Chairman's notes

 

IPR call reminder:

"I draw your attention to your obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations' IPR policies. Every Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become essential to the work of 3GPP.

Delegates are asked to take note that they are thereby invited:

  • to investigate whether their organization or any other organization owns IPRs which are, or are likely to become Essential in respect of the work of 3GPP.
  • to notify their respective Organizational Partners of all potential IPRs, e.g., for ETSI, by means of the IPR Information Statement and the Licensing declaration forms".

 

Antitrust policy Reminder:

"I also draw your attention to the fact that 3GPP activities are subject to all applicable antitrust and competition laws and that compliance with said laws is therefore required of any participant of this TSG/WG meeting including the Chairman and Vice Chairman. In case of question I recommend that you contact your legal counsel.

The leadership shall conduct the present meeting with impartiality and in the interests of 3GPP.

 

Furthermore, I would like to remind you that timely submission of work items in advance of TSG/WG meetings is important to allow for full and fair consideration of such matters."

 

 

List for Meeting: All Sessions
Temporary Documents List - Ordered by Agenda Item
AI TD# Type Doc For Subject Source Rel Comments e-mail_Discussion Result
0 - - - All Agenda Items - - Docs:=0 -
1.1 - - - Opening of the meeting - - Docs:=0 -
2 - - - Agenda - - Docs:=1 -
2 S2-2201916 AGENDA Approval SA WG2 #150E Meeting Agenda SA WG2 Chair Approved Approved
2.1 - - - IPR Call and Antitrust Reminder - - Docs:=0 -
3 - - - SA2#149E Meeting report - - Docs:=1 -
3 S2-2201917 REPORT Approval Auto-Generated Report of SA WG2 meeting #149E SA WG2 Secretary Approved Approved
4 - - - General - - Docs:=0 -
4.1 - - - Common issues and Incoming LSs - - Docs:=82 -
4.1 S2-2201950 LS In Information LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on opens issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN RAN WG2 (R2-2204108) Rel-17 Noted Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to NOTE the LS, there is no action for SA2.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201958 LS In Information LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on opens issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN SA WG3 (S3-220543) Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) Proposes to note.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom): same view as Steve, LS shall be noted, no action for SA2.
Noted
4.1 S2-2201962 LS In Information LS from ETSI ISG MEC: LS to 3GPP on MEC Federation and interest to collaborate ETSI ISG MEC (MEC(22)000127r5) Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
Magnus O (Ericsson) Agree with Hui, the LS is for information and should be Noted.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201922 LS In Information LS from GSMA: Reply LS on IMEI for Non-Public Networks/Private Networks without using USIM GSMA (TSG46_028) Revision of Postponed S2-2200040 from S2#149E. Noted Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the LS.
Qianghua (Huawei) the tile should be S2-2201922 and agrees to note 1922.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201929 LS In Action LS from CT WG1: LS on progress of FS_eIMS5G2 CT WG1 (C1-220734) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200082 from S2#149E. Noted Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the LS as CT1 has made no progress on this topic.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201935 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: LS on full Registration Request upon AMF re-allocation SA WG3 (S3-220453) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2201519 from S2#149E. Noted Fenqin (Huawei) Propose to note this LS.
Qian (Ericsson) agrees that the LS can be noted.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202238 DISCUSSION Discussion Discussion paper on Mapped NSSAI handling. Apple Rel-17 Noted Noted
4.1 S2-2202378 DISCUSSION Discussion Discussion on the mapped S-NSSAI in VPLMN. Qualcomm Incorporated Noted Jinguo(ZTE) comments that the observation 2 is incorrect.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) recommends this paper be noted. It is also incorrect.
Jinguo(ZTE) response to Guillaume,
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202047 CR Approval 23.501 CR3583 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Mapped NSSAI Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202240 CR Approval 23.501 CR3598 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of description of Mapped NSSAI handling Apple Rel-17 Noted Jinguo(ZTE) correct the title since this topic is moved to 4.1
Dongeun (Samsung) objects to this CR.
Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to this CR.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201936 LS In Action LS from CT WG1: LS on Mapped NSSAI CT WG1 (C1-222095) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202046, S2-2202239, S2-2202369, S2-2202662, S2-2202876, S2-2202576. Final response in S2-2203151 Replied to
4.1 S2-2202046 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2203022 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to use 2662 as basis
Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to use 2046 as baseline.
Robert (Apple) is asking a question for clarification on 2046 and the corresponding proposed CR in 2047.
Tao(VC) please use this thread for discussion of response of 1936, per the checking with people on CC#1.
Haiyang(Huawei) responds to Robert (Apple).
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04
Genadi (Lenovo) provides r03.
Robert (Apple) provides r02
Alessio(Nokia) provides r01
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) comments.
Jinguo(ZTE) asks question for clarification
Guillaume (MediaTek) objects r04, provides r05.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
Haiyang (Huawei) responses to Jinguo(ZTE) , provides r06 for clean up
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) object to r06.
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r07
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) thanks Haiyang (Huawei)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
alessio(nokia) provides r08 as some wording in r07 was a bit not correct (in our opinion)
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question why r07 was wrong
alessio(Nokia) comments that the rejected s-NSSAI has to include the mirror of what the UE requested and the UE would request the REQUESTED NSSAI with the mapped value in scenarios where it is roaming.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and r08 is not aligned with SA2 specs and prefers to go with r07 + removal of text
Alessio(nokia) is ok with whatever works which is not creating further issues on thisrel-15 topic.
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r09 based on the agreement: which is r07 + removal of text 'A rejected S-NSSAI for the entire Serving PLMN is expected to be provided without a mapped HPLMN S-NSSAI value if the reason of rejection is that there is no mapping info available. However, if the reason of rejection is not due to unavailable mapping info, the Serving PLMN can provide the rejected VPLMN S-NSSAI value with the corresponding mapped HPLMN S-NSSAI value. In both cases, a new configured NSSAI is provided to the UE with the correct mapping for the S-NSSAIs the UE is expected to be able to request in the VPLMN.'
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r09
==== Comments Deadline ====
alessioi(nokia) ok with r09
Robert (Apple) is ok with r09
Revised
4.1 S2-2203022 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202046r07. Approved. Incorrect attachment provided. Revised to S2-2203151. Revised
4.1 S2-2203151 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2203022 Approved
4.1 S2-2202239 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI Apple (UK) Limited Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. Noted Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to use 2662 as basis for discussion
Jinguo(ZTE) correct the title since this topic is moved to 4.1
Dongeun (Samsung) objects to this LS response.
Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to this LS response.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202369 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. Noted Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to use 2662 as basis
Apples objects to the LS, especially to the interpretation which is expressed in the answer to question 2 and described in more detail in 2378.
Haiyang (Huawei) comments, agrees with Robert (Apple) and Jinguo (ZTE).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202662 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI ZTE Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. Noted Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes suggested answer in the mail.
Haiyang (Huawei ) comments on r00 and thinks what Peter (Ericsson) proposes is quite aligned with S2-2202046. Thus suggests to use 2046 as baseline directly.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.): ok to use 2662 as placeholder for discussions.
Tao(VC) suggest to use either 2262 or 2046 as the basis. If not agreeable, use 1936 instead. Suggest to check in CC#1.
Robert (Apple): also ok to use 2662 as placeholder for discussions.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202876 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI MediaTek Inc. Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. Noted Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to use 2662 as basis for discussion
Jinguo(ZTE) correct the title since this topic is moved to 4.1
Stefano (Qualcomm) objects to this LS response.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) respectfully disagrees with Stefano (Qualcomm) assessment.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202576 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Mapped NSSAI Lenovo, Motorola Mobility Rel-17 Response to S2-2201936. Noted Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to use 2662 as basis for discussion
Jinguo(ZTE) correct the title since this topic is moved to 4.1
Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to consider the LS merged into 2369.
Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201921 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on paging subgrouping and PEI RAN WG2 (R2-2111415) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200032 from S2#149E. Postponed Qian (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the paper as there is no reply paper in this meeting.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2201924 LS In Action LS on access to multiple IMS networks via a 5GC network slice CT WG1 (C1-216839) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200042 from S2#149E. Noted Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the LS as CT1 has made no progress on this topic.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201925 LS In Action LS from CT WG4: Reply LS on Support of Asynchronous Type Communication in N1N2MessageTransfer CT WG4 (C4-216381) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200054 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202048. Noted Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to note this LS In.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202048 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Support of Asynchronous Type Communication in N1N2MessageTransfer Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201925. Noted Hannu (Nokia) can't agree with the proposed analysis in this LS. Proposes to re-use the text from S2-2200282r01 in r01.
Haris(Qualcomm) agrees with Hannu (Nokia) analysis and supports r01, or suggests to simply note the incoming LS to not spend further time
Haiyang (Huawei) comments to r01.
Qian (Ericsson) supports r01
Hannu (Nokia) expresses his concern on SA2 working procedures when the same proposal is submitted repeatedly after clear and justified objections have been made against it.
Haiyang (Huawei) cannot accept r01; and can agree with Haris (Qualcomm) to note the incoming LS S2-2201925
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201940 LS In Action LS from GSMA: Reply LS to 3GPP SA2 on ARP PL GSMA (NRG 012_206r3) Response drafted in S2-2202185. Final response in S2-2203023 Judy (Ericsson) comments that S2-2202170 is not a response to the LS thus to be removed.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Replied to
4.1 S2-2202185 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS to GSMA NRG on ARP override and GBR alignment for VoLTE roaming Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201940 and S2-2201970. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203023 Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 to take out the GBR part, see discussion in 2186 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) supports r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203023 LS OUT Approval Reply LS to GSMA NRG on ARP override VoLTE roaming SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202185r01. Approved Approved
4.1 S2-2201941 LS In Action LS from EUWENA: LS on presentation of EUWENA and involvement in 3GPP on Non Public Network EUWENA (LS EUWENA) Noted Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the LS as there is no action to SA2.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201951 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on EPS fallback enhancements RAN WG2 (R2-2204236) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2201997 and S2-2202366. Final response in S2-2203590 Replied to
4.1 S2-2201997 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on EPS fallback enhancements Qualcomm Rel-17 Response to S2-2201951. r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2203590. George Foti (Ericsson) provides r01
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r02
Genadi (Lenovo) provides r03. Prefers to take this LS reply as basis and merge S2-2202366 into this one.
Alessio(Nokia) provides r04.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r05
Xiaobo (vivo) asks for clarification from George Foti (Ericsson).
Chris provides rev 6 to address Vivo question and clarify that network control is needed for the MO case.
Xiaobo (vivo) thanks clarification from Chris(VDF) and support that network control is needed for the MO case and reword CT1 related content and provides r07.
Wanqiang (Huawei) provides r08.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Antoine (Orange) : Small changes needed on top of r08.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with Orange, r08 can be the basis, but for the final version changes are necessary.
Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r08 but agrees that the Orange comments are valid. If editing, one extra typo should be fixed.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides post deadline r09 to discuss in CC
Xiaobo (vivo) is ok with r09 and thanks Haris for the update.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203590 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on EPS fallback enhancements SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201997r09. Approved Approved
4.1 S2-2202366 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on EPS fallback enhancements Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201951. Noted George Foti (Ericsson) objects to the LS
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also objects to the LS. For the reply LS SA2 should continue with S2-2201997
Jungshin (Samsung): We also object to the proposed LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201960 LS In Action LS from SA WG4: LS on Traffic Identification within 5G Media Streaming SA WG4 (S4-220305) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202188. This was postponed. Postponed
4.1 S2-2202188 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Traffic Identification within 5G Media Streaming Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201960. This was postponed. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to first discuss and agree on the CR proposed in 2189 before agreeing on the LS OUT
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Pallab (Nokia) proposes r01 of the LS OUT based on discussions in 2189
Judy (Ericsson) request to discuss in CC#2, see discussion in 2189 thread
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202189 CR Approval 23.502 CR3431 (Rel-17, 'F'): Traffic Identification using ToS/TC for 5G Media Streaming Ericsson Rel-17 This was postponed. Pallab (Nokia) comments and asks for clarification
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Pallab (Nokia)
Pallab (Nokia) responds to Judy (Ericsson)
Haiyang (Huawei) comments; suggests to generate a 503 CR to update description of flow description.
Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Pallab (Nokia) and asks Haiyang (Huawei) for clarification
Judy (Ericsson) ask further questions
Haiyang (Huawei) further responds
Dario (Qualcomm) provides r01
Judy (Ericsson) provides r03 based on r00 and comments, please ignore r02.
Pallab (Nokia) asks if we can agree that there is no need for this CR and reply to SA4 accordingly
Dario (Qualcomm) comments.
Judy (Ericsson) propose to go with the CR proposal to support the SA4 use case.
Pallab (Nokia) proposes to NOTE the CR and respond to SA4 accordingly
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) is fine with noting the CR.
Judy (Ericsson) does not agree to note this CR as there is no technical argument provided, and requests we allow for services deployment support by the operators with knowledge of responsibility documented in 3GPP specs.
Pallab (Nokia) responds to Judy (Ericsson) and maintains the position to NOTE the paper. Proposes LS OUT draft revision to SA4
Judy (Ericsson) does not agree it is 3GPP scope to specify 'How the operator and the external DN (service provider) can collaborate' in the context of the discussion, and request to discuss in CC#2
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2201945 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on how to receive the first PC5-S unicast message during PC5-S connection setup procedure RAN WG2 (R2-2203691) Rel-16 Response drafted in S2-2202376. Final response in S2-2203024 Replied to
4.1 S2-2202376 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on how to receive the first PC5-S unicast message during PC5-S connection setup procedure CATT Rel-16 Response to S2-2201945. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203024 Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 to improve the wording.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Hannu (Nokia).
Hannu (Nokia) answers to Deng Qiang
Fei (OPPO) comments
Steve (Huawei) has a preference for r00
LaeYoung (LGE) also prefers r00, so proposes to go with r00.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) still prefers r01 but can also live with r00.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203024 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on how to receive the first PC5-S unicast message during PC5-S connection setup procedure SA WG2 Rel-16 Revision of S2-2202376r00. Approved Approved
4.1 S2-2201964 LS In Action LS from ETSI EMTEL: LS response to 3GPP SA1 on IMS emergency communication improvement - SMS to emergency centre ETSI EMTEL (EMTEL(22)000042) Noted Vodafone proposes to note this LS. Response to EMTEL should be sent by SA1.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) also requests to note this LS. Response to EMTEL should be sent by SA1.
Rainer (Nokia) agrees to not the LS as it is asking to add requirements to 3gpp specs.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2201970 LS In Information LS from GSMA: LS to 3GPP SA2 on VoLTE Roaming GBR Handling GSMA (NRG 13_201r2) Response drafted in S2-2202185. Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments this LS is also responded in S2-2202185 thus to be added in 'Comments' column.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to POSTPONE the LS-in, VoLTE Roaming GBR Handling is proposed to be discussed at the next SA2 meeting.
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202775 LS In Action Reply LS on mandatory SSC modes supported by UE CT WG1 (C1-222033) Rel-15 Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
Stefan (Ericsson) agrees that it can be noted
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202780 LS In Action LS from CT WG4: Reply-LS on Deletion of ME support of SOR-CMCI indicator during Nudm_SDM_Get CT WG4 (C4-221079) Rel-17 Noted Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to NOTE the LS
Qian (Ericsson) supports to NOTE the LS as SA2 spec covered the aspect already.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202781 LS In Information LS from CT WG4: Reply LS On User Consent Updating CT WG4 (C4-221413) Rel-17 Noted Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to NOTE the LS, there is no action for SA2.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202789 LS In Information LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on paging subgrouping and PEI RAN WG3 (R3-222874) Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) Proposes to note.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202793 LS In Information LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on User Consent Updating SA WG3 (S3-220474) Rel-17 Noted Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to NOTE the LS, there is no action for SA2.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
4.1 S2-2202798 LS In Information LS on Alignment concerning 5G RG requirements and its remote management TSG SA (SP-220347) Rel-18 Noted Noted
4.1 S2-2202783 LS In Information LS from BBF: 3GPP TS 29.244 BBF (LIAISE-507-02) Noted Noted
4.1 S2-2202784 LS In Information LS from BBF: ATSSS and Co-located AGF-UPF procedures BBF (LIAISE-519) Response drafted in S2-2202242. Final response in S2-2203021 Replied to
4.1 S2-2202242 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on ATSSS and Co-located AGF-UPF procedures Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2202784. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203021 Revised
4.1 S2-2203021 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on ATSSS and Co-located AGF-UPF procedures SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202242r00. Approved Approved
4.1 S2-2201983 CR Approval 23.316 CR2063 (Rel-17, 'F'): Generalizing NAS transport between 5G and W-AGF to accommodate latest BBF developments Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2201996 CR Approval 23.501 CR3496R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Requirement for signalling separate IMEI for each network subscription Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-16 Revision of (Postponed) S2-2200386 from S2#149E. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203026 Rainer (Nokia) provides comment.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203026 CR Approval 23.501 CR3496R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Requirement for signalling separate IMEI for each network subscription Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-16 Revision of S2-2201996r01. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202171 CR Approval 23.316 CR2064 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to BBF LS 512 (Frame route, BBF references) Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203030 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203030 CR Approval 23.316 CR2064R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to BBF LS 512 (Frame route, BBF references) Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202171r02. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202172 CR Approval 23.501 CR3591 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to BBF LS 512 (Frame route, BBF references) Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203031 Marco (Huawei) provide r01 with editorial clean up
Marco (Huawei)
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Marco (Huawei) agree r02 (reference missing in chair note)
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203031 CR Approval 23.501 CR3591R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to BBF LS 512 (Frame route, BBF references) Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202172r02. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202186 CR Approval 23.401 CR3695 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of ARP and GBR for IMS voice service in home routed roaming Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom Rel-17 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203027 Robert (Peraton Labs) provides r01
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r03 and responds to Mirko (Huawei) and Chris (Vodafone)
So far this discussion has covered both 5GC and EPC but Chris (Vodafone) suggests that Alternative QoS Profiles are used for the GBR issue on 5GC.
Mirko (Huawei) comments.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03
Chris (Vodafone) repeats his request for an explanation of how rev 3 works. Alt QoS remains a possibility for 5GC.
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Chris (Vodafone)
Chris (Vodafone) answers on Alt QoS and requests an explanation of how rev 3 works
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Chris (Vodafone) and provides r06 taking out GBR downgrade.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) prefers r06, and objects to r01.
Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r06 (which solves the ARP issue). We need to work on the GBR issue at the next SA2.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203027 CR Approval 23.401 CR3695R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of ARP for IMS voice service in home routed roaming Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202186r06. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202187 CR Approval 23.501 CR3593 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of ARP and GBR for IMS voice service in home routed roaming Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom Rel-17 r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2203028 Robert (Peraton Labs) provides r01
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
Chris (Vodafone) suggests that Alternative QoS Profiles are used for the GBR issue on 5GC.
Mirko (Huawei) comments.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03
Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r03 and responds to Chris (Vodafone) & Mirko (Huawei).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Chris (Vodafone) objects to all versions of this CR. This is stop misalignment with S2-2202186. We need to revisit this in the next SA2.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) asks VF to withdraw objection for r07.
Judy (Ericsson) also ask Chris (Vodafone) to withdraw objection against r07 which is fully aligned with 2186
Chris (Vodafone) withdraws his objection and is OK with r07.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203028 CR Approval 23.501 CR3593R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of ARP for IMS voice service in home routed roaming Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202187r07. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202190 CR Approval 23.501 CR3594 (Rel-17, 'F'): RRC state terminology alignment Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Hannu (Nokia) proposes to mark S2-2202190 and S2-2202191 as 'not handled' since 5GS_Ph1 is not on the agenda.
Shabnam (Ericsson) Clarifies that as other Rel-17 new spec like MBS starting to align terminology with base specs 501 and 502, we need to get agreement on this in April.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202191 CR Approval 23.502 CR3432 (Rel-17, 'F'): RRC state terminology alignment Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Tao(VC) correct the title with correct tdoc number.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202241 CR Approval 23.316 CR2065 (Rel-17, 'F'): Additional support for selecting UPF collocated with W-AGF Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203025 Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) changing to correct AI in subject. OK with r01
Marco (Huawei) question for clarification and some doubts
Stefan (Ericsson) provides replies to Marco
Marco (Huawei) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203025 CR Approval 23.316 CR2065R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Additional support for selecting UPF collocated with W-AGF Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202241r02. Approved Agreed
4.1 S2-2202375 DISCUSSION Discussion Discussion on Source Layer-2 ID of first PC5-S unicast message. CATT, LG Electronics, Deutsche Telekom Rel-16 Noted Noted
4.1 S2-2201937 LS In Action LS on handling of packet filters when the supported number is exceeded CT WG3 (C3-221503) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202182, S2-2202448, S2-2202825. Postponed Pallab (Nokia) also agrees to discuss the proposals in this thread. Also provides comments on the related CRs
zhendong (ZTE) agree to use this as discussion reflector
Judy (Ericsson) comments that there are 3 sets of papers with different solutions and propose to use this thread for solution discussion.
Peter (Vodafone) agrees with the text in draft LS out in S2-2202182 that the decision on packet filters for TFT is to be based on operator policy, as also proposed in S2-2202825. Vodafone also prefers the response proposed in S2-2202182 or S2-2202825 rather than the response in S2-2202448.
Mirko (Huawei) comments that the solution has to allow that more than 16 packet filters can be assigned to a PDU session eligible for EPS IWK.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments
Judy (Ericsson) share Mirko (Huawei)'s view, thanks Sebastian (Qualcomm)'s support for Set 1 papers and propose to continue the revisions on Set 1 (2182, 2183, 2184).
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Judy (Ericsson) responds to zhendong (ZTE)
Pallab (Nokia) comments
Mirko (Huawei) responds.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the repsonse
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Zhendong
Mirko (Huawei) comments.
zhendong (ZTE) ask question for clarificaiton
zhendong (ZTE) provides response to mirko
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Mirko (Huawei), zhendong (ZTE) and Pallab (Nokia)
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response to nokia
Pallab (Nokia) respond to zhendong (ZTE)
Pallab (Nokia) responds to Judy (Ericsson)
Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to postpone all CRs and the reply LS given that no solution seems to be agreeable this time
zhendong (ZTE) is fine to have more discussion.
