (Nokia) do not agree with r01. Runze (Huawei) replies to Ericsson, Pallab and Qualcomm. It is unfair to receive objections without technical reasons! Pallab (Nokia) responds to Runze (Huawei) Ake Busin (Ericsson) Clarifies further Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to r00, r01 and r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2007416 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0134 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update of obtaining Non-UE Associated Network Assistance Data procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Confirm CR Number - CR states XXXX! Noted | Pallab (Nokia) questions the need for the CR Sherry (Xiaomi) questions the need for the CR and requests for clarification. Ake Busin (Ericsson) Objects to CR. Runze (Huawei) replies to Sherry. Runze (Huawei) replies to Ake and suggest to withdraw the objection. Tao(Chair)further check whether r00 is agreeable with clarifications. Pallab (Nokia) does not agree to the CR Ake Busin (Ericsson) objects to r00. Runze (Huawei) replies to Nokia and Ericsson. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2007417 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0135 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of LMF handling on receiving Cartesian coordinate report from RAN | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Confirm CR Number - CR states XXXX! Noted | Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification Stephen (Qualcomm) adds more comments on why the CR is unsuitable Ake Busin (Ericsson) Objects to CR. Runze replies to Pallab. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stephen. Runze (Huawei) replies to Ake and suggest to withdraw the objection. Runze (Huawei) provides r01. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Runze (Huawei) and objects to any further revision of the CR. Runze (Huawei) replies to Pallab. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Runze (Huawei). Stephen (Qualcomm) object to r00 and r01 Stephen (Qualcomm) objects again to r00 and r01 Runze (Huawei) replies to Pallab (Nokia). Ake Busin (Ericsson) objects to r00. Ake Busin (Ericsson) objects to r00 and r01 Pallab (Nokia) responds to Runze (Huawei) and proposes to postpone this CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2007658 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0136 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of NAS message used for event reporting | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008231 | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01 which replaces the r00 Runze (Huawei) provides r02. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r03 Runze (Huawei) agrees to r03 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) agrees to r03 but requests that on cover page 'June' has to be replaced by 'October' before the final version is uploaded. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.6 | S2-2008231 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0136R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of NAS message used for event reporting | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007658R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services (Vertical_LAN) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.7.1 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services - 5G-LAN aspects | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2007046 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2468 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GLAN clarifications | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007801 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r01 Josep (DT) asks a question. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Laurent (Nokia) supports Qianghua's answer === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2007801 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2468R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GLAN clarifications | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007046R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services - TSN aspects | - | - | Docs:=27 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | LSs and related CRs | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007744 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006797. Covered by S2-2007105. Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE this response and take response in 7105 as the baseline, see comment. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. Qianghua (Huawei) asks for clarification Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and Huawei comments. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this merged to 7105. zhendong (ZTE) provies a suggestion. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2006797 | LS In | Information | LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on the need for survival time | IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-3GPP-SA2-survival-time) | - | Revision of postponed S2-2004934 from S2#140E. Final response in S2-2007821. | Replied to | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=25 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2006994 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2462 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Bridge Management Information | Intel | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007807 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to align with Stage 3 thus merge with S2-2007741. Saso (Intel) comments. Saso (Intel) is OK to merge 6994 in 7741. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007043 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0493 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on transfer of BMIC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007804 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) asks questions Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge 7510, 7071 to this. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Saso (Intel) proposes to merge this contribution 7043 in 7071 because it has an additional change. zhendong (ZTE) is fine, using the 7071 as base. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with merging into S2-2007071. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007044 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2466 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on gPTP handling at NW-TT acting as the GM | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007802 | Devaki (Nokia) comments this paper is not FASMO. Nokia objects to this paper as it is a late addition for Rel-16, rather address this is in Rel-17. zhendong (ZTE) ask for clarification Shabnam (Ericsson) comments Qianghua (Huawei) responds Shabnam (Ericsson) asks that if we are adding normative requirements then it should not be a NOTE but clarified in the main body. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01, changing NOTE2 into Normative text zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments zhendong (ZTE) provides the response and provides the r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007802 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2466R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on gPTP handling at NW-TT acting as the GM | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007044R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007045 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2467 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections on usage of PSFP | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007743R04 (but this was eventually noted) | Devaki (Nokia) asks questions for clarification. György (Ericsson) disagrees with the CR. Qianghua (Huawei) responds György (Ericsson) responds Saso (Intel) comments and proposes to consider the discussion on the 7743 thread. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responses Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with 7743. György (Ericsson) proposes r02. Devaki (Nokia) proposes that this was merged with 7743, requests Ericsson to provide revision for 7743. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 György (Ericsson) objects to r03, r01 and r00. Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses Devaki (Nokia) comments. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei . Qianghua (Huawei) asks a question Devaki (Nokia) objects to r00, r02. We believe the clarification in r02 is not FASMO nor technically solving the issue raised. R01 or R03 is ok but also merged in 7743. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees that this should be merged in 7743 György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei's question. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. György (Ericsson) responds to Jari Devaki (Nokia) asks Ericsson. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) responds to Jari. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007056 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2411 (Rel-16, 'F'): Replacing Bridge Address with Bridge ID | Intel | Rel-16 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.501. Intel confirmed 23.502. R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007803 | Saso (Intel) provides r01 fixing the cover page (23.502 instead of 23.501). zhendong (ZTE) question for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Zhendong. zhendong (ZTE) provides response === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007803 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2411R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Replacing Bridge Address with Bridge ID | Intel | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007056R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007071 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0494 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to TSN Bridge Information on N7 | Intel | Rel-16 | Confirm Specification Number - CR states 23.501. Intel confirmed 23.503. R02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007510 and S2-2007043, to S2-2007804 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with revisions of 7043. Saso (Intel) proposes r01. Also proposes to merge 7043 and 7510 into 7071. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r01 and merging 7043 into 7071r01 zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007804 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0494R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to TSN Bridge Information on N7 | Intel, ZTE, Huawei | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007071R02, merging S2-2007510 and S2-2007043. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007073 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2470 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to inaccurate and misleading NOTE4 in the BMIC table | Intel | Rel-16 | CC#2: Samsung withdrew their objection to this. The original document was approved. | Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Saso (Intel) objects to r01 and replies to Sang-Jun. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Saso and others. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. Saso (Intel) disagrees with Sang-Jun; agrees with Zhendong. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Zhendong and Saso; and objects to r00. Saso (Intel) requests this CR to be handled in CC#2. zhendong (ZTE) response Saso (Intel) confirms Zhendong view === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Jari, Saso, Zhendong. Saso (Intel) comments to Sang-Jun (Samsung). Sang-Jun (Samsung) withdraws his objection to r00. Saso (Intel) thanks Sang-Jun (Samsung) for the constructive proposal. === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007106 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2472 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of TSN AF role | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | Devaki (Nokia) proposes that the architecture figure shall not be deleted. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds it is not deleted, it is updated since the TSN system on the right somehow was deleted in the spec. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007394 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2492 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on H.3 Signaling for Announce message | ETRI | Rel-16 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) questions the need for this CR as current text already states to follow IEEE spec. Yoohwa (ETRI) responds. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with ZTE comment and objects to the CR, current text is sufficiently describing Rel-16 agreement. Yoohwa (ETRI) responds to Shabnam and Zhendong . zhendong (ZTE) provides response to ETRI Yoohwa (ETRI) responds to zhendong. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. yoohwa (ETRI) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007399 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2493 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification for TSCAI | OPPO | Rel-16 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) wonders about technical feasibility of this CR for Rel-16. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to this CR, as it expands the already clearly defined scope of Rel-16 for this parameter, see comments. Yali (OPPO) replies to Devaki . Yali (OPPO) asks Shabnam for clarification. György (Ericsson) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) share the same understanding with Ericsson and Nokia Yali (OPPO) ok to note the CR. Chunshan (Tencent) shares the same understanding with Ericsson. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) also proposes to note the CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007507 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2503 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify the time synchronization figure | ZTE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to original, r02, r03, provides reasons in the comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Shabnam Shabnam (Ericsson) Comments. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03/r02, disagree with r01 zhendong (ZTE) ok with r03 and r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007508 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2504 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UPF report Bridge ID | ZTE | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007805 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) responds György (Ericsson) provides r03 zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments to r03 György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE. Qianghua (Huawei) shares Ericsson's answers and OK with R03 Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Yoohwa (ETRI) comments. György (Ericsson) aks Nokia about r04. György (Ericsson) responds to ETRI. zhendong (ZTE) provides r05 Devaki (Nokia) can accept r01, r04, has objections to r05 as it describes UPF internals, restricting it. György (Ericsson) objects to r01. We prefer r03, but we could live with the shortened r04. zhendong (ZTE) can accept r04 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007805 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2504R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UPF report Bridge ID | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007508R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007509 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2434 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UPF report Bridge ID | ZTE | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007806 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007806 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2434R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UPF report Bridge ID | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007509R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007510 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0498 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update the 5GS bridge information and BMIC. | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007804 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with revisions of 7043. zhendong (ZTE) agree to merge to 7043. zhendong (ZTE) agree with intel proposal Saso (Intel) proposes to merge 7510 in 7071 because 7071 has an additional change. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007511 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2505 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the N4 session management | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007807 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with revisions of 7741. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments and agree the merge === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007741 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2511 (Rel-16, 'F'): Updates to N4 for NW-TT port number reporting | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007511 and S2-2006994, to S2-2007807 | Saso (Intel) proposes to merge with S2-2006994. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Saso (Intel) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) fine with r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides the r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007807 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2511R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Updates to N4 for NW-TT port number reporting | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007741R03, merging S2-2007511 and S2-2006994. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007742 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2512 (Rel-16, 'F'): TSN QoS determination | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007808 | Xiaowan(vivo) provides comments and r01 Devaki (Nokia) comments on r01. Xiaowan(vivo) replies Devaki (Nokia) Xiaowan(vivo) provided r02 Qianghua(Huawei) provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) fine with r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports r03 provided by Huawei as that is correct way of referencing within same spec. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007808 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2512R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): TSN QoS determination | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007742R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2007743 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2513 (Rel-16, 'F'): Ingress port determination of 5GS Bridge | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Noted | György (Ericsson) comments. Saso (Intel) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) fine with r01. Saso (Intel) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02, merging S2-2007045r01 György (Ericsson) raises issues with the proposal. Saso (Intel) comments and provides r03. György (Ericsson) objects to r03. Devaki (Nokia) replies to Ericsson. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with Devaki and Saso, r04 is provided merging S2-2007045 György (Ericsson) replies to Nokia. György (Ericsson) objects to all revisions r00-r04. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson and provides r05. György (Ericsson) objects to r05. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson's arguments. Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees with Ericsson's arguments and proposes to go with r05. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services - Type a/b aspects | - | - | Docs:=24 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | LSs and related CRs | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2006801 | LS In | Action | LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | CT WG1 (C1-205222) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2007039, S2-2007313, S2-2007348 and S2-2007599. Final response in S2-2007809 | Kundan Tiwari (NEC) propose to send an LS response to the CT1 indicating that CAG only UE cannot access E-UTRAN connected to EPS. The reasoning is provided below. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Kundan (NEC) Kundan(NEC) responds to Guillaume (Mediatek). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Replied to |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007039 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006801. Merged into S2-2007809 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the proposal and mark it as merged into S2-2007348 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with the merging === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007313 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | Ericsson | Response to S2-2006801 Merged into S2-2007809 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the proposal and mark it as merged into S2-2007348 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007348 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | OPPO | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006801. R01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007696, S2-2007599, S2-2007313 and S2-2007039, to S2-2007809 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007809 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007348R01, merging S2-2007696, S2-2007599, S2-2007313 and S2-2007039. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007599 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006801 Merged into S2-2007809 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the proposal and mark it as merged into S2-2007348 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007696 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} Reply LS on clarification of CAG only UE accessing EPS network | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006801 Merged into S2-2007809 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the proposal and mark it as merged into S2-2007348 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok to merge === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007373 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2491 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the CAG not applied for EPS selection | OPPO | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007810 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes CR marked as merged into CR in S2-2007314 Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark merged. Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends to note the CR as it is not FASMO. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007314 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2486 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of CAG information | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007373, to S2-2007810 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Fei (OPPO) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends to note the CR as it is not FASMO. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to MediaTek. Fei (OPPO) supports what Peter (Ericsson) said. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Ericsson, Oppo. Kundan Tiwari (NEC) has different opinion than Ericsson that CAG only UE can access EPS i.e. CAG information (CAG only) has no implication on UE behaviour on E-UTRAN connected to EPS. Details are given below. So we are NOT fine with the CR v1 or initial version. NEC (Kundan Tiwari) disagrees with Ericsson, Oppo, Mediatek and provides reasoning to them. The reasoning is given below Kundan Tiwari (NEC) provides further clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to NEC and MediaTek. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Ericsson, NEC. Guillaume (MediaTek) meant to say 'Samsung' not 'NEC'. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) CAG indication should not impact EPS selection and registration Kundan (NEC) provides further explanation that CAG only was only designed for 5GS not for EPS. Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Kundan (NEC) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Kundan (NEC) clarifies that S2-2007314r04.zip brings service continuity issues. Further explanation is given below. Devaki (Nokia) comments on r04. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides responses to Nokia and NEC. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Peter. R04 is ok for us. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Kundan (NEC) clarifies further . === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007810 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2486R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of CAG information | Ericsson, OPPO, MediaTek Inc. | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007314R04, merging S2-2007373. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007698 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Access to EPS for UEs with CAG only configuration. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2006793 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3LI: Additional Clarifications on LI requirements applicable to SNPNs | SA WG3LI (S3i200409) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004810 from S2#140E. Response drafted in S2-2007305. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008334. | Revised | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007305 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Additional Clarifications on LI requirements applicable to SNPNs | Ericsson | Response to S2-2006793. R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007811 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) prefers r01; objects to r00 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Devaki (Nokia) flags that there is an issue with the approved r01 of the LS out - it states attached document is approved but it has not been approved. === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions and request this be noted. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007811 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Additional Clarifications on LI requirements applicable to SNPNs | Ericsson | - | Revision of S2-2007305R01. The attached CR was not agreed, so this LS was noted. | Noted | |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007040 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2464 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on CAG configuration update via Deregistration request to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2007813 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes that this CR is noted as it is not aligned with stage 3, and instead CR in S2-2007347 is used. Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Ericsson and OK merging this into S2-2007347 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007041 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2410 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on CAG configuration update via Deregistration request to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) objects to the CR & its revisions. zhendong (ZTE) correct the AI in the title Devaki (Nokia) raises a question regarding the need for this CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments that the CR is not correct. Qianghua (Huawei) asks Nokia to withdraw the objection since you object to this CR by mistake, and reply to Ericsson Devaki (Nokia) withdraws the objections, open for further discussions related to this CR. Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (all revisions) Qianghua (Huawei) responds Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Huawei Kundan(NEC) provides comment. This is an alignment CR not a FASMO CR. So it is not needed. Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to go with R02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (all revisions) (2nd time) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007042 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2465 (Rel-16, 'F'): Reject UE access to SNPN service via a PLMN to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007812 | Devaki (Nokia) objects to the CR & its revisions. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Antoine (Orange): asks a question. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Curt (Charter) agrees with Peter (Ericsson) and Devaki (Nokia). Qianghua (Huawei) responds and accepts to postpone this CR Devaki (Nokia) replies. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 Devaki (Nokia) raises a question regarding the chosen restriction type in the revisions. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to agree r03 as technically corect. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) Ericsson is ok with r04. Devaki (Nokia) can live with r04 provided we agree to revisit the right restriction and access type for this in a future meeting. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007812 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2465R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Reject UE access to SNPN service via a PLMN to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007042R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007304 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2484 (Rel-16, 'F'): N3IWF selection procedure when accessing SNPN via PLMN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Marco (Huawei) comments George (Ericsson) [provides response. Marco (Huawei) further asks. George (Ericsson) [provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Marco George (Ericsson) [Ericsson objects to r02. See comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r00 and r01 George (Ericsson) provides a response. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to George Marco (Huawei) agrees with Sebastian's explanation === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Alex (Rogers) asks for clarification Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Alex === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007347 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2488 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment with CT specification on updating the UE with new CAG information | China Telecom | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007040, to S2-2007813 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) we are fine with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007813 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2488R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment with CT specification on updating the UE with new CAG information | China Telecom, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007347R02, merging S2-2007040. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007434 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2498 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on RRC Resume procedure when considering CAG information | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. In our view current stage 2 text is fine and this is not a FASMO CR. Hence we object r0 of that CR. Hualin(Huawei) response to Paul (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 modifying the definition as to make it usable in both stage 2 and stage 3 specs. Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) and provides r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and a question. Shuyi Tian(China Telecom) provides comments to r01. Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter(E///). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides clarifications. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks why this is a FASMO issue Chia-Lin (MediaTek) propose to postpone this CR Hualin(Huawei) response to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the topic as CT1 discussing it. Hualin(Huawei) agree to postpone the topic as CT1 discussing it. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007740 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2451 (Rel-16, 'F'): Use of NSSF Services for SNPN | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Cisco | Rel-16 | R03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007814 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Devaki (Nokia) replies. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment and agrees with Nokia. Josep (DT) comments whether this is the correct place and asks whether S2-2007084 is related. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Josep. Patrice (Huawei) comments and objects to the CR. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Patrice (Huawei) replies, objects to r01 as being non-FASMO stage 3 description in the wrong section. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides replies to the comments from Huawei. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) comment. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to raise this CR for CC#2 as this issue has open since SA2#138 (blocked due to one objection always). Patrice (Huawei) comments further, shows that the CR is not in line with the reasoning, and that what is intended is already supported by the specifications since Rel-15 (and is nothing special for Vertical_LAN). Patrice (Huawei) provides r02 in the good spirit of compromise, and objects to all other revisions. Devaki (Nokia) fine with r02. Patrice (Huawei) thanks Devaki (Nokia), and prefers to keep the statement as a note. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Patrice (Huawei) is OK with r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2007814 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2451R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Use of NSSF Services for SNPN | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Cisco | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007740R03. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | - | - | - | Enhancements to the Service-Based 5G System Architecture (5G_eSBA) | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 7.8 | S2-2006877 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2456 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on SMF change with eSBA | Samsung | Rel-16 | R04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008232 | Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r01. Josep (DT) proposes r02. Thomas (Nokia) proposes r03. Sangsoo (Samsung) is fine with r03, and proposes r04 to reflect the correct reason for change in the cover page. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2008232 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2456R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on SMF change with eSBA | Samsung, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006877R04. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2006949 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2458 (Rel-16, 'F'): Routiing through SCP for notifications | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Fenqin (Huawei) comments and object this CR Magnus H (Ericsson) ask for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Magnus H (Ericsson) responds. Josep (DT) comments that the text is not clear and may even be wrong. Thomas (Nokia) objects to this CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.8 | S2-2006950 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2459 (Rel-16, 'F'): SCP domain definition correction | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r01 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia) objects against this CR Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for the clarification. Magnus H (Ericsson) clarifies this CR Antoine (Orange) doesn't understand the Reason for change. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Magnus Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Josep (DT) does not understand why this is FASMO or the reason for change. Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Jinguo (ZTE) asks question Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 Magnus H (Ericsson) accepts r03 Josep (DT) rejects r03 and provides r04 Thomas(Nokia) replies to Jinguo (ZTE) Antoine (Orange) objects to r03 and r04. Thomas (Nokia) objects to r00, r01 and r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.8 | S2-2006951 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2460 (Rel-16, 'F'): Multiplicity of discovery and selection parameters | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) objects against this CR Magnus H (Ericsson) clarifies Fenqin (Huawei) comments Thomas (Nokia) replies to Magnus === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.8 | S2-2007279 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2483 (Rel-16, 'F'): Group Id from AMF to SMF removal when SCP is responsible for reselection | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008233 | Fenqin (Huawei) comments Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments and asks if it clarifies. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Fenqin (Huawei) responds, Thomas (Nokia) objects against this CR Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 and replies to questions and comments from Nokia and Huawei. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) asks Nokia if r02 is okay for them since they raised objections to this CR. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02 Thomas (Nokia) can accept r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2008233 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2483R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Group Id from AMF to SMF removal when SCP is responsible for reselection | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007279R02. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.9 | - | - | - | Architecture enhancements for the support of Integrated access and backhaul (IABARC) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10 | - | - | - | Other Rel-16 WIDs | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.1 | - | - | - | Enhancement of URLLC supporting in 5GC (5G_URLLC) | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2006796 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS on Support of Dual Connectivity end to end Redundant User Plane Paths | CT WG3 (C3-203678) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004933 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008335. | Belen (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this LS. Hui (Huawei) supports to postpone this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2006792 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | RAN WG3 (R3-204325) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004809 from S2#140E. Responses drafted in S2-2007000 and S2-2007142. Final response in S2-2008234 | Replied to | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007000 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to RAN WG3 for clarification of QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006792. R02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008234 | Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks to ignore r01. Hui (Huawei) fine with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2008234 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to RAN WG3 for clarification of QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007000R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007142 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006792. Noted | Hui (Huawei) objects to this tdoc. Devaki (Nokia) agrees with Huawei. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) support Huawei and Nokia. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007001 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2358R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS related parameters to be updated during Handover | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005372 from S2#140E. R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008235 | OPPO (Yang Xu) comments and asks for clarification. Hui (Huawei) responses. Hui (Huawei) provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2008235 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2358R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS related parameters to be updated during Handover | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007001R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007002 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2416R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): TSCAI update during Handover procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005371 from S2#140E. Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007143 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2348R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS parameter update at Xn HO | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005132 from S2#140E. Noted | Qian (Ericsson) provides r01. Hui (Huawei) comments to r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments on r01. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Hui (Huawei). Qian (Ericsson) responses. Devaki (Nokia) OK objects to r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments Qian (Ericsson) provides response to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Qian (Ericsson) provides response to Devaki (Nokia). Hui(Huawei) provides comments to Qian. Qian(Ericsson) provides responses to Hui (Huawei). Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments to Qian (Ericsson) Qian (Ericsson) responds Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and r02 Hui(Huawei) replies to Qian. Hui(Huawei) provides comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Hui's summary. Qian (Ericsson) says noting the paper since we go with 7001. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007140 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2475 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to QoS monitoring for URLLC on GTP-U | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008236 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. We are fine with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2008236 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2475R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to QoS monitoring for URLLC on GTP-U | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007140R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2007141 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2413 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correcting configuration of QoS monitoring for URLLC | Ericsson | Rel-16 | R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008237 | Susan (Huawei) raises objection to this CR. Paul (Ericsson) provides r01. Susan (Huawei) asks to send an LS to RAN3 to clarify the URLCC Monitoring measurement period and reporting frequency, apart from keeping objection to this CR. Susan (Huawei) is ok with r01, but still asks to send an LS to RAN3 to clarify the URLCC Monitoring measurement period and reporting frequency. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2008237 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2413R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correcting configuration of QoS monitoring for URLLC | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007141R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.2 | - | - | - | Enhancement of Network Slicing (eNS) | - | - | Docs:=17 | - | |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006808 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Counter of UEs Registering Network Slice | CT WG4 (C4-204421) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2006843 and 2006942. Final response in S2-2008238 | Alessio(Nokia) this incoming LS points to a CT4 solution not yet in our specs which is about counting UEs registered in a NS. This is covered also by KI of the FS_eNS_Ph2 (which handle Quota management but requires this counting as an enabler), so we wonder how to best handle this and in which release. Andy (VC, Samsung) says that this document is in AI 7.10.2 Gerald (Matrixx) proposed to postpone this LS till the conclusion. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Replied to |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006843 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on Counter of UEs Registering Network Slice | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006808 Merged into S2-2008238 | Dan (China Mobile) suggests this is merged with S2-2006942 and let's work for an agreement Haiyang (Huawei) is OK to merge based on the discussion. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006942 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Counter of UEs Registering Network Slice | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006808. R09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006843, to S2-2008238 | Haiyang (Huawei) comments and suggests to go with S2-2006843. Andy (VC, Samsung) says that this document is in AI 7.10.2 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggests that the topic should be handled in considerations of eNS_Ph2. Jinguo (ZTE) suggests to use this tdoc as basis and also add action to SA5 Alessio(Nokia) makes additional comments Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Dan(China Mobile) provides the reply to previous comments and request DOCOMO send the email again because I lost it. Hoyeon (Samsung) agrees with the suggestion to inform CT4 of the Rel-17 FS_eNS_Ph2 status in the response. Dan(China Mobile) provides r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and is ok with r01. Jinguo (ZTE) provides r02. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and prefers r02 from ZTE. Haiyang(Huawei) provides r03. Dan (China Mobile) is OK with r02, but can leave with r03 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r04 Genadi (Lenovo) proposes to document the reason for SA2 not specifying the procedure in Rel-16 and provides r05. Haiyang (Huawei) comments on r05 Jinguo (ZTE) response to Haiyang(Huawei) and provide r06. Dan (China Mobile) provide r07 Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r08. Gerald (Matrixx) suggest a rewording on the SA2 proposal to normative specifications. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2008238 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Counter of UEs Registering Network Slice | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006942R09, merging S2-2006843. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006958 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2461 (Rel-16, 'F'): AMF provides the Allowed NSSAI to UDM after UE's successful registration | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) suggests discuss this together with decision on handling of CT4 in S2-2006808 Andy (VC, Samsung) says that this document is in AI 7.10.2 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and agrees that the topic should be handled in considerations of eNS_Ph2. Dan (China Mobile) agrees that the CR can be handled with the decision of the correponding CT4 LS Hoyeon (Samsung) agrees with Ericsson and Nokia that the topic should be handled in considerations of eNS_Ph2. Tricci (ZTE) agree with Nokia, Ericsson, Samsung that this Rel-16 CR should be handled in considerations of eNS_Ph2. Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to note the CR base on the discussion. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006959 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2408 (Rel-16, 'F'): AMF provides the Allowed NSSAI to UDM after UE's successful registration | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) suggests discuss this together with decision on handling of CT4 in S2-2006808 Andy (VC, Samsung) says that this document is in AI 7.10.2 Dan (China Mobile) changes the AI and agree to handle the CR together with the decision of corresponding LS Gerald (Matrixx) proposed to postpone this CR till this topic will be handled in considerations of eNS_Ph2. Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to note the CR base on the discussion. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006790 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG4: LS Reply on SNSSAI support in N4 Session Establishment | CT WG4 (C4-203215) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004800 from S2#140E. Noted | Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to postpone the LS to the next meeting as there is ongoing discussion in S2-2007083 at this meeting, regarding the scenario where multiple PLMNs can share the same 5GC, which is also relevant to this LS. Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the incoming LS. Alessio (nokia) proposes to note the incoming LS. Jinguo (ZTE) support to note the incoming LS as there is no action for SA2. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question to Patrice (Huawei) about their opinion on the scenario where two PLMNs share the same 5GC. Patrice (Huawei) apologises to Hoyeon (Samsung) for the lack of clarity in his comment to last meeting, and clarifies. Hoyeon (Samsung) thanks Patrice (Huawei) for further explanation and asks a following question. Patrice (Huawei) provides some further comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007082 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2006785. Noted | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a r01 and proposes that the LS is set as one candidate to be agreed at the next CC after a show of hands. Patrice (Huawei) replies, provides r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to all revisions and proposes a resolution at the CC. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007302 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Handling of AAA-S address in NSSAA. | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note this discussion paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007300 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2389R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of AAA-S address in NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2004877 from S2#140E. CC#2: This was approved with an objection from Huawei. | Patrice (Huawei) objects to original version, and for the sake of good compromise provides r01 (details in this thread). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r01 as it still have the issue of disclosing not needed information to VPLMN and causing double implementations. Patrice (Huawei) comments further and makes it clear that the update answers the concerns that were expressed by Ericsson, and therefore the objection to the update does not seem legitimate. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as for CC. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007301 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2332R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of AAA-S address in NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2004878 from S2#140E. Should be CR 2332R1. CC#2: This was approved with an objection from Huawei. | Patrice (Huawei) objects to original version, and for the sake of compromise provides r01 (see S2-2007300 for more details). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r01 as it still have the issue of disclosing not needed information to VPLMN and causing double implementations. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to mark this as for CC. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007080 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2412 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Nnssaaf_NSSAA_Notify service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007299 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2383R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): NSAAA re-authentication by AAA-S | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005576 from S2#140E. R01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008239 | Patrice (Huawei) cannot accept original version, provides r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and a question. Patrice (Huawei) comments further. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) can accept r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2008239 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2383R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): NSAAA re-authentication by AAA-S | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2007299R01. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007315 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2487 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of NSSAA related statements | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007451 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on discriminating PLMNs in NSSAA. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2007452 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2429 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to NSSAA to prevent failure in two-PLMN scenario | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a question for clarification. Patrice (Huawei) answers the question from Peter (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Alessio(Nokia) provides comments, suggest to move topic to CT4 and note all revisions Patrice (Huawei) disagrees with Nokia's very late comment that this is a CT4 issue, as it is a system issue, not a protocol issue. Asks for clarification to Ericsson's proposed update. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) propose to postpone the CR and provides reply to Huawei and propose to let SA3 sort out the issue as they seem to discuss the same issue based on Huawei papers. Patrice (Huawei) is OK with postponing the CR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 7.10.3 | - | - | - | Optimisations on UE radio capability signalling (RACS) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.4 | - | - | - | Enhanced IMS to 5GC Integration (eIMS5G_SBA) | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2007574 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1236 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to HSS Discovery and Selection via NRF | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | === Close of Phase 1 === === Close of e-meeting === | Agreed |
| 7.10.5 | - | - | - | User Data Interworking and Coexistence (UDICoM) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.6 | - | - | - | Enhancing Topology of SMF and UPF in 5G Networks (ETSUN) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.7 | - | - | - | 5GS Transfer of Policies for Background Data Transfer (xBDT) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.8 | - | - | - | Single radio voice continuity from 5GS to 3G (5G_SRVCC) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8 | - | - | - | Rel-17 SID/WID | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | Study on Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 2 (FS_eNA_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=193 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006908 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Miscellaneous corrections for TR 23.700-91. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008016. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaobo (Huawei) is ok with r02 from Yannick(Nokia). === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008016 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Miscellaneous corrections for TR 23.700-91. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006908R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007478 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Overview of solutions proposing new/enhanced Analytics. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008017. | Dimitris (Lenovo) provides rev1 David (Samsung) provides comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to Samsung and provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) replies to Nokia. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung. David (Samsung) agrees with Nokia's proposal. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008017 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Overview of solutions proposing new/enhanced Analytics. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007478R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006784 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on network data analysis energy saving | SA WG5 (S5-203360) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004785 from S2#140E. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008330. | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to postpone the LS to the next SA2 meeting to have time to prepare reply-LS. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia supports postponing this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007075 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1-Update to solution 5. | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008018. | David (Samsung) requests clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Hucheng(CATT) provide r01 and responds to the comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on r01 Hucheng(CATT) replies to Lenovo. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments to r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hucheng(CATT) replies to Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to CATT. Hucheng(CATT) provides r02 to address the comment from Nokia. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r02 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008018 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1-Update to solution 5. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007075R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007021 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to clarify the solution of NWDAF functionality Split . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Approved | David (Samsung) requests clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also requests for clarification. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and David (Samsung). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2007023 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1: Overall Evaluation. | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005399 from S2#140E Merged into S2-2008019 | Merged | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007191 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1 overall evaluation proposal. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005470 from S2#140E. r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007023 and S2-2007383, to S2-2008019. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. David (Samsung) provides r01 addressing Nokia's comments and merging S2-2007023 and S2-2007383 into S2-2007191. Aihua(China Mobile) agrees to continue working on S2-2007191 as basis of evaluation. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to r02. David (Samsung) comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to David (Samsung) and Yannick (Nokia). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) provides r03, replies to Xiaoyan (CATT) Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides a comment to r03. David (Samsung) provides r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008019 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1 overall evaluation proposal. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007191R04, merging S2-2007023 and S2-2007383. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007383 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation for key issue #1: NWDAF logic decomposition. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008019 | David (Samsung) suggests to merge into S2-2007191. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK to merge into S2-2007191. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007024 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1: Interim conclusions. | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005399 from S2#140E. R15 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007385 and S2-2007580, to S2-2008108. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provide r01 based on Rapporteur's suggestion and Yannick's comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia), Malla (NTT DOCOMO) and provide r03. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r04. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides comments and agree with Yannick(Nokia) in principle. Linghang (NEC) provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Juan (Qualcomm), Yannick (Nokia), and provide r05. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Linghang's (NEC) comments === CC#2 === Xiaobo (Huawei) replies Linghang's (NEC) and Juan's(Qualcomm)comments and provides r06 David (Samsung) provides r07. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r08. David (Samsung) replies to comment from Yannick (Nokia). Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r09. Xiaobo(Huawei) provides r10 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r10. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r11. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r12. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r13. David (Samsung) provides r14. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r14. David (Samsung) provides r15. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) can live with r15. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r15. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r15. Xiaobo(Huawei) is ok with r15. Aihua (China Mobile) is fine with r15. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008108 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1: Interim conclusions. | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007024R15, merging S2-2007385 and S2-2007580. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007385 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Conclusion for key issue #1: NWDAF logic decomposition. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008108 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that discussion on KI#1 conclusions is happening via discussion on S2-2007024 so assumes that eventually S2-2007385 could be indicated as merged into S2-2007024. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) our understanding it is merged into 2007024. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007580 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1 conclusion. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008108 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and comments Samsung to merge S2-2007580 into S2-2007024 based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 David (Samsung) notifies that Malla (NTT DOCOMO) has provided a revision of S2-2007024 in the S2-2007580 thread. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) notifies that this paper can be marked as merged into S2-2007024. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=41 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007018 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Update to Sol#11. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008048. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0 Yang (OPPO) replies Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to OPPO. Hucheng(CATT) provides comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) answers and provides rr01 and r02 Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yang (OPPO) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) Ulf (Ericsson) asks for further clarification === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008048 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Update to Sol#11. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007018R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007483 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, sol #60 updates. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007610 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #26: Update of relocation procedure. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008021. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Ulf (Ericsson) has comments and ask for clarification Jungshin (Samsung) provides clarification Ulf (Ericsson) asks for further clarifications Jungshin (Samsung) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) comments Ulf (Ericsson) commenting on idea from Jungshin Jungshin (Samsung) provides r01. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jungshin (Samsung) proposes to move forward with r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia prefers original or r01. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for agreement to keep open for possible changes in solution Ulf (Ericsson) can agree to original or r01 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008021 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #26: Update of relocation procedure. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007610R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006909 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KIs #2, #11, Sol #58: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to NOKIA. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Huawei. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2007025 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2 -Update Sol#57 by merging with Sol# 26 and 59. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provide r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Mobile Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung provide comments and cannot agree to r01. === CC#2 === Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and Jungshin (Samsung), and provide r02. Jungshin (Samsung) sustains the concern and cannot accept r02. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jungshin (Samsung) and provide r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification and proposes to postpone the pCR. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jungshin (Samsung) . Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) . Ulf (Ericsson) replies back === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2007476 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, sol #59: Update to show example trigger in procedure. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008022. | Aihua (China Mobile) comments and asks for clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Mobile. === CC#2 === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to DOCOMO. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) fine with r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008022 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, sol #59: Update to show example trigger in procedure. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007476R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006910 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #19: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008023. | Gerald (Nokia) comments and asks for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to Yannick (Nokia) and revision r1. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia disagrees on r02 and provides comments. ZhangBin (ZTE): comments on r02 Andy (VC, Samsung) comments that only r01 has been produced. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia clarifies that comments had been against r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to NOKIA and ZTE comments (about r01 not r02) and revision r2. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification on r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to Gerald(Nokia) and revision r3. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008023 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #19: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006910R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006911 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #17: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008024. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments and asks for clarification Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to NOKIA and revision r1. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) accepts NOKIA changes and provides revision r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008024 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #17: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006911R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006995 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#24: Update to Federated Learning among Multiple NWDAF Instances. | China Mobile, OPPO, ETRI | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008025. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification Soohwan (ETRI): ETRI replies to the comments from Nokia Aihua (China Mobile) replies and provides r01. Ulf (Ericsson) replies on question === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) and provide r02. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 Aihua (China Mobile) is fine with r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008025 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#24: Update to Federated Learning among Multiple NWDAF Instances. | China Mobile, OPPO, ETRI | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006995R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007604 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1, Sol #25 Update to clarify the solution impacts . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008026. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia notes that this solution is for KI#2. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Aihua (China Mobile) replies and provide r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with r01 === CC#2 === Aihua (China Mobile) replies and provide r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02 Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) and provides r03. Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification on r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia requests to show all new text in change marks Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r04. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r04 Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) fine with r05 and r04. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r05. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008026 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol #25 Update to clarify the solution impacts . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007604R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007016 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation and conclusion on analytics generated by multiple NWDAFs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008051 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on the evaluation and objects to the conclusions in r0. Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns on the conclusion Yang Xu (OPPO) replies to Ulf and Gerald Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and proposes to merge this with other relevant PCRs. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge evaluation/ conclusion part of 7016, 7317 and 7076 into S2-2007480/7481. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to clarify the status of this paper and whether it is merged in S2-2007480/7481. Mehrdad (Samsung) request to clarify the status of this PCR either as merged or NOTED. Yang (OPPO) is fine to mark it as merged to 7480 and 7481. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007111 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2 - Evaluation. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008051 | Dimitris (Lenovo) comments and requests clarifications Ulf (Ericsson) answers and clarifies to Lenovo Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides further responses Ulf (Ericsson) responds to Samsung and Lenovo === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper already merged in S2-2007480/81. Ulf (Ericsson) agree that this paper is being merged into S2-2007480/81 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007017 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2: Evaluation on Federated Learning aspect. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008027. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia proposes to consider solution #24 (Federated Learning) as part of KI#19 evaluations/conclusions. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with r0 and r01 and provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Ulf (Ericsson) is OK with r02 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008027 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2: Evaluation on Federated Learning aspect. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007017R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007019 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2: Conclusion on Federated Learning aspect. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with r0 Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia). Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Mobile and sustains concerns Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia cannot agree on original and r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Aihua (China Mobile) === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2007027 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Conclusion on NWDAF re-selection due to UE mobility . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008049 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with r0 === CC#2 === Jungshin (Samsung): We propose S2-2007027 is merged by S2-2007701. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia understands we discussed on merged conclusions in 7701 and therefore proposes to NOTE this pCR. Aihua(China Mobile) is fine that 7027 is merged with 7701 since we have lots of discussion on 7701, which is to address the same topic. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007032 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation and Interim conclusion on exposing UE mobility analytics for multiple NWDAFs case . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008028. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia). === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Mobile. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns on r0 and asks for clarification on inconsistencies. Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provide r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01 and has concerns on conclusions. Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Gerald (Nokia) and provide r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Aihua (China Mobile) === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008028 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation on exposing UE mobility analytics for multiple NWDAFs case . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007032R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007076 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Overall evaluation and interim conclusion for KI#2: hierarchical NWDAF architecture aspect. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008051 | Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and proposes to merge this with other relevant PCRs. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge evaluation/ conclusion part of 7016, 7317 and 7076 into S2-2007480/7481. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hucheng (CATT) is fine to merge the papers. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007317 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion - analytics and data aggregation . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005175 from S2#140E Merged into S2-2008052 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia and clarifies the comments are on original version. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007319 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion -Time Coordination. | Samsung, AT&T | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008029. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on sol.13 and its evaluation. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia and clarifies Sol.13. Xiaobo (Huawei) comments and provides a revision r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Huawei and Nokia and suggests to keep original order. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung and comments on r01 Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answer to Samsung question. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia had comments on r01, can live with r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r01 and happy to resolve the editorial issues in next meeting as suggested by NOK. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008029 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion -Time Coordination. | Samsung, AT&T | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007319R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007701 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Evaluation & Interim conclusion - re-selection category. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Partially merged into S2-2007782. r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007027, to S2-2008049. | Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns on the conclusion Gerald (Nokia): Nokia answers to Ericsson and provides r01 and r02. Linghang (NEC) asks for clarification. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to NEC. Aihua(China Mobile) comments and provides r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to China Mobile and provides r04. Aihua(China Mobile) comments and provides r05. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Aihua(China Mobile) provides clarification on Bullet d to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung provides r06. === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r07 Ulf (Ericsson) provides r08 Hucheng(CATT) provides r09 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with r08 Aihua(China Mobile) comments and provides r10. Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns on all previous revisions before r08 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification to CATT. Jungshin (Samsung) requests clarification to CATT on changes in r09 and r10. Hucheng(CATT) replies to Nokia and SAMSUNG. Jungshin (Samsung) provides further comments to Hucheng (CATT). Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to CATT and disagrees to r09, r10. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hucheng (CATT) can accept r09, r10 and objects other versions. Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification to Hucheng (CATT). Gerald (Nokia): Nokia objects to r03, r05, r06, r09, r10 and is okay with original and other revisions Ulf (Ericsson) lets go for r08 then as stated in chairman's notes Gerald (Nokia): Nokia supports going with r08 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008049 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Interim conclusion - re-selection category. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007701R08, merging S2-2007027 and adding also an editor's note. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007026 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Evaluation on NWDAF re-selection due to UE mobility . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007782 | Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns for the evaluation === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007608 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Interim Evaluation - Mobility / Reselection Aspects. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005683 from S2#140E. Revised, merging S2-2007026 and S2-2007701, to S2-2007782. | Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns on the conclusion === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007782 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Interim Evaluation - Mobility / Reselection Aspects. | Samsung, Nokia, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007608, merging S2-2007026 and parts of S2-2007701. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008050. | Ulf (Ericsson) ask for clarifications and gives comments Hucheng(CATT) provides comments. Jungshin (Samsung) replies to CATT comment. Jungshin (Samsung) replies to Ulf (Ericsson). Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) and asks for clarifications from Ulf (Ericsson). Ulf (Ericsson) clarifies to China mobile Aihua(China Mobile) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) and comments. Ulf (Ericsson) replies to Aihua (China Mobile) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Ulf (Ericsson) provides r01 and objects to original === CC#2 === Ulf (Ericsson) provides comments to all solutions solving re-selection of NWDAF Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson Ulf (Ericsson) replies to Gerald (Nokia) questions Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. Ulf (Ericsson) replies back to Gerald (Nokia) Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson and proposes way forward. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008050 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Interim Evaluation - Reselection Aspects. | Samsung, Nokia, China Mobile, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007782R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007479 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Evaluation: Categorization of solution. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007480 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Evaluation: Observation on solutions addressing NWDAF interactions in hierarchical NWDAF architecture. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007111, S2-2007016, S2-2007076 and S2-2007615, to S2-2008051. | Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and proposes to merge this with other relevant PCRs. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge on evaluation part of 7016, 7317 and 7076 into S2-2007480 . === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) merges evaluation part of 7317 into S2-2007480 and provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01 and provides r02. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. Hucheng (CATT) provides r03. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r04 Seungik (ETRI) provides comments on r04. === CC#2 === Hucheng(CATT) clarifies to ETRI. Seungik (ETRI) replies to CATT. Hucheng(CATT) has different understanding from ETRI. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008051 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Evaluation: Observation on solutions addressing NWDAF interactions in hierarchical NWDAF architecture. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Samsung, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007480R04, merging S2-2007111, S2-2007016, S2-2007076 and S2-2007615. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007481 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Interim conclusion on solutions addressing NWDAF interactions in hierarchical NWDAF architecture. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007317, to S2-2008052. | Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and proposes to merge this with other relevant PCRs. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge conclusion part of 7016, 7317 and 7076 into S2-2007481. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) merges conclusion part of 7317 into S2-2007481 and provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia thanks Samsung for the merger in r01 and revises to r02 Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 to merge in principle from TS-2007111 Ulf (Ericsson) comments on r03 and provides r04 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia disagrees with r04 and provides r05. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06. Seungik (ETRI) provides r07. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson Ulf (Ericsson) replies to Gerald (Nokia) === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia thanks Ericsson and provides r08. Malla (NTT DOCOMO): provides comments. Hucheng(CATT) comments and provides r09. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to CATT. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r10. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NTT DOCOMO Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Samsung Mehrdad (Samsung) will reply to NTT DOCOMO Hucheng(CATT) replies to Nokia and comments on r10. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT Seungik (ETRI) provides r11. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia does not agree on r11 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hucheng(CATT) proposes a wording change to bullet b in r10, otherwise objects all versions except for r04, 09. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r10 with or without the new wording change suggested by CATT but will object to all other revisions and original version. Ulf (Ericsson) want to make clear that Ericsson's will add a contribution on conclusion for NWDAF registering per UE in next meeting Andy (VC, Samsung) asks if CATT can accept r10. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) fine with r10 and capture chairs note that Hucheng's text proposal for b) is added in next meeting. Seungik (ETRI) is fine with r10. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008052 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Interim conclusion on solutions addressing NWDAF interactions in hierarchical NWDAF architecture. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007481R10, merging S2-2007317. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007615 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2: Evaluation and interim conclusions. | Orange | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008051 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Seungik (ETRI) provides comments. Ulf (Ericsson) provides comment Hucheng(CATT) provides comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Antoine (Orange) provides r01 to address the comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns with the conclusions and asks for clarification on r01. Antoine (Orange) provides r02. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns on r02 and asks for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) has concern on this evaluation methodology. Antoine (Orange) wonders where the discussion is happening. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides answer to Orange. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper is already merged into S2-2007480/1 and objects to original version and all revisions. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=57 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007117 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4 - Solution #2, Clarification on EN to check with SA WG5, and alignment with eNS_ph2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2008030. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Peretz (Spirent) provides additional comment. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 to align description in Table 6.2.1.3.2-1 and Table 6.2.1.3.2-2. David (Samsung) provides r02 and comments. Mall (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02, and cannot accept either r01 or r03. Peretz (Spirent) asking for clarifications. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) except r03, we object original and all other revision. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Malla. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) provides r04, co-signs contribution. Belen (Ericsson) provides r05. David (Samsung) provides r06, provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r07. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008030 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4 - Solution #2, Clarification on EN to check with SA WG5, and alignment with eNS_ph2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007117R07. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007541 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4, Sol#2: Update on solution impacts. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2008031. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification. David (Samsung) replies to Ericsson and Nokia, provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. David (Samsung) replies. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung. David (Samsung) replies to Nokia. Mall (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 and replies to Nokia. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02 and r04. R03 does not exist. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. David (Samsung) answers Nokia, provides r06. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) ask confirmation from Nokia on NRF impact. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to NTT DOCOMO. Malla (NTT DOCOMO): replies to Nokia David (Samsung) provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with compromise proposal from Samsung. Provides r07 to remove OAM completely from the impacts for the solution. David (Samsung) is OK with r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008031 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4, Sol#2: Update on solution impacts. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007541R07. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007277 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4: Evaluation update . | Samsung, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008032. | Belen (Ericsson) provides a r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02. David (Samsung) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 and ask a question for clarification. David (Samsung) replies to Yannick. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008032 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4: Evaluation update . | Samsung, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007277R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007246 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key Issue #4 Interim conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008033 | David (Samsung) notifies this document should be marked as merged into S2-2007114 where the KI#4 conclusion discussions are taking place. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007114 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4- Conclusion . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007246, to S2-2008033. | Belen (Ericsson) provides a r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. David (Samsung) provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. David (Samsung) is OK with r03. Belen (Ericsson) asks Nokia for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r04 and asks for clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) response to Nokia. David (Samsung) provides r05 addressing Nokia/Docomo's suggestion. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r05. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008033 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4- Conclusion . | Ericsson, Samsung, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007114R05, merging S2-2007246. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007245 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Slice information collection: KI#4 | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008034. | David (Samsung) provides comments and r01. Belen (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the LS until 6.2.1.2 in TR 23.700-91 is agreed. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) asks Ericsson if it would be OK to agree on the LS now that we have a new draft for 6.2.1.2 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) accepts r02 David (Samsung) agrees with Nokia and Ericsson, accepts r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) fine with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008034 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Slice information collection | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007245R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#7 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007772 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol 61: Update to improves the Observed Service Experience Analytics ID . | Sandvine | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008035. | Belen (Ericsson) asks questions and objects to the contribution in the current form === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Manuel (Sandvine) responds questions to Ericsson and .... Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments, also concerned that UPF provides service experience as input to NWDAF. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 Manuel (Sandvine) Sandvine responds to Nokia comments Manuel (Sandvine) responds to Belen (Ericsson). We are OK with r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008035 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol 61: Update to improves the Observed Service Experience Analytics ID . | Sandvine | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007772R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007773 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol 61: Update QoS sustainability . | Sandvine | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008036. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia questions the need for NOTE 2. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Manuel (Sandvine) responds to Ericsson and Nokia Belen (Ericsson) asks Sandvine Manuel (Sandvine): provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008036 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol 61: Update QoS sustainability . | Sandvine | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007773R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#8 | - | - | Docs:=27 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006859 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, Sol#62: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008037. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Jaehyu (LGE) responds to Nokia and provides r01. Sherry (Xiaomi) requests for clarification. Jaehyu (LGE) answers to Xiaomi's Q. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jaehyu (LGE) provides r02. === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r02. Belen (Ericsson) asks about the UE Data storage. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jaehyu (LGE) responses to Ericsson. Jaehyu (LGE) suggests to accept r02. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008037 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, Sol#62: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006859R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007722 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update to Solution#27 UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008038. | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies. Jaehyu (LGE) asks for another clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also requests for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) support LGE's comment. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sherry (Xiaomi) replies and provides r01. Yang Xu (OPPO) has similar view with Xiaomi === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008038 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update to Solution#27 UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007722R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007523 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, KI#13, Solution #65 clarifications. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revised, undoing the removal of the editor's note, to S2-2007929. KI#8 and KI#13 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes comments for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note the paper. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Qualcomm, Samsung and Ericsson. Nokia believes comments are related to evaluation and coexistence between solution #65 and other solutions, not to the change proposal itself. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with original version but clarifies more work is needed to address comments raised. Belen (Ericsson) can accept original version if the EN is kept, otherwise Ericsson mantains objections. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) also proposes to keep the editor's note. === Phase 2 final deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with proposal to go with original version and editor's note kept. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007929 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, KI#13, Solution #65 clarifications. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007523, undoing the removal of the editor's note. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007697 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, Solution #29 updates: clarifications to input data. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008039. | Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agrees with Samsung, fine with r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008039 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, Solution #29 updates: clarifications to input data. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007697R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007291 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#63: Update. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008040. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) addresses Yannick(Nokia)'s comments in r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008040 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#63: Update. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007291R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007320 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol #29: Update to UE Input data for CP load balancing analytics. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008041. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia and provides r01. === CC#2 === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NTT DOCOMO and provided r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r03. Xiaobo(Huawei) is also ok with r03 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r03 Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008041 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol #29: Update to UE Input data for CP load balancing analytics. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007320R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006861 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#27: Update to add filter information. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008042. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Jaehyu (LGE) answers to Nokia's Q. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Jaehyu (LGE) provides r02. Jaehyu (LGE) answers to Qualcomm's Q. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008042 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#27: Update to add filter information. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006861R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007723 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update to Solution#64 MNO owned Data Collection AF for UE data collection. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2007930. CC#4: Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r01 and r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions for both r01 and r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Belen (Ericsson) objects to r02 and asks Sherry (Xiaomi) to answer questions if possible. Ericsson proposes to add an EN to r01 to resolve the questions raised yesterday. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r01 adding an EN on how DC-AF knows the External UE id and how the DCF-AF discovers the NEF. Ericsson objects to r01 and r02 in the current state. === Phase 2 final deadline === Sherry (Xiaomi) replies. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r03. === CC#3 === Yan Xu (OPPO) comments and provides r04. Yan Xu (OPPO) comments and provides r05. Sherry (Xiaomi) is fine with r07. Belen (Ericsson) is fine with r07 === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2007930 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update to Solution#64 MNO owned Data Collection AF for UE data collection. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007723. CC#4: WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006860 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8 Evaluation and Conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 Mehrdad (Samsung) request clarification on status of this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jaehyu (LGE) confirms that S2-2006860 is merged into S2-2007387/89. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007014 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, conclusion for KI#8 -eNA . | OPPO, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 Mehrdad (Samsung) request clarification on status of this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yang (OPPO) agrees this is merged into 2007387/89 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007278 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8 evaluation and conclusion proposal. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007292 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Evaluation of Solutions and Conclusions. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 Guanzhou (InterDigital) confirms that 7292 is merged into 7387/7389. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007387 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation for Key Issue #8: UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r13 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006860, S2-2007014, S2-2007015, S2-2007278, S2-2007292, S2-2007642 and S2-2007724, to S2-2008043 | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides a r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r06. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments and provides r07. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r08. Belen (Ericsson) provides r09. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on r07 changes Yang (OPPO) provides answers to Dimitris. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r10. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yang Xu (OPPO) replies to Yannick and provides r11. === CC#2 === Belen (Ericsson) provides r12 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r13. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yang Xu (OPPO) is fine to r13 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine to r13 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008043 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation for Key Issue #8: UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007387R13. Approved, merging S2-2006860, S2-2007014, S2-2007015, S2-2007278, S2-2007292, S2-2007642 and S2-2007724 | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007015 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#3, evaluation and conclusion for KI#8 -eNA . | OPPO, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 Mehrdad (Samsung) request clarification on status of this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yang (OPPO) agrees this is merged into 2007387/89 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007389 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Interim conclusion for Key Issue #8: UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r23 agreed. Revised to S2-2008044. | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides a r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Guanzhou (InterDigital) welcomes the merge and asks for clarification. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments and provides a r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies InterDigital's comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03. Samsung comments on r03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r04. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks Guanzhou for clarification. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a question to Mehrdad (Samsung). Belen (Ericsson) comments and proposes a way forward. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to r04. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Samsung's comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for further clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r06 Belen (Ericsson) provides r07. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r07 and replies Samsung's comment. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to YangXu(Oppo)'s questions. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NTT DOCOMO. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r08. Belen (Ericsson) asks Samsung Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides more clarification. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications to QC and Samsung Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies Ericsson. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Samsung and asks more questions Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r09 and r10 === CC#2 === Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r11. Yang (OPPO) provides comments Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NTT DOCMO and provides r12 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r13. Belen (Ericsson) provides r14. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r15. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r16. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Jaehyu (LGE) provides r17. Yang(OPPO) comments and provide questions Belen (Ericsson) asks about r17 changes. Jaehyu (LGE) provides r18. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r19. Yang (OPPO) provides r20. Mehrdad (Samsung) is not sure if ENs in r20 are needed. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r21 . Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r22. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r23. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yang Xu (OPPO) is ok to r22 and r23. Yang (OPPO) replies to Mehrdad Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r23. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r23. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008044 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Interim conclusion for Key Issue #8: UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007389R23. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007642 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8 Solutions Evaluation. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Mehrdad (Samsung) merges this paper into S2-2007387/89 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007724 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Overall Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#8. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008043 | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Jayhyu. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this paper as merged into S2-2007387/89 Mehrdad (Samsung) request clarification on status of this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sherry (Xiaomi) confirms that this paper is merged into S2-2007387/89. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#9 | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006912 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Sol 30: Update to add OAM as Consumer of the Data Dispersion Analytics. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised to S2-2008053. | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Peretz Feder (Spirent) provides a comment and a revision r01 Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contributin, both r01 and initial version. Whether to create or not a UPF instance is OAM tasks out of scope of this SID. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications to Huawei. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03. === CC#2 === Peretz (Spirent): Spirent comments on r03. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Yannick (Nokia), Peretz (Spirent) and provides r03. Peretz (Spirent) followed up regarding the application optionality. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Peretz (Spirent) and provides r05. Peretz (Spirent) replies to Xiaobo and provides r06. Belen (Ericsson) provides r07. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies Belen and provides r08. Belen (Ericsson) provides r09. Xiaobo (Huawei) is ok with r09. Peretz (Spirent) providing r10 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008053 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Sol 30, Sol 66: Update to clarify the Consumer NF's behaviours of the Data Dispersion Analytics for an Application. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006912R10. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007136 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9, Sol#30 - Update solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008054. | Peretz (Spirent): Spirent provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept r01, asks Spirent not to revert changes without track changes marking. Peretz (Spirent) provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept r01 or r02. Ericsson provides r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Peretz (Spirent) asking for clarification. Belen (Ericsson) answers questions from Spirent. === CC#2 === Peretz (Spirent) replies to Belen's input regarding 'Any UE' filtering option and provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r04. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and Spirent === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008054 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9, Sol#30 - Update solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007136R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006977 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Solution Completion and Procedures: Dispersion Analytic Output Provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Comm., AT&T, Convida Wireless, Sandvine | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008055. | Belen (Ericsson) asks questions included in r01 and objects to the contribution in the current form. === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Peretz (Spirent) provides answers and includes r02 with yellow highlighted changes. Peretz (Spirent): Replies and provided r02 Peretz (Spirent): Replies and provided r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03 Peretz (Spirent) responds to Ericsson's input and provides r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r03 and objects to other revisions and initial version Peretz (Belen) is asking for clarifications Peretz (Spirent) is asking for clarifications Belen (Ericsson) clarifies comments and replies to questions. === Phase 2 final deadline === Peretz (Spirent) question to Belen === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008055 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Solution Completion and Procedures: Dispersion Analytic Output Provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Comm., AT&T, Convida Wireless, Sandvine | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006977R03. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007115 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9 Sol#66 Solving ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01 and asks for clarification. === CC#2 === Belen (Ericsson) clarifies to Nokia, r01 is fine. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with the explanation. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r00/r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === Belen (Ericsson) asks not to consider CATT objections since it did not procide comments to any revision before deadline for revisions === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2007135 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9 - Evaluation. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007822 | Peretz (Spirent): provides proposed merged solution evaluation r01 Peretz (Spirent): provides proposed merged solution evaluation r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r02, objects to r01 Peretz (Spirent) providing r03 and asking a clarification question. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007318 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#19_Solution Evaluation for Dispersion analytic output provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Communications | Rel-17 | Is actually for KI#9, not KI#19. Noted. CC#4: r05 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007960. | Peretz (Spirent): provides proposed merged solution evaluation r01 Peretz (Spirent): provides proposed merged solution evaluation r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments and objects to r01/r02/r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === Peretz (Spirent) provides answers to Xiaoyan === CC#3 === Peretz (Spirent) provides answers to Xiaoyan and provides r04 === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007960 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#19_Solution Evaluation for Dispersion analytic output provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Communications, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007318R05. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#10 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006855 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, Sol#68: Update to remove EN. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008045. | Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and has concerns Hyunsook (LGE) clarifies and provides r03. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to LGE === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Ulf (Ericsson) provides r04 Hyunsook (LGE) reponses to Ulf. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r04. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008045 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, Sol#68: Update to remove EN. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006855R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007192 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10 evaluation. | Samsung, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007193 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10 conclusion. | Samsung, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Ulf (Ericsson) provides r01 and objects to original David (Samsung) objects to r01, requests an urgent explanation from Ericsson Ulf (Ericsson) explains the objection Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0 and r1 David (Samsung) agrees with Nokia, provides r02. Ulf (Ericsson) Withdraws the previous objection to original version, and supports only original David (Samsung) replies to Ericsson, is OK with original === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Ulf (Ericsson) asks for update to next meeting David (Samsung) agrees to Ericsson's proposal === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#11 | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007028 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#15: Update to add a method of using DCCF. | China Mobile, Huawei | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008056. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Aihua(China Mobile) gives feedback to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r01. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r01. Aihua(China Mobile) gives feedback to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 and asks for clarification. Aihua(China Mobile) provides feedback to Yannick (Nokia). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008056 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#15: Update to add a method of using DCCF. | China Mobile, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007028R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007518 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Updates to Solution #9. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T, NTT DOCOMO, Verizon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008057. | Ulf (Ericsson) sends comments Xiaobo (Huawei) sends comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Huawei. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01 and r02. Please ignore r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks clarification to Huawei. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008057 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Updates to Solution #9. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T, NTT DOCOMO, Verizon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007518R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007236 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#35: Clarifications on DCNF identifying NFs and caching locally data. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007522 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, Solution #71 updates: adding examples for partition criteria. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2007477 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#72: Update to add Impacts. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. Ulf (Ericsson) replies back to Nokia Ulf (Ericsson) further asks and replies === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2007020 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Conclusion for KI#11. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008058 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO): propose to merge into S2-2007401. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2006913 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11: Evaluation and Conclusion of solutions without architectural changes. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008046. | Ulf (Ericsson) has comments on conclusion clause Malla (NTT DOCOMO) providers comment === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agrees with Ericsson and NTT DOCOMO. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks if S2-2007538 can be taken as baseline for interim evaluation for solutions proposing enhancements to event exposure framework. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Ericsson, NTT Docomo, and NOKIA and a revision r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) accepts S2-2007538 as baseline for solutions proposing enhancements to event exposure framework and provides revision r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. Nokia notices that brand new observations have been introduced in r01 and provided on October 19th, thus not allowing proper review time. Nokia prefers postponing these observations to next meeting. Xiaobo (Huawei) accepts revision r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008046 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11: Evaluation of solutions without architectural changes. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006913R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007286 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11: Conclusion on solutions introducing a data collection function. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008058 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO): propose to merge into S2-2007401. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) confirms 7286 is merged in 7401 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007401 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key Issue #11 Interim conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Deutsche Telekom, Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile USA, Spirent | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007020 and S2-2007286, to S2-2008058. | Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and suggests to go with second option, i.e. to list principles. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that S2-2007020 from OPPO and S2-2007286 from Lenovo/Motorola Mobility also propose conclusions for KI#11 and data collection (coordination) function aspects. Nokia asks if discussions on principles can take place via S2-20074101. Dimitris (Lenovo) agrees to have the discussion of KI#11 interim conclusions in the S2-2007401 thread Malla (NTT DOCOMO): provides r01 merge of S2-2007020 and S2-2007286 for the discussion Hucheng(CATT) ask a question for r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Xiaobo (Huawei) send comments and provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. Cannot accept r03 and r04. Xiaobo (Huawei) send comments and provides r06. Ulf (Ericsson) comment on the data collection from NWDAF Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks Ericsson for clarification. Ulf (Ericsson) clarifies Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r07 and r08 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia cannot accept r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r07 Ulf (Ericsson) Also supports r07 Xiaobo (Huawei) prefer r08 and can live with r07. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008058 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key Issue #11 Interim conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Deutsche Telekom, Verizon, AT&T, T-Mobile USA, Spirent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007401R07, merging S2-2007020 and S2-2007286. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007538 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11: Evaluation on solutions. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2008059. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia supports grouping together, in the evaluation, solutions enhancing exposure framework, and provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Song Zhao (China Telecom): China Telecom replies the comments from Nokia and provide r01 Song Zhao (China Telecom): China Telecom provides r02 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. Nokia asks if S2-2007538 can be taken as baseline for interim evaluation for solutions proposing enhancements to event exposure framework. Song Zhao (China Telecom): China Telecom provides r04. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides revision r05. Huawei accepts S2-2007538 as baseline for solutions proposing enhancements to event exposure framework. Antoine (Orange) provides r06. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r07. Ulf (Ericsson) some comments on r06 Song Zhao (China Telecom): China Telecom provide r08. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008059 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11: Evaluation on solutions. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007538R08. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007519 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11 Evaluation: solutions with data collection coordination functionality. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, AT&T, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007616, to S2-2008060. | Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson and provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Ulf (Ericsson) replies to Yannick (Nokia) Antoine (Orange) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008060 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11 Evaluation: solutions with data collection coordination functionality. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, AT&T, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007519R03, merging S2-2007616. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007616 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11: Evaluation and interim conclusions. | Orange | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008060 | Dimitris (Lenovo) has concerns with the suggested interim conclusions Yannick (Nokia): Nokia shares the concerns with proposed interim conclusions. Antoine (Orange) replies to Lenovo and Nokia. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to merge into S2-2007519 and S2-2006913. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007244 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on authorization to access data: KI#11 | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007244r01 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007931. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes this LS depends on S2-2007401, and the note number referred to in the LS may not be correct. We should come back to the disposition of the LS. Malla (NTT DOCOMO): provided r01 and ask to handle in CC === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007931 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on authorization to access data | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007244R01. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#12 | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006850 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12_Solution Evaluation for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004929 from S2#140E. Noted. CC#4: r05 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007116 and S2-2007390, to S2-2007953. | Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides an r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02. Peretz (Spirent): Spirent provides r03. Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom is Ok with r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03. Peretz (Spirent): Provides requested clarification === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Antoine (Orange) provides r04. Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom objects to r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) prefers r02 and object r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia prefers r02, can live with r03. Antoine (Orange) replies to Zhuoyi and objects to r00, r01, r02 and r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides r05. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007953 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12_Solution Evaluation for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006850R05, merging S2-2007116 and S2-2007390. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006851 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12_Solution Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r09 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007954. | Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides an r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02 and objects to r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02. Xiaobo (Huawei) agree with Yannick(Nokia) and provide r03. Belen (Ericsson) agrees with China Telecom, Huawei and Nokia. Ericsson provides r04 Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to China Telecom === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom replies to Ericsson and provides r06. Antoine (Orange) provides r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom objects to r07. Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom provides further comments on r07. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r05 or r02 and objects to all other revisions and the initial version. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) China Telecom is okay with r05 at current stage. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports r05. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia supports going forward with r05 or r06. Xiaobo (Huawei) is ok with either r05 or r06. Antoine (Orange) replies to Zhuoyi and objects to all versions except r07. === Phase 2 final deadline === Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides r08. === CC#3 === Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides r09. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007954 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12_Solution Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006851R09. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007116 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007953 | Merged | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007390 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#12: NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007953 | Merged | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007617 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #12: Evaluation and conclusion. | Orange | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhuoyi (China Telecom): China Telecom provides comments and ask for clarifications. Antoine (Orange) answers and provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) objects to define multiple solutions for KI#12. Ericsson objects to this contribution. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2007035 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on OAM that supports RATfrequency data | China Telecomunication Corp. | Revised to S2-2008107. Agreed. Revised to remove 'draft' to S2-2008107. CC#4: Postponed | Postponed | ||
| 8.1 | S2-2008107 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on OAM that supports RATfrequency data | China Telecomunication Corp. | - | Revision of S2-2007035. CC#4: WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#13 | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007118 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Sol# 45 updates . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007520 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Solution #75 updates: Addition of subscriber category to analytics control information . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that Ericsson objection came one hour before revision deadline, thus allowing no time for discussion, while no other comment had been provided for the rest of the meeting. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and maintans objection. Ericsson proposes to postpone the proposal for next meeting. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia disagrees with Ericsson, the proposal is related to KI#13, as based on solution #75 which addresses KI#13. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and maintains objections. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2007521 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Solution #73 updates: adding new target of analytics reporting . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that Ericsson objection came one hour before revision deadline, thus allowing no time for discussion, while no other comment had been provided for the rest of the meeting. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and maintains objection. Ericsson proposes to postpone the proposal for next meeting. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia disagrees with Ericsson, the proposal is related to KI#13, as based on solution #73 which addresses KI#13. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and mantains objections. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2006914 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Sol #75: Update to clarify concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to NOKIA and revision r1. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Belen (Ericsson) states that no replied was received yet. Ericsson objects to this contribution since comments are not addressed so far. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2006839 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Sol#73: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2006839r01 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007932. | Belen (Ericsson) comments that EN are not really resolved. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) is okay with adding the 2 Editor´s notes. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2007932 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, Sol#73: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006839R01. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007561 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13 evaluation and interim conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2006838 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that S2-2006838, S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 are all proposing evaluation and conclusion for KI#13. Wonders whether a merge of the evaluation part could be attempted. Nokia provides comments to the pCR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Xiaoyan (CATT) merged S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 into S2-2006838. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2006838 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13 evaluation and conclusion. | CATT, LG Electronics, Huawei | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008061. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that S2-2006838, S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 are all proposing evaluation and conclusion for KI#13. Wonders whether a merge of the evaluation part could be attempted. Nokia provides comments to the pCR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02 to merge S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 into S2-2006838. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01 to address comments from Yannick (Nokia). Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) wrong r03. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Ericsson and revision r03 (Ericsson provided wrong r03 file). Belen (Ericsson) provides r03, the document was uploaded and states that Huawei did not include a link to any revision. Ericsson objects to all other revisions of the merged document. Belen (Ericsson) comments that EN are not really resolved. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008061 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13 evaluation and conclusion. | CATT, LG Electronics, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006838R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007618 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13: Evaluation and interim conclusions. | Orange | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2006838 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that S2-2006838, S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 are all proposing evaluation and conclusion for KI#13. Wonders whether a merge of the evaluation part could be attempted. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Xiaoyan (CATT) merged S2-2007561 and S2-2007618 into S2-2006838. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#14 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006993 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#14, Sol#46: Update to remove FFS on how to determine App ID for new PFD. | China Mobile, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005379 from S2#140E. Approved | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarifications, and is concerned about the proposed functionality. Linghang (NEC) provides clarification. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Yannick (Nokia). === CC#2 === Linghang(NEC) replies to Yannick (Nokia). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia cannot accept the proposal in current form. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests further clarifications. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with the proposal in this meeting, but requests evaluation (S2-2007611) and conclusion (S2-2007033) to be postponed to next meeting. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2007034 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #14: Evaluation. | China Mobile, NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Postponed | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007033 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #14: Conclusion. | China Mobile, NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that the conclusion is dependent on pending proposal in S2-2006993. We suggest to put conclusion on hold until solution #46 updates are better understood. === CC#2 === Linghang (NEC) provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests to postpone conclusion to next meeting. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2007611 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#14: Interim evaluation and conclusion. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Aihua (China Mobile) provides S2-2007611 r01 as the merged version with S2-2007034 from China Mobile&NEC. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes that the evaluation is related to pending proposal in S2-2006993. We suggest to put evaluation on hold until solution #46 updates are better understood. === CC#2 === Linghang (NEC) provides comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests to postpone the evaluation to next meeting. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#15 | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006952 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution Evaluation for KI#15 User Consent. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008047 | Merged | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006953 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Interim Conclusion for KI#15 User Consent. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008047 | Merged | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007091 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#15 - Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#15 User consent for UE data collection/analysis. | NEC, Nokia | Rel-17 | r19 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006952 and S2-2006953, to S2-2008047. | Yifan (China Telecom) provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and r01. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to Samsung === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Iskren (NEC) replies to questions from Mehrdad (Samsung) === CC#2 === Belen (Ericsson) objects to this document and asks for updates in the conclusions to be accepted. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NTT DOCOMO. Iskren (NEC) answers Mehrdad (Samsung) and Malla (NTT DOCOMO) and suggests to keep with r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) prefers we list principles and suggests NEC and NOK to improve the list in next revision. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia answers Samsung and DOCOMO and prefers r01 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r05, object to all other revision except r01 with clarification that URDCF can be standalone or placed in DCCF, but not in NWDAF Belen (Ericsson) provides r06 and objects to r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) agrees with Ericsson and provides r07 to fix a typo. Iskren (NEC) comments and expresses concern with switching to principles definition. Mehrdad (Samsung) can not agree with r01 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r08, object to r06 and r07. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r10, objects to r05 to r08. Ignore r09. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r08 but cannot agree with r10 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r11. Iskren (NEC) provides r12. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r13. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r12. Iskren (NEC) answers Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r14. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r15. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments to DOCOMO, objects to r15, and provides r16. Yifan (China Telecom) comments. Iskren (NEC) provides comments. Iskren (NEC) provides r17 based on r015 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r18. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r19. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r19 Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r19 but objects to the rest of revisions and original version. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r19 but objects all revisions and original. Iskren (NEC) also agrees with r19. Let's fix the Editor's Notes for the next meeting. === Phase 2 final deadline === Yifan (China Telecom) is okay with r19. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008047 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#15 - Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#15 User consent for UE data collection/analysis. | NEC, Nokia | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007091R19, merging S2-2006952 and S2-2006953. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007482 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS to SA WG3 for KI#15 | Nokia | Rel-17 | Postponed | Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) based on outcome of S2-2007091, we need to update the LS text. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asking for clarification of the need of this LS. Mehrdad (Samsung) confirms DOCOMO view that we have not received the last LS reply yet. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia replies to DOCOMO Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides r02 Malla (NTT DOCOMO): provides r03 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia prefers r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to defer the LS next meeting. We object to sending an LS. Mehrdad (Samsung) agrees with NTT DOCOMO that LS can be postponed to address SA3 questions. Xiaobo (Huawei) agrees with NTT DOCOMO that LS can be postponed to address SA3 questions. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#16 | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006915 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16, Sol# 31: Update Sol# 31 merging with Sol# 48, 49, 50 and 51. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2008062. | Ulf (Ericsson) gives comments and asks for clarification Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Ulf(Ericsson) and provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Aihua(China Mobile) responds to Ulf(Ericsson) on how the AF will make use of the output. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Malla(NTT DoCoMo) and provides r04. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia requests clarification on why impacts are not updated in this merger. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia) and provides r05. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r06 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia). Gerald (Nokia): Nokia is okay with r06 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008062 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16, Sol# 31: Update Sol# 31 merging with Sol# 48, 49, 50 and 51. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006915R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006916 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Source: Huawei, CATT, China Mobile KI #16, Sol #48: Update Sol #48 merging with Sol #49 and #50. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile Title: KI #16, Sol #48: Update Sol #48 merging with Sol #49 and #50 | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2008063. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification on r0. Hucheng(CATT) provides a response to the comments. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia responds to CATT Ulf (Ericsson) gives comments and asks for clarification Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia) and Ulf(Ericsson). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hucheng(CATT) provides r02 and responds to the comment. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02 === CC#2 === Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r03 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 Hucheng(CATT) provides r05 to address the comments from Nokia. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r05 to address the additional comments from Gerald. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r05 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification on r05 Xiaobo (Huawei) request to use r05 from Hucheng(CATT). Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments. Hucheng(CATT) provides r06. Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung is ok with r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008063 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16, Sol #48: Update Sol #48 merging with Sol #49 and #50. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006916R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007234 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16, Sol#49: Clarification on how App Server Performance analytics can be leveraged by Consumer NF. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008064. | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r0. Gerald (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia thanks Lenovo for the clarifications Ulf (Ericsson) has comments and requests changes Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r03 and responds to Ul (Ericsson) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008064 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16, Sol#49: Clarification on how App Server Performance analytics can be leveraged by Consumer NF. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007234R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006917 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16: Evaluation Update . | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile, LGE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008065. | Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns and propose changes Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Comment from Ulf(Ericsson) and further propose to merge S2-2007612 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia shares concerns and asks for clarification Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns on r1 Hyunsook (LGE) clarifies sol#47. Xiaobo(Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia) Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jungshin (Samsung) provides r03 Ulf (Ericsson) has comments on sol#47 again Hyunsook (LGE) responds to Ulf (Ericsson) Ulf (Ericsson) responds back to Hyunsook Hyunsook (LGE) replies back to Ulf. Ulf (Ericsson) replies back to Hyunsook === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008065 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16: Evaluation Update . | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile, LGE, Lenovo, Sumsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006917R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006918 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16: Conclusion. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile, LGE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007235, to S2-2008066. | Ulf (Ericsson) has concerns and request changes Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Comment from Ulf(Ericsson) and further propose to merging S2-2007612 Gerald (Nokia): Nokia has concerns and asks for clarification Xiaobo(Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for status of this pCR Xiaobo(Huawei) responds to Gerald(Nokia) and provide r03 Hyunsook (LGE) has a concern about r03. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r04. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r05 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r06. Xiaobo(Huawei) ask clarification from Dimitrios (Lenovo). Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Xiaobo (Huawei) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hucheng(CATT) ask for further clarification from Dimitrios (Lenovo). Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung object to r05 and can accept r03 or r04. Xiaobo(Huawei) propose to go with r03 or r04. Hyunsook (LGE) can accept r04, and objects to r03 and r05. Dimitris (Lenovo) propose to agree to take into normative work either Sol#31 or Sol#48. Objects to agree including Sol#47 for normative work at this meeting Xiaobo(Huawei) is ok with either r03 or r04 and propose to gather more feedback about Sol#47 to decide whether to agree including Sol#47 for normative work Ulf (Ericsson) agrees with Xiaobo to further discuss solution#47 in next meeting Xiaobo(Huawei) propose to go with r03 and further discuss solution#47 in next meeting and kindly request Hyunsook to withdraw her objection. Hyunsook (LGE) withdraws the previous objection on r03, with asking to add 'expect to further discuss solution#47 in next meeting' into the Chair's notes === Phase 2 final deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) accepts going with r03 === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008066 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #16: Conclusion. | Huawei, CATT, China Mobile, LGE, Lenovo, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006918R03, merging S2-2007235. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007612 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16: Evaluation and Conclusion. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007907 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia provides comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Gerald (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification Jungshin (Samsung) agrees to merge S2-2007612 to S2-2006917. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007235 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16, Conclusions on Analytics for Application Server Performance. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008066 | Gerald (Nokia): Nokia suggests to conclude on one of the two alternative during the study. Ulf (Ericsson) has comments and asks for changes === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Ulf (Ericsson) and Gerald (Nokia) and provides r01 Hucheng(CATT) suggests merging this paper into S2-2006918. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#18 | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006954 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#18, Sol 54: Update to merge Solution#55 into Solution#54. | China Unicom, Huawei | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008067. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarifications. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Ulf (Ericsson). Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Ulf (Ericsson) again asks for clarifications === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r02. Chi (China Unicom): Answers to Yannick (Nokia). Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Ulf (Ericsson), Yannick (Nokia) and provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03. Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification. Chi (China Unicom): Answers to Yannick. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r04. Further discussion needed on the determination of analytics delay. Chi (China Unicom): Can accept the way forward proposed by Yannick. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008067 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#18, Sol 54: Update to merge Solution#55 into Solution#54. | China Unicom, Huawei, Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006954R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006955 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #18, Evaluation for KI#18. | China Unicom, Huawei | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008068. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Nokia notes this evaluation is dependent on updates to solution #54 in S2-2006954. We should first get clear understanding for solution #54 updates. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Yannick and provides r01. === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. Chi (China Unicom): Replies to Yannick and provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r02, with the understanding that evaluation may need refinement in next meeting based on S2-2006954 progress. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008068 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #18, Evaluation for KI#18. | China Unicom, Huawei, Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006955R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006956 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #18, Conclusion for KI#18. | China Unicom, Huawei | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes this conclusion proposal is highly dependent on updates to solution #54 under S2-2006954. A clear understanding of solution #54 updates is needed before concluding. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests to postpone discussion on conclusion. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Chi (China Unicom): Can accept Yannick's proposal to postpone this proposal. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#19 | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006919 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Sol #56: Update to further clarify ML Model sharing between NWDAF instances. | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007725, to S2-2008069. | David (Samsung) requests first clarification. Megha(Intel) provides r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies David (Samsung) and Intel (Megha), and provides r02. Soohwan (ETRI) provides r03 and comments on r02 . === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r03. David (Samsung) provides comments, requests clarifications. Megha(Intel) provides r04 and few comments === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008069 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Sol #56: Update to further clarify ML Model sharing between NWDAF instances. | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006919R04, merging S2-2007725. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007725 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#19, Sol#56: Update to add Model and LocalTrainingData update service . | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008069 | David (Samsung) suggests an early merging of S2-2007725 and S2-2006919. Megha(Intel) provided a merged version in 6919r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2007112 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Sol #56: Update to introduce Confidence level parameter. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008070. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r01 and answers comments from Nokia === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) expresses concerns with this proposal. Ulf (Ericsson) replies to David === Phase 2 revisions deadline === David (Samsung) can live with r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008070 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Sol #56: Update to introduce Confidence level parameter. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007112R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007113 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19 Evaluation of model sharing and federated learning. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008071 | Ulf (Ericsson) this contribution is being merged with S2-2006920 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2006920 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Evaluation . | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007113, to S2-2008071. | Aihua(China Mobile) provides comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies to Aihua (China Mobile) and provides r01 to merge Ericsson's S2-2007113 into S2-2006920 based on Rapporteur's suggestion . Ulf (Ericsson) provides r02 and objects to original and r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r03. Xiaobo (Huawei) is replies to Ulf (Ericsson), Yannick (Nokia), and provides r03. === CC#2 === Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008071 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Evaluation . | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006920R04, merging S2-2007113. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006921 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Conclusion . | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007137, to S2-2008072. | Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r01 to merge Ericsson's S2-2007137 into S2-2006921 based on Rapporteur's suggestion . David (Samsung) provides r02. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 and objects to previous revisions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === David (Samsung) provides r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaobo(Huawei) is ok with r03 and r04 and propose to go with r04. Ulf (Ericsson) is OK with r04 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia supports going forward with r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008072 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Conclusion . | Huawei, HiSilicon, ETRI, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006921R04, merging S2-2007137. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2007137 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#19 - Conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008072 | David (Samsung) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Ulf (Ericsson) replies to David (Samsung) David (Samsung) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === David (Samsung) notes this document should be marked as merged into S2-2006921. Ulf (Ericsson) agrees it is merged into S2-2006921 and deems it is applicable for any solution suggesting sending of models or model parameters in any KI Xiaobo(Huawei) replies to Ulf (Ericsson) and thanks for the merging. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#20 | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006922 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #20: Status update for Key Issue #20. | Huawei | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008073. | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r01 per comments from Yannick(Nokia). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008073 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #20: Status update for Key Issue #20. | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006922R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI#21 | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006984 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#21 evaluation and conclusion. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008074. | Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Dimitris (Lenovo). Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to LaeYoung (LGE) LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers. Ulf (Ericsson) has comments and concerns === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) answers to questions from Ulf (Ericsson). Ulf (Ericsson) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) === CC#2 === LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comments on r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2008074 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#21 evaluation and conclusion. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006984R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Study on enhanced support of Non-Public Networks (FS_eNPN) | - | - | Docs:=113 | - | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - LSs/General | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007583 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | ENPN and enabling NPN for new features like 5MBS | Ericsson | CC#4: This was postponed. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) asks whether we need to bring up the discussion to a CC (e.g. CC#4)? === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) support to bring up this discussion to CC#4. Marco (Huawei) comments Haris (Qualcomm) comments that we are open to consider whether MBS architecture can apply to SNPN without many changes but we cannot agree on that assumption before understanding the final architecture and basic procedures Devaki (Nokia) comments that SNPN can be applied for 5G_MBS, but also other features. Hualin(Huawei) support to bring it to CC #4. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees it could be discussed in a CC. === CC#2 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) thanks for comments and propose to discuss ppt in a CC and will let SA2 chair decide which. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007692 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on credentials for SNPN service continuity | Philips International B.V. | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007828. | Josep (DT) comments that a LS should have clear questions. Provides r01 Walter Dees (Philips) agrees with r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Walter (Philips) provides r03 Dieter (DT) prefers r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dieter (DT) is ok with r01 or r03... Hualin(Huawei) ask question for clarification. Marco (Huawei) r03 is preferable Daniel (Ericsson) prefer R02 but can accept R03 as well Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r03; objects to r01 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007828 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on credentials for SNPN service continuity | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007692R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution Related | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2006866 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #41 - Solution update to address ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007829 | Seokjung (LGE) agrees to merge 6866 into 7053. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007053 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#41, updates to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006866, to S2-2007829. | Devaki (Nokia) supports the proposal and provides r01. Merge 6866 to this paper. Daniel (Ericsson) ask questions for clarification Qianghua (Huawei) responds Daniel (Ericsson) ask further questions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Daniel (Ericsson) provides follow-up questions on R02 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 === CC#2 === Daniel (Ericsson) provides r04 Seokjung (LGE) provides r05 Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) asks clarifications for new additions on r05 Seokjung (LGE) replies to Huawei and provides r06. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 Seokjung (LGE) is fine with r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007829 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#41, updates to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007053R07, merging S2-2006866. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007254 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Update solution #9, Clarification on missing information . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007830. | Devaki (Nokia) raises question for clarifications. Fei (OPPO) asks clarification Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007830 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Update solution #9, Clarification on missing information . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007254R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007255 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Update solution #11, Resolve Editor's note on SoR. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007781 | Merged | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007581 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Solution #11, update to remove Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips, Alibaba | Rel-17 | Revised in e-mail session, merging S2-2007255, to S2-2007781. | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the paper. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 S2-2007581 has be revised to S2-2007781 with merging with S2-2007255. Continue the discussion in a new email thread for S2-2007781. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007781 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Solution #11, update to remove Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips, Alibaba, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007581, merging S2-2007255. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007831. | Continue discussion of 2007781 which was 2007581. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) responses to Qualcomm and Nokia with r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r02; objects to all other versions Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) provide response to Qualcomm and prefer r03 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007831 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Solution #11, update to remove Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips, Alibaba, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007781R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007349 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #44: Update to maintain the consistency of UE subscription data between SNPN and AAA-Server. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007432 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#44: Update to clarify the solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007832. | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Hualin(Huawei) response to Devaki (Nokia) comments and provide r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007832 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#44: Update to clarify the solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007432R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007431 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#43: Update to clarify the solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007833. | Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 === CC#2 === Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007833 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#43: Update to clarify the solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007431R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007755 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#4, update to differentiate the architecture options. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007834. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Daniel (Ericsson) asks question on R01 and a propose a clarification Qianghua (Huawei) responds Devaki (Nokia) asks regarding r01. Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007834 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#4, update to differentiate the architecture options. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007755R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion related | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007047 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, evaluations and conclusions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03A agreed. Revised to S2-2007919. | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) responds === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 Daniel (Ericsson) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) shares Ericsson's view Antoine (Orange) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) prefers very much r03. Daniel (Ericsson) objects to r03 and is ok with r02 Qianghua (Huawei) provides a way forward Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r03 and is ok with r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) also objects to r00 and r01 Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to go with r02 or r03A (in draft folder) Antoine (Orange) can accept r03 or r03A, objects to r00, r01 and r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) asks if r03A is OK for you Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with R3A Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok also with R3A Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) is ok with r03A. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007919 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, evaluations and conclusions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007047R03A. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007089 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Proposed conclusions. | Intel, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007738r10 | Saso (Intel) provides r01. === CC#2 === Devaki (Nokia) asks if this paper can be merged to S2-2007738 based on show of hands outcome? Saso (Intel) is OK to consider 7089 merged in S2-2007738 based on show of hands outcome. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007252 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Proposed conclusions. | Ericsson, Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Saso (Intel) replies to Ravi (Cisco) === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks if this paper can be considered merged into S2-2007738 based on the outcome of the show of hands? Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes this paper to be merged into S2-2007738 based on the outcome of the show of hands Daniel (Ericsson) is ok to consider this contrbution merged into S2-2007738 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007153 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Update to evaluation and conclusion . | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007737. Noted | Devaki (Nokia) comments SoR conclusion in this paper is pre-mature until the conclusion for AAA architecture is stable. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to the comments from Nokia and provides r01. Fei (OPPO) asks clarification. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarification to Fei (OPPO) and provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Ravi and provides r03 === CC#2 === Fei (OPPO) comments on r02 and r03. Josep (DT) questions whether this is KI#1. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Fei(OPPO) Fei (OPPO) responds to Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) and proposed to merged this PCR into S2-2007737 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) answers to the question from Josep (DT). Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to Note this paper. Ericsson objects to all revisions of this document. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) agree to merge this pCR into 2007737 and use 2007737 as the baseline for UE SNPN list update. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007253 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Proposed conclusions for AAA scenario. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007835 | Devaki (Nokia) raises concerns with the proposed way forward. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to consider this paper merged with S2-2007757 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007374 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Evalution Part for the SoR. | OPPO | Rel-17 | This P-CR was approved | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) assumes this pCR will be noted, right? Fei (OPPO) responds to Dieter (DT). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2007375 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Partial conclusion formobility. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) has concerns with both r00 and r01. Fei (OPPO) responds to Devaki (Nokia) and Daniel(Ericsson) Daniel (Ericsson) responds to Devaki (Nokia) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Chia-Lin (MediaTek) share the similar view with Nokia Daniel (Ericsson) replies to Chia-Lin (MediaTek) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the clarifications and suggest to note this pCR === Phase 2 final deadline === Fei (OPPO) responds to Chia-Lin (MediaTeK). === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007587 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1: Interim conclusions. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007738r10. Noted | Devaki (Nokia) asks if this paper can be merged to S2-2007738 based on show of hands outcome? Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the responses and r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to note this paper as it is not in line with the show of hands Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to this paper (all revs) as it is not in line with the show of hands Guillaume (MediaTek) questions Qualcomm objection and rationale. Guillaume (MediaTek) asks 7587 be merged into 7738. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007737 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 conclusion for update of SNPN selection information in the UE. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) cannot agree to second part of the conclusion under 'Home SP owns AAA'. Fei (OPPO) asks clarification === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to OPPO and Nokia and provides r01 Daniel (Ericsson) shares QC view and supports R01 Fei (OPPO) is fine with r01. Antoine (Orange) objects to r00 and r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks Orange to define roaming interface === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Antoine (Orange) defines roaming interface. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007738 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 conclusion for UEs with SNPN subscription. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Verizon UK Ltd., Vodafone, Charter Communications, Sennheiser, Tencent, Samsung, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Cisco Systems, Futurewei | Rel-17 | S2-2007738r10 was then technically endorsed and can be used as a basis for further revisions and returned to at the next meeting. | Daniel (Ericsson) provides Ericsson view on extra information in SIB to enable SNPN network selection for KI#1 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Ericsson Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comments on Ericsson's view Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaomi Saso (Intel) agrees with the points raised by Ericsson and adds one more point. Daniel (Ericsson) replies to Qualcomm Devaki (Nokia) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Fei (OPPO) asks a question on r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Fei Daniel (Ericsson) provides r03 Walter Dees (Philips) supports these conclusions. Antoine (Orange) provides r04 and objects to previous versions. Daniel (Ericsson) provides r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Orange, objects to r04 and r05, provides r06 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r07. Josep (DT) suggests to agree on the non-controversial part first and leave the rest for the next meeting. Saso (Intel) supports r07; can live with r08 Hualin (Huawei) provide r09 based on r07. We prefer r09 and can live with r08, r07. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Huawei; disagrees with r09; provides r10 Guillaume (MediaTek): ok with r10 Saso (Intel) asks Antoine (Orange) why they want to prevent SNPN operators from using 5GS architecture including 5GS roaming interfaces Daniel (Ericsson) provides r11 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r11 Antoine (Orange) provides r12. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r08 as it is not in line with the result of the show of hands Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r12 Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r10. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Daniel (Ericsson) comments QC objection to R11 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Daniel Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r04, r05, r08, r09, r11, r12 Sebastian (Qualcomm) prefers r10 because it is in line with the show of hands from CC#2 Mike (Convida Wireless) also objects to r11 and r12 and supports proceeding with r10 which represents what the majority supported in the show of hands. Gerry (Verizon) prefers r10 in line with the show of hands in CC#2. Florin (Broadcom) shares Qualcomm's position expressed by Sebastian. Florin (Broadcom) supports r10 in line with the show of hands in CC#2. Florin (Broadcom) objects to r04, r05, r08, r09, r11, r12 which are not inline with the show of hands. Chris J(T-Mobile USA) Agrees with Verizon and prefers r10. Curt (Charter) also supports r10 with same view that it is in-line with the SoH in CC#2. Devaki (Nokia) supports r10. Objects to r04, r08, r11, r12. Chunshan (Tencent) supports r10 in line with the show of hands in CC#2 and objects to r04, r05, r08, r09, r11, r12 which are not inline with the show of hands. Irfan (Cisco) supports r10 Walter Dees (Philips) supports r10 Antoine (Orange) object to r10, which is NOT in line with the SoH . Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments that r12 would already be a big step forward so why not go with r12? Sebastian (Qualcomm) requests to handle S2-2007738 in CC#3 or CC#4 and to establish a working agreement based on r10 Saso (Intel) supports Sebastian's proposal to handle S2-2007738 in CC#3 or CC#4 and to establish a working agreement based on r10 Jens (Sennheiser) supports Sebastian's proposal to handle S2-2007738 in CC#3 or CC#4 and to establish a working agreement based on r10 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and asks whether working assumption or working agreement is meant. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Peter; confirms working assumption Sebastian (Qualcomm) clarifies that at some point also a working agreement may be needed to make progress === Phase 2 final deadline === Kisuk (Samsung) prefers the r10. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Endorsed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007756 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007738r10. Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks if this paper can be considered merged into S2-2007738 given that 7738r02 has been updated to reflect the outcome of the show of hands? Devaki (Nokia) is fine to consider this merged with 7738 as long as it is updated to cover the missing part (SIB bit for trial and error selection). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007757 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Conclusion - architecture approach for AAA support. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007253, to S2-2007835. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 (from Ericsson and Nokia), thanks Daniel (Ericsson) for merging with S2-2007253. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 merging part of S2-2007051, based on offline discussion === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 merging part of S2-2007047, based on offline discussion Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and r04. Daniel (Ericsson) provides r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 Devaki (Nokia) asks regarding External ID. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06 Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r06. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r06; objects to the other versions === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007835 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Conclusion - architecture approach for AAA support. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007757R06, merging S2-2007253. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007763 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 conclusion for UEs with SNPN subscription (incl. AAA aspects). | Qualcomm Incorporated, Huawei | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007738r10. Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper to 7738 (and 7757 possibly). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with Devaki (Nokia) for merging Devaki (Nokia) corrects AI# for email subject. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - LSs/General | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007124 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on SNPN determination on the PLMN subscription to use for PLMN | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r10, with Q3 modified, agreed. Revised to S2-2007959. | Fei (OPPO) proposes to note the draft LS. Belen (Ericsson) explains that an EN on solution#46 on whether SA1 requirement exist so we ask for them. Ericsson clarifies that the requirement may exist so we need the LS. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hualin (Huawei) provides the r02 Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. Fei (OPPO) provides r04. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision Josep (DT) comments and provides r06 and asks a question for clarification. === CC#2 === Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the clarification for 'Home network' Belen (Ericsson) provides r07 Josep (DT) comments on the addition in r07 Marco (Huawei) provides r08 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r09 Belen (Ericsson) provides r10. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Belen Belen (Ericsson) clarifies to Sebastian and asks for confirmation on the prefered way forward. Sebastian (Qualcomm) clarifies and proposes a way forward to Belen Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r10 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r10 Antoine (Orange) expresses concerns with this LS. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Orange regarding the scope of the work. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is not ok with r10 and is only ok with the revisions without 'user consent be given earlier' === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Belen (Ericsson) provides r11 including comments rfom MediaTek and will upload it for CC#4 === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007959 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on SNPN determination on the PLMN subscription to use for PLMN selection | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007124R10, with Q3 modified. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution related | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007125 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2 - Solution#46- Propose resolution of Editor´s Notes. | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007433, to S2-2007836. | Belen (Ericsson) provides a r01 as the merged version based on Rapporteur's suggestion. Marco (Huawei) agree to consider 7433 merged in this doc. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03 and asks QC to provide comments early enough to address them. Ericsson states that this is the 3 meeting that QC sends late comments close to the deadline and provide no explanation. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Belen and clarifies that the deadline is tomorrow Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks follow-up questions on r03 Myungjune (LGE) provides comments on r03. Josep (DT) asks some questions for clarification and provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Sebastian, Josep and Chia-Lin and ask for feedback to be able to provide a new revision if needed. Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) provide r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 Belen (Ericsson) provides r07. Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) provides the responses to Ericsson and prefer to go with r05 or r06 Belen (Ericsson) clarifies to MediaTek and do not agree with r06 or r05. Ericsson asks MediaTek to confirm if it is okay or not. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r07. Marco (Huawei) prefers r07. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007836 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2 - Solution#46- Propose resolution of Editor´s Notes. | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007125R07, merging S2-2007433. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007433 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol#46: Update to solve EN(s). | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007836 | Marco (Huawei) consider merged into 7125. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007155 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol#14: Update to enable selective UEs being released to RRC-Inactive. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005568 from S2#140E. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007837. | Qianghua (Huawei) expresses concerns on this PCR Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to the comments from Qianghua (Huawei) and provide r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) requests the P-CR to be updated with correct formatting. Qianghua (Huawei) still has concerns Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r02 for solving the format issue. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r03 based on the offline discussion with Qianghua === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007837 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol#14: Update to enable selective UEs being released to RRC-Inactive. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007155R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007436 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol#49: Update to clarify and correct the solution 49. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides request to fill in the clause on impacts. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2007439 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 Sol#48 Further clarifications . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2007575 | Revised | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007575 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 Sol#48 Further clarifications . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007439. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007838. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions and a r01 Marco (Huawei) responses to E///'s comments and provides a r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007838 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 Sol#48 Further clarifications . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007575R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007534 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: Enabling a UE to receive paging message from another network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r01 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007948. | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Marco (Huawei) due lack of answers propose to note the doc Kisuk(Samsung) replies to Huawei. Kisuk (Samsung) response to Huawei. Josep (DT) asks question for clarification and proposes to note this pCR. Marco (Huawei) seconded Josep's. Kisuk (Samsung) responses DT. Kisuk (Samsung) responses Huawei. Josep (DT) replies to Kisuk (Samsung). Kisuk (Samsung) provides revision and replies to Josep (DT). Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for justification for this proposal === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Kisuk (Samsung) responses to MediaTek. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Kisuk (Samsung) Kisuk (Samsung) responds to Guillaume (MediaTek) === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment that it is assumed that UE is kept in CM-CONNECTED over NWu i.e. no paging needed. Kisuk (Samsung) replies to Peter (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Samsung, and asks if there are more supporters as we should focus on evaluation/conclusions. Josep (DT) comments. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007948 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: Enabling a UE to receive paging message from another network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007534R01. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007586 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Solution #18, update impact analysis and Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007839. | Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides responses to Ericsson and provide r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007839 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Solution #18, update impact analysis and Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007586R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007707 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update for solution45 to remove ENs . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007840. | Devaki (Nokia) questions the proposal. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007840 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update for solution45 to remove ENs . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007707R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion related | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007154 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Update to evaluation and conclusion . | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Noted | Marco (Huawei) proposed to merge into contribution S2-2007572. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Antoine (Orange) object to r00 and r01 . === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007312 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Update evaluation and conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Fei (OPPO) propose to merge the evaluation part into S2-2007376. Marco (Huawei) proposed to merge the conclusion into contribution S2-2007572. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Josep (DT) proposes to postpone this pCR based on the result of CC2's SoH (at least the conclusion part). Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok to postpone this pCR Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the PCR (all revisions) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007376 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Update on the Evaluation. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007841. | Fei (OPPO) provides r01 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007841 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Update on the Evaluation. | OPPO, Futurewei, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007376R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007468 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 CM states and paging: considerations and conclusion proposal. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007842. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007842 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 CM states and paging: considerations and conclusion proposal. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007468R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007572 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 QoS and session continuity considerations and conclusion proposal. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r11 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007949. | Fei (OPPO) propose to merge the evaluation part into S2-2007376. Lars (Sony) Ask a question Marco (Huawei) answers Marco (Huawei) provides R01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Lars (Sony) Comments the reply from Marco === CC#2 === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provide r02 for merging 2007154 to 2007572 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r04 and replies to comments from Peter. Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Xiaobo (Alibaba). Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) answers to question from Myungjune. Hualin(Huawei) response to Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba). Myungjune (LGE) provides comments and supports r03. Fei (OPPO) comments on r04 regarding the application indication. Marco (Huawei) provides R05. Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Marco (Huawei). Marco (Huawei) answers to Myungjune (LGE) Myungjune (LGE) provides comments and suggests to remove the new EN. Marco (Huawei) answers. Lars (Sony) provide r06 Myungjune (LGE) answers Marco (Huawei). Devaki (Nokia) provides r07. Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) provide r08 Chia-Lin ( MediaTek) further provide r09 on the correction of the part related to single radio UE Marco ( Huawei) object to r09 in replacing Session continuity with PDU session continuity Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask the clarification to Huawei (Marco) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and questions. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) respond to Huawei (Marco) Marco (Huawe) respond Marco (Huawei) responds Chia-Lin (MediaTek) reponded to Huawei (Marco) Marco (Huawei) responded === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r08 or r09. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is only ok with r09 and object all the other revisions Marco (Huawei) we are ok with r08 and object r09 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r08 or r09; objects to other versions === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Marco (Huawei) per offline discussion propose r10a for CC#4 Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r10a Peter Hedman (Ericsson) is ok with r10a === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007949 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#2 QoS and session continuity considerations and conclusion proposal. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Alibaba Group, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007572R11. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007579 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Interim Conclusion update. | Sony, Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2007843. | Marco (Huawei) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to comments from Marco (Huawei) Hualin(Huawei) propose to note this paper. Because we see no benefits to take it as conclusion. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Hualin (Huawei) Hualin(Huawei) comments on Hualin reason for noting the paper. === CC#2 === Josep (DT)asks a question for clarification. Lars (Sony) answers Josep Hualin(Huawei) comments on the paper. Lars (Sony) responds to Hualin. Devaki (Nokia) shares the same concern as HUA regarding the trigger for RRC_INACTIVE. Hualin(Huawei) response to Lars(Sony). Lars (Sony) responds to Devaki. Hualin(Huawei) response to Lars (Sony). Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks for clarification Lars (Sony) responds to Sebastian Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 Lars (Sony) ask Peter Hedman question on provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Lars (Sony) ask to approve r01. We can't accept r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Sony, and ok to postpone the conclusion to next meeting. Antoine (Orange) asks for clarification on r02. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) prefers r01 and can not accept r02 because the r02 is not clear. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides suggestions for compromise and asks for review on CC#3 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Orange. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Alibaba. Lars (Sony) reply to Ericsson that you discuss different case in r02. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) supports Lars's point and asks to approve r01 (Perhaps with minor update as I suggested) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Sony. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to go with r00 with an additional Editor's note to address Ericsson's concerns Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides reply to Ericsson. Lars (Sony) thanks Sebastian for way forward. I may be better to use r01+EN since Nokia requested some clarifications. Marco (Huawei) concern on R01 and for way forward wait to see the actual proposal. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes r04 Lars (Sony) comments on Sebastian's proposal Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r02 or the late r04; objects to r00 and r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r05 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r05 (or r02) and object other revisions. Lars (Sony) provides r06 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r05 Marco (Huawei) objects to r00, r01, r02, r03, r04 and r06, I can live with r05 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) prefers r06, can live with r05 and objects to r02 Lars (Sony) to make progress we accept r05 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007843 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Interim Conclusion update. | Sony, Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007579R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007584 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Conclusion. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Noted | Hualin(Huawei) have comments on this paper. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Hualin (Huawei) and asks clarification. Hualin(Huawei) response to Myungjune (LGE). === CC#2 === Myungjune (LGE) replies to Hualin (Huawei). Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper (all versions) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Devaki (Nokia) shares the same view as Qualcomm, objects to the P-CR and its revisions. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Devaki (Nokia). Devaki (Nokia) responds to Myungjune (LG). Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r01. Marco (huawei) commented and provides r02 Myungjune (LGE) replies to Marco (Huawei) and provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) asks whether r03 can be agreed. Antoine (Orange) objects to r03. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Antoine (Orange) and requests to reconsider. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007588 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2: Interim conclusion on UE steering. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Postponed | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) agrees this is a general case but prefer to keep in the conclusion of KI#2 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) suggest this move to KI #1 instead of KI#2 with some changes Myungjune (LGE) provides comments and suggests to note or postpone. Chia-Lin (LGE) provides the clarification to LGE(Myungjune) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02, and proposes to keep in KI#2. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to LGE. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides comments. Fei (OPPO) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) asks whether the issue with enabling the possibility to influence the network/subscription selection should be discussed at CC#2 with show of hands question? Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) support the view from OPPO and have concerns on r02. Suggest to have separate discussion with this contribution and S2-2007312 Marco (Huawei) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Myungjune (LGE) replies to Peter (Ericsson) and Chia-Lin (MediaTek). === CC#2 === Josep (DT) proposes to postpone this pCR based on the result of CC2's SoH. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok to postpone this pCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007600 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2 , evaluation and conclusion on simultaneously connections with both networks. | Futurewei, Philips, | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007600r09 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007920. | Fei (OPPO) propose to merge the evaluation part into S2-2007376. Lars (Sony) Ask a question Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r01 and propose a draft LS to RAN WG on 2Rx/1Tx device support for KI #2 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) response to Sony and OPPO and provides r01 Lars (Sony) response to Amanda Chia-Lin (MediaTek) prefer not to send the LS out to RAN Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 and a question. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and response to Ericsson. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides r03 and response to Ericsson. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r04 Hualin(Huawei) object r04 and provide r05 based on r03. === CC#2 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 Walter Dees (Philips) comments to Sebastian. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) response to Qualcomm and Huawei and provides r07 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r08 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Antoine (Orange) object to r07 and r08 . Marco (Huawei) prefer r05 but I ask clarifications on wording of r08 in order to be able to eventually consider r08 or a further improvements, if possible. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r08 or r06; objects to the other versions. Marco ( Huawei) considering that S2-2007705 has been withdrawn, the r09 is ok as way out Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides r09 on top of r05 in draft folder as way move forward === Phase 2 final deadline === Dieter ( Deutsche Telekom ) comments. QC cannot withdraw S2-2007705. They would need to object to it. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007920 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2 , evaluation and conclusion on simultaneously connections with both networks. | Futurewei, Philips, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007600R09. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007705 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2 conclusion. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Sennheiser, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | CC#4: r05 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007950. | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hualin(Huawei) propose to note this paper and mark it merged to S2-2007600, since they are resolving the same issue. === CC#2 === Josep (DT) replies to Myungjune (LGE) Myungjune (LGE) relies to Josep (DT). Sebastian (Qualcomm) does not agree to merge with 7600 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide r01 Devaki (Nokia) provides r02, cannot accept r00, r02 as it removes EN without resolution. Marco (Nokia) provides r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Nokia; objects to r01 and r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provides response to Qualcomm and ok with r04 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r04 Devaki (Nokia) corrects previously made comment, cannot accept r00, r01, can accept r02 (own revision). Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) response to Qualcomm === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) only can accept r04. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r03, supports approval of r04 and clarifies that difference with r04 is only to maintain the EN about interim conclusion. Sebastian (Qualcomm) withdraws the paper (all versions) === Phase 2 final deadline === Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comment: Sebastian you cannot withdraw a paper in this mode of operation (especially which was co-sourced). You may object to it. === CC#3 === Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05 Myungjune (LGE) ok with r05. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r05 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) is fine with r05, and can add Futurewei as co-sign company. Marco (Huawei) asks final clarification Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with Peter and comments to Marco === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007950 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2 conclusion. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Sennheiser, Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007705R05. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007758 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Conclusion update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007844. | Marco (Huawei) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Marco (Huawei) propose to note this contribution due to lack of feedback in 1 week Devaki (Nokia) responds to Marco (Huawei). Reminds that the 2nd deadline is only tomorrow. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Myungjune (LG). Marco (Huawei) proposes r02. Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007844 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Conclusion update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007758R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Solution related | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2006946 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, Solution#53 Update to remove Editor's Notes . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007845. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 George (Ericsson) agrees to r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007845 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, Solution#53 Update to remove Editor's Notes . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006946R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007162 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, Solution #21: Update on IMC provisioning. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | George (Ericsson): Ericsson objects to this revision. Please see additional comments Rainer (Nokia) agrees with George (Ericsson). Haris (Qualcomm) objects to this pCR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007163 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, Solution #26: Removal of remained ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007846. CC#3: It had been requested to add an editor's note to S2-2007163R01. It was decided to do this at the next meeting and S2-2007163 was postponed | George (Ericsson): Ericsson objects to this revision. Please see additional comments Haris (Qualcomm) objects to using UPU to provision the IMC Yi (China Mobile) replies and provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r01 and suggests to keep EN-- Editor's note: Support for Emergency Services is FFS. Yi (China Mobile) ask question for clarification on Haris's comment. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007846 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, Solution #26: Removal of remained ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007163R01. CC#3: WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007164 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, New Solution: SNPN selection based on SNPN service capability. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | George (Ericsson): Ericsson objects to this pCR. Please see additional comments Hualin(Huawei) suggest the way forward. Yi (China Mobile) clarify and provide r01. Rainer (Nokia) shares the concerns of Ericsson. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on the solution and indicates that is better handled/discussed as KI#1 solution === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yi (China Mobile) responds. R02 is provided and we think this solution should be discussed in KI#3, the solution is on top of SNPN selection taking into account voice support capability of SNPNs. George (Ericsson) provides a response. Yi (China Mobile) responds to George. George (Ericsson) provides response.. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === George (Ericsson) objects to all revisions. Yi (China Mobile) responds although George objects. George (Ericsson) response. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007377 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, new solution: new solution for the SNPN selection. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007847. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 George (Ericsson) seeking clarification Curt (Charter) seeks a clarification and suggests a change to the following texts... Haris (Qualcomm) comments Curt (Charter) comments Devaki (Nokia) cannot agree to second part of the conclusion under 'Home SP owns AAA'. Devaki (Nokia) withdraws comment for this paper. Fei (OPPO) provides response to George (Ericsson). Fei (OPPO) responds to Curt (Charter) and Haris (Qualcomm); Saso (Intel) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007847 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, new solution: new solution for the SNPN selection. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007377R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusion related | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2006945 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Update Interim conclusion on KI#3 - add SLA use Case. | Ericsson, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the pCR George (Ericsson) provides comments. Curt (Charter) provides comments. Susan (Huawei) supports this paper and can cosign. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2006944 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Update Interim conclusion on KI#3. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007848. | Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) asks questions and comments Haris (Qualcomm) asks question and proposes alternative George (Ericsson) provides response. George (Ericsson) provides r1. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007848 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Update Interim conclusion on KI#3. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006944R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - LSs/General | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007326 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on NG-RAN broadcast of Onboarding Network information in the SIB | Intel | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2007849. | Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless) object to the original version and provides r01. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless) provides r03 Fei (OPPO) asks clarification Mike (Convida Wireless) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Walter Dees (Philips) comments and provides revision r04. Mike (Convida Wireless) replies Walter Dees (Philips) and is fine with r04. Megha(Intel) provides r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007849 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on NG-RAN broadcast of Onboarding Network information in the SIB | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007326R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007435 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Revise the term of UE Onboarding for NPN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Josep (DT) objects to this pCR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok to note the P-CR as we are anyway in hopefully final stages. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - Solution related | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2006992 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol. 40 update - Removal of Editor's Notes. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007311 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Update solution #6, Addressing ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007430 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#34: Update to remove EN(s). | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Josep (DT) asks a question for clarification Hualin(Huawei) response to Josep (DT). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2007437 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#38 Update to clarify and correct the solution 38. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007438 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update to clarify and correct the solution 32. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Telecom | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007850. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007850 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update to clarify and correct the solution 32. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007438R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007535 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #5: Update to clarify how the UE discovers and selects the onboarding network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007851. | Megha(Intel) proposes to note the pCR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Kisuk(Samsung) replies to Intel and provides revision Megha(Intel) provides r02 Kisuk (Samsung) responses to Intel. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Megha(Intel) is fine with r03. Kisuk (Samsung) is fine with r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007851 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #5: Update to clarify how the UE discovers and selects the onboarding network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007535R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007706 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update for solution37 to remove ENs . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - Evaluation and Conclusion related | - | - | Docs:=21 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007048 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, evaluations and conclusions update. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007854 | Megha(Intel) requests clarification. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment. Megha(Intel) provides r01 and additional question Fei (OPPO) asks clarification. Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r02 Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 removing conclusion content as already merged into S2-2007309 and provides comments. === CC#2 === Megha(Intel) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) agrees that this contribution is merged into S2-2007309 and S2-2007327 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok to mark paper marged into S2-2007327. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007156 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Update to evaluation and conclusion . | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | CC#4: r04 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007958. | Josep (DT) objects to this pCR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Josep (DT) Fei (OPPO) asks for clafication. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Fei (OPPO) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification on the change Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarification to Chia-Lin (MediaTek) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) asks to approve r02 which is provided before revision deadline since there is no objection on r02, and asks for review on CC#3 if needed. Josep (DT) additionally comments that the KI#4 merge pCR S2-2007309 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) suggests that revisions should be announced within the tags. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Peter and Josep and sorry for not announcing the revision within the tags. === CC#3 === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) proposes to consider r02 for CC#4. Antoine (Orange) asks questions on r02. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) answers questions from Orange. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the comments to r02 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r03 and replies to comments from MTK, and asks to use r03 for CC#4 Fei (OPPO) comments that the change in r03 has been covered in the S2-2007309r18. Walter Dees (Philips) comments to Xiaobo (Alibaba) Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) has clarified that the paper is not covered by 2007309r18 based on offline discussion with Fei (OPPO) Fei (OPPO) is fine with r03. Xiaobo (Alibaba) replies to Philips (Walter). Xiaobo (Alibaba) provides r04. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007958 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Update to evaluation and conclusion . | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007156R04. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007173 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Interim conclusions update. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007852. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments, r01, objects the original Haris (Qualcomm) comments that only remaining text in r01 is not explained and is not understandable === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Megha(Intel) proposes to note the pCR === CC#2 === Xiaowan(vivo) disagrees r01, replies to comments and provide r02 Qianghua (Huawei) disagree r02 Fei (OPPO) comments on r02. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r03 Josep (DT) comments. Xiaowan(vivo) replies === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007852 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Interim conclusions update. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007173R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007309 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Interim conclusions. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r18 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007310, S2-2007324, S2-2007325, S2-2007356, S2-2007378, S2-2007589, S2-2007634 and S2-2007759 to S2-2007853. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 merging in content from 7324+7356+7589+7759 Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless) objects to r01 and provides r02 Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides r03 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and questions. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r04 and comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r05. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06, merging S2-2007048r02; === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r07 and comments Hualin(Huawei) provides r08. === CC#2 === Haris (Qualcomm) cannot accept the leaving the decision about DCS discovery to SA3 and objects to r08 Rainer (Nokia) objects to r8. Mike (Convida Wireless) objects to r08. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to base further revisions on r07 and add what can be agreed. Fei (OPPO) provides r09 based on r07 and merged the discussion of S2-2007378 into r09. Hualin response to Haris (Qualcomm). Hualin(Huawei) response to Rainer (Nokia). Hualin(Huawei) response to Mike (Convida Wireless). Hualin (Huawei) object r09. Because it skip all the changes in r08 although the changes are not comments by companies. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question on r09 and provides r11 Megha(Intel) provides r12 Fei (OPPO) responds to Haris (Qualcomm). Hualin(Huawei) object r11 and only accept r10 so far. Rainer (Nokia) prefers r11. Hualin(Huawei) response to Rainer (Nokia) and provide r12. Josep (DT) asks whether r12 is from Megha (Intel) or Zhualin (Huawei). Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r12. Hualin(Huawei) response to Josep (DT) and provide r13. Megha(Intel) provides r14 and some comments. Megha(Intel) provides r15 merging 7325r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r16 Hualin(Huawei) provide r17. Antoine (Orange) provides r18. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) comments and asks question Hualin(Huawei) response to Haris (Qualcomm). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment on UDM/UDR provisioning. Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Rainer (Nokia) replies to Haris (Qualcomm) and is ok with r18. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r18 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Hualin. Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that is also ok with r18 Megha(Intel) prefers r16, but can live with r18. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007853 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Interim conclusions. | Ericsson, Intel, China Telecom, MediaTek Inc., Nokia, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007309R18, merging S2-2007310, S2-2007324, S2-2007325, S2-2007356, S2-2007378, S2-2007589, S2-2007634 and S2-2007759. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007310 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Interim conclusions - DCS and PS. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hualin(Huawei) propose to merge this paper to S2-2007309. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007324 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Conclusion Update - Resolve ENs . | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note and mark it as merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Megha (Intel) ok to mark this pCR merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007325 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Conclusion Update - CP provisioning SNPN case . | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides comment Fei (OPPO) objects to this PCR Qianghua (Huawei) objects to this PCR Megha(Intel) provides r01 and comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hualin(Huawei) propose to merge this paper to S2-2007309. Fei (OPPO) questions the need to add editors note. === CC#2 === Megha(Intel) responds to Fei (OPPO) Fei (OPPO) responds to Megha (Intel). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Megha(Intel) states this document merged with 7309. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007327 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Evaluation - UE Onboarding . | Intel | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007048, to S2-2007854. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides S2-2007327r01, merging evaluation part from S2-2007048 Chengsui (Alibaba) provides S2-2007327r02, merging evaluation part from S2-2007679 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Megha(Intel) is fine with r02 . === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2007854 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Evaluation - UE Onboarding . | Intel, Huawei, Alibaba | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007327R02, merging S2-2007048. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2007339 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Conclusion Update Related to O-SNPN discovery . | Convida Wireless LLC, Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Haris (Qualcomm) comments that given we have to send LS to SA3 in S2-2007326 this paper is better postponed until we receive response === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mike (Convida Wireless) proposes to postpone this paper, but does not agree that we necessarily need to wait for a response from SA3. === CC#2 === Guanzhou (InterDigital) shares the view of Haris(Qualcomm) and objects to this tdoc. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) asks for clarification. Mike (Convida Wireless) replies to Shuyi Tian (China Telecom). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007356 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Update interim conclusions on NG-RAN impact. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note and mark it as merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) agrees to merge S2-2007356 into S2-2007309. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007378 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Update on the conclusion. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Josep (DT) comments on the use of RI and asks a question for clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments, and proposes to merge in part of the proposal to S2-2007309. Fei (OPPO) provides reply to Peter (Ericsson) and Josep (DT). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hualin(Huawei) response to Fei (OPPO) and provides r01. === CC#2 === Fei (OPPO) provides reponses to Hualin (Huawei) and is fine to mark merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007571 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Update to conclusion. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Noted | Mike Starsinic (Convida Wireless) objects to the original version. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007589 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Interim conclusion. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note and mark it as merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007634 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Closing Editor's Notes for conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this into S2-2007309 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Haris (Qualcomm) agrees to merge into S2-2007309 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2007636 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4 and KI#1: SNPN selection for onboarding . | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Megha(Intel) objects to the pCR === CC#2 === Haris (Qualcomm) comments that Intel's objection is not based agreed assumptions Megha (Intel) sustains objection and provides additional comments === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2007679 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, evaluations and conclusions. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) objects to this PCR === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) for evaluation parts it seems most are covered by S2-2007327 i.e. can we mark it as merged into S2-2007327? Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to comments from Qianghua and Peter === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to mark this merged in 7309 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) proposes to postpone this pCR. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2007759 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Conclusion update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007853 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note and mark it as merged into S2-2007309. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Documents not available | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Study on enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5GC (FS_enh_EC) | - | - | Docs:=112 | - | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Other (non of KI 1, 2 3 5) | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#1 solutions (ordered by solution #) | - | - | Docs:=28 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007767 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution 6.2.3.1. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007855. | Magnus (Ericsson) provides rev 1 Laurent (Nokia): asks for clarification and provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Magnus (Ericsson): r02 looks ok and answers Laurent Laurent (Nokia) provides r03 Dan (China Mobie) provides r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007855 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution 6.2.3.1. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007767R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007128 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, KI#2, KI#5, Sol #12: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2007856. | Hui (Huawei) proposes this contribution focus on update of general and KI#1 part only. Laurent (Nokia): asks a question about 6.12.2.1 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Magnus (Ericsson): Provides r01 Laurent (Nokia) comments Magnus (Ericsson) provides r03. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04 and objects to any previous revision Magnus (Ericsson) provides r05 Hui (Huawei) provides r06 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Magnus (Ericsson) provides answers and potential ways fw Laurent (Nokia) comments, Objects to any version from r00 to r05. For the sake of progress can live with r06 but many aspects SHALL be revisited Hui (Huawei) replies. Magnus (Ericsson) propose to go with r06 + reinstate the editors not in the conclusion. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r07 (r06+reinstated EN) to progress the conclusions === Phase 2 final deadline === Hui (Huawei) fine with r07. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007856 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #12: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007128R07. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006937 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: Update to Solution #13 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007134, to S2-2007857. | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) comments. Magnus (Ericsson): provides r04 and asks a few questions about Sol#13 === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei): provides r06 and asks to clarify new information of Sol#13 comparing to Sol#1. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05 Magnus (Ericsson) provides r06 Magnus (Ericsson) provides r07 Changhong (Intel) is fine with r06 and r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007857 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: Update to Solution #13 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006937R07, merging S2-2007134. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007134 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #13: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007857 | Laurent (Nokia): suggests to merge S2-2007134 in S2-2006937 which is a superset of S2-2007134 Hui (Huawei) supports the merging. Magnus (Ericsson) we are happy to consider S2-2007134 merged into S2-2006937 and use that as base for further revisions of Solution 13. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007552 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol#14: Solution update. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007858. | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r02; === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007858 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol#14: Solution update. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007552R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007556 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol#15: Solution update. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007333 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Solution #16 Update . | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007859. | Revised | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007859 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Solution #16 Update . | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007333R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006981 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #19: Edge Application Server discovery using an Address Resolution Function . | ITRI | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): I am not sure we need this update + further comments Samer (ITRI) replies to Laurent Hui (Huawei) agree this update is not necessary. Samer (ITRI) replies to Hui Susana (Vodafone) proposes to note this pCR Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) agree this update is not necessary. Samer (ITRI) replies to Tingfang Tang and Susana === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) objects to the paper. Samer (ITRI) agree to note this paper and further comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2006868 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Solution 22 updates with correcting option3. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007921 | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Dan (China Mobile) provides some comments for clarification and provide r02 John (Futurewei) provides r03 Dan (China Mobile) provides r04 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments on overlap part for 6868 and 7240. John (Futurewei) provides comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies and provides revision. === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) provides r06. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r07. Tony (Futurewei) comments, object to revisions of 6868, and as indicated before proposes to merge 6868 into 7240. Tony (Futurewei) agrees to keep 6868 and 7240 separate for now after seeing the new revisions by Ericsson. Dan (China Mobile) propose that keep 6868 and 7240 separate, 6868 will not invlve LDNSR location Tony (Futurewei) responds to Dan. Okay to proceed with 6868. Laurent (Nokia) provides same comment to S2-2006868 and S2-2007240: please keep only one of them Laurent (Nokia) Based on the fact that S2-2007006 merges S2-2006868r07 + S2-2007240 I object to any version of S2-2006868 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dan (China Mobile) this paper is merged into S2-2007006 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007005 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on LDNSR placement | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007006 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update Solution#22 to resolve ENs not related to LDNSR placement . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007006r11 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006868, S2-2007127, S2-2007240 and S2-2007551, to S2-2007921. | Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Qian (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks to ignore the r01. Changhong (Intel) proposes r01. Jinguo(ZTE) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) proposes r02. Dan (China Mobile) proposes r03. Zhuoyun (Tencent) proposes r04. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05 Hui (Huawei) provides r06 Changhong (Intel) provides r07. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r08. Hui (Huawei) provides r09. Laurent (Nokia) provides r10 Hui (Huawei) insists on r09. Magnus (Ericsson) agrees with Huawei to continue based on r09. Jinguo (ZTE) ask question for clarification on both r09 and r10. Hui (Huawei) replies to Jinguo. Jinguo(ZTE) further reply to Hui (Huawei) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hui (Huawei) objects r10, and proposes to approve r09. Magnus (Ericsson) also r10, and proposes to approve r09. Changhong (Intel) also proposes to approve r09. Laurent (Nokia) Objects to any version apart from r10 but proposes a way forward Laurent (Nokia) clarifies the way forward Hui (Huawei) provides a revised way forward Laurent (Nokia) further clarifies the proposed way forward === Phase 2 final deadline === Hui(Huawei) provides a draft r11. Laurent (Nokia) OK with draft r11. Magnus (Ericsson) Also OK with r11. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007921 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update Solution#22 to resolve ENs not related to LDNSR placement . | Huawei, HiSilicon, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007006R11, merging S2-2006868, S2-2007127, S2-2007240 and S2-2007551. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006935 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: (new) Solution #22': LDNSR as a (pseudo) DNS Resolver to support low latency applications . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007860 | Hui (Huawei) objects to the paper unless it is revised as a solution update. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Hui Hui (Huawei) replies to Laurent. Changhong (Intel) objects this paper since new solution is not allowed at this meeting. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Chang Hong Laurent (Nokia) Asks for guidance on how he can fulfil the agreement of the CC to provide details of each option (e.g. by different papers) of solution 22 Hui (Huawei) replies to Laurent and provide comments to the solution. Magnus (Ericsson) provides comments and a revision, S2-2006935r01. Laurent (Nokia) provides comments:. Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 Laurent (Nokia): provides r03. changes from r02 are not mine but a copy from E///'s John (Futurewei) comments and requests clarification. Dan(China Mobile) comments and object to r02, r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Laurent (Nokia): answers to Dan Dan(China Mobile) reply to Laurent and do not agree with the way to update sol22 Hui(Huawei) supports China Mobile's comments. Laurent (Nokia) answers. I'll produce r04 this afternoon taking into account Magnus', dan's, Hui's and John's comment John (Futurewei) requests further clarification. === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) objects to r02 and r03. Laurent (Nokia) answers to John John (Futurewei) replies re: impact in sol#22. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04 and comments Susana (Vodafone) asks for clarification Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this as merged into S2-2007699. Laurent (Nokia) for the sake of reducing the number of living documents is happy to consider S2-2006935 merged into S2-2007699 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007127 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Solution #22 Update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007921 | Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of this Tdoc Magnus (Ericsson): We can either Note it or consider the non-LDNSR placement improvements merged into S2-2007006 Hui(Huawei) proposes to consider this as merged into S2-2007006. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007240 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol 22 Update for Option 3A. | Futurewei, ITRI | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007921 | Changhong (Intel) proposes r01. John (Futurewei) provides r02. Dan (China Mobile) provide comments and concerns John (Futurewei) provides answers. Hui (Huawei) provides comments. Dan (China Mobile) provides comments. John (Futurewei) replies, provides r03. John (Futurewei) replies. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments on overlap part for 6868 and 7240. John (Futurewei) provides r04 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies and provides revision. Dan (China Mobile) provides r06 based on r05 provided by Lenovo === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) provides r06. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r07. Changhong (Intel) provides r08. Laurent (Nokia) provides same comment to S2-2006868 and S2-2007240: please keep only one of them Laurent (Nokia) Based on the fact that S2-2007006 merges S2-2006868r07 + S2-2007240 I object to any version of S2-2007240 John (Futurewei) considers S2-2007240 merged into S2-2007006. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007525 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22: update on LDNSR placement. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007860 | Gerry Libunao (Verizon): Verizon provides comments. Riccardo Guerzoni (NTT docomo): provides r01 to include Verizon as a co-signing company. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for clarification. Riccardo Guerzoni (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) ask further question for clarification. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) commenst Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to take this tdoc as baseline for sol#22 updates related to LDNSR as standalone entity. Laurent (Nokia) proses to take one of the other Tdocs (7699 or 6935) as the baseline Laurent (Nokia) proposes a way forward Hui (Huawei) comments. Hui (Huawei) replies. Laurent (Nokia) replies. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Hui. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Riccardo and supports Hui Laurent (Nokia) comments Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Laurent. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Dario (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Laurent (Nokia) for the sake of reducing the number of living documents I object to any version of S2-2007525, Keeping only 7699 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) merges this tdoc to -7699. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007458 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: LDNSR placement in solution 22. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Riccardo Guerzoni (NTT docomo): provides r01 including ENs on N4. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Riccardo Guerzoni (NTT DOCOMO) provides new comments on N4 and LDNSR in UPF. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of this Tdoc === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007551 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol#22: Update to solve the Editor's Notes. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007921 | Zhuoyun (Tencent) proposes to merge to S2-2007006. Laurent (Nokia) thanks a lot Zhuoyun to reduce the number of Tdocs to be discussed and objects to any revision of S2-2007551 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007360 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1 solution#22 update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any revision of this Tdoc === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007699 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22: update on LDNSR as standalone NF. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, NTT DOCOMO? | Rel-17 | Confirm Sources! r13 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006935 and S2-2007525, to S2-2007860. | Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Laurent (Nokia) provides r01 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) requests clarifications on the purpose of S2-2007699r01. Laurent (Nokia) answers Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Laurent. Dario (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Hui (Huawei) provides r02. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies for r01 and r02, and provides r03. Laurent (Nokia) replies to Riccardo. Laurent (Nokia) replies to Riccardo and comments. Riccardo (NTT docomo) provides r04. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05 Dan (China Mobile) provides some clarification Riccardo (NTT docomo) provides r06. Hui(Huawei) provides r07 Jicheol (Samsung) provides r08. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies and provides r09. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r10. Laurent (Nokia) provides r11 and r12 Hui (Huawei) comments. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) comments on r11 and r12. Hui (Huawei) provide r13. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies and is ok with r11 or r13 but not other revisions. Hui (Huawei) suggest to go with r11. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) supports r13 or r10, and objects r11 and r12. Hui (Huawei) withdraw previous comments and suggest to go with r13. Laurent (Nokia) Objects to any version but R11 and R12 and agrees that r12 is a bit harsh so DO suggest to agree R11 that just adds 'Editor's Note: option 2b is FFS' Laurent (Nokia) clarifies that he can easily accept r13 just modified by adding 'Editor's Note: option 2b is FFS' Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007860 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22: update on LDNSR as standalone NF. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007699R13, merging S2-2006935 and S2-2007525. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007361 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 solution#27 update. | ZTE, Intel, Convida Wireless, Tencent, NTT Docomo | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007717 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Solution #X usage of user category and subscribed services to control local offload. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Vodafone | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper because new solution is not allowed at this meeting. Hui (Huawei) objects the paper and question on the necessary of introducing the two information. Laurent (Nokia): answers Hui (Huawei): answers Susana (Vodafone) comments to Hui Dan (China Mobile) comments Magnus (Ericsson) is not supporting this proposal and provides comments Laurent (Nokia): provides answers and r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) asks clarification to Laurent. Susana (Vodafone) replies to Magnus and asks for clarification === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) answers to Changhong Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02 Magnus (Ericsson) apologies for posting the last comment in the wrong threead Hui (Huawei) objects to any revision of the tdoc. Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#1 conclusions | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007129 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Additional Conclusions for Multiple Anchors. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007861. | Hui (Huawei) asks why the revision is needed. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) provides r01 Hui (Huawei) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007861 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Additional Conclusions for Multiple Anchors. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007129R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006938 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Conclusions on Key Issue #1 for DNS based solutions for Multiple PDU Sessions . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007862. | Hui (Huawei) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007862 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Conclusions on Key Issue #1 for DNS based solutions for Multiple PDU Sessions . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006938R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007472 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update of evaluation for DNS based solutions for Multiple PDU Sessions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007863. | Magnus (Ericsson) proposes to Note or possibly revise this doc. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r01 and explain why it necessary === CC#2 === Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Laurent and clarifies Hui(Huawei) provides r02. Laurent (Nokia) agrees with Hui provides r03 Dario (Qualcomm) is fine with r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Magnus (Ericsson) is also fine with r03 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007863 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update of evaluation for DNS based solutions for Multiple PDU Sessions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007472R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006936 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Updates to Key Issue #1 conclusions about Distributed Anchors . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Magnus (Ericsson) Comments and proposes to merge S2-2006936 into S2-2007130 Laurent (Nokia): is OK to merge in 7130: let's reduce the number of papers where we can === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) objects to the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007130 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Additional Conclusions for Distributed Anchor. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007495, to S2-2007864. | Magnus (Ericsson) provides r01 which is a proposed merge with S2-2007495 and S2-2006936 (partial) Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 (mistake) and r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hui (Huawei): provides r04. Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r05. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) provides r06 Magnus (Ericsson) provides r07 Hui (Huawei) provides r08 Laurent (Nokia) provides r09 Susana (Vodafone) supports the conclusion as clarified in r09 Hui(Huawei) fine with r09. Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r10. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Laurent (Nokia) Objects to any version of this Tdoc from r00 to r08, prefers r09, can live with r10 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007864 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Additional Conclusions for Distributed Anchor . | Ericsson, Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007130R10, merging S2-2007495. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007495 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Clarification on the guidelines in the evaluation and conclusion for Distributed Anchors. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007864 | Magnus (Ericsson) proposes to merge S2-2007495 into S2-2007130 Laurent (Nokia): Objects to this paper for the sake of merging in 7130: let's reduce the number of papers where we can === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Zhuoyun (Tencent) agrees with Magnus to merge S2-2007495 into S2-2007130. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2006923 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1 conclusion - A way forward on LDNSR. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007865 | Gerry Libunao (Verizon): Verizon provides comments. Dario (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Laurent (Nokia): provides answers to Dario === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jicheol (Samsung) provides answers with r01. Changhong (Intel) comments and supports the way forward. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc and suggests to use S2-2007639 as a baseline for conclusions on LDNSR as a stand-alone NF Hui (Huawei) suggest to merge the contribution into S2-2007007. Jicheol (Samsung) is okay to merge the contribution into S2-2007007. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007639 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1 conclusion - A way forward on LDNSR. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007865 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 and suggests to use S2-2007639 as a baseline for conclusions on LDNSR as a stand-alone NF Hui (Huawei) suggest to merge the contribution into S2-2007007. Changhong (Intel) also proposes to merge this paper into S2-2007007. Laurent (Nokia) then objects to any version of S2-2007639 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) is fine to merge S2-2007639 in S2-2007007 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007007 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Evaluation of solutions and conclusion for session breakout. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005366 from S2#140E. r11 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006923, S2-2007639 and S2-2007718, to S2-2007865. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Dan (China Mobile) provides r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r03. Dan (China Mobile) provides r04 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Magnus (Ericsson) questions the need for the evaluation section. === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) supports Magnus (questions the need for the evaluation section) Changhong (Intel) agrees with Magnus and Laurent to remove the evaluation section and provides r05. Changhong (Intel) provides r06 based on the approved SA3 LS OUT to SA2. Dan (China Mobile) provides r07 in order to reflect SA3 LS and instruct deployment option. Hui (Huawei) fine with r07. Laurent (Nokia) provides r08 Laurent (Nokia) provides r09 Changhong (Intel) comments to Laurent. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Changhong Hui (Huawei) provide r09 Changhong (Intel) objects to r08 and r09. Hui (Huawei) provide r10 Changhong (Intel) provides r11 Dan (China Mobile) object r09, OK with r10 and r11 Jicheol (Samsung) comments with r12. Hui(Huawei) fine with r12. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides r13. Laurent (Nokia) provides r14 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Changhong (Intel) comments on r14, the texts added in r14 only apply to option 3a. Dan (China Mobile) comments and the text about DNS security may only apply to option 3b, but we are ok with r14 Changhong (Intel) replies to Dan's comments and asks Laurent to clarify. Dan (China Mobile) retrieve previous statement, and also asks Laurent to clarify for the new part in r14. And if we can not have common understanding, the r14 is not preferred and r13 should be agreed Changhong (Intel) proposes to go with r13 and disagrees with r14. Dario (Qualcomm) prefers r11 and is NOT OK with r12, r13, r14. Hui (Huawei) suggests to go with r11 or r13. Laurent (Nokia) Objects to any version from r00 to r07 both included, objects to r10, supports to take r14 as the approved version === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007865 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Evaluation of solutions and conclusion for session breakout. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007007R11, merging S2-2006923, S2-2007639 and S2-2007718. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007718 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Updates to Key Issue #1 conclusions about Session Breakout. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007865 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this paper as merged into S2-2007007. Laurent (Nokia) OK to merge but please Hui check the versions r09 of 7007 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007558 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Evaluation and Conclusion on LDNSR placement for Session Breakout Model. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any version of this document === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007570 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Update the Conclusion for the EAS discovery. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui (Huawei) objects to the paper. Chunshan (Tencent) asks for more clarification. Laurent (Nokia) comments Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Chunshan Hui (Huawei) agrees with Laurent. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007400 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on KI#1 Discovery of Edge Application Server. | KDDI | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia) proposes to Note this paper === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007331 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Evaluation Update . | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007866. | Huazhang (vivo) don't agree with the changes in 7331. Mike (Convida Wireless) replies to Huazhang (vivo) Huazhang (vivo) replies to Mike Mike (Convida Wireless) replies Huazhang (vivo) and provides r01. Huazhang(vivo) replies to Mike (Convida Wireless). Mike (Convida Wireless) replies to Huazhang (vivo). Huazhang (vivo) reply to Mike and agree to use r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007866 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Evaluation Update . | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007331R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#2 solutions (ordered by solution #) | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007010 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update solution #27: Reducing packet loss during EAS relocation . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006927 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, Sol #33 update for editorial corrections. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007702 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#2, Solution#37 solution update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, InterDigital Inc? | Rel-17 | Confirm Sources! CC#3: This was revised to clean up the source companies in S2-2007922 | Revised | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007922 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#2, Solution#37 solution update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, InterDigital Inc | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007702. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007158 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#39: Update the Figure and procedure step number. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007867. | Hui (Huawei) comments. Xiaobo Yu(Alibaba) provides r01 and replies to Hui. Hui(Huawei) fine with r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007867 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#39: Update the Figure and procedure step number. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007158R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007132 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, Sol #51: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007868. | John (Futurewei) proposes r01. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Fenqin (Huawei) ask question for clarification Magnus (Ericsson) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007868 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, Sol #51: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007132R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007131 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, Sol #53: Updates to the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007459 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Update to solution 54: EAS relocation for SSC mode 3. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007869. | Huazhang (vivo) provides r01 of 7459 and add UE impacts. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r02 Huazhang (vivo) agree with r02 Shubhranshu (Nokia) requests for clarification Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and disagrees with the proposal. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Fenqin(Huawei) responds. Fenqin (Huawei) replies. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies that can live with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007869 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Update to solution 54: EAS relocation for SSC mode 3. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007459R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#2 conclusions | - | - | Docs:=30 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007009 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion for C1 solutions on reducing packet loss. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007243, to S2-2007870. | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as baseline to conclude solutions related to packet lossless === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) comments and is fine with using this paper as baseline to conclude the aspects of reducing packet loss. Hui(Huawei) provides r01. Shubhranshu (Nokia) objects to S2-2007009r01 and provides S2-2007009r02 Hui (Huawei) objects to r02. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) Hui (Huawei) provides r03 to address Nokia's comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r04 based on r02. Hui (Huawei) provide r05. Jinguo (ZTE) provide r06. Hui (Huawei) fine with r06. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r07 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hui (Huawei) fine with r07. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007870 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion for C1 solutions on reducing packet loss. | Huawei, HiSilicon,ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007009R07, merging S2-2007243. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007011 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion for C4 solutions on supporting seamless edge relocation by 3GPP layer. | Huawei, HiSilicon, InterDigital Inc., Alibaba Group, ITRI | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui (Huawei) proposes the tdoc as baseline to conclude solution 39. === CC#2 === Shubhranshu (Nokia) objects to S2-2007011 Hui(Huawei) responses and think it's not fair to raise the technical questions in last day before deadline to a solution that has been included in the TR for half year. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) on pointing concerns to the conclusion paper S2-2007011 which only on Friday was indicated to be considered as baseline to conclude solution#39 Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) we also find these concerns are brought a bit late, and also want to point out we have already addressed some of them. Jicheol (Samsung) proposes to postpone this issue next meeting. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Ulises and asks why it is already a bit late to raise concerns to conclude solution 39 Hui(Huawei) replies to Shubhranshu. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hui(Huawei) proposes a way forward. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007012 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion for C5 solutions for KI#2 on other sub-issues. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007871. | Hui (Huawei) proposes the tdoc as baseline to conclude solution 26 and 40, and merge other parts into corresponding tdocs. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) provide r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007871 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion for C5 solutions for KI#2 on other sub-issues. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007012R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006856 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Interim Conclusion for KI#2. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461. === CC#2 === Hyunsook (LGE) accepts Rapporteur's suggestion. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2006924 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 conclusions on group 1. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007872. Postponed at CC#3 | Hui (Huawei) proposes the tdoc conclude solution 33 only, and merge other parts into corresponding tdocs. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) provide r01. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r02. Shubhranshu (Nokia) agrees to r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hui (Huawei) objects r02 and can only accept r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === Jicheol (Samsung) agree to propose this paper. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2007872 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 conclusions on group 1. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006924R01. WITHDRAWN at CC#3 | Withdrawn | |
| 8.3 | S2-2006925 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 conclusions on group 2. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2006926 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 conclusions on solution #35 and #35 for group 3. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007873. | Hui (Huawei) proposes the tdoc as baseline to conclude solution 35 and 36. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007873 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 conclusions on solution #35 and #35 for group 3. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006926R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007008 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | KI#2: Comparison of solutions for KI#2 and way forward. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005367 from S2#140E. Noted | Noted | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007133 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Conclusions Regarding Edge Relocation. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007133r16 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007460, to S2-2007923. | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as baseline to conclude option c of sub-issue 1-1. Fenqin (Huawei) proposes r01. Changhong (Intel) provides r02. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r03. Magnus (Ericsson) comments on the suggested NAS based approach to provide the new EAS IP address. Jinguo(ZTE) see the need for SoH at CC#2b Dario (Qualcomm) provides r05 (please ignore r04). Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Huazhang (vivo) ask question to Ericsson on 7133 Jinguo (ZTE) suggest that this paper to be handled together with 7461(EAS address via NAS signaling part) Fenqin (Huawei) comments Huazhang (Huawei) comments Jinguo (ZTE) response to Fenqin (Huawei) Fenqin (Huawei) Response to Jinguo (ZTE) Magnus (Ericsson) supports Jinuo's comments Jinguo(ZTE) agree the new question for SoH is not clear and ask further work on this paper Fenqin(Huawei) Responds. Changhong (Intel) objects r03, r04, r05 and r06. Jicheol (samsung) objects r00, r01 and r02 Dario (Qualcomm) can only accept r04, r05 and r06 Changhong (Intel) is fine with r04, r05 and r06 if Sol#34 is removed from conclusion part. Jinguo(ZTE) objects to r01-r06 and proposes to remove the first bullet in conclusion part as way foward === Phase 2 final deadline === Fenqin(Huawei) suggest to take this to CC Fenqin(Huawei) provides r07 Changhong (Intel) provides r08. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r09 with comments. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r10 with further update. Jicheol (Samsung) objects r07, r08 with reason for objection. Jicheol (Samsung) provides a link for r10. Dario (Qualcomm) is fine with r12 and r13 Magnus (Ericsson) can live with r13 for now Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) can live with r13 for now. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007923 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Conclusions Regarding Edge Relocation. | Ericsson, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007133R16. This P-CR was approved, merging S2-2007460 | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007242 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 Evaluation: Application Level Name Resolution Cache. | Futurewei, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 or S2-2007133. === CC#2 === John (Futurewei) agrees with merge into S2-2007133 (or S2-2007461). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007765 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2: Solution #55 Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007765r03 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007924. | Hui (Huawei) proposes the tdoc as baseline to conclude solution 55. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) provides r01. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) and provides S2-2007765r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hui (Huawei) objects r02 and proposed a way forward. Jinguo(ZTE) agree with Hui (Huawei) to focus on solution update in this meeting Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) and agrees to way forward Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Jinguo (ZTE) === Phase 2 final deadline === Hui (Huawei) provides draft r03 in draft folder. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) and OK with r03 === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007924 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2: Solution #55 Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007765R03. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007703 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI #2, Way Forward on Connecting the UE with the relocated edge application server. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) confirms that this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007243 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 Evaluation: Impact of In-network buffers. | Futurewei | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007870 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007009. === CC#2 === John (Futurewei) agrees with merging this tdoc into S2-2007009 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007249 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Way Forward of UE behaviour and responsibility in Edge Relocation. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into corresponding baseline papers for solutions. === CC#2 === Huazhang(vivo) agree to merge 7249 into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007250 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Evaluation and conclusion of providing New EAS IP address to UE . | Vivo, OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into corresponding baseline papers for solutions. === CC#2 === Huazhang(vivo) agree to merge 7250 into S2-2007461. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007251 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Evaluation and Conclusion of Edge relocation. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 or S2-2007133. === CC#2 === Huazhang (vivo) agree to merge into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007343 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, Evaluation and conclusion . | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === CC#2 === Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge this paper into S2-2007461 and S2-2007133. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007460 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion on UE based DNS cache renewal and EAS reselection. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007923 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc is merged into S2-2007133. Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as baseline to conclude option c of sub-issue 1-1. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) withdraw the previous comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007461 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion on AF based EAS re-discovery. | Huawei, Hisilicon, Toyota | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007461r11 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006856, S2-200692,5 S2-2007242, S2-2007249, S2-2007250, S2-2007251, S2-2007252, S2-2007343 and S2-2007703 to S2-2007925 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as baseline to conclude option a,b of sub-issue 1-1. === CC#2 === Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01 for option a,b of sub-issue 1-1. Yuan (CATT) is fine to merge S2-2007343 into this paper per rapporteur's suggestion. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02. Huazhang (vivo) provides r04. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) provides r05. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. Yuan (CATT) Responds. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r06. Huazhang (vivo) responds and provides r07 based on r06. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r08. Huazhang (vivo) responds and agree with r08. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) we can move forward with r08. Huazhang (vivo) objects to any version before show-hand of EAS discovery and provides r09 . Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) InterDigital objects to r09. Fenqin(Huawei) ask for clarification. Dan(China Mobile) propose to have a show of hands in CC3 Jicheol (Samsung) objects the concept of sending EAS IP via NAS and all its revisions. Jinguo(ZTE) see the need for SoH at CC#2b Fenqin (Huawei) responds.. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Thouraya (Orange) propose to have a show of hands in CC3 Jicheol (Samsung) comments. === Phase 2 final deadline === Fenqin (Huawei) provides r10 Huazhang (vivo) provides r11 based on r10 Magnus (Ericsson) is ok with r10 and r11 === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007925 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: Conclusion on AF based EAS re-discovery. | Huawei, Hisilicon, Toyota, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007461R11, merging S2-2006856, S2-200692,5 S2-2007242, S2-2007249, S2-2007250, S2-2007251, S2-2007252, S2-2007343 and S2-2007703. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007362 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 solution#27 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007874. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01 with merging some parts from S2-2007621. John (Futurewei) requests clarification re: packet loss Jinguo (ZTE) response to John (Futurewei) Hui (Huawei) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007874 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 solution#27 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE, Convida Wireless, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007362R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007621 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol #27 Evaluation and KI#2 Conclusion. | Intel, Tencent, China Telecom | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007875. | Hui (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as baseline to conclude solutions related to EAS IP replacement. === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) provides r01 based on Hui's suggestion. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provides r02 and r03 Changhong (Intel) proposes to go with r03. Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments and provides r04 Hui (Huawei) questions on the change in r04. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Hui (Huawei) Changhong (Intel) also questions on the change in r04 and disagree with the changes in r04. Changhong (Intel) replies to Shubhranshu's answer. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Shubhranshu (Nokia) agrees to r04 and objects to all previous revisions Changhong (Intel) comments to Shubhranshu's comments. Changhong (Intel) can live with r04 after offline talk to Shubharanshu. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007875 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol #27 Evaluation and KI#2 Conclusion. | Intel, Tencent, China Telecom, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007621R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#3 solutions (ordered by solution #) | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007474 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusions of solution 41. | Qualcomm Incorporated, ZTE, Futurewei | Rel-17 | Noted | Magnus H (Ericsson) makes a first comment Jinguo (ZTE) response to the first comment from Ericsson Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Magnus (Ericsson) Dario (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dario (Qualcomm) objects to r02 and r03 Magnus (Ericsson) objects to the original doc and r01 and is fine with r02 and r03 Laurent (Nokia) objects to the original doc and r01 and is fine with r02 and r03 === Phase 2 final deadline === Magnus (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007769 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI3: Update to Solution 42 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007363 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3 solution#49 update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007876. | Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Laurent (Nokia) is happy with any version but prefers r01 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007876 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3 solution#49 update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007363R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007247 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, New Sol: Network Information Provisioning to EAS with low latency based on L-NWDAF. | Vivo | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Lyu (vivo) withdrawn the 7247 === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Withdrawn |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#3 conclusions | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007013 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion of solutions for KI#3. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005368 from S2#140E. CC#3: S2-2007013r08 was technically endorsed and should be used as a basis for further work. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Hui (Huawei) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) provides r03 and add Intel as co-signer. Magnus (Ericsson) asks for a consistent evaluation criteria and provides r04 consistent with the argumentation in S2-2007474 === CC#2 === Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) proposes to merge 2007157 to 2007013 and provides r05 Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) proposes to update S2-2007013, r05, to reflect one of main principles of Sol#46 and provides r06 Hui(Huawei) fine with r06. Xiaobo Yu(Alibaba) provides r07. Magnus (Ericsson) is only ok with r04 and objects to r000-r03 andr05-r07. Hui (Huawei) objects r04 and prefer to r07. Jicheol (Samsung) prefer the approach r07, provides r08. Laurent (Nokia) provides r09 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dario (Qualcomm) prefers r07. NOTE: this paper was proposed for SoH in CC#2b. Magnus (Ericsson) is only ok with r04 and objects to r000-r03 and r05-r09. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) can accept r06-r09, and objects r03 Hui (Huawei) proposes to go with r07 or r08 based on the SoH results. Laurent (Nokia) Objects to any version of this Tdoc except to r09 === Phase 2 final deadline === Laurent (Nokia) confirms that he objects to r08 Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) as stated before, we can only accept r06-r09 for the same reasons that we already described. Magnus (Ericsson) objects to r08 and earlier version and can live with r09 for now Hui(Huawei) can live with r09. === CC#3 === Dan(China Mobile) comment Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) would like to co-sign this paper. === Close of e-meeting === | Endorsed |
| 8.3 | S2-2007126 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Way forward. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui (Huawei) objects to any version of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007719 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Conclusion on KI 3. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r01. === CC#2 === Hui (Huawei) objects to any version of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Zhuoyun (Tencent) comments. Hui (Huawei) responses. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2006999 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, evaluation and conclusion for KI#3. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007013r08 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge this contribution into S2-2007013. Yang (OPPO) is ok to merge === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007157 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, Interim conclusion for KI#3. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Hui (Huawei) objects to any revision of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007248 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Way Forward of Low Latency QoS monitoring. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007013r08 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge part or all of this contribution into S2-2007013. Lyu (vivo) agree to merge. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007473 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusions of solutions 42, 45 and 47. | Qualcomm Incorporated, FutureWei, ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui (Huawei) proposes this contribution focus on OAM based solutions. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Hui. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Laurent (Nokia) provides r02 Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r03. Dario (Qualcomm) is not OK with r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dario (Qualcomm) objects r02 and r03 Zhuoyun (Tencent) objects r01 and the original version. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r01 and the original version. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007494 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3: Evaluation and Conclusion on OAM based solutions. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007719. Noted | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge this contribution into S2-2007719. Zhuoyun (Tencent) is fine with merging this contribution into S2-2007719. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2007605 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3: Evaluation and interim conclusion. | Sony | Rel-17 | Covered by technically endorsed S2-2007013r08 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge this into S2-2007013. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any version of this Tdoc (for the sake of limiting the number of living paper as this can be merged to 70131° Lars (Sony) We are ok to merge this into S2-2007013 to have one common conclusion paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#5 solutions | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007704 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#5, Solution#12 solution update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007877 | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge this contribution into S2-2007128. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Hui. Hui (Huawei) replies to Laurent. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Hui. Solution#12 is to be split up as the 2 procedures are very different Hui (Huawei) replies. Jinguo(ZTE) ask for comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Tingfang and asks for clarification to S2-2007704 Jinguo answer toTingfang Tang (Lenovo) . Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Tingfang (Lenovo) Huazhang (vivo) don't agree with 7704 Jinguo(ZTE) is fine to use 7770 as basis. Hui (Huawei) proposes to stop the discussion in this thread, consider the pCR is merged into S2-2007770. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) agrees to merge 7704 into 7770 and to further discuss in that thread. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007770 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI# 5: solution 12 update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007704, to S2-2007877. | Hui (Huawei) proposes to merge this contribution into S2-2007128. Hui (Huawei) withdraw the previous comments, and proposes to take this as baseline for solution 12 update (KI#2/#5 part). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides S2-2007770r01 Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides S2-2007770r01 (resending with typo correction) === CC#2 === Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03 Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) and provides r04 Fenqin (Huawei) replies Shubhranshu (Nokia). Fenqin (Huawei) responds Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provides r05 Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Tingfang (Lenovo) and provides r06 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies and provides r07 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007877 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI# 5: solution 12 update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, ZTE, Ericsson, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007770R07, merging S2-2007704. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007364 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5 Sol#12 and Sol#50 update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007878 | Hui (Huawei) suggests to merge this contribution into S2-2007462 and S2-2007128. Jinguo(ZTE) response. Laurent (Nokia): answers to Jinguo Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies. Jinguo(ZTE) response to Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Jinguo (ZTE) Hui (Huawei) proposes to stop the discussion in this thread, consider the pCR is merged into S2-2007462(sol#50), S2-2007128(sol#12 general/KI#1 part) and S2-2007770(sol#12 KI#2/5 part). Laurent (Nokia): we support the split proposed by the rapporteur below === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2007462 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5: Solution 50 update and evaluation/conclusion of KI#5. | Huawei, HiSilicon, | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007364, to S2-2007878. | Hui (Huawei) suggests to take this contribution as baseline for solution 50 update. Fenqin (Huawei) update the contribution and provides r01 Jinguo (ZTE) provides r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007878 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5: Solution 50 update and evaluation/conclusion of KI#5. | Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007462R02, merging S2-2007364. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#5 conclusions | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007365 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE, CATT, China Mobile | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007768, to S2-2007879. | Hui (Huawei) suggests to take S2-2007365 as baseline for KI#5 evaluation and conclusion since it has more co-signers, and merge S2-2007768 and conclusion/evaluation part of S2-2007462 into S2-2007365. Shubhranshu (Nokia) is OK to Hui (Huawei) suggestions and provides S2-2007365r01 Jinguo (ZTE) provides r02 to simplify the text. Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r03. Yuan (CATT) comments and provides r04. Shubhranshu (Nokia) asks for clarification to Fenqin (Huawei) on r03 Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Yuan Tao (CATT) on r04 Yuan (CATT) replies to Shubhranshu (Nokia) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yuan Tao (CATT) replies to Shubhranshu (Nokia) === CC#2 === Fenqin (Huawei) responds to Shubhranshu (Nokia) Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds to CATT and provides v05 Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) Fenqin (Huawei) responds to Shubhranshu (Huawei) Jinguo (ZTE) comments Shubhranshu (Nokia) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides revision. I am fine with r06 provided by Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r07 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2007879 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE, CATT, China Mobile, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007365R07, merging S2-2007768. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2007768 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #5: Conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007879 | Hui (Huawei) suggests to merge this contribution into S2-2007365. Shubhranshu (Nokia) is OK to Hui (Huawei) suggestion to merge S2-2007768 into S2-2007365 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Study on Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 2 (FS_eNS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=97 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007180 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | FS_eNS_Ph2 Moderated Discussions on 5GC and EPC interworking support for quota management support for maximum numbers of PDU Sessions . | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007181 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | FS_eNS_Ph2 Moderated Discussions on Max. UEs and Max. PDU Sessions Quota Management support according to access types . | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007182 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | FS_eNS_Ph2 Moderated Discussions on Operator Controlled on UE's Behaviour on Slicing Access . | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006816 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on Enhancement of RAN Slicing | RAN WG3 (R3-205802) | Rel-17 | Response drafted in S2-2007328. Final response in S2-2008240 | Replied to | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007328 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on Enhancement of RAN Slicing | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2006816. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008240. | Alessio (Nokia) provides r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications Tricci (ZTE) provided r02 for some rewording and agreed with Stefano's comment to restore the e2e slicing aspect in LSout. Alessio(Nokia) provides a response to Stefano Tricci (ZTE) proposes r04 with minor additional wordings to have a more complete response. Alessio(Nokia) can only accept r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Tao(Chair) Do not see follow up discussion. People ok with r03 (not shown in Notes) ? Jinguo(ZTE) is fine with r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008240 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on Enhancement of RAN Slicing | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007328R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006879 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1: Evaluation and Interim conclusion of KI#1. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | Dan (China Mobile) provides comments and propose the NOTE this paper which does not help to conclude the key issue1 Sangsoo (Samsung) provides response to CMCC. Jinguo(ZTE) propose to merge this paper with 7555 Sangsoo (Samsung) is fine to merge 6879 into other baseline paper (possibly 7555) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006878 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Partial conclusion on KI #1 and KI #2 . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005553 from S2#140E Merged into S2-2008242 | George (Ericsson) propose to note this. The conclusion is captured. Solution 38 is missing as well. Jinguo (ZTE) propose to merge this P-CR into 7555 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) is fine to merge 6878 into 7555 Tricci (ZTE) corrects the baseline tdoc# is 7553 and NOT 7555 for KI#1. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006886 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, New Sol: Registration via multiple access networks . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Kaisu (Nokia): Nokia comments on one aspect of the solution. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Kaisu (Nokia). Gerald (Matrixx) suggest a revision to more specific reference for NF. George (Ericsson) provides a comment Jinguo (ZTE) propose to note this paper. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Gerald (Matrixx), George (Ericsson) and Jinguo (ZTE). Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Fenqin (Huawei). Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) and provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Gerald (Matrixx) provided r02 with adjustments on quota management. Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r02. Jinguo(ZTE) thanks Hoyeon (Samsung) and still have conern to agree this solution Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Jinguo(ZTE) and provides r03. Kaisu (Nokia) comments, has concerns about double counting. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) asks question to Hoyeon. Kaisu (Nokia) answers to Hoyeon. We don't agree to include this proposal into the interim conclusion for KI#1. Hoyeon (Samsung) thinks we can update evaluation/conclusion at the next meeting. George (Ericsson) does not agree with an explicit conclusion counting twice until we have a clear requirement from GSMA. At minimum this has to be policy based. It is very reasonable that some may count twice, some may not count twice. SO we are not Ok with this revision mandating one option. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Hoyeon. Tao(Chair) I see discussion not comfortable with the conclusion but some are targeting to next meeting. I still use 'r03' as the target for approval, if you have problem with that. Please indicate it clearly. Kaisu (Nokia) proposes to note the document. === Phase 2 final deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question to all interested parties and suggests to make a clear direction on the work plan. Alessio(Nokia) comments that there is no input we still need to receive from GSMA === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007322 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1: Conclusions on the enforced actions. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | George (Ericsson): Ericsson provides r01. We are not OK with the notification. Kaisu (Nokia) asks Ericsson for clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) asks for clarification. Jinguo (ZTE) propose to merge with 2007555 or others. Genadi (Lenovo) agrees to merge with 2007555. Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Gerald (Matrixx). Genadi (Lenovo) responds to the proposal from George (Ericsson). We do not agree with r01. Iskren (NEC) asks question. Genadi (Lenovo) comments regarding the notification to AF and particular to Iskren (NEC). Iskren (NEC) comments regarding the notification to AF requirement addition to KI#1 Gerald (Matrixx) advise a refinement based on more details on UE registration charging. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) asks questions to Gerald for clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Iskren (NEC) regarding the notification to AF requirement addition to KI#1 Dan (China Mobile) provide r02 and do not agree with the charging part Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to merge this paper into 7555 again. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) suggest to merge this paper into 7553 instead as 7553 is planned to be used a baseline document for KI#1. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) supports DoCoMo/ZTE to use 7553 as a baseline for KI#1 discussion. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007366 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | George (Ericsson): Ericsson object to using this pCR as a basis for the TR. Please see comments Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and disagrees on the evaluation of Sol#4 and Sol#9. Jinguo response to Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jinguo(ZTE) agree to merge this paper into 7553 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006881 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Updates to Architecture Requirements to consider EPS/5GS interworking . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2008241. | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01. Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification about the quota for UEs number. Jinguo(ZTE) response to Hyunsook (LGE). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 Dan (China Mobile) is OK with r01 and r02 Samsung (Hoyeon) provides r03. Gerald (Matrixx) proposed refinements in r04. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r05. Jinguo (ZTE) provides r06. Sangsoo (Samsung) provides r07. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Fenqin (Huawei) comment Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments === CC#2 === Alessio (Nokia) agrees with Fenqin (Huawei) Alessio(Nokia) provides r07. Alessio(Nokia) provides r08. Jinguo(ZTE) asks Alessio(Nokia) for clarification. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) objects to r02, r05, r06. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008241 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Updates to Architecture Requirements to consider EPS/5GS interworking . | China Mobile, Ericsson, Samsung, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006881R08. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006884 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Thought on EPC interworking support. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Jinguo (ZTE) propose to note Patrice (Huawei) supports noting the document. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007185 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, 2 &5, Sol#19: Update the solution to support roaming scenario. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007553 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #1 solution evaluation . | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r32 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006878, S2-2007322, S2-2007366, S2-2007463, S2-2007555, S2-2006879, S2-2007632, to S2-2008242. | George (Ericsson). This is a reasonable evaluation to include in the pCR. It can also include elements from the evaluation part of S2-2007493. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 as a basis for evaluation and interim conclusion for KI#1. George (Ericsson) ask for clarification. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 and clarifications to George (Ericsson). Kaisu (Nokia) provides r03, where evaluations have been edited. Fenqin (Huawei) Comments. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 and agrees on questions raised by Fenqin for clarification for r03 proposed by NOKIA. Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r05. Sangsoo (Samsung) comments and provides r06. Kaisu (Nokia) comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r07 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides feedbacks to Kaisu. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r08. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r09. Jinguo (ZTE) provides a clean version in r10. George (Ericsson) provide r10. Please see comments: Jinguo(ZTE) ask George (Ericsson) to provide r11 Fenqin (Huawei) comments: George (Ericsson) provides r12. Please see comments. My r10 got hijacked. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provide r13 === CC#2 === George (Ericsson) provides r14. Please see comments. Kaisu (Nokia) provides r15. Please see comments. Iskren (NEC) provides r16. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r17. George (Ericsson) provides response. We are OK with r16. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r18 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r19 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r20 George (Ericsson) provides r2. George (Ericsson) provides r21. Typo, resend Gerald (Matrixx) correct implications of SOL#38 and add refinements on quota management usage in r22. George (Ericsson) provides r23. Just accepted everything. A clean revision Gerald (Matrixx) with some editorial refinements on consistency in r24. Jinguo(ZTE) says there is no difference between r23 and r24. Gerald (Matrixx) clarifies the delta and with update on quota determination in r25. Sangsoo (Samsung) provides r26 on the top of r22 (as r25 still not shows the track changes) Fenqin(Huawei) provides r27 Gerald (Matrixx) object the wording on local quota in r27. Gerald (Matrixx) clarifies the wrong statement on revisions. Jinguo(ZTE) suggests Gerald (Matrixx) to build new version for the update. Fenqin(Huawei) responds Gerald (Matrixx) provided the finetuning in r28 as suggested. Fenqin (Huawei) provided r29. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r30. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r31. Krisztian (Apple) provides r32: adding Apple as co-signer and fixing some editorials. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Srisakul(NTT DOCOMO) responds to Fenqin. Fenqin(Huawei) responds to Srisakul. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Fenqin. Gerald (Matrixx) provided further comments on quota management with a concern on conclusion for NS quota storage functionality. Sangsoo (Samsung) objects to r00 ~ r25, suggests to agree r30. Fenqin (Huawei) responds Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to agree with r32. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) is Ok with r30, r31 and r32. Object to all earlier reversions as the content was premature. Kaisu (Nokia) agrees with DCM view: we are ok with r30, r31 and r32 and reject earlier reversions. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008242 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #1 solution evaluation and interim conclusions. | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, ZTE, NEC, Huawei, Ericsson. Matrixx, Samsung, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007553R32, merging S2-2006878, S2-2007322, S2-2007366, S2-2007463, S2-2007555, S2-2006879, S2-2007632. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007463 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1: Evaluation and Conclusion of solutions proposed for KI#1. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Mobile, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | George (Ericsson): Ericsson object to using this pCR as a basis for the TR. Please see comments Kaisu (Nokia): Nokia disagrees with some of the conclusions in this pCR. Please see comments. Jinguo (ZTE) ask clarification to Kaisu (Nokia) and George (Ericsson) Iskren (NEC) disagrees with the evaluation in this pCR, especially with the centralised v/s distributed quota management analysis. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to merge this paper into 7553 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007555 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #1 Interim Conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | Fenqin (Huawei) Comments and suggest to merge this contribution into 7553 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) agrees to merge 7555 into 7553 as suggested by Fenqin. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007632 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1 Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | NEC, Apple | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008242 | Dan (China Mobile) disagree with the conclusion === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Iskren (NEC): parts of the evaluation were merged to the baseline paper S2-2007553. It now can be marked as merged to S2-2007553. Vimal (Cisco) responds to NEC/Apple === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007533 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, KI#2: postponed solution: Operator controlled UE behaviour. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T, CMCC | Rel-17 | Noted | Vimal (Cisco) responds to Nokia/AT&T Patrice (Huawei) comments that this contribution is not within the scope of eNS phase 2 study, is changing fundamental aspects of 5GS, and should be noted (we object to all revisions). Alessio(Nokia) comments on Patrice comments Genadi (Lenovo) has concerns with the proposal. Alessio(Nokia) provides a response to Genadi and R01 Genadi (Lenovo) provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) can live with R02. Patrice (Huawei) replies to the comments from Alessio(Nokia). Alessio(Nokia) refutes the arguments by HUAWEI === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to note this pCR (any revision). Alessio(Nokia) would kindly ask Samsung to write why the introduction or this paper that says it is in scope is incorrect. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the P-CR. Alessio(Nokia) responds this is related to attributes #of UE/slice and #of PDU session slice. So it is in scope Patrice (Huawei) maintains his objection to this contribution S2-2007533 (all versions). === Phase 2 final deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) provides response. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007536 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2: updated solution 6. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007464 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2: Evaluation and Conclusion of solutions proposed for KI#2. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Mobile, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2007559 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007323 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2: Conclusions on the enforced actions. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) provide comments and do not agree with the charging part === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Gerald (Matrixx) suggest to note this contribution because 7559 already covers the basics. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2006880 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #2: Evaluation and Interim conclusion of KI#2. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation to S2-2007559 Sangsoo (Samsung) is okay to merge this paper into S2-2007559. ? === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006857 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Sol#32: Update to remove EN. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006858 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Interim Conclusion for KI#2. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | George (Ericsson) Ericsson Objects to this pCR. Premature conclusion === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hyunsook (LGE) think it is merged into S2-2007559 and discussed based on Rapporteur's suggestion. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006874 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Solution 6.6 updates with considering EPS/5GS interworking. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005211 from S2#140E. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007367 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and disagrees on the evaluation of Sol#5 and Sol#9. Propose to merge into S2-2007559. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jinguo (ZTE) agree to merge into 7559 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007493 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1,2, Evaluation and conclusions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Alessio(Nokia): submits r01 George (Ericsson): Ericsson provide r02. The text onN3PP is incorrect and too broad. Gerald (Matrixx) supports this conclusion provided in r02. Jinguo(ZTE) cannot agree this document and suggest to focus on evaluation on each solution Fenqin (Huawei) object to using this pCR as a basis for the TR. Please see comments. George (Ericsson) provides a response on the roaming part. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to merge this paper into 7559 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007559 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #2 solution evaluation . | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r20 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006858, S2-2007367, S2-2007464, S2-2007493, S2-2007560, S2-2007635 and S2-2006880, to S2-2008243 | Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === George (Ericsson ) provides r03. Iskren (NEC) provides r04. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06. Gerald (Matrixx) correct implications of SOL#38 in r04 and ask questions for clarification on quota check. Gerald (Matrixx) correct implications of SOL#38 with r07 which are added so far and ask question for clarification on quota check. George (Ericsson) provides r8. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r10. Gerald (Matrixx) provided some more corrections in rev11. George (Ericsson) proved rev12. Added Ericsson name. Please don't jump revisions. It creates issues. Jinguo (ZTE) provide r13 Sangsoo (Samsung) provide r14 Gerald (Matrixx) provided r15 with alignment on quota determination to 7553 for KI#1. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r16. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r17. Gerald (Matrixx) agree on the removal of 'global quota vs local quota' which needs to be done in 7553 for KI#1 as well. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides r18. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r19. Krisztian (Apple) provides r20: adding Apple as co-signer and fixing some editorials. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) objects to r00 ~ r15, suggests to agree r18. Gerald (Matrixx) recommend the agreement of r15, based on the provided r14 by Samsung, which removed the concern on multiple NW slice management functionalities. Fenqin (Huawei) suggests to agree r20. Tao(Chair) it is not converge with latest two email since Sangsoo object r15 and Gerald recommend r15. I would still use r20 as the target for approval as shown in the chairman notes. It is the latest and I did not seen objection to it. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) is Ok with r18, r19 and r20. Object to all earlier reversions as the content was premature. Kaisu (Nokia) agrees with DCM view: we are ok with r18, r19 and r20 and reject earlier reversions. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008243 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #2 solution evaluation and interim conclusions. | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, NEC, Matrixx, Ericsson, ZTE, Samsung, Huawei, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007559R20, merging S2-2006858, S2-2007367, S2-2007464, S2-2007493, S2-2007560, S2-2007635 and S2-2006880. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007560 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #2 Interim Conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Fenqin (Huawei) Comments and suggest to merge this contribution into 7559 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) agrees to merge 7560 into 7559 as suggested by Fenqin. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007635 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2 Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | NEC, Apple | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008243 | Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 to use S2-2007635 (from NEC, Apple) as the baseline document to merge all evaluations for KI#2 Fenqin (Huawei) comments Tricci (ZTE) responds to Huawei to suggest that we can use S2-2007635 to complement S2-2007559. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2007559 Iskren (NEC) agrees with Tricci (ZTE) to consider this pCR merged with S2-2007559 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007537 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3: updated solution 22 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008244. | Haiyang(Huawei) provides r01. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008244 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3: updated solution 22 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007537R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006887 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol #37: Update to remove ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008245. | Haiyang (Huawei) comments and seeks for clarification. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Haiyang (Huawei). Haiyang (Huawei) further comments. === CC#2 === Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r01. Haiyang (Huawei) thanks for the update and asks one more question. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to postpone this pCR. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides clarification. Haiyang (Huawei) can accept r01 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008245 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol #37: Update to remove ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006887R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007668 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Solution 13 update for KI#3. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | LATE DOC: Rx 03/10 10:30. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008246. | Jinguo (ZTE) asks question for clarification Heng Nie (China Telecom) provides clarification and r01 Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification Heng Nie (China Telecom) offer clarification === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008246 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Solution 13 update for KI#3. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007668R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006844 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3: Evaluation update . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: There was no agreement on r10 or r11 and S2-2006844 was noted. | Haiyang(Huawei) provides r01 as the merge of 7779, 7687, 7368 and 7517 === CC#2 === Heng Nie(China Telecom) provide comment for impact on NF Discovery and selection. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies to Heng (China Telecom) Hoyeon (Samsung) comments and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies and provides r04 Hoyeon (Samsung) objects to r00, r01 and r04, provides r05. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r06. Alessio(nokia) provides r07 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r08 Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Haiyang (Huawei) responses === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Haiyang (Huawei) and comments that the evaluation text is not valid. Hoyeon (Samsung) objects to r06, r07 and r08 as the revisions include invalid/incomplete evaluation. Haiyang (Huawei) objects the revisions which include IWK support, i.e. r02, r03 and r05. Suggests to go with r08 moving the NF Selection part Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to remove the URLLC part? Haiyang (Huawei) agrees with Jinguo (ZTE). Belen (Ericsson) asks ZTE for new updates. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r07, r06, r05 and prefers r01. Belen (Ericsson) provides r10. Ericsson objects to other revisions, except r05 that needs minor updates. Nokia cannot agree to a new r10. Also cannot agree to r05. Jinguo(ZTE) asks can we go r08 with some wording changes as suggested by Belen: Alessio(Nokia) can accept the compromise by ZTE: otherwise we can just note this. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2006845 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3: Conclusion for the solutions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008248. | Belen (Ericsson) provides to note this contribution. Ericsson objects to this contribution. Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification from Belen (Ericsson) Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies and provide r01 as a merger of conclusion Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to postpone KI conclusion to the next meeting, and OK with r03 as r03 doesn't include any conclusion. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008248 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3: Conclusion for the solutions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006845R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007120 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 - Evaluation and Interim Conclusions . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revised to contain KI#3 conclusions in S2-2007681 | Revised | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007681 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusions . | Ericsson, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007120. Revised, merging S2-2006888, to S2-2007779. | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2006844 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2007779 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusions . | Ericsson, Apple, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007681, merging S2-2006888. Covered by S2-2006844. Noted | Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 6844. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2006888 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3: Evaluation and Interim conclusion of KI#3. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007779 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2006844 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007687 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation update on Solutions of KI#3. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2006844. Noted | Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 6844. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007368 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2006844. Noted | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2006844 Haiyang(Huawei) corrects the number in the title and proposes to merge this paper into 6844. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007517 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Evaluation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2006844. Noted | Alessio(Nokia): submits r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 6844. === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) supports Samsung to merge this paper into S2-2006844. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2006889 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #4: Evaluation and Interim conclusion of KI#4. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008247 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this paper with S2-2007369 which is used as the baseline for evaluation for KI#4 Hoyeon (Samsung) is fine to merge this paper with S2-2007369 which is used as the baseline for evaluation for KI#4 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2006846 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4: Evaluation and Conclusion of solutions proposed for KI#4. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008247 | Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and asks questions before providing a revision. Iskren (NEC) comments - this pCR is not acceptable for baseline. The solution principles table does not demonstrate understanding of the solutions and understanding the independence from KI#1 to KI#5 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Tricci (ZTE) asks for suggestions on how to proceed to evaluate KI#4 Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments to Tricci (ZTE). Tricci (ZTE) thanks Genadi (Lenovo) for the suggestion. Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Yunjing (CATT) provides comments. Haiyang (Huawei) responses. === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) confirms that this paper will be merged into S2-2007369 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007184 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #4: Evaluation and conclusion. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008247 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this paper with S2-2007369 which is used as the baseline for evaluation for KI#4 Yunjing (CATT) is fine to merge this paper with S2-2007369. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007369 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006846, S2-2006889 and S2-2007184, to S2-2008247. | Haiyang(Huawei) proposes to merge this paper into 6844. === CC#2 === Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r01 (6889 is merged into 7369) Jinguo (ZTE) correct the title and fine with r01 Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provide r02 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r03 Jinguo (Jinguo) provides r04 Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r05 to decouple the NF for event subscription/notification from the NF for quota management for now. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) is ok with r01, r02 and r05. Object to r00, r03 and r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008247 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007369R05, merging S2-2006846, S2-2006889 and S2-2007184. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006873 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation and conclusion on KI#5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008249 | Tricci (ZTE) propose that this paper to be merged into S2-2007121 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007121 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 - Evaluation and Interim Conclusions . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007449, S2-2007524, S2-2006873 and S2-2007370, to S2-2008249. | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 proposing a merge as suggeted by rapporteur === CC#2 === Susan (Huawei) provides r02. Sangsoo (Samsung) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Susan (Huawei) asks for clarification on the removal of some conclusion principles. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r05 Susan (Huawei) provides r06. Alessio(nokia) provides r07. Susan (Huawei) replies to Alessio. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) objects to r00, r01, r02, and r07. Susan (Huawei) objects to r00, r01, and r07. Tao(Chair) Can we fallback and approve r06 then? I use r06 as the target for approval. Let people know if you have problem with it. Alessio(Nokia) can only accept R07. R06 is technically unacceptable. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r07, also with r05. Ericsson objects to r06 Tao(Chair) Alessio, do you also object other earlier versions? Can we try other earlier version, r03, r04, r05? Any chance or proposed way forward? Jinguo(ZTE) proposes to further work on an acceptable version and discuss at CC#3. Alessio(Nokia) responds to the chair that unfortunately the revisions before r07 are technically flawed Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to go with r05 with removing one sentence in conclusion part. Alessio(Nokia) could live with R07 with the conclusion clause taken away if that could help. Nokia cannot accept also other parts of r05 conclusion ... so please consider taking R07 with no conclusion caluse. Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with r07 without conclusion clause. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r07 without conclusions, but the evaluation still needs some work for next meeting. Susan (Huawei) can live with r07 without conclusions for this meeting, but hope some companies could be constructive in the future meeting and provide their explanation for objection to a revision. === Phase 2 final deadline === Sangsoo (Samsung) can live with r07 without conclusions in this meeting. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008249 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 - Evaluation and Interim Conclusions . | Ericsson, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007121R07, merging S2-2007449, S2-2007524, S2-2006873 and S2-2007370. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007122 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Slice MBR enforcement | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Haiyang(Huawei) comments and suggests to discuss together with 7485 === CC#2 === Alessio(nokia) proposes to mark this LS as noted and use S2-2007485 instead === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tao (Chair) check to NOTE this one is ok for Belen === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007280 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Slice MBR attribute definition | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) provides r01 Patrice (Huawei) provides r02, simplifying some of the wording without changing the intention. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Alessio(Nokia) objects to sending this LS out Tao(Chair) I do not see convergence of this LS then === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007370 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008249 | Tricci (ZTE) confirms that this paper will be merged into S2-2007121 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007449 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 evaluation and conclusion. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008249 | Dan(China Mobile) suggests to merge this paper in S2-2007121 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007524 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #5, interim Evaluation and conclusions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008249 | Tricci (ZTE) propose that this paper to be merged into S2-2007121 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007726 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#27: Solution #27 clarification update. | NEC | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008250. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Iskren (NEC) answers Peter (Ericsson) and provides r02 Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification, requests an update. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Patrice (Huawei) and provides r03. Iskren (NEC) updates further to clarify the operation modes and provides r04. Patrice (Huawei) thanks Iskren(NEC) for the clarifications and update, ask for another clarification. Iskren (NEC) answers question from Patrice (Huawei). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008250 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#27: Solution #27 clarification update. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007726R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007316 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6, New Solution: Ensuring network control of simultaneous access to network slices with application awareness. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Hoyeon (Samsung) expresses concerns on this new solution and asks a question for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) share the same concern and object to this paper Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to LGE. Patrice (Huawei) supports Samsung and ZTE and objects to the paper. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei and a r01. Patrice (Huawei) provides further comments, unfortunately cannot accept the update. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to note the PCR. Patrice (Huawei) maintains his objection to S2-2007316 (all versions). === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007081 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6, Solution#41: Removal of ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2008251. | George (Ericsson): Ericsson asking clarification. Patrice (Huawei) replies to George (Ericsson)'s question. George (Ericsson) requests additional clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) asks for clarification on the solution === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Patrice (Huawei) answers George(Ericsson)'s question. Patrice (Huawei) answers Jinguo(ZTE)'s question. George (Ericsson) request additional clarification. George (Ericsson) replaces his comments with a new one. Patrice (Huawei) clarifies further. Patrice (Huawei) provides r02. Alessio(nokia) provides r03 with questions embedded as editor's notes. George (Ericsson) has additional questions. . Patrice (Huawei) answers the further questions. Patrice (Huawei) provides r04 and answers the questions in the editor's notes. George (Ericsson) provides r05 with some editor notes that require clarification. George (Ericsson) Why are all these details in an email and not in the solution description? Patrice (Huawei) provides r06 answering the questions from George (Ericsson). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008251 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6, Solution#41: Removal of ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007081R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006885 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6, New Sol: Interworking support. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Jinguo (ZTE) propose to Note this new solution. Alessio(Nokia) comments we should draw a line on EPS interworking efforts in eNS_Ph2 , would politely request to not proceed with this new solution Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment. Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK to discuss such logic once we conclude the key issue first. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007539 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6: updated solution 28. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008252. | Patrice (Huawei) comments, requests an update. Alessio(Nokia) provides answers and an update in r01 providing further clarity based on comments Patrice (Huawei) answers Alessio(Nokia)'s comments, provides r02. Alessio(nokia) can live with r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008252 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6: updated solution 28. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007539R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007582 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6: Update Solution #17: Support of radio spectrum attribute by CN assisted RAN control. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008253. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and a clarification that update is for solution #17 that is for KI#7 and not KI#6. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008253 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7: Update Solution #17: Support of radio spectrum attribute by CN assisted RAN control. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007582R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2006904 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6: Evaluation on the solutions . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008254. CC#4: S2-2008254 was withdrawn and S2-2007332 postponed. This was marked as postponed. | George (Ericsson): Ericsson provides comments below. We don't agree to use this pCR as a basis in the TR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007332 which is used as the baseline for merging the evaluation for KI#6. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2006947 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6: Update to solution 40 - Associated-Identifiers. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === George (Ericsson) provides response Patrice (Huawei) proposes to further discuss the questions as part of the evaluation effort, can accept r00 in the meantime. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2007092 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Evaluation and Conclusion. | NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008254. CC#4: S2-2008254 was withdrawn and S2-2007332 postponed. This was marked as postponed. | George (Ericsson): Ericsson object to the CR. Very subjective evaluation/conclusion and actually shows lack of understanding of some solutions. Not acceptable to Ericsson as a basis for inclusion in the TR. See more comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Iskren (NEC): S2-2007092 can now be marked as merged to the baseline evaluation paper S2-2007332 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2007332 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 evaluation and conclusion. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r15 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006904, S2-2007092, S2-2007371 and S2-2007527, to S2-2008254. CC#4: Postponed | George (Ericsson): Ericsson provides comments. Not acceptable to Ericsson as a basis for inclusion in the TR. Alessio (Nokia) provides r01 George (Ericsson) provides r02 Iskren (NEC) provides r03 Tricci (ZTE) provides r04 to make the evaluations to be more like solution principles format. Alessio (nokia) comments and cannot accept r03 Iskren (NEC) comments and cannot accept r01 and r02 Tricci (ZTE) suggests a mutually respectful way forward for merging. George (Ericsson) provides r05 updating solution 40. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Iskren (NEC) provides r06 with updates to solution 27. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r07 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r08 Iskren (NEC) provides r09 Patrice (Huawei) provides r10. Iskren (NEC) provides r11. Alessio (nokia) provide r12. Patrice (Huawei) comments that r12 seems to have been based inadvertently on r09. Provides r13 reinserting the comments in r10. Alessio (nokia) provides r14. Iskren (NEC) provides r15. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) have comments on r15, but ok to agree r15 now and fix the table at the next meeting. Patrice (Huawei) objects to r00~r09, r12, r14~15. Can only accept r10~r11, r13. Could accept r15 if the following cyan-highlighted statement is removed from sol#28: 'but these are not is scope of KI#6'. === Phase 2 final deadline === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Still proposes to accept r15 and further progress the KI at the next meeting. === CC#3 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei and proposes a way forward. === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2008254 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 evaluation and conclusion. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007332R15, merging S2-2006904, S2-2007092, S2-2007371 and S2-2007527. CC#4: Withdrawn | Withdrawn | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007371 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 evaluation and conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008254. CC#4: S2-2008254 was withdrawn and S2-2007332 postponed. This was marked as postponed. | George (Ericsson): Ericsson provides comments. Not acceptable to Ericsson as a basis for inclusion in the TR. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007332 which is used as the baseline for merging the evaluation for KI#6. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2007527 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6, interim Evaluations and conclusions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008254. CC#4: S2-2008254 was withdrawn and S2-2007332 postponed. This was marked as postponed. | Alessio(Nokia): submits r01 George (Ericsson): Ericsson provides r02. See additional comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007332 which is used as the baseline for merging the evaluation for KI#6. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2007540 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: updated solution 29. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008255. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions. Jinguo(ZTE) asks questions. Genadi (Lenovo) asks a question for clarification. Alessio(Nokia) provides clarifications Alessio(Nokia) responds to Jinguo(ZTE) Jinguo(ZTE) ask further clarification to Alessio(Nokia) Mike (Convida Wireless) responds to Jinguo (ZTE) Jinguo(ZTE) response to Mike (Convida Wireless) Alessio(Nokia) replies Alessio (Nokia) replies to Jinguo(ZTE) Jinguo(ZTE) response to Alessio (Nokia) Alessio (Nokia) responds to Jinguo(ZTE) Genadi (Lenovo) responds to Jinguo (ZTE). Jinguo(ZTE) response to Genadi (Lenovo) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Alessio( Nokia) +1 to Genadi (Lenovo) responds to Jinguo (ZTE). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides same questions before. === CC#2 === Alessio (nokia ) responds as before Peter Hedman (Ericsson) propose the solution description should be updated according to the clarification. Alessio (nokia ) provides r02 (after having submitted a wrong r01) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008255 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: updated solution 29. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007540R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007542 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: updated solution 31. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, | Rel-17 | Noted | Iskren (NEC) suggest to note this pCR as it is an unacceptable change to solution 31. There is another pCR (S2-2007764) that fixes the misalignment between the Figure and the text. Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to note this pCR Alessio(Nokia) is ok to note this paper but will not agree to adoption of solution 31 for normative work. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007330 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, New Sol: Compatibility of S-NSSAIs operating frequency bands with UE Radio Capabilities. | Qualcomm Incorporated, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r01 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007956. | Alessio (nokia) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Patrice (Huawei) objects to r01, and can only accept the original version. === Phase 2 final deadline === Alessio (Nokia) cannot accept r00, for avoidance of doubt Alessio (Nokia) observes TAO notes asked in the notes whether to approve r01 and Patrice objected === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2007956 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, New Sol: Compatibility of S-NSSAIs operating frequency bands with UE Radio Capabilities. | Qualcomm Incorporated, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007330R01. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007764 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#31: Solution #31 update. | NEC | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008257. | Alessio (nokia) proposes to NOTE this P-CR Iskren (NEC) addresses comment from Alessio (Nokia) and proposes r01 to align the text with the Figure. Alessio(Nokia) comments he cannot accept r01 as it is actually worse than r00 Iskren(NEC) addresses comments from Alessio (Nokia) and provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008257 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#31: Solution #31 update. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007764R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007554 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: updated solution 17. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008258. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 moving the proposal into a new solution. Alessio(nokia) responds === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a proposed way forward. Patrice (Huawei) comments, requires an update. Alessio(nokia) responds and provides r02 Alessio(nokia) responds to Patrice and provides R03 Patrice (Huawei) thanks Alessio(Nokia) for the update, accepts r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008258 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: new solution based on 17. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007554R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007372 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7, Sol#44 update . | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Patrice (Huawei) comments, requests an update. Alessio(Nokia) does not think this solution update is required. Proposed to note all revisions unless a justification fo the update is provided. Jinguo (ZTE) respose to Alessio(Nokia) and Patrice (Huawei) Patrice (Huawei) further asks for clarification. Jinguo (ZTE) reply to Patrice (Huawei) Patrice (Huawei) thanks Jinguo(ZTE) for taking the time to address his comments, is OK with the contribution. Iskren (NEC) comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Alessio(Nokia) responds to Jinguo (ZTE) and unless further justification is provided this paper should be noted. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to approve original version. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2007308 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7, evaluation and interim conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008259 | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge the evaluation of this paper with S2_2007337 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok to mark it as merged into S2-2007337 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.4 | S2-2007337 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Evaluation and Conclusion. | Convida Wireless LLC, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | r22 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007308, to S2-2008259. | Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and r01. Mike (Convida Wireless) provides comments and r02. Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications. Genadi (Lenovo) provides proposals for the conclusions in r03. Mike (Convida) replies to Tricci (ZTE). Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r04. Mike (Convida Wireless) provides r05 and replies to Hoyeon (Samsung). Serge (T-Mobile USA) asks a question to Mike (Convida Wireless) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mike (Convida Wireless) replies to Serge (T-Mobile USA) Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a question on the use case envisioned for the described functionality. Mike (Convida) replies. Serge (T-Mobile USA) replies to Mike (Convida Wireless), has concerns with solution 29. Tricci (ZTE) provides feedback to Mike (Covinda Wireless). Mike (Convida Wireless) replies to Tricci (ZTE) and provide r06. Tricci (ZTE) thanks Mike (Convida Wireless) and provide r07. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r08 and proposes to document evaluation only in this meeting. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r09 and ask opinion whethe to use r08 or r09 for further update Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Convida. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r10 === CC#2 === Serge Manning (T-Mobile USA) objects to rev7 and all older revisions, can live with rev8 but prefers rev9 or rev10. Mike (Convida Wireless) objects to rev08, rev09 and rev10. Provides rev11 Jinguo(ZTE) thanks Mike (Convida Wireless) and provides a clean version with updates in r12 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r13 Genadi (Lenovo) asks a question to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Lenovo. Patrice (Huawei) comments, provides r14. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r19. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r21. Mike (Convida Wireless) provides r22. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r19. Objects to all the other revisions. Mike replies to Hoyeon (Samsung) Tao(Chair) Can we approve r19 then? Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and objects to r19. Alessio(Nokia) responds to Samsung Alessio(Nokia) is ok with rev22 and would really be pleased if Samsung understood our comment context Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r21 or r22. Mike (Convida Wireless) prefers r22. === Phase 2 final deadline === Tao(Chair) in view of significant effort and majority view, I approve r22. I understand Hoyeon cannot reply email now. Please raise your objection to r22 in CC#4 if still hard to accept it. Hoyeon (Samsung) can live with r22, but will come back to the next meeting. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2008259 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Evaluation and Conclusion. | Convida Wireless LLC, Telecom Italia, Ericsson, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007337R22, merging S2-2007308. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007396 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | FS_eNS_Ph2 Open Issues _x00B_Way Forwards | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB | Rel-17 | LATE DOC: Rx 03/10 09:15. Noted | Noted | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007485 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on restricting the rate per UE per network slice | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#4: r04 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007946. | Haiyang(Huawei) suggests to discuss together with 7122 and prefers this one as baseline. === CC#2 === Belen (Ericsson) proposes to mark this LS as merged into S2-2007122. Alessio ( Nokia) proposes to not follow Belen's advice and keep this Ls as the baseline. Alessio(nokia) agrees with Huawei Belen (Ericsson) objects to this LS since it does not cover all solutions impacting RAN. Alessio(nokia) provides feedback to Belen and asks Belen to please provide a revision with precise not open ended questions. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and informs that those questions are listed in Ericsson LS Jinguo(ZTE) provide r01 Alessio(Nokia) provides R02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r05. Tao(Chair) r05 will not be considered due to revision deadline passed. Can people live with r04? Alessio(nokia) agrees with Sun Tao to proceed with rev04 Hoyeon (Samsung)proposes to discuss the LS during the CC as the LS is important to make KI#3 conclusion at the next meeting. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2007946 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on restricting the rate per UE per network slice | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007485R04. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2007794 | LS In | Information | LS from GSMA 5GJA: LS response to TCCA on Public Safety | GSMA 5GJA (5GJA14_121r1) (5GJA14_121r1) | Postponed. Revised to S2-2008342. | Revised | ||
| 8.5 | - | - | - | Study on enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (FS_IIoT) | - | - | Docs:=106 | - | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | LS Out/General | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007093 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Per-Packet Delay measurements | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) questions the need for the LS out. Shabnam (Ericsson) waiting to see how the updates to the related solutions clarifies this issue, if it is clear no change needed then we can note it. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007094 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Use of Survival Time for Deterministic Applications in 5GS | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007880 | Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to consider this document as merged with 7754 and take 7754 as the base to comment upon, if any. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007754 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Use of Survival Time for Deterministic Applications in 5GS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007094, to S2-2007880. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Sang-Jun (Samsung) asks for clarification for r01/r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r04 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r05 after deadline for revision has passed. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Shabnam; is not ok with the late r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r04 or r03 but objects to other versions Shabnam (Ericsson) can live with r04 but not r03. Devaki (Nokia) propose to go with r04. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r04 and r05. prefer r05. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007880 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Use of Survival Time for Deterministic Applications in 5GS | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007754R04, merging S2-2007094. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007055 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update for resolving ENs for BMCA. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007884 | zhendong (ZTE) proposes this merged to 7204 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with the merge === CC#2 === Sang-Jun (Samsung) accept the merge proposal by zhendong (ZTE) abd Jari (NTT DOCOMO). 7055 is merged to 7204 and to 7176. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007057 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update for resolving ENs for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007881. | Devaki (Nokia) raises a question and concern regarding feasibility. Sang-Jun (Samsung) asks Devaki (Nokia) a question for clarification. Devaki (Nokia) responds. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007881 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update for resolving ENs for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007057R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007176 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: update to fix EN of method3 for BMCA. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2007882. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Jari (NTT DOCOMO) and provided r01. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Xiaowan Xiaowan responds to Jari (NTT DOCOMO) Xiaowan(vivo) agrees Jari (NTT DOCOMO) and provides r02 accordingly === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to zhendong (ZTE) === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) asks why the newly introduced text is a Note and not normal text since it describes how this method supposed to work? Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Sang-Jun (Samsung) and Qianghua (Huawei), and provides r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r05 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007882 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: update to fix EN of method3 for BMCA. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007176R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007177 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#2: correct the impacts part. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007883. | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks if the text actually should be removed, see detailed comment. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Xiaowan(vivo) replies and provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Devaki (Nokia) comments that there seems to be no change left in r01. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Devaki (Nokia), r01 does remove 'UE: - UE indicates the port's DS-TT identifier in the Port Management Container and send to AF.' and has the revision mark === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007883 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#2: correct the impacts part. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007177R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007204 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Sol#1: Updates on Solution #1 for support of PTP/UDP/IP. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007745 and S2-2007055, to S2-2007884. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) indicates that the generalisation of this KI and removing the TSN is not according the WI scope and as such needs to be removed. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007884 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Sol#1: Updates on Solution #1 for support of PTP/UDP/IP. | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007204R04, merging S2-2007745 and S2-2007055. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007227 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Sol#17: Updates on Solution #17 . | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007497, to S2-2007885. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) has same comment as in other Key Issue #1 solutions that are being updated for non-TSN case(IEEE 1588-2008), which is not in scope of the study and needs to be removed. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007885 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Sol#17: Updates on Solution #17 . | NTT DOCOMO, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007227R02, merging S2-2007497. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007345 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, sol #1: updates . | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007886. | Shabnam (Ericsson) disagrees that NEF can replace a TSN AF, NEF role is not that so removes such text providing r01. Devaki (Nokia) objects to the paper, method 1 update is not scalable. Yuan (CATT) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007886 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, sol #1: updates . | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007345R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007397 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1 Sol #18: Update to clarify Exposure of Time Synchronization. | ETRI | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007887. | Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects as disagrees with proposes changes as soln#7 has NEF storing information in the UDR and seems the TSN AF/NEF roles are missed up. Devaki (Nokia) objects to the paper. Yoohwa(ETRI) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Devaki (Nokia) is OK with r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007887 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1 Sol #18: Update to clarify Exposure of Time Synchronization. | ETRI | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007397R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007497 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, sol#17, update the description and remove the Note. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007885 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to merge with S2-2007227 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === zhendong (ZTE) is fine to merge === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007745 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: Updates for Uplink Time Synchronization for TSN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007884 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to merge with S2-2007204 Devaki (Nokia) fine with Jari's (NTT DOCOMO) proposal to merge with 7204. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007498 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: Discussion on the forwarding of (g)PTP message. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | György (Ericsson) raises a question zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the document or consider it merged in 7171. György (Ericsson) responds Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to zhendong (ZTE) György (Ericsson) responds and objects. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r01 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note the paper György (Ericsson) objects to r01 and r00, proposes to note the paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007050 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Conclusion for BMCA control plane solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Qianghua (Huawei) suggests merging this into S2-2007054, based on offline discussion === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007054 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Evaluation and Conclusion Updates. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes that the evaluation in this paper should be removed. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes this for show of hands Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note, based on the result of the show-of-hands === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007095 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion updates. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007926 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this with 7746. Shabnam (Ericsson) confirms the merge with 7746. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007174 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Interim evaluation and conclusions update. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2007888. | Xiaowan (vivo) provided r01. Devaki (Nokia) requests Xiaowan (Vivo) if this paper can be merged to 7746? Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Devaki (Nokia) : agree to merge conclusion part into 7776 but keep the evaluation part in 7174 standalone. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Devaki (Nokia) : agree to merge conclusion part into 7746 but keep the evaluation part in 7174 standalone. (The previous email: '7776' is a typo) Xiaowan(vivo) provide r02 to merge the evaluation part in 7095 and 7746 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes partial merge (evaluation part) from 7095 and provides r05. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007888 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Interim evaluation and conclusions update. | Vivo, Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007174R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007183 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1; Conclusion update. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007889 | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Saso (Intel) is OK with r01 provided by Devaki. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note, the paper collides with S2-2007226 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007226 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Update the evaluation and conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007183, to S2-2007889. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes partial merge with S2-2007746, provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007889 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Update the evaluation and conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007226R04, merging S2-2007183. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007496 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Evaluation and conclusion for the BMCA part. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007926 | Devaki (Nokia) asks if this can be merged with 7746? zhendong (ZTE) i am fine to merge into 7746 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007627 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Update Conclusion on BMCA. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007926 | Devaki (Nokia) propose to merge with 7746. Chunshan (Tencent) is OK to merge with 7746. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007746 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007746r11 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007496 S2-2007627 and S2-2007095, to S2-2007926. | Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaowan (vivo) provides r03 and seek the clarification for the last bullet === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r05, responds to Qianghua (Huawei) zhendong (ZTE) provides r06 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r07 with minor corrections. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Devaki (Nokia) provides r08. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r09. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers r07 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r08ER Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers r09, then r07. Does not agree with R08Er. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r07, r08 or r09; objects to other versions Devaki (Nokia) proposes to go with r08. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Devaki. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds some more to Devaki. Devaki (Nokia) provides r10. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r11. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Jari for r11 and are ok with this version to proceed. Minor editorial spelling for the rapporteur to take on board for the TR, highlighted below. === Phase 2 final deadline === Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to keep the E.N. indicated in Shabnam (Ericsson)'s mail. Sang-Jun (Samsung) is ok with r11 with minor editorial spelling correction indicated in Shabnam (Ericsson)'s mail. === CC#3 === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to agree r11 in the CC#4 === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007926 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, ZTE, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007746R11, merging S2-2007496 S2-2007627 and S2-2007095. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007052 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Updates to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007059, to S2-2007890. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) objects to r00 (original) and to r01. === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 György (Ericsson) provides r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05, disagree r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) can accept r05 and responds to Huawei. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007890 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Updates to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007052R05, merging S2-2007059. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007059 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update for resolving ENs for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007890 | Qianghua (Huawei) suggests merging this into S2-2007052 === CC#2 === György (Ericsson) raises questions, ok with merging this into S2-2007052 Devaki (Nokia) questions the feasibility of this proposal. Sang-Jun (Samsung) confirms that 7059 is merged to 7052. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007096 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol #2: Update of solution #2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007891. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei questions. Xiaowan(vivo) comments Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with Vivo and ask further questions György (Ericsson) responds to Vivo and provides r01. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Xiaowan(vivo) comments and provides r02. György(Ericsson) fine with r02. Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees with the arguments regarding to non-TSC traffic György (Ericsson) poses a question to Huawei === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02 and provides responses to György (Ericsson) Qianghua (Huawei) responds === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007891 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol #2: Update of solution #2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007096R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007097 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol #10: Addressing Editor's notes in Solution #10. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === György (Ericsson) fine with r01. Devaki (Nokia) raises a question. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. György (Ericsson) raises questions about r02, and provides r03. === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments, only OK with r02. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei Devaki (Nokia) proposes to add an EN for determining the right UE for the incoming packet. György (Ericsson) provides r04. Qianghua (Huawei) comments György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) repeats the comments === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments on r03 and r04; György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and proposes to use r04 for the way forward. Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r02 György (Ericsson) requests Huawei to justify their statement. Qianghua (Huawei) responds György (Ericsson) responds and proposes to go ahead with r04. György (Ericsson) objects to r02 and proposes to go ahead with r04. Qianghua (Huawei) insists the opinions György (Ericsson) explains why the Huawei justification is wrong. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007098 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol #20: Addressing Editor's notes in Solution #20. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2007892. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 György (Ericsson) provides r04 Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Devaki (Nokia) has concerns with the latest revisions. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. György (Ericsson) ok with r05 and provides comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 György (Ericsson) provides r07 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments on r07 and suggests to go with r06 György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and proposes to go with r07. Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to go with r06, but can live with r07 György (Ericsson) proposes to go with r07 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007892 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol #20: Addressing Editor's notes in Solution #20. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007098R07. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007499 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, sol#12 update to remove the ENs. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | György (Ericsson) raises issues with the proposal. === CC#2 === zhendong (ZTE) provides the response György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) objects to the PCR and responds to ZTE. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007747 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Solution Update: Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007893. | György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides questions for clarification Devaki (Nokia) replies to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) replies to Gyorgy (Ericsson), provides r03 to address Ericsson comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03 György (Ericsson) is ok with r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007893 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Solution Update: Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007747R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007051 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: Updates on Conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | Devaki (Nokia) asks questions. György (Ericsson) objects to the original r00 version. === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) responds György (Ericsson) responds Qianghua (Huawei) confirms that this merges into S2-2007058 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei, === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007058 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Conclusion Updates. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007051, S2-2007074, S2-2007099, S2-2007100, S2-2007175, S2-2007276 and S2-2007748 to S2-2007894. | György (Ericsson) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) disagrees with r01 and the rationale, provides r03. Sang-Jun is fine with r03 provided by Devaki (Nokia). György (Ericsson) provides r04 to update according to the offline discussion and merges in 7100. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r06 Devaki (Nokia) replies to Gyorgy (Ericsson). György (Ericsson) replies Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) replies to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) replies to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with Devaki (Nokia) zhendong (ZTE) similar view with nokia and fine with r06 Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r06. György (Ericsson) responds to comments. Jiang-Liang (III) is fine with r06 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007894 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Conclusion Updates. | Samsung, Huawei, Hisilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, III | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007058R0, merging S2-2007051, S2-2007074, S2-2007099, S2-2007100, S2-2007175, S2-2007276 and S2-2007748. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007074 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: Updates for evaluation and conclusion . | III | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | György (Ericsson) objects to the original PCR. Devaki (Nokia) actually supports the proposal. Samsung (Sang-Jun) has the same view with Devaki (Nokia), and is fine with r01. György (Ericsson) responds to Devaki. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with Ericsson comments and proposes this merged into 7748 Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. Jiang-Liang (III) is fine with r01 György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and objects to r01. Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058, object to any revisions of this PCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007099 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, evaluation: Ethernet bridging principles. | Ericsson, Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === György (Ericsson) provides clarification to DOCOMO. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to György (Ericsson) Qianghua (Huawei) objects to this PCR György (Ericsson) requests clarifications from Huawei. György (Ericsson) responds to Jari. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to György. === CC#2 === György (Ericsson) responds to Jari (DOCOMO) Qianghua (Huawei) still holds concerns for this PCR György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia, can accept r01. Qianghua (Huawei) proposes this merged in S2-2007058, which is agreeable for UE-UE port pair consideration György (Ericsson) responds to DOCOMO. Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058, objects to any revisions of this PCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) agrees this paper can be considered merged into S2-2007058. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007100 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, evaluation: way forward for UE to UE traffic . | Ericsson, Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) responds Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. (r01 in server, author unknown). Qianghua (Huawei) Ok with r02 Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) agrees this is merged into S2-2007058. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007175 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2: Interim conclusions update . | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments for clarification Xiaowan replies to Qianghua (Huawei) Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058, objects to any revisions of this PCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007276 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, evaluation: Industrial requirements . | Ericsson, Bosch | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | Qianghua (Huawei) objects to this PCR György (Ericsson) requests clarifications from Huawei. === CC#2 === Qianghua (Huawei) hold the concerns Devaki (Nokia) questions the need for this P-CR to Stage 2 and TR. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) share Nokia views Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058, objects to any revisions of this PCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === György (Ericsson) agrees this is considered merged into S2-2007058. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007748 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007894 | György (Ericsson) comments. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments for clarification Devaki (Nokia) replies to Qianghua (Huawei). György (Ericsson) replies. zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to mark as merged into 7058 Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this in S2-2007058, objects to any revisions of this PCR === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=19 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2006943 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #13: Updates to remove ENs. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2007895. | Dan(China Mobile) correct the title of this email and provide r02 based on Belen's r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. === CC#2 === Dan (China Mobile) provide r04 and r05, but please ignore r04, let's use r05 for discussion Belen (Ericsson) provides r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007895 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #13: Updates to remove ENs. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006943R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007049 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #22: Update on spread time. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007896. | Shabnam (Ericsson) have concerns with this proposal and it is a new soln, mixing burst spread with other information and thus changing the concept, see comments. Propose to NOTE the pCR. Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) please see comments on what the issue is from our perspective, defn vs change in defn on burst spread. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007896 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #22: Update on spread time. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007049R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007088 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #23: Updates to remove ENs. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007897. | Belen (Ericsson) provides comments and asks for clarifications. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Dan (China Mobile) provides reply to Belen and provide r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r02 === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007897 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #23: Updates to remove ENs. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007088R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007090 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5 Update to merge jitter with Solution #5 and part of conclusion for KI #3A. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007898. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 (conclusions should all be handled in 7004 as discussed offline) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007898 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5 Update to merge jitter with Solution #5 and part of conclusion for KI #3A. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007090R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007101 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to remove EN. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007899. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r02, proposes to merge last change to 7751 to avoid conflicts. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007899 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to remove EN. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007101R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007502 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, sol#23 update to clarify the report. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) have concerns with this pCR, provides comments and propose to note it. Devaki (Nokia) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007503 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, solution#22, update to remove the ENs. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007900. | Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns in adding multiple options, we suggest to choose one. Devaki (Nokia) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007900 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, solution#22, update to remove the ENs. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007503R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007749 | DISCUSSION | Information | KI#3A: HoldAndForwardWayForward | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007750 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Sol#21: Updates for TSN stream information provisioning from CNC to 5GS. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007901. | Shabnam (Ericsson) has concern with this proposal, we don't believe it is related to the issue or soln, provides comments. Note the paper. Devaki (Nokia) replies, does not agree with the rationale to note. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) supports r02 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007901 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Sol#21: Updates for TSN stream information provisioning from CNC to 5GS. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007750R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007751 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Solution Update - Solution 5 Capability Exposure Procedure. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007752 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A: Solution update: #5 Addendum on Configuring Hold and Forward Buffers . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007902. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007902 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A: Solution update: #5 Addendum on Configuring Hold and Forward Buffers . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007752R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - New Solution | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007344 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, New Sol: CN assisted burst spread measurement . | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to any new solution, as we have already concluded no new solns. Devaki (Nokia) objects to new solution, also raises technical concerns. Yuan (CATT) responds and provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007004 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A: Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#3A . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007500 and S2-2007501, to S2-2007903. | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Hui (Huawei) replies. Devaki (Nokia) replies. === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) does not agree with this paper's conclusion so hard for us to merge 7102 with this. As such let's discuss first a way forward offline and come back with a proposed way forward and take one paper as a base. Hui (Huawei) provides r01. Hui (Huawei) proposes the related KI#3A evaluation/conclusion tdocs are merged into this tdoc. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007903 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A: Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#3A . | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007004R05, merging S2-2007500 and S2-2007501. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007102 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A: Evaluation and conclusion . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with S2-2007004. Shabnam (Ericsson) does not agree with 7004 and as such no merger. Let's discuss first a way forward offline and come back with a proposed way forward and take one paper as a base. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Dan (China Mobile) provides r02 and comments zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments Dan (China Mobile) reply to ZTE Hui (Huawei) objects to any revision of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007500 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Evaluation for the KI#3A. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007903 | Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to this contribution, it concludes when there is a separate conclusion paper and we also disagree with the conclusion. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response zhendong (ZTE) this paper is merged to 7004 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007501 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A interim conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007903 | Shabnam (Ericsson) does not agree with the conclusion, nor adding the new parameters proposed via solns update. Propose to discuss single paper way forward. Devaki (Nokia) proposes r01. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to this conclusion, we believe soln#21 also provides the right way forward, and we should communicate to IEEE and get feedback on it. Dan (China Mobile) ask the question to Shabnam about the sol21 zhendong (ZTE) provides the response zhendong (ZTE) this paper is merged to 7004 Hui (Huawei) objects to any revision of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007760 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A conclusion. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Sennheiser | Rel-17 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) disagree with the proposal Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Dan Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Qualcomm and provides TR Key issue #3A description where it is described. Hui (Huawei) objects to any revision of the paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3B - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007003 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Update conclusion for KI#3B. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007506, to S2-2007904. | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02. === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) disagrees with r02 and objects to unilaterally extending TSN functions DS-TT and NW-TT to non-TSN. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification from Shabnam (Ericsson) Hui (Huawei) asks clarification from Shabnam (Ericsson) Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) accepts r03 zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r03 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007904 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Update conclusion for KI#3B. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007003R03, merging S2-2007506. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007061 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for resolving ENs for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007905 | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification via comments. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to use 7202 as the basis for solving the EN regarding validity time. Merge this paper to 7202. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. Shabnam (Ericsson) disagrees with r01 as it adds back the validity time, supports original version. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) asks can we merge this in S2-2007202 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sang-Jun (Samsung) agrees merging the paper to 7202. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007202 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Removal of EN in Solution #7 . | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007061 and S2-2007568, to S2-2007905. | Chunshan (Tencent) request for clarification on questions. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Chunshan (Tencent) replies. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Chunshan (Tencent) === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) supports the proposed way forward in this paper compared to other ones. Chunshan (Tencent) has questions on Jari's answer. Sang-Jun (Samsung) and provides r01 with comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02 with comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03, and responds to Sang-Jun (Samsung) Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Jari (NTT DOCOMO). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007905 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Removal of EN in Solution #7 . | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007202R03, merging S2-2007061 and S2-2007568. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007228 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Solution #7 update . | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revised, merging S2-2007346, to S2-2007775. | Revised | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007346 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, sol #7: updates. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007775 | Merged | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007775 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Solution #7 update . | NTT DOCOMO, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007228, merging S2-2007346. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007504 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, solution#7, update to clarify method 2 and method 4. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Devaki (Nokia) comments. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.5 | S2-2007505 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, sol#9, Update the solution on BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007906. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone BMCA method update for KI#3B related solutions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === zhendong (ZTE) provides response Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to progress with BMCA for Sol 9 in S2-2007619 === CC#2 === zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to zhendong (ZTE) Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007906 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, sol#9, Update the solution on BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007505R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007568 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update the TSN Time Synchronization procedure. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007905 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note the document Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to go with 7202 approach instead of this one. Qianghua (Huawei) asks can we merge this in S2-2007202 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes this for show of hands Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Chunshan (Tencent) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007202r03 to make forward.. === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007619 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#9: BMCA procedure. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007612, to S2-2007907. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007907 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#9: BMCA procedure. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007619R01, merging S2-2007612. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007753 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, Sol#7: Updates for Exposure of Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007908. | Qianghua (Huawei) suggests merging this with S2-2007202 Devaki (Nokia) indicates that this cannot be merged with 7202 as they are handling different aspects thus this paper needs to be independent. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification Qianghua (Huawei) 7207 and 7753 use the similar method to address the same EN, indeed can be merged Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Disagrees that this is same as 7207 thus merge proposal is not valid. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Devaki (Nokia) replies. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r01, if you want to keep this. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Chunshan (Tencent) proposed this paper to be merged into the S2-2007202. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007908 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, Sol#7: Updates for Exposure of Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007753R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3B - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007060 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Conclusion Updates. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) proposes author to create r01 without 'Additional indications can be considered during the normative work' Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03 and responses to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r03 and co-signs this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes this for show of hands Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper (all revisions) === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007506 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, update the conclusion to remove the EN and clarify the BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007904 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note the paper. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Qianghua (Huawei) proposes merging this into 7003 zhendong (ZTE) is fine to merge this into 7003 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2007569 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Update the conclusion and remove the ENs . | Tencent | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007060. Noted | Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r01. Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to note this paper and go with Samsung paper 7060r02. Chunshan (Tencent) is Ok to be merged into Samsung paper S2-2007060r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2007762 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2007910. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r01; objects to r00 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007910 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007762R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007103 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | KI #5: Survival Time definition. | Ericsson | Noted | Noted | ||
| 8.5 | S2-2007638 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | KI#5: Definition of Survival Time. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks to use 7103 as the definition, which is based on SA1 requirements and defn. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note this paper (as this changes the concept of burst) and use 7754 as the basis for LS out. Guillaume (MediaTek) disagrees with Devaki (Nokia) assertion given the paper is correct and does not change the concept of data burst. Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok to note the paper as it was used as basis for LS out in 7754. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007104 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5: Conclusion Update . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2007761 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#5 conclusion update. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007911. | Dan (China Mobile) support the idea and ask for clarification Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note as this goes beyond scope of the KI(s) in FS_IIoT. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Devaki Qianghua (Huawei) provides concerns on support of communication service availability zhendong (ZTE) has similar concerns with qianghua Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r02 zhendong (ZTE) agree with qianghua and is fine with r02 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2007911 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#5 conclusion update. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007761R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | Study Extended Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (FS_ATSSS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=34 | - | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006862 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Architecture assumption on GBR QoS flow. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007545 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1, Sol#2: Solution Update for Autonomous Steering Mode . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008075. | Susan (Huawei) raises comments and cannot accept the changes as they are. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. DongYeon (Samsung) ask questions to Susan's reply and Stefan's proposed r01. DongYeon (Samsung) revised typo is previous comment. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Susan and ask questions Stefan (Ericsson) replies to DongYeon Susan (Huawei) replies to DongYeon. DongYeon (Samsung) comments to Susan's reply. DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Susan. Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan and provides r02. DongYeon (Samsung) replies. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Susan and DongYeon DongYeon (Samsung) has no objection but asks questions. Rainer (Nokia) replies to DongYeon (Samsung). === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008075 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1, Sol#2: Solution Update for Autonomous Steering Mode . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007545R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007233 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Conclusion on solutions for KI #1 about additional steering modes. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008076 | Florin (Broadcom) requests clarification regarding the status for this document. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Florin (Broadcom) for clarification. Florin (Broadcom) responds to Tricci (ZTE) and agrees with her proposal. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Florin (Broadcom) regarding his concern on companies' disagreements. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hualin(Huawei) is ok to merge this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2007546 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1, Sol#11: Update to enhance rel-16 steering modes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007603 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1, Sol#12: Update to resolve ENs. | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Pavan (Google) replies to Ericsson and provides r1. Susan (Huawei) provides comments and raises questions. Rainer (Nokia) agrees with Susan (Huawei). Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r02 Dario (Qualcomm) comments and provide r03 Rainer (Nokia) replies to Dario (Qualcomm). Google replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Susan (Huawei), and responds to Dario (Qualcomm) and Rainer (Nokia), and provides r04. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r05 Susan (Huawei) replies to Rainer (Nokia). Susan (Huawei) provides comments and asks to either address the issues in the paper or add ENs to move forward. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Rainer Susan (Huawei) relies to Dario. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Pavan (Google) replies to Susan (Huawei) and seeks a clarification for r05. Jinguo response to Pavan (Google) Susan (Huawei) relies to Pavan. Susan (Huawei) asks to postpone this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007547 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1: Evaluation and interim conclusions for KI#1 (Steering Modes) . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r13 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007233, S2-2007440, S2-2007645, S2-2007728, to S2-2008076. and S2-2007475 and S2-2007728, to S2-2008076. | Tricci (ZTE) provides r01 to use Ericsson's evaluation/interim conclusion as the baseline for merging. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions for clarification. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks additional questions. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02 Rainer (Nokia) replies to Lenovo. Susan (Huawei) provides comments. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stefan (Ericsson) comments and asks questions Hualin(Huawei) comments on this paper. Rainer (Nokia) comments. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Stefan (Ericsson). Pavan (Google) provides some comments and provides r03.. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Hualin(Huawei) response to Stefan (Ericsson). Susan (Huawei) provides r03. Susan (Huawei) provides r04. Myungjune (LGE) provides r05. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r06. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r07 Susan (Huawei) provides r08 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r09 Susan (Huawei) provides r10 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r11 Dario (Qualcomm) provides r12 Krisztian (Apple) provides r13: adding Apple as co-signer and fixing some editorials. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Susan Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Apostolis (Lenovo) accepts r13. Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification. Susan (Huawei) replies to Rainer. === Phase 2 final deadline === Rainer (Nokia) replies to Susan. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008076 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1: Evaluation and interim conclusions for KI#1 (Steering Modes) . | Ericsson, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007547R13, merging S2-2007233, S2-2007440, S2-2007645 S2-2007728. Approved and S2-2007475 | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007440 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Evaluation on solutions for KI #1 about additional steering modes. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008076 | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to use Ericsson's S2-2007547 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#1. Hualin(Huawei) ask Tricci (ZTE) to explain why, otherwise Huawei tend to object the proposal. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Hualin (Huawei)'s concern that the basic intent is to have common starting point for converged evaluation/interim conclusion. Jinguo (ZTE) comment on this paper and suggest to merge with 7547 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === We are ok to merge it with 7547 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2007475 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1: Interim conclusions on solutions 2 and 12. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008076 | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to use Ericsson's S2-2007547 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#1. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2007645 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Interim Conclusions for KI#1: Steering Modes. | Broadcom, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Apple, Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008076 | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to use Ericsson's S2-2007547 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#1. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) comments === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) responds to Stefan (Ericsson) regarding using S2-2007547 as the baseline === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2007728 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: 23.700-93: KI#1: Evaluation and interim conclusions for KI#1. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008076 | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to use Ericsson's S2-2007547 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#1. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Tricci and asking for clarification. Stefan (Ericsson) comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006869 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Solution #8 - Solution update. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006870 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Solution #7 - Solution update. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008077. | Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Susan (Huawei) replies to Apostolis and can accept r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008077 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Solution #7 - Solution update. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006870R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007548 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#13: Update to resolve open issues and clarify options . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008078. | Susan (Huawei) raises questions for clarification. Susan (Huawei) raises questions for clarification and asks to update the solution. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r01 Susan (Huawei) replies and asks to add an EN or update the solution for DL-only QoS Flows. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008078 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#13: Update to resolve open issues and clarify options . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007548R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007549 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#14: Update to resolve open issues and clarify options . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008079. | Susan (Huawei) raises the same comments as for S2-2007548. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008079 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#14: Update to resolve open issues and clarify options . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007549R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007640 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #1: QUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008080. | Susan (Huawei) asks questions for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) corrects the AI# from 7.3 to 8.6 Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan's (Huawei) questions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Jinguo's (ZTE) comments Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan's (Huawei) comments and provides r01. Susan (Huawei) replies to Apostolis and askes to add EN for future meeting discussion. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r02 including the EN suggested by Susan (Huawei). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008080 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #1: QUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007640R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007643 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #6: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008081. | Susan (Huawei) asks questions and raise comments, and asks to add ENs or update the paper to clarify. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan's (Huawei) comments and provides r01. Susan (Huawei) asks to add EN for next meeting discussion. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r02 including the EN suggested by Susan (Huawei). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008081 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #6: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007643R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006871 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Evaluation and conclusion on KI#2 for IP/UDP traffic. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008110 | Jinguo (ZTE) asks comment and suggest to merge this paper to 7750. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Susan (Huawei) responds to Jinguo. Jinguo(ZTE) reply to Susan (Huawei) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Apostolis (Lenovo) proposes to mark this paper as 'Merged into 7644'. Susan (Huawei) agrees to mark this paper as Merged into 7644 and/or 7550. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2006872 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Evaluation and conclusion on KI#2 for Ethernet traffic. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Jinguo (ZTE) asks comment and suggest to merge this paper to 7750. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Susan (Huawei) asks ZTE to provide reasoning for requesting the merge to 7750. Jinguo(ZTE) reply and is fine to use 6872 for evaluation on Ethernet part. Susan (Huawei) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Apostolis (Lenovo) proposes to postpone this paper because more study is needed for the Ethernet traffic. Susan (Huawei) is ok to postpone this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.6 | S2-2007550 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2: Evaluation of solutions for Key Issue #2 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008082. | Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 to propose Ericsson's S2-2007550 to be used as the baseline to merge with other evaluation papers for KI#2 Rainer (Nokia) providing comments and asking for clarification. Susan (Huawei) raises comments. Susan (Huawei) raises objection to r01, and asks to further discuss the original version of the paper and how to move forward on the evaluation part. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Susan (Huawei) concern. Susan (Huawei) responds to ZTE and cannot accept to use this paper as basis for merging without any reasonable argumentation. Susan (Huawei) propose to use S2-2006871 as basis for merging. Susan (Huawei) responds to Tricci (ZTE). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Susan and provides r02 === CC#2 === Tricci (ZTE) thanks Stefan (Ericsson) to provide r02 to progress the discussions on merging evaluation for KI#2. Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan and provides r03 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04 Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Apostolis (Lenovo) believes that this is a useful document but proposes to postpone it to the next meeting. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to work on this paper in this meeting. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05 to address Apostolis' comments === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Florin (Broadcom) requests clarifications from Susan. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008082 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2: Evaluation of solutions for Key Issue #2 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007550R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007644 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Interim Conclusions for KI#2: Steering Functionality. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Apple, Broadcom, Tencent, Interdigital, Deutsche Telecom, Charter | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006871 and S2-2007729, to S2-2008110. | Susan (Huawei) raises objection to this paper, and provides details for the objection. Jinguo(ZTE) corrects the AI# from 7.3 to 8.6 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02 Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r03 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04 Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r05 Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan. Thouraya (Orange) provides r06 Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Thouraya (Orange). Rainer (Nokia) provides r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008110 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Interim Conclusions for KI#2: Steering Functionality. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Apple, Broadcom, Tencent, Interdigital, Deutsche Telecom, Charter, LG Electronics, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia, AT&T, Huawei, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson, Google, Orange | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007644R07, merging S2-2006871 and S2-2007729. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2007729 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2: Interim conclusions for FS_ATSSS_Ph2 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008110 | Jinguo (ZTE) suggests to merge this paper into 2007644 and 2007550. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006863 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #3, Evaluation and Conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006939 and S2-2007293, to S2-2008083. | Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 and proposed to use LG's S2-2006863 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#3. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02 and asks questions for clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with the merge and comments. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Qualcomm and Interdigital comments Laurent (Nokia): provides r03 Myungjune (LGE) provides r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r05. Guanzhou (InterDigital) adds InterDigital as co-sourcing in r06. No other changes. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2008083 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #3, Evaluation and Conclusion. | LG Electronics, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Deutsche Telekom, InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006863R06, merging S2-2006939 and S2-2007293. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006939 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#3: Interim conclusions for FS_ATSSS_Ph2 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008083 | Tricci (ZTE) provided comment to Nokia to propose LG's S2-2006863 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#3. Laurent (Nokia): OK to merge and use S2-2006863 as the baseline for revisions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2007293 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#3: Evaluation and interim conclusions. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008083 | Tricci (ZTE) provided comment to Interdigital to propose LG's S2-2006863 as the baseline to merge evaluation/interim conclusions for KI#3. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | - | - | - | Study on supporting UAS Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (FS_ID_UAS-SA2) | - | - | Docs:=56 | - | |
