IPR call reminder:
|
"I draw your attention to your
obligations under the 3GPP Partner Organizations' IPR policies. Every
Individual Member organization is obliged to declare to the Partner
Organization or Organizations of which it is a member any IPR owned by the
Individual Member or any other organization which is or is likely to become
essential to the work of 3GPP. Delegates are asked to take note that they
are thereby invited:
|
Antitrust policy Reminder:
|
"I
also draw your attention to the fact that 3GPP activities are subject to all
applicable antitrust and competition laws and that compliance with said laws
is therefore required of any participant of this TSG/WG meeting including the
Chairman and Vice Chairman. In case of question I recommend that you contact
your legal counsel. The
leadership shall conduct the present meeting with impartiality and in the
interests of 3GPP. Furthermore,
I would like to remind you that timely submission of work items in advance of
TSG/WG meetings is important to allow for full and fair consideration of such
matters." |
| AI | TD# | Type | Doc For | Subject | Source | Rel | Comments | e-mail_Discussion | Result |
| 0 | - | - | - | All Agenda Items | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 1.1 | - | - | - | Opening of the meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 2 | - | - | - | Agenda | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 2 | S2-2004765 | AGENDA | Approval | SA WG2 #140E Meeting Agenda | SA WG2 Chairman | Approved | Approved | ||
| 3 | - | - | - | SA2#139E Meeting report | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 3 | S2-2004766 | REPORT | Approval | Auto-Generated Report of SA WG2 meeting #139E | SA WG2 Secretary | Approved | Approved | ||
| 4 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Common issues and Incoming LSs | - | - | Docs:=75 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Papers with no incoming LS | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005492 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2278R3 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction on Deregistration procedures for SMS over NAS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-15 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006178 Sent back to SA WG2 by TSG SA | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r03. Hannu (Nokia) responds to Hui Ni (Huawei) and provides r04. Nokia can agree either r03 or r04. Hui Ni(Huawei) fine with r04. Hannu (Nokia) supports Hui Ni(Huawei) in proposing r04. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is fine with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006178 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2278R4 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correction on Deregistration procedures for SMS over NAS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-15 | Revision r04 of S2-2005492. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005493 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2368 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction on Deregistration procedures for SMS over NAS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006179 Sent back to SA WG2 by TSG SA | Hui Ni (Huawei) comments whether the version is correct. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Hannu (Nokia) supports revision r01 by Qian, objects to r02 and explains that this Cat A CR should be processed along with the Cat F as the reference text is fundamentally different. Hui Ni (Huawei) fine with r01. Hannu replies to Hui Ni (Huawei) and proposes to go ahead with r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006179 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2368R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correction on Deregistration procedures for SMS over NAS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005493. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005746 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2391 (Rel-16, 'F'): Fixing Redirection for EPS Fallback indication | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Verizon, Samsung | Rel-16 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2005822 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2400 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to MME Emergency Configuration Data for enable the selection of diffrent emergency gateways based on UE capabilities | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | LSs for information | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004769 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG5: Reply LS on analytics support for energy saving | SA WG5 (S5-201472) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2003532 from S2#139E. Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia propose to note this LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004781 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG1: reply LS on GSMA NG.116 Attribute Area of service and impact on PLMN | SA WG1 (S1-202294) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004323 from S2#139E. Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004789 | LS In | Information | LS from GSMA 5GJA: LS on NG.116 support of different access types | GSMA 5GJA (5GJA13_117r4) | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004790 | LS In | Information | LS from ETSI ISG ENI: Proposed Liaison to 3GPP SA2/SA5 on mapping between ENI architecture and NWDAF/MDAF | ETSI ISG ENI (ENI(20)014_022r1) | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia propose to note this LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004791 | LS In | Information | LS from ETSI ISG ETI: Announcement of ISG ETI | ETSI ISG ETI (ETI(20)000009r1) | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004799 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG3: Reply LS on PAP/CHAP and other point-to-point protocols usage in 5GS | CT WG3 (C3-203609) | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004811 | LS In | Information | LS from SA WG5: Reply LS to Reply LS on support for eCall over NR | SA WG5 (S5-203369) | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004788 | LS In | Information | LS from 5G-ACIA (5G Alliance for Connected Industries and Automation): 5G capabilities exposure for factories of the future | 5G-ACIA (5G-ACIA_ LS_3GPP_Exposure_29062020) | Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) asks to keep this LS open. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone the LS given that no actionable papers have been submitted (only a discussion paper) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to note the LS. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) supports to postpone the LS. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone the LS. Samsung (Samsung) supports to postpone the LS, and provides comments to Qianghua (Huawei). Qianghua (Huawei) responds ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005616 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Work analytics on 5G capabilities for factories of the future requested by 5G-ACIA. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) disagrees with the proposal for release 17 in this paper and proposes to note it. Qianghua (Huawei) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) suggests marking the S2-2005616 'postponed' ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004814 | LS In | Information | LS from TSG SA: LS on HO to congested cells | TSG SA (SP-200631) | Rel-17 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to note the LS as SA2 is anyhow to receive an input from RAN3 before doing anything Jean Yves (Thales) propose to withdrawn this LS out to CT4 as CT4 chairman confirmed that stage 2 is mandatory first, even in this case. Laurent (Nokia): asks Jean-Yves to clarify his comment, was it really addressing this Tdoc Andy (Convenor): Jean-Yves comment was intended for a different LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005087 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on support of eCall over NR | CT WG1 (C1-203221) | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005088 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on Updated User Plane Integrity Protection advice | CT WG1 (C1-204194) | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | LSs for action, but no input in this meeting | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004767 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on analysis of GSMA GST attributes | SA WG5 (S5-197853) | Revision of postponed S2-2003518 from S2#139E. Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004770 | LS In | Action | LS from GSMA 5GJA: LS reply to SA WG2 on PLMN Selection | GSMA 5GJA (5GJA12_115r3) | Revision of postponed S2-2003533 from S2#139E. Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004771 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3LI: LS on Location information for SMS over IMS | SA WG3LI (S3i200161) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2003551 from S2#139E. Postponed | Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to postpone this LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004774 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on SIB indication for UE specific DRX | RAN WG2 (R2-2004057) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2003561 from S2#139E. Noted | = Haris (Qualcomm) indicates LS should be noted ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004777 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on CMAS/ETWS and emergency services for SNPNs | SA WG1 (S1-202220) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004315 from S2#139E. Noted | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provide comments and proposes to note the LS. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to Note the LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004778 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: LS on 5GC assisted cell selection for accessing network slice | SA WG1 (S1-202264) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004316 from S2#139E. Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004780 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: Reply to LS on Clarification of the definition of a UAS | SA WG1 (S1-202267) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004319 from S2#139E. Noted | Stefano (Faccin) proposes to note since the corresponding SA1 CR was objected in SA plenary, thus the LS has no meaning. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004785 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on network data analysis energy saving | SA WG5 (S5-203360) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004631 from S2#139E. Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia propose to postpone this LS. Ulf (Ericsson) agree with Nokia to not handle this LS in this meeting ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004787 | LS In | Information | LS from IETF DRIP: Scope and goals of the Drone Remote ID Protocol Working Group (DRIP) of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) | IETF DRIP (LSs_from_IETF_9June2020) | Revision of postponed S2-2004636 from S2#139E. Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) Qualcomm suggests to note the LS since it has no actions for SA2. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004798 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on maximum number of UP resources supported by NB-N1 mode UEs | CT WG1 (C1-204083) | Rel-16 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004805 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS reply on RACS multiple radio capability formats | RAN WG3 (R3-204147) | Rel-16 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to note this LS Wanqiang (Huawei) OK to note this LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004810 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3LI: Additional Clarifications on LI requirements applicable to SNPNs | SA WG3LI (S3i200409) | Rel-16 | Postponed | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone the LS as there is no actionable paper/CR to address this LS during this meeting. Please assign this LS to 7.7.3 for next meeting. Marco (huawei) postpone the LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004812 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on SA5 Rel-17 work on SLA | SA WG5 (S5-203370) | Rel-17 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2005875 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | RAN WG3 (R3-205653) | Rel-16 | Noted | Andy (Convenor) suggests we note this LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note this LS as we have no actual action in the short term ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | AS rekeying | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004772 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on AS rekeying handling | RAN WG3 (R3-202833) | Rel-15 | Revision of postponed S2-2003557 from S2#139E. Responses drafted in S2-2005233 and S2-2005406. CC#2: Final response in S2-2005909 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2005233 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on AS rekeying handling | CATT | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2004772. Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to note this LS response and move forward with S2-2005406 and revisions ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005231 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2354 (Rel-15, 'F'): Removal of sending AS key | CATT | Rel-15 | Noted | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to note this CR (original or r01) Hucheng(CATT) clarifies and comments Jungshin (Samsung) requests clarification Laurent (Nokia): provides r02 and r03 and comments Jungshin (Samsung): can accept r01 and r02. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r04. Haris (Qualcomm) comments that none of the revisions are acceptable Hucheng(CATT) clarifies why the CR is needed. Hucheng(CATT) replies to Qualcomm ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005232 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2355 (Rel-16, 'A'): Removal of sending security key | CATT | Rel-16 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the CR ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005406 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on AS rekeying handling | Huawei | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004772. CC#2: S2 200540r01 was agreed. Revised in S2-2005909. | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01 Hucheng (CATT) provides r02.. Laurent (Nokia) provides r03.. Hucheng(CATT) agree with Nokia. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r04. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comment and is ok with r04. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00. LiMeng (Huawei) objects to r02 and r03. Hucheng (CATT) agrees with Ericsson and can only accepts r02, r03 or 04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2005909 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on AS rekeying handling | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005406. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005407 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2419 (Rel-15, 'F'): Clarification on concurrency of AS rekeying handling and Emergency Fallback procedure for R15 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-15 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 4.1 | S2-2005408 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2420 (Rel-16, 'A'): Clarification on concurrency of AS rekeying handling and Emergency Fallback procedure for R16 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | UPIP | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004776 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG3: LS on Updated User Plane Integrity Protection advice | SA WG3 (S3-201487) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004308 from S2#139E. Response drafted in S2-2005688. Final response in S2-2006180 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2005688 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Updated User Plane Integrity Protection advice | Samsung R&D Institute India | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004776. Revised to S2-2006180. | Laurent (Nokia): proposes to Note S2-2005688 (objects to it) and to only consider one LS out for this User Plane Integrity Protection issue: 4945 Lalith (Samsung) requests for justification Laurent (Nokia) answers and provides r01 Lalith (Samsung) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia) comments that he very much prefers r01 Hui Ni (Huawei) prefers r01 Chunhui Zhu(Spreadtrum) prefers r01. Saso (Intel) prefers r01 Haris (Qualcomm) provides r03 Laurent (Nokia) answers and provides r04; I can live with r01 or r04 Lalith (Samsung) supports r04 or r03. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00, r02 and r03; prefers r01, can live with r04 Lalith (Samsung) objects to r01 and OK with r03, r04 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Chunhui Zhu(Spreadtrum) objects to r02 and r03; prefers r01, can live with r04 ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006180 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Updated User Plane Integrity Protection advice | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005688. CC#2: Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004813 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG SA: LS on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | TSG SA (SP-200617) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2004945. Final response in S2-2006181 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2004945 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004813. Agreed. Revised to S2-2006181. | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006181 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on mandatory support of full rate user plane integrity protection for 5G | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2004945. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004943 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2400 (Rel-16, 'C'): UE user plane integrity protection mandatory at full rate | Qualcomm Incorporated, MediaTek, Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom, Orange | Rel-16 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006182 | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and r01. Haris (Qualcomm) comments that r01 is not correct Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02 to clarify UPIP is only applied NR. Wanqiang (Huawei) provides r03 and cosign the paper. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks question for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) replies Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) Laurent (nokia) provides r04 Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) objects to r04. Laurent (nokia) answers Chris (Vodafone) comments that this CR shall not make UPIP deployment more difficult and provides r5. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r05 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r06. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments Laurent (nokia) provides r07 Saso (Intel) comments Chris (Vodafone) provides rev 8 Guillaume (MediaTek) comments. Haris(Qualcomm) comments Wanqiang(Huawei) comments and ok with r07 and r08 Antoine (Orange) comments. Haris (Qualcomm) prefers r07 Qian Chen (Ericsson) agress with Qualcomm and supports r07 Laurent (Nokia) agrees with Ericsson and Qualcomm and supports r07 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) prefers r08 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006182 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2400R1 (Rel-16, 'C'): UE user plane integrity protection mandatory at full rate | Qualcomm Incorporated, MediaTek, Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom, Orange, OPPO, Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r07 of S2-2004943. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004944 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2341 (Rel-16, 'F'): UE user plane integrity protection mandatory at full rate | Qualcomm Incorporated, MediaTek, Ericsson, Deutsche Telekom, Orange | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | GPSI translation | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | 'Any PLMN' requirement | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004796 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on mandate to provide any PLMN entry in the non-3GPP access node selection information | CT WG1 (C1-204034) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2004948. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.1 | S2-2004946 | CR | Agreement | 23.501 CR2401 (Rel-15, 'F'): Correcting preventing of home routing due to 'any PLMN' requirement | BlackBerry UK Ltd. | Rel-15 | Noted | Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to note the Rel-15 CR Stefano (Qualcomm) Qualcomm objects to S2-2004946. John-Luc (BlackBerry) replies to Qualcomm's and Samsung's concerns. SA2 ought to confirm that if 'Any_PLMN' is missing in the Non-3GPP access node (N3AN) selection information yet HPLMN information is present in the N3AN selection information, the UE can use the HPLMN information when performing home routing. Stefano (Qualcomm) Qualcomm replies to the comments and maintains the objection to S2-2004946. John-Luc (BlackBerry) clarifies that the 'UE policy delivery service' (UPDS) is not based on OMA DM. John-Luc (BlackBerry) offers to note the Rel-15 CR. We wish to continue working on a solution in a later release. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004947 | CR | Agreement | 23.501 CR2402 (Rel-16, 'A'): Correcting preventing of home routing due to 'any PLMN' requirement | BlackBerry UK Ltd. | Rel-16 | Noted | Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comment. Stefano (Qualcomm) Qualcomm objects to S2-2004947. John-Luc (BlackBerry) provides a revision (r01). The revision is a Cat F CR against Rel-16. Stefano (Qualcomm) reconfirms Qualcomm objection for 4947, due to the CRs already approved in CT1 and the fact that CT1 is only asking why we have a mandatory 'Any PLMN', and not asking to make it optional. Alex (Rogers Communications) comments on Qualcomm objection to CR in 4947. Chris Joul (T-Mobile) Comments on CR and proposes postponing the matter. Sangsoo (Samsung) also propose to note or postpone this CR John-Luc (BlackBerry) would like the CR and LS to be postponed if they cannot be agreed. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) is fine to postpone this CR. The LS in 4948 would then be postponed as well, right? ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Alex (Rogers Communications) is fine to postpone this CR and the related LS in 4948. Some closing (for now) comments are provided. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004948 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response to LS on the mandate to provide 'any PLMN' entry in the non-3GPP access node selection information | BlackBerry UK Limited | Response to S2-2004796. Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) recommends just replying to the incoming LS with an explanation of why the 'Any_PLMN' was made mandatory. Stefano (Qualcomm) clarifies the LS in its current form is not acceptable (we object to it) because it refers to CRs that have been objected. John-Luc (BlackBerry) provides a revision (r01). Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) If CR in 4947 will be postponed this LS will be as well, right? Stefano (Qualcomm) we can accept postponing the LS reply, and cannot accept any revisions at this meeting as indicated previously. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | UE reachability event | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004801 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarifications on UE Reachability event | CT WG4 (C4-203425) | Rel-15 | Response drafted in S2-2004899. Final response in S2-2006183 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 4.1 | S2-2004899 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on 'LS on Clarifications on UE Reachability event' | Ericsson | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2004801. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006183 | Fenqin (Huawei) comment . Judy (Ericsson) responds and asks question. Fenqin(Huawei) responds. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Fenqin(Huawei). Hannu (Nokia) proposes a revision via referencing to the notification event criteria that is specific in TS 23.502. Fenqin (Huawei) proposes r03 . Leo (Deutsche Telekom) proposes r02 . Fenqin (Huawei) proposes r04 . Leo (Deutsche Telekom) is fine with the changes made in r04 and proposes to agree r04 . Judy (Ericsson) is also fine with r04 . ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006183 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on 'LS on Clarifications on UE Reachability event' | SA WG2 | Rel-15 | Revision r04 of S2-2004899. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004900 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2335 (Rel-15, 'F'): SMF aware of UE Reachability after N1N2MessageTransfer error due to UE unreachable | Ericsson | Rel-15 | Agreed. Revised to S2-2006184. | Judy (Ericsson) provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006184 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2335R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): SMF aware of UE Reachability after N1N2MessageTransfer error due to UE unreachable | Ericsson | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2004900. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004901 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2336 (Rel-16, 'A'): SMF aware of UE Reachability after N1N2MessageTransfer error due to UE unreachable | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Agreed. Revised to S2-2006185. | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 on this mirror CR to align with the corresponding Rel-15 Cat F CR. Andy (Convenor) says can wait for agreed Rel-15 CR and then generate updated mirror. Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Andy (Convenor) that further revisions of mirror CRs can be done later. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006185 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2336R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): SMF aware of UE Reachability after N1N2MessageTransfer error due to UE unreachable | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2004901. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005381 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2359 (Rel-16, 'F'): UE Reachability event clarification | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006186 | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments Hannu (Nokia) proposes to merge the Huawei CR S2-2005381 to the NTT Docomo CR S2-2005547 and move forward with the NTT DoCoMo CRs on Rel-15 and Rel-16. Fenqin(Huawei) agree to merge this paper with S2-2005547. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | S2-2005544 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2378 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on UE reachability event | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-15 | r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005381, to S2-2006186 | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Judy (Ericsson) provides r02. Atsushi (NTT DOCOMO) agrees to r02 and understands r01 is not ok. Hannu (Nokia) provides revision and asks questions on possible further revision? Judy (Ericsson) provides r04. Judy (Ericsson) provides r06. Hannu (Nokia) provides r07 and comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r08. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Hannu (Nokia) and prefers r06. Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r09 Hannu (Nokia) replies to Judy (Ericsson). Judy (Ericsson) is fine with r09. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006186 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2378R1 (Rel-15, 'F'): Stage 3 alignment on UE reachability event | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei | Rel-15 | Revision r09 of S2-2005544, merging S2-2005381. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005547 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2380 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on UE reachability event | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006187 | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) provides r01 Andy (Convenor) asks for clarification on way forward Atsushi (NTT Docomo) agrees Andy (Convenor). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006187 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2380R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Stage 3 alignment on UE reachability event | NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Huawei | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005547 (mirror to S2-2006186). Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | End Marker | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2004768 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on End Marker Indication | CT WG4 (C4-201165) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2003529 from S2#139E. Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2004844 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2330 (Rel-16, 'F'): Remove un-necessary End Marker Indication in invocations of Nsmf_PDUSession_Update Request (missing part) | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005196, to S2-2006188 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006188 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2330R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Remove un-necessary End Marker Indication in invocations of Nsmf_PDUSession_Update Request (missing part) | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2004844, merging S2-2005196. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005196 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2353 (Rel-16, 'F'): Remove End Marker Indication in N16/N16a | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006188 | Dan(China Mobile): this paper is merged into S2-2004844 Laurent (Nokia): 'objects' and suggest to merge within 4844 on the same topic (that has one more change) in order to have a single CR (and not 3) to discuss the same topic. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 4.1 | S2-2005385 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2361 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on End marker | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006189 | Laurent (Nokia): 'objects' and suggest to merge within 4844 on the same topic in order to have a single CR (and not 3) to discuss the same topic Fenqin(Huawei) comments and upload r01 version. Laurent (Nokia) comments. Fenqin(Huawei) responds and upload r02. Fenqin(Huawei) upload r03. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04. Fenqin(Huawei) agree to go r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006189 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2361R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on End marker | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005385. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.1 | - | - | - | Others | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 4.1 | S2-2005050 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG CT: Reply LS on S1/NG DAPS handover | TSG CT (CP-201312) | Rel-16 | Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to note this LS Laurent (nokia) proposes also to note this LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.1 | S2-2005480 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2367 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections on DAPS HO Procedure | Samsung | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 4.1 | S2-2005702 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2442 (Rel-16, 'F'): Support for DTLS | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Confirm Spec version used - CR states 16.7.0! r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006190. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 that corrects coversheet errors and adds cosigning companies Lalith (Samsung) provides r02 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r03 Laurent (Nokia) indicates the full mail thread is wrong as AI should have been 4.1; can live with r01, r02 or r03 (with small revisions) Haris (Qualcomm) suggest to approve r03 with the editorial change suggested by Laurent (delete 'is') and the updated coversheet from r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) supports QC's suggestion. Chris (Vodafone) supports QC's suggestion. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.1 | S2-2006190 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2442R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Support for DTLS | Qualcomm Incorporated, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005702. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | - | - | - | Late incoming LS and pending issues | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 4.2 | - | - | - | Late Incoming LSs | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 4.2 | S2-2006778 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on early UE capability retrieval for eMTC | RAN WG2 (R2-2008238) | Rel-16 | Postponed | Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to POSTPONE the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.2 | S2-2005876 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on dynamic 5QIs | SA WG5 (S5-204443) | Rel-16 | CC#3: Response drafted in S2-2005920. Postponed | Andy (Convenor) suggests we postpone this LS. Saso (Intel) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.2 | S2-2005920 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on dynamic 5QIs | Intel | - | Generated during CC#3. Response to S2-2005876. Postponed | Saso (Intel) provides LS reply to SA5 as discussed on CC#3 earlier today. Susan (Huawei) provides comments and propose to postpone this LS. Saso (Intel) is ok to postpone the LS reply. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.2 | - | - | - | Pending Issues | - | - | Docs:=17 | - | |
| 4.2 | S2-2004784 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG6: LS on IP address to GPSI translation | SA WG6 (S6-200947) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004338 from S2#139E. Responses drafted in S2-2004845 and S2-2005255. Final response in S2-2005923 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 4.2 | S2-2004845 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on IP address to GPSI translation | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2004784. r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005255, to S2-2005923. | Dan(China Mobile): we object the LS and let's provide the response to SA6 for further clarification Hui Ni (Huawei): proposes to note this LS reply or consider it merged into S2-2005255. Laurent (Nokia) proposes a revision r01 Saso (Intel) comments and proposes a way forward. Josep (DT) asks a question regarding Q2 for the public IP case Laurent (Nokia) proposes a revision r02, comments and asks this topic to be handled at CC#2 Saso (Intel) proposes r03. Dan (China Mobile) proposes this LS merged into S2-2005255, or we discuss the two LSs together in CC#2 Hui (Huawei) supports to merge the LS into S2-2005255. Laurent (Nokia) comments. Laurent (Nokia) proposes r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia) proposes r05. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r06. Patrice (Huawei) provides r07, has an issue with r06. Mike (Convida) provides r08 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r09. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2005923 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on IP address to GPSI translation | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r09 of S2-2004845., merging S2-2005255. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2004841 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2385 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hui Ni (Huawei): propose to note or postpone the solution. Dan(China Mobile): we object the CR and suggest to send LS to SA6 for clarification Josep (DT) comments on the solution and proposes a way forward with r01. Laurent (Nokia) comments. Dan (China Mobile) object the CR and revisions, and let's postpond this Laurent (Nokia) proposes a revision r02 Laurent (Nokia): answers to comments and asks Dan and Ni Hui whether they object to the version without GPSI reporting and if yes why. Dan(China Mobile) answers Laurent's question and still suggest to postpond Laurent(Nokai) answers to Dan Dan(China Mobile) answers to Laurent Laurent (Nokia) answers to Dan Hui Ni (Huawei) comments and asks for postpone the discussion. Dan (China Mobile) answers to Laurent Josep (DT) replies to Lauren't comment. Laurent (Nokia) comments and asks this topic to be handled at CC#2 Andy (Convenor) asks whether the topic does need to be handled in CC#2 Laurenbt (Nokia) indicates this topic needs to be handled in CC#2 Saso (Intel) support's Laurent (Nokia) proposal that this topic needs to be handled in CC#2 Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to postpone the CR Laurent (Nokia) eagerly accepts to postpone the CR and the .502 CR assuming we decide during CC2 on how to progress the issue. The LS is already along these lines ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 4.2 | S2-2004842 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2329 (Rel-17, 'B'): Support of the mapping from IP addressing information provided to an AF to the user identity | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni(Huawei): objects the CR due to same reason on S2-2004841. Dan(China Mobile): we object the 502 CR and suggest let's firstly focus on the related 501 paper. Laurent (Nokia) proposes a revision r02 (sorry I skipped number r01) Laurent (Nokia): asks Dan and Ni Hui whether they object to the version without GPSI reporting and if yes why. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.2 | S2-2005255 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on IP address to GPSI translation | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2004784 Merged into S2-2005923 | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r01. Dan (China Mobile) provides r02 and suggest this LS also discuss on CC#2 if we can not let the 4845 merge into this one ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Dan (China Mobile) this paper is merged into S2-2004845 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 4.2 | S2-2005499 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3611 (Rel-16, 'F'): Further corrections to SGC handling | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005924. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Haris (Qualcomm) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2005924 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3611R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Further corrections to SGC handling | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005499. Approved | Agreed | |
| 4.2 | S2-2004803 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Bulk operation of LCS-service | CT WG4 (C4-203629) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2004897, S2-2005039 and S2-2005676. Final response in S2-2005921 | Replied to | |