Pallab (Nokia) is also OK to postpone and have more discussion.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) kindly asks authors of all related CRs and draft LSs to indicate in the respective threads that the papers should be marked postponed
Judy (Ericsson) is OK with the postponement if preferred by the majority
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202182 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply to LS handling of packet filters when the supported number is exceeded Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201937. Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202448 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS OUT on handling of packet filters when the supported number is exceeded; Response to S2-2201937 Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Response to S2-2201937. Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202825 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS On handling of packet filters when the supported number is exceeded ZTE Response to S2-2201937. Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
zhendong (ZTE) is fine to postpone
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202183 CR Approval 23.502 CR3430 (Rel-17, 'F'): Number of TFT filters exceeding allowed limit for 5GS to EPS interworking Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
Mirko (Huawei) provides r01.
Judy (Ericsson) thanks Mirko (Huawei) for the revision and is fine with r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202184 CR Approval 23.503 CR0712 (Rel-17, 'F'): Number of TFT filters exceeding allowed limit for 5GS to EPS interworking Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
Mirko (Huawei) provides r01.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202449 CR Approval 23.503 CR0713 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of number of supported Packet Filters for signalled QoS rules for the PDU Session with EPS IWK Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202450 CR Approval 23.502 CR3444 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of number of supported Packet Filters for signalled QoS rules for the PDU Session with EPS IWK Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202451 CR Approval 23.501 CR3608 (Rel-17, 'F'): Handling of number of supported Packet Filters for signalled QoS rules for the PDU Session with EPS IWK Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202823 CR Approval 23.502 CR3455 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the TFT exceeding 16 for 5GS-EPS interworking ZTE Rel-16 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
zhendong (ZTE) is fine to postpone
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2202824 CR Approval 23.502 CR3456 (Rel-17, 'A'): Clarification on the TFT exceeding 16 for 5GS-EPS interworking ZTE Rel-17 Postponed Judy (Ericsson) comments the discussion is in S2-2201937 thread.
zhendong (ZTE) is fine to postpone
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
4.1 S2-2201938 LS In Information LS from BBF: EAP-5G change; Answer to S2-2109043 BBF (LIAISE-508-02) Response drafted in S2-2201984. Final response in S2-2203017 Endorsed
4.1 S2-2201984 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on EAP-5G change Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201938. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203017 Revised
4.1 S2-2203017 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on EAP-5G change SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201984r00. Approved Approved
4.1 S2-2201939 LS In Information LS from BBF: LS on 5GC Support of DHCP signaling for RG; Response to S2-2009340 BBF (LIAISE-512-on DHCP to SA-03) Response drafted in S2-2202170. Final response in S2-2203029 Replied to
4.1 S2-2202170 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS on LS on 5GC Support of DHCP signaling for RG Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Response to S2-2201939. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203029 Judy (Ericsson) comments this reply is not a response to S2-2201940 but a response to S2-2009340
Judy (Ericsson) agrees with Tao.
Tao(VC) clarifies the response to 1939
Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
4.1 S2-2203029 LS OUT Approval LS on LS on 5GC Support of DHCP signaling for RG; SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202170r01. Approved Approved
4.2 - - - P-CRs/CRs related to use of inclusive language in 3GPP - - Docs:=0 -
8 - - - Pre-Rel-17 Maintenance (excluding all 5G topics) - - Docs:=0 -
8.1 - - - Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 2 (eNA_Ph2) - - Docs:=33 -
8.1 S2-2201993 CR Approval 23.288 CR0510 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on historical data and analytics storage via MFAF China Telecom, Huawei, Hisilicon Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203217 Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments and r01
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r00.
Jiahui (China Telecom) provides comments and agrees with r01
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203217 CR Approval 23.288 CR0510R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on historical data and analytics storage via MFAF China Telecom, Huawei, Hisilicon, Ericsson, Nokia Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201993r02. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2201994 CR Approval 23.288 CR0511 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment and corrections on analytics subscription procedures China Telecom, Huawei, Hisilicon Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203218 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments.
Jiahui (China Telecom): China Telecom provides r01.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02.
Kenichi (KDDI: KDDI provides comment for r02.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03.
Kenichi (KDDI): provides r04 for adding KDDI as co-signer.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203218 CR Approval 23.288 CR0511R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment and corrections on analytics subscription procedures China Telecom, Huawei, Hisilicon, Nokia, KDDI Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201994r04. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202045 CR Approval 23.288 CR0512 (Rel-17, 'F'): Inputs update for Nnwdaf Notify services for missing elements China Telecom Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203219 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01.
Zhuoyi (China Telecom) accepts r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203219 CR Approval 23.288 CR0512R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Inputs update for NWDAF Notify services for missing elements China Telecom Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202045r01. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202085 CR Approval 23.502 CR3426 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to Naf_EventExposure service Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203220 Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments.
Belen (Ericsson) provides r01.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r01.
Belen (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Wang Yuan (Huawei) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203220 CR Approval 23.502 CR3426R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to Naf_EventExposure service Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202085r02. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202086 CR Approval 23.288 CR0513 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to Dispersion Analytics Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203221 David (Spirent) updates Ericsson's Dispersion analytics addition of 'any UE'
Belen (Ericsson) provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203221 CR Approval 23.288 CR0513R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to Dispersion Analytics Ericsson, Spirent Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202086r02. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202118 CR Approval 23.288 CR0516 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the data and analytics storage in ADRF Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203226 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes there is similar proposal from Vivo in S2-2202498. Can these two contributions be merged?
Vivian(vivo) has provided a merged version using S2-2202498 as baseline, and asks for your opinion on whether agree it or not?
Wang Yuan (Huawei) is ok to merge this CR into S2-2202498.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.1 S2-2202119 DISCUSSION Agreement Discussion on the parameter 'list of analytics subsets that are requested'. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.1 S2-2202120 CR Approval 23.288 CR0517 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Analytics subset per different Analytics ID Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203222 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments, can only accept changes in clause 6.5.3.
Belen (Ericsson) provides comments, objects to the CR in the current form
Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and Belen (Ericsson), and provides r01.
Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept r01
David (Samsung) cannot accept current changes in cl. 6.5.3 for both r00 and r01
Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and David (Samsung), and provides r02.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is ok with r02.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request that cover page is updated according to latest development for the CR.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03.
Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Yannick (Nokia), and provides r03.
Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203222 CR Approval 23.288 CR0517R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Analytics subset per different Analytics ID Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202120r03. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202248 CR Approval 23.288 CR0518 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding UE ID to the Service Data from AF related to the Observed Service Experience InterDigital Inc. Rel-17 Approved Mike (InterDigital) replies to Zhuoyi
Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides comments
Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies to Mike.
Belen (Ericsson) provides comments
Mike (InterDigital) replies to Belen and Zhuoyi
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Agreed
8.1 S2-2202337 CR Approval 23.502 CR3441 (Rel-17, 'F'): Add NWDAF as a consumer NF of the Nnsacf_SliceEventExposure services Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203224 Wang Yuan (Huawei) proposes to merge this CR into S2-2202664 per offline discussion with Jinguo (ZTE).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.1 S2-2202117 CR Approval 23.288 CR0515 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment on the data collection from NSACF Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203223, merging S2-2202663 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments and request for clarification. Also notes that there is a similar proposal in S2-2202663 so a merge would be needed.
Wang Yuan (Huawei) replies to Yannick and provide r01 (also merge S-2202663 into this CR Per offline discussion with Jinguo (ZTE)).
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r02.
Wang Yuan (Huawei) is OK with r02.
Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to approve r02
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also supports approving r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203223 CR Approval 23.288 CR0515R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment on the data collection from NSACF Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202117r02, merging S2-2202663. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202664 CR Approval 23.502 CR3450 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding NWDAF as service consumer of NSACF ZTE Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203224, merging S2-2202337 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comment. Also notes that there is similar proposal in S2-2202337.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Wang Yuan (Huawei) ae fine with r01, thanks Jinguo.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203224 CR Approval 23.502 CR3450R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding NWDAF as service consumer of NSACF ZTE,Huawei Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202664r01, merging S2-2202337. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202663 CR Approval 23.288 CR0522 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding the NSACF as NWDAF data source ZTE Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203223 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Also notes that there is similar proposal in S2-2202117.
Jinguo(ZTE) propose to merge this paper into 2117.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.1 S2-2202420 CR Approval 23.288 CR0488R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of transferring ML model during analytics transfer Lenovo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of (Postponed) S2-2200808. r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203225 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02.
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01.
Dimitris (Lenovo) comments
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03 and asks Xiaoyan to not delete changes in previous versions without change marks, otherwise it is hard to get the new changes in each version.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification on r03.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to NTT DOCOMO.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Nokia.
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Yannick (Nokia).
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r05. Objects to r04.
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r06.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r06.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203225 CR Approval 23.288 CR0488R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of transferring ML model during analytics transfer Lenovo, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CATT Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202420r06. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202498 CR Approval 23.288 CR0519 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update inputs parameters for the Nadrf_DataManagement_StorageRequest service Vivo Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203226, merging S2-2202118 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia notes there is similar proposal from Huawei in S2-2202118. Can these two contributions be merged?
Vivian(vivo) replies to Yannick (Nokia) comment and gives a merged version r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203226 CR Approval 23.288 CR0519R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update inputs parameters for the Nadrf_DataManagement_StorageRequest service Vivo Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202498r01, merging S2-2202118. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202499 CR Approval 23.288 CR0520 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on data collection with Event Muting Mechanism Vivo Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203227 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia requests for clarification.
Vivian(vivo) replies to Yannick (Nokia)'s comments and provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203227 CR Approval 23.288 CR0520R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on data collection with Event Muting Mechanism Vivo Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202499r01. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202500 CR Approval 23.288 CR0521 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update ML model to AI/ML model for AI terminology alignment Vivo Rel-17 Noted Yannick (Nokia): Nokia do not see the need for this correction in Rel-17.
Xiaobo (vivo) provides comments.
Xiaobo (vivo) provides additional comments.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Vivo.
Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided comment.
David (Samsung) agrees with previous companies and would prefer to leave the terminology in R17 as it is now
Xiaobo (vivo) request Tricci(OPPO) or David(Samsung) for clarification about the meaning of AI/ML model in R18 SA2 SID FS_AIMLsys and in SA1 WID AI/ML model transfer in 5GS .
Xiaobo (vivo) provides response to Zhang(Ericsson)/Malla(NTT DoCoMo)/David(Samsung).
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Vivo. Suggest we do not discuss this in the context of Rel-17 maintenance, rather this seems more a discussion for e.g. AIMLsys work in Rel-18. We should note this Rel-17 CR.
David (Samsung) replies to Xiaobo.
Xiaobo (vivo) provides response and agree to note this CR and postpone the discussion to R18
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia thanks Vivo for agreeing to postpone this discussion.
David (Samsung) supports latest comments by Yannick (Nokia) and agrees with the way forward proposed by Xiaobo (vivo).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.1 S2-2202678 CR Approval 23.288 CR0462R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Redundant Transmission Experience related analytics China Mobile, Huawei Rel-17 Revision of (Postponed) S2-2200971. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203228, merging S2-2202726 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Antoine (Orange).
Antoine (Orange) asks a question and indicates that this CR clashes with 2-2202726.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm).
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01 with contents from S2-2202726.
Antoine (Orange) provides r02.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Huawei.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Yannick (Nokia).
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks Huawei for further clarification.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks Huawei for clarification.
Susan (Huawei) provides r03.
Susan (Huawei) provides r04.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r04.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.1 S2-2203228 CR Approval 23.288 CR0462R4 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify the Redundant Transmission Experience related analytics China Mobile, Huawei, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202678r04, merging S2-2202726. Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202726 CR Approval 23.288 CR0523 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to Redundant Transmission Experience analytics Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203228 Aihua(CMCC) provides comments.
Susan (Huawei) propose to merge this CR to S2-2202678.
Antoine (Orange) asks if one of the changes is really FASMO and indicates that this CR clashes with S2-2202678.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Orange and Huawei.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks Huawei for clarification.
Susan (Huawei) replies to Yannick.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request convenor to mark this CR as merged into S2-2202678.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.1 S2-2202727 CR Approval 23.502 CR3453 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to Redundant Transmission Experience for SMF event exposure Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.1 S2-2202925 CR Approval 23.288 CR0524 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for analytics subscription transfer for group of UEs and for any UE Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Noted Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments
Antoine (Orange) proposes to make the 2nd bullet more general.
Wang Yuan (Huawei) provides comments.
Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01, and answers to comments from Orange, NTT DOCOMO, Ericsson and Huawei.
Yingying(CATT) provides comments.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson.
Zhang (Ericsson) response to Nokia
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson and asks Ericsson to explain the issue they see.
Zhang (Ericsson) provides r02 and co-sign the paper
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia objects to r02.
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks Ericsson for clarification.
Zhang (Ericsson) object r01 and the original version
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia kindly asks Zhang (Ericsson) to not use text from the CR out of the context, that can only introduce confusion. We are discussing subscription or a group of UEs, while the quoted text is for subscription for any UE.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Ericsson. It would be good to focus the discussion on the technical contents of the CR at stake, not on digging old emails nor on quoting text out of context.
Zhang (Ericsson) kindly ask Nokia to have clear assumption or mind before discussion
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.2 - - - Enhanced support of Non-Public Networks (eNPN) - - Docs:=34 -
8.2 S2-2201918 LS In Action LS from CT WG1: LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 CT WG1 (C1-215137) Rel-16 Revision of Postponed S2-2200007 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202157. Final response in S2-2203419 Replied to
8.2 S2-2201926 LS In Action LS from SA WG1: LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 SA WG1 (S1-214234) Rel-16 Revision of Postponed S2-2200061 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202157. Final response in S2-2203419 Replied to
8.2 S2-2202157 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 Ericsson Rel-16 Response to S2-2201918 and S2-2201926. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203419 Josep (DT) comments, provides r01.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203419 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on the scope of applying Network Slicing feature in Rel-17 and Rel-16 SA WG2 Rel-16 Revision of S2-2202157r01. Approved Approved
8.2 S2-2201920 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: LS on conclusions of authentication methods for initial access for onboarding. SA WG3 (S3-214334) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200029 from S2#149E. Postponed Postponed
8.2 S2-2201955 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: REPLY LS on support of DCS variants in UE Onboarding Architecture SA WG3 (S3-220493) Rel-17 Noted Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.2 S2-2201961 LS In Action LS from SA WG4: LS on Media Production over 5G NPN SA WG4 (S4-220328) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202639. Final response in S2-2203417 Replied to
8.2 S2-2202639 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Media Production over 5G NPN Qualcomm Rel-17 Response to S2-2201961. Revised to S2-2203417. Revised
8.2 S2-2203417 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Media Production over 5G NPN SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202639. Approved Approved
8.2 S2-2202790 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: LS on conclusions of authentication methods for initial access for onboarding SA WG3 (S3-214541) Rel-17 Noted Peter (Ericsson) proposes to note the LS as it is outdated
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.2 S2-2201998 CR Approval 23.501 CR3581 (Rel-17, 'F'): Role of Credential Holder Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203420 Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01
Josep (DT) proposes to NOTE this CR. Not FASMO
Haris(Qualcomm) replies why the CR is FASMO
Josep (DT) replies.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides comments
Josep (DT) comments, provides r02.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Josep (DT) is fine with r03, objects to r00, r01.
Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03.
Haris(Qualcomm) is ok w r03
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203420 CR Approval 23.501 CR3581R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Role of Credential Holder Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201998r03. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202132 CR Approval 23.501 CR3588 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Remote Provisioning Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR for now
Saso (Intel) proposes to postpone the CR.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202158 CR Approval 23.501 CR3589 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network Slicing Support in SNPN Ericsson Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203421 Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply ok to align with eNS_Ph2 conclusions
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203421 CR Approval 23.501 CR3589R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network Slicing Support in SNPN Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202158r01. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202159 CR Approval 23.501 CR3590 (Rel-17, 'F'): SNPN onboarding correction Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Haris(Qualcomm) asks questions
Saso (Intel) supports the CR and comments.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Rainer (Nokia) concurs with Haris (Qualcomm).
Qianghua (Huawei) understands a singular DNN/S-NSSAI is used for onboarding in ON-SNPN
Saso (Intel) comments that only Option 1 makes sense, but the clarification can be done in a future meeting.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provide replies
Ashok (Samsung) comments
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes we discuss a possible update of 23.502 flow for the no DCS case at the next meeting
Saso (Intel) replies to Haris.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to postpone
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with the CR
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202160 CR Approval 23.503 CR0710 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to URSP provisioning when UE accesses an SNPN using CH credentials Ericsson Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203425 Antoine (Orange) assumes this CR is merged into S2-2202877.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.2 S2-2202161 CR Approval 23.503 CR0711 (Rel-17, 'F'): Identification of a list of PSIs provided by an SNPN Ericsson Rel-17 Noted Josep (DT) comments, provides r01.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments that the updates are not necessary and proposes to note.
Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r01, replies to Huawei.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) objects this CR (r00-r01) because of the changes are not necessary and bring backward compatibility issues
Belen (Ericsson) asks Huawei to explain which the backward compatibility issue is.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies that UE->5GC direction is already supported in CT1 spec, and backward compatibility issue is that: Rel-16 UEs/SNPNs don't support this CR enhancement while Rel-17 UEs does for the same scenario. Without enhancements in this CR, the current mechanism works well.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.2 S2-2202514 CR Approval 23.501 CR3609 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF UP remote provisioning capability Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203422 Pengfei (vivo) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Pengfei (vivo)
Haris(Qualcomm) asks questions
Rainer (Nokia) comments.
Rainer (Nokia) provides r01 removing the second change.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203422 CR Approval 23.501 CR3609R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF UP remote provisioning capability Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202514r02. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202515 CR Approval 23.502 CR3445 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF UP remote provisioning capability Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203423 Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203423 CR Approval 23.502 CR3445R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): SMF UP remote provisioning capability Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202515r01. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202516 CR Approval 23.501 CR3610 (Rel-17, 'F'): Provisioning of PVS address to UE for SNPN onboarding Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the CR as it is adding new functionality.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides to use 2827 as basis
zhendong (ZTE) same view with ericsson and nokia
Qianghua (Huawei) still suggests to use 2516 as basis
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees to mark it merged with 2827, since 2827 doesn't address any technical issues for this scenario. Propose to postpone.
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to this CR
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202517 CR Approval 23.502 CR3446 (Rel-17, 'F'): Provisioning of PVS address to UE for SNPN onboarding Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Rainer (Nokia) proposes to note the CR as it is adding new functionality.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to use 2828 as basis
zhendong (ZTE) same view with ericsson and nokia
Qianghua (Huawei) still suggests to use 2517 as basis
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees to mark it merged with 2828, since 2828 doesn't address any technical issues for this scenario. Propose to postpone.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202577 CR Approval 23.503 CR0715 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify URSP provisioning when UE accesses an SNPN using CH credentials Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203425 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments
Antoine (Orange) points out that this CR clashes with S2-2202160.
Rainer (Nokia) proposes to mark 2577 as merged into 2877.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.2 S2-2202579 CR Approval 23.501 CR3613 (Rel-17, 'F'): DCS supporting AUSF/UDM and AAA server functionality Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202684 CR Approval 23.503 CR0716 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications for eNPN related description Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203424 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments
Belen (Ericsson) provides comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01
Antoine (Orange) provides r02, removing 'accessing'.
Belen (Ericsson) provides r03, disagrees with r02,r01 and initial version
Antoine (Orange) objects to r03 because we have never studied NSSAI mapping for SNPN.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies
Qianghua (Huawei) provides a way forward
Qianghua (Huawei) replies and provides r04
Belen (Ericsson) asks Orange to clarify his comment.
Antoine (Orange) clarifies.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203424 CR Approval 23.503 CR0716R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications for eNPN related description Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202684r04. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202826 CR Approval 23.501 CR3622 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the PVS address DCS. ZTE Rel-17 Postponed Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
zhendong (ZTE) comments
Saso (Intel) replies to Zhendong.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments, and do not see the need to restrict the specs
Saso (Intel) objects to r00.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r01
Rainer (Nokia) provides r02.
Saso (Intel) is OK with r02.
Qianghua (Huawei) objects this CR
Saso (Intel) points to Qianghua that the concern 'how to ensure that the DCS knows the SO-SNPN' is not valid. The DCS may, but does not have to, know the SO-SNPN identity.
Qianghua (Huawei) asks how to make this 'if' happens at DCS?
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and suggests to go with r02
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r03
zhendong (ZTE) similar view with saso (intel)
zhendong (ZTE) provides r03 hyperlink
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to postpone the CR, objects this CR (r00-r03) for NOTEs
Rainer (Nokia) is ok to note the CR.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok to note the CR
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202827 CR Approval 23.501 CR3623 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the FQDN(s) and IP address(es) of PVS for remote provisionning ZTE Rel-17 This was postponed Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and suggests to use 2516/2517 for basis
Rainer (Nokia) replies and prefers 2827 and 2828.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to use 2827/2828 as basis and provides r01
Haris(Qualcomm) also prefer 2827/2828 technical proposal vs. what is included in 2516/2517
zhendong (ZTE) same view with Qualcomm and Nokia, prefer with 2827/2828 proposal
Jihoon (ETRI) also prefers 2827/2828 and provides r02.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments that the NOTE doesn't address the technical concerns and is not acceptable as a way forward
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r03
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to postpone the CR, objects this CR (r00-r03) for NOTEs
Rainer (Nokia) proposes to agree the CR.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to agree the CR in r03
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to agree r03 but if not possible proposes to do SoH in CC#2/3
zhendong (ZTE) agree with haris, proposes to agree r03 but if not possible proposes to do SoH
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with SoH on CR, but will still object the CR with the reasons expressed before.
zhendong (ZTE) ask to take this CR to CC#3
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202828 CR Approval 23.502 CR3457 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the FQDN(s) and IP address(es) of PVS for remote provisionning ZTE Rel-17 Postponed Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and suggests to use 2516/2517 for basis
Rainer (Nokia) prefers 2827 and 2828.
zhendong (ZTE) also prefer 2827 amd 2828
Qianghua (Huawei) comments that the 2827 NOTE doesn't address the technical concerns and is not acceptable as a way forward
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to postpone the CR, objects this CR (r00-r01) for NOTEs
Rainer (Nokia) proposes to agree the CR.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to agree r01
Haris(Qualcomm) supports approving the CR
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to do SoH in CC#2/3
zhendong (ZTE) agree to do SoH in CC#2/3
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with SoH on CC, but will still object the CR with the reasons expressed before.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies and asks to check email history for 2827.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies: Rather than agree a CR that only captures partial clarification, I prefer not rush and come back with a full picture
zhendong (ZTE) ask to take this CR to CC#3
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.2 S2-2202877 CR Approval 23.503 CR0719 (Rel-17, 'F'): ENPN: Correction to URSP provisioning when UE accesses an SNPN using CH credentials MediaTek Inc. Rel-17 r13 agreed. Revised to S2-2203425, merging S2-2202160 and S2-2202577 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments
Josep (DT) asks question for clarification, comments.
Pengfei (vivo) provides a revision r01.
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides r02 and suggests to use this CR as baseline to merge S2-2202160, S2-2202577 and S2-2202684
Belen (Ericsson) provides r03.
Qianghua (Huawei) revisions of 2877 do not contain changes of 2684 and 2684 can be handled separately
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) responds to Qianghua (Huawei)
Belen (Ericsson) objects to r04
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides r04
Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) objects to r05 and provides r06
Antoine (Orange) provides r07.
Belen (Ericsson) provides r07.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments that r07 has already been provided by Antoine
Belen (Ericsson) provides r08
Antoine (Orange) comments on r08.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to Orange
Antoine (Orange) replies to Ericsson.
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) responds to Belen (Ericsson)
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) responds to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r09
Qianghua (Huawei) objects to r00-r08, except the r05
Antoine (Orange) replies to Belen: Yes.
Belen (Ericsson) replies to MediaTek
Belen (Ericsson) provides r10.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) comments.
Guillaume (MediaTek inc.) responds to Belen.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r12 (pls. ignore r11 uploaded with a mistake)
Belen (Ericsson) replies to MediaTek, Ericsson is okay with r09.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r13
Chia-Lin (MediaTek) suggest to go either r09/r13 (without new sub-clauses) or r12 and suggest to discuss in CC#2 to decide to go with which revision since they are different proposals.
Qianghua (Huawei) asks what is the misleading with title 'URSP rules for an SNPN-enabled UE'
Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question
Belen (Ericsson) prefers r13 or r09.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) responds to Qianghua (Huawei)
Qianghua (Huawei) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.)
Qianghua (Huawei) replies and asks again the invalidating, thanks
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.2 S2-2203425 CR Approval 23.503 CR0719R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): ENPN: Correction to URSP provisioning when UE accesses an SNPN using CH credentials MediaTek Inc., Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202877r13, merging S2-2202160 and S2-2202577. Approved Agreed
8.2 S2-2202938 CR Approval 23.502 CR3463 (Rel-17, 'F'): DN-AAA server selection during UE onboarding Intel Rel-17 Postponed Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and question whether we can postpone the CR
Saso (Intel) is OK to postpone the CR.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.3 - - - Enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5GC (eEDGE_5GC) - - Docs:=30 -
8.3 S2-2201930 LS In Information LS from CT WG1: LS on ECS provider identification in ECS address provisioning CT WG1 (C1-220854) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200196 from S2#149E. Postponed Postponed
8.3 S2-2201966 LS In Information LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on Prioritized Vehicle to Cloud Technical Solutions (Automotive Edge Computing Consortium (AECC)) SA WG6 (S6-220265) Rel-17 Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
Magnus O (Ericsson) Also propose to note this LS
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2201967 LS In Information Reply LS on follow-up on EAS definition SA WG6 (S6-220351) Rel-18 Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2201969 LS In Information Reply LS on further Operator Platform Group questions following SDO Workshop SA WG6 (S6-220432) Rel-17 Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202779 LS In Action LS on AF specific UE ID retrieval CT WG3 (C3-221735) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202964. Final response in S2-2203426 Replied to
8.3 S2-2202964 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on AF specific UE ID retrieval Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2202779. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203426 Hui (Huawei) provides r01.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) is OK with r02
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203426 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on AF specific UE ID retrieval SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202964r02. Approved Approved
8.3 S2-2202796 LS In Information LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Further Operator Platform Group questions following SDO Workshop SA WG3 (S3-220571) Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202797 LS In Information LS from TSG SA: Reply LS to GSMA OPG on Further Operator Platform Group questions following SDO Workshop TSG SA (SP-220346) Noted Hui (Huawei) proposes to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202063 CR Approval 23.502 CR3423 (Rel-17, 'F'): Outcome of UE Policies delivery procedure Samsung Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203427 Hui (Huawei) asks for clarification.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Magnus (Ericsson) provides comments
Jicheol (Samsung) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203427 CR Approval 23.502 CR3423R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Outcome of UE Policies delivery procedure Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202063r01. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202064 CR Approval 23.503 CR0708 (Rel-17, 'F'): Outcome of UE Policies delivery procedure Samsung Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203428 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides comments
Jicheol (Samsung) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203428 CR Approval 23.503 CR0708R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Outcome of UE Policies delivery procedure Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202064r01. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202089 CR Approval 23.501 CR3587 (Rel-17, 'F'): Discovery and selection Ericsson Rel-17 Postponed Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Hui (Huawei) comments
Magnus H (Ericsson) withdraws the CR to be postponed to next meeting
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.3 S2-2202090 CR Approval 23.502 CR3427 (Rel-17, 'F'): AF specific UE ID retrieval procedure correction Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202091 CR Approval 23.548 CR0052 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to EAS IP Address in EDI Ericsson Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203429 Hui (Huawei) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203429 CR Approval 23.548 CR0052R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction related to EAS IP Address in EDI Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202091r01. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202273 CR Approval 23.548 CR0053 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections on enabling EAS IP Replacement procedure by AF China Unicom Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202374 CR Approval 23.548 CR0054 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of EAS Deployment Information Management procedures and services Tencent, Tencent Cloud Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203430 Magnus (Ericsson) provides r01
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification.
Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r02.
Magnus H (Ericsson) comments
Xinpeng(Huawei) provides r03.
Zhuoyun (Tencent) provides r04.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203430 CR Approval 23.548 CR0054R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of EAS Deployment Information Management procedures and services Tencent, Tencent Cloud, Ericsson, Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202374r04. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202397 CR Approval 23.548 CR0055 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to SA WG6 on ECS Configuration Information Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone this CR.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hui (Huawei) agrees to postpone.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.3 S2-2202398 CR Approval 23.502 CR3443 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment to SA WG6 on ECS Configuration Information Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Hui (Huawei) replies to Shubhranshu.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds
Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone this CR.
Hui (Huawei) asks question.
Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Hui.
Hui (Huawei) replies to Dario.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hui (Huawei) agrees to postpone.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.3 S2-2202741 CR Approval 23.548 CR0056 (Rel-17, 'F'): Parameter supplement of EDI China Mobile Rel-17 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203602. Hui (Huawei) provides r01.
Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r02
Hui (Huawei) asks for clarification on r02
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Hui
Dario (Qualcomm) provides r03
Dario (Qualcomm) provides r06 based on r05 + a correction.
Magnus H (Ericsson) disagrees with r04 and provides r05 based on r03
Xinpeng(Huawei) replies to Magnus H (Ericsson).
Xinpeng(Huawei) ask Magnus H (Ericsson) question.
Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Xinpeng
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provide r07.
Magnus H (Ericsson) expresses concerns of r07
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Magnus.
Magnus H (Ericsson) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to go with r06 because does not seem agreeable.
Dan (China Mobile) also suggest to go with r06
Dario (Qualcomm) proposes to go with r06 because r07 does not seem agreeable.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Dario and Dan.
Hui (Huawei) asks question to Magnus.
Dan(China Mobile) provide r08 based on r07 with removing the NOTE
Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to all versions of this document except r00 and r06
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Dan and is ok with r07 with removing the NOTE, and suggests further time for discussion and discusses this CR in CC#3.
Dan (China Mobile) ask further and request to discuss this in CC#2 or CC#3
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203602 CR Approval 23.548 CR0056R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Parameter supplement of EDI China Mobile, Huawei, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202741r06. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202845 CR Approval 23.502 CR3460 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Edge Relocation Triggered by AF Lenovo, Motorola Mobility Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203431 Magnus (Ericsson) provides r01
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.3 S2-2203431 CR Approval 23.502 CR3460R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification for Edge Relocation Triggered by AF Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202845r01. Approved Agreed
8.3 S2-2202846 CR Approval 23.548 CR0057 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on EAS Deployment Information Lenovo, Motorola Mobility Rel-17 Noted Magnus H (Ericsson) comments
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and asks for clarification.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r01
Magnus (Ericsson) provides r02
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Shubhranshu .
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Magnus.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Magnus H (Ericsson) can only accept r02 and objects to r00 and r01
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Shubhranshu.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments and does not agree to r02
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK to note this paper.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202847 CR Approval 23.502 CR3461 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on EAS Deployment Information Lenovo, Motorola Mobility Rel-17 Noted Magnus H (Ericsson) comments
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies.
Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) proposes to withdraw 2847 based on the discussion on 2846.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to this document
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202851 CR Approval 23.548 CR0058 (Rel-18, 'F'): Update of EASDF functional description and clarication on scope of EAS in EAS discovey and selection procedure IIT Delhi Rel-18 Noted Hui (Huawei) provides comment.
Hyesung (Samsung) comments.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Ashish (IIT Delhi) provides r02
Magnus (Ericsson) provides comments
Dario (Qualcomm) comments
Ashish (IIT Delhi) accepts Samsung and Huawei comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) clarifies that this paper should be note.
Hyesung (Samsung) also thinks that the status of this CR should be 'noted'.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.3 S2-2202963 CR Approval 23.502 CR3464 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to the Service Specific Authorization procedure Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.4 - - - Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 2 (eNS_Ph2) - - Docs:=17 -
8.4 S2-2202800 LS In Information LS from GSMA: LS on enforcement of maximum number of UEs and maximum number of PDU sessions in a network slice GSMA (ENSWI09_Doc006) Postponed Postponed
8.4 S2-2202017 CR Approval 23.501 CR3582 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of NSACF from HPLMN in LBO Model Ericsson Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203032 alessio(nokia) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.4 S2-2203032 CR Approval 23.501 CR3582R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of NSACF from HPLMN in LBO Model Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202017r01. Approved Agreed
8.4 S2-2202049 CR Approval 23.501 CR3584 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on determination of Registration Area Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203033 Haiyang (Huawei) responds to Stefano (Qualcomm)
Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR because it is not FASMO, not cat. F, and technically incorrect.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01
Dongeun (Samsung) cannot agree with r00 and can live with r01
Alessio(Nokia) the issue is that the feature requesting a specific behaviour precisely defines what to do so there is no FASMO unless one ignores doing what the specific feature requires. maintains the position on this CR
Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with r01.
Alessio(nokia) while r01 is correct in referencing a certain lause, we do not believe that it is needed as the clause that imposes a certain behaviour in connection to the support of TARGET NSSAI already describes that! we have to only approve FASMO CRs at this meeting (also the meeting agenda says that). so we also agree with those that think this CR is not meeting FASMO and shall not be approved.
Genadi (Lenovo) supports r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.4 S2-2203033 CR Approval 23.501 CR3584R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on determination of Registration Area Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202049r01. Approved Agreed
8.4 S2-2202075 CR Approval 23.502 CR3425 (Rel-17, 'F'): Providing differential NSAC BOT Samsung Rel-17 Noted Fenqin (Huawei) provide comment and consider this is an implementation issue.
Ashok (Samsung) comments
Fenqin (Huawei) provide comment.
Ashok (Samsung) responds to Fenqin (Huawei)
Jinguo(ZTE) agree with Fenqin and suggest to note this paper, not FASMO
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.4 S2-2202280 CR Approval 23.502 CR3438 (Rel-17, 'F'): NSSRG during PDN connections Samsung, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Noted Jinguo(ZTE) comments
Ashok (Samsung) replies to Jinguo (ZTE)
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments that it is not a FASMO issue
Patrice (Huawei) supports Peter (Ericsson) and proposes to note the CR.
Jinguo (ZTE) provides comments that it is not a FASMO issue
Ashok (Samsung) responds to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) and Patrice (Huawei)
Ashok (Samsung) responds to Jinguo (ZTE) and explains how it is FASMO
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and objects to the CR as it is not FASMO and adding new functionality
Alessio(nokia) comments we supported this CR as it is common and frequent to establish PDU sessions in EPS so this CR ensures retaining the slice compatibility for PDU sessions that are established while in EPS.
Ashok (Samsung) responds to Peter Hedman (Ericsson): Peter, your comments seems to suggest to restrict the service to user/not giving the feature and hence eliminating problem statement to justify solution not needed
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.4 S2-2202660 CR Approval 23.502 CR3405R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NSACF exposure ZTE, Rel-17 Revision of (Postponed) S2-2201043. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203034 Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment and r01.
Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with r03.
alessio(Nokia) is ok with r03.
Srisakul (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments and r03.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.4 S2-2203034 CR Approval 23.502 CR3405R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on NSACF exposure ZTE, Huawei Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202660r03. Approved Agreed
8.4 S2-2202088 CR Approval 23.503 CR0709 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to the UE-Slice-MBR Ericsson Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203035 Jinguo(ZTE) comments
DongEun(Samsung) propose to note the CR
Belen (Ericsson) replies to ZTE and Samsung
Jinguo(ZTE) replies to Belen (Ericsson)
Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this paper and use option 2 of 2661
Jinguo(ZTE) proposes r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to approve r01
Dongeun (Samsung) object to r01
Alessio(nokia) justifies why cannot accept r01 either
Belen (Ericsson) asks if r01 can be agreed removing the NOTE
Jinguo(ZTE) is ok to remove the NOTE and agree r01
TAO(VC) check whether the proposed, remove the NOTE and agree r01, agreeable to everyone
Haiyang (Huawei) is ok to remove the NOTE and agree r01
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.4 S2-2203035 CR Approval 23.503 CR0709R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to the UE-Slice-MBR Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202088r01. Approved Agreed
8.4 S2-2202661 CR Approval 23.501 CR3616 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on UE-Slice-MBR ZTE Rel-17 Postponed DongEun(Samsung) provides r01
Belen (Ericsson) objects to this CR both initial version and r01
Jinguo(ZTE) asks clarification to Belen (Ericsson).
Alessio(Nokia) proposes r02 that actually makes the 1:1 constraint for slices associated with a UE_slice_MBR normative.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to postpone this paper as offline comment.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.4 S2-2202756 CR Approval 23.501 CR3620 (Rel-17, 'F'): UE-Slice-MBR exemption for emergency and priority services Samsung Rel-17 Noted DongEun (Samsung) provides r01 to correct cover page
Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification
Belen (Ericsson) objects to this CR.
Dongeun (Samsung) replies to Haiyang (Huawei)
Dongeun (Samsung) clarifies to Belen (Ericsson)
Jinguo(ZTE) agree with Belen (Ericsson) and Haiyang(Huawie) and propose to note this CR
Dongeun (Samsung) cannot agree to Zinguo (ZTE) and clarifies
Alessio(Nokia) also objects to this CR as it is not FASMO
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dongeun (Samsung) is OK to note the CR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.4 S2-2202074 CR Approval 23.502 CR3424 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on storage of rejected S-NSSAI and BOT due to NSAC in UE Samsung Rel-17 Noted Stefano (Qualcomm) has questions for clarification.
Ashok (Samsung) provides clarification to Stefano (Qualcomm)
Jinguo(ZTE) believes this details are stage 3 and should be noted.
alessio(Nokia) suggest we note this paper as the FASMO issue seems to be missing.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.4 S2-2202858 CR Approval 23.501 CR3550R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC about the Access Type Xiaomi Rel-17 Revision of S2-2200945. Noted Alessio(Nokia) supports Jinguo that there is no requirement to support quota per AT so this cannot be FASMO.
Jinguo(ZTE) comments
Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Jinguo and Alessio, 2858 can be noted.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.4 S2-2202859 CR Approval 23.502 CR3391R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC about the Access Type Xiaomi Rel-17 Revision of (Noted) S2-2200946. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203036 Alessio(Nokia) supports Jinguo that there is no requirement to support quota per AT so this cannot be FASMO. proposed to not this and the other paper in 2858
Jinguo(ZTE) comments
Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Jinguo and Alessio, with r01 provided.
Fenqin(Huawei) comments and provides r02
Fenqin(Huawei) suggest to go with r02
Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Fenqin, r02 is fine, with r03 provided for clarification,
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinhua(Xiaomi) replies to Fenqin, r02 is OK with me,
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.4 S2-2203036 CR Approval 23.502 CR3391R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of NSAC about the Access Type Xiaomi Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202859r02. Approved Agreed
8.5 - - - Enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (IIoT) - - Docs:=40 -
8.5 S2-2201923 LS In Action LS from ITU-T SG15: LS/r on Time Synchronization support in 3GPP specification ITU-T SG15 (SG15-LS348) Revision of Postponed S2-2200041 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202196. Final response in S2-2203229 Shabnam (Ericsson) can be marked Noted since response has been approved. Replied to
8.5 S2-2202196 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply Time Synchronization support in 3GPP Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201923. Revised to S2-2203229. Revised
8.5 S2-2203229 LS OUT Approval Reply Time Synchronization support in 3GPP SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202196. Approved Approved
8.5 S2-2202192 CR Approval 23.501 CR3595 (Rel-17, 'F'): Cleaning up the description of time distribution methods and parameters Ericsson Rel-17 This was postponed Scott (Inspur) comments on this paper and propose to merge it to 2279.
Devaki (Nokia) provides r01.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) supports r01, asks to add Samsung as co-signer, and objects to merging it to 2279.
Scott (Inspur) propose the way forward.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r02
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
György (Ericsson) responds
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04
==== Revisions Deadline ====
György (Ericsson) comments and proposes to go with r03
Qianghua (Huawei) objects r00-r03, and suggests a way forward
zhendong (ZTE) provides clarification on the dependency
Devaki (Nokia) comments.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) supports r03, and asks to add Samsung as co-signer before final upload.
Scott(Inspur) objects 00-03.
Shabnam (Ericsson) attaches the email with Ericsson responses and asks Inspur to not block progress. We understand that INSPUR joined these discussions recently. We request you reconsider your objection, as external readers found it difficult to understand the two methods so we are trying to avoid mistakes by misunderstanding.
Scott(Inspur) replies to withdraw objection.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.5 S2-2202193 CR Approval 23.502 CR3433 (Rel-17, 'F'): Cleaning up the time synchronization procedures Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203230 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, removing overlaps with tdoc 2296 and Nokia co-signs.
Sang-Jun(Samsung) supports r01, and asks to add Samsung as co-signer.
Shabnam (Ericsson) r02, adding no technical changes, Samsung and fixing the diagrams to be editable.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203230 CR Approval 23.502 CR3433R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Cleaning up the time synchronization procedures Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202193r02. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202194 CR Approval 23.501 CR3485R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting the 5G AS time distribution procedure Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of (Noted) S2-2200299. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203231 Devaki (Nokia) supports the CR, incorporates our updates from last meeting thus wish to cosign as well.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 removing the new interface between TSCTSF-UDM
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02 and indicates to Huawei that it is from SBI perspective not new interface, but for point to point based there is no way to describe without new interface. This is the consequence of the agreement that was not completed due to many parallel CRs ongoing.
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203231 CR Approval 23.501 CR3485R2 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting the 5G AS time distribution procedure Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202194r02. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202195 CR Approval 23.502 CR3434 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting the 5G AS time distribution procedure Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203232 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, removing overlaps with tdoc 2296 and Nokia co-signs.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Shabnam (Ericsson) r02 with editable figure, thanks for catching it.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203232 CR Approval 23.502 CR3434R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting the 5G AS time distribution procedure Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202195r02. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202268 CR Approval 23.501 CR3602 (Rel-17, 'F'): Changing the TSCTSF Services Inspur Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203234 Devaki (Nokia) replies.
Scott(Inspur) agree to merge with 2295 in principle with extra comments.
Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this CR as merged with 2295, as that is a super set of the changes proposed in this CR.
Scott (Inspur) replies.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.5 S2-2202279 CR Approval 23.501 CR3603 (Rel-17, 'F'): Revisions on Exposure of Time Synchronization Inspur Rel-17 This was postponed. Devaki (Nokia) responds to INSPUR.
Scott (Inspur) comments on Devaki's comments.
Devaki (Nokia) comments that the changes in this CR conflicts with 2192 (which in our view is better basis to start), conflict needs to be resolved, only one CR can be used as the basis.
Sang-Jun (samsung) has similar views as Devaki (Nokia).
György (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia and proposes to consider this merged into 2192
zhendong (ZTE) provides comment
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Scott(Inspur) replies to zhendong (ZTE)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Scott(Inspur) provides the response
Devaki (Nokia) replies
Scott(Inspur) replies to Devaki
Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that changes in the first clause we do not see needed, it is just different ways of presenting the content and not FASMO. For change of clause title in your second change, I can understand your proposal is better formulated but needs consensus to change.
Also, I would like to point out that we discussed last time and agreed we should not add parameters on the title
as that restricts future use of the clause. So, we need to avoid that.
Scott(Inspur) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson).
Shabnam (Ericsson) responds in line to clarify and hope we can decouple approval of 2192 from this.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Devaki (Nokia) comments that this document should be marked as withdrawn or noted as discussed with Scott offline. Scott does not prefer this to be marked as merged with 2192.
Postponed
8.5 S2-2202293 CR Approval 23.501 CR3605 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to Survival Time description Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203233 Sang-Jun (Samsung) agrees on the changes of this CR, and asks to add Samsung as co-signer.
Mirko (Huawei) comments and asks whether the same reference can be used in both tables.
Devaki (Nokia) provides r01, with Samsung as cosigner, fixing SA1 spec reference to align the tables.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203233 CR Approval 23.501 CR3605R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to Survival Time description Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202293r01. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202294 CR Approval 23.502 CR3439 (Rel-17, 'F'): Terminology Alignment for AF session with required QoS procedures Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202295 CR Approval 23.501 CR3606 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to time synchronization description Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203234, merging S2-2202268, S2-2202518 and S2-2202590 Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 resolving the comments by INSPUR/Scott Jiang.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Scott(Inspur) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203234 CR Approval 23.501 CR3606R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to time synchronization description Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, INSPUR Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202295r02, merging S2-2202268, S2-2202518 and S2-2202590. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202296 CR Approval 23.502 CR3440 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to time synchronization procedures Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203235 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, removing overlaps with tdoc 2193 and 2195 and Ericsson co-signs.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203235 CR Approval 23.502 CR3440R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to time synchronization procedures Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202296r01. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202518 CR Approval 23.501 CR3611 (Rel-17, 'F'): Split TimeSynchronization service Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203234 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this with 2295 as it covers the changes proposed here, third change in this CR needs correction which is already corrected in 2295.
Qianghua (Huawei) OK to merge with 2295 if my comments on 2295 are addressed in the revision.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.5 S2-2202519 CR Approval 23.502 CR3447 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections for 5GS Bridge Information reporting and subscription Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203236 Devaki (Nokia) provides r01.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments on r03
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r04.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203236 CR Approval 23.502 CR3447R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections for 5GS Bridge Information reporting and subscription Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202519r06. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202520 CR Approval 23.503 CR0714 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections for 5GS Bridge Information reporting and subscription Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202590 CR Approval 23.501 CR3614 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501 Term Changes for IIoT Samsung Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203234 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge with 2295 as it covers the Master -> Leader changes proposed in this CR.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) agrees to merge 2590 with 2295.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.5 S2-2202591 CR Approval 23.502 CR3448 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Term Changes for IIoT Samsung Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203237 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to remove the note from this CR for 23.502 (to avoid duplication), instead simply refer to the Note in TS 23.501.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01, which applies Devaki (Nokia)'s proposal.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203237 CR Approval 23.502 CR3448R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.502 Term Changes for IIoT Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202591r02. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202685 CR Approval 23.503 CR0717 (Rel-17, 'F'): PCF response when rejecting an AF session with required QoS Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Approved Devaki (Nokia) comments.
Gyorgy (Ericsson) comments.
Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments.
György (Ericsson) provides r01
zhendong (ZTE) comments
György (Ericsson) responds.
Mirko (Huawei) replies to the comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Mirko (Huawei) proposes to agree on the original version of the CR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Agreed
8.5 S2-2202686 CR Approval 23.503 CR0718 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of description for support of Time Sensitive Communication and Time Synchronization Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203238 Devaki (Nokia) provides r01 (third change proposing to remove existing functionality is not acceptable for us).
zhendong (ZTE) provides comments
Mirko (Huawei) responds to comments.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides additional comments and questions if we should really add some of the details.
Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Mirko (Huawei) proposes to agree on the original version of the CR.
Devaki (Nokia) objects to the original version of the CR, can only accept r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203238 CR Approval 23.503 CR0718R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of description for support of Time Sensitive Communication and Time Synchronization Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202686r01. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202719 CR Approval 23.501 CR3618 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction the residence time for the 5G as end-to-end Transparent Clock CATT Rel-17 Noted Devaki (Nokia) comments that this CR is not a FASMO (the format in which the timer is stored is anyhow implementation specific, also we believe current text is correct).
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provids comments, and agrees with with Devaki (Nokia).
Chunshan (CATT) provides clarification.
Shabnam (Ericsson) corrects CATT misunderstanding on Ericsson comment, we don't believe it is correct to change it as you do and that other parts already also reflect same association so by just changing here does not change the function.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.5 S2-2202720 CR Approval 23.501 CR3619 (Rel-17, 'F'): NW-TT Identification and Clock Drift Report CATT Rel-17 Noted Chunshan (CATT) provides more clarification.
Jari (NT DOCOMO) responds
Chunshan (CATT) responds
Chunshan (CATT) provides clarifications
Jari (NT DOCOMO) objects
Jari (NT DOCOMO) objects, not FASMO
Chunshan (CATT) provides clarification.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.5 S2-2202721 CR Approval 23.502 CR3452 (Rel-17, 'F'): NW-TT Identification and Clock Drift Report CATT Rel-17 Noted Chunshan (CATT) provides clarifications
Jari (NT DOCOMO) objects
Jari (NT DOCOMO) objects, not FASMO
Chunshan (CATT) provides clarification.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.5 S2-2202829 CR Approval 23.501 CR3624 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on how the TSFTSF assign the NW-TT port to PPT instance ZTE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203239 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
==== Revisions Deadline ====
zhendong (ZTE) proposes to approve r00
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203239 CR Approval 23.501 CR3624R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on how the TSFTSF assign the NW-TT port to PPT instance ZTE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202829r00. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202830 CR Approval 23.502 CR3458 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the PCF service operation consumer ZTE Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203240 Devaki (Nokia) responds to ZTE.
zhendong (ZTE) respond the CR includes other change which is not cover by 2195
Devaki (Nokia) comments that this CR is not a FASMO by itself (adding an example consumer is not normative nor FASMO) but to retain the change, propose to merge with 2195.
Mirko (Huawei) comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.5 S2-2203240 CR Approval 23.502 CR3458R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on the PCF service operation consumer ZTE Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202830r01. Approved Agreed
8.5 S2-2202831 CR Approval 23.501 CR3625 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on 5G access stratum distribution in mobility ZTE Rel-17 Postponed zhendong (ZTE) provides r01.
Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note this CR as the proposed description is not correct nor useful (we are ok with the intention captured in the companion 23.502 CR - 2832).
Devaki (Nokia) comments that this CR is not a FASMO by itself (adding an example consumer is not normative nor FASMO) but to retain the change, propose to merge with 2195.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Shabnam (Ericsson) also does not see any value to add a new subclause to refer to another spec/clause. We can add such text in one of the main clauses where related functions are described or 23.502 covers it.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) this CR should be marked postponed based on offline discussion (needs LS to RAN). But OK to mark this endorsed or approved in this meeting.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers to postpone
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.5 S2-2202832 CR Approval 23.502 CR3459 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on 5G access stratum distribution in mobility ZTE Rel-17 Postponed Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Shabnam (Ericsson) similar view as Jari, but also I would like to know what RAN has decided on this if any. It should be aligned with RAN for Xn case.
Qianghua (Huawei) comments further
Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Zhendong for RAN3 information, comments..
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) this CR should be marked postponed based on offline discussion (needs LS to RAN). But OK to mark this endorsed or approved in this meeting.
Shabnam (Ericsson) prefer to postpone and discuss the new LS to RAN3 and discuss in CT#2 potentially to discuss the CR to conclude.
Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers to postpone
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.5 S2-2203621 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS On handover issue for 5G access stratum time distribution ZTE Created at CC#2: Related to postponed CRs S2-2202831 and S2-2202832. Revised to S2-2203596. Revised
8.5 S2-2203596 LS OUT Approval LS on handover issue for 5G access stratum time distribution SA WG2 - Revision of S2-2203621. This Approved Approved
8.6 - - - Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture Phase 2 (ATSSS_Ph2) - - Docs:=0 -
8.7 - - - Support of Aerial Systems Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (ID_UAS) - - Docs:=17 -
8.7 S2-2201927 LS In Action Reply LS on 3GPP SA1 clarifications on problematic UAV SA WG1 (S1-214238) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200062 from S2#149E. Noted Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note, no actions required.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.7 S2-2201934 LS In Action LS from CT WG4: LS on SMF initiated reauthorization CT WG4 (C4-221445) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2201270 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202361, S2-2202446. Final response in S2-2203037 Replied to
8.7 S2-2202361 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS Reply on SMF initiated reauthorization QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy Rel-17 Response to S2-2201934. Merged into S2-2203037 Pallab (Nokia) agrees with the proposal to merge.
Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to consider merged into S2-222446
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.7 S2-2202446 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS OUT SMF initiated reauthorization; Response to S2-2201934 Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Response to S2-2201934. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203037, merging S2-2202361 Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to take this LS as the way forward.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.7 S2-2203037 LS OUT Approval LS SMF initiated reauthorization; Response to S2-2201934 SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202446r00, merging S2-2202361. Approved Approved
8.7 S2-2202778 LS In Action LS from CT WG3: LS on NEF-initiated reauthorization CT WG3 (C3-221444) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202367. Final response in S2-2203038 Replied to
8.7 S2-2202367 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS Reply on NEF-initiated reauthorization QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy Rel-17 Response to S2-2202778. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203038 Stefano (Qualcomm) provides R01 to align to Nokia LS reply to CT4.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.7 S2-2203038 LS OUT Approval LS Reply on NEF-initiated reauthorization SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202367r01. Approved Approved
8.7 S2-2202245 CR Approval 23.256 CR0059 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting errors for UAV-C address Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203039 Guanglei (Huawei) provides r02 to further correct step numbers.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, removing overlapped clauses with CR in 2439.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.7 S2-2203039 CR Approval 23.256 CR0059R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting errors for UAV-C address Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202245r02. Approved Agreed
8.7 S2-2202246 CR Approval 23.256 CR0060 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correcting terminology inconsistencies Ericsson Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203040 Shabnam (Ericsson) can be considered merged into revision of 2439 revision 01 as provided, if the changes are agreeable.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.7 S2-2202362 CR Approval 23.256 CR0061 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to SMF-initiated and NEF-initiated re-authorization Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203041 Pallab (Nokia) agrees to merge this into S2-2202447.
Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to consider this merged into S2-2202447.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.7 S2-2202396 CR Approval 23.256 CR0062 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to Naf(Nnef)_Authentication_AuthenticateAuthorize service operation LG Electronics Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.7 S2-2202439 CR Approval 23.256 CR0063 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification and Correction on C2 payload Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203040, merging S2-2202246 Guanglei (Huawei) provides r02.
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 which includes changes from 2246 and some additional improvements.
Dimitris (Lenovo) comments
Guanglei (Huawei) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo).
Hans (Ericsson) comments on r02.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r03.
Stefano (Faccin) provides r04.
Shabnam (Ericsson) is OK with r04 and comments. Thanks for the updates, looks good and clear.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK with r04.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.7 S2-2203040 CR Approval 23.256 CR0063R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification and Correction on C2 payload Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202439r04, merging S2-2202246. Approved Agreed
8.7 S2-2202447 CR Approval 23.256 CR0064 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to service operation names Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203041, merging S2-2202362 Pallab (Nokia) provides r01 merging 2362, added Qualcomm as co-source and corrected as per comment received from Vodafone .
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.7 S2-2203041 CR Approval 23.256 CR0064R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Corrections to service operation names Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202447r01, merging S2-2202362. Approved Agreed
8.8 - - - System enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (5G_ProSe) - - Docs:=31 -
8.8 - - - LS on new interface btw PKMF and UDM - - Docs:=6 -
8.8 S2-2201956 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: LS on new reference point name for the interface between PKMF and UDM in 5G ProSe SA WG3 (S3-220505) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202106. Final response in S2-2203018 Replied to
8.8 S2-2202106 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply to LS on new reference point name for the interface between PKMF and UDM in 5G ProSe Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201956.r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203018 Revised
8.8 S2-2203018 LS OUT Approval Reply to LS on new reference point name for the interface between PKMF and UDM in 5G ProSe SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202106r00. Approved Approved
8.8 S2-2202105 CR Approval 23.304 CR0089 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding reference point between 5G PKMF and UDM Ericsson Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203042 Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r01
Steve (Huawei) provides r01
Hannu (Nokia) provides r02.
Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with r02
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Steve (Huawei) comments
Zhang (Ericsson) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) is fine with r03.
Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203042 CR Approval 23.304 CR0089R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Adding reference point between 5G PKMF and UDM Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202105r03. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202987 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS on 5G ProSe security open items Nokia Created at CC#1. Noted Steve (Huawei) what is the different to the ENs that SA3 already have?
Hannu (Nokia) provides the initial draft of the new LS that was allocated in CC #1.
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) provides r01.
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Steve (Huawei) and provides r03.
Steve (Huawei) comments
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02.
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Steve on the LS justification.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Fei
Hannu (Nokia) provides r04 and r05. Can live with either r04 or r05 and lets the others decide which one to send?
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Hong (Qualcomm) and Judy (Ericsson).
Judy (Ericsson) comments
Judy (Ericsson) see the need of SA2 impact and comments
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Judy (Ericsson)
Steve (Huawei) can this be sent? Perhaps note it.
Judy (Ericsson) share similar view and supports Steve (Huawei)'s proposal to note this paper.
TAO(VC) it seems we cannot converge on any revision? Or some candidate revision move forward
Hannu (Nokia) agrees to note the LS.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 - - - LS for information - - Docs:=1 -
8.8 S2-2202774 LS In Information LS from CT WG1: LS on the SDU type used over user plane for NR PC5 reference point CT WG1 (C1-221835) Rel-17 Noted Fei (OPPO) proposes to note this incoming LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 - - - CP based security solution for UE-to-Network Relay - - Docs:=7 -
8.8 S2-2201999 DISCUSSION Endorsement Open issues for control plane authentication/authorisation and secondary authentication for L3 UE-NW Relays. Qualcomm Incorporated Noted Hannu (Nokia) proposes to address items 1 - 4 in revision of S2-2202596 and to allocate tdoc number for LS out to SA3 on items 5 - 7.
Hannu (Nokia) clarifies the proposal item by item.
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Hannu.
Judy (Ericsson) comments
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Hong (Qualcomm).
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Myungjune.
Myungjune (LGE) replies to Hong (Qualcomm).
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) comments.
Hannu (Nokia) responds to comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 S2-2202104 CR Approval 23.304 CR0088 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify for security procedure for UE-to-Network Relaying Ericsson Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203043 Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r03 based on r01.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r01.
Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r02.
Zhang (Ericsson) provides r01
Steve (Huawei) comments, provides r04
Zhang (Ericsson) is OK with R04
Hannu (Nokia) supports r04
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203043 CR Approval 23.304 CR0088R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarify for security procedure for UE-to-Network Relaying Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202104r04. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202596 CR Approval 23.304 CR0102 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF and AUSF selection for CP authentication and authorisation Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Interdigital Inc. Rel-17 r06 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2203591. Fei (OPPO) asks questions.
Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to address the issues raised in 1999 in revisions.
Steve (Huawei) comments
Hannu (Nokia) answers the questions and provides r01.
Fei (OPPO) responds
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
Judy (Ericsson) comments
Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments
Myungjune (LGE) provides r02
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r02.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Fei
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Hong
Myungjune (LGE) provides r03
Hannu (Nokia) answers to Judy
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Steve
Hannu (Nokia) thanks Myungjune for r02, provides r03 and comments.
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Hannu.
Steve (Huawei) comments, provides r06.
Fei (OPPO) provides comments.
Fei (OPPO) provides comments on standarized SST value.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) comments r06 is not acceptable unless the last bullet is removed from r06.
Judy (Ericsson) comments a revision is needed to take out the per user basis authorization, and remove 'Layer-3' from cover sheet
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r06, it does not fully address the comments.
TAO(VC) check whether the following can be clarified and some revision based upon r06 can achieve agreement.
Hannu (Nokia) proposes after revision deadline r07 to address the comments.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203591 CR Approval 23.304 CR0102R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF and AUSF selection for CP authentication and authorisation Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Interdigital Inc. Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202596r06 + changes. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202597 CR Approval 23.501 CR3615 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF and AUSF selection for CP authentication and authorisation Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Interdigital Inc. Rel-17 This was postponed. Judy (Ericsson) comments
Hannu (Nokia) does not agree to postpone as this CR addresses some of the open issues identified in S2-2201999. Provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments the principle on 2596 and 2597 should be aligned.
Hannu (Nokia) responds to Deng Qiang that even if the AMF and slice selection solution is removed from S2-2202596, the AUSF selection using NF profile should still be kept.
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to go ahead with r01, with one more deletion of 'Layer-3' on the cover page if requested by Ericsson.
Steve (Huawei) suggests postponing, lets sort out 2596, then align
Judy (Ericsson) supports Steve (Huawei)'s proposal to postpone it, sort out the impacted SA2 aspects first and then align.
Hannu (Nokia) accepts to leave the AMF change to later date and points out that S2-2202596r07 provided in drafts area already removes the AMF aspect completely and updates the cover page as requested. The related S2-2202597 and 2598 do not touch this AMF aspect and can be agreed with comment that the text 'Layer-3' is to be removed from the cover page.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.8 S2-2202598 CR Approval 23.502 CR3449 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF and AUSF selection for CP authentication and authorisation Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Interdigital Inc. Rel-17 This was postponed. Judy (Ericsson) comments
Hannu (Nokia) does not agree to postpone as this CR addresses some of the open issues identified in S2-2201999. Provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments the principle on 2596 and 2598 should be aligned. Similar comments to 2597.
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to agree r01 with cover page cleanup to remove the text 'Layer-3' as suggested by Judy.
Steve (Huawei) This CR DEPENDS in S2-2202597. This can't be agreed unless is agreed.
Hannu (Nokia) accepts to leave the AMF change to later date and points out that S2-2202596r07 provided in drafts area already removes the AMF aspect completely and updates the cover page as requested. The related S2-2202597 and 2598 do not touch this AMF aspect and can be agreed with comment that the text 'Layer-3' is to be removed from the cover page.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.8 - - - Miscellaneous corrections and alignments - - Docs:=17 -
8.8 S2-2202247 CR Approval 23.304 CR0090 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mobility restrictions for MCX cleanup Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203044 Steve (Huawei) comments
Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with this CR and co-signs the CR
Judy (Ericsson) provides r01 to add Samsung in co-source and responds to Steve (Huawei)
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Judy (Ericsson) responds to LaeYoung (LGE)
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Judy (Ericsson).
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02, the only change is to tick the ME box in cover sheet
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) is ok with r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r02.
Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203044 CR Approval 23.304 CR0090R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mobility restrictions for MCX cleanup Ericsson, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202247r02. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202871 CR Approval 23.304 CR0103 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification to mobility restrictions Samsung, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Noted Judy (Ericsson) comments that the change in this paper is not needed with the correction in 02247.
Hannu (Nokia) can live without this CR following the comment from Judy.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK to note this CR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 S2-2202292 CR Approval 23.304 CR0093 (Rel-17, 'F'): TAI delivery OPPO Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203045 Judy (Ericsson) ask questions
Fei (OPPO) responds to Judy (Ericsson)
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments.
Fei (OPPO) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT).
Steve (Huawei) comments
Fei (OPPO) responds and provides r01.
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01.
Fei (OPPO) responds to Hong (Qualcomm) and provides r02.
Judy (Ericsson) comments
Fei (OPPO) provides r03.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fei (OPPO)
Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203045 CR Approval 23.304 CR0093R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): TAI delivery OPPO Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202292r03. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202320 CR Approval 23.304 CR0094 (Rel-17, 'F'): Remove ENs on Security Parameters Provisioning for UE-NW Relay CATT, Ericsson Rel-17 r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2203046 Fei (OPPO) provides comments.
Steve (Huawei) provides r01
Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01
Walter Dees (Philips) comments on r02 and provides r03.
Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r01 and provides r02.
Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r02.
Deng Qiang (CATT) can live with r01 and comments on r03.
Walter Dees (Philips) answers to Deng Qiang (CATT).
Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r05.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) is ok with r05.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203046 CR Approval 23.304 CR0094R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Remove ENs on Security Parameters Provisioning for UE-NW Relay CATT, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202320r05. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202462 CR Approval 23.304 CR0098 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections and alignments Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203047 Zhang (Ericsson) suggest to merge the paper with S2-2202320
Steve (Huawei) part can be merged, provides r01 with remainder.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203047 CR Approval 23.304 CR0098R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscellaneous corrections and alignments Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202462r01. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202350 DISCUSSION Agreement Clarification on multiple PDU sessions during L2 U2N direct to indirect path switching. ASUSTeK Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.8 S2-2202351 CR Approval 23.304 CR0095 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on multiple PDU sessions during L2 U2N direct to indirect path switching ASUSTeK Rel-17 Noted Wen (vivo) comments.
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments
Lider (ASUSTeK) has questions for clarification.
Fei (OPPO) provides comments.
Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) replies to Lider.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) supports noting the CR.
Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the CR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 S2-2202352 CR Approval 23.304 CR0096 (Rel-17, 'F'): Differ source L2ID for unstructured type PDU session ASUSTeK Rel-17 Noted Wen (vivo) comments.
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Lider (ASUSTeK) comments.
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note the document as adding more conditions to informative note is not a FASMO change.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comments
Hong (Qualcomm) agrees with Mehrdad (Samsung).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to NOTE this CR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 S2-2202353 CR Approval 23.304 CR0097 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on layer-2 link release ASUSTeK Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) Is this needed?
Lider (ASUSTeK) comments.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comments
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) should be NOTED.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.8 S2-2202564 CR Approval 23.304 CR0099 (Rel-17, 'F'): Modify description in clause 4.3.9.3 ZTE Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202573 CR Approval 23.304 CR0100 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on DRX handling for unicast communication procedures ZTE Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203048 Fei (OPPO) comments.
Steve (Huawei) comments
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides comments
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds and provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) comments.
Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.8 S2-2203048 CR Approval 23.304 CR0100R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on DRX handling for unicast communication procedures ZTE Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202573r02. Approved Agreed
8.8 S2-2202595 CR Approval 23.304 CR0101 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of non-existent reference point Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Noted Zhang (Ericsson) provides comments
Steve (Huawei) comments
Hannu (Nokia) responds to Zhang and Steve and points out the description of this reference point is incomplete and outside of the scope of 3GPP TS.
Fei (OPPO) comments
Hannu (Nokia) thanks Steve for the way forward.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Zhang (Ericsson) object r01 and original version
Hannu (Nokia) agrees to note the CR but points out that some other correction is still needed as Figure 4.2.7.1-2 is not aligned with TS 23.501 Figure D.3-2.
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Hong.
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Hannu.
Noted
8.9 - - - Architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (5MBS) - - Docs:=53 -
8.9 - - - LSs, replies and associated CRs - - Docs:=31 -
8.9 S2-2201933 LS In Action LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarifications on Namf_MBSCommunication N2MessageTransfer service operation CT WG4 (C4-221427) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2201269 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202985. Final response in S2-2203049 Replied to
8.9 S2-2202985 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on LS on Clarifications on Namf_MBSCommunication N2MessageTransfer service operation Nokia Rel-17 Response to S2-2201933. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203049 LiMeng(Huawei) provides r01.
Miguel (Qualcomm) comments that ACTIONS section in the draft LS is incorrect
Thomas(Nokia) provides r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203049 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Clarifications on Namf_MBSCommunication N2MessageTransfer service operation SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202985r02. Approved Approved
8.9 S2-2201949 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on maximum number of MBS sessions that can be associated to a PDU session RAN WG2 (R2-2204107) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202140. Final response in S2-2203050 Replied to
8.9 S2-2201965 LS In Action LS from SA WG6: Reply LS on maximum number of MBS sessions that can be associated to a PDU session SA WG6 (S6-220262) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202140. Final response in S2-2203050 Robbie (Ericsson) comments this LS is responded in S2-2202140 Replied to
8.9 S2-2202140 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on maximum number of MBS sessions that can be associated to a PDU session Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201949 and S2-2201965. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203050 LiMeng(Huawei) provides r01.
Robbie (Ericsson) thanks LiMeng(Huawei) for r01 and comments.
Miguel (Qualcomm) provides some views, ok with either 16 or 32.
Thomas(Nokia) prefers value 16 and provides r02.
Miguel (Qualcomm) comments on Thomas argument
Robbie (Ericsson) shares Miguel's view and prefers 32 to be upper limit in protocol
Robbie (Ericsson) objects to r02, the reason is 32 is the appropriate value in protocol design, and it aligns with RAN2 and SA6 feedback as well.
Thomas (Nokia) objects to r00 and r01
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) is OK with r03
Miguel (Qualcomm) also ok with r03
Robbie (Ericsson) prefers r01 and can live with r03
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203050 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on maximum number of MBS sessions that can be associated to a PDU session SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202140r03. Approved Approved
8.9 S2-2201959 LS In Action LS on 5MBS User Services SA WG4 (S4-220304) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202002, S2-2202356, S2-2202141. Final response in S2-2203051 Robbie (Ericsson) provides comments
LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to LiMeng (Huawei).
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to Haris (Qualcomm).
Haris(Qualcomm) replies
Thomas (Nokia) replies to LiMeng
Thomas (Nokia) provides comments
Thomas(Nokia) comments that the reply in S2-2202002 is fully in line with his technical understanding and suggest to use it as basis for revisions.
zhendong (ZTE) is fine with ericsson proposal
Robbie (Ericsson) responds to zhendong (ZTE)
zhendong (ZTE) respond to robbie
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to Zhendong (ZTE)
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Robbie(Ericsson) asks
Thomas(Nokia) replies to Robbie(Ericsson)
LiMeng (Huawei) agrees with Robbie's view
Robbie (Ericsson) asks whether S2-2202141 or S2-2202202 should be use as a basis for further progress.
LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to use S2-2202141 as the baseline.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Replied to
8.9 S2-2202002 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on 5MBS User Services Qualcomm Rel-17 Response to S2-2201959. Noted Robbie (Ericsson) suggests having the discussion in LS In thread (S2-2201959).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202141 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on 5MBS User Services Ericsson Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203051 Robbie (Ericsson) suggests having the discussion in LS In thread (S2-2201959).
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r02.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203051 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on 5MBS User Services SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202141r03. Approved Approved
8.9 S2-2202356 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on 5MBS User Service Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201959. Noted Robbie (Ericsson) suggests having the discussion in LS In thread (S2-2201959).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
LiMeng (Huawei) agrees to mark this document as 'NOTED'.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2201963 LS In Action LS from TSG CT: LS on parameters preconfigured in the UE to receive MBS service TSG CT (CP-220398) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202001 and S2-2202357. This was postponed. Postponed
8.9 S2-2202001 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on parameters preconfigured in the UE to receive MBS service Qualcomm Rel-17 Response to S2-2201963. Noted Thomas (Nokia) raises concerns against this LS
LiMeng (Huawei) object to this LS.
Kaixin (CBN) raises concerns
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202357 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on preconfigured in the UE receiving MBS Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201963. This was postponed. Haris(Qualcomm) objects to this LS out
Thomas (Nokia) provides r01
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, has concerns on both original and r01 versions as they attempt to add new functions into the spec that does not current exist.
Haris(Qualcomm) comment on r02 and provides r03
Thomas(Nokia) raises concerns against r03
LiMeng (Huawei) objects to r02 and 03.
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r0 and comments
Kaixin (CBN) raises concerns
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes post deadline r04
LiMeng (Huawei) proposes post deadline r05 on top of post deadline r04.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Thomas (Nokia) proposes post deadline r06
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Postponed
8.9 S2-2202000 CR Approval 23.247 CR0100 (Rel-17, 'F'): Need for pre-configured USD and service announcement Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Noted Youngkyo(Samsung) provides a comment.
LiMeng (Huawei) comments
Haris(Qualcomm) provides answers
Thomas (Nokia) raises concerns
Haris(Qualcomm) responds and provides r01
Shabnam (Ericsson) it is wrong to have MBMS spec referred for 5G service announcement when 5G spec is available. Comments and asks clarification
Thomas(Nokia) replies to Harris and provides r02
LiMeng (Huawei) provides r03, and objects to r00, r01, and has concern with r02.
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to r03
Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments and supports r03.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Kaixin (CBN) raises concerns
zhendong (ZTE) proposes to go with r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) asks to whom it will confusion
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes post deadline r04
Shabnam (Ericsson) supports the revised versions of the CR and associated LS response provided here, comments.
LiMeng (Huawei) proposes the post deadline r05
LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Haris.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments that this is ROM and is out of scope of the WI in rel.17
Antoine (Orange) agrees with Haris that UE receiving broadcast communication service data without interaction with the network is out of Rel-17 scope and should not be introduced after the freeze.
LiMeng (Huawei) replies there is no ROM defined for NR in rel.17.
Thomas(Nokia) comments that ruling out ROM in rel.17 is not required
Haris(Qualcomm) comments that not ruling out ROM in rel.17 are absurd
Thomas(Nokia) suggest no explicit wording whether ROM mode is enabled in LS and CR.
Suggest approving r02 of CR
Suggest a post-deadline revision of related LS
==== Comments Deadline ====
James Hu (AT&T) agrees with Haris that receiving broadcast content using preconfiguration without registering in PLMN should not be introduced and is out of Rel-17 scope.
Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Qualcomm, AT&T, Orange that receiving broadcast content using preconfiguration without registering in PLMN is out of Rel-17 scope. This is shown via the Rel-17 and Rel-18 Study items deprioritisation of the associated work in SA plenary as indicated by Qualcomm.
Thomas(Nokia) replies to Shabnam that she is correct that no related work was performed,
but that this does not prove that ROM reception is not possible.
Suggest as compromise avoiding any explicit wording in either direction.
Noted
8.9 S2-2202801 LS In Action LS from RAN WG3: LS on further outstanding issues in TS 23.247 RAN WG3 (R3-222867) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202146 and S2-2202535. Postponed Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments.
Thomas (Nokia) provides comments.
Paul (Ericsson) replies.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Zhendong.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Paul (Ericsson)
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
Thomas(Nokia) replies to zhendong (ZTE)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Postponed
8.9 S2-2202146 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on further outstanding issues in TS 23.247 Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2202801. Noted Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to note this paper and take 2535 as LS out base line.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against this LS
zhendong (ZTE) agree with fenqin proposal
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202535 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Response LS on further outstanding issues in TS 23.247 Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2202801. Noted Paul (Ericsson) proposes to note this draft LS in 2535 and take the draft LS in 2146 as a baseline.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against this LS
Thomas (Nokia) Withdraws objection
zhendong (ZTE) proposes to use this as baseline
Paul (Ericsson) objects to this LS as it neither takes the RAN3 request nor RAN3 agreements into account.
Hence the content of the LS are incorrect.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Thomas (Nokia) provides late r01
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202145 DISCUSSION Agreement Discussion of RAN WG3 LS Related Topics. Ericsson Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.9 S2-2202147 CR Approval 23.247 CR0104 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment with RAN WG3 and other corrections Ericsson Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203052 Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment
Thomas (Nokia) provides r01
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203052 CR Approval 23.247 CR0104R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment with RAN WG3 and other corrections Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202147r02. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202773 LS In Action LS from CT WG1: LS on the impact of MSK update on MBS multicast session update procedure CT WG1 (C1-221747) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202984. Postponed Postponed
8.9 S2-2202984 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on LS on the impact of MSK update on MBS multicast session update procedure Nokia Rel-17 Response to S2-2202773. Postponed Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01.
LiMeng (Huawei) asks question.
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r02 to include the question from LiMeng (Huawei).
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03
Robbie (Ericsson) asks Thomas (Nokia).
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Robbie (Ericsson)
Thomas (Nokia) provides r04
Thomas (Nokia) provides r07, object against r01, r02 and r06
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r06 to address his concerns and comments
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Robbie and provides r05 to address the comments
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r08.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against r08 and provides r09
Robbie (Ericsson) asks why Thomas (Nokia) can decide the MBSF/MBSTF's behavior in SA2, which is under the remits of SA3.
Robbie (Ericsson) asks Thomas (Nokia) to let SA3 do their work, and consider more energy saving option.
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Robbie.
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to Thomas (Nokia).
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Robble
Robbie (Ericsson) accepts only r01, r02, r06, r08, and objects to other revisions, no consensus can be reached, suggests to postpone this paper
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.9 S2-2202960 CR Approval 23.247 CR0116 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscelaneous corrections Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203053 Robbie (Ericsson) comments this CR contains several unrelated issues. Suggest removing the security related updates which require feedback from SA3 and SA4, to align with the LS response (S2-2202984).
Youngkyo(Samsung) supports removing the security related updates.
Thomas(Nokia) replies to Robbie
Provides r01
Thomas(Nokia) provides r02 to remove security related updates as requested by Robbie
Fenqin(Huawei) provides r03
Thomas(Nokia) provides r04
Robbie (Ericsson) asks whether 'N2 MBS info change indicator' is FASMO
Thomas replies to Robbie
Robbie (Ericsson) still tries to understand whether 'N2 MBS info change indicator' is FASMO
Robbie (Ericsson) provides further comments and r05
Robbie (Ericsson) provide r06 since r05 is corrupted
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fenqin (Huawei) is fine with r06
Robbie (Ericsson) accepts r06 only, and cannot accept other revisions.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203053 CR Approval 23.247 CR0116R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Miscelaneous corrections Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202960r06. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202782 LS In Action LS from CT WG4: LS on Traffic usage reporting on 5MBS service CT WG4 (C4-221443) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202142. Final response in S2-2203019 Replied to
8.9 S2-2202142 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Traffic usage reporting on 5MBS service Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2202782. r00 agreed. Revised to S2-2203019 Revised
8.9 S2-2203019 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Traffic usage reporting on 5MBS service SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202142r00. Approved Approved
8.9 S2-2202785 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on the Length of MBS Service Area Identity RAN WG2 (R2-2203902) Rel-17 Noted LiMeng(Huawei) suggests to note this LS, RAN2 already specified that.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202794 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Multicast paging with TMGI SA WG3 (S3-220537) Rel-17 Noted LiMeng(Huawei) suggests to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 - - - Others - - Docs:=22 -
8.9 S2-2202044 CR Approval 23.247 CR0101 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on the mobility procedures for MBS Inspur Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203054 Xiaohua (Inspur) provides r01 to fill CR number on the cover sheet.
Judy (Ericsson) asks to copy the complete content of 7.2.3.2 where the changes apply.
Xiaohua (Inspur) provides r02 based on Judy's comment.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203054 CR Approval 23.247 CR0101R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction on the mobility procedures for MBS Inspur Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202044r02. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202355 CR Approval 23.247 CR0107 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mega CR to clean up Huawei, Hisilicon, Samsung Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203055 Youngkyo(Samsung) replies.
Robbie (Ericsson) raises a question.
Youngkyo(Samsung) comments.
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01.
LiMeng(provides) r02.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203055 CR Approval 23.247 CR0107R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Mega CR to clean up Huawei, Hisilicon, Samsung, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202355r02. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202833 CR Approval 23.247 CR0113 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on Activation procedure ZTE Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202834 CR Approval 23.247 CR0114 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarificaiton on the MBS session create and start procedure ZTE Rel-17 Noted Judy (Ericsson) comments that change to 7.3.3 overlaps with 02960 and removal of ENs need some justification.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r01
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) accepts r02 and objects to r00, r01
Thomas (Nokia) object against r02
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202712 CR Approval 23.247 CR0110 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MBS security function Samsung Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202143 CR Approval 23.247 CR0102 (Rel-17, 'F'): Broadcast MBS Session Release Require Procedure Ericsson Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202144 CR Approval 23.247 CR0103 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS Service Area for MB-SMF selection in TMGI Allocation Ericsson Rel-17 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203056 Youngkyo(Samsung) asks a question.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment.
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to Fenqin (Huawei) and Youngkyo (Samsung).
Fenqin (Huawei) provides further comment.
Robbie (Ericsson) replies to Fenqin (Huawei).
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r01.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02.
Robbie (Ericsson) provides r03.
Youngkyo(Samsung) comments.
Robbie(Ericsson) replies and provides r04
Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provide r05
Robbie (Ericsson) comments.
Robbie (Ericsson) asks Fenqin (Huawei)
Fenqin(Huawei) responds to Robbie(Ericsson).
Robbie(Ericsson) replies to Youngkyo(Samsung) and asks Fenqin(Huawei).
Robbie(Ericsson) raises concerns on r05
Fenqin (Huawei) provides responds
Fenqin (Huawei) provides responds and r06
Robbie (Ericsson) is fine with r06
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203056 CR Approval 23.247 CR0103R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): MBS Service Area for MB-SMF selection in TMGI Allocation Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202144r06. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202148 CR Approval 23.247 CR0105 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to MBS Session Context and MBS Session Activation procedure Ericsson Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203057 Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment and r01
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) that the current description does not match the condition and the change in r00 makes them consistent.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02 based on r00
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03
Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203057 CR Approval 23.247 CR0105R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction to MBS Session Context and MBS Session Activation procedure Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202148r03. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202354 CR Approval 23.247 CR0106 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolve the residual ENs and Clean-up in TS 23.247 Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2203592. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01
Judy (Ericsson) provides r02
Thomas (Nokia) provides r03
Judy (Ericsson) does not agree with r03 and comments
Thomas (Nokia) does not agree with r02 and comments
Thomas (Nokia) provides r04 (with additional affected clause requested by Judy) and r05 (reverting the controversial changes) to choose from
LiMeng (Huawei) can accept r04.
Judy (Ericsson) provides r06 based on r04
Thomas (Nokia) provides r08 based on r06
Thomas (Nokia) objects against r04 and r06
Judy (Ericsson) provides r09
LiMeng (Huawei) comments on r09 and provides r10.
Thomas (Nokia) provides r11.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) accepts r02, r05, r06 & r09, objects to other revisions including r00 as the added text does not capture the implication of the removed EN and NOTE 4.
LiMeng (Huawei) can accept r00, r01, r03-05, r10 and r11, and objects to other versions of this document. Suggest to go with r05 in this meeting for the sake of progress.
Thomas (Nokia) objects against r02 and r06.
Thomas Nokia asks if Judy could accept r09 with two minor changes on top.
If so suggest bringing that version to CC
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Thomas (Nokia)
Thomas (Nokia) replies to Judy
Thomas(Nokia) can accept r09
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203592 CR Approval 23.247 CR0106R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolve the residual ENs and Clean-up in TS 23.247 Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202354r09. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202536 CR Approval 23.247 CR0090R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification of MBS data forwarding Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2200882. Noted Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02
Thomas (Nokia) provides r01
Paul (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments that RAN3 asked SA2 in their LS in 2801 to take into account their agreements and specifically referring to a solution based on NG-C/N2 signaling.
Thomas (Nokia) raises comments against r03
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r04
zhendong (ZTE) provides r05
Fenqin (Huawei) objects r03 and r06 and suggest to take r04 way forward.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
zhendong (ZTE) only accept r05
Thomas (Nokia) can accept r04 and r05
Comments that the issue was already discussed in a SA2#149e CC and the chair indicated that we could try to establish a working agreement in 150E is the same situation continues.
Suggest bringing this matter to a CC to see if a working agreement can this time be established
Paul (Ericsson) objects to all revisions except r03 and r06.
Fenqin (Huawei) object r03 and r06, and suggest to bring this to CC#2.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202687 CR Approval 23.247 CR0109 (Rel-17, 'F'): Update of PCC procedure for 5MBS Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Noted Judy (Ericsson) fully supports the simplification for no NEF deployment, and proposes further simplification for the NEF deployment and makes the NEF-PCF interaction optional.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the comments
Thomas(Nokia) objects against this CR
Mirko (Huawei) responds to the comments and asks for constructive proposals for the simplification/streamlining of the PCC procedures for 5MBS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) does not accept r00, asks Tao (VC) if r01 provided on April 6 can be updated in the note, if yes, propose to go for r01 for simplification, and asks Nokia&ZTE to reconsider their position as the current MBS PCC is unnecessarily complicated and very inefficient and it does not consider Energy Efficiency as guiding principle either.
Thomas(Nokia) continues to inject against all revisions (including the original).
zhendong (ZTE) object this CR.
Thomas(Nokia) continues to object against all revisions (including the original). Sorry for my typo in the previous email
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.9 S2-2202736 CR Approval 23.247 CR0111 (Rel-17, 'F'): Usage of NAS message for UE joining procedure Samsung Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203058 Judy (Ericsson) provides r01
Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r02
Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r03
Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay with r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203058 CR Approval 23.247 CR0111R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Usage of NAS message for UE joining procedure Samsung, Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202736r03. Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202738 CR Approval 23.247 CR0112 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MBS session activation procedure Samsung Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.9 S2-2202537 CR Approval 23.247 CR0108 (Rel-17, 'F'): Left issue on local MBS service Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed zhendong (ZTE) provides comment
Judy (Ericsson) provides r01
Fenqin (Huawei) provides response and r02
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei)
Fenqin (Huawei) responds.
zhendong (ZTE) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Judy (Ericsson) accepts r01, objects to other revisions including r00
zhendong (ZTE) is fine with r01
Fenqin (Huawei) object to remove the multi MB-SMF case and suggest to keep the change on resource reservation for data forwarding
Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin (Huawei).
Fenqin (Huawei) responds to Judy (Ericsson).
Thomas(Nokia) objects against r01 that removes multi MB-SMF case
Judy (Ericsson) comments
==== Comments Deadline ====
Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to bring this to CC#3.
Postponed
8.9 S2-2202835 CR Approval 23.247 CR0115 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on local dependent MBS session ZTE Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203059 Judy (Ericsson) provides r01
Thomas (Nokia) provides r02
zhendong (ZTE) provies response
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.9 S2-2203059 CR Approval 23.247 CR0115R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on local dependent MBS session ZTE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202835r02. Approved Agreed
8.10 - - - System enablers for multi-USIM devices (MUSIM) - - Docs:=3 -
8.10 S2-2202210 CR Approval 23.501 CR3596 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of message name for paging restriction information Ericsson Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.10 S2-2202211 CR Approval 23.401 CR3696 (Rel-17, 'F'): Acceptance and Rejection of Paging restriction information Ericsson Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203241 Steve (Huawei) provides r01
Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.10 S2-2203241 CR Approval 23.401 CR3696R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Acceptance and Rejection of Paging Restriction Information Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202211r01. Approved Agreed
8.11 - - - Architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G (5GSAT_ARCH) - - Docs:=20 -
8.11 S2-2201928 LS In Action Reply LS on UE location aspects in NTN SA WG3 (S3-214360) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200065 from S2#149E. Noted DongYeon (Samsung) proposes to postpone, becuase there's no action required from SA2 yet.
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note as the LS is only CC to us and no response is requested.
Stefan (Ericsson) supports to note the LS
DongYeon (Samsung) supports to note the LS
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.11 S2-2201931 LS In Action LS from RAN WG3: LS on RAN Initiated Release due to out-of-PLMN area condition RAN WG3 (R3-221379) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200417 from S2#149E. Responses drafted in S2-2201981, S2-2202803. Final response in S2-2203242 Replied to
8.11 S2-2201943 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on UE location during initial access in NTN RAN WG2 (R2-2202057) Rel-17 Already replied to in S2-2201540. Noted Steve (Huawei) already replied to, should be noted?
Jean Yves (Thales) also proposes to note
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.11 S2-2201953 LS In Information LS from RAN WG2: LS on UE location in connected mode in NTN RAN WG2 (R2-2204257) Rel-17 Noted DongYeon (Samsung) proposes to NOTE, because this input is information LS to SA2.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.11 S2-2201981 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on RAN Initiated Release due to out-of-PLMN area condition Ericsson Rel-17 Response to S2-2201931. Merged into S2-2203242 Steve (Huawei) We need to pick one of S2-2201981 or S2-2202803 to send, can't send both.
Stefan (Ericsson) OK to merge S2-2201981 into S2-2202803
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.11 S2-2202803 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on RAN Initiated Release due to out-of-PLMN area condition Samsung Electronics Romania Rel-17 Response to S2-2201931. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203242, merging S2-2201981 Steve (Huawei) We need to pick one of S2-2201981 or S2-2202803 to send, can't send both.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01
Yuxin (Xiaomi) agrees the r01
Jean Yves (Thales) agrees the r01
Steve (Huawei) fine to select this one, r01 is ok.
DongYeon (Samsung) agrees to r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.11 S2-2203242 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on RAN Initiated Release due to out-of-PLMN area condition SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202803r01, merging S2-2201981. Approved Approved
8.11 S2-2202776 LS In Information LS from CT WG1: NR satellite RAT type in UE NAS CT WG1 (C1-222098) Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.11 S2-2201980 CR Approval 23.502 CR3420 (Rel-17, 'F'): RAN indication that UE has moved out of PLMN serving area Ericsson Rel-17 Approved, merging S2-2202805 Agreed
8.11 S2-2202235 CR Approval 23.501 CR3597 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of last visited TAI requirement Apple Rel-17 Postponed DongYeon (Samsung) comments.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments
Yuxin (Xiaomi) has the same comment.
Hannu (Nokia) supports the comment from Stephen and Yuxin and provides r01.
Robert (Apple) responds to Hannu's comment. r01 is not acceptable.
Robert (Apple) responds to Stephen (Qualcomm) and provides r02.
Scott (Inspur) comments.
Robert (Apple) responds to Scott's (Inspur) comment.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the r01 and r02
Robert (Apple) responds to Stephen's (Qualcomm) comments and provides r04.
Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r03
Chris (Vodafone) provides r05.
Robert (Apple) responds to Chris (Vodafone) and provides r08.
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept r03 but has reservations for other rev.s
Hannu (Nokia) provides r09.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r10
Robert (Apple) provides r11
Scott(Inspur) comments.
Chris (Vodafone) provides r12.
Robert (Apple) responds to Scott (?) and Chris (Vodafone) and provides r13.
Chris (Vodafone) believes R13 is wrong (and R12 is correct).
Robert (Apple) comments on Chris's (Vodafone) believe.
Steve (Huawei) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Robert (Apple): r14 is OK for Apple
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r14
Stephen (Qualcomm) can agree r03 only and no other rev.
Hucheng (CATT) proposes to postpone the discussion as there is no perfect version.
Stefan (Ericsson) comments that r14 was uploaded before deadline but email announcing it was delayed due to altospam.
Leo (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with CATT, CR shall be postponed to the next SA2 meeting.
Jean Yves (Thales) is in favor to postponed to the next SA2 meeting.
DongYeon (Samsung) agrees with Hucheng (CATT), it needs to be postponed to the next meeting.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.11 S2-2202236 CR Approval 23.502 CR3436 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of last visited TAI requirement Apple Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203243 DongYeon (Samsung) comments.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments
Yuxin (Xiaomi) has the same comment.
Hannu (Nokia) comments.
Scott (Inspur) comments.
Hannu (Nokia) asks for clarification to understand the non-FASMO comment?
Scott (Inspur) responds to Hannu and clarifies the FASMO problem.
Robert (Apple) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm) and provides r01.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the r01
Robert (Apple) responds to Stephen's (Qualcomm) comments and provides r02
Stephen (Qualcomm) can agree the r02
Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 as the only possible solution, i.e. we need to update the incorrect note.
Stefan (Ericsson) also agrees with r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
DongYeon (Samsung) also agree with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.11 S2-2203243 CR Approval 23.502 CR3436R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Correction of last visited TAI requirement Apple Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202236r02. Approved Agreed
8.11 S2-2202281 CR Approval 23.501 CR3604 (Rel-17, 'F'): Criterion of Verification of UE location for UE registering via 5G Satellite Access Inspur Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203244 Hannu (Nokia) proposes r01 to avoid re-use of reserved word 'country' in different meaning.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the r00 and r01
Scott (Inspur) replies Hannu and Stephen.
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Chris (Vodafone) objects to r00, but r01 seems OK.
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) comments
Runze (Huawei) comments.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments again on the r00 versus r01
DongYeon (Samsung) objects to r00, but r01 is OK.
Scott(Inspur) replies to Chris.
Scott(Inspur) relies to Stephen (Qualcomm)'s comments
Scott(Inspur) replies to DongYeon (Samsung) and all.
Hannu (Nokia) replies to Scott
Jean Yves (Thales) comments
Scott (Inspur) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can agree the r01
Scott(Inspur) provides the r02
Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 and thanks Scott for cleaning up the revision.
Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with r02 (and r01)
==== Comments Deadline ====
Hannu (Nokia) comments that r02 is a cleaned up version of r01 to remove changes on changes. Since r02 was provided after the revision deadline, it should go to CC #3 but I support r02 as r01 would need the same cleanup anyway.
Revised
8.11 S2-2203244 CR Approval 23.501 CR3604R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Criterion of Verification of UE location for UE registering via 5G Satellite Access Inspur Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202281r01. Approved Agreed
8.11 S2-2202329 CR Approval 23.501 CR3607 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on AMF obtaining the satellite-related information Inspur Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203245 DongYeon (Samsung) comments.
Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with DongYeon that this CR is not needed
Hannu (Nokia) proposes to note this CR for the reasons mentioned by DongYeong and Stefan.
Xiaohua (Inspur) replies and provides r01.
Yuxin (Xiaomi) comments
Xiaohua (Inspur) replies to Yuxin
DongYeon (Samsung) comments, and provides r02.
Hannu (Nokia) provides r03 and comments.
Xiaohua (Inspur) replies to DongYeon and Hannu.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Yuxin (Xiaomi) can live with r03
Xiaohua (Inspur) accepts r03 and comments.
DongYeon (Samsung) is Okay with r03 and r02 (prefers r03), objects to any other versions.
Jean Yves (Thales) is ok with r03
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.11 S2-2203245 CR Approval 23.501 CR3607R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on AMF obtaining the satellite-related information Inspur Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202329r03. Approved Agreed
8.11 S2-2202380 CR Approval 23.502 CR3442 (Rel-17, 'F'): TAIs reporting corresponding to the Selected PLMN OPPO Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.11 S2-2202804 CR Approval 23.501 CR3621 (Rel-17, 'F'): RAN Initiated UE Context Release for UE using NR satellite access Samsung Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203246 Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that the wrong clause is being changed
Scott (Inspur) comments that we support the paper, but it is subject to change.
Hucheng (CATT) has similar understanding as Stephen (Qualcomm).
Yuxin (Xiaomi) provides r02.
DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Scott (Inspur).
DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm) and Hucheng (CATT), and provides r01.
Stephen (Qualcomm) comments that the r02 is acceptable
Scott (Inspur) replies to DongYeon (Samsung).
Scott (Inspur) comments and propose the way forward.
DongYeon (Samsung) responds to Scott (Inspur), and provides r03.
Scott (Inspur) responds to DongYeon (Samsung), and comment on r03.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept the r03
Yuxin (Xiaomi) can accept the r03
Hucheng (CATT) prefers r02, but objects r00 and r03.
DongYeon (Samsung) is Okay with r02 and r03.
Yuxin(Xiaomi) withdraw supporting r03, can live with r02
Hucheng (CATT) clarifies to DongYeon (Samsung).
DongYeon (Samsung) asks everyone if r02 is acceptable.
Jean Yves (Thales) is ok with r02 and comments
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.11 S2-2203246 CR Approval 23.501 CR3621R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): RAN Initiated UE Context Release for UE using NR satellite access Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202804r02. Approved Agreed
8.11 S2-2202805 CR Approval 23.502 CR3454 (Rel-17, 'F'): RAN Initiated UE Context Release for UE using NR satellite access Samsung Rel-17 Merged into S2-2201980 Stefan (Ericsson) comments and proposes to merge into S2-2201980
Steve (Huawei) merging into 1980 looks sensible.
DongYeon (Samsung) agrees to MERGE S2-2202805 into S2-2201980.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.12 - - - Architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services - Phase 2 (eV2XARC_Ph2) - - Docs:=15 -
8.12 S2-2201946 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on Tx Profile RAN WG2 (R2-2203693) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202283, S2-2202287, S2-2202681. Final response in S2-2203595 Replied to
8.12 S2-2202283 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Tx Profile LG Electronics Rel-17 Response to S2-2201946. r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2203595, merging S2-2202681 and S2-2202287. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Fei (OPPO) comments on r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Fei (OPPO).
Fei (OPPO) provides response.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers to Mehrdad (Samsung).
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments and requests clarification and changes.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Fei (OPPO) provides further comments.
Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03 and also adds further comments
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04.
Hong (Qualcomm) provides r05.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06 with further clean-ups and editorial/minor changes.
Fei (OPPO) provides r07.
LaeYoung (LGE) responds to Fei (OPPO).
Fei (OPPO) responds
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hong (Qualcomm) cannot accept r07 and prefer r06.
LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with wording suggestion from Fei (OPPO) with small editorial changes.
Fei (OPPO) provides response to LaeYoung (LG).
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to add 'that seems not controllable by 3GPP standardization' to r07 to move forward.
Fei (OPPO) can only accept r07 and object r00 to r06.
LaeYoung (LGE) is OK to go with r06, and also fine with either option suggested by Hong (Qualcomm).
LaeYoung (LGE) is also fine with wording suggestion from Hong (Qualcomm).
Fei (OPPO) asks clarification on the new wording from Hong (Qualcomm)
Hong (Qualcomm) comments and suggest new wording.
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Fei.
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to discuss this LS at CC#2 in order to add the agreeable text to the latest version, r07.
Fei (OPPO) replies to LaeYoung (LGE)
Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Laeyoung.
LaeYoung (LGE) suggests wording on top of wording from Hong (Qualcomm).
LaeYoung (LGE) uploaded r08 adding the agreeable text on top of r07 (latest version before revision deadline) to Revisions folder as well as CC#2 folder for discussion at CC#2.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.12 S2-2203595 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Tx Profile SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202283r08, merging S2-2202681 and S2-2202287. Approved Approved
8.12 S2-2202681 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Response LS on Tx Profile Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201946. Merged into S2-2203595 LiMeng (Huawei) corrects the previous comment.
LiMeng (Huawei) replies.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
LaeYoung (LGE) responds to LiMeng (Huawei).
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to use 2283 as the discussion thread and to finalize the LS
LiMeng (Huawei) is fine to use 2283 as the one to further discuss the issue.
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this LS into 2283 or get this LS NOTED.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.12 S2-2202287 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Tx Profile OPPO Response to S2-2201946. Merged into S2-2203595 LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Fei (OPPO).
Fei (OPPO) responds to LaeYoung (LGE).
LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to use 2283 as the discussion thread and to finalize the LS
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this LS into 2283 or get this LS NOTED.
Fei (OPPO) responds.
Mehrdad (Samsung) apologies for confusion. 2283 is the thread to merge all the LSs. We follow the discussions in 2283.
LaeYoung (LGE) will reply to Mehrdad (Samsung) on 2283 thread because we agreed to use 2283 thread for further discussion.
Mehrdad (Samsung) comments and requests clarification and changes.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.12 S2-2202284 CR Approval 23.287 CR0177 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on PC5 DRX operations LG Electronics, CATT Rel-17 r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2203247, merging S2-2202290 Fei (OPPO) comments on r01 and proposes to focus on reply LS first.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to adopt either 2284 or 2290 for the DRX changes of V2X
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Fei (OPPO) comments on r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03.
Hong (Qualcomm) comments.
LaeYoung (LGE) replies to Hong (Qualcomm).
Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r04 to make it clearer on the mapping when Tx profile not available and co-signs.
LaeYoung (LGE) thanks to Shabnam (Ericsson) for wording improvement and co-sign.
Mehrdad (Samsung) asks a question for clarification.
LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Mehrdad (Samsung).
Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LGE.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) is fine with r05.
Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r05 and would like to co-source this CR based on r05.
LaeYoung (LGE) will add Samsung to the final version.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.12 S2-2203247 CR Approval 23.287 CR0177R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on PC5 DRX operations LG Electronics, CATT, Ericsson, Samsung, OPPO Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202284r05, merging S2-2202290. Approved Agreed
8.12 S2-2202285 CR Approval 23.304 CR0091 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on PC5 DRX operations LG Electronics, CATT Rel-17 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203248, merging S2-2202289 LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Fei (OPPO).
Fei (OPPO) comments and proposes to focus on reply LS first.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to adopt either 2285 or 2289 for the DRX changes of ProSe
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Fei (OPPO) comments on r02.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) is fine with r04.
Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r04 and would like to co-source this CR based on r04.
LaeYoung (LGE) will add Samsung to the final version.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.12 S2-2203248 CR Approval 23.304 CR0091R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifications on PC5 DRX operations LG Electronics, CATT, Ericsson, Samsung, OPPO Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202285r04, merging S2-2202289. Approved Agreed
8.12 S2-2202288 DISCUSSION Discussion Tx profile. OPPO Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.12 S2-2202289 CR Approval 23.304 CR0092 (Rel-17, 'F'): DRX operations OPPO Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203248 Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to adopt either 2285 or 2289 for the DRX changes of ProSe
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this CR into S2-2202285 (LGE, CATT).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) is ok to mark merged or noted.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.12 S2-2202290 CR Approval 23.287 CR0178 (Rel-17, 'F'): DRX operations OPPO Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203247 Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to adopt either 2284 or 2290 for the DRX changes of V2X
LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this CR into S2-2202284 (LGE, CATT).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Fei (OPPO) is ok to mark merged or noted.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.12 S2-2202680 CR Approval 23.287 CR0179 (Rel-17, 'F'): SL DRX update considering new QoS parameters Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203249 Cai Simon (Nokia) provides comments
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01.
LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02.
Cai Simon (Nokia) supports r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.12 S2-2203249 CR Approval 23.287 CR0179R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): SL DRX update considering new QoS parameters Huawei, HiSilicon, Tencent Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202680r02. Approved Agreed
8.12 S2-2202704 CR Approval 23.285 CR0064 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on parameter for NR Tx Profile selection LG Electronics Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.13 - - - 5G System Enhancement for Advanced Interactive Services (5G_AIS) - - Docs:=0 -
8.14 - - - Enhancement to the 5GC LoCation Services-Phase 2 (5G_eLCS_Ph2) - - Docs:=9 -
8.14 S2-2201942 LS In Information LS from RAN WG1: Reply LS on Positioning Reference Units (PRUs) for enhancing positioning performance RAN WG1 (R1-2202912) Rel-17 Noted Yunjing (CATT) proposes to note the LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.14 S2-2201948 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: LS on Positioning in RRC_INACTIVE State RAN WG2 (R2-2203949) Rel-17 Responses drafted in S2-2202915, S2-2202974. Final response in S2-2203250 Replied to
8.14 S2-2202915 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Positioning in RRC_INACTIVE State Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Response to S2-2201948. Revised to S2-2203250, merging S2-2202974 Revised
8.14 S2-2203250 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Positioning in RRC_INACTIVE State SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202915, merging S2-2202974. Approved Approved
8.14 S2-2202974 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS Response to LS on Positioning in RRC_INACTIVE State Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Response to S2-2201948. Merged into S2-2203250 Runze (Huawei) propose to merge the paper into S2-2202915
Stephen (Qualcomm) agrees merger of S2-2202974 into S2-2202915.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.14 S2-2202916 CR Approval 23.273 CR0226 (Rel-17, 'B'): Adding procedures to support UE positioning in RRC inactive state Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203251 Stephen (Qualcomm) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) proposes that S2-2202916 be merged into S2-2202973
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.14 S2-2202971 CR Approval 23.273 CR0227 (Rel-17, 'B'): Periodic and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR Procedure in RRC INACTIVE state Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Noted Stephen (Qualcomm) proposes to note this CR
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.14 S2-2202973 CR Approval 23.273 CR0228 (Rel-17, 'B'): Periodic and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR Procedure in RRC INACTIVE state Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203251, merging S2-2202916 Yunjing (CATT) provides comments.
Yunjing (CATT) provides comment.
Stephen (Qualcomm) provides an r01 and responds to comments from Yunjing (CATT)
Runze (Huawei) comments.
Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Runze (Huawei)
Cai Simon (Nokia) provides comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Stephen (Qualcomm) replies to Cai Simon (Nokia)
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.14 S2-2203251 CR Approval 23.273 CR0228R1 (Rel-17, 'B'): Periodic and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR Procedure in RRC INACTIVE state Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202973r01, merging S2-2202916. Approved Agreed
8.15 - - - Multimedia Priority Service (MPS) Phase 2 (MPS2) - - Docs:=0 -
8.16 - - - Dynamic management of group-based event monitoring (TEI17_GEM) - - Docs:=0 -
8.17 - - - N7/N40 Interfaces Enhancements to Support GERAN and UTRAN (TEI17_NIESGU) - - Docs:=0 -
8.18 - - - System enhancement for Redundant PDU Session (TEI17_SE_RPS) - - Docs:=0 -
8.19 - - - IMS Optimization for HSS Group ID in an SBA environment (TEI17_IMSGID) - - Docs:=0 -
8.20 - - - Support for Signed Attestation for Priority and Emergency Sessions (TEI17_SAPES) - - Docs:=0 -
8.21 - - - Dynamically Changing AM Policies in the 5GC (TEI17_DCAMP) - - Docs:=2 -
8.21 S2-2202688 CR Approval 23.502 CR3451 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of terminology for PCF related procedures Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203432 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments
Mirko (Huawei) responds.
Mirko (Huawei) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.21 S2-2203432 CR Approval 23.502 CR3451R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Alignment of terminology for PCF related procedures Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202688r01. Approved Agreed
8.22 - - - IP address pool information from UDM (TEI17_IPU) - - Docs:=0 -
8.23 - - - Same PCF selection for AMF and SMF (TEI17-SPSFAS) - - Docs:=0 -
8.24 - - - Support of different slices over different Non-3GPP access (TEI17_N3SLICE) - - Docs:=0 -
8.25 - - - Minimization of Service Interruption (MINT) - - Docs:=16 -
8.25 S2-2201957 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on Reply LS on MINT functionality for Disaster Roaming SA WG3 (S3-220518) Rel-17 Noted Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to note this LS.
Lalith(Samsung) also proposes to note this LS.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.25 S2-2202051 CR Approval 23.501 CR3585 (Rel-17, 'F'): Disaster Roaming for Short Message Service Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Postponed Qian (Ericsson) asks question
Haiyang (Huawei) responds to Qian (Ericsson)
Qian (Ericsson) comments and provide r01
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with r01
Haris(Qualcomm) asks question
Hyunsook (LGE) comments
Lalith(Samsung) comments.
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02
Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r02
Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies to Haris(Qualcomm)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) proposes to postpone, no revision is acceptable
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.25 S2-2202208 CR Approval 23.501 CR3580R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Disaster roaming service indication Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2201832. Endorsed Qian (Ericsson) responds to Haiyang (Huawei)
Haiyang (Huawei) provides a question
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to mark it as 'POSTPONED'
Lalith(Samsung) is OK with 'POSTPONED' or 'ENDORSED'
Qian (Ericsson) comments and consider the paper shall be 'ENDORSED' as the outcome from last SA2 meeting, if we did not get reply from SA5 in time.
Hyunsook (LGE) can agree to mark it as 'ENDORSED'
==== Comments Deadline ====
Endorsed
8.25 S2-2202209 CR Approval 23.502 CR3147R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): Session procedure improvement for MINT Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of (Endorsed) S2-2201833. Endorsed Haiyang (Huawei) provides a question
Qian (Ericsson) responds
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to mark it as 'POSTPONED'
Lalith(Samsung) is OK with 'POSTPONED' or 'ENDORSED'
Qian (Ericsson) comments and consider the paper shall be 'ENDORSED' as the outcome from last SA2 meeting, if we did not get reply from SA5 in time.
Hyunsook (LGE) can agree to mark it as 'ENDORSED'
==== Comments Deadline ====
Endorsed
8.25 S2-2202259 CR Approval 23.501 CR3599 (Rel-17, 'F'): Session related subscription infomation LG Electronics Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203060 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.25 S2-2203060 CR Approval 23.501 CR3599R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Session related subscription information LG Electronics Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202259r01. Approved Agreed
8.25 S2-2202260 CR Approval 23.502 CR3437 (Rel-17, 'F'): Session related subscription infomation LG Electronics Rel-17 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203061 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.25 S2-2203061 CR Approval 23.502 CR3437R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Session related subscription information LG Electronics Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202260r01. Approved Agreed
8.25 S2-2202261 CR Approval 23.501 CR3600 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on UE 5GMM Capability LG Electronics Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.25 S2-2202262 CR Approval 23.501 CR3601 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removing the editor's note related to CT WG1 LG Electronics Rel-17 Approved, merging S2-2202912 Agreed
8.25 S2-2202912 CR Approval 23.501 CR3627 (Rel-17, 'F'): Resolving the EN. Samsung Rel-17 Merged into S2-2202262 Hyunsook (LGE) proposes to mark it as 'merged into 2262'
Lalith(Samsung) agrees to merge into 2262
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.25 S2-2202903 CR Approval 23.501 CR3626 (Rel-17, 'F'): End of disaster condition Samsung Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.25 S2-2202911 CR Approval 23.502 CR3462 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MINT support and end of disaster Samsung Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203062 Haiyang (Huawei) provides r01
Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Lalith(Samsung) is OK r02
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.25 S2-2203062 CR Approval 23.502 CR3462R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarification on MINT support and end of disaster Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202911r02. Approved Agreed
8.25 S2-2202050 CR Approval 23.502 CR3421 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network-initiated Deregistration if disaster condition is no longer being applicable Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203063 Lalith(Samsung) comments
Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r01
Hyunsook (LGE) provides r02
Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Lalith(Samsung) is OK with r02
Qian (Ericsson) is ok with r02
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.25 S2-2203063 CR Approval 23.502 CR3421R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Network-initiated Deregistration if disaster condition is no longer being applicable Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202050r02. Approved Agreed
8.26 - - - Architecture Enhancement for NR Reduced Capability Devices (ARCH_NR_REDCAP) - - Docs:=1 -
8.26 S2-2202544 CR Approval 23.501 CR3612 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF selection to support HLcom feaure for RedCap using power saving function Sony Rel-17 Postponed Antoine (Orange) asks a question and comments.
Lars (Sony) responds to Antoine.
Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
Lars (Sony) is ok with r01 provided by Antoine.
Steve (Huawei) comments
Qian (Ericsson) provides comments.
Lars (Sony) responds to Steve
Lars (Sony) responds to Qian
Qian (Ericsson) provides further comments.
Qian (Ericsson) responds to Lars (Sony)
Steve (Huawei) thanks Lars for the reference.
Hannu (Nokia) supports Qian (Ericsson) and comments.
Hannu (Nokia) provides r03.
Lars (Sony) thanks Qian for r02
Qian (Ericsson) comments and provides r02
Steve (Huawei) a bit more checking would be a good thing.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Lars (Sony) ask what to at this meeting?
Steve (Huawei) lets postpone and come back.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.27 - - - Architecture support for NB-IoT/eMTC Non-Terrestrial Networks in EPS (IoT_SAT_ARCH_EPS) - - Docs:=15 -
8.27 S2-2201932 LS In Action LS from RAN WG3: LS on opens issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN RAN WG3 (R3-221406) Rel-17 Revision of Postponed S2-2200418 from S2#149E. Response drafted in S2-2202006, S2-2202875. Final response in S2-2203064 Replied to
8.27 S2-2202875 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on open issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN MediaTek Inc. Rel-17 Response to S2-2201932. Merged into S2-2203064 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) proposes to merge 2875 with 2006.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.27 S2-2202006 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on opens issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN Qualcomm Rel-17 Response to S2-2201932. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203064, merging S2-2202875 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r01.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.27 S2-2203064 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on opens issues for NB-IoT and eMTC support for NTN SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202006r02, merging S2-2202875. Approved Approved
8.27 S2-2202005 LS OUT Approval NB-IoT Control Plane Relocation procedure upon NTN to TN mobility Qualcomm Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) comments, related to CR in S2-2202004. Needs to wait for fate of 2004.
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification
Haris(Qualcomm) comments and provides r02
Steve (Huawei) why is this needed?
Stefan (Ericsson) also not clear why it is needed, but provides r03 just in case
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) objects to all revisions (r00, r01, r02, r03).
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.27 S2-2202777 LS In Action LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on UE providing Location Information for NB-IoT CT WG1 (C1-222100) Rel-17 Noted Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.27 S2-2202787 LS In Action LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on UE providing Location Information for NB-IoT RAN WG3 (R3-222858) Rel-17 Noted Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) proposes to note the LS. No response needed.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.27 S2-2202788 LS In Information LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on UE location during initial access in NTN RAN WG3 (R3-222861) Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) Proposes to note.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.27 S2-2202795 LS In Information LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on security concerns for UE providing Location Information for NB-IoT SA WG3 (S3-220544) Rel-17 Noted Steve (Huawei) Proposes to note.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.27 S2-2202003 DISCUSSION Approval TN-NTN NB-IoT mobility for CP-CIoT Qualcomm Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.27 S2-2202004 CR Endorsement 23.401 CR3693 (Rel-17, 'C'): NB-IOT TN-NTN mobility for CP-CIoT Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Postponed Hannu (Nokia) asks for clarification as revision might be needed?
Hannu (Nokia) asks for clarification as revision might be needed? (re-sending to correct the AI)
Haris(Qualcomm) answers
Steve (Huawei) comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides comments and r01.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r01
Hannu (Nokia) is open to either endorsing the CR or sending LS, but points out that neither r00 nor r01 really solve the problem so more revisions would be needed?