| 8.7 | S2-2006940 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to References,Terms, Architectural Assumptions and Annex. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008260. | Runze (Huawei) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008260 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to References,Terms, Architectural Assumptions and Annex. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006940R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007412 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: AA: Clarification on UAS concept. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications and reserves to object Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Runze. === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note 7412 since it does not reflect any CRs approved in SA1. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm). Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks for the reply and proposes to note 7412 since it does not reflect any architectural impacts. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2006941 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7,Sol. 5 update: 5G LAN can be used to support the communication between paired UAV and networked UAV Controller. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments Dan (China Mobile) reply to Stefano Pallab (Nokia) provides further comments Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments. Dan (China Mobile) provides response to previous comments Pallab (Nokia) responds to Dan (China Mobile) Dan(China Mobile) reply to the comments Runze (Huawei) supports Dan's response. Guanzhou (InterDigital) further comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) re-iterates the concerns. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Dan (China Mobile) reply to Stefano, and agree that maybe this optimization needs further thinking and this paper can be NOTED === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Dan and proposes to note 6941. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007187 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 1, 2, 3, 5, 6 &7, Sol#5: Update the solution to clarify UTM triggered re-authentication and re-authorization case. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | Runze (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Yunjing (CATT) responses to Runze (Huawei). === CC#2 === Runze (Huawei) replies to Yunjing (CATT). Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Runze (Huawei) can accept the response from Yunjing (CATT). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2007107 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Update of solution #4 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008261. | Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, as per discussion. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Runze (Huawei) replies to Shabnam. Pallab (Nokia) adds further comments Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, provides response to Nokia and Huawei. Pallab (Nokia) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008261 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Update of solution #4 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007107R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007188 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 1&4, Sol#9: Update the solution to clarify unknown UAV tracking. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests noting the document because that part of solution #9 is merged into solution 25. OPPO also suggest noting this pCR and confirms that handling of unknown UAV is in Sol#25. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007189 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 2&3, Sol#24: Update the solution to delete the procedure of UAV and UAVC pairing re-authentication and re-authorization via AMF. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007341 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Sol#5 Update: Simplification and clarifications of solution 5. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008262. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) reiterates the concerns on removing support for separate PDU sessions/PDN connections. R01 is provided. And proposes to seek a merge with 7410. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r02 merging the content of 7410. Runze (Huawei) provides r03, and agrees to merge 2007410 into this pCR. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r04. Runze (Huawei) can accept r04 from Stefano (Qualcomm). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008262 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Sol#5 Update: Simplification and clarifications of solution 5. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007341R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007288 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1,2,7: Conclusions on UAV authorization/authentication. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008263 | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concerns on 'flight authorization ID' and provides r02. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Stefano and Guanzhou === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note 7288 and revisions and consider it merged in 7335 Runze (Huawei) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007335. Dimitris (Lenovo) confirms that S2-2007288 is merged into S2-2007335 and S2-2007338 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007335 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: additional conclusions for various key issues. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007064, S2-2007413, to S2-2008263. and S2-2007288 and S2-2007413, to S2-2008263. | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and raises other question and seek clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r03 and asks for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Pallab (Nokia) agrees with the comments from Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides rev r04 === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) accepts the changes but reinstates in the provided rev. 05 the proposal for a control plane solution. Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification to Stefano (Qualcomm) on safety concerns raised against Sol #23. Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification from Pallab (Nokia) Pallab (Nokia) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks Stefano(Qualcomm) for clarification on r05. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to questions. Shabnam (Ericsson) also have concerns with the updates and proposes to use 7108 common parts as base for this meeting and take the CP/UP aspects of the architecture in November. Guanzhou (InterDigital) further comments on Stefano(Qualcomm) clarification on r05. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r06. Chen (OPPO) provides r07, and raise a concern to Pallab (Nokia). Stefano (Qualcomm) is OK with r07. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to conclusion with CP only proposals, comments. Pallab (Nokia) objects to r07. OK with r06 Runze (Huawei) prefers r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r06 or r07. Stefano (Qualcomm) in view of CC#2b results, I suggest capturing the conclusion on CP solution in 7335 and propose r08. === Phase 2 final deadline === Runze (Huawei) agrees to r08. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008263 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: additional conclusions for various key issues. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007335R08, merging S2-2007064 S2-2007413. Approved and S2-2007288 | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007410 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1,2,3,7, Sol#5 Update: Simplification of PDU Session establishment between USS/UTM and C2 PDU Sessions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008264. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to seek a merge with 7341. Stefano (Qualcomm) recommends merging 7410 into 7341 (see revision of 7341 in its email thread) and discuss separately the 3rd change of 7410. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm). Stefano (Qualcomm) clarifies the proposal to merge and provides r01. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008264 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1,2,3,7, Sol#5 Update: Simplification of PDU Session establishment between USS/UTM and C2 PDU Sessions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007410R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007062 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol#10: Further update to remove ENs . | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | Dan (China Mobile) provide comments Chen (OPPO) provides answer to Dan (China Mobile) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2007064 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2: Update of conclusions for KI#2. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008263 | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes a merger with 7335. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Chen (OPPO) accepts that S2-2007064 is merged into revision of S2-2007335 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007167 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol #23: Updates to clarify on interfacing with USS/UTM . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008265. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides comments and r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution Pallab (Nokia) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) and Guanzhou (InterDigital) and provided rev r02 Shabnam (Ericsson) shares Interdigital concerns and adds more comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Pallab (Nokia) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides rev r03 === CC#2 === Runze (Huawei) agrees to r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008265 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol #23: Updates to clarify on interfacing with USS/UTM . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007167R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007168 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusion on KI#2 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) rev. 01 proposed Pallab (Nokia) responds to Stefano and provides rev r02 Pallab (Nokia) responds to Pallab's comments Pallab (Nokia) responds to Stefano (Qualcomm) Shabnam (Ericsson) corrects errors in understanding and provides r03 Pallab (Nokia) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson) Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response to Nokia questions in line. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Pallab (Nokia) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides rev r04 === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) responds to comments and provides rev r05. Pallab (Nokia) provides clarification to Stefano (Qualcomm). Stefano (Qualcomm) replies with comments. Pallab (Nokia) answers comments from Stefano (Qualcomm). Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to this paper, the evaluation is incomplete/incorrect and conclusion is not acceptable. Pallab (Nokia) requests Shabnam (Ericsson) to provide reason for objection. Without a valid reason Pallab (Nokia) questions the motivation behind the objection Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all versions of this pCR and soln#23 and CP only option, see comments further. Pallab (Nokia) clarifies to Shabnam (Ericsson) and requests to remove objection === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007413 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008263 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests merging in revision of 7335. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Runze (Huawei) agrees to merge the paper into 7335.. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007336 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: Simplifications to existing conclusions related to AUV Controllers, conclusions for KI#3 and KI#6. | Qualcomm, Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008266. | Guanzhou (InterDgitial) provides r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) is OK with r01 Pallab (Nokia) provides rev r02 Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to r01, r02. OK with original version and can continue at next meeting for additional aspects. See comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to comments. Guanzhou(InterDigital) supports Stefano's replies to Shabnam's comments. Runze (Huawei) supports Stefano (Qualcomm) and r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tao(Chair) check r02 or r00 as possible way forward. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Tao and hopes r02 is not objected just because the company objecting does not agrees with the requirements coming from SA1 and the aviation community. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to QC comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) responds to Ericsson comments and provides a compromise rev. 03. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008266 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: Simplifications to existing conclusions related to AUV Controllers, conclusions for KI#3 and KI#6. | Qualcomm, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007336R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007063 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Sol#25: Update to Sol#25 with GMLC part of Sol#9 where UAVF cannot map to 3GPP areas. | OPPO, Futurewei | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008267. | Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and provides comment for clarification. Chen (OPPO) provides r01 and answers to Stefano (Qualcomm). Yunjing (CATT) comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on r01 Pallab (Nokia) comments on r01 Chen (OPPO) responding to discussion on where filtering ought to be done Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments. === CC#2 === Chen (OPPO) provide r02. Guanzhou (InterDgitial) provides r03. Chen (OPPO) accepts Guanzhou (InterDgitial) r03. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r04. Chen (OPPO) is OK with r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r04. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008267 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Sol#25: Update to Sol#25 with GMLC part of Sol#9 where UAVF cannot map to 3GPP areas. | OPPO, Futurewei, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007063R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007065 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4: Evaluations of solutions addressing KI#4 . | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008269 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to note this pCR, other documents discussion ongoing. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Chen (OPPO) indicates S2-2007065 is merged into S2-2007407 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007066 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Conclusion for KI#4 . | OPPO | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007186 and S2-2007294, to S2-2008268. | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes rev. 01 Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes rev. 01 with additional text and merging 7294 conclusions Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with the merge but has concern over some proposal in original 7066 . Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with the merge but has concern over some proposal in original 7066. R02 is provided. Chen (OPPO) provides r03 and answers to Guanzhou (InterDigital) and Stefano (Qualcomm). Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on r03. Chen (OPPO) provides r04 merging in the intentions of 7186. Also provides more answers to Guanzhou (InterDigital). Yunjing (CATT) provides r05. Guanzhou(InterDigital) comments on r05. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r06. Chen (OPPO) provides r07. OPPO cannot accept the use of 'near' and 'specific location'. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r08. Chen (OPPO) provides r09 taking in what is now amended for Sol#25 (S2-2007063r04). Stefano (Qualcomm) is OK with r09. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r10, with both options. Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to r10, we do not accept both UP and CP options for reasons explained previously. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r09 and objects to r10. Pallab (Nokia) OK with r09 and objects to r10. Stefano (Qualcomm) in view of CC#2b results, I'd propose to proceed with r09 that is focused on CP solution. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008268 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Conclusion for KI#4 . | OPPO, Interdigital, Qualcomm, CATT, Futurewei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007066R09, merging S2-2007186 and S2-2007294. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007186 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 4: Update the conclusion. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008268 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests to consider this merged with 7066. Yunjing (CATT) is ok to merge 7186 into 7066. Chen (OPPO) indicates that an attempt to merge 7186 to rev of 7066 is in 7066r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007294 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4: Evaluation and conclusion. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008268 | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes merger of conclusions part with 7066 (see 7066 thread). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007407 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007065, to S2-2008269. | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes merging the conclusion part in the revision of 7066, and keeping the evaluation part in this one OPPO provide r01 merging in evaluation parts of S2-2007065 and removing conclusions part of S2-2007407. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02. Runze (Huawei) replies to Shabnam. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008269 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon, OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007407R03, merging S2-2007065. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007414 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008270. | Pallab (Nokia) provides r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to all revisions. Runze (Huawei) replies to Shabnam and Pallab. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tao(Chair): Runze provided r02 and r03. Can either version agreeable? I check r02 first. Shabnam (Ericsson) sustained objection, cannot accept either version since both have proposed to conclude normative work using CP only two options and we have strong objections to go forward with #5 and # 23. Pallab (Nokia) OK with both r02 and r03. Stefano (Qualcomm) in view of CC#2b results, I'd propose to proceed with r03. Runze (Huawei) propose to agree r03, following the outcome of SoH in CC#3 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008270 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007414R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007295 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#6: Solution evaluation and conclusion proposal. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008271 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications, suggests merging with conclusion part of 7408, and provides rev. 01. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Guanzhou (InterDgitial) indicates 7295 has been merged into 7408 and asks Dimitris(Lenovo) to consider revisions to 7408 instead of 7295. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r03 and prefers to keep this separate as it becomes impossible to update different documents each time. We should have then agreed from the beginning what is base. Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to keep this merged in 7408 and addressed some of Shabnam's comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) supports Interdigital and proposes additional answers. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007408 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#6: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007295, to S2-2008271. | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests merging the conclusion part with the proposed revision of 7295. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r02 that merges 7295. Pallab (Nokia) provides r02 === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Nokia and ID for the merger and providers rev. 03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) corrects the record that we provided r01 instead of r02. Weijun (Huawei) is fine with r03. Pallab (Nokia) also OK with r03. Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === Sherry (Xiaomi) requests for clarification. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008271 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#6: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon, InterDigital, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007408R03, merging S2-2007295. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007067 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: Evaluations of solutions addressing KI#7. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Guanzhou (InterDgitial) proposes to Note this. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Chen (OPPO) accepts to note this pCR. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007068 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: Conclusions for KI#7. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008272 | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to merge with 7338. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides comments and asks for clarification. Chen (OPPO) provides answers to Guanzhou (InterDigital) and accepts that 7068 will be merged into rev of 7338. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007409 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008272 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Weijun (Huawei) agrees to merge this paper to 7338. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007108 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Evaluation and Conclusion . | Ericsson, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Noted | Pallab (Nokia) proposes to NOTE the paper === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Nokia explaining why it makes sense and beneficial for 3GPP to consider both approaches. Guanzhou (InterDgitial) shares view of Pallab(Nokia). Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 with the common aspects of all solutions being proposed so far as a way forward. Chris Joul (T-Mobile) Provides comments supporting r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) respectfully disagree based with TMO on aviation discussion and has concerns with r01. Pallab (Nokia) objects to r00 and r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) objects to original and r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007334 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on NR Aerial Features for Unmanned Aerial Vehicles | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | Postponed | Saso (Intel) seeks clarification about the motivation for this LS. Pallab (Nokia) questions the need for the LS Pallab (Nokia) questions the need for the LS Resending the email in the same thread that was already initiated by Saso (Intel) Runze (Huawei) supports the view from Saso(Intel) and Pallab(Nokia). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefano (Qualcomm) address comments and provides rev. 01. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefano. Saso (Intel) provides r02. === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) OK with rev. 02. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports r02 Chris (Vodafone) comments Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r03 adding link to SA2 meetings website. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Runze (Huawei) proposes to postpone the LS. === Phase 2 final deadline === Stefano (Qualcomm) does not agree on arguments for postponement. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports sending the LS to get feedback to decide the scope of SA2 normative work. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2007338 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: conclusions. | Qualcomm, Ericsson | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007068, S2-2007409, to S2-2008272. and S2-2007563 and S2-2007409, to S2-2008272. | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes rev. 01 merging with 7068 and others. Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r02 which merges S2-2007563. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r03 that includes content from S2-2007288 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and asks that Ericsson is removed as supporting company for the pCR at its current form. Chen (OPPO) provides r05 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Guanzhou (InterDigital) objects to r05. Stefano (Qualcomm) address comments and provides rev. 06. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports r06 and objects to r05 Pallab (Nokia) provides r07 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r07. Objection to r05. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008272 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: conclusions. | Qualcomm, Oppo, InterDigital, Futurewei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007338R07, merging S2-2007068 S2-2007409 and S2-2007563. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007340 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: simplification of conclusions on UAV connectivity. | Qualcomm, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) objects to only consider single PDU session for both C2 and UAV-USS for this release Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concern on removing support for separate PDU Sessions. Pallab(Nokia) shares the same concerns raised by Guanzhou(InterDigital). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Dimitris (Lenovo) supports the proposal provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guanzhou (InterDigital) objects to original and r01. Pallab (Nokia) also objects to original and r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2007342 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Sol#9 Update: clarifications of solution 9. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008273. | Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) objects some of the changes which removes the text without reasons. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stefano (Qualcomm) replies that the text was removed because already moved to the merged solution, no sense in having it twice. However, I can re-instate it if it pleases you. Provides rev.01 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) is fine with r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008273 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Sol#9 Update: clarifications of solution 9. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007342R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007411 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4,7, Sol#25: Update to merge solution 17. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007563 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#7: Solution evaluation and conclusion. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008272 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefano(Qualcomm) questions and OK to merge. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2007641 | WID NEW | Approval | New WID on Support of Aerial Systems Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | LATE DOC: Rx 03/10 21:15. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008274. | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r01 and clarifies the document is for information === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008274 | WID NEW | Approval | New WID on Support of Aerial Systems Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007641R01. WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007766 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: conclusions for KI #1 based on solution 9. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008275. | Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) shares Interdigital concerns, comments further. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Stefano (Qualcomm) addresses questions/comments. Guanzhou (InterDigital) further comments. === CC#2 === Guanzhou (InterDgitial) further questions. Guanzhou (InterDgitial) corrects one typo in the previous email. Guanzhou (InterDgitial) provides r01. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) still has concerns on the 3GPP Assisted ID handling when there is no urgency for this complexity. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2008275 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions: conclusions for KI #1 based on solution 9. | Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007766R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2007776 | LS In | Information | LS from ACJA: Support of UAVs in 3GPP system and interfacing with USS/UTM | ACJA (GSMA and GUTMA) (ACJA Liaison Statement 3GPP) | Response drafted in S2-2007784. Postponed. Revised to S2-2008340. | Revised | ||
| 8.7 | S2-2007784 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to Support of UAVs in 3GPP system and interfacing with USS/UTM | SA WG2 | Created at CC#1. Response to S2-2007776. Postponed | Runze (Huawei) asks for clarification. Stefano (Qualcomm) agrees to postpone the LS reply and to leave LS 7776 open, since we won't have sufficient conclusions to reply. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Study on system enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (FS_5G_ProSe) | - | - | Docs:=113 | - | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | LS in & out | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006812 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: RAN2 relay discovery assumptions | RAN WG2 (R2-2008270) | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2006974 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on SA WG2 progress on UE-to-Network Relay and UE-to-UE Relay | OPPO | Rel-17 | CC#4: r06 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007945. | Deng Qiang (CATT) the LS out needs to be revised based on conclusion of KI#3 and #4. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Tao(Chair) do we still have chance to go with some form of this one? Some easy offline update to capture conclusions? Deng Qiang (CATT) Clarifies to Tao (Chair). Jianhua (OPPO) asks how to handle the LS capturing the meeting agreement. Tao(Chair) response and suggest to prepare a DRAFT LS offline. === Phase 2 final deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) provides draft LS based on the conclusions. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. === CC#3 === Jianhua (OPPO) is ok with r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) supports r03. Steve (Huawei) maybe more clarification needed? Deng Qiang (CATT) provide r04 to simplify the text. Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r02 and r03. Steve (Huawei) provides r05, based on r03 Jianhua (OPPO) is also OK with r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r05. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2007945 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on SA WG2 progress on UE-to-Network Relay and UE-to-UE Relay | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006974R06. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007492 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on ProSe charging | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#4: r06 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007947. | Deng Qiang (CATT) the LS out needs to be revised based on conclusion of KI#7. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) Clarifies to Tao (Chair). Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Deng Qiang (CATT) that the LS 7492 needs to be revised based on conclusion on KI #7. Hannu (Nokia) shares r01 as requested in CC #2b today. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02 with editorial changes. === Phase 2 final deadline === Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. Hannu (Nokia) explains the structure of the LS, shares r04. Can agree either r02 or r04. === CC#3 === Hong (Qualcomm) provides r05. Deng Qiang (CATT) supports r03 and r05. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2007947 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on 5G ProSe charging | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007492R06. This LS OUT was approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#1: Direct Discovery | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007660 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Update to User Plane based Architecture. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008276. | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r01 Runze(Huawei) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Huawei. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Runze (Huawei) replied to Mehrdad (Samsung). === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008276 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Update to User Plane based Architecture. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007660R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006960 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Conclusion Update. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008277. | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes it be merge into S2-2007686. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to merge discovery conclusion of S2-2007686 into S2-2006960. Changhong (Intel) proposes to note it. Jianhua (OPPO) respond to Changhong comments. Hong (Qualcomm) response to Jianhua. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) provides r01. Changhong (Intel) provides r02. === CC#2 === Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008277 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Conclusion Update. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006960R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007270 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1,2: Proposal to include explicit support for public safety in conclusion sections 8.1 and 8.2 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008278. | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) asks an additional Q for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. Walter Dees (Philips) provides comment. Ihab Guirguis (FirstNet) agrees with concern from Philips and agree that some level of adoption may be needed to fit the 5G ProSe framework. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Walter Dees (Philips) provides r04 with merge of first change in S2-2007219. Judy (Ericsson) comment. Tao(Chair) I still check r02 as target reason as shown by Judy === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008278 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1,2: Proposal to include explicit support for public safety in conclusion sections 8.1 and 8.2 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007270R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007441 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #1 Conclusion: Update to Resolve Editor's Note. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Jianhua (OPPO) prefers to Note the paper. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Changhong (Intel) also proposes to note this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007712 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#1: Information element clarifications. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008279. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Adrian(vivo) responds and proposed rev03. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. === CC#2 === Adrian (vivo) comments and r04. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and is fine with r04. Walter Dees (Philips) requests clarification Adrian (vivo) responds to Walter (Philips) Hong (Qualcomm) comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008279 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#1: Information element clarifications. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007712R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007664 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#1 on 5G DDNMF aspect. | Qualcomm Incorporated, vivo, CATT | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | Runze(Huawei) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) outcome of this paper depends on CC discussion. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Runze (Huawei) objects to r02. === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007219 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Evaluation and conclusion on key issue 1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments outcome of this paper depends on CC discussion. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Walter Dees (Philips) asks question about merge Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Walter Dees (Philips). Walter Dees (Philips) comments to Deng Qiang (CATT). Runze (Huawei) replied to Dengqiang and Walter. === Phase 2 final deadline === Runze (Huawei) provides r01 based on the outcome of CC#2b. === CC#3 === Jianhua (OPPO) don't think we have the way forward that the 5G DDNMF will be mandatory support in 5GS Runze (Huawei) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Runze. Runze (Huawei) replies to Jianhua. === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#2: Direct Communication | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007713 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#2: Clear identification TS 23.287 [5] clause 5.2 is being extended with new data types. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#3: UE-to-Network Relay | - | - | Docs:=60 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007491 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: New Solution #X: Determining the slice of the PDU Session supporting relayed traffic. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Wen (vivo) comments for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to respect the agreed work plan and Note the paper. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Hong (Qualcomm). Hannu (Nokia) responds to Jianhua (OPPO) that this is not a new solution but general enhancement to multiple solutions and shares r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask question for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) propose to NOTED this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hannu (Nokia) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT) Hannu (Nokia) replies to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) propose to NOTED this paper and come back next meeting. Changhong (Intel) comments. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007683 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: New sol: Secure PC5 link establishment for L3 UE-to-NW relay. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to NOTE this paper. Changhong (Intel) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper with a new solution. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007296 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #6: Update to Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay . | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008280. | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies to LG. Steve (Huawei) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Huawei and Interdigital. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LG. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT, Qualcomm, Huawei and LG. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. === CC#2 === Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) proposes a draft NOTE. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) agrees with LG Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Ihab Guirguis (FirstNet) agrees with LG and Samsung and we support r01 Steve (Huawei) provides r02 LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. Ihab Guirguis (FirstNet) is OK with r02 Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r02 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is OK with r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008280 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #6: Update to Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007296R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007214 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#7: Update to resolve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008281. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008281 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#7: Update to resolve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007214R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007730 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #7: Update for support of IMS Emergency Services over L2 relay. | Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) suggests to NOTE. Sudeep (Apple) responds to Hong's comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides further comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === James (AT&T) provides comments on the potential requirement to support IMS emergency service over relay === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007218 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#19: Update to remove DNN for L2 Relay discovery and selection. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007689 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#23: Update N3IWF selection for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008282. | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r01 and ask question for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02 and answers the questions. Walter Dees (Philips) requests clarification Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Walter. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r03 with Interdigital co-signing. Hong (Qualcomm) provide r04. Walter Dees (Philips) is ok with r04 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is ok with r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008282 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#23: Update N3IWF selection for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007689R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007388 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #6, 24, 25 to address ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008283. | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Yali (OPPO) replies. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01 as solution update. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008283 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #6, 24, 25 to address ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007388R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007215 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#24: Update on the configured QoS mapping. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008284. | Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Yali (OPPO) comments. Yali (OPPO) comments again and pls skip my previous mail for this thread. Steve (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask question for clarification. === CC#2 === Changhong (Intel) objects to original version and provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r01. Hong (Qualcomm) objects original version, fine with r01. Steve (Huawei) can accept r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008284 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#24: Update on the configured QoS mapping. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007215R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007351 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#24: Updates to the E2E QoS mapping. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments Wen (vivo) replies Deng Qiang (CATT) thinks this has been covered by sol#25 and can be NOTED. Wen (vivo) replies to Deng Qiang and can't accept NOTED. Deng Qiang (CATT) further comments. Wen (vivo) replies. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r00 as solution update. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2007386 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #24 about RQ. | OPPO, Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008285. | Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008285 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #24 about RQ. | OPPO, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007386R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007216 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#25: Update to clarify the QoS handling. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008286. | Yali (OPPO) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Steve (Huawei) comments, prefers original. === CC#2 === Yali (OPPO) can only accept r01. Steve (Huawei) comments, provides way forward. Yali (OPPO) replies. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008286 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#25: Update to clarify the QoS handling. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007216R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007350 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#25: Updates to the QoS handling for Layer-3 relay. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008287 | Yali (OPPO) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2007384. Wen (vivo) replies according to OPPO(Yali)'s proposal. Yali (OPPO) replies. Wen (vivo) replies. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Yali (OPPO) replies to Hong. Wen (vivo) replies to Hong's comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yali (OPPO) clarifies this paper has been merged to S2-2007384. === Phase 2 final deadline === Wen (vivo) confirm. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2007384 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #25. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007350, to S2-2008287. | Yali (OPPO) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Yali (OPPO) replies to Deng Qiang. Changhong (Intel) comments. Yali (OPPO) replies to Changhong. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Yali (OPPO) can accept the original version and r01, but object to r02. Mehrdad clarifies that Alt 2 is wrong in original version and r01 and can not progress to normative phase. Yali (OPPO) replies to Mehrdad. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yali (OPPO) replies to Mehrdad, prefer to approve r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) does not stop r01 but this solution has several issues and cannot go to normative work. Yali (OPPO) confirms we still prefer to approve r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === Wen (vivo) is fine with r01. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008287 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Sol #25. | OPPO, vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007384R01, merging S2-2007350. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007622 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Solution 26 Update: Resolve EN and Add Clarification. | Intel | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006865 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #27: Update to add alternative. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Deng Qian (CATT). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r00 as solution update. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2007733 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update Solution#28 to remove EN. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008288. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) thanks Changhong and is fine with r01. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008288 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update Solution#28 to remove EN. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007733R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007213 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#30: Update on Authorization for Indirect Network Communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005646 from S2#140E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008289. | Changhong (Intel) comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) provides r02, please disregard r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008289 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#30: Update on Authorization for Indirect Network Communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007213R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006928 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#40 Update for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008290. | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and thinks this solution is incomplete. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008290 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#40 Update for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006928R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006962 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Solution #42. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008291. | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) provides r01 LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01. === CC#2 === Jianhua(OPPO) responds to LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r02. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) further comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r03. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04. Steve (Huawei) provides r05 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008291 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Update to Solution #42. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006962R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007442 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #44: Update Procedures of QoS Handling. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008292. | Changhong (Intel) comments. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Changhong (Intel) and provides r01. Steve (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Steve (HUAWEI). Steve (Huawei) comments, suggests to note. === CC#2 === Hao Dong (ZTE) provides r02 to address comment/suggestion from Steve (HUAWEI). Steve (Huawei) provides r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hao Dong (ZTE) is OK with r03. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008292 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #44: Update Procedures of QoS Handling. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007442R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007444 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #45: Update to remove ENs and add clarifications. | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008293. | Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies to Myungjune (LGE). Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Myungjune (LGE) provides comments and asks clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Deng Qiang replies to Steve (Huawei). === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Steve (Huawei) checks which version is the latest and which might be approved Deng Qiang (CATT) provided r01 on 14th Oct (forgot to mention in Comments for notes), r01 is assumed to be agreeable. Tao(Chair) r01 does not shown in chairman notes. Ok I then check whether r01 can be approved? === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008293 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #45: Update to remove ENs and add clarifications. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007444R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007271 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Sol#47 update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008294. CC#4: r01 with an editor's note agreed. Revised to S2-2008294 | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask question for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) ask a question about lifetime of the authorisation Deng Qiang (CATT) reminds S2-2007489 is also updating this solution, please make sure they are not conflict. Hannu (Nokia) asks about UE identification. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT) and proposes to take 7489 instead of 7271. Hannu (Nokia) proposes two alternative solutions to the conflict between 7489 and 7271. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Steve (Huawei) was there a reply to the question about lifetime and subsequent failure to connect? === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Hannu (Nokia) repeats the questions on 'Relay authorisation info' and the use of Remote UE SUCI. Hannu (Nokia) thanks Judy for explanation and proposes to update the text in the next SA2. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008294 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Sol#47 update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007271R01r01 with an editor's note. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007489 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Solution update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved. CC#4: r01 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007957. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 as possible plan B that can be used depending on discussion on 7271. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2007957 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Solution update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007489R01. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007686 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Closing Editor's Notes in TR 23.752 based on RAN WG2 conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008295. | Steve (Huawei) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008295 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Closing Editor's Notes in TR 23.752 based on RAN WG2 conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007686R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007666 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for L3 UE-to-Network Relay solutions for Key Issue#3. | Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised to S2-2008296. | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Steve (Huawei) comments on conclusion formulation === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Steve and Jianhua, and fine with r01. Jianhua (OPPO) asks further question for supporting non-IP Jicheol (Samsung) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03 Changhong (Intel) provides r04 LaeYoung (LGE) comments to Q from Jianhua (OPPO). Steve (Huawei) provides r05 Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Jianhua. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06. Steve (Huawei) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks question on 'showstopper'. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung (LG). LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Jianhua (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments and provides r07. Steve (Huawei) provides r07 (the r07 that Deng Qiang (CATT) mentioned previously was another document). Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r08 based on r06. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r09 based on r08 Steve (Huawei) provides r10 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Guillaume (MediaTek): ok with r10 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r10 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008296 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for L3 UE-to-Network Relay solutions for Key Issue#3. | Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007666R10. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006864 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Evaluation and Conclusion - Secondary Authentication aspects. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008297. | Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Myungjune (LGE) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT). Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments and propose to NOTE. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Hong (Qualcomm). === CC#2 === Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postponed this paper. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Deng Qiang (CATT) and provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) objects r01 and provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) prefer r01 but can live with r02. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008297 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Evaluation and Conclusion - Secondary Authentication aspects. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006864R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006966 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion on Relay PDU Session establishment for UE-to-Network Relay. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to postpone this paper. Jianhua(OPPO) responds to Changhong (Intel) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to NOTE it or merge it to S2-2007734. Jianhua (OPPO) responds Xiaoyan (Interdigital). === CC#2 === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Xiaoyan. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) propose to NOTE this contribution. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007734 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for KI #3 on handling of PDU Session related attributes for L3 NW relay. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to postpone this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Changhong. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note or postpose the contribution. === CC#2 === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note this paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua and provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) objects all versions, including original and revisions. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) asks OPPO indicate the reason for objection clearly. Jianhua (OPPO) give reasons for objection. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua that all OPPO's concern has been replies in previous email. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007392 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion for QoS handling of L3 UE-to-Network Relay. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yali (OPPO) proposes to use this paper as baseline to capture the conclusion of L3 U2N Relay QoS. Hannu (Nokia) responds to Yali (OPPO). Yali (OPPO) provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version and r01. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and replies to Yali (OPPO). Changhong (Intel) proposes to POSTPONE this paper. Yali (OPPO) replies. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO, Intel and Qualcomm. Wen (vivo) replies. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Yali. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. === CC#2 === Yali (OPPO) provides r02. Wen (vivo) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to POSTPONED this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007297 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion for QoS handling of L3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yali (OPPO) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2007392 for the discussion of L3 U2N Relay QoS. Hannu (Nokia) asks to see the merged text. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO. We need to agree on the grounds for merging before we proceed. Changhong (Intel) proposes to POSTPONE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Intel and asks for clarification. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to POSTPONED this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007352 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, evaluation and conclusion for KI #3 on the L3 relay QoS handling. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yali (OPPO) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2007392 for the discussion of L3 U2N Relay QoS. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Yali (OPPO) and asks for revision to show the merged document Changhong (Intel) proposes to POSTPONE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to POSTPONED this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007220 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation for KI#3 on L2 UE-to-Network Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006963 and S2-2007669, to S2-2008298. | Steve (Huawei) provides r01 merging S2-2006963 & S2-2007669 following the sugguestion from the rapporteur. Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01, and ask to copy 7669 structure for conclusion formulation. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Steve (Huawei) comments on formulation === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Steve. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed WF on formulation and also r02. Jianhua(OPPO) provides r03 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r04 Changhong (Intel) provides r05. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 Deng Qiang (CATT) comments and provides r07. Steve (Huawei) provides r08 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) is fine with r08. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r08. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008298 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation for KI#3 on L2 UE-to-Network Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007220R08, merging S2-2006963 and S2-2007669. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006963 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion for Layer-2 based UE-to-Network Relay (solution #7). | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008298 | Steve (Huawei) Following the sugguestion from the rapporteur this should be merged with S2-2007220. Jianhua(OPPO) is OK to merge into S2-2007220. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2007669 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Key Issue#3: Interim conclusion for L2 UE-to-Network Relay solutions . | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008298 | Steve (Huawei) following the sugguestion from the rapporteur this should be merged with S2-2007220. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2006965 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Evaluation and conclusion for Layer-2 based UE-to-Network Relay selection and PLMN selection. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Changhong. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to POSTPONE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Guillaume (MediaTek) comments. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007353 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, evaluation and conclusion for KI #3 on the L2 relay QoS handling. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposed to NOTED or POSTPONED this paper. Wen(vivo) replies. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) also suggests to wait for RAN2 progress. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007221 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Overall evaluation for KI#3. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008299. | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postponed this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Mehrdad (Samsung) also suggests to wait for RAN2 progress. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE. Deng Qiang (CATT) propose to NOTE. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008299 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Overall evaluation for KI#3. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007221R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007731 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for Key Issue #3. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postponed this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#4: UE-to-UE Relay | - | - | Docs:=17 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007735 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #4, New Sol #X: Privacy handling for Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay based on IP routing. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper with new solution. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to LaeYoung and provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) also proposes to NOTE this paper with new solution. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong, Dengqiang. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) propose to Note the contribution. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007272 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Update to Sol#8 to Add Details and Clarifications. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks questions. Judy (Ericsson) answers questions from Dengqiang (CATT). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks follow up questions. Jianhua (OPPO) provide comments on NOTE 4. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Jianhua (OPPO) and Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) and provide r01. === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to postpone this contribution. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments on Judy (Ericsson). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007212 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#9: Update on protocol stacks for Layer 2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005643 from S2#140E. Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Weijun (Huawei) provides r01. Jianhua(OPPO) proposes to Note the paper. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Weijun (Huawei) responds to Jianhua (OPPO) and Hong (Qualcomm) and provides r02. Jianhua (OPPO) still think the paper is not correct. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong and Jianhua. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments this solution is not aligned with RAN2 conclusion. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan (Interdigital). Weijun (Huawei) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT). Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies to Hong. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Deng Qiang. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Xiaoyan. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and asks for explanation of the protocol stack to support the procedures in this sol. Weijun (Huawei) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). Jianhua (OPPO) proposes we don't discuss how to design the AS protocol. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Weijun (Huawei) objects to r04 and provides r05. === CC#2 === Jianhua(OPPO) provides r06 on top of r04. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) object r06 and provides r07 on top of r05 with co-signing. Jianhua (OPPO) can only accept r06, and object any of other versions. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007217 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#9: Update on connection establishment for Layer 2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008300. | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to NOTE this paper. Weijun (Huawei) response to Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) and provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) response to Weijun. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008300 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#9: Update on connection establishment for Layer 2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007217R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007443 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #4, Sol #49: Update to Clarify the Mapping Information for Relay. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007447 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #4, Sol #50 Update regarding Candidate UE-to-UE Relay. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments Hao Dong (ZTE) answers Q from Deng Qiang (CATT). Jianhua (OPPO) comments whether the pCR is needed. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) supports this proposal. Jianhua (OPPO) provide further comments. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Hao. Wen (vivo) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua and Wen. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua(OPPO) objects all versions. Jianhua(OPPO) changes the view and suggests to postpone. Hao Dong (ZTE) agrees to postpone the pCR for further discussion. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007736 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #4, Sol #50: Update to add more details to UE-to-UE Relay Re-selection. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008301. | Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong and provide r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008301 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #4, Sol #50: Update to add more details to UE-to-UE Relay Re-selection. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007736R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007355 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Evaluation and conclusion for KI #4 UE-to-UE relay. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong (Intel) asks to POSTPONE this paper. Hong (Qualcomm) also suggest to POSTPONE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note or postpone the paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007222 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Evaluation for KI#4 on L2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) asks to POSTPONE this paper. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) propose to NOTE this paper. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) doesn't agree to note the paper. Xiaoyan proposes SA2 should give conclusions on both L2 and L3 solution. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments sol#9 is not ready for conclusion. Weijun (Huawei) provides clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides replies to Qiang, Hong and provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm) OBJECTs original version and r01. Jianhua(OPPO) objects any version concluding solution #9. === CC#2 === Weijun (Huawei) responds to Jianhua (OPPO), Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) and Hong (Qualcomm). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2006964 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Evaluation and conclusion on Layer-2 based UE-to-UE Relay . | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) asks to POSTPONE this paper. Hong (Qualcomm) provide comments and suggest to POSTPONE or NOTE the paper. Judy (Ericsson) comments Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2007222. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) provides response and r01, === CC#2 === Xiaoyan Shi (OPPO) proposes to note this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007273 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Interim Conclusion for UE-to-UE relay. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007670. Noted | Changhong (Intel) asks to merge this paper into S2-2007670. Judy (Ericsson) agrees to merge 7273 into 7670. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007670 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#4. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01. Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments Judy (Ericsson) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) object this contribution. Suggest to use S2-2007223 or S2-2007732 as baseline to merge. Weijun (Huawei) agrees with Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) and provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Jianhua (OPPO) proposes a way forward for progress. Weijun (Huawei) responds to Hong (QC) and Jianhua (OPPO) and provides r02. Thank Jianhua and Weijun. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r03. Jianhua (OPPO) provide r04 and suggest to focus on L3 conclusion. Hong (Qualcomm) objects r02 and r03. Changhong (Intel) provides r05. Weijun (Huawei) propose to NOTE this paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) propose to NOTE this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007391 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Evaluation and conclusion for QoS handling of UE-to-UE Relay. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2007670. Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to Merge this paper into S2-2007670. Yali (OPPO) replies. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007732 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for Key Issue #4. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to Merge this paper into S2-2007670. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Changhong. === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) proposes to NOTE. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) objects all versions. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007223 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4: Overall evaluation for KI#4. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Changhong (Intel) proposes to Postpone it. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Weijun (Huawei) responds to Changhong (Intel) and Jianhua (OPPO) and provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Jianhua (OPPO) is fine with r01, object original version. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r01. Changhong (Intel) asks Weijun to upload a .zip file, my company doesn't allow me to open .rar file on my laptop. Hong (Qualcomm) comments that r01 is in a format not usable. Hong (Qualcomm) suggests to POSTPONE the paper. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to POSTPONED this paper. R01 Zip file is also uploaded as requested by Changhong. === Phase 2 final deadline === Weijun (Huawei) reuploaded a .zip file. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#5: Path Selection | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007623 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Solution#51: Update to Option 1. | Intel, LG Electronics, CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008302. | Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) cannot accept original version Changhong (Intel) replies to Mehrdad. Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies to Intel that Samsung did suggest some changes in r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Changhong (Intel) replies to Mehrdad and provides r02. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) prefers r00, but can live with r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) prefers r01 and may live with r02 but objects to original version. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008302 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Solution#51: Update to Option 1. | Intel, LG Electronics, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007623R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007298 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5: Evaluation and Conclusion- Direct communication path selection. | Samsung, Huawei, Apple, ZTE, ITRI | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005169 from S2#140E. Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT Toon Norp (KPN) asks a question for clarification Changhong (Intel) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2007445. Mehrdad (Samsung) requests to wait until CC#2. Steve (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Sudeep (Apple) responds to Toon Norp (KPN). Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Sudeep (Apple) comments. === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) comments that the outcome depends on CC discussion, so we need to discuss this paper with S2-2007445. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007445 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Conclusion: Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | CATT, OPPO, LG Electronics, Intel | Rel-17 | Postponed | Mehrdad (Samsung) does not accept original version. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) the outcome depends on CC discussion. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to postpone this based on the CC outcome. We object to the original version. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#7: PC5 Charging | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006848 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004816 from S2#140E. Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to partially merge of this contribution (in clause 7.7 area) to 7490r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) the evaluation part can be merged into S2-2007490, the conclusion part depends on CC outcome. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007274 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to partially merge of this contribution (in clause 7.7 area) to 7490 and to revise 7274 to make it clause 8.7 update only. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) the evaluation part can be merged into S2-2007490, the conclusion part depends on CC outcome. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2006961 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and interim conclusion for PC5 usage information configuration. | OPPO, NEC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to partially merge of this contribution (in clause 7.7 area) to 7490r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) the evaluation part can be merged into S2-2007490, the conclusion part depends on CC outcome. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007662 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#7. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida, Matrixx, CATT | Rel-17 | Postponed | Linghang (NEC) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hong (Qualcomm) answers Linghang. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Deng Qiang (CATT) the evaluation part can be merged into S2-2007490, the conclusion part depends on CC outcome. Tao(Chair) request to have well prepared CC since many papers dependents on the so called 'CC outcome' magic. It reads not clear how those are impacted and proceed. The baseline paper shall be clear by then. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2007490 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7, Charging, solution evaluation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008303. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 intended to merge updates on clause 7.7 from 7274, 6961 and 6848. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments to r01. Jianhua (OPPO) asks question to Hong. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Jianhua. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Gerald (Matrixx) supports the way forward with comments. Hannu (Nokia) thanks for the feedback and shares r02. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hannu (Nokia) can agree either the earlier r02 or r03 provided by Hong (Qualcomm). === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008303 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7, Charging solution evaluation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007490R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | KI#8: Service Authorization | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007448 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #8 Conclusion: Update to Resolve Editor's Note. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006979 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Sol#17: Clarification on some policy/parameters. | LG Electronics, Intel, Samsung, CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008304. | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) points out that Deng Qiang (CATT) used wrong email thread, so r01 provided by him is not for this paper. Previously, r01 was provided by LaeYoung (LGE). === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to approve r01. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008304 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Sol#17: Clarification on some policy/parameters. | LG Electronics, Intel, Samsung, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006979R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2006929 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, #8, Resolve EN in Sol #35: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-Network Relay Service. | Fraunhofer HHI | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Judy (Ericsson) comment. Changhong (Intel) still proposes to NOTE this paper and keep the EN open. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine to NOTE this paper. Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) answers to the comments and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) comments about security LaeYoung (LGE) is wondering how SM PCF for the Relay can acquire UE policy for ProSe for Remote UE. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) replies to the comments from Huawei and LGE and provides r03. === CC#2 === LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on r03. Steve (Huawei) should be noted? Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE it. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2007354 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3&8, Sol#35, Updates to relay authorization information of NG-RAN. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008305. | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Wen (vivo) provides r01 based on OPPO(Jianhua)'s comments . === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008305 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3&8, Sol#35, Updates to relay authorization information of NG-RAN. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007354R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007624 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Conclusion for Key Issue#8 on UE-to-Network Relay. | Intel | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008306. | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to move this conclusion to KI#3. Changhong (Intel) prefers to keep the conclusion related to authorization aspect to KI#8. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Changhong (Intel) replies to Jianhua's comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Changhong (Intel) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2008306 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Conclusion for Key Issue#8 on UE-to-Network Relay. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007624R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2007625 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Conclusion for Key Issue#8 on UE-to-UE Relay. | Intel | Rel-17 | Approved | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes to move this conclusion to KI#4. Changhong (Intel) prefers to keep the conclusion related to authorization aspect to KI#8. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Changhong. Changhong (Intel) replies to Xiaoyan and Jianhua's comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Study on architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (FS_5MBS) | - | - | Docs:=127 | - | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007512 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Architecture#: Discussion and proposal on the convergence of architecture. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006890, S2-2006988 and S2-2007261, to S2-2008084. | zhendong (ZTE) provides r01 zhendong (ZTE), the 6988, 7261 and 6890 are merged into 7512 according to the MBS cc Judy (Ericsson) provide r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Thomas (Nokia) provides r04. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r06. Judy (Ericsson) provide r07. LiMeng (Huawei) provide r08. David (Samsung) provides r09. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r09. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008084 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Architecture#: Discussion and proposal on the convergence of architecture. | ZTE, Ericsson, Huawei, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007512R09, merging S2-2006890, S2-2006988 and S2-2007261. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007671 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Proposed Merged Baseline Architecture. | Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2008085. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Miguel (Qualcomm) is ok with r01 Fenqin (Huawei) provide r03 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r04 Judy (Ericsson) provide r05 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r06 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008085 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Proposed Merged Baseline Architecture. | Qualcomm Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007671R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006988 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: On the Consolidated Architecture. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008084 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007261 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Architecture consideration . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008084 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007262 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Traffic delivery methods. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007262r06 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007933. | Jeffrey (Juniper) provides comments and r1. Judy (Ericsson) provides comments and prefers the original revision. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Judy (Ericsson) comments and prefers r1 or a newly proposed text in this email. Thomas (Nokia) provides r2. Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r03. Thomas (Nokia) provide r04. Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === zhendong (ZTE) provides r05 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06 Xiaoyan (CATT) can accept r02, but objects to other revisions. Judy (Ericsson) asks Xiaoyan (CATT) to provide justification why the new note is not needed. Ericsson provided justification in the paper and discussion that the note is necessary because the same term is currently used for different purposes in the TR which causes confusion. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Judy (Ericsson) object r02, accepts all other revisions, and asks Xiaoyan (CATT) to reconsider their position. Andy (VC, Samsung) asks CATT to clarify their concern with the NOTE. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007933 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Traffic delivery methods. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007262R06. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007281 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on individual delivery definition. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2008086. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. David (Samsung) is OK with r02. Modified text in r02 seems a reasonable clarification. Richard (BBC) provides r03 which further refines this to clarify that the cardinality of PDU Sessions associated with a multicast session will be one or more. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Thomas (Nokia) comments and provides r04. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r05. === CC#2 === Thomas (Nokia) accepts r05. zhendong (ZTE) r05 is fine Richard (BBC) accepts formulation in r04, and update in r05. Provides a minor editorial fix in r06. David (Samsung) is OK with r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008086 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on individual delivery definition. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007281R06. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007528 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Stage 2 work on interface between MSF-C and MSF-U | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008087 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007691 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} LS on Service Layer aspects for 5G MBS | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007528, to S2-2008087. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 that merges content of S2-2007528 === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 aligned with comments provided during offline discussion. Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r02. LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and Vivo and asks that we do terminology alignment across documents. Miguel (Qualcomm) prefers MBSF-C/U terminology as it's more descriptive of their functionalities split into user and control plane, and also neutral David (Samsung) provides r04. Thomas (Nokia) accepts r04. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with r04 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r06. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r07 with editorials. Thomas (Nokia) provides r08 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008087 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Service Layer aspects for 5G MBS | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007691R08, merging S2-2007528. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006817 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG RAN: Reply LS on RAN impact of FS_5MBS Study | TSG RAN (RP-202086) | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to NOTE this LS. Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees with LiMeng to NOTE this LS. Judy (Ericsson) agrees to NOTE this LS. Thomas (Nokia) agrees to NOTE this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2006828 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG SA: Reply LS on RAN impact of FS_5MBS Study | TSG SA (SP-200884) | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to NOTE this LS. Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees with LiMeng to NOTE this LS. Judy (Ericsson) agrees to NOTE this LS. Thomas (Nokia) agrees to NOTE this LS. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=45 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007263 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: new Sol: Support broadcast service. | Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008088. | LiMeng (Huawei) asks question for clarification. Judy (Ericsson) responds to LiMeng (Huawei) and provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Judy (Ericsson) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) asks a f/up Q for clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Yonatan (KPN) asks a question for clarification. === CC#2 === Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r03 Thomas (Nokia) provide r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008088 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: new Sol: Support broadcast service. | Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007263R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007688 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: New Solution to Key Issue #1 for Broadcast Service. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008089. | Judy (Ericsson) provide r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Judy's question and includes r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008089 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: New Solution to Key Issue #1 for Broadcast Service. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007688R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007282 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution 2 EN clarifications. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2 2007282r01 with added note agreed. Revised to S2-2007934. Updates solutions 2, 11 and 12 (KI#1) and solution 35 (KI#4) | Judy (Ericsson) provide r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) agree the comments from Xiaoyan (CATT) related to the removal of the EN on HL MC address. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Zhenhua (vivo) and Xiaoyan (CATT). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r00/r01. Judy (Ericsson) comments that Xiaoyan (CATT)'s objection lacks of technical basis and ask to reconsider her position. === Phase 2 final deadline === Judy (Ericsson) provides r02 adding note 'HL MC address is not used by PSA-UPF for receiving MBS session data in this solution' === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007934 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution 2 EN clarifications. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007282R01 with added note. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006900 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: Modification for clarification. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008090. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008090 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: Modification for clarification. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006900R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006901 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: Clarification on N9 tunnel operation. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008091. | Judy (Ericsson) ask Q. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008091 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: Clarification on N9 tunnel operation. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006901R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007329 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1: Update of solution #5 on broadcast. | CBN, CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008092 | Thomas (Nokia) suggests merging this document into S2-2007557 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007557 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of solution #5. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007329, to S2-2008092. | Shuang (CBN) provides r01. Thomas(Nokia) accepts r01. This is the result of an offline merger with S2-2007329 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === LiMeng (Huawei) Provides r02. Thomas (Nokia) accpts r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008092 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of solution #5. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CBN, CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007557R02, merging S2-2007329. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007530 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#6: adding leave and release procedures. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008093. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Youngkyo(Samsung) provides reply to Thomas (Nokia) and the revision r02 Thomas (Nokia) requests further improvements Youngkyo(Samsung) provides answer to comment of Thomas (Nokia) and revision r03 Thomas(Nokia provides r04 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05 Youngkyo(samsung) is okay with r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008093 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#6: adding leave and release procedures. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007530R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007531 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#9: adding leave and release procedures. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007516 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol#10 update to clarify the ENs. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008094. | LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) withdraw the previous comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === zhendong (ZTE) provides the response and r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008094 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol#10 update to clarify the ENs. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007516R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007567 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #14: Update MBS Session Management procedure. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006902 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#15: Update handover when target gNB does not transmit data for a MB session. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | LiMeng (Huawei) asks questions for clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) response. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2006971 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Update to solution #13. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006985 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution #3. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008096 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this contribution into S2-2007196, LiMeng (Huawei) accepts to merge S2-2006985 into S2-2007196. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007197 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Update to Interim Requirements on UP join/leave and Application Awareness. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Judy (Ericsson) propose to merge 7197 either into 7774 (i.e. base doc for KI#1 evaluation) or into 7672 (i.e. based doc for KI#1 Conclusion). Lei(Tencent) respond to Judy (Ericsson), fine to merge into 7672 if people are ok. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007287 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution #33 to address editor´s note. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Judy (Ericsson) comments that the interface between MBSF and MBSU requires SA4 feedback/support and proposes to postpone this paper. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Judy Judy (Ericsson) comment it is not SA2 decision on protocol choice, and as such cannot agree with this paper. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides additional comments and provides detailed explanation and comments that if this is the right protocol choice then stage 3 WG can easily come to the same conclusion without SA2. Thomas (Nokia) replies that the proposal is rather about the stage 2 requirements and provides rev1 Thomas(Nokia) replies to Shabnam Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Thomas providing more details. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Richard (BBC) provides more context of SA4 MBS subworking group activities and recommends deeper engagement with SA4 on this topic. Judy (Ericsson) objects to all revisions as SA4 feedback/support is required for the interface between MBSF and MBSU as expressed in LS 7691. Thomas (Nokia) responds to Shabnam. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2007266 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Sol#3: Evaluation and Conclusion on IGMP JOIN . | Ericsson, Samsung, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Richard (BBC) comments regarding User Plane multicast join: In the narrow IPTV Use Case, UE-side interworking between IGMP/MLD and 5MBS Control Plane signalling may be possible by implementing this function in the IPTV Residential Gateway device, as suggested in contribution S2-2007266. However, unless a general purpose interworking function can be defined independently of the IPTV technical specification, and mandated in a broader range of 5MBS-compatible UEs, we conclude that some form of User Plane multicast join needs to be supported by the network in order to satisfy a broader set of transport-only multicast Use Cases. Regardless of whether the interworking function is realised in the UE or in the network, it is an architectural enhancement needed for 5G multicast-broadcast, and is therefore relevant to the scope of the FS_5MBS study. It should be properly documented in TR 23.757 in order to guide future normative work. This could be achieved by expanding the text proposed in S2-2007266. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Thomas (Nokia) comments. === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide 7266r01 to address Richard's comment and such change will be taken as input to the merging to 7774. zhendong (ZTE) provides comment to judy Judy (Ericsson) responds to Zhendong (ZTE) zhendong (ZTE) responds to judy Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy Richard (BBC) accepts r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) comments and disagrees with S2-2007266 r00/r01. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Thomas (Nokia) and asks Xiaoyan (CATT) to clarify which legacy UE supports IGMP and which legacy UE supports 5MBS. Thomas Nokia replies to Judy === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007267 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Sol#3 Evaluation on PCC rule handling and multicast group configuration. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | LiMeng (Huawei) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Thomas (Nokia) comments. === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) responds and comments. Thomas (Nokia) replies === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007774 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Evaluation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2 2007774r09 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006832, S2-2006891, S2-2006892, S2-2006896, S2-2006893, S2-2006972, S2-2006986, S2-2007266, S2-2007267 and S2-2007514, to S2-2007935 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 which is an attempt to merge various other evaluation proposals Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04 Judy (Ericsson) provides r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Thomas (Nokia) objects against r05, provides r06. Judy (Ericsson) accepts r05, and objects to r06 and other revisions. LiMeng (Huawei) suggests we could remove the 'faster' related description for CP/UP based join in the revision. Judy (Ericsson) accepts LiMeng (Huawei)'s proposal to remove the 'faster' related description from r06, and keep the rest. Judy (Ericsson) prefers late revision r07 to follow Li Meng (Hauwei) suggestion === Phase 2 final deadline === Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy and makes new text proposal.. Thomas (Nokia) provides rev8 with compromise text proposal Comments that link to revision Judy suggested points to wrong document Thomas (Nokia) provides rev9 with compromise text agreed offline with Judy === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007935 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Evaluation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT, ZTE, Ericsson, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007774R09, merging S2-2006832, S2-2006891, S2-2006892, S2-2006896, S2-2006893, S2-2006972, S2-2006986, S2-2007266, S2-2007267 and S2-2007514. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007514 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, proposal on evaluation for KI#1. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006832 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1 evaluation. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006891 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#1 - session operation. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006892 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#1 - service continuity. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006986 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1: Evaluation. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007264 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Interim Conclusion: 5GC Individual MBS traffic delivery method. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008095. CC#4: Merged into S2 2007937 | David (Samsung) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2008095 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Interim Conclusion: 5GC Individual MBS traffic delivery method. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007264R01. CC#4: S2-2007264 should be merged into S2 2007937 instead of revised. S2 2008095 was then withdrawn. | Withdrawn | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007265 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Interim conclusion on MBS Session/Service Id . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2006987 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1: Conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006896 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion on KI#1 - MBS session management. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006972 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Evaluation and conclusion on MBS Session deactivation and activation. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006991 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1 interim conclusion for MBS session management triggered by AF. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007513 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, conclusion on the MBS session ID. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007515 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, discussion and interim conclusion on the several aspect of key issue #1. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007566 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1: Update the conclusion of MBS session management to include MBS Session Stop. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007937 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007672 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusions for Key Issue #1 on Multicast session model. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | CC#4: S2-2007672r12 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007264, S2-2007197 S2-2007265 S2-2006987 S2-2006991, S2-2007513, S2-2007515 and S2-2007566, to S2-20079 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r03. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r04 LiMeng (Huawei) kindly asks the source of r04. David (Samsung) provides r05 Judy (Ericsson) corrects comments for notes that Judy (Ericsson) (instead of Xiaoyan (CATT)) provided r04. Miguel (Qualcomm) says r04 is actually not mine LiMeng (Huawei) provides r06. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r07. Thomas (Nokia) provides r08. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Judy (Ericsson) comments Zhenhua (vivo) response to Judy (Ericsson) Xiaoyan (CATT) comments. Zhenhua (vivo) suggest Xiaoyan (CATT) add a EN for this issue to make progress for the pCR, and bring the new revision in CC. Aihua(China Mobile) proposes to support of AF requested MBS session establishment. Miguel (Qualcomm) is ok with r06 or r07 and objects to r08 Judy (Ericsson) prefers r04, can live with r05/06/07 and objects to r08 and other revisions. LiMeng (Huawei) suggest to go with r06 and can live with r07. === Phase 2 final deadline === Thomas (Nokia) objects to all revisions before r08 Provides r09 to address the concern of Miguel Miguel (Qualcomm) can live with r09. Youngkyo(Samsung) provide a comment and revision r10. Zhenhua (vivo) ask for clarification on r10. Aihua(China Mobile) proposes to add an EN with respect to the mechanism of AF requested MBS session establishment and provides r11. Youngkyo(Samsung) answer to Zhenhua (vivo). Zhenhua (vivo) responses to Youngkyo(Samsung). === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007937 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusions for Key Issue #1 on Multicast session model. | Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007672R12, merging S2-2007264, S2-2007197 S2-2007265 S2-2006987 S2-2006991, S2-2007513, S2-2007515 and S2-2007566. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007195 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#2 Update of Solution #1. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005659 from S2#140E Merged into S2-2007938 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007285 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#2, Sol#1: Completion of multicast service levels. | Samsung | Rel-17 | CC#4: S2-2007285r07 with the changes from r13 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007195, to S2-2007938. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 that merges S2-2007195 Judy (Ericsson) asks Q for clarification LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02. David (Samsung) confirms LiMeng's understanding, objects to r01. Judy (Ericsson) provide r03. David (Samsung) provides r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) provide r04, objects to r01/r03. zhendong (ZTE) ask the question on the r04 LiMeng (Huawei) thinks r04 is from David (Samsung), and Xiaoyan (CATT) can further provide r05. David (Samsung) notifies Xiaoyan that CATT's r04 link points to previously shared Samsung's r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) provide r05/r06, objects to r01/r03. Thomas (Nokia) provide r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Judy (Ericsson) accepts r01/r03, objects to all other revisions. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks r03 is most reasonable. Youngkyo(Samsung) comments to LaeYoung(LGE)'s logic. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks comment from Youngkyo (Samsung) is fair, so broadcast is not directly related to this solution. Anyhow, she thinks r03 works for various deployment options although only multicast services are considered. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r05/06/07. David (Samsung) is OK with r07, objects to r01/r03. LaeYoung (LGE) can live with r07. Thomas (Nokia) suggest putting this on CC2b for show of hands and replies to LeeYoung LaeYoung (LGE) changed her position, so already provided comment that can live with r07. Andy (VC, Samsung) responds to Thomas, suggests a late revision instead. LiMeng (Huawei) suggest we can first try to figure out an agreeable version. LiMeng (Huawei) objects to r01 and r03, prefer r02/r04/r06, we can live with r07 only if the word 'ONLY' in the NOTE can be removed. Thomas (Nokia) replies that we need a reply of Judy whether putting switching to individual delivery on basic service level plus a correct note describing under which conditions this is required could be a way forward. Judy (Ericsson) responds that r03 captures the needed requirement and is aligned with WA. David (Samsung) clarifies to Judy. Judy (Ericsson) comments that even though Discussion part is not reflective of what is being proposed, we can accept a proposal if it is consistent, however this is not the case with r07 in our view. Thomas (Nokia) prefers r07 and objects r04/r05/r06 Provides late r08 to address the comment of LiMeng === Phase 2 final deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r09, taking the content out of both levels for now. We object to all revisions that haveIndividual delivery as basic Level. Thomas (Nokia) provides r10, really taking the content out of both levels as Shabnam was suggesting LiMeng (Huawei) prepares r11 based on r09 for the CC#3. Thomas (Nokia) prepares r12 based on r11 for the CC#3. LiMeng (Huawei) has a minor correction on r12 and provides r13 for the CC#3. David (Samsung) is OK bringing r13 to CC#3. Thomas (Nokia) is fine with rev13. LiMeng (Huawei) finds rev13 is problematic and withdrawn this revision. Thomas(Nokia) provides r15 for the CC#3. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks, good way taking r13 forward for approval. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007938 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#2, Sol#1: Completion of multicast service levels. | Samsung, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007285R07 with the changes from R13, merging S2-2007195. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007196 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#3 Update of Solution #3. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006985, to S2-2008096. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 and r02 and asks to ignore r01. This merges contents of S2-2006985 LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008096 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#3 Update of Solution #3. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007196R02, merging S2-2006985. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007268 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#3: Evaluation and Conclusion on authorization. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: r19 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007939. | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Judy (Ericsson) responds. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Thomas (Nokia) asks question about rev3. Zhenhua (vivo) replies Thomas (Nokia). Thomas (Nokia) provides late rev4 for CC Zhenhua (vivo) is fine with r04 Judy (Ericsson) is OK with r04 Fenqin(Huawei) ask question for clarification === Phase 2 final deadline === Zhenhua (vivo) replies Fenqin(Huawei) Fenqin(Huawei) provides r05 Zhenhua (vivo) is OK for r05 Thomas (Nokia) is OK with r05 Judy (Ericsson) provides r06. Thomas (Nokia) provides r07. Judy (Ericsson) provides r09 based Thomas' r07. Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Judy (Ericsson) and provides r10 based on r08. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r11 because r10 wrongly delete last 'service'. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007939 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#3: Evaluation and Conclusion on authorization. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007268R19. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006847 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #17: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008097. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008097 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #17: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006847R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007283 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4, Solution 2 QoS update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: r01 with 2 editor's notes added, as provided in r02 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007940. | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) responds and provide r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to r00/r01 and proposes a way forward. Judy (Ericsson) finds it unfair that Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to Ericsson papers without technical basis in different threads. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007940 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4, Solution 2 QoS update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007283R01 with 2 editor's notes added, as provided in R02. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007564 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #36: Remove the EN for the QoS Control for MBS Session . | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007284 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4, Non-GBR for 5MBS. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) suggest noting this PCR Paul (Ericsson) replies. Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to NOTE this paper Thomas (Nokia) replies to Paul === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2006833 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4 evaluation. | CATT | Rel-17 | CC#4: r04 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007941. | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01, as a merger of S2-2006833 and S2-2006893. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this contribution in r0, r01 and r02. Zhenhua (vivo) ask Paul (Ericsson) to reconsider the position. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Paul. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Paul (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) replies Paul (Ericsson). Paul (Ericsson) replies and objects to r03. Zhenhua (vivo) provide r04 to remove the controversial sentence and ask Paul (Ericsson) whether r04 is OK for approval in CC. Zhenhua (vivo) ask Paul (Ericsson) whether r04 is OK for approval in CC. === Phase 2 final deadline === Paul (Ericsson) replies. We can accept r04. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007941 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4 evaluation. | CATT, vivo | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006833R04. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006893 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#4 - QoS. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007935 | Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this contribution in r0. Zhenhua (vivo) informs that this PCR is merged into 6833 according to the offline CC. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2006834 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4 interim conclusion. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to NOTE this paper Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. We share Haris view and propose to note this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2006897 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion on K#4 - QoS level support. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008098 | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2006897 into S2-2007637 Thomas (Nokia) suggest considering this merged into S2-2007637 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007565 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4: Conclusion for MBS QoS Model and QoS Control. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008098 | Haris (Qualcomm) comments that we don't see value and use 'MBS Session AMBR' or 'UE AMBR' for MBS traffic Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification on requirements of the 'MBS Session AMBR' for MBS traffic Thomas (Nokia) shares concerns about value and use 'MBS Session AMBR' or 'UE AMBR' for MBS traffic Chunshan (Tencent) provides some clarification on MBS Session-AMBR. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Chunshan === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) thinks this paper should be marked as merged into S2-2007637 (Qualcomm). LiMeng (Huawei) wonders the fate of this document. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === Chunshan(Tencent) is OK to be merged into S2-2007637. === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007637 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4: Conclusions of QoS support for MBS . | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006897 and S2-2007565, to S2-2008098. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) provide r02 Zhenhua (vivo) response and provide r03 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r04 Haris (Qualcomm) asks question about the need to confirm with RAN WGs support for all unicast 5QIs Chunshan (Tencent) provides r05. Thomas (Nokia) provides r06. Paul (Ericsson) provides response. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) accepts r06, objects to r01~r06. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 text and indicates that other parts of r06 are not acceptable Xiaoyan (CATT) corrects the position to: accepts r06, objects to r01~r05 and r07. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with 06 and 07 Thomas (Nokia) replies to Haris and clarifies meaning of Rev6 text === Phase 2 final deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that understands the meaning of r06 and is ok === CC#3 === Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r06 and asks for co-sign this r06 paper. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008098 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4: Conclusions of QoS support for MBS . | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007637R06, merging S2-2006897 and S2-2007565. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007659 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} LS on Feedback on conclusions for QoS support in MBS | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Paul (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes to note this contribution. Haris (Qualcomm) comments that sending LS to RAN WGs if any concerns with assumption of non-GBR QoS flows is part of the WA proposed by the rapporteur Paul (Ericsson) provides response. LiMeng (Huawei) supports to document the support of non-GBR in the conclusion of KI#4. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#6 | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007450 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6, Sol#7, Update to clarify signaling procedures. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006980 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#20: Add SMF providing the latest multicast service area info to UE. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007238 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6 Update of Solution #21. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008099. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02 Judy (Ericsson) provides r03 Thomas(Nokia) accepts r02 Thomas (Nokia) accepts r03 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008099 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6 Update of Solution #21. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007238R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006982 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#38: Clarify target service area. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007529 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#38: Solve EN. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008100. | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay with LaeYoung(LGE) and Thomas (Nokia)'s comment and its revision r01. Youngkyo(Samsung) reply to LaeYoung(LGE) and provides its revision r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008100 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#38: Solve EN. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007529R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006894 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#6 - Local MBS service. | Vivo | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006989, to S2-2008101. | Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 to merge S2-2006989. Thomas(Nokia)) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Judy (Ericsson) provide r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008101 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#6 - Local MBS service. | Vivo, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006894R04, merging S2-2006989. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006989 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6: Evaluation. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008101 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006990 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6: Conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: r13 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006983 and S2-2006898, to S2-2007942. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. === CC#2 === Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. LiMeng (Huawei) thanks to the effort from Laeyoung, Thomas and Zhenhua, and provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. Judy (Ericsson) provides r06, and ask Q to vivo for clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r07. LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on r07. Zhenhua (vivo) response to LaeYoung and provide r08. LaeYoung (LGE) is not fine with r08. Judy (Ericsson) comments. Zhenhua (vivo) response to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r09. Zhenhua (vivo) response to Judy (Ericsson). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r10. Thomas (Nokia) provides r11. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Judy (Ericsson). Zhenhua (vivo) explain LaeYoung's response to Judy (Ericsson) further. Youngkyo(Samsung) provide comment. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Zhenhua (vivo) reponses to Youngkyo(Samsung). Youngkyo(Samsung) provides a reply to the response of Zhenhua (vivo). Zhenhua (vivo) replies to Youngkyo(Samsung). Judy (Ericsson) responds to Zhenhua (Vivo) Thomas (Nokia) suggest converting controversial bullets into editor´s notes Judy (Ericsson) responds that converting controversial bullets into editor´s notes could be a way forward Zhenhua (vivo) provides r12 based on r11 to move a controversial bullets into editor´s note, and ask for approval in CC LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r12. Zhenhu (vivo) provide r13 for approval in CC. LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r13 and thanks to Zhenhua (vivo). Youngkyo (samsung) is OK with r13 also. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007942 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6: Conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006990R13, merging S2-2006983 and S2-2006898. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006983 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6: proposal for conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007942 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006898 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion on K#6 - Local MBS service. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007942 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#7 | - | - | Docs:=22 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006837 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #18: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r01, with a clarification of the first paragraph, agreed. Revised to S2-2007955. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) asks Qs and comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Judy (Ericsson) comments Judy (Ericsson) objects to r0 as the comments are not addressed, and the proposed EN 'assumed baseline architecture is FFS' makes the solution built on nowhere thus not acceptable. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007955 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #18: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006837R01, with a clarification of the first paragraph. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007199 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #18: Clarification on MBS assistance information for delivery mode switching and update to remove ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007591 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7 update the sol#25 to keep align with sol#10 and clarify the EN. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008102. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 zhendong (ZTE) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008102 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7 update the sol#25 to keep align with sol#10 and clarify the EN. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007591R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007592 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7 update the sol#26 to keep align with sol#10. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007466 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Update to Solution#27 . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008103. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008103 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Update to Solution#27 . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007466R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006903 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#29: Update handover from legacy to enhanced RAN node. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007198 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #29: Update to clarify MBS switching procedures. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007194 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Multiple updates to solution. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008104. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 David (Samsung) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Thomas (Nokia) objects to r00 and r02 and replies to David === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008104 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Multiple updates to solution. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007194R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006835 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7 evaluation. | CATT | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2006895, to S2-2008105. | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01, merging S2-2006895 and eval parts of S2-2007465/6973 into S2-2006835. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) ask questions and comments. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. zhendong (ZTE) agree with fenqin on the category Zhenhua (vivo) comments. David (Samsung) provides r03. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r04. Thomas (Nokia) provides r05. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r06. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r07. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008105 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7 evaluation. | CATT, vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, OPPO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006835R07, merging S2-2006895. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006895 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation on K#7 - delivery method switching. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008105 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006836 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7 interim conclusion. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008109 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007465 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Evaluation and Conclusion of KI#7. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | R19 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2008109, S2-2006899, S2-2006973 and S2-2007593, to S2-2008109. | Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01, zhendong (ZTE) ask question for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) responds zhendong (ZTE) response to huawei Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02 Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02 and ask questions. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. David (Samsung) provides r04. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r05. Judy (Ericsson) ask Q. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06. Zhenhua (vivo) ask Q to Fenqin (Huawei). Jianhua (OPPO) provides r07 and revert data forwarding part. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r08 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r09 Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r10. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r11 as r09 miss to include 'if exists' for PDU session associated with MBS session during HO. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r12 to fix misunderstanding. zhendong (ZTE) provides r14 on top of r12 Judy (Ericsson) provide r13. David (Samsung) provides r15. Thomas (Nokia) provides r16. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r17. David (Samsung) provides r18. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds and suggest go r17. David (Samsung) replies to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds and provides r19. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r20. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaoyan (CATT) prefers r17/r18 to r19/r20, and objects to other revisions. Judy (Ericsson) prefers r14, can live with r17/r18/r19, objects to other revisions. Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to go with r19 David (Samsung) is okay with r19 zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r17, r18 and r19. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008109 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Evaluation and Conclusion of KI#7. | Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, OPPO, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007465R19, merging S2-2008109, S2-2006899, S2-2006973 and S2-2007593. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006899 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion on K#7 - delivery method switching. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008109 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006890 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation and conclusion on architecture. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008084 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2006973 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Evaluation and conclusion of MBS Handover. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008109 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007593 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7 proposal on the conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008109 | Merged | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#9 | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007269 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9: New solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008106 | Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to mark this document as merged into S2-2007685 Judy (Ericsson) is fine with Dario (Qualcomm)'s proposal to merge 7269 to 7685 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007532 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9, new solution: MBS service continuity between NR/5GC and E-UTRAN/EPC . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008106 | Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to note this document Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Dario (Qualcomm) suggestion === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dario (Qualcomm) is fine with marking it as merged to 7685 === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2007594 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9, New Sol: service continuity with eMBMS. | ZTE | Rel-17 | CC#4: r02 with added note was agreed. Revised to S2-2007943. | Thomas (Nokia) asks for clarification zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Dario (Qualcomm) asks a question for clarification zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01 Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Thomas(Nokia) suggest that ZTE provides a late revision to address the comments zhendong (ZTE) responds to thomas Thomas(Nokia) provides late r03 for CC3 === Phase 2 final deadline === zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r03 Dario (Qualcomm) is fine with r03. === CC#3 === Ihab Guirguis (FirstNet) is fine with r03. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007943 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9, New Sol: service continuity with eMBMS. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007594R02 with added note. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007467 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9: Update date to Solution #41 to resolve the Editor's note. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007685 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9: Sol. 43 update and conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007269 and S2-2007532, to S2-2008106. | LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions. === CC#2 === Dario (Qualcomm) replies to LaeYoung and provides r01 LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) realized that the merging proposal with S2-2007595 was for the conclusions and evaluation parts, but this document also includes Solution #43 updating, so it should be kept open. ATTN Andy. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to LaeYoung and provides r02 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a comment. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r04 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Youngkyo(Samsung) provide reply Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Youngkyo. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) Responds.. === Phase 2 final deadline === Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay with r04. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2008106 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9: Sol. 43 update and conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007685R04, merging S2-2007269 and S2-2007532. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2007595 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9 proposal on the interim conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | CC#4: r06 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007944. | Judy (Ericsson) proposes to postpone this paper as there are still new solutions on KI#9 for this meeting. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response Miguel (Qualcomm) agrees it may be better to hold conclusions until next meeting, we might want to start some preliminary evaluation though? zhendong (ZTE) provides the r01, the evaluation and conclusion part of 7685 is merged to 7595. zhendong (ZTE) provides the response. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides request for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. zhendong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Zhendong (ZTE). Judy (Ericsson) provided r03. Dario (Qualcomm) provides r04 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r05 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r05. zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r05 Thomas (Nokia) has concerns with r05, Suggest bringing this to CC2 Fenqin (Huawei) Responds. Thomas (Nokia) provides late r06, Suggest bringing this to CC2 zhendong (ZTE) responds to thomas === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2007944 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#9 proposal on the interim conclusion. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007595R06. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | Study on system enablers for multi-USIM devices (FS_MUSIM) | - | - | Docs:=49 | - | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007577 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on paging response upper timer boundary | Sony | Rel-17 | Noted | Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification Lars (Sony) responds to Lalith Alessio (nokia) : suggests to not send this LS. Lars (Sony) : Responds to Alessio Alessio(Nokia) Saso (Intel) : comments Steve (Huawei) comments. Alessio(Nokia) responds to LARS and ASKS to note the LS Alessio(Nokia) responds to Intel that both cases are valid. The timer refer to the user interaction case indeed. Saso (Intel) proposes a way for closing the Upper Bound Timer discussion. Saso (Intel) replies to Steve. Alessio(Nokia) responds to Saso (Intel) Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Alessio Steve (Huawei) asks about the yellow text that is suggested to be kept. Curt (Charter) comments about this timer. Alessio (nokia) comments that probably Saso has misunderstood the note Alessio(Nokia) responds to Curt that real time interaction with user is at the core of the paging cause code solution ... if preset behavior is used paging filtering seems much better on all fronts. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comment to the upper bound timer. Lars (Sony) Comment on Genadi Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Lars (Sony). Alessio(Nokia) is not agreeing with LARS Lars (Sony) comments Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio. Saso (Intel) replies to Lars and Genadi Saso (Intel) asks Alessio to clarify the claim that real time interaction with user is at the core of the paging cause code solution. It is not. Alessio(nokia) commends Lars (Sony) for having come to the right conclusion and understanding! Qian (Ericsson) provides comments and ask questions Lars (Sony) Ask Qian for clarification Qian (Ericsson) responds to Lars (Sony) Myungjune (LGE) asks question. Lalith (Samsung) comments. Curt (Charter) asks a question about this timer. Alessio(Nokia) provides comments Alessio(Nokia) comments Guillaume (MediaTek) responds === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Lars (Sony) Based on the good discussion, we propose to either Note the paper or mark it as Withdrawn === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | Overall conclusions | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007085 | DISCUSSION | Information | FS_MUSIM evaluation and conclusions | Intel | Rel-16 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007469 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Overall MUSIM interim conclusions proposal. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Lalith (Samsung) provides comments Alessio(Nokia) welcomes Samsung to provide updates to this paper as they see fit. Saso (Intel) proposes this paper to be NOTED because it does not follow the agreed structure for conclusions on per key issue basis. Saso (Intel) provides r01 and proposes to use r01 as a basis for question Q2 (Paging Filtering) in the Show-of-Hands slides. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007210 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1 Sol#1, Evaluation Update: Update for configuration and deployments. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Lalith (Samsung) provides comments. Saso (Intel) proposes this contribution to be NOTED. Ouyang(Huawei) replies Saso(Intel) and Lalith(Samsung) Lalith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei) Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei) Ouyang(Huawei) provide r01 . === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Curt (Charter) suggest to NOTE this paper. Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2007429 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Paging cause values. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007912. | Pinghui (China Telecom) provides r01. Saso (Intel) proposes to consider this document merged in 7526. Lalith (Samsung) provides r03. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007912 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Paging cause values. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007429R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007526 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to add Paging Cause for 'SMS' and clarify solution impact. | Intel | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007526r06 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007927. | Saso (Intel) proposes r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Alessio(Nokia) has concerns with R01 (cannot accept) Alessio(Nokia) can agree with a cause code for SMS reception if only a stable setting a the UE (which the user may change at any time for the USIM) or local logic are only used to control reception and the user is never requested to say yes or not to receiving an SMS. R00 as is therefore is unacceptable as the user can still have to ACK whether an inbound SMS should be received or not at the UE for each individual SMS. Saso (Intel) provides r02. Ouyang(Huawei) has concerns on the new note for pre-configuration . Ouyang(Huawei) has further concerns on the 6.1.3.4. Pinghui(China Telecom) merged the 7429 and provide r03. Lalith(Samsung) provides r04. Saso (Intel) is ok with r04. Replies to Ouyang. Saso (Intel) provides r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Ouyang(Huawei) objects the original version to r05 Saso (Intel) regrets that Ouyang(Huawei) objects to all versions without having clarified earlier how their concerns could be addressed. Asks if anyone would have concerns with agreeing 7526r5 without the changes in clause 6.1.3.4. Lalith(Samsung) answers Saso Ouyang(Huawei) is OK if the changes on clause of 6.1.3.4 can be removed. Ouyang replies to Saso that we showed our concerns in our email discussion, but can't get a satisfying answer. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) answers Saso that we are fine with r05. Saso (Intel) provides r06 in the DRAFTS folder, which is based on 7526r5 without the changes in clause 6.1.3.4; asks if anyone has concerns with this way forward. Nokia asks a question on r06 Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio === Phase 2 final deadline === Saso (Intel) proposes to go with r06 for CC#3 === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007927 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to add Paging Cause for 'SMS' and clarify solution impact. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007526R06. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007427 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol#24 Resolving EN. | Samsung, NEC, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=22 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2006997 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | KI#1, Discussion on the value of paging cause and proposed way forward. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note the Discussion paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2006998 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, update of paging cause solution and conclusion proposal. | OPPO | Rel-17 | CC#4: r09 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007951. | Alessio (nokia) : suggests that this approach needs to be clarified Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Saso (Intel) comments and proposes to NOTE the document. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Qualcomm, Intel. Yang Xu (OPPO) answers to Juan Yang (OPPO) replies to Saso. Yang (OPPO) replies to Guillaume Saso (Intel) objects to this pCR. Saso (Intel) replies to Yang. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification from Wanqiang on the compromise proposal. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Yang (OPPO ) replies to Juan Yang (OPPO) explains to Saso. Lalith(Samsung) requests clarification from Yang (OPPO) Yang (OPPO) replies to Lalith Lalith(Samsung) requests further clarification. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === Saso (Intel) thinks it is a good idea to document this Paging Cause variant; provides r04 in DRAFTS folder. Ouyang(Huawei) supports Intel's view to document this solution. Myungjune (LGE) provides r05 in DRAFTS. Lalith (Samsung) provides comments for r05. Alessio (Nokia) agrees with Lalith (Samsung) Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lalith(Samsung). Myungjune (LGE) responds to Lalith (Samsung) Saso (ntel) proposes to go with r05 for CC#3 Yang Xu (OPPO) propose to agree r04 and leave the necessity of UE-NW negotiation to next meeting. YAng (OPPO) replies to LGE Guillaume (MediaTek) fully agrees with Juan (Qualcomm) on both matters. === CC#3 === Yang (OPPO) replies to Juan (QC) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) reply comments Ouyang(Huawei) comments . Yang (OPPO) revised to r06 based on Juan's comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r07. Yang (OPPO) is ok to Juan's proposal and provide r08 with an editorial change. Yang (OPPO) provides r09 since r08 cannot be open Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek) . === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007951 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, update of paging cause solution and conclusion proposal. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006998R09. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007087 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005685 from S2#140E. Revised, merging S2-2007576 and parts of S2-2007620, to S2-2007778. | Alessio (nokia) : requests this paper be noted Saso (Intel) tells Alessio to use the correct thread (7778). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007576 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Interim Conclusions . | Sony | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007778 | Merged | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007778 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Intel, Charter, Comcast, Sony | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007087, merging S2-2007576 and parts of S2-2007620. CC#4: r31 was agreed. Revised to S2-2007952. | Alessio(nokia) provides R01 with what we can agree from 7778 and also taking on board the good suggestion by Genadi Saso (Intel) comments. Alessio(Nokia) comments on sAso. comments Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio. Lalith (Samsung) expresses his concerns. Genadi (Lenovo) proposes a new NOTE and provides r02. Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments for r02. Lars (Sony) comments Xiaowan (vivo) comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) support Xiaowan (vivo) === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Saso (Intel) proposes r03. Qian (Ericsson) ask questions. Saso (Intel) replies to Qian (Ericsson). Qian (Ericsson) responds. Lars (Sony) responds. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Saso (Intel) adds one more comment. Saso (Intel) replies to Juan. === CC#2 === Genadi (Lenovo) replies comments to Ericsson, Sonny and Qualcomm on handling of solution 2. Alessio(nokia) agrees with Lars (Sony) comment Yang (OPPO) asks questions for r03 Saso (Intel) replies to Yang. Qian (Ericsson) responds to previous questions and provide r04 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r05 Saso (Intel) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek) Saso (Intel) is OK with r04 changes provided by Qian (Ericsson) Myungjune (LGE) provides r06. Yang (OPPO) comments Alessio(Nokia) provides R07 Guillaume (MediaTek): r07 is not acceptable. Alessio(nokia) only r07 is acceptable as it represent the status of discussion (since now interim conclusions 9include things not subject of firm agreement or even not stable in SA2) Ouyang(Huawei) comments . Saso (Intel) comments . Saso (Intel) provides r09. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Saso (Intel) provides r15. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides a compromise proposal. === Phase 2 final deadline === Saso (Intel) provides r17. Alessio(nokia) provides r18 as a compromise. Lalith(Samsung) confirms fine with r17. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r19 as a compromise. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Wanqiang (Huawei). Saso (Intel) provides r20. Yang Xu (OPPO) supports Xiaowan's position on Busy Indication. Wanqiang (Huawei) replies to Saso (Intel). Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to all revisions recommending a baseline functionality that is entirely in RAN domain i.e. Negotiated Short Absence Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r21 in inbox drafts folder Saso (Intel) proposes to take r21 for CC#3 Guillaume (MediaTek) also posted r21 in the revision folder... Saso (Intel) points out to Wanqiang (Huawei) that it was Huawei who proposed the addition of 'framework' in the question Q1 for SoH. Wanqiang (Huawei) points out to Saso (Intel) that it was Intel push the situation of non-paging cause vs any paging cause. Alessio (Nokia) cannot accept R21 for CC#3 instead of the compromise proposal 1. It is considered no longer necessary precondition to get SA3 clearance before PC solution is moved to normative phase 2. There is no identification of explicit need to consider whether paging filtering is superior from SA2 standpoint now that MMI interaction are off the table so everything works off known logic in the UE not dependent on User interaction. 3. It is no longer ruled out the MMI of the UE interacts with the user still the paging timer has been removed as this statement has been dropped '- The UE MMI shall not require input from the User in order to decide whether to respond to paging.' So it means the timer should be there as people said timer was not needed as there is no MMI interaction to respond to paging. Saso (Intel) asks Wanqiang (Huawei) to make a proposal that will reflect the potential compromise about the one paging cause. Saso (Intel) provides r22; replies to Alessio Wanqiang (Huawei) provides the potential compromise regarding the paging cause. === CC#3 === Saso (Intel) thanks Wanqiang (Huawei) for the potential compromise proposal. Guillaume (MediaTek): r22 is good Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r23: not in line with SoH Guillaume (MediaTek) also requests revisions not be sent during CC (and so late into the CC!) Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r24 as it is not in line with the SoH Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports r22 and also think that r23 and r24 are not in line with SoH. Wanqiang (Huawei) objects any version mixing the one paging cause and multiple paging causes. The SoH was indicative and there was no any discussion on objections Lars (Sony) provides r25 Saso (Intel) provides r26 Xiaowan(vivo) has strong concern about multiple paging cause, and provide r27 to see whether everyone can live. Curt (Charter) is okay with r26 Guillaume (MediaTek) regrets no constructive proposal is being made. Alessio(Nokia) can live with R26,. Clarifies that if MMI interaction is back at any time in the future the timer solution will be back also. Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r25 and r26 Guillaume (MediaTek) does not understand what Xiaowan strong concern is about. Guillaume (MediaTek) r27 is not acceptable Lars (Sony) can live with R26. Saso (Intel) points out to Xiaowan (vivo) that there is misunderstanding about the MMI interaction. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments the revision provided by Xiaowan(VIVO) is good compromise and constructive way to move forward Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r28: r27 is clearly not a sound baseline nor a compromise. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r29 on the basis of r26. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides concerns on multiple paging cause and ok with R28 Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Jianning (Xiaomi). Myungjune (LGE) supports r26/r29 and objects r27/r28. Saso (Intel) proposes to take r26 for CC#4. Wanqiang (Huawei) comments and uploads r30. Lars (Sony) we can live with r30. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r31 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r31. Saso (Intel) announces that r31 is uploaded in the CC#4 folder. Alessio (Nokia) is also fine with MediaTek's r31. Lars (Sony) is also fine with MediaTek's r31. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007952 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Intel, Charter, Comcast, Sony, LG Electronics, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Qualcomm, MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007778R31. This P-CR was approved, merging S2-2007590 | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007152 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, evaluation updates for newly included solutions . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007428, S2-2007633 and S2-2007708, to S2-2007913. | Qian (Ericsson) provides r01 based on the proposal from rapporteur to merge in 7428, 7633,7708 and 7590 (partial). Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Pavan (Google) provides r03.. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007913 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, evaluation updates for newly included solutions . | Ericsson, Intel, Samsung, NEC, Apple, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, MediaTek Inc., Google Inc., Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007152R05, merging S2-2007428, S2-2007633 and S2-2007708. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007170 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1: Interim conclusion. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Lalith (Samsung) expresses his concerns Saso (Intel) proposes to merge this paper in 7778. Xiaowan(vivo) suggest to keep 7170 open until SoH confirmed Saso (Intel) agrees with Xiaowan(vivo) to keep 7170 open until SoH confirmed === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Alessio(Nokia) would object even after the SoH (and before). Nokia OBJECTS. Sas (Intel) proposes this paper to be NOTED based on the SoH outcome. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2007211 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1: Conclusion on Key Issue #1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005490 from S2#140E. Noted | Lalith (Samsung) expresses concerns with this conclusion. Saso (Intel) proposes to keep this contribution open until SoH. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this contribution based on the SoH outcome. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2007393 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Key Issue #1: update of solution #3. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2007914. | Lalith (Samsung) provides comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Lalith (Samsung)'s comment. Lalith (Samsung) replies Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Qian (Ericsson) comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Alessio(Nokia) provides r01 Lars (Sony) agrees with r00 Lars (Sony) we are also fine with r01 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r01. Steve (Huawei) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) has concern about r01 and provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) Provides R03 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r04. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Lars (Sony) We are ok with r04. Alessio(Nokia) r04 has some text issue as the last sentence is truncated. If this can be fixed by the editor fine otherwise we would prefer R03 as it seems ok anyhow. Also not sure why R03 was not good? === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007914 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Key Issue #1: update of solution #3. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007393R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007423 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, KI#3, MUSIM Assistance Information. | Samsung, InterDigital, Apple, NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007928 | Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the document or consider it merged in 7171. Lalith(Samsung) indicates fine to mark it merged in S2-2007171 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007425 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1 Interim Conclusion. | Samsung, NEC, Apple, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, InterDigital | Rel-17 | Postponed | Saso (Intel) proposes r01. Notes that this conclusion is subject to SoH. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Lalith (Samsung) proposes proposes to mark it merged into 7778 Ouyang(Huawei) propose to postpone this document if it is not going to SoH in this meeting. Alessio(Nokia) supports Huawei to postpone this. Saso (Intel) agrees with Huawei and Nokia that the correct status for this paper should be POSTPONED. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2007428 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Evaluation of sol#24 and sol#26. | Samsung, NEC, Apple, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007913 | Lalith (Samsung) indicates fine to merge 7428 in 7152 based on rapporteur's proposal === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007585 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, conclusion on notification solutions. | LG Electronics, LG Uplus | Rel-17 | Postponed | Lars (Sony) have concerns with this conclusion === CC#2 === Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lars (Sony). Lars (Sony) responds to Myungjune. Qian (Ericsson) comments. Myungjune (LGE) replies Lars (Sony) and Qian (Ericsson). Saso (Intel) replies to (Sony). Pavan (Google) expresses concerns. Xiaowan (vivo) provides comments and requests to postpone 7585. Qian (Ericsson) supports Vivo's view to postpone this paper. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Qian (Ericsson) and Vivo's view to postpone this paper. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) also supports this view to postpone this paper. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Myungjune (LGE) is ok to postpone. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2007590 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1 - Outstanding evaluations and Way Forward . | MediaTek Inc., Google Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007952 | Lars (Sony) provides r01 and ask question. Pavan (Google) asks a clarification for r01. Lars (Sony) responds to Pavan. Lalith (Samsung) comments Xiaowan (vivo) request to merge or note this paper into 2007778 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r02 Qian (Ericsson) also consider it's good to merge into 7778 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports to merge this one into 7778 and share the same comment about sol#13 with Ericsson. Guillaume (MediaTek) suggests to merge into 7778 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Adrian (vivo) asks Lars (sony) if he can point to the relevant section in the relevant TR regarding IMS and NPN. Lars (Sony) responds to Adrian. Adrian (vivo) thanks Lars (Sony) for the helpful comments. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007607 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Evaluation of notification type of solutions. | Google, vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, Comcast | Rel-17 | Approved | Qian (Ericsson) asks questions Guillaume (MediaTek) responds Qian (Ericsson) asks further questions === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Pavan (Google) responds to Qian (Ericsson) Qian (Ericsson) comments Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Qian (Ericsson) === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Approved |