| 4.2 | S2-2005039 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on Bulk operation of LCS-service | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004803. Merged into S2-2005921 | Åke Busin (Ericsson) Objects to S2-2005039 Pallab (Nokia) provides clarification to Åke Busin (Ericsson) Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r01. Runze (Huawei) provides comments on r01. Pallab (Nokia) provides clarification to Runze (Huawei). Runze (Huawei) responds to Pallab (Nokia). Åke Busin (Ericsson) propose to merge to S2-2004897 Runze (Huawei) supports to merge this paper to S2-2004897 | Merged |
| 4.2 | S2-2005676 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Bulk operation of LCS-service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004803. Merged into S2-2005921 | Åke Busin (Ericsson) Objects to S2-2005676 Runze (Huawei) disagrees to reasons for objection Ming ( CATT) comments. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides comments. Runze (Huawei) response to Ming. Runze ( Huawei) responds to Sherry. Åke Busin (Ericsson) propose to merge to S2-2004897 Runze (Huawei) agreed to merge this paper to S2-2004897 | Merged |
| 4.2 | S2-2004897 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response on Bulk operation of LCS-service | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004803. CC#3: S2 2004897R04 was reviewed and agreed. This was revised to clean up, merging S2-2005039 and S2-2005676, in S2-2005921 | Runze (Huewei) objects to this paper. Åke Busin (Ericsson ) provides r01 Runze (Huawei) provides r02 Pallab (Nokia) provides r04 Åke Busin (Ericsson ) agrees to r04 Sherry (Xiaomi) agrees to r04. Runze (Huawei ) agrees to r04 Åke Busin (Ericsson ) agrees to r04 and notifies on agreement tagged AI#7.6 Ming Ai (CATT) agrees to r04. | Revised |
| 4.2 | S2-2005921 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Response on Bulk operation of LCS-service | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision R04 of S2-2004897, merging S2-2005039 and S2-2005676. Approved | Approved | |
| 4.2 | S2-2005917 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on 5G RG that support MA PDU Session | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Generated during CC#3. Approved | Laurent (Nokia): provides r00 | Approved |
| 4.2 | S2-2004792 | LS In | Information | LS from BBF: Uniqueness of FN-RG PEI for Lawful Interception purposes | BBF (LIAISE-407-02) | Missing from Chairmans Notes. CC#4: This LS was noted. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 4.2 | S2-2004795 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG1: Reply LS on the applicability of 5G NAS protocol for 5G-RG and FN-RG (LIAISE-397) | CT WG1 (C1-203949) | Rel-16 | Missing from Chairmans Notes. CC#4: This LS was noted. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 4.2 | S2-2006779 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS on New function for Network Slice PA and Management Charging | SA WG5 (S5-204593) | Rel-16 | CC#4: This LS was missing from Chairman's notes and was postponed. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 5 | - | - | - | Pre-Rel-17 Maintenance (excluding all 5G topics) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.1 | - | - | - | 3GPP Packet Access Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=23 | - | |
| 5.1 | S2-2004783 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS | RAN WG2 (R2-2005939) | Rel-15 | Revision of postponed S2-2004337 from S2#139E. Response drafted in S2-2005078. Final response in S2-2006499 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 5.1 | S2-2004807 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS | RAN WG3 (R3-204175) | Rel-15 | Response drafted in S2-2005078. Final response in S2-2006499 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 5.1 | S2-2005078 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS | Qualcomm Korea | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2004783 and S2-2004807. CC#2: A revision was allocated for this to clean up the LS in S2-2006499 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 5.1 | S2-2006499 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on assistance indication for WUS | SA WG2 | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2004783 and S2-2004807. Revision of S2-2005078. Approved | Approved | |
| 5.1 | S2-2005090 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on system support for WUS | RAN WG2 (R2-2005985) | Rel-15 | Responses drafted in S2-2005516 and S2-2005783. Final response in S2-2006478 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 5.1 | S2-2005516 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on system support for WUS | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2005090 Merged into S2-2006478 | Jinguo (ZTE) comment and objection Miguel (Qualcomm) proposes to note and continue discussion in S2-2005783 Hannu (Nokia) supports Miguel (Qualcomm) to address this topic via revision of S2-2005783 Steve (Huawei) lets mark this as merged (if you can for LS) into S2-2005783/noted (if you can't). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 5.1 | S2-2005783 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on system support for WUS | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-15 | Response to S2-2005090. r11 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005516, to S2-2006478. | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Jinguo (ZTE) comment and objection Steve (Huawei) provides r02 Jinguo (ZTE) comment and objection for current version. Qian Chen (Ericsson) asks questions to HW and ZTE. Steve (Huawei) comments on data loss Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) responds to Jinguo Jinguo(ZTE) responds to Miguel Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Jinguo Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r03 Jinguo (ZTE) response to Miguel and provides r04 Hannu (Nokia) provides r05 and comments. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r06 Hannu (Nokia) comments on r06 Steve (Huawei) provides r07 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) supports r07 Jinguo (ZTE) provides r08. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r09. Steve (Huawei) provides r09. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r10. Hannu asks a question on the action to RAN2 and RAN3 in r10. Steve (Huawei) provides r11....to clarify aspects of the option discussed and actions. Miguel (Qualcomm) can live with r11 Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r11. Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with r11. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 5.1 | S2-2006478 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on system support for WUS | SA WG2 | Rel-15 | Revision r11 of S2-2005783, merging S2-2005516. Approved | Approved | |
| 5.1 | S2-2004924 | CR | Approval | 23.214 CR0075 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to CUPS Session/Bearer deactivation procedures | Ericsson, AT&T, T-Mobile USA | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006479 | Runze (Huawei ) provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) asks a question on r01. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Hannu Gerald (Matrixx) with comment. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) thanks Stefan (Ericsson) for answers and clarifies the collision case. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 5.1 | S2-2006479 | CR | Approval | 23.214 CR0075R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to CUPS Session/Bearer deactivation procedures | Ericsson, AT&T, T-Mobile USA | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2004924. Approved | Agreed | |
| 5.1 | S2-2005067 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3606 (Rel-15, 'F'): Providing Recommended Cells for Paging information by WUS-capable eNBs for all UEs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-15 | Approved | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with r01; prefers original Steve (Huawei) disagrees with r01. Jinguo (ZTE) OK with original version. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005074 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3607 (Rel-16, 'A'): Providing Recommended Cells for Paging information by WUS-capable eNBs for all UEs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Approved | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with r01; prefers original Jinguo(ZTE) is ok with original version. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005128 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3608 (Rel-15, 'F'): System support for Wake Up Signal Update | Ericsson | Rel-15 | Covered by S2-2005067 (approved) | Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to merge with 5067 Qian Chen (Ericsson) agrees to merge this CR into 5067 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 5.1 | S2-2005129 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3609 (Rel-16, 'A'): System support for Wake Up Signal Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Covered by S2-2005074 (approved) | Jinguo (ZTE) suggest to merge with 5074 Qian Chen (Ericsson) agrees to merge this CR into 5074 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 5.1 | S2-2005130 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0471 (Rel-16, 'F'): MTC provider information for network parameter configuration | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005498 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3610 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to Initial Attach for PARLOS | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-16 | Approved | George (Ericsson) objects because the CR is not FASMO, and indeed the text before the added Note says exactly the same thing as the Note. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to George (Ericsson). Thomas (Nokia) provides rev1.. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Thomas George (Ericsson) provide a reply Thomas (Nokia) replies to Guillaume Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Thomas. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to the CR. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Dieter. Thomas (Nokia) provide a reply Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Thomas (Nokia) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) withdraws objection to the CR. George (Ericsson) accepts r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Tao (Chair) can we go with the r00 then? ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005546 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2379 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback with emergency service | Samsung | Rel-16 | WI Code shuould be 5GS_Ph1. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005548 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2381 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on EPS fallback for voice service quality | Samsung | Rel-16 | WI Code shuould be 5GS_Ph1. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005596 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2384 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update Nudm_UECM_Get service operation | CATT | Rel-16 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005600 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3612 (Rel-15, 'F'): Clarification on Paging retransmission for WUS capable UE | ZTE | Rel-15 | Noted | Steve (Huawei) We should note this approach and ask RAN to resolve this. Jinguo (ZTE) response to Steve(Huawei) Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes to note this CR and provides justification Jinguo(ZTE) response to Miguel and provide r01 Jinguo(ZTE) provide r02 Steve (Huawei) this CR should be noted. Jinguo (ZTE) ask clarification Miguel (Qualcomm) objects to this CR Steve (Huawei) still thinks noting is right. No version is acceptable. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) shares the view of Steve (Huawei) and Miguel (Qualcomm). ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 5.1 | S2-2005601 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3613 (Rel-16, 'A'): Clarification on Paging retransmission for WUS capable UE | ZTE | Rel-16 | Noted | Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) proposes to note this Category 'A' CR (justification in thread for the corresponding Rel-15 cat 'F' CR S2-2005600) Jinguo (ZTE) OK to note this CR ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 5.1 | S2-2005820 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2399 (Rel-16, 'F'): PDU SID handling in SMF for PDNs with IWK with 5GS | Cisco Systems | Rel-16 | Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 5.1 | S2-2005874 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: Reply LS on system support for WUS | RAN WG3 (R3-205652) | Rel-15 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 5.2 | - | - | - | QoS and PCC Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.3 | - | - | - | Non-3GPP Access Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 5.4 | - | - | - | IMS and IMS-Related Maintenance | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7 | - | - | - | Rel-16 Maintenance for 5G (excluding 5GS_Ph1) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.1 | - | - | - | Architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services (eV2XARC) | - | - | Docs:=37 | - | |
| 7.1 | S2-2004884 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2334 (Rel-16, 'F'): V2X Subscription data | Ericsson, Intel, LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.1 | S2-2004935 | LS In | Information | LS from ITU-R WP5A: LIAISON STATEMENT TO EXTERNAL ORGANIZATIONS ON ITS Connected Automated Vehicles (CAV) | ITU-R WP5A (R19-WP5A-200720-TD-0029) | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 7.1 | S2-2004941 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0141 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on V2X Packet Filter Set | LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.1 | S2-2004942 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0142 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of Tx Profile for NR PC5 | LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Postponed | LaeYoung (LGE) requests Andy (VC and AI7.1 convener) one tdoc# for outgoing LS to RAN2 on Tx Profile for NR PC5. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments, and suggest sending LS to RAN2. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to comment from Hao Dong (ZTE). Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with postponing the CR and sending an LS to RAN2 as suggested by Hong (Qualcomm). Ouyang (Huawei) agree with Heoyeon, prefers the original version. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hong(QC) and LaeYoung(LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this CR because SA2 will send an LS to RAN2 for final check. Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Qualcomm and MediaTek to postpone the CR and send LS to RAN2. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Ouyang. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek) . Shabnam (Ericsson) comments on Huawei input. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.1 | S2-2005057 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2228R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of Alternative QoS Profile handling | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision of (merged and agreed) S2-2003910. Note: 23.501 CR2379R1 was approved at TSG SA#88-e, check this does not overlap. CC#2: Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mirko (Huawei) responds to LaeYoung's comments. Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision 01. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Haris (Qualcomm). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02 and comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides r03. Apostolos (Nokia) comments on r04. Mirko (Huawei) responds to questions and provides r04. Mirko (Huawei) responds and provides r05. Paul (Ericsson) provides a response. We object to rev0, rev01, rev02 and rev04. Apostolos (Nokia) can live with either r03 provided by Ericsson or r05 provided by Huawei. Mirko (Huawei) responds. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. Chris (Vodafone) provides comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. We object to r05. Mirko (Huawei) responds and provides r06. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. We object to r06 and we will object to revisions/versions of this CR adding new text to section 5.7.2.4.1b. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r07. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. We object rev07. Apostolos (Nokia) requests clarification. Mirko (Huawei) responds and provides r08. Apostolos (Nokia) requests further clarification. Mirko (Huawei) respond. Apostolos (Nokia) responds. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. We object to r08. Paul (Ericsson) replies to Mirko. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with from r03 to r08. Mirko (Huawei) responds to Paul. Chris (Vodafone) prefers rev 3. Mirko (Huawei) is ok with r08 but objects to r07 and r04 to r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.1 | S2-2005058 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0478 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS Flow establishment based on AQP | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006192 | Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision 01. Mirko (Huawei) provides revision 02. Apostolos (Nokia) comments. Mirko (Huawei) responds to Apostolos' comments. Judy (Ericsson) provides r03. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r04. Mirko (Huawei) responds and is fine with r04. LaeYoung (LGE) is also fine with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006192 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0478R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS Flow establishment based on AQP | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005058. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005188 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0143 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update Illustration Figure of PC5 Unicast Links | ZTE | Rel-16 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper and r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Hong. Apostolos (Nokia) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Qualcomm to note the paper and r01: editorial. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Wen (vivo) provides comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) also shares the view that it is not FASMO, but if we are to include another example type then we should add the new diagram without removing the existing one. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.1 | S2-2005205 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0144 (Rel-16, 'F'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006193 | LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) answers LaeYoung's question. Dan (China Mobile) support CATT LaeYoung (LGE) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to the comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01. Dan (China Mobile) is fine with r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006193 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0144R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005205. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005206 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0061 (Rel-14, 'F'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-14 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006194. CC#2: Postponed | Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification. Ouyang(Huawei) replies. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) questions the CRs for frozen release and comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Shabnam (Ericsson). Ouyang(Huawei) replies again. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to the comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02 for consideration. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) share same view with LaeYoung. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to CATT/LGE. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports MediaTek view about ensuring we don't open specs across releases to add examples. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03. Chris (Vodafone) is unhappy that a Rel 14 CR is submitted to a Rel 16 agenda item. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and is sorry to make Chris (Vodafone) unhappy. *^____^* LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to go with r03 from Deng Qiang (CATT). Chris (Vodafone) says thanks to LaeYoung (LGE). Apostolos (Nokia) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Apostolos (Nokia). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.1 | S2-2006194 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0061R1 (Rel-14, 'F'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-14 | Revision r03 of S2-2005206. WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005207 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0062 (Rel-15, 'A'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-15 | The mirror of S2-2005206r03 was agreed. Revised to S2-2006195. CC#2: Postponed | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.1 | S2-2006195 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0062R1 (Rel-15, 'A'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-15 | Revision of S2-2005207 (Mirror of S2-2005206r03 in S2-2006194). WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005208 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0063 (Rel-16, 'A'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | The mirror of S2-2005206r03 was agreed. Revised to S2-2006196 | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006196 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0063R1 (Rel-16, 'A'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005208 (Mirror of S2-2005206r03 in S2-2006194). Revised in CC#2 to S2-2005912. | Revised | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005912 | CR | Approval | 23.285 CR0063R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Introducing new V2X service type | CATT, CAICT, China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2006196. This CR was approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005241 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0145 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of QoS info in accept message | vivo | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006197 | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Wen (vivo) responses. Ouyang(Huawei) comments. Wen (vivo) responses to Ouyang . Ouyang(Huawei) comments . Wen (vivo) agrees with Hong's comments and provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Ouyang(Huawei) is OK with r03. Ouyang(Huawei) requests clarification on r04. LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept r04. Judy (Ericsson) provides r04. Wen(vivo) responses. Judy (Ericsson) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Judy (Ericsson). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006197 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0145R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of QoS info in accept message | vivo | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005241. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005254 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0146 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SMF Configuration to UPF | Tencent | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006198 | Judy (Ericsson) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision 01. Lei (Tencent) provides comments and ok with r01. Judy (Ericsson) provide r02. Lei (Tencent) ok with r02. Lei (Tencent) respond to LaeYoung(LGE) and provide r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006198 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0146R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SMF Configuration to UPF | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005254. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005256 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0147 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on QoS sustainability | Tencent | Rel-16 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006199 | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments and provides r01: Regarding the new added text in Note 4: the first part has overlap with the description in another paragraph; and the second part could be simply converged in the related paragraph. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments. Lei (Tencent) provides comments and ok with r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides comments and r03. Judy (Ericsson) provides r04. Lei (Tencent) provides comments and can also accept r03. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r03 while r04 is not preferred. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and supports r03. Hoyeon (Samsung) supports r03. Lei(Tencent) confirm is fine with r03 and provide r05 with only editorial changes on top of r03 e.g. clean the cover sheet and change over changes. Lei(Tencent) ask Hoyeon(Samsung) to check the editorial update of r03, i.e. r05. Judy (Ericsson) answer's LaeYoung (LGE)'s question, and prefer r04. LaeYoung (LGE) asks Q to Judy (Ericsson). Lei (Tencent) provides comments to Judy (Ericsson) and LaeYoung(LGE). Judy (Ericsson) provides r06 and responds to Lei (Tencent). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006199 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0147R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on QoS sustainability | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r06 of S2-2005256. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005305 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0486 (Rel-16, 'F'): V2X Policy Control | Xiaomi, LG Electronics, ZTE, Nokia, Qualcomm, Ericsson, Intel | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006200 | Mirko (Huawei) provides r01. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006200 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0486R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): V2X Policy Control | Xiaomi, LG Electronics, ZTE, Nokia, Qualcomm, Ericsson, Intel | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005305. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005314 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2356 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on UE policy related description | LG Electronics, Nokia, Ericsson, Intel, ZTE, Xiaomi | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.1 | S2-2005542 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0148 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on PC5 RAT selection | Samsung | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006201 | Hao Dong (ZTE) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) supports r02 (pending clean-ups) Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r03 (clean up changes on changes) Changhong (Intel) provides r04. Hoyeon responds to Changhong (Intel). Changhong (Intel) answers to Hoyeon (Samsung). Shabnam (Ericsson) provides further comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK with r05. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006201 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0148R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on PC5 RAT selection | Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005542. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005849 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion paper on Link Identifier Update Procedure | InterDigital Belgium. LLC | Rel-16 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Saad (Interdigital) is ok to note the discussion paper. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.1 | S2-2005850 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0151 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to Link Identifier Update Procedure | Interdigital | Rel-16 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006202 | Hong (Qualcomm) provide r01. Changhong (Intel) provide r02. Ouyang(Huawei) supports changes of the L2 IDs . Saad (Interdigital) provide r04. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r05. Saad (Interdigital) is fine with r05. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r06. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006202 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0151R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections to Link Identifier Update Procedure | Interdigital | Rel-16 | Revision r06 of S2-2005850. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005823 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0149 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correct the triggering conditions for the link identifier update procedure | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006203 | Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Saad (IDCC) asks a question. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Saad (IDCC). Saad (IDCC) replies to Hong (Qualcomm) Hong (Qualcomm) answers Saad and Hoyeon. Saad (Interdigital) replies to Hong (QCOM) Hong (Qualcomm) replies. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Saad (Interdigital) does not agree with the original doc and r01 Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02 and replies to Saad (Interdigital). Saad (Interdigital) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) comments, as it may require confirmation from the Chairs. Saad (Interdigital) provides r04 LaeYoung (LGE) would like to check with Andy (7.1 session convener) whether modifying the text from 'e.g. Layer-2 ID conflict resolution' to 'e.g. application layer requirement' in the Reason for change of the coversheet is possible when cleaning-up r03. Andy (Convener) says he believes that a late revision to change to the coversheet to align with the latest contents of the CR is fine, but if anyone challenges this then we would need to discuss it in CC#2. LaeYoung (LGE) thanks to Andy (Convener) for guidance and proposes to go with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006203 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0149R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correct the triggering conditions for the link identifier update procedure | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005823. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005848 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0150 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update to Link Release Procedure | Interdigital | Rel-16 | Confirm Spec version used - CR states 16.2.0! r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006204. | Wen (vivo) asks for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) provides comment. Judy (Ericsson) provide r01. Saad (IDCC) replies to Hao (ZTE) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r03. Saad (IDCC) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and provides r01. Saad (IDCC) replies to Wen's (Vivo) questions Saad (IDCC) is fine with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006204 | CR | Approval | 23.287 CR0150R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update to Link Release Procedure | Interdigital | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005848. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.1 | S2-2005866 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Tx Profile for NR PC5 | LGE | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006191 | LaeYoung (LGE) provides r00. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r03. Ouyang(Huawei) provides r04. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r05. LaeYoung (LGE) is OK with r05. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.1 | S2-2006191 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Tx Profile for NR PC5 | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005866. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.2 | - | - | - | Wireless and Wireline Convergence for the 5G system architecture (5WWC) | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 7.2 | S2-2004815 | LS In | Information | LS from BBF: Completion of WT-456 and WT-470 | BBF (LIAISE-411) | Postponed | Marco (Huawei) proposes to postpone the LS Laurent (nokia) agrees to postpone the LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed | |
| 7.2 | S2-2004775 | LS In | Action | LS from BBF: Issue with FN-RG IPv6 support | BBF (LIAISE-394) | Revision of postponed S2-2003627 from S2#139E. Response drafted in S2-2004927. Final response in S2-2006205 | Laurent (Nokia): Now that the CR and LS out have been agreed we can Note the LS Stefan (Ericsson) supports noting the LS ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to | |
| 7.2 | S2-2004926 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2046R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of IPv6 addresses for FN-RG | Ericsson, Telecom Italia, Nokia, Charter, Cablelabs | Rel-16 | Revision of (postponed) S2-2003685 from S2#139E. Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2004927 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Issue with FN-RG IPv6 support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004775. Agreed. Revised to S2-2006205. | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2006205 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Issue with FN-RG IPv6 support | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2004927. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.2 | S2-2004843 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2047 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5G-RG indicating over 5G NAS whether it supports ATSSS over EPC | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | CC#2: This CR was postponed. | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications on motivation Laurent (Nokia) answers to Marco (Huawei) Marco (Huawei) commented Apostolis (Lenovo) suggests changes and clarifications. Laurent (Nokia) provides r01. Marco (Huawei) comments. Marco (Huawei) provides r02. Laurent (Nokia) comments and requests an associated LS to be sent to BBF. Marco (Huawei) support sending an LS to BBF. Laurent (Nokia) provides r03 but has still preference for the solution in r01 (more aligned with future work on R17). Andy (Convenor) suggests requesting a number for the LS. Marco (Nokia) provides r04. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Marco (Huawei) replies to comment. Marco (Huawei) propose to agree r04 (last one), Not OK with Original & r01. Laurent (Nokia) proposes to agree r00 or r01, Not OK (but no objection) r03 and r04. Objection to r02 Marco (Huawei) OK to postpone the CR and to ask BBF assuming that we can work on LS text Laurent (Nokia) comments: Good idea to postpone the CR and to ask BBF Stefan (Ericsson) comments Stefan (Ericsson) OK to postpone CR and work on LS text ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Laurent (Nokia) OK to postpone CR and work on LS text; I'll propose some text update of the previous LS version ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.2 | S2-2004928 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2048 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to the description of FN-RG Session Modification Procedure | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2005424 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2364 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correcting UE Id in the Access Network parameters | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2005426 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2365 (Rel-16, 'F'): Selecting the authentication method for devices that do not support 5GC NAS over WLAN access | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom | Rel-16 | Noted | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications and expresses concern Stefan (Ericsson) comments and agrees with Marco Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with Stefan (Ericsson) and Marko (Huawei) and proposes to note CR. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to comments and asks Marco (HW) to clarify if they see the issue. Marco (Huawei) expresses concern wait first SA3. Marco (Huawei) proposes to note. Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to note Thouraya (Orange) agrees with Marko's (Huawei) concerns and proposes to note the CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.2 | S2-2005525 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2374 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding emergency registration procedure for trusted non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.2 | S2-2005526 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2375 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding handover procedure between EPS and 5GC-TNGF | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006206 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r02 Marco (Huawei) provides r03 Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2006206 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2375R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding handover procedure between EPS and 5GC-TNGF | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005526. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.2 | S2-2005527 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2376 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Identifiers of N5CW devices | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006207 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Apostolis provides r02 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2006207 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2376R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Identifiers of N5CW devices | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005527. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.2 | S2-2005528 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2049 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on figure in 5WWC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006208 | Apostolis (Lenovo) asks for clarification. Marco (Huawei) reply to Apostolis. Laurent (Nokia) comments. Apostolis agrees with r00 after Laurent's (Nokia) comments. Marco (Huawei) provides r01 for fixing caption. Marco (Huawei) hyperlink issue fixed. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.2 | S2-2006208 | CR | Approval | 23.316 CR2049R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on figure in 5WWC | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005528. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.3 | - | - | - | Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (ATSSS) | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 7.3 | S2-2005842 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2453 (Rel-16, 'F'): RFC for draft-ietf-tcpm-converters | Apple | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | - | - | - | Cellular IoT support and evolution for the 5G System (5G_CIoT) + RAN Rel-16 alignment – MT-EDT | - | - | Docs:=32 | - | |