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) agrees with Hannu and proposes to postpone
Steve (Huawei) objects to r00, is ok with r01. Postponing is not acceptable.
Stefan (Ericsson) OK to note the CR
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.27 S2-2202007 CR Approval 23.401 CR3694 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of unecessary LTE-M satellite Indication in S1-AP Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203065 Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) comments and provides r01.
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) replies to Haris (Qualcomm)
Steve (Huawei) thanks Haris
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Haris(Qualcomm) replies
Steve (Huawei) comments
Steve (Huawei) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03, except the spec on the coversheet is wrong (should be 23.401 not 23.501).
Haris(Qualcomm) will correct the coverheet indicated spec to TS 23.401 in final version
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.27 S2-2203065 CR Approval 23.401 CR3694R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): Removal of unecessary LTE-M satellite Indication in S1-AP Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202007r03. Approved Agreed
8.27 S2-2202237 CR Approval 23.401 CR3697 (Rel-17, 'F'): IoT NTN: Correction of last visited TAI requirement Apple Rel-17 Postponed Hannu (Nokia) provides r01.
Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. (re-sending to correct the wrong AI in the previous email)
Robert (Apple) replies to Hannu's (Nokia) comments and provides r02.
Hannu (Nokia) supports r02
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r03
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04
Hannu (Nokia) provides r05
Robert (Apple) responds to Hannu (Nokia).
Chris (Vodafone) provides rev 7.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Robert (Apple) requests to postpone this CR.
Chris (Vodafone) agrees to postpone this CR. We should come up with a common text for 5GC-NR-NTN and EPC-IoT -NTN
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
8.27 S2-2202395 CR Approval 23.401 CR3698 (Rel-17, 'F'): IoT NTN: Alignment of TA handling for moving cells with NR NTN OPPO Rel-17 Approved Agreed
8.28 - - - Rel-17 CAT B/C alignment CR(s) due to the work led by other 3GPP Working Groups - - Docs:=36 -
8.28 S2-2201952 LS In Information LS from RAN WG2: LS out on PEI and UE Subgrouping RAN WG2 (R2-2204240) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202900. Final response in S2-2203252 Replied to
8.28 S2-2202900 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS out on PEI and UE Subgrouping Qualcomm Europe Inc. Sweden Rel-17 Response to S2-2201952. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203252 Qian (Ericsson) provides r01
Miguel (Qualcomm) ok with r01
Qian (Ericsson) asks a further question
Steve (Huawei) comments, provides r02
Steve (Huawei) provides r04
Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Qian, Steve provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qian (Ericsson) supports r04
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203252 LS OUT Approval Reply LS out on PEI and UE Subgrouping SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202900r04. Approved Approved
8.28 S2-2201944 LS In Information LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on LTE User Plane Integrity Protection RAN WG2 (R2-2203663) Rel-17 Noted Tim (Vodafone) believes this LS can be noted by SA2 and treated by SA3.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
8.28 S2-2201947 LS In Action LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection RAN WG2 (R2-2203807) Rel-17 Response drafted in S2-2202658. Final response in S2-2203597 Replied to
8.28 S2-2202658 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection ZTE Rel-17 Response to S2-2201947. r17 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2203597, merging S2-2202228. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r01
alessio(nokia) provides r02
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03
alessio (nokia) cannot agree with r03
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and cannot accept r02
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r04
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r05
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r06
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r07
Haiyang (Huawei) provides response to Peter(Ericsson) and r08
alessio (nokia) provides r09 cannot agree with any other revision.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to r09, instead provides r10
alessio (nokia) objects to r10
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to keep it open and discuss it during CC#2 or CC#3
==== Comments Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r11
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
Tricci So (OPPO) provides r13 for couple editorial changes.
Alessio(nokia) provides r14
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r16 and ask to ignore r15.
Alessio(nokia) provides r17
Jinguo(ZTE) is fine with r17
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments that R17 endanger other WGs to finalize the work in Q2
Revised
8.28 S2-2203597 LS OUT Approval Reply LS on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202658r17 + changes, merging S2-2202228. Approved Approved
8.28 S2-2202052 CR Approval 23.501 CR3586 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling Network Slice Access Stratum groups Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203618 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2706 to use single thread for further discussion.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202053 CR Approval 23.502 CR3422 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling Network Slice Access Stratum groups Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203619 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2711 and use single thread for futher discussion
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202176 CR Approval 23.501 CR3592 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates to support 5G NSWO Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203254 Laurent (Nokia): suggests to merge his own 23.501 CR (2176) into 2677
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202177 CR Approval 23.502 CR3429 (Rel-17, 'F'): Updates to support 5G NSWO Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Noted Apostolis (Lenovo) proposes to Note this CR.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Apostolis (Lenovo) cannot accept r01.
Marco (Huawei) comment.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Apostolis (Lenovo) objects to r00 and r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.28 S2-2202178 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS on 5G NSWO roaming aspects Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203253 Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Marco (Huawei): provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203253 LS OUT Approval LS on 5G NSWO roaming aspects SA WG2 Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202178r02. Approved Approved
8.28 S2-2202223 DISCUSSION Agreement Discussion on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection. Ericsson Noted Noted
8.28 S2-2202224 CR Approval 23.501 CR3317R5 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling slice priority and slice groups for RRM purposes Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of SP-220319. Revised to S2-2203620, merging S2-2202702 and S2-2202225 Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and r01 as per CC#1 working assumption
alessio(Nokia) is ok with this revision r01, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell can be added as supporting company.
Jinguo(ZTE) supports this paper and can be added as supporting company, and provide additional comment
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply
Jinguo(ZTE) corrects the title (which miss an 'S').
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r05
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment that r05 leaves the option for NSAG priorities to the UE implementation, i.e. r06 clarifies that intention but Ericsson got concerns with leaving this to UE implementation.
Jinguo(ZTE) provides r07
Haiyang (Huawei) responds to Peter (Ericsson)
alessio(nokia) can only accept r03
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and cannot accept r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) propose a way forward
Dan(China Mobile) provide r10 and suggest to endorse r10 in this emeeting
Haiyang (Huawei) comments. Suggest to endorse r05.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Haiyang(Huawei) suggests one more EN on Jinguo (ZTE)'s proposal: 'When there is TAC in the NSAG information, whether the priority is valid within a TA or among different TAs (i.e. unique per PLMN/larger area) is FFS'
Revised
8.28 S2-2203620 CR Approval 23.501 CR3317R7 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling slice priority and slice groups for RRM purposes Ericsson, ZTE, AT&T, China Mobile, OPPO Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202224, merging S2-2202702 and S2-2202225. This CR was agreed Agreed
8.28 S2-2202225 CR Approval 23.502 CR3435 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling slice priority and slice groups for RRM purposes Ericsson Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203620 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2711 and use single thread for futher discussion
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202226 CR Approval 23.501 CR3482R2 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling Network Slice Access Stratum groups Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of SP-220317. Merged into S2-2203618 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2706 to use single thread for further discussion.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202227 CR Approval 23.502 CR3334R2 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling Network Slice Acess stratum group Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of SP-220318. Merged into S2-2203619 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2711 and use single thread for futher discussion
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202228 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS on enabling support for Slice Groups and Slice priorities for RAN Slicing Ericsson Rel-17 Merged into S2-2203597 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2658
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202655 DISCUSSION Agreement NSWO and N3GPP access support. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-17 Noted Apostolis (Lenovo) provides comments and does not agree with conclusion #2.
Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version of this Tdoc (to discuss only the CR)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
8.28 S2-2202659 CR Approval 23.501 CR3539R2 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling configuration of Network Slice AS Groups ZTE, China Mobile Rel-17 Revision of SP-220303. Merged into S2-2203618 Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2706 and use single thread for futher discussion
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202676 DISCUSSION Discussion Proposal on slice priority and slice group China Mobile Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.28 S2-2202677 CR Approval 23.501 CR3617 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501: NSWO and N3GPP access support Huawei Rel-17 r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2203254, merging S2-2202176 Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions and proposes changes.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
Haris(Qualcomm) provides r03
Marco (Huawei) answers to Apostolis (Lenovo) .
Marco(Huawei) provides r04
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05
Walter Dees (Philips) agrees with Laurent (Nokia).
Marco (Huawei) comments on SNPN.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r06
Haris(Qualcomm) comments on r06 and suggests to not consider SNPN case in rel.17
Laurent (Nokia): answers
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r07
Laurent (Nokia): provides r08
Marco (huawei) objects to any CR version including support in SNPN in R17
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to R00; order of preference is R08 preferred then R07 then R06
Josep (DT) objects to r08, r07, r06. Shares Marco's (Huawei) and Haris' (Qualcomm) view.
Marco (huawei): objects to r06, r07 r08 for SNPN part. Agreed with r05, however It is ok to add revisions to SBA roaming description of r07 in r05.
Stefan (Ericsson) OK with r05 but there are remaining errors in the SBA figures that were fixed in r07
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203254 CR Approval 23.501 CR3617R1 (Rel-17, 'F'): 23.501: NSWO and N3GPP access support Huawei, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202677r05, merging S2-2202176. Approved Agreed
8.28 S2-2202702 CR Approval 23.501 CR3317R6 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling slice priority and slice groups for RRM purposes Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CMCC, NEC, Verizon UK ltd.,ZTE, InterDigital, Xiaomi, LGE, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2200508. Merged into S2-2203620 Alessio(Nokia) provides r01
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment that RAN is in a better position to know how to limit the number of re-directs which is the main goal.
Jinguo(ZTE) suggests to merge into 2224 and use single thread for futher discussion
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
8.28 S2-2202706 CR Approval 23.501 CR3539R3 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling configuration of Network Slice AS Groups Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CMCC, NEC, Verizon UK ltd, ZTE, InterDigital, Xiaomi, LGE, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2200847. Revised to S2-2203618, merging S2-2202052, S2-2202226 and S2-2202659 Alessio(Nokia) provides r01
Atsushi(NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Jinguo(ZTE) response to Atsushi(NTT DOCOMO)
Atsushi(NTT DOCOMO) response to Jinguo(NTT DOCOMO)
Atsushi(NTT DOCOMO) corrects the comments; it's Jinguo (ZTE) very sorry
Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r03.
Alessio(Nokia) provides r04
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and r05
Alessio(Nokia) provides reply and r06
Haiyang (Huawei) comments on r05/ r06
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions and r07
Haiyang(Huawei) provides r08
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r09
alessio(Nokia) replies to comments by Haiyang (Huawei) on r05/ r06
Alessio(nokia) cannot agree with r08 as, as we already clarifies) the fact a NSAG is unique per PLMN does not eliminate its association to a TA needs to be known unless these are supported in all the cells of the PLMN.
alessio(nokia) cannot agree to r09 as the EN introduces an issue that does not exist if we allow the addition of TAC to NSAG (as this allows including also NSAGs that are reused). It is because of revisions not by source companies that this EN becomes necessary.
Alessio(nokia) can accept r07
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) provides r10
alessio(nokia) provides r11
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to use r11 as basis
Dongeun (Samsung) supports r11 which aligns with the WA at CC#1.
?
Haiyang (Huawei) suggest to add one more EN
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and propose that r11 needs more work, i.e. objects to r11.
alessio(nokia) ok to use r11 as basis but I wonder why from SA2 perspective it would be acceptable to restrict the RA formation to enable cell reselection just to not include a TAC in a configuration passed via NAS, when we already can pass up to 16 TAIs (incl. PLMN Id) in the RA. At least nokia does not like the idea this feature would introduce constraints to RA formation (i.e. potentially make RA smaller than needed).
Alessio(Nokia) accepts ontly to include this EN: 'Editor's Note: TAC information iclusion in in NSAG information depends on enabling TAC advertisement in 38.331 SIB format
alessio (Nokia) considers the objections by erisson not valid and explains why
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to any revision including editor's note. Stage 3 work groups need to be able to finish the work in this quarter.
Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to update the following on top of r11 and approve/technique endorse r11
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia
Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.) objects to r11 and responds to Peter (Ericsson), Alessio (Nokia).
Jinguo(ZTE) asks question to Guillaume (MediaTek Inc.)
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Guillaume
Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with the EN proposed by Alessio(Nokia): 'Editor's Note: TAC information iclusion in in NSAG information depends on enabling TAC advertisement in 38.331 SIB format' with considering the open issue on priority will be added as EN in 2224
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203618 CR Approval 23.501 CR3539R4 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling configuration of Network Slice AS Groups Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CMCC, NEC, Verizon UK ltd, ZTE, InterDigital, Xiaomi, LGE, Samsung, AT&T, Oppo, Huawei Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202706, merging S2-2202052, S2-2202226 and S2-2202659. This CR was agreed Agreed
8.28 S2-2202711 CR Approval 23.502 CR3300R3 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling configuration of Network Slice AS Groups Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CMCC, NEC, Verizon UK ltd.,ZTE, InterDigital, Xiaomi, LGE, Samsung Rel-17 Revision of S2-2200918. Revised to S2-2203619, merging S2-2202053 and S2-2202227 Peter (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Alessio(nokia) replies. and provides r01
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides explanation why Service accept need also the priority information
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) it is not acceptable to have the feature cause more redirections between frequencies than with legacy logic i.e. we object to r01 and r00 as we need the AMF to be able to send the NSAG priorities in the Service Accept.
Alessio(nokia) comments that the AMF may chose to not store the NSAGs for slices it does not support and rely on NSSF to provide the right NSAG configuration for all subscribed slices. this is why the 'GET' operation is needed (to outsource the NSAG configuration to be valid beyond the supported slices by the AMF). we do not see the Service accept need as the NSAG configuration should be from the same AMF as before and for same RA. we do not accept r02 as it seems still not justified and it seems the RAN now reshuffles the priorities of the groups! RAN can still cause stickiness to a band using dedicated signalling per UE.
alessio(nokia) cannot accept the change of slice priorities as by product or dependent variable of RRM as NOKIA has proven the RAN can do RRM as it likes and cause the UE to camp on the band it likes at any time using dedicated signalling irrespective of the group priorities. so we insist on not including the SR aspect as the RAN will decide whether to pin the UE to current band for up to T320.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply that it is not acceptable to suddenly disable the feature just because Nokia proposal does not work
Alessio(nokia) replies to Ericsson
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Jinguo(ZTE) comments and propose a way forward, suggest to technique endorse r01
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and object to approve r01, but conditionally ok to technically endorse the r01 as basis for work at the next meeting.
alessio(Nokia) agrees to proceed with r01 as the service accept proposal by ericsson is new and not enough motivation has been provided given that the RAN can already steer the UE to a certain band using UE specific policies, if so desired, not impacting the NSAG priorities that should be based on service level criteria set by HPLMN.
Alessio(nokia) comments that if there is no agreement then the feature is postponed so Peter Hedman (Ericsson) is asking to postpone the feature if he wants to make the acceptance conditional to adding something people do not agree with as not needed. we should have a working agreement
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments.
Jinguo(ZTE) replies
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203619 CR Approval 23.502 CR3300R4 (Rel-17, 'B'): Enabling configuration of Network Slice AS Groups Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, CMCC, NEC, Verizon UK ltd.,ZTE, InterDigital, Xiaomi, LGE, Samsung, AT&T, Oppo, Huawei Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202711, merging S2-2202053 and S2-2202227. This CR was agreed Agreed
8.28 S2-2202725 DISCUSSION Discussion Discussion on Slice list and priority information for cell reselection. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, InterDigital, NEC Rel-17 Noted Noted
8.28 S2-2202739 CR Approval 23.502 CR3102R3 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF relocation in connected state NEC Rel-17 Revision of S2-2201165. r02 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2203598 (New CR number 3465 allocated as this one was already TSG SA approved). Jinguo(ZTE) propose to note this paper
Fenqin(Huawei) share the view as Jinguo
Jinguo(ZTE) replies to Kundan(NEC)
Alessio(Nokia) requests to just remove the editor's note and approve r01
Kundan(NEC) addresses Jinguo and Fenqin concern.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02
Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with r02
Fenqin (Huawei) is also ok with r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
alessio(Nokia) would suggest to update to r03 in draft folder in CC#2/3 as there is a coversheet error in r02 and also the note can be made a little bit more clear with the addition of an if (as we update the coversheet it is worth it)
Kundan(NEC) is fine with r02. don't think r03 is needed.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
8.28 S2-2203598 CR Approval 23.502 CR3465 (Rel-17, 'F'): AMF relocation in connected state NEC, Nokia; Nokia Shanghai Bell., Ericsson Rel-17 Revision of S2-2202739r02 + changes. Approved Agreed
8.28 S2-2202786 LS In Information LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on User Plane Integrity Protection for eUTRA connected to EPC RAN WG3 (R3-222610) Noted Noted
8.28 S2-2202791 LS In Action LS on 5G NSWO roaming aspects SA WG3 (S3-220446) Rel-17 Postponed Postponed
8.28 S2-2202792 LS In Action LS from SA WG3: Reply LS on LTE User Plane Integrity Protection SA WG3 (S3-220464) Rel-17 Noted Haiyang (Huawei) suggests to note this LS as no action is needed for SA2
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Noted
9 - - - Rel-18 SIDs - - Docs:=0 -
9.1 - - - Study on System Enabler for Service Function Chaining (FS_SFC) - - Docs:=19 -
9.1 - - - General - - Docs:=1 -
9.1 S2-2202651 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Updating Annex A. ETRI Rel-18 Approved Approved
9.1 - - - Key issues - - Docs:=2 -
9.1 S2-2202650 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Updating KIs. ETRI Rel-18 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203433 Megha(Intel) provides comments
Fenqin (Huawei) agree with the view from Intel
Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Huawei and Intel
Yoohwa (ETRI) responds to Megha (Intel)
Megha (Intel) provides r01 and comments
Yoohwa (ETRI) agrees to r01 from Megha.
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02
Laurent (Nokia): provides r03
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions and r04
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version except R03 and R04
Stefan (Ericsson) objects to any revision except r04
Yoohwa (ETRI) is ok with r04.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203433 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Updating KIs. ETRI Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202650r04. Approved Approved
9.1 - - - Solutions - - Docs:=16 -
9.1 S2-2201978 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for Key Issue #1 for Traffic Steering Policy and SFC Enhancements. Ericsson Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203434 Megha (Intel) provides comments
Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r01
Megha (Intel) provides r02 and comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Megha(Intel) is ok with r02, r03
Stefan (Ericsson) cannot accept r02. OK with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203434 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for Key Issue #1 for Traffic Steering Policy and SFC Enhancements. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201978r03. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2201979 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for Key Issue #2 for Exposure to enable AF to request predefined SFC for traffic flow(s) related with target UE(s). Ericsson Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203435 Megha(Intel) asks question for clarification
Fenqin(Huawei) asks one question for clarification
Megha(Intel) provides comments
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Megha and provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Fenqin
Fenqin (Huawei) replies to Stefan
Megha (Intel) provides r02 and comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Megha(Intel) is ok with r02, r03
Stefan (Ericsson) cannot accept r02. OK with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203435 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for Key Issue #2 for Exposure to enable AF to request predefined SFC for traffic flow(s) related with target UE(s). Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201979r03. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202206 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: New Solution: AF influencing Service Function Chaining support by 5GC. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203436 Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Megha(Intel) provides comments and questions for clarification
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments and questions
Megha (Intel) provides more comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02
Stefan (Ericsson) adds one question
Fenqin (Huawei) agree the view on the exposure issue as Stefan mentioned and provides r03
Laurent (Nokia): provides r04
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203436 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: New Solution: AF influencing Service Function Chaining support by 5GC . Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202206r04. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202231 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: KI 1 and KI 2: New Solution for traffic steering control and SFC enhancements. Intel Rel-18 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203437 Laurent (Nokia): Comments/ questions
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments/questions
Fenqin (Huawei) share the similar view.
Megha (Intel) provides r01 and further clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides additional comments
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comment.
Megha(Intel) provides r02 and some further comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r03
Megha (Intel) provides r04 and some comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to R00 + R01 + R02
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203437 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: KI 1 and KI 2: New Solution for traffic steering control and SFC enhancements. Intel Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202231r04. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202319 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI #1: UPF enhancement with SFC capability. ETRI Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203438 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments/questions
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments/questions
Yoohwa (ETRI) provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to R00
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203438 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI #1: UPF enhancement with SFC capability. ETRI Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202319r01. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202336 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI#2: Service Function Chaining exposure. ETRI Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203439 Megha(Intel) provides comments and questions for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): Comments that clarifications are required in the Tdoc
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments/questions
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Jaewook
Jaewook (ETRI) answers to Laurent (Nokia) and ask for clarification
Jaewook (ETRI) answers to Stefan (Ericsson) and ask for clarification
Jaewook (ETRI) answers to Megha(Intel) and ask for clarification
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments/questions
Megha (Intel) responds to Jaewook (ETRI)
Jaewook (ETRI) answer Fenqin (Huawei) and provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to any version BUT as he does not want to block the solution can live with R01 with the addition of an EN just above 6.X.2: EN: the content of the classification rule referred to in Table 6.x.1-4 as well as its usage in 5GC is FFS.
Jaewook (ETRI) to Laurent (Nokia) and all: Jaewook (ETRI) is ok with R01 with the addition of an EN for approval.
Megha(Intel) objects to the r00 (original), ok with r01
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203439 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI#2: Service Function Chaining exposure. ETRI Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202336r01. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202483 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI#2: Enhancing Application Function influence on traffic routing to an N6-LAN based on pre-defined SFC policies. Lenovo Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203440 Megha(Intel) provides comments and proposes merging this document with S2-2202206 (Nokia) and S2-2201979 (Ericsson)
Laurent (Nokia): Comments asking clarifications (changes) within the tdoc
Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 to address comments
Fenqin (Huawei) provides comments
Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Fenqin (Huawei)
Fenqin (Huawei) ask two question.
Megha (Intel) provides some comments
Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 responds to Megha and Fenqin
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03
Stefan (Ericsson) supports adding this EN
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Laurent (Nokia): objects to R00 and R01
Fenqin (Huawei) only accept r03
Megha(Intel) is ok with r03, r04
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203440 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: Solution for KI#2: Enhancing Application Function influence on traffic routing to an N6-LAN based on pre-defined SFC policies. Lenovo Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202483r03. Approved Approved
9.1 S2-2202538 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: KI#1/KI#2, AF request predefined SFC for traffic flow(s) related with target UE(s). Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203441 Fenqin (Huawei) provides responds
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions and comments
Megha (Intel) provides comments
Fenqin (Huawei) provides feedback and provides r01
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02
Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Megha(Intel) is ok with r03
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.1 S2-2203441 P-CR Approval 23.700-18: KI#1/KI#2, AF request predefined SFC for traffic flow(s) related with target UE(s). Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202538r03. Approved Approved
9.2 - - - Study on Generic group management, exposure and communication enhancements (FS_GMEC) - - Docs:=43 -
9.2 - - - Definitions, Architectural assumptions - - Docs:=3 -
9.2 S2-2202521 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Definition and assumption for the group in GMEC study. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Merged into S2-2203255 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01.