| 8.10 | S2-2007633 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Evaluations of solutions added in SA WG2#140E. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007913 | Saso (Intel) is OK to merge 7633 in 7152. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007684 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1: Interim evaluation update. | Vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Lars (Sony) : There is no justification for the new text, we propose to note this paper. Saso (Intel) agrees with Sony; proposes to note this paper. Alessio (Nokia) supports Lars (Sony) : There is no justification for the new text, we propose to note this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Curt (Charter) asks a question from Jianning (Xiaomi) for clarification purpose. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2007708 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update valuation for KI#1 . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007913 | Jianning (Xiaomi) agrees to merge 7708 into 7152. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2006867 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Sol #15: Correction of the solution impact on RAN. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2007915. | Lars (Sony) provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Pinghui (China Telecom) provides r02 Lars (Sony) comments and is ok with r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007915 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Sol #15: Correction of the solution impact on RAN. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006867R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007711 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update solution #14 for clarification with an EN. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007151 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, evaluations of updated solutions . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007916 | Qian (Ericsson) indicates it's ok to merge this paper into 7709. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007709 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update valuation for KI#2 . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007151, to S2-2007916. | Jianning (Xiaomi) proposes to merge S2-2007151 (Ericsson) and provides r01. Qian (Ericsson) responds and it's ok to merge in 7151. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007916 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update valuation for KI#2 . | Xiaomi, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007709R02, merging S2-2007151. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Solution update | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007149 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs and clarify . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Juan Zhang and provides r01. Ouyang(Huawei) requests for clarification. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Ouyang. Xiaowan(vivo) request for clarifications === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Lars (Sony) Another question Qian (Ericsson) responds to Lars (Sony) and Xiaowan (Vivo) === CC#2 === Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r02 Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r03 Xiaowan comments Qian (Ericsson) agrees to move the evaluation part to 7710 and provide r04. Qian (Ericsson) provides r05 as an alternative option in case the 'short' timer description is not acceptable in 7395. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Xiaowan (vivo) accept r02 and r04, and objects to the rest revisions and original version. Qian (Ericsson) prefers r05, but can live with r04 for now since we still have room for further discussion. Saso (Intel) points that 'room for discussion' is only for conclusion papers, not solution updates. Qian (Ericsson) comments. Saso (Intel) replies to Qian (Ericsson): as clarified in CC#2b, only simple changes are accepted for solution updates. Please use the DRAFTS folder for uploading changes to solution updates. Ouyang(Huawei) suggests to postpone this paper to next meeting. Qian (Ericsson) responds and propose to go with r05. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to go with r05. Qian (Ericsson) responds to Ouyang(Huawei). Steve (Huawei) It's cleaner to postpone. === Phase 2 final deadline === Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Qian (Ericsson) and repeat we can only live with r02 and r04 Qian (Ericsson) is ok to postpone the paper === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2007395 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Update of solution #5. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed | Lars (Sony) : Ask a question for clarification Qian (Ericsson) : asks one more question Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comment to Lars (Sony) and Qian (Ericcsson) Qian (Ericsson) ask further questions Lars (Sony) : Responds to Juan Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Ericsson's comment Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Lars (Sony) and provides r01. Lars (Sony) replies to Juan and provides r02. Alessio(nokia) provides comments and proposes that RAN 2 decides on this matter if the timer is shorter than T-380. Alessio(Nokia) comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to Alessio (Nokia) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Alessio (Nokia) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Alessio (Nokia) Alessio(Nokia) is fine to not send LS to RAN as anyhow this will be a RAN discussion and work so eventually it will go there. On the >t380 we appreciate people overlooked that case so far but if we do not rule it out it needs handling. And the only reasonable solution is to release the UE unless the UE can come back earlier that the pause timer, then we should agree that the T380 still control the release and then the AMF enforces no paging for the leftover time. Genadi (Lenovo) comments on the pause time. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Genadi (Lenovo)'s comment Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification Myungjune (LGE) asks some questions. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to Steve (Huawei) and Myungjune (LGE). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Saso's (Intel) comment. Xiaowan (vivo) seeks clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to Xiaowan (vivo). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Steve (Huawei) checks understand of the current proposal. Qian (Ericsson) provides comments. Lalith (Samsung) provides r04 Lars (Sony) provides r05 Steve (Huawei) comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Steve's (Huawei) comments. Qian (Ericsson) comments. === CC#2 === Alessio(Nokia) provides R06 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies Qian's (Ericsson) Comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment to r06 Curt (Charter) provides R07 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments from Curt (Charter) and Steve (Huawei) and provides r08. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comment to Curt (Charter). Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r09 Alessio (nokia) We are ok with R07 if that is what people can be happy with... the alternative behaviour is in r06: the UE remains RRC inactive till released and if released when the Tp is still running residual Tp is passed to AMF. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) comments and provides r10. Alessio(Nokia) comments this revision no longer refer to the pause timer if I am not correct and what happens if it is < T380 or > t380 the picture shows a pause timer box also that is not explained. Also in step 3 the MUSIM assistance info should include not a full Tp but the residual tp... so this version needs to be updated. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and comments Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) asks clarification to Alessio (Nokia). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to Xiaowan (vivo). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Lars (Sony) provides comments Xiaowan (vivo) accept r9 and r10 Alessio(Nokia) Honestly I think the pause timer is captured by R06 better... or we should keep the existing text (so object to all revisions inclusing original CR) that seems aligned with NAS level (time the UE expects to be away from the network) Qian (Ericsson) prefers r08 but can leave with r10. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007086 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Conclusion updates. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007928 | Alessio (nokia) : suggests this paper be noted Ouyang(Huawei) also suggests to note this paper, if it is not merged in a decent way . Saso (Intel) expects 7086 will be merged in 7171. Provides answers. Alessio(Nokia) responds to saso Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio. Alessio (Nokia) clarifies we have made an evaluation comment. And clarifies we should aim at an extensible framework to make what we are doing useful in the long term Saso (Intel) disagrees to leave the specification of 'sophisticated filters' to normative phase. Xiaowan (vivo) request to merge this contribution in S2-2007171 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007150 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, conclusion on assistance information . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007928 | Xiaowan (vivo) requests to merge this contribution into S2-2007171 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Qian (Ericsson) is ok to merge the paper into 7171 === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007171 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Interim conclusions update. | Vivo | Rel-17 | CC#3: S2-2007171r32 was agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007086, S2-2007150, to S2-2007928., S2-2007321, S2-2007150, to S2-2007928. and S2-2007423 and S2-2007321 and S2-2007150, to S2-2007928. | Lalith (Samsung) provides comments Xiaowan relies to Lalith (Samsung) and provide r01 to merged docs Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments on r01. Alessio(nokia) provides R01 Alessio(nokia) provided R02 not R01 Saso (Intel) provides r03. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r04. Lalith (Samsung) objects r04. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Xiaowan (vivo) provide r05 based r03. Qian (Ericsson) provide r06 based on r05. Curt (Charter) supports keeping the PDU session ID in EN (r06). Ouyang(Huawei) doubts the structure of the interim agreement. === CC#2 === Lars (Sony) provides r07 Myungjune (LGE) asks question to Lars (Sony). Curt (Charter) comments Myungjune (LGE) replies to Curt (Charter). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Curt (Charter) provided r27 too late. Pls ignore this version . Lars (Sony) we are ok with either r25 and r26, but prefers r25 Qian (Ericsson) prefers r25, but ok with r26 as well Saso (Intel) prefers r25, can live with r26 Ouyang(Huawei) suggests to go with r26. Xiaowan(vivo) is OK with r25 an r26 Lalith(Samsung) ok with revision from r19 to r26, prefer r25/r26. Object before r19 Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends r25. Myungjune (LGE) supports r25. Alessio(Nokia) can only accept r16. It contains the testable UE behavior for MT services handling, behavior for RM, and also the specific case that the UE knows it cannot respond to paging in the other PLMN so the other PLMN does not even try to page. The contributions revisions after this provide flurry of editor's notes that are not really the spirit of an interim conclusion. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) that r16 is not acceptable because it contains content that is related to Q2 in SoH. Rapporteur's suggestion is to agree r26. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) prefer r25, but can compromise to r26. Saso (Rapporteur) asks Alessio to please clarify whether he is OK with r25 or r26, based on the SoH outcome. Nokia still retain our preference for R16. We do not believe there is a stable agreement on the filter set up and removal/modification (so far only set up is there in the agreement) and the rest of R16 is linked to UE behavior description. === Phase 2 final deadline === Xiaowan(vivo) replies and agree Lalith's understanding Lars (Sony) comments and hope everyone could re-consider r25 as a way forward. Alessio(Nokia) provides a revision 28 based on revision 26. Alessio(Nokia) provides a revision 29 that fixes two more occurrences of NAS-triggered and AS-triggered procedures and replaces them with NAS level and AS-level.. Xiaowan(vivo) provides r30 Nokia cannot accept r30 Xiaowan(vivo)request Nokia to clarify why cannot accept r30? Your r28/r29 to change the NAS leaving terminology into NAS procedure, which is not align with the SoH result'OPTION 2: UE can set Paging Filters on ONLY when it initiates the Coordinated leaving procedure.' Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provides r31 . Xiaowan(vivo) provides r32 Alessio(nokia) OK with r32 Saso (Intel) proposes to use r32 for CC#3 . === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007928 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Interim conclusions update. | Vivo, Intel, Ericsson, Lenovo, Qualcomm, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007171R32, merging S2-2007086, S2-2007150, S2-2007321 and S2-2007423. This P-CR was approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2007321 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Conclusions on the leave/absence solutions. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007928 | Xiaowan (vivo) requests to merge this contribution into S2-2007171 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments on r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007578 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Interim Conclusion update . | Sony | Rel-17 | Revised, merging parts of S2-2007620, to S2-2007780. | Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r01 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007620 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Proposal to agree on NAS solution as default for KI#3 and default action for KI#1. | Charter, Comcast | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2007778 and S2-2007780 | Xiaowan (vivo) requests to merge this paper into 2007578 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2007780 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Interim Conclusion update . | Sony, Charter, Comcast | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007578, merging parts of S2-2007620. Postponed | Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2007710 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update evaluation for KI#3 . | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2007917. | Xiaowan (vivo) comments. === CC#2 === Xiaowan (vivo) requests to note this paper === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2007917 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update evaluation for KI#3 . | Xiaomi, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007710R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | Documents not available | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G (5GSAT_ARCH) | - | - | Docs:=27 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2006811 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS Reply on SA WG2 assumptions on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G | RAN WG2 (R2-2008229) | Rel-17 | Postponed. Revised to S2-2008338. | Revised | |
| 8.11 | S2-2006815 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G | RAN WG3 (R3-205795) | Rel-17 | Responses drafted S2-2007667 and S2-2007695. Final response in S2-2008307 | Replied to | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007667 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} Reply LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G | Intel | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2006815. Agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007695, to remove 'draft' to S2-2008307 | Dong (Xiaomi) provide a comment and ask a question. Saso (Intel) replies to Dong (Xiaomi). Jean Yves (Thales), agrees with Saso (Intel) replying to Dong (Xiaomi. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Hucheng(CATT) comments and provides r02 . DongYeon (Samsung) asks a question for clarification. Saso(Intel) is OK with r02 . Saso (Intel) replies to Dong and DongYeon. === CC#2 === Saso (Intel) replies to Dong. Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the discussion so far and suggests to merge S2-2007667 into S2-2007695 Saso (Intel) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm) Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03 Saso (Intel) is OK with r03 Hannu (Nokia) uploads r04 and asks about the action? Hannu (Nokia) re-distributes r04. Jean Yves (Thales) comments on Stephen and Saso discussion, merging the 2 LSs would be very valuable for 5GSAT_ARCH to move forward. Saso (Intel) replies to Hannu. Does not think r04 is a good idea. Saso (Intel) ok to merge, but how? There is an ongoing discussion on the diverging replies on the location granularity. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides an r05 which merges in part of S2-2007695 Jean Yves (Thales) thank Stephen for providing r05 and support it. Saso (Intel) is OK with r05. Chris (Vodafone) provides r06. Saso (Intel) prefers r05 and replies to Chris (Vodafone). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Saso Stephen (Qualcomm) prefers r05 but can accept r06 Hannu (Nokia) can agree r04, r05 or r06 Jean Yves (Qualcomm) prefers also r05 but can accept r06, both revisions are preferred to leverage on the merge done. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008307 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007667, merging S2-2007695. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007695 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT} Reply LS on SA WG2 assumptions from conclusion of study on architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2006815 Merged into S2-2008307 | Dong (Xiaomi) provide a comment. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Hannu (Nokia) asks if this should be or is already merged to 7667? Stephen (Qualcomm) confirms that S2-2007695 has been merged into S2-2007667r05. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.11 | S2-2006849 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on signalling of satellite backhaul connection | Samsung Electronics Romania | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007078, to S2-2008308. | Hucheng(CATT) comments. === CC#2 === Hannu (Nokia) challenges the need to send the LS at all, let's agree draft CR S2-2007700 instead. DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Hannu and Hucheng while providing r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that can only accept r0, objects to r1 Relja (TNO) provides r02 that take into account comments of Haris (Qualcom). DongYeon (Samsung) is okay with r02 provided by Relja. Jean Yves (Thales) is also okay with r02 provided by Relja. Tao(Chair) please use r00 as the version to check for approval (Haris object r01, r02 is provided after revision deadline). Can we go with r00? Haris (Qualcomm) is ok with r02 (and as indicated previously r00) DongYeon (Samsung) asks to the group, Can we go with r02 for this DRAFT LS? Relja (TNO) asks Tao (Chinamobile) why is LS provided 1.5h before the deadline considered as late submission. Jean Yves (Thales - rapporteur) thinks r02 is valid as 1/ Relja'a mail with date 21/10/2020 00:26 CET which is before 24:00 UTC 2/ file is 22:24 UTC on the ftp server Tao(Chair) the revision deadline is 17 UTC 20/10/2020. If r02 can be agreed with all people, we can consider this as an offline further consensus as an exception. For sure, people can challenge this in the CC. Jean Yves (Thales - rapporteur), you are right sir (I was locked on 24 UTC like for doc submission). This r02 is merging valuable contributions and is supported be several companies. Thank you for exception. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008308 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on signalling of satellite backhaul connection | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006849R02, merging S2-2007078. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007077 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Discussion on satellite backhaul. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) comments === CC#2 === Hucheng(CATT) replies to Qualcomm Hannu (Nokia) disagrees with the proposal in 7077 and supports the view from Haris. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2007078 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on satellite backhaul | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008308 | Haris (Qualcomm) suggests to mark this LS out as noted as merged in S2-2006849 DongYeon(Samsung) also suggests this document to merge into S2-2006849. Hucheng(CATT) agree to have a merge but disagree with the justification. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 8.11 | S2-2007079 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Discussion on QoS limitation awared UPF selection. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) comments similar to S2-2007078 === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2007165 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2479 (Rel-17, 'B'): Add GNSS based location as optional user location information for 3GPP and non-3GPP satellite accesses | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 and asks whether we are expecting to send Rel-17 CRs for approval to TSG SA #90-e? Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === DongYeon (Samsung) expresses sympathy with Ericsson's comments. === CC#2 === Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r02 Dong (Xiaomi) comment and asked a question. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r03. Hannu (Nokia) supports the changes from Stephen and Sherry. Stefan (Ericsson) asks about the use case Dong (Xiaomi) comment. Stephen (Qualcomm) responds to questions from Stefan and Dong Hannu (Nokia) comments. Stefan (Ericsson) suggests to postpone this DRAFTCR and focus on first sorting out basic aspects === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Yi (China Mobile) comments. Stefan (Ericsson) replies and proposes to postpone the CR Yi (China Mobile) is fine to postpone the CR. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2007379 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | NAS timer for GEO | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and proposes that this DRAFTCR is postponed until CT1 has progressed === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees with Stefan - CT1 should first progress this and then SA2 can align DongYeon (Samsung) replies to the comment. Jean Yves (Thales) feels sympathy for DongYeon comment. Hannu (Nokia) asks question on UE detection of NR satellite access? Jean Yves (Thales) answers to Hannu and provides r01 Hannu (Nokia) revises further to r02 Fei (OPPO) responds to Nokia, Thales, Samsung, Ericsson& Qualcomm. Dong (Xiaomi) comment. Stephen (Qualcomm) clarifies earlier comment DongYeon (Samsung) supports r00 and provides comments. Dong (Xiaomi) asks a question. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Dong and Stephen and uploads r03. Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Dong on CN RAT. Fei (OPPO) responds to DongYeon (Samsung). DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Fei, and supports r03. Stefan (Ericsson) again suggest to give CT1 some more time. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees with Stefan to give CT1 more time - by postponing the CR === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2007486 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | Network selection for NR satellite access | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and asks questions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Fei (OPPO) comments. DongYeon (Samsung) comments. === CC#2 === Stephen (Qualcomm) indicates support for r00 Fei (OPPO) asks questions on comments from Stephen (Qualcomm) Hannu (Nokia) answers to Stefan. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Fei (OPPO). Hannu (Nokia) replies to DongYeon (Samsung). Hannu (Nokia) shares r01 with editorial updates and replies to Fei (OPPO). Stefan (Ericsson) repeats questions Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Hannu and provides r02 Fei (OPPO) asks questions in the r02. Hucheng(CATT) comments Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Fei Hannu (Nokia) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and provides r03 Chris (Vodafone) provides r04 to move this text from the wrong part of the procedure. Fei (OPPO) responds to Hannu (Nokia) and Stefan (Ericsson). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) prefers r05 but with r03 and r04 acceptable (and r00-r02 tolerable) Fei (OPPO) provides r05. DongYeon (Samsung) objects to all revisions and asks postponement. Jean Yves (Thales) comments on DongYeon questions and objections. Hannu (Nokia) agrees with r04 and replies to Chris (Vodafone). Hannu agrees r05 and replies to Fei (OPPO) Hannu (Nokia) asks DongYeon to re-consider the request to postpone. I have now answered to your questions and have got questions back to you to understand what you are proposing. Tao(Chair) both r04 and r05 have chance to approve but I am not sure whether DongYeon can reconsider the postpone request? Otherwise, we cannot go with any revision of this paper. Chris(Vodafone) asks whether we should consult CT 1 as to how they would use this information, given that 23.122 already specifies PLMN reselection rules? === Phase 2 final deadline === Fei (OPPO) gives clarification. === CC#3 === Hannu (Nokia) asks if LS to CT1 would be needed to ask about the reject cause values? DongYeon (Samsung) retains position of postponement, and agrees on sending LS to CT1. Hannu (Nokia) can agree to postpone 7486 if we send an LS to ask for CT1 guidance. LS is proposed for CC #4. === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2007487 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | Network selection for NR satellite access | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008309. | Fei (OPPO) comments. === CC#2 === Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r01 Dong (Xiaomi) asks a question and comment. Fei (OPPO) provides r02. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03 Hannu (Nokia) replies to all and supports r01. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept any of r01, r02 or r03 Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to go with r03 Hannu (Nokia) asks for clarification from Stephen === Phase 2 final deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Hannu === CC#3 === Hannu (Nokia) admits it's been a long meeting and apologises for misunderstanding and thanks for support. === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008309 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | Network selection for NR satellite access | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007487R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007544 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | Identification and mobility restrictions for satellite access | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008310. | Dong (Xiaomi) provide a comment and ask a question. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === DongYeon (Samsung) provides a comment.. === CC#2 === Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r01 Stephen (Qualcomm) provides r02 Dong (Xiaomi) provide comment revised versions r03. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Dong and prefers r02 Hannu (Nokia) also prefers r02 template and provides further revision r04. Dong (Xiaomi) comment. Chris(Vodafone)provides r05 to avoid inaccurate statements on DC and CA. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) prefers r02 or r03, other versions are not preferred (but are not objected) DongYeon (Samsung) supports only r05. Hannu (Nokia) can agree r04 or r05. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008310 | DRAFTCR | Agreement | Identification and mobility restrictions for satellite access | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007544R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007573 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Introduce new standardized 5QI to QoS characteristics mapping due to Satellite Access/Satellite Backhaul | XiaoMi | Rel-17 | Postponed | Haris (Qualcomm) suggests to postpone this draft CR and in mean time instigate for some interaction with RAN2 to understand some realistic number for PDB and PER before defining new 5QIs for satellite access === CC#2 === Dong (Xiaomi) provides r01. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Dong (Xiaomi) answers the questions. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Dong Relja (TNO) asks for clarification of introduction of (satellite) access based 5QI instead of traditional service based 5QIs. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone this draft CR Dong (Xiaomi) provide answers and provide r02. Dong (Xiaomi) answered the question. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Dong and proposes to postpone the CR DongYeon (Samsung) also suggests postponement of this proposal. Hannu (Nokia) supports the proposal to postpone and comments. === Phase 2 final deadline === Dong (Xiaomi) agrees to postpone and comments. === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2007601 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2506 (Rel-17, 'B'): Selection of CN node by NG-RAN node providing satellite access across multiple countries | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004839 from S2#140E. r02 agreed. Revised as a DraftCR to S2-2008311. | Hannu (Nokia) asks whether we are expecting to send Rel-17 CRs for approval to TSG SA #90-e? Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on both S2-2007601 and S2-2007602 Fei (OPPO) comments and asks questions to Stephen (Qualcomm). Jean Yves (Thales) reminds that during July SA2 Q3/Q4 work planning meetings it was agreed for 5GSAT_ARCH: draft CRs for SA2-e140 but CRs for SA2-e141 'CRs for all TSG SA approved WID (except TEI17)' Chris (Vodafone) says that SA2 or SA can put CRs on hold to avoid creation of R17 specs. CRs are easier to track than draft CRs as they have CR numbers. Chris also answers the comments from Qualcomm and refers to the LS in S2-2007680. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Dong (Xiaomi) asked questions. DongYeon (Samsung) comments and ask questions. Jean Yves (Thales) responds to DongYeon regarding DraftCR/CR question, proposing sharing view during next SA2 CC. Stefan (Ericsson) comments === CC#2 === Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments to responses from Chris and question from Fei Hannu (Nokia) shares r01 and comments. Chris (Vodafone) provides answers to Nokia, Qualcomm and DongYeon. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides more comments to Chris Chris (Vodafone) provides answers to Qualcomm. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Chris (Vodafone) and Stephen (Qualcomm) Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions Chris (Vodafone) answers Ericsson Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Chris prefers rev 01 but does not object to r02 Stephen (Qualcomm) adds more comments to show why RAN3 (and RAN2) should be involved Stefan (Ericsson) comments that this should be a DRAFTCR, and not approved as CR. Chis comments that he assumes that Stefan (Ericsson) means that this should be approved as a DRAFTCR. Stefan (Ericsson) comments: right, whatever we approve will be DRAFTCR === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008311 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Selection of CN node by NG-RAN node providing satellite access across multiple countries | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007601R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007602 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2436 (Rel-17, 'B'): Intra NG-RAN handover via CN for NR satellite access | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004840 from S2#140E. Agreed. Revised as a DraftCR to S2-2008312 | Hannu (Nokia) asks whether we are expecting to send Rel-17 CRs for approval to TSG SA #90-e? === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Relja (TNO) asks for clarification of the procedures/assumptions proposed. Chris (Vodafone) answers Relja (TNO). Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from Chris (Vodafone) and proposes r01. Chris (Vodafone) prefers the simpler use case in rev 0. Hannu (Nokia) thanks Chris (Vodafone) for explanation and agrees go back to previous revision. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stefan (Ericsson) comments that this should be a DRAFTCR, and not approved as CR. Chis comments that he assumes that Stefan (Ericsson) means that this should be approved as a DRAFTCR. Stefan (Ericsson) comments: right, whatever we approve will be DRAFTCR === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2008312 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Intra NG-RAN handover via CN for NR satellite access | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007602. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007680 | OTHER | Action | Response LS on the 'LS OUT on Location of UEs and associated key issues'. | SA WG3-LI | Rel-17 | The LS In from SA WG3-LI was noted at S2-139E (S2-2003520): Postponed S2-2001792 at S2#137E, Postponed S2-2002621 at S2#138E). Noted | Noted | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007690 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Discussion of Radio Cells versus Fixed Location Areas. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Dong (Xiaomi) asked a question. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Stephen (Qualcomm) answers question from Dong. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2007700 | DRAFTCR | Approval | CN PDB for slow backhaul links | Qualcomm Incorprorated | Rel-17 | Noted | Dong (Xiaomi) asked a question. Stefan (Ericsson) also has questions === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Haris (Qualcomm) responds to the questions Hucheng(CATT) shares same understanding as E/// and comments Stefan (Ericsson) comments === CC#2 === Dong (Xiaomi) privide comments. Haris (Qualcomm) comments Hucheng(CATT) comments Sherry (Xiaomi) requests for clarification. Hui (Huawei) comments. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to take S2-2007700 as the way forward for satellite backhaul QoS. Hannu (Nokia) supports taking this solution under consideration. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and still has concerns with the CR as it does not solve the problem Dong (Xiaomi) comment. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. DongYeon (Samsung) comments. Hucheng(CATT) has further comments Hui(Huawei) replies. DongYeon (Samsung) replies. Relja (TNO) asks a questions. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Hucheng(CATT) objects this CR as it doesn't solve any issue. Stefan (Ericsson) also objects to the CR Dong (Xiaomi) also objects to the CR. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2007721 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Introduction of Satellite Category - discussion | TNO | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 8.11 | S2-2007727 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Policy control based on satellite category | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: Postponed | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Sherry (Xiaomi) replies. Hannu (Nokia) asks whether such generic PCF update would be justified under this WI for satellite RAT? Sherry (Xiaomi) clarifies that this paper is based on TR 23.737 KI#5 conclusion. DongYeon (Samsung) comments. DongYeon (Samsung) corrects her comments. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Sherry and provides r01 Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Relja (TNO) provides comments/questions related to the terminology used. Haris (Qualcomm) asks what is the scenario that will lead to satellite backhaul category change DongYeon (Samsung) supports r02 (but terminology shall be corrected) and provides comments. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Relja. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Haris. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions because the problem is not satellite backhaul specific === Phase 2 final deadline === Sherry (Xiaomi) couldn't understand the objection to a CR fully aligned with the TR conclusion, and propose to add this topic to the CC#3 agenda to understand if this issue has to be re-studied. === CC#3 === Hannu (Nokia) replies to Sherry (Xiaomi) Jean Yves (Thales): comments on Sherry and Hannu discussion, recommending to postpone. Relja (TNO) answers to Sherry (Xiaomi) and challenges her statement 'the proposed CR is fully in line with the TR conclusion'. Sherry (Xiaomi) requests for clarification. === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Study on architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services - Phase 2 (FS_eV2XARC_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=36 | - | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#1 updates | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007203 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify application requirements and PC5 DRX schedule generation. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008313. | Saad (Interdigital ) providing comments Lei (Tencent) providing response and clarifications. Changhong (Intel) provides comments. Lei (Tencent) provides comments. Adrian(vivo) would like to know what a traffic pattern is. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. === CC#2 === Lei (Tencent) responds to Shabnam(Ericsson). Lei(Tencent) responds to Adrian(vivo). LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed changes about traffic pattern are not needed as discussed in S2-2007200 (Tencent). Lei(Tencent) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). Please do not mix different cases together. I agree the change is not needed in 7200 for because DRX configuration is determined in AS llayer in that solution and I have explained that. Lei(Tencent) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Lei(Tencent) comments. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008313 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify application requirements and PC5 DRX schedule generation. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007203R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007275 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1: Update to Sol#1 to Clarify the PC5 DRX Impact to Uu DRX. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008314. | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments to LGE and Qualcomm and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008314 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1: Update to Sol#1 to Clarify the PC5 DRX Impact to Uu DRX. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007275R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007694 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1 Sol.#1 Updates to remove ENs. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008315. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Ouyang(Huawei) has concerns on V2X layer determines the DRX parameters. Consequently, Ouyang asks a question on the solution for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) asks for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) provides answers to Ouyang (Huawei)'s comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides answers to Hao Dong (ZTE). Dimitris (Lenovo) requests clarification on how the V2X layer determines PC5 DRX based on V2X service type Ouyang(Huawei) seeksfurther clarification. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008315 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1 Sol.#1 Updates to remove ENs. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007694R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#2 updates | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007201 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #2: Update to clarify application requirements and traffic pattern. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2008316. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that introduction of traffic pattern needs to be defined in a common way as updates are being made for many solutions. === CC#2 === Lei (Tencent) responds to Shabnam(Ericsson). LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed changes about traffic pattern are not needed as discussed in S2-2007200 (Tencent). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lei(Tecent), suggesting Lei to take a look at the S2-2007716r07. Lei(Tencent) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Lei (Tencent) comments. Apostolos (Nokia) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Apostolos (Nokia). Apostolos (Nokia) comments. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q on r02. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Apostolos (Nokia) is fine with r04. Lei (Tencent) is ok with the updates. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008316 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #2: Update to clarify application requirements and traffic pattern. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007201R04. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007421 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#2 Update PC5 DRX Configuration Procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2008317. | Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and is fine with r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) is fine with r01. Apostolos (Nokia) says thanks for agreeing and apologizes for the mistake ?? === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008317 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#2 Update PC5 DRX Configuration Procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007421R01. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007597 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#2: Update to clarify PC5 DRX pattern information, PC5 DRX activation and deactivation, and AS-layer PC5 DRX adjustments. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008318. | Ouyang (Huawei) has concerns on AF/PCF providing the PC5 DRX pattern set. Ouyang comments on several issues. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Ouyang. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Apostolos (Nokia). Apostolos (Nokia) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) expresses sympathy with Huawei comments, asks some more clarification. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Shabnam and asks for some clarifications. === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Nokia, in line. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r02. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008318 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#2: Update to clarify PC5 DRX pattern information, PC5 DRX activation and deactivation, and AS-layer PC5 DRX adjustments. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007597R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007715 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution #2 update - add use broad/groupcast to 'impact on other entities'. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008319. | Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the proposal to exchange DRX offset via broadcast/groupcast Apostolos (Nokia) comments Adrian (vivo) provides r01 and also comments Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Adrian and provides r02 Adrian (vivo) is good with r02 === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Ouyang(Huawei) request for additional clarification on the text. Apostolos (Nokia) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). Adrian (vivo) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008319 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution #2 update - add use broad/groupcast to 'impact on other entities'. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007715R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#3 updates | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007029 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Update of Sol#3 to add Rx UE initiated PC5 DRX negotiation. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2008320. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification === CC#2 === Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson). Ouyang(Huawei) is OK with r01 provided by LaeYoung(LG). Shabnam (Ericsson) responds as don't believe the concern is addressed? Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Shabnam(Ericsson) and provides r02 . === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008320 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Update of Sol#3 to add Rx UE initiated PC5 DRX negotiation. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007029R02. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#4 updates | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2006882 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: V2X layer assisted DRX over PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2008321. | LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) asks for clarification. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LG) Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hao Dong (ZTE). Adrian(vivo) provides some comments and proposed changes to the text in the P-CR. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Hao Dong (ZTE) thanks for clarificatin from Ouyang and provides further comment. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01 provided by Ouyang (Huawei). Adrian (vivo) responds to LaeYoung. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Adrian , Hong, LaeYoung and Hao Dong. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) further comments. Ouyang(Huawei) provides r02. Ouyang(Huawei) requests LaeYoung (LGE) to further clarify her suggestion. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Ouyang(Huawei). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for some clarifications. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LG), Hong(QC) and Shabnam(Ericsson). Ouyang(Huawei) provides r03. === CC#2 === Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Huawei for the feedback and proposes then to change Complete Reception mode to Continuous Reception Mode? Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Shabnam(Ericsson) and provide r04. LaeYoung (LGE) comments on r04. Ouyang(Huawei) provides r05 . LaeYoung (LGE) comments on r05. Ouyang provides r06 as requested LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r06. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r07. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Huawei for the updates and ok with the latest version r06. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Ouyang(Huawei) notices that Hong(QC) proposed r07 without notes. Ouyang(Huawei) is fine with r07. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks we can go with r07 (= the last version) instead of r06. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008321 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: V2X layer assisted DRX over PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006882R07. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#5 updates | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007200 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #5: Update for procedure clarification and alignment. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2008322. | Dimitris (Lenovo) requests clarification on traffic pattern provided by application Lei (Tencent) provides clarifications. Apostolos (Nokia) asks some questions. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Apostolos (Nokia) comments and has concerns with the proposal === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === Lei(Tencent) responds to Dimitris(Lenovo) and Apostolos(Nokia) Lei(Tencent) provides r01 and invite V2X folks to provide further comments. If a revision to 7200 is acceptable, similar change will be synced to 7201 and 7203. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) provides comment on r01. Lei(Tencent) provide response to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks that the change in r02 is editorial, so can be addressed in the update of S2-2007714 (vivo) and we can get this paper NOTED. Lei(Tencent) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Lei(Tencent) is ok with r03 provided by LaeYoung(LGE). === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008322 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, Sol #5: Update for procedure clarification and alignment. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007200R03. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007237 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#5: Additional option on PC5 DRX configuration. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008323. | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) comments. Dimitris provides r03 and addresses comments from Shabnam (Ericsson) === CC#2 === Ouyang(Huawei) continues the discussion from S2-2007030 Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Ouyang (Huawei) Adrian (vivo) comments that r03 is not based on the baseline TR. LaeYoung (LGE) does not find something strange in r03. ^^ Adrian (vivo) provides screen shots of r03 to show the issue. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Adrian (vivo). Ouyang(Huawei) requests to Dimitris (Lenovo) to highlight/document the points in the solution , which are clarified in the email. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 to address comments from Ouyang (Huawei) Ouyang(Huawei) thanks Dimitrios(Lenovo) for the update. OK with r04. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r05 with an editorial correction. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008323 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#5: Additional option on PC5 DRX configuration. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007237R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007714 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution #5 update - add ability to use broad/groupcast for DRX offset updating and correct terminology. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. LaeYoung (LGE) provides further comment. Adrian (vivo) thanks LaeYoung for the reminder and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02 while complaining about some unresolved changes. >__< === Phase 2 revisions deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) propose to note S2-2007714 LaeYoung (LGE) agrees with Dimitris (Lenovo) that this paper can be NOTED. Adrian (vivo) is ok with the majority view. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#6 updates | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007598 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#6: Evaluation of the level on which PC5 DRX schedules should be mapped. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2008324. | Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the evaluation points Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Dimitris. Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision r01. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to the content in its current form, Rel-17 TRs will not have individual Evaluation per solution as was agreed at the beginning for all TRs. See comments. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper and to focus on the interim agreements working with 7716 and LS Out working to 6978. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Dimitris, Shabnam, and LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers to Apostolos (Nokia). Apostolos (Nokia) asks for further clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Apostolos (Nokia). Apostolos (Nokia) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). === CC#2 === LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Ouyang(Huawei) asks for clarification . LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung and provide r03 Apostolos (Nokia) responds and provides r04 LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04 if no one has concern on this approach. ^^ Shabnam (Ericsson) if we are proceeding with this paper, then I suggest we add a subclause for evaluation and add EN that we need RAN feedback. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson). LaeYoung (LGE) comments on the title. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r05. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r05. Ouyang(Huawei) is fine with r05 and thanks Apostolos(Nokia)'s hard work. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008324 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#6: Evaluation of the level on which PC5 DRX schedules should be mapped. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007598R05. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Sol#7 updates | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007424 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#7 Update to Clarify VRU Clustering related Description. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because the proposed changes are not needed. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. Hong (Qualcomm) agree with LGE that the paper should be NOTED. Adrian(vivo) agree QC that the paper should be NOTED. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam(Ericsson) supports that the document should be NOTED. === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Evaluations and Conclusions | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2006883 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Evaluation and Conclusion on Solution 4. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2007030 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Evaluation on PC5 DRX determination. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Dimitris (Lenovo) disagrees with the evaluation points of Sol #5 LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper and to focus on the interim conclusions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2007239 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1: Evaluation of solutions. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper and to focus on the interim conclusions. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2007241 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1: Proposed conclusions . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2007693 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1 interim conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2007716 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Interim conclusions. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | r12 agreed. Revised to S2-2008325. | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Ouyang(Huawei) requests LaeYoung(LGE) for clarification. Suggest to keep vivo's conclusion paper as placeholder for interim conclusion, if any. LaeYoung(LGE) is fine with suggestion from Ouyang (Huawei) to keep this paper open as placeholder for interim conclusion, if any. Apostolos (Nokia) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung and Apostolos. Adrian(vivo) asks 'we using the vivo paper as baseline?' LaeYoung (LGE) answers 'We will use the vivo paper just as skeleton :)' and provides r01. Ouyang(Huawei) provides r02. Adrian(vivo) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and provides r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Shabnam (Ericsson) comments for update. Adrian (vivo) provides some response. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r05. === CC#2 === Ouyang(Huawei) has concerns on (pre-)configurations and asks Hong(QC) for clarification . Ouyang(Huawei) asks Apostolos (Nokia) for clarification . Adrian(vivo) responds to Ouyang and provides r06. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments. Adrian (vivo) provides comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Adrian(vivo) and Hong(QC). Ouyang(Huawei) provides r07 LaeYoung provides r08 Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung and comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks some questions and comments. LaeYoung provides answers and r09 Ouyang(Huawei) seeks Hoyeon's clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) questions what value this conclusion paper brings with many ENs due to still pending decision? Adrian (vivo) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson). Apostolos (Nokia) provides r10. Ouyang(Huawei) seeks Apostolos(Nokia) for clarification. The authors of solution #5 and #6 can be related. Apostolos (Nokia) provides clarification to Ouyang (Huawei) LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Apostolos (Nokia) responds. Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provides r11 Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Apostolos(Nokia) and provide r12. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r13 LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r12, but r13 is not preferred. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to LaeYoung LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Dimitris (Lenovo). Dimitris (Lenovo) is ok with r12 based on LaeYoung (LGE) clarifications Apostolos (Nokia) is also fine with r12. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008325 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Interim conclusions. | Vivo Mobile Communications Ltd, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2007716R12. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | LS Out | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2006978 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on PC5 DRX operation | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r13 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2007031, to S2-2008326. | Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Ouyang(Huawei) objects to original version and r01, provides r02. Let's start with the simple and RAN2 related questions. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r03. === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r05 and question for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06. === CC#2 === Ouyang(Huawei) provides r07 . LaeYoung (LGE) provides r08. Apostolos (Nokia) comments and asks for feedback. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) objects to r07 and r08. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r09. Ouyang(Huawei) has issue with Q1 . Consider Q5 is overlapping with Q1. Apostolos (Nokia) responds. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r10 Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and asks for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r11. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r12. Ouyang(Huawei) provides the r13. Also provides r14 as backup. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on r12 Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r15 Hong (Qualcomm) asks Dimitris for clarifications. Shabnam (Ericsson) also trying to understand Lenovo position and if it is RAN2 then why not propose directly there, since it is ambiguous at this point in SA2 what are we discussing? Dimitris (Lenovo) replies to Hong (Qualcomm) Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) Apostolos (Nokia) provides r16. LaeYoung (LGE) who is sleepy provides comment on r15 adding Starting point of the PC5 DRX 'ON periods'. === Phase 2 revisions deadline === LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r16 and proposes to go with r16. Anyhow, r13 is also fine. LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo). Ouyang(Huawei) can't accept r16. Ouyang(Huawei) propose r17 to be discussed in CC. If this is not possible , r13 is our preference. Apostolos (Nokia) prefers r16, but can also live with r13. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r13 and asks Tao (VC) to check r13 instead of r16 for approval. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r13. LaeYoung (LGE) will fix some grammar issues when cleaning-up (i.e. 'reach' to 'has reached', 'both is' to 'both are'). Shabnam (Ericsson) is OK with r13. === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2008326 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on PC5 DRX operation | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006978R13, merging S2-2007031. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2007031 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS to RAN WG2 on PC5 DRX determination | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2008326 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this LS into S2-2006978 (LGE) and update S2-2006978. Ouyang (Huawei) is OK to merge 2007031 to 2006978. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to mark this LS merged into S2-2006978 (LGE). === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Merged |
| 9 | - | - | - | Project Planning and Management | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | New and Revised Work Items, Cover sheets for completed work items | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | Revised SIDs | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2007380 | SID REVISED | Approval | Revised SID: Feasibility Study on Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 2. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | S2-2007381 | SID REVISED | Approval | Revised SID: Study on Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture Phase 2. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | Revised TEI17 WID | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2007119 | WID REVISED | Approval | Revised WID: TEI17_DCAMP - Dynamically Changing AM Policies in the 5GC . | Ericsson, Telstra | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | New WIDs | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2007446 | WID NEW | Approval | New WID on System enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS. | CATT, OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hannu (Nokia) proposes to postpone new WID in S2-2007446 and proposes also to consider the same approach on all tdocs in AI 9.1, if feasible? === Phase 1 revisions Deadline === === CC#2 === === Phase 2 revisions deadline === === Phase 2 final deadline === === CC#3 === === Close of e-meeting === | Postponed |
| 9.2 | - | - | - | Review of the Work Plan | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 9.2 | - | - | - | Rel-17 SID status reports | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 9.2 | S2-2006831 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2007936. | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2007936 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006831. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2007306 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eNPN Status Report | Ericsson (rapporteur) | Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007771 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_IS_UAS-SA2 Status Report | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2007785 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_IIoT Status report | Nokia (Rapporteur) | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007786 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eNS_Ph2 Status Report | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB (Rapporteur) | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007787 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Status Report | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007788 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_MUSIM Status Report | Intel (rapporteur) | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007789 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | Report of FS_enh_EC status | Huawei | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007790 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_5MBS status report | Huawei | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007791 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_5G_ProSe Status Report | CATT. OPPO | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2007792 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eNA_ph2 Status Report | Huawei, China Mobile | Created at CC#1. Noted | Noted | ||
| 9.2 | - | - | - | CC#_Work_Planning | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 9.2 | S2-2008111 | OTHER | Discussion | SA WG2_2020_WP_r1.pptx | SA WG2 Chair | CC#_Work_Planning: Slides 2, 3, 4 and the first item (i.e. No Rel-18 proposal will be handled in Q1, 2021) of Slide 6 were endorsed. | Endorsed | ||
| 9.2 | S2-2008112 | OTHER | Discussion | SA WG2_Rel-17_SID_status_post_SA WG2#141E | SA WG2 Chair | CC#_Work_Planning: Rapporteurs were asked to provide input to the SA WG2 Chair before 23.59 UTC Friday 30 October. | Noted | ||
| 9.3 | - | - | - | Planning future meetings | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 11 | - | - | - | Close of e-meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 99 | - | - | - | Withdrawn and reserved documents | - | - | Docs:=154 | - | |
| 99 | S2-2007673 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update for solution37 to remove Ens | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN Not available, replaced by next? | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007674 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update for solution45 to remove Ens | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN Not available, replaced by next? | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007675 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update valuation for KI#1 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007678 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update solution #14 for clarification with an EN | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007676 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update valuation for KI#2 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007677 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Update evaluation for KI#3 | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007777 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006967 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8: Update for Solution #17 and Conclusion | OPPO | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007166 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Evaluation and conclution on PNI-NPN provisioning | China Mobile | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007172 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1: Interim conclusions | vivo | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007072 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation update on Solutions of KI#3. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Tricci (ZTE) proposes to merge this evaluation paper to S2-2006844 === Close of e-meeting === | Withdrawn |
| 99 | S2-2006975 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0490 (Rel-15, 'F'): Location change (serving cell) for Policy Control Request Trigger in R15 | China Mobile | Rel-15 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006830 | WID NEW | Approval | KI#12_Solution Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision of (postponed) S2-2004929 WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006957 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on OAM that supports RAT/frequency data | China Telecomunication Corp. | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | ||
| 99 | S2-2007022 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1: Overall Evaluation | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision of (noted) S2-2005399 WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007069 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1: Update to Sol#22 for negative A&A from RID USS | OPPO | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006968 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8: Update for Solution #17 and Conclusion. | OPPO | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006969 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and interim conclusion for PC5 usage information configuration | OPPO | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2006970 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Conclusion Update | OPPO | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2007626 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2437 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections for EPS/RAT fallback for VoWiFi session | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn |