32.584 session rapporteur notes: Wednesday, February 18, 2009 S5-091329r1: discussion: rapporteur - presented the current 32.584 status - skeleton - updated at sa5-62bis with TS number - updated at sa5-63 based on the vote results (removed FM file section) - CM section (placeholder) needs to be filled up - PM section may be referenced to an existing document ip.access - we could directly reference 32.435 for the PM file format ALU - volunteered to generate a contribution for the CM section (during SA5-63) chair - proposed an exception request for 32.584 ip.access - exception may not be needed, with CM contribution from ALU we pretty much need to reference sections from 32.435 in corresponding sections of PM file format chair - certain elements in 32.435 are not needed here (in 32.584) ip.access - we (company) already using the 32.435 for PM in our product E// - mapping table is needed (some names in 32.435 do not match 32.582) E// - need to add PM section to 32.582 chair - we do need a mapping table to ensure the consistency E// - one of the issues - currently we don't have a GP E// - volunteered to provide help with new table generation ip.access - we need a confirmation on TR-069 from Taka outcome: - ALU will provides a contribution for CM format (soon) new tdoc number 091459 - E// will help with PM format table for 32.582 (start the CR) new tdoc number 091452 - with PM format table in 32.582 the schema will be referenced to 32.435 in 32.584 new tdoc 091453 - exception may not be needed if SA5 manages to approve 091459, 091452 and 091453 S5-091173: discussion: ip.access - based on the results of voting, this contribution does not belong to the 32.58x series, suggested to put it in a new informative annex of TR 32.821, so that the important information contained in this contribution is preserved and readily available later (when needed) ALU - can the informative annex be added to a 32.58x series document chair - adding it (even as informative annex) to the 32.58x series contradicts with the agreement to remove the FM file transfer (voting results) ALU - how the 32.821 will be managed/maintained? chair - let's keep the TR 32.821 open (with this contribution in it) ALU - what is the value of keeping the 32.821 alive? chair - TR 32.821 will be used as a repository ip. access - presented the contribution all - no objection outcome: - the contribution will be added as an informative annex to the TR 32.821 Thursday, February 19, 2009 S5-091470: E// - presented the document with motivation that semantics definition is neede in stage 2 document chair - confirmed that the document contains 3GPP table 4.1 from 32.432 All - no objection to include it in 32.582 outcome: - accepted for inclusion into 32.582 S5-091329r2: rapporteur - presented the document. noted that the table 6.1 requires "File Content Item" to be populated E// - the "File Content Item" column shall be populated with values from table 4.1 in S5-091470 ip.access - there will be no additional column with BBF terms in table 6.1. instead the "description" column will be edited to add references to related BBF terms. the editing will be done offline with rapporteur chair - are we sure that all rows in table 6.1 (table 4.1 in S5-091470) are needed for the HNB PM? all - no objection (to including all lines) outcome: - document will be revised (table 6.1 edited) to a new t-doc S5-091475 Friday, February 20, 2009 S5-091475: rapporteur - presented the document E// - the description of measObjInstId has to be changed from "Local DN of HNB" to the terms agreed in 32.582 (6.2.1) chair - make the required changes and produce version 0.1.0 and submit for e-mail approval, no need to send the TS for info since it's less than 60% complete (CM part is missing) all - no objection outcome: - document will be sent for e-mail approval (approval deadline - one week from the meeting)