Laurent (Nokia): in order to keep a single thread objects to any version of this TDOC (let's discuss only 2836)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) OK for merge with 2836
Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to consider it merged to 2836.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Merged
9.2 S2-2202836 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Adding the group description to the Terms definition. ZTE Rel-18 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203255, merging S2-2202521 Laurent (Nokia): Comments (concern on having 5G group definition, better just have a Note: the solutions for this study will describe what kind of group the solution they are targeting)
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) supports Nokia proposal
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and proposes to use 2521 as the basis
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
zhendong (ZTE) provides r01
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02. objects to R00
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 and comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r04
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Samsung is fine with r05.
Stefan (Ericsson) can only accept r04, objects to other revisions.
Laurent (Nokia): can only live with r04; objects to any other version
Sang-Jun (Samsung) can live with r04.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203255 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Adding the group description to the Terms definition. ZTE, Huawei Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202836r04, merging S2-2202521. Approved Approved
9.2 - - - New KIs - - Docs:=2 -
9.2 S2-2202814 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Key Issue: Efficient N19 tunnel management for VN group communication. China Mobile, China Southern Power Grid Rel-18 Noted Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any version of this Tdoc that goes beyond the scope of the approved SID
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments and wonders whether this can be a update for KI#4
Laurent (Nokia): Comments. but no need to update KI#4
Yue (China Telecom) propose this KI as an update for KI#4.
Qianghua (Huawei) proposes a way forward, provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.2 S2-2202815 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Key Issue: Enhancement on UPF to support diverse terminal access. China Mobile, China Southern Power Grid Rel-18 Noted Laurent (Nokia): Objects to any version of this Tdoc that goes beyond the scope of the approved SID
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Josep (DT) asks question for clarification.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to note the paper.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.2 - - - new Sol, rev Sol, rev KI PCRs for KI#1 - - Docs:=13 -
9.2 S2-2201988 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#1 based on 5G VN group management APIs. Ericsson Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203256 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Sang-Jun
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Qianghua
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Tugce
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203256 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#1 based on 5G VN group management APIs. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201988r01. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2201989 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#1 based on NEF Parameter Provision and Service Parameter services. Ericsson Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203257 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Sang-Jun
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Tugce and Qianghua
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01
Stefan (Ericsson) replies and provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203257 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#1 based on NEF Parameter Provision and Service Parameter services. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201989r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202377 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution on supporting 5G VN group service area with LADN mechanism. China Mobile Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203258 Dan(China Mobile) provides response
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Dan (China Mobile) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203258 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution on supporting 5G VN group service area with LADN mechanism China Mobile Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202377r01. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202522 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Split Sol1 and address the related ENs. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203259 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions/comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responses
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203259 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Split Sol1 and address the related ENs. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202522r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202653 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution on support 5G VN service area restriction with SMF service area. China Mobile Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203260 Dan (China Mobile) provides response.
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Dan(China Mobile) provides r01 to reflect Tugce (NTT DOCOMO)'s comment
Qianghua (Huawei) comments
Dan (China Mobile) reply
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203260 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution on support 5G VN service area restriction with SMF service area . China Mobile Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202653r01. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202961 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Solution to Key Issue #1 of FS_GMEC WT#1.1. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203261 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds and provides r01
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
Shubhranshu (Nokia) responds and provides r03
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04
Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06
Shubhranshu (Nokia) asks for clarification
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r06.
Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine with r06 and r05 and objects to other versions
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203261 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Solution to Key Issue #1 of FS_GMEC WT#1.1. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202961r06. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202578 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update KI#1 with new solution: Support for attribute of maximum number of users for a 5G VN group. China Telecom Rel-18 Noted Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Haoquan(China Telecom) provides example usages.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Stefan (Ericsson) objects to expanding the scope of the KI and thus to this pCR
Qianghua (Huawei) same rules should apply to other PCRs that are expanding the scope, to be fair
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to note the PCR.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.2 - - - new Sol for KI#2 - - Docs:=4 -
9.2 S2-2201990 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#2 on group status event reporting. Ericsson Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203262 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to question and provides r01
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Qianghua
Qianghua (Huawei) replies
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203262 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#2 on group status event reporting. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201990r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202612 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Solution for KI#2: Enhance group status event reporting. NTT DOCOMO Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203263 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) responds.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Qianghua (Huawei).
Qianghua (Huawei) replies and proposes a way forward
Tugce (NTT DOCOMO) agrees to add an EN and provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203263 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New Solution for KI#2: Enhance group status event reporting. NTT DOCOMO Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202612r01. Approved Approved
9.2 - - - rev Sol for KI#3 - - Docs:=3 -
9.2 S2-2202523 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Sol2 update to investigate some specific parameters. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203264 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responses
Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203264 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Sol2 update to investigate some specific parameters. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202523r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202614 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Revision of Solution #2 NEF service for connection management for a group for KI#3. Samsung Rel-18 Postponed Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts Shubhranshu (Nokia) proposal to postpone the PCR so that tne EN will be clarified during next meeting.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
9.2 - - - new Sol, rev Sol, rev KI for KI#4 - - Docs:=12 -
9.2 S2-2201991 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#4 to support multiple SMFs per 5G VN. Ericsson Rel-18 r03 + changes agreed. Revised to S2-2203265 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides replies and r01
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02
Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Qianghua
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04
Qianghua (Huawei) comments
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Qianghua (Huawei) objects to r00, r01, r02, r04. OK with r03
Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to go with r03 and continue discussions next meeting.
Laurent (Nokia): Proposes to go with R04 which is a good compromise.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203265 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution for KI#4 to support multiple SMFs per 5G VN. Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2201991r03 + changes. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202174 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution #3 update. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203266 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r01
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203266 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution #3 update. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202174r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202524 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update Solution 5 to complete the procedure. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203267 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): Comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responses
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 and objects to any previous version
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203267 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update Solution 5 to complete the procedure. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202524r03. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202611 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Revision of Solution #5 Multiple SMFs involved 5G VN group communication for KI#4. Samsung Rel-18 r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2203268 Laurent (Nokia): Comments
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01.
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02. Objects to any previous version (un clear)
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r04.
Stefan (Ericsson) prefers r00/r03/r04
Qianghua (Huawei) prefers r00/r03/r04
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) prefers r04.
Laurent (Nokia): (repats) objects to R00+R01
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203268 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Revision of Solution #5 Multiple SMFs involved 5G VN group communication for KI#4. Samsung Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202611r04. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202837 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: KI#4, update to the sol#4 Multiple SMFs for VN group communication. ZTE Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203269 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): Comments
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 and objects to any previous version
zhendong (ZTE) provides the response
zhendong (ZTE) propvides response
zhendong (ZTE) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203269 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: KI#4, update to the sol#4 Multiple SMFs for VN group communication. ZTE Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202837r02. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202817 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update to Key Issue#4 on session management efficiency of multiple SMFs. China Mobile Com. Corporation, China Southern Power Grid Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203270 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): I don't think we need this update of KI#4
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203270 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update to Key Issue#4 on session management efficiency of multiple SMFs. China Mobile Com. Corporation, China Southern Power Grid Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202817r01. Approved Approved
9.2 - - - new Sol, rev Sol, rev KI for KI#5 - - Docs:=6 -
9.2 S2-2202175 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Solution #6 update. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Approved Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): answers
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) thanks to Laurent (Nokia) for answers and agrees to approve r00.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Approved
9.2 S2-2202525 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution to address key issue 5. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203271 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Laurent (Nokia): Comments
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responses
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 and objects to any previous version
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) supports r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203271 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: New solution to address key issue 5. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202525r03. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202609 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Revision of Solution #7 a PDU Session with multiple groups for KI#5. Samsung Rel-18 r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2203272 Laurent (Nokia): requests to have Mandatory clarifications added
Sang-Jun (Samsung) responses to Laurent (Nokia) and and provides r01.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments
Sang-Jun (Samsung) repies to Qianghua (Huawei).
Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Stefan (Ericsson).
Laurent (Nokia): provides r02, OBJECTS to any previous version
Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03 on top of r02.
Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r05
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts r05.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.2 S2-2203272 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Revision of Solution #7 a PDU Session with multiple groups for KI#5. Samsung Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202609r05. Approved Approved
9.2 S2-2202818 P-CR Approval 23.700-74: Update to Key Issue#5. China Mobile Com. Corporation, China Southern Power Grid Rel-18 This was postponed. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides comments for clarification.
Qianghua (Huawei) supports the updates
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Yi (CMCC) provides r01 in the GMEC draft folder for your information.
Qianghua (Huawei) OK with either r00 or r01
Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01, and asks to add Samsung as co-signer.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Postponed
9.3 - - - Study on Access Traffic Steering, Switching and Splitting support in the 5GS; Phase 3 (FS_ATSSS_Ph3) - - Docs:=30 -
9.3 - - - Solutions for KI#2 - - Docs:=10 -
9.3 S2-2202728 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: New Solution to KI#2: Re-ordering Modes and Features. Deutsche Telekom AG Rel-18 Noted Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions for clarification.
Markus (Deutsche Telekom) reply
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.3 S2-2202734 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update of Solution 3 MP-DCCP-LL based ATSSS steering functionality Deutsche Telekom AG Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203066 Apostolis (Lenovo) suggests changes.
Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01 addressing comments from Apostolis..
Dario (Qualcomm) provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203066 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update of Solution 3 MP-DCCP-LL based ATSSS steering functionality . Deutsche Telekom AG Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202734r03. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202742 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: MPQUIC steering functionality using UDP proxying over HTTP Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, ZTE, Broadcom, Ericsson, LGE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Charter Communications Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203067 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks questions, comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203067 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: MPQUIC steering functionality using UDP proxying over HTTP. Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, ZTE, Broadcom, Ericsson, LGE, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Charter Communications, Apple Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202742r03. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202745 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: MPQUIC steering functionality using IP proxying over HTTP Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203068 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks questions, comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203068 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: MPQUIC steering functionality using IP proxying over HTTP. Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202745r02. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202863 DISCUSSION Agreement Discussion on Key Issue #2: Per-Packet Overhead of QUIC/DCCP-based Steering Functionalities. InterDigital Inc. Rel-18 Noted Noted
9.3 S2-2202866 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: New Solution: Limiting MA-PDU Per-Packet Overhead. InterDigital Inc. Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203069 Apostolis (Lenovo) provides comments and questions.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Apostolis' comments and provides r01.
Dario (Qualcomm) comments and asks questions.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Dario's comments and provides r02.
Rainer (Nokia) comments.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r03.
Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r03.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) is OK with r03 but points out inconsistency to be solved at the next meeting.
Apostolis (Lenovo) is also fine with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203069 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: New Solution: Limiting MA-PDU Per-Packet Overhead. InterDigital Inc. Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202866r03. Approved Approved
9.3 - - - Solutions for KI#3 - - Docs:=10 -
9.3 S2-2202134 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: New solution on redundant traffic steering triggered by AF. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203070 Rainer (Nokia) replies.
Yishan (Huawei) answers to Rainer (Nokia).
Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification.
Dario (Qualcomm) comments.
Yishan (Huawei) answers to Dario (Qualcomm).
Apostolis (Lenovo) comments.
Yishan (Huawei) answers to Apostolis (Lenovo) and provides r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203070 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: New solution on redundant traffic steering triggered by AF. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202134r02. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202551 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update solution for redundancy steering mode. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203071 Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concerns on removing the EN.
Rainer (Nokia) comments.
Myungjune (LGE) comments.
Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r01.
Dario (Qualcomm) comments.
Susan (Huawei) replies and provides r02.
Stefan (Ericsson) provides r03
Susan (Huawei) is ok with r03.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) is OK with r03.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK with r03.
Rainer (Nokia) is also ok with r03.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203071 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update solution for redundancy steering mode. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202551r03. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202583 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for support of redundant traffic steering. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203072 Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and asks for clarification.
Rainer (Nokia) replies to Guanzhou (InterDigital).
Susan (Huawei) provides comments.
Myungjune (LGE) provides comments.
Rainer (Nokia) replies.
Rainer (Nokia) replies to Susan (Huawei).
Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Dario (Qualcomm) comments and asks questions
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r01.
Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203072 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for support of redundant traffic steering. Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202583r03. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202862 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solutions for KI#3 Redundant Traffic Steering Mode. InterDigital Inc. Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203073 Rainer (Nokia) asks for clarification.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Rainer and provides r01.
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Rainer (Nokia) is ok to add the EN.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r02.
Dario (Qualcomm) comments and asks questions.
Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Dario's comments.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Dario (Qualcomm) replies to Guanzhou.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203073 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solutions for KI#3 Redundant Traffic Steering Mode. InterDigital Inc. Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202862r02. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202965 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: KI#3: Solution for redundant steering mode with duplication information and trigger mechanisms. Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203074 Stefan (Ericsson) provides questions
Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments.
Susan (Huawei) provides comments.
Myungjune (LGE) provides comments.
Rainer (Nokia) comments.
Dario (Qualcomm) replies and provides r01.
Rainer (Nokia) replies.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203074 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: KI#3: Solution for redundant steering mode with duplication information and trigger mechanisms. Qualcomm Incorporated Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202965r01. Approved Approved
9.3 - - - Solutions for KI#5 - - Docs:=8 -
9.3 S2-2202133 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for supporting traffic switching between two N3GPP paths. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203075 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Yishan (Huawei) answers to Stefan (Ericsson).
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203075 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for supporting traffic switching between two N3GPP paths. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202133r02. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202275 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: KI #5, New Sol: Delaying UDM Registration until non-3GPP access switching completes. LG Electronics Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203076 Marco (huawei) asks questions
Myungjune (LGE) responds to Marco (Huawei)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203076 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: KI #5, New Sol: Delaying UDM Registration until non-3GPP access switching completes. LG Electronics Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202275r02. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202948 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: KI#5 - Path switching between Non-3GPP accesses. Charter Communications, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, CableLabs, Apple, Comcast Rel-18 r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2203077 DongYeon (Samsung) comments, and provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203077 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution #X: KI#5 - Path switching between Non-3GPP accesses. Charter Communications, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Broadcom, CableLabs, Apple, Comcast Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202948r01. Approved Approved
9.3 S2-2202807 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for KI#5 Switching traffic of an MA PDU Session between two non-3GPP access paths. Samsung Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203078 Marco (Huawei) provides comments and questions.
Myungjune (LGE) comments.
Rainer (Nokia) comments.
DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Marco (Huawei) and Myungjune (LGE), and provides r01.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203078 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Solution for KI#5 Switching traffic of an MA PDU Session between two non-3GPP access paths. Samsung Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202807r03. Approved Approved
9.3 - - - Solutions for KI#6 - - Docs:=2 -
9.3 S2-2202552 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update solution for Multi-access between EPC and 5GC. Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203079 Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions
Myungjune (LGE) comments
Myungjune (LGE) replies to Susan (Huawei)
Susan (Huawei) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Myungjune (LGE), and provides r01.
Stefan (Ericsson) comments
Susan (Huawei) replies.
Susan (Huawei) provides r03.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.3 S2-2203079 P-CR Approval 23.700-53: Update solution for Multi-access between EPC and 5GC . Huawei, HiSilicon Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202552r03. Approved Approved
9.4 - - - Study on enhanced support of Non-Public Networks phase 2 (FS_eNPN_Ph2) - - Docs:=68 -
9.4 - - - General - - Docs:=4 -
9.4 S2-2202581 LS OUT Approval [DRAFT] LS on eNPN Control Plane remote provisioning Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Samsung Rel-18 Noted Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on the SA2's commitment.
Rainer (Nokia) objects to the LS.
Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Saso (Intel) and Rainer (Nokia).
Rainer (Nokia) replies.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and suggestion for way forward.
Qianghua (Huawei) agrees views from Kisuk, and can accept the outgoing LS
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the LS
Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Josep (DT) and Rainer (Nokia).
Kisuk (Samsung) comments
Josep (DT) agrees with Saso's (Intel) and Rainer's (Nokia) view.
Fei (OPPO) comments.
Kisuk (Samsung) provides comment.
Walter Dees (Philips) supports sending the LS.
Huan (vivo) agrees to send out the LS
Kisuk (Samsung) agrees to send out the LS
Saso (Intel) asking for revision.
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the LS again
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Genadi (Lenovo) requests to capture in the minutes the following statement as proposed by the rapporteur 'The reason why CP provisioning could not be part of Rel-17 was that SA3 could not agree on the security functionality. It is up to SA3 whether and how to progress CP provisioning in Rel-18.'
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.4 S2-2202166 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: Terminology and definition for localized service. Ericsson Rel-18 r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2203442 Jianning (Xiaomi) provides comment
Walter Dees (Philips) provides comment.
Antoine (Orange) provides r01.
Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02
Walter (Philips) comments that r02 is empty
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r01 while r02 is empty?
Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r03
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.4 S2-2203442 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: Terminology and definition for localized service. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202166r03. Approved Approved
9.4 S2-2202888 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: FS_eNPN_Ph2: architecture assumption. Xiaomi Rel-18 Noted Pallab (Nokia) comments and questions the need for the pCR
Josep (DT) objects to r00.
Jianning (Xiaomi) response to Peter (Ericsson)
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and wonder if S2-2202642 is enough?
Jianning (Xiaomi) replies to Josep (DT) and Pallab (Nokia)
Antoine (Orange): The proposed addition is not readable and not needed.
Marco (Huawei) share others view that it is not required
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Noted
9.4 - - - New Key issues - - Docs:=3 -
9.4 S2-2202496 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: Key issue #2: Support of Non-3GPP access for SNPN. Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Charter Communications, CableLabs, Intel, Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2203443 Marco (Huawei) comments and provide r01
Josep (DT) is fine with how the note in r03 reads.
Genadi (Lenovo) provides r03.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question
Josep (DT) objects to r01. Provides r02
Marco (Huawei) provide r03 with change in Note 1.
Antoine (Orange) provides r05.
Marco (Huawei) provide r06.
Josep (DT) disagrees with the addition in r06.
Antoine (Orange) provide r07.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Josep (DT) is OK with r07, objects to r06, r04, r01, r00.
Rainer (Nokia) is ok with r07.
Genadi (Lenovo) can live with r07.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r07
Marco (Huawei) for progressing we can accept r07
Yi (China Mobile) provides r08 after revision deadline based on discussions on S2-2202813.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) that r08 is not acceptable without additional explanation
Yi (China Mobile) replies to Haris.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
Saso (Intel) agrees with the Rapporter's proposal for adding a NOTE (but not extending the KI scope); provides comments
Yi (China Mobile) replies.
Saso (Intel) replies to Yi.
Yi (China Mobile) replies to Saso.
Revised
9.4 S2-2203443 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: Key issue #2: Support of Non-3GPP access for SNPN. Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Charter Communications, CableLabs, Intel, Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202496r07. Approved Approved
9.4 S2-2202813 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: KI for simultaneous access to multiple NPNs and services. China Mobile Rel-18 Noted Saso (Intel) comments that the proposed KI is not in the SID scope and proposes to NOTE the document.
Josep (DT) also proposes to NOTE this document.
Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and linkage to the r03 of S2-2202496.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments
Haris(Qualcomm) objects to the pCR
Josep (DT) comments that this new, unrelated KI wold require a re-evaluation & agreement of the TUs stated in the SID (new WT).
Yi (China Mobile) responds.
Antoine (Orange) asks clarification on Yi's proposal.
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Yi (China Mobile) confirms Antoine's understanding is correct.
Josep (DT) is OK to add a NOTE to 2496 but has to object to this pCR (new KI).
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question
Yi (China Mobile) propose to try to add note to 2496 at CC this meeting.
Genadi (Lenovo) proposes slight re-wording to the NOTE to 2496.
Yi (China Mobile) is fine with the rewording.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Haris(Qualcomm) comments
Yi (China Mobile) replies to Haris.
Noted
9.4 - - - Update of Key issues - - Docs:=6 -
9.4 S2-2202642 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: KI#3 updates. Ericsson Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203444 Marco (Huawei) provides r01
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments, ok with r02
Josep (DT) comments, provides r02.
marco (Huawei) ok with r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.4 S2-2203444 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: KI#3 updates. Ericsson Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202642r02. Approved Approved
9.4 S2-2202643 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: KI#4: adding key issue description. Ericsson, InterDigital, Futurewei, Vivo Rel-18 r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2203445 Yishan (Huawei) provides r01
Josep (DT) finds that the changes in r01 make the text less clear.
Yishan (Huawei) answers to Josep (DT)
Josep (DT) replies to Yishan (Huawei).
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and a question
Josep (DT) answers to Yishan (Huawei), provides r02.
Walter Dees (Philips) provides comments and revision r03
Antoine (Orange) objects to r03, OK with r02.
Walter Dees (Philips) comments to Antoine (Orange).
Josep (DT) find the changes in r03 unclear.
Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r04
Walter Dees (Philips) can live with r02.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r05 on changing the note (but not yet checked what r04 changed)
Walter (Philips) provides r06 given that r05 did not include the requested changes by Peter (Ericsson)
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Josep (DT) in Ok with the change in the note in r06.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r06
Yishan (Huawei) is ok with r06 and objects to r03
Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK to r06 AND objects r03.
Ashok (Samsung) comments
Antoine (Orange) is fine with the clarification that Ashok proposes to add.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Josep (DT) asks for clarification.
Ashok (Samsung) is fine Josep (DT)'s suggestion.
Revised
9.4 S2-2203445 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: KI#4: adding key issue description . Ericsson, InterDigital, Futurewei, Vivo Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202643r06. Approved Approved
9.4 S2-2202679 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: FS_eNPN_Ph2 Update of Key Issue #6. Vivo Rel-18 r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2203446 Josep (DT) comments, provides r01.
Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02
Huan (vivo) is OK to r02
==== Revisions Deadline ====
Josep (DT) is also OK with r02.
==== Comments Deadline ====
Revised
9.4 S2-2203446 P-CR Approval 23.700-08: FS_eNPN_Ph2 Update of Key Issue #6. Vivo Rel-18 Revision of S2-2202679r02. Approved Approved
9.4