| 7.4 | S2-2004804 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG2: LS on AS RAI and optimization of release | RAN WG2 (R2-2005839) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005149. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005147 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Discussion on AS RAI and optimization of release of the RRC connection. | Ericsson, AT&T, Sony, Thales, Turkcell | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2005148 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2350 (Rel-16, 'F'): Introducing NG-eNB awareness of pending DL transaction when UE in CM-IDLE with Suspend | Ericsson, AT&T, Sony, LG Electronics, Turkcell | Rel-16 | Noted | Wanqiang (Huawei) object the CR as we already concluded this issue in SA2 for R16. Paul (Ericsson) provides response to Wanqiang (Huawei). Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides comments, and would like to understand from companies if they are willing to reopen this discussion again or not. Paul (Ericsson) provides a response and revision r01 of the CR. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02 clarifying the RAN stores ECT if received when the UE is in CM-IDLE to use when UE transitions to CM-CONNECTED. Wanqiang (Huawei) object any revision of the CR/reopen the discussion again for R16. Lars (Sony) Comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. Farooq (AT&T) is fine with r02. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r03, also fine with r02 Chris (Vodafone) is concerned that we are rushing changes that may disable security capabilities. At least this needs to be mandatory for the RAN to use. Rev 4 is uploaded. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with rev04. Paul (Ericsson) provides r05. Wanqiang (Huawei) sustains objection to all rev.s and provides the reasons again. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides a comment on technical part of Wanqiang's objection justification, bullet 3, for r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) does not see the justification for this change in Rel-16. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2005149 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on LS on AS RAI and optimization of release | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004804. Noted | Wanqiang (Huawei) object the paper as it relates with the CR in S2-2005148. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) says that the LS must reflect the outcome on CR in S2-2005148. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2004885 | CR | Approval | 23.682 CR0470 (Rel-16, 'F'): Common Network Exposure | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) shares the same view; the CR should be noted. Steve (Huawei) Is this even CIoT? Should be TEIx. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides responses. Steve (Huawei) is not convienced this is a CIoT correction. Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to note this CR and bring it back as a TEI17 proposal Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR; this is not a correction and can be brought back as a TEI17 proposal ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Steve (Huawei) and Sebastian (Qualcomm) that this is not a correction but a new feature? Qian Chen (Ericsson) accepts the comments and agrees to NOTE the paper. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2004936 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2340 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on use of N2 message in PDU Session establishment for Control Plane CIoT 5GS Optimization | NEC | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005797 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion regarding LS on system support for WUS (S2-2005090/R2-2005985). | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-15 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.4 | S2-2005076 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2407 (Rel-16, 'F'): WUS system support for 5GC | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006209 | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 and r02 Jinguo (ZTE) asks to ignore r01 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05 (please ignore r04, uploaded by mistake) Jinguo (ZTE) is ok with r05 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006209 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2407R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): WUS system support for 5GC | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005076. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005077 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2345 (Rel-16, 'F'): WUS system support for 5GC | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Approved | Jinguo (ZTE) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with r01, prefers original Steve (Huawei) disagrees with r01. Jinguo (ZTE) ask for clarification and provide r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and suggests to go ahead with the original version Jinguo (ZTE) replies to Sebastian and prefers r01 Steve (Huawei) disagrees with r02. Let's get 5GS aligned with EPS, original does that. Jinguo(ZTE) ask clarification Steve (Huawei) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) prefers to go with original, objects to other versions Qian Chen (Ericsson) agrees to go with the original version Jinguo (ZTE) can live with original version ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hannu (Nokia) supports fall back to original version ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005507 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2424 (Rel-16, 'F'): Overview Clarifications for multiple UP resource support for an NB-IoT UE | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005508 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2370 (Rel-16, 'F'): Procedure Clarifications for multiple UP resource support for an NB-IoT UE | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005509 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2425 (Rel-16, 'F'): Overview Clarifications about the CIoT optimisations during mobility to and from non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks why the PDU session establishment rejection is at AMF and not at SMF Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r01, rejecting at SMF instead of AMF when moving to non-3GPP access Steve (Huawei) comments on why the AMF. Miguel (Qualcomm) OK with original version, withdraws r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005510 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2371 (Rel-16, 'F'): Procedure Clarifications for CIoT optimisations during mobility to and from non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006210 | Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks to clarify meaning of first change Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006210 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2371R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Procedure Clarifications for CIoT optimisations during mobility to and from non-3GPP access | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005510. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005511 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2426 (Rel-16, 'F'): Overview Clarifications for handling Control Plane CIoT optimisation during interworking between EPS and 5GS | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005512 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2427 (Rel-16, 'F'): Drop downlink packets with notification of the discarded downlink packet | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006211 | Judy (Ericsson) provide r01. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006211 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2427R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Drop downlink packets with notification of the discarded downlink packet | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005512. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005513 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2372 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to interaction between the SMF and UPF for Availability after DDN failure event | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006212 | Judy (Ericsson) provide r01. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006212 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2372R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to interaction between the SMF and UPF for Availability after DDN failure event | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005513. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005514 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2428 (Rel-16, 'F'): Overview of redirecting UE via service reject to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.4 | S2-2005515 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2373 (Rel-16, 'F'): Procedures to Redirect UE via service reject to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006213 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r02 and asks to ignore the wrongly uploaded r01 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006213 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2373R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Procedures to Redirect UE via service reject to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005515. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005787 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0489 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC control for DDD status and availability after DDN failure events | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006214 | Thomas (Nokia) accepts r01. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006214 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0489R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC control for DDD status and availability after DDN failure events | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005787. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005803 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2398 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC control for DDD status and availability after DDN failure events | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006215 | Qianghua (Huawei) asks for clarification. Thomas (Nokia) answers to Qianghua Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and objects to r00. Belen (Ericsson) prefers initial version. Thomas (Nokia) also prefers initial version. Qianghua (Huawei) can only accept r01, given the comments we listed before. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006215 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2398R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): PCC control for DDD status and availability after DDN failure events | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005803. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2004806 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on addition of the Pending Data Indication to 5GS | RAN WG3 (R3-204152) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005704. Final response in S2-2006216 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.4 | S2-2005706 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2443 (Rel-16, 'F'): Extended Connected Timer in mobility messages | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006217 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. Lars Nord (Sony) provides comments and r03. Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that is ok with r03 Steve (Huawei) checks is just 'UE' inactivity could be misunderstood. Lars (Sony) comments Haris (Qualcomm) comments and proposes r04 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and support r04 Lars (Sony) provides comments and provides r05 Haris (Qualcomm) comments and responds to Lars Hannu (Nokia) asks question on the AMF mandate to always apply Extended Connected Time? ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006217 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2443R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Extended Connected Timer in mobility messages | Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson, Sony | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005706. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.4 | S2-2005704 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on addition of the Pending Data Indication to 5GS | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004806. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006216. | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.4 | S2-2006216 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on addition of the Pending Data Indication to 5GS | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005704. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | Enablers for Network Automation for 5G (eNA) | - | - | Docs:=24 | - | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 1: Analytics Exposure to 5GC NF | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005422 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0179 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Target of Event Reporting | LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.5 | S2-2005439 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0181 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Analytics Exposure | CATT | Rel-16 | CC#2: Nokia and Ericsson withdrew their objections to r02. S2 2005439r02 was agreed and revised to S2-2005913 | Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia prefer to live with the restriction in Rel-16 and suggest noting the proposal. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01 and suggest to note the proposal. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Nokia's comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to CATT. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Yannick (Nokia). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2005913 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0181R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Analytics Exposure | CATT | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005439. This CR was agreed | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 2: Data Collection from 5GC NF/AF | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005440 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0182 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on data collection for statistics | CATT | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006218 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Antoine (Orange): suggests to Note and consider this for Rel-17. Belen (Ericsson) also propose to Note this document. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Nokia's comment. Peretz (Spirent) is asking for a clarification regarding 'For a subscription to statistics in the future'?. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Peretz (Spirent) and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r04. Belen (Ericsson) okay with r04. Peretz (Spirent) comment on r02 Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r04. Peretz (Spirent) agrees with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006218 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0182R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on data collection for statistics | CATT, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005440. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005446 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0184 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on NWDAF identifying the AF to collect data for an Event | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006219 | Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a question for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and request for clarification. Belen (Ericsson) commemts and asks for clarifications Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agree with Ericsson's understanding for trusted AF handling. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Yannick and Belen Belen (Ericsson) comments, replise to Lenovo. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Xiaoyan Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments and asks for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Yan Xu (OPPO) provides comments Dimitris(Lenovo) provides editorial corrections in r03 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia express concerns on all versions for this CR. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Lenovo. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Lenovo and provide r05. r04 is not acceptable. Dimitris (Lenovo) is OK with r05 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006219 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0184R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on NWDAF identifying the AF to collect data for an Event | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005446. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 4: Data Collection from OAM | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005378 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0178 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections for wrong references for TS 28.532 clauses | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 5: NWDAF-Assisted QoS Profile Provisioning - (QoS related) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005066 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0177 (Rel-16, 'F'): Service experience analytics discrimination | Samsung | Rel-16 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006220 | Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and request for clarification. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarification and updates to the CR. David (Samsung) provides answers, asks for comments clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung. David (Samsung) provides r01. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments and asks to add ETRI as a co-signer company. Peretz (Spirent) asking for further clarification Peretz (Spirent) asks for clarification to the CR. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia). Peretz (Spirent) would like more clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r03. David (Samsung) provides r03, answers comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia further reply to Huawei. David (Samsung) comments. David (Samsung) provides further clarifications to Peretz. Belen (Ericsson) comments to r03. David (Samsung) provides r04. Soohwan (ETRI) provides r05. David (Samsung) provides comments. David (Samsung) provides r06. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006220 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0177R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Service experience analytics discrimination | Samsung, CATT, ETRI | Rel-16 | Revision r06 of S2-2005066. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005543 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0185 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Service Experience procedure | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-16 | Noted | Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a question. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Yang. David (Samsung) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Apostolis (Lenovo) replies to David's (Samsung) comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Belen (Ericsson). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Xiaoyan (CATT). Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provided comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) provided additional comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Apostolis and provides r02 . Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to David's (Samsung) comments. David (Samsung) provides comments on r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r03. Xiaobo (Huawei): Huawei responds to Yannick(Nokia) and Huawei is ok with r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Apostolis (Lenovo) cannot accept r03 and r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia cannot accept r02. Apostolis (Lenovo) requests from Yannick (Nokia) to clarify his statement that r02 specifies 'when the NWDAF trains a ML model'. This is not the intention of the CR. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Lenovo. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks if r01 is acceptable. David (Samsung) cannot accept r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.5 | S2-2005760 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2393 (Rel-16, 'F'): Location event filter for trusted AF | Samsung, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 7: NWDAF assisting Future Background Data Transfer - (PCC related) | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005059 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0479 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment of BDT policy negotiation description with the procedures in TS 23.502 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006221 | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Mirko (Huawei) provides r02. Mirko (Huawei) provides r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006221 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0479R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment of BDT policy negotiation description with the procedures in TS 23.502 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005059. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005060 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0480 (Rel-16, 'F'): Re-ordering of interactions in the BDT policy re-negotiation description | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006222 | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Mirko (Huawei) provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r02 and the original vesion. Mirko (Huawei) responds to Belen. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Mirko Belen (Ericsson) comments and provides a way forward for Mirko to check Mirko (Huawei) responds to Belen and provides r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006222 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0480R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Re-ordering of interactions in the BDT policy re-negotiation description | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005060. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005061 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2342 (Rel-16, 'F'): Re-ordering of interactions in the BDT policy re-negotiation procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006223 | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Mirko (Huawei) provides r02. Mirko (Huawei) provides r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006223 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2342R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Re-ordering of interactions in the BDT policy re-negotiation procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005061. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 8: performance improvement and supervision of mIoT terminals - (IoT related) | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005117 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2346 (Rel-16, 'F'): Time in trajectories of Expected UE Behaviour | 439 | Rel-16 | CC#2: S2 2005117r07 with additional corrections was agreed and revised to S2-2005914 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to this contribution. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments to CATT Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides comments. Lars (Sony) comment and objects to r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Lars (Sony) We are ok with r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) is okay to remove the Note, but asks Samsung. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK r02 and suggests to keep the NOTE. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03 Lars (Sony) we are ok with r03 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to NOK. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r05, also comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia cannot accept r05. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia, and asks if any revision would be acceptable for them. Mehrdad (Samsung) is ok with r05 and may live with r01 or r02 but cannot accept original version, r03 or r04. Lars (Sony) is ok with all versions except r01 which we object to. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggest to postpone the proposal. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to this CR (all versions). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2005914 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2346R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Time in trajectories of Expected UE Behaviour | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r07 of S2-2005117 with additional changes. This CR was approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005441 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0183 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on mapping of expected analytics type and Exception IDs | CATT | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006224 | Jaehyu (LGE) provides comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides clarification. Jaehyu (LGE) asks for clarification. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Jaehyu (LGE)'s comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Yannick, and provides r01. Jaehyu (LGE) fines with r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies to Jaehyu (LGE) and provides r02, but prefers r01. Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification on r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006224 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0183R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on mapping of expected analytics type and Exception IDs | CATT | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005441. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.5 | - | - | - | KI 11: NWDAF-Assisted predictable network performance - (V2X related) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 7.5 | S2-2005753 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0186 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Multiple Parameter Sets for QoS Sustainability | Tencent | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006225 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Belen (Ericsson). Lei(Tencent) provides comments. Lei(Tencent) provides r01 for further review. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.5 | S2-2006225 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0186R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on Multiple Parameter Sets for QoS Sustainability | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005753. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.6 | - | - | - | Enhancement to the 5GC Location Services (5G_eLCS) | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 7.6 | S2-2004797 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on UE initiated Event Reporting Procedure for Low Power Event Reporting and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR | CT WG1 (C1-204046) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005677 and S2-2005824. CC#2: This was postponed. | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.6 | S2-2005677 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS response on UE initiated Event Reporting Procedure for Low Power Event Reporting and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004797. Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) comments, and propose to consider this merged to S2-2005824 . Runze (Huawei) disagrees to merge to paper into S2-2005824, because the principle of two papers are different. Runze (Huawei) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE this LS draft and use S2-2005824r02 instead. Runze (Huawei) disagrees to postpone the CR without technical reason. Hong (Qualcomm) response to Runze (Huawei). Runze (Huawei) responds to Hong (Qualcomm). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2005824 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on UE initiated Event Reporting Procedure for Low Power Event Reporting and Triggered 5GC-MT-LR | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004797. Noted | Ming (CATT) comments and support r01. Hong (Qualcomm) response and provides r01, and propose to select r01 as response to CT1 (consider S2-2005677 as merged). Runze (Huawei) proposes to note this paper Leo (Deutsche Telekom) comments. Runze (Huawei) responds to Hong, and agrees to Leo (Deutsche Telekom) to NOTE this LS. Runze (Huawei) responds to Stephen (Qualcomm). Stephen (Qualcomm) clarifies why Qualcomm and Huawei may have a similar opinion Runze (Huawei) responds to Hong, and sustains the objection to the LS. Runze (Huawei) suggests to merge the paper into S2-2005677. Hong (Qaulcomm) provides r02 and prefer to reply CT1 based on this LS. Runze (Huawei) objects to any version of S2-2005824. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to any version of S2-2005824. Hong (Qualcomm) responds to Runze (Huawei). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.6 | S2-2004898 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0127 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to Bulk Operation | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: This CR was postponed. | Ming (CATT) comments and provides rev01. Runze (Huawei) objects to the original version and revision 01. Sherry (Xiaomi) requests for clarification. Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides r02 and comment. Runze (Huawei) agrees to Sherry in general and provides further elaboration. Runze (Huawei) agrees with the principle in r02, and provides r03 with more clarifications. Pallab (Nokia) does not agree with current revisions and provides r06 with further changes. Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides r05. Runze(Huawei) does not agree with Pallab(Nokia). Runze(Huawei)supports r05 in principle and provides r07. Pallab(Nokia) requests for clarification to Runze(Huawei) Sherry(Xiaomi)provides comments to r05, r06 and r07. Tao (Chair) asks whether some consensus can be achieved for this. Pallab (Nokia) proposes to postpone this topic (along with all other related Tdocs) and offers to organize offline discussions to agree on a solution before next SA2 meeting Runze (Huawei) asks for the reason to postpone the CR (and LS ) Pallab (Nokia) requests for technical clarification to Runze (Huawei) Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides response to question from Pallab. Pallab (Nokia) provides further comments and not OK with current revision r07 Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides responses to further question from Pallab. Runze (Huawei) responds to Pallab (Nokia). Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides responses and propose to resolve at CC2. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Runze (Huawei). Not OK with r07 yet. Please see the response sent to Ake's email Pallab (Nokia) responds to Ake (Ericsson) Runze (Huawei) responds to Pallab(Nokia),and suggests to agree r07. Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides responses to further question from Pallab (Nokia). Pallab (Nokia) responds to Ake (Ericsson) and Runze (Huawei) and seeks further clarification. Still not OK with r07 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Åke Busin (Ericsson) refers to response to original questions. Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides clarification related to r08 in preparation to CC2. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments Pallab (Nokia) provides further suggestion to Ake (Ericsson) Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Ake. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Ake (Ericsson). ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.6 | S2-2005675 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0128 (Rel-16, 'F'): Several FASMO corrections in TS 23.273 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Åke Busin (Ericsson) Objects to S2-2005675 Runze (Huawei) disagrees to reason for objection from Ericsson. Stephen (Qualcomm) adds more information regarding the objection Runze (Huawei) disagrees to the Stephen's comment and provide more justification. R01 is provided. Åke Busin (Ericsson ) objects to R01 and provides further comments. Stephen (Qualcomm) clarifies objection to R00 and R01 Runze (Huawei ) responds to Ake and provides r02. Åke Busin (Ericsson ) objects to R02 and provides reason. Runze (Huawei ) responds to Stephen and Ake, and provides r03 and r04. Stephen (Qualcomm) responds to comments from Runze and sustains objection to all rev.s Runze (Huawei) responds to Stephen and propose to postpone the paper. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.6 | S2-2005678 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0129 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on information carried in NAS Service Accept | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Postponed | Hong (Qualcomm) comments, and propose to NOTE this CR. Runze (Huawei) replies to Hong' comment and provide r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on the R01 Runze (Huawei) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to POSTPONE this CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.6 | S2-2005679 | CR | Approval | 23.273 CR0130 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of description on bulk operation initiated by LCS client | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Åke Busin (Ericsson) Objects to S2-2005679 Runze (Huawei) disagrees to Ake's 'reason for objection' to S2-2005679 Sherry (Xiaomi) proposes to postpone this CR until this issue is clarified by OMA. Åke Busin (Ericsson) Provides clarifications & comments to Runze and Sherry Runze (Huawei) replies to Ake. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Ake and agrees to note the paper. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services (Vertical_LAN) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.7.1 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services – 5G-LAN aspects | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005611 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2437 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify Ethernet Frames handling for Ethernet PDU session | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Unicom, China Mobile | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005878 | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia) provides r02 Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses and r03; Stefan (Ericsson) comments Laurent (Nokia) provides r04 Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r05 Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00. Can live with other versions especially r05 proposed for approval ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005878 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2437R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify Ethernet Frames handling for Ethernet PDU session | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Unicom, China Mobile | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005611. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005612 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2388 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify Ethernet Frames handling for Ethernet PDU session | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Unicom, China Mobile | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005879 | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Laurent (Nokia) provides r02 Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) suggests approving the R03, which has some editorial changes and updates on the cover page based on r02. Laurent (nokia) suggests approving the R03 (Qianghua), which has some editorial changes and updates on the cover page based on r02 (Laurent). Laurent objects to r00 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005879 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2388R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify Ethernet Frames handling for Ethernet PDU session | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Unicom, China Mobile | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005612. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005613 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2438 (Rel-16, 'F'): Dedicated SMF selection clarification | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005880 | Josep (DT) objects to r00, provides comments and r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses and R02. Josep (DT) is OK with r02 Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) accepts R03 Josep (DT) we are also fine with r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005880 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2438R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Dedicated SMF selection clarification | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005613. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005614 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2439 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GLAN clarifications | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005881 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005881 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2439R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GLAN clarifications | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005614. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005615 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2440 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the 5G VN usage of IP Multicast mechanisms | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005882 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses and R02. Stefan (Ericsson) replies Qianghua (Huawei) responds. Laurent (Nokia) comments Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00 and to r02; ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.1 | S2-2005882 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2440R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on the 5G VN usage of IP Multicast mechanisms | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005615. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services – TSN aspects | - | - | Docs:=65 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | LSs and related CRs | - | - | Docs:=19 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004782 | LS In | Action | LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on TSN support in 3GPP Release-16 stage 2 completion | IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-TSN-support-in-3GPP-Release-16) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004336 from S2#139E. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004932 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS Reply on clarification on TSN for Vertical_LAN | CT WG3 (C3-203675) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005069. Final response in S2-2005883 | zhendong (ZTE), provises the response. Haiyang (Huawei) suggests a way forward for the related CRs. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies. Sang-Jun accepts Haiyang (Huawei)'s suggestion of merging the related CRs. zhendong (ZTE), provides response ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005069 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on clarification on TSN for Vertical_LAN | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004932. Agreed. Revised to S2-2005883. | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005883 | LS OUT | Approval | LS Reply on clarification on TSN for Vertical_LAN | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision of S2-2005069. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004902 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2392 (Rel-16, 'F'): PSFP clarifications including IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005846, to S2-2005884 | Dan (China Mobile) provides for clarification. György (Ericsson) responds to China Mobile. Qianghua (Huawei) objects this CR Saso (Intel) likes Qianghua (Huawei) proposal to ask IEEE why the PSFP that apply to the ingress port does not contain the ingress port number György (Ericsson) responds to Intel and Huawei. György (Ericsson) provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r01 with the link. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments to Intel György (Ericsson) ok with r03 Qianghua (Huawei) provided r04 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r05 Saso (Intel) provides r06 Chunshan (Tencent) requests for clarificaiton. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r07. Saso (Intel) seeking clarification on NOTE1 in r05. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies György (Ericsson) responds to Saso. György (Ericsson) provides clarification for Tencent. György (Ericsson) proposes to agree on r05. The correction of the typo in r07 can be added as an editorial correction. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05 and objects to r06 and r07 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies: ok with r05 with shortened NOTE1 Saso (Intel) objects to r05 as is. Proposes to agree r05 with shortened NOTE1. Devaki (Nokia) prefers to go with r5, not r6. If the Note is shortened, then we prefer to leave the information used as implementation specific, should be reflected in the normative part of the spec. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Saso (Intel) replies to Devaki (Nokia). Devaki (Nokia) responds to Intel. György (Ericsson) is also fine with the shortened note of r05. Saso (Intel) comments. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005884 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2392R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): PSFP clarifications including IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2004902, merging S2-2005846. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004903 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2393 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing technical comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2005885 | Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Chunshan (Tencent) provides r03. György (Ericsson ) responds to Tencent. György (Ericsson) is OK with r02 Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. György (Ericsson) responds to Tencent. Chunshan (Tencent) responses to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) responds to Tencent and provides r04. Chunshan (Tencent) responds to Ericsson and OK with the r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Devaki (Nokia) has the same view as HUA regarding port #s, provides r06 based on r05. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Devaki (Nokia) responds. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response György (Ericsson) can accept r06 and responds. zhendong (ZTE), ask the question for clarification zhendong (ZTE), provides the clarification Qianghua (Huawei) comments zhendong (ZTE), provide the response Saso (Intel) proposes a way forward on 'serving NW-TT port(s)'. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with Saso's proposal Saso (Intel) provides r07 Qianghua (Huawei) comments on r07 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response to huawei György (Ericsson) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) only accepts r06, r05 György (Ericsson) proposes to accept r06 as the way forward. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005885 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2393R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing technical comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r06 of S2-2004903. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004904 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2337 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing technical comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Postponed | Qianghua (Huawei) objects this CR György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Devaki (Nokia) also objects to the CR, port number changes for the same reason as in 4903. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Devaki (Nokia) responds. zhendong (ZTE), provises the response György (Ericsson) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) comments Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 György (Ericsson) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 György (Ericsson) asks a question from Huawei and provides r05 Qianghua (Huawei) responds. Devaki (Nokia) wonders what is really the FASMO with r04, r05? It simply adds the (vague) phrase 'In combination with local information,' which is possible to do even without this CR. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05 György (Ericsson) proposes to go ahead with r05. Devaki (Nokia) comments r04 or r05 are really editorial (not FASMO), proposes to postpone and discuss next meeting with meaningful update. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004905 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2394 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing wording comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005886 | Shabnam (Ericsson) revises r01 removing overlapped parts from S2-2005725. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005886 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2394R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing wording comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2004905. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004906 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2338 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing wording comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005887 | Shabnam (Ericsson) revises r01 removing overlapped parts with S2-2005726. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005887 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2338R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing wording comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2004906. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004907 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0476 (Rel-16, 'F'): Addressing wording comments from IEEE LS response on TSN support | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) revises r01 removing overlapped parts with S2-2005727. Devaki (Nokia) comments that the IEEE spec reference (simply stating IEEE 802.1) is wrong. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) comments that the reference introduced by this CR ''IEEE 802.1' managed objects, to interwork with 'IEEE 802.1 TSN networks...' is rather blank - more specifically, which IEEE spec does this refer to for managed objects? Anyhow unclear to me what would fail otherwise (FASMO)? Proposes to note this paper as just an addition of 'IEEE 802.1' (as a reference) without a proper reference to the appropriate spec is not adding value and not FASMO. The other references to 501/2 are implicit. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004908 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2395 (Rel-16, 'F'): Delay clarifications including IEEE LS input clarifications | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: r06 (with the annex changes removed) agreed. Revised to S2-2005888 | zhendong (ZTE), correct the title Devaki (Nokia) cannot accept original version. Qianghua (Huawei) comments György (Ericsson) provides r01. zhendong (ZTE), ask question for clarification Devaki (Nokia) responds zhendong (ZTE), confirm the understanding Devaki (Nokia) comments on r01. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia Qianghua (Huawei) provides a way forward György (Ericsson) is OK with the way forward suggested by Huawei and Nokia, and provides the corresponding r02. Devaki (Nokia) has strong concerns with r02 due to radical change in semantics of BAT in the Uplink. György (Ericsson) provides r03 but still prefers r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments on R02 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE, provides r04, but still prefers r02. zhendong (ZTE), provides r05 Devaki (Nokia) provides r06. Qianghua (Huawei) only can accept r03, r02; since we don't think other versions address the issue. György (Ericsson), can accept all revisions (r01-r05) as well as the original CR, but prefers r02. György (Ericsson) can also accept r06. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification zhendong (ZTE), can accept with r05 and r06 György (Ericsson) comments to Huawei that the focus of the release-16 CR is to correct the issues with the existing text; while new parameters can still be added in later releases. György (Ericsson) provides clarifications. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r06 but objects to r02/r03 zhendong (ZTE), can live with r05,06, but object r02,r03 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005888 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2395R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Delay clarifications including IEEE LS input clarifications | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | CC#2: Revision r06 of S2-2004908 with the annex changes removed. S2-2005888 had already been uploaded, so this was revised to S2-2005922 | Revised | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005922 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2395R3 (Rel-16, 'F'): Delay clarifications including IEEE LS input clarifications | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r06 (with the annex changes removed) of S2-2005888. This CR was agreed | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004910 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2396 (Rel-16, 'F'): Solving Synchronization issues, addressing IEEE LS response | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005889 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments zhendong (ZTE), provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that DCM provided wording is acceptable and provides response to Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) agrees with DCM/Jari's comment. Shabnam (Ericsson) responds to ZTE that r03 is ok and comments to Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r03 or r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that IEEE LS already mentions that 'based on' is not technically correct, either 3GPP complies with the role as defined by IEEE specs or does not. Can Nokia consider r03 as a way forward? Devaki (Nokia) comments that r03 is proposing a requirement to comply and asks why Stage 2 writes requirement? Prefers to go with r04. Devaki (Nokia) wonders if the CR is needed as current spec repeatedly states is 5GS is compliant to IEEE 802.1AS. Current spec seem to cover the intent already. Devaki (Nokia) can go with r03 or r04, in the interest of progress. zhendong (ZTE), can accept r03 and r04. prefer r03 Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Devaki for reconsidering, Puneet can we go with r03 please? ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005889 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2396R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Solving Synchronization issues, addressing IEEE LS response | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2004910. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=46 | - | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004871 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0475 (Rel-16, 'F'): Supplement for TSN QoS information | China Mobile | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004909 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0477 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of the delay parameter for TSN QoS | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005891 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) objects to original version and the revisions. This is clearly NOT FASMO rather it is also based on wrong technical assumption. Original version - PDB is not an input for picking 5QI rather delay is; Revision - PDB for 5QI is not picked dynamically rather it is standardized. Appropriate 5QI (with the right PDB value) has to be picked considering delay parameter. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides r02. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments, prefers r01 Devaki (Nokia) uploads r03. Devaki (Nokia) comments that our position remains the same. We have objection to original version and the revisions as the existing spec clarifies the PCF requirement for 5QI while R01 / R02 gives the impression that PCF has to change the PDB for a standardized 5QI which is incorrect. György (Ericsson) does not see why the text in r01/02 would be misinterpreted as suggested by Nokia. György (Ericsson) could accept r03 though it does not address the original intent of the CR. Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification. György (Ericsson) provides clarification. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005891 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0477R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of the delay parameter for TSN QoS | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2004909. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004911 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2397 (Rel-16, 'F'): Ammendment of VLAN configuration | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Postponed | Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks a question for clarification. György (Ericsson) responds to Qualcomm. Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) has concerns that r01 introduces a requirement that is not implementable by UPF. Request to postpone. György (Ericsson) confirms that the CR only provides clarification and no technical change, but it is possible to postpone. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004912 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2398 (Rel-16, 'F'): Mapping GBR and Averaging Window | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005892 | Haiyang (Huawei) comments and provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) comments that this is NOT a FASMO, changing TSCAI and QoS parameters semantics so late, I am afraid. Refer to SA2#137E, S2-2002112, QoS Mapping considering Time Conversion Belen (Ericsson) replies, asks for references, provides r03. In our view, this is FASMO, as there is no way to define how Averaging window is obtained from TSN QoS. Belen (Ericsson) prefers r02, but it is okay with r03 if objections to r02. Haiyang (Huawei) prefers r01, and objects the original version. Devaki (Nokia) can accept r01 only, not any other version. Other versions introduce reopen determination of QoS parameters (that are not really FASMO). Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications to Huawei and request Nokia to provide a resonable explanation on why this is not FASMO, so that we can work on the topic or not. Belen (Ericsson) thanks Huawei for explanation, and asks if Huawei and Nokia agree this is FASMO or not. Devaki (Nokia) replies why other revisions are not FASMO. Belen (Ericsson) asks how it is possible that a revision is FASMO, in our view the problem exists or does not exist, but not a revision. Haiyang (Huawei) responses. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects r02 and r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005892 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2398R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Mapping GBR and Averaging Window | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2004912. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2004913 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2399 (Rel-16, 'F'): Amendment of contradiction related to PMIC | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005898 | Saso (Intel) points to overlapping clause 5.8.2.11.X on BMIC with S2-2005454. György (Ericsson) agrees with the overlap. If one of the revisions of S2-2005454 can be agreed, this CR can be regarded merged into that CR. Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to remove the overlapping clause 5.8.2.11.X on BMIC from S2-2005454 on final version and approve this CR since it has no comments. zhendong (ZTE), provides the suggestion ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005028 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2403 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to TSN stream identification in PSFP information | Intel | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005893 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Saso and Zhendong Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments zhendong (ZTE), provides the r02 Saso (Intel) ok with r02, plus one comment. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Devaki (Nokia) provides r03 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 Saso (Intel) provides r05, plus one comment. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005893 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2403R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to TSN stream identification in PSFP information | Intel | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005028. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005029 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2404 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction and claritication related to the choice of PDU Session when exchanging BMIC or PMIC between TSN AF and NW-TT | Intel | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005894 | Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02. Saso (Intel) objects to r02. Seeks clarification on r01. Jari (DNN DOCOMO) asks clarification from Saso Samsung replies to Saso (Intel) and objects to r00 and can accept r01 or r02. Saso (Intel) disagrees with Samsung's reply. Saso (Intel) withdraws objection on r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005894 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2404R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction and claritication related to the choice of PDU Session when exchanging BMIC or PMIC between TSN AF and NW-TT | Intel | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005029. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005053 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2405 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GS BMCA support and PTP port state configuration | Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson, ZTE | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005895 | Xiaowan (vivo) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Chunshan (Tencent) provides comments and r03. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Qianghua (Huawei) responds. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments to to huawei Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Chunshan (Tencent) replies Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Chunshan (Tencent) provides further clarifications. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarifications. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r04 and r03 Chunshan (Tencent) updates the link to r04. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with r03, prefers r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and provides r05 Devaki (Nokia) supports the CR in principle, asks question for clarification. Devaki (Nokia) replies Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies and proposes to move ahead with r05 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005895 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2405R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): 5GS BMCA support and PTP port state configuration | Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson, ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005053. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005056 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2406 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of Bridge ID | Intel | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Saso (Intel) withdraws S2-2005056. | Withdrawn |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005062 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2343 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of Bridge ID | Intel | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Saso (Intel) withdraws S2-2005062. | Withdrawn |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005064 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0481 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of Bridge ID | Intel | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Saso (Intel) withdraws S2-2005064. | Withdrawn |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005151 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2410 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify the Announe message handling | ZTE | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005896 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. zhendong (ZTE), provides the clarification Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds. Devaki (Nokia) agrees with Ericsson, believes CR is not needed nor aligned with Rel-16 functionality, also not FASMO. Shabnam (Ericsson), this is not FASMO but change of function, comments. Devaki (Nokia) answers zhendong (ZTE), provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005896 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2410R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify the Announe message handling | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005151. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005152 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2411 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarify the time synchronization figure | ZTE | Rel-16 | Noted | zhendong (ZTE), agree with devaki comments zhendong (ZTE), clarify the issue in the original figure Devaki (Nokia) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson), objects to the CR, not correct update of the figure, see comments. Sang-Jun (Samsung) proposes to note the CR. Qianghua (Huawei) agrees with the problems. zhendong (ZTE), provies the response to samsung zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Chunshan (Tencent) support s Nokia's proposal. Devaki (Nokia) proposes a way forward. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with Devaki's proposal Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts the way forward proposed by Devaki (Nokia). zhendong (ZTE), provides the r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) maintains objection to any revision of the CR, we have had this discussion before and no FASMO found here and no confusion from IEEE on the figure reported. zhendong (ZTE), clarify the concnern. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, adding a note under the existing diagram to find way forward. Devaki (Nokia) has concerns with r02, prefers original version or r01 only. Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to any revisions except r02. There is nothing wrong in the figure to change now. Devaki (Nokia) comments that we should bring up the CR for discussion during SA2#140E CC#2. The figure is incorrect in our view thus the CR is indeed FASMO, original version or r01 provide the fix for it. zhendong (ZTE), provides the proposal Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Qianghua (Huawei) asks questions on Ericsson comment 'referring to wrong clause' Shabnam (Ericsson) can accept ZTE proposal, as part of the HW proposal was referring to wrong clause. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005153 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2352 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the SMF determining the DS-TT PMIC and NW-TT PMIC | ZTE | Rel-16 | Noted | György (Ericsson) thinks this is not FASMO zhendong (ZTE), provides the clarifiction Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005154 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0484 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding BMIC information to TSN part. | ZTE | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005897 | György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 to align with S2-2005608 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005897 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0484R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Adding BMIC information to TSN part. | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005154. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005155 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0485 (Rel-16, 'F'): Modify PCF selection and discovery with DS-TT MAC address | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005902 | zhendong (ZTE), please mark this CR as merged to S2-2005070 Haiyang (Huawei) proposes to merge this CR into S2-2005070 based on the discussion. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005226 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2414 (Rel-16, 'F'): Change port ID on the DS-TT to DS-TT port number | Tencent | Rel-16 | Noted | Saso (Intel) proposes to note this CR because it is not a FASMO. Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification that the CR is a FASMO. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005454 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2421 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the bridge model and NW-TT ports | ZTE | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004913, to S2-2005898 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this with S2-2005779 Saso (Intel) comments on the proposal to merge this with S2-2005779 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response zhendong (ZTE), provides r01 zhendong (ZTE), give the response on split between two cR Qianghua (Huawei) disagrees r01 György (Ericsson) comments. Saso (Intel) provides r02 György (Ericsson) provides r03 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to go in the direction of r02. Asks question for clarification regarding r03. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia regarding r03. György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia and provides r06. GYörgy (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. zhendong (ZTE), explain the different understadning Qianghua (Huawei) responds Devaki (Nokia) comments that Ericsson's revisions r03/r06 cause Non-backward compatible changes to N4. Saso (Intel) replies to Devaki. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response on Non-backward compatible Devaki (Nokia) responds to Intel. György (Ericsson) replies to Devaki. Devaki (Nokia) responds to ZTE regarding NBC. It is about NBC changes after spec is considered frozen for a given release. zhendong (ZTE), clarify the solution Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Saso (Intel) points to overlapping clause 5.8.2.11.X on BMIC with S2-2004913. Devaki (Nokia) proposes way forward i.e. remove all impacts to N4, simply keep the updates and correction to Bridge model description. Let us go with r02. We cannot accept r03/r06 as they are self-inconsistent CRs, can result in confusion for CT4. Qianghua (Huawei) only accepts r05 György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. György (Ericsson) disagrees with Huawei when they say that we specify parameters without giving a reason why the parameter is there. zhendong (ZTE), provides the proposal György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei, Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Ericsson ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005898 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2421R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the bridge model and NW-TT ports | ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005454, merging S2-2004913. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005455 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2366 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the serving NW-TT port | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005901 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this with S2-2005781 Saso (Intel) supports the proposal to merge this with S2-2005781 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005484 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0487 (Rel-16, 'F'): BSF updates for TSN support | Samsung | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005902 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Sang-Jun (Samsung) replise to Sebastian (Qualcomm).and clarifies that 5484 is merged to 5070, as they are addressing the same issue with similar approaches. Sang-Jun accepts r01 provided by Sebastian (Qualcomm). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005608 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2435 (Rel-16, 'F'): Remove bridge name to align with CT WG3 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005609 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2387 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification for merge clash on approved proposal | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005901 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this with S2-2005781 Saso (Intel) supports the proposal to merge this with S2-2005781 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005610 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2436 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification for Serving NW-TT port | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005900 | Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to merge this with S2-2005779 György (Ericsson) agrees to merge this into S2-2005779, hence this CR will not be considered further. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005629 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2441 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on the SMF determining the DS-TT PMIC and NW-TT PMIC | ZTE | Rel-16 | Noted | Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (original and revision) zhendong (ZTE), provides the clarification Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) reconfirms objection to the CR (original and revision) ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005725 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2446 (Rel-16, 'F'): Resolution of open items related to IEEE LS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005890 | Shabnam (Ericsson) revises r01 to update conflicts between multiple CRs. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Devaki (Nokia) responds to HUA comment ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005890 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2446R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Resolution of open items related to IEEE LS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005725. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005726 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2390 (Rel-16, 'F'): 23.502 - Resolution of open items related to IEEE LS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005727 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0488 (Rel-16, 'F'): 23.503 - Resolution of open items related to IEEE LS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005764 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2448 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update the UE-DS-TT Resident Time | Tencent | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005899 | Xiaowan (vivo) provides comments and r01. Chunshan (Tencent) provides responses and r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (original and all revisions) Chunshan(Tencent) provides clarifications to Sebastian. Chunshan(Tencent) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) believes it is not FASMO but can live with r03 (only). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005899 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2448R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update the UE-DS-TT Resident Time | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005764. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005765 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2449 (Rel-16, 'F'): Change the Default QoS Flow to the QoS Flow with the default QoS rule | Tencent | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005779 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2451 (Rel-16, 'F'): Moving NW-TT ports from BMI into BMIC | Intel | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005610, to S2-2005900 | Saso (Intel) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 Saso (Intel) is OK with r02; comments on r03. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Saso Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Devaki. Saso (Intel) provides r04. Devaki (Nokia) points out change to 5.8.2.11.9 in r04 is not correct. Saso (Intel) replies to Devaki (Nokia). György (Ericsson) replies to Devaki (Nokia) that the text in the CR is correct about single NW-TT port number in the BMI. Devaki (Nokia) comments. György (Ericsson) responds. Saso (Intel) comments. zhendong (ZTE), adding ZTE as co-signer Saso (Intel) is fine to go with 5779r4 minus the change in clause 5.8.2.11.9. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to go with 5779r4 minus the change in clause 5.8.2.11.9 (as changes to N4 results in different interpretations for CT4) and come back with changes to 5.8.2.11.9 for next meeting. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005900 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2451R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Moving NW-TT ports from BMI into BMIC | Intel, ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005779, merging S2-2005610. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005781 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2396 (Rel-16, 'F'): Moving NW-TT ports from BMI into BMIC | Intel | Rel-16 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005609 and S2-2005455, to S2-2005901 | Saso (Intel) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02; Saso (Intel) ok with r02. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03. György (Ericsson) provides r04. Saso (Intel) OK with r03 and r04. Saso (Intel) provides r05. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005901 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2396R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Moving NW-TT ports from BMI into BMIC | Intel, ZTE | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005781, merging S2-2005609 and S2-2005455. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005846 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2454 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifying PSFP support for 5GS bridge | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005884 | Saso (Intel) thinks S2-2005846 can be considered merged into S2-2004902 Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with Saso; the CR can be considered merged ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005070 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0482 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on BSF behaviour for TSN service | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005484 and S2-2005155, to S2-2005902 | Haiyang (Huawei) provides r01 as the merge of S2-2005155 and S2-2005484. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. Haiyang (Huawei) responses and r03 is OK for us. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.2 | S2-2005902 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0482R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on BSF behaviour for TSN service | Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005070, merging S2-2005484 and S2-2005155. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | 5GS Enhanced support of Vertical and LAN Services – Type a/b aspects | - | - | Docs:=33 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | LSs and related CRs | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2004808 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on NG-RAN behaviour upon AMF triggered changes of the MRL for PNI-NPN | RAN WG3 (R3-204324) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2005280 and S2-2005575. Final response in S2-2005904 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005328 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2415 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of HO triggered by MRL | OPPO | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005906 | Fei (OPPO) provides r01 . Fei (OPPO) proposes to mark merged into revision of S2-2005535 . ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005329 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2357 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of HO triggered by MRL | OPPO | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005574 and S2-2005536, to S2-2005903 | Fei (OPPO) provides r01 . Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 and comments. Fei (OPPO) provides r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r04 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005903 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2357R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of HO triggered by MRL | OPPO, Ericsson, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005329, merging S2-2005574 and S2-2005536. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005280 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on NG-RAN behaviour upon AMF triggered changes of the MRL for PNI-NPN | OPPO | Response to S2-2004808. Noted | Fei (OPPO) proposes to note this draft reply LS . Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note and mark the LS as merged into 5575 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005575 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on NG-RAN behaviour upon AMF triggered changes of the MRL for PNI-NPN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004808. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005904. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005904 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on NG-RAN behaviour upon AMF triggered changes of the MRL for PNI-NPN | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005575. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005051 | LS In | Action | LS from TSG CT: LS on human-readable network name (HRNN) | TSG CT (CP-201361) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005573. Final response in S2-2005911 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2004863 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2266R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Human readable name for SNPN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of (noted) S2-2002847 from S2#139E. CC#2: r03 with an added reference to 22.261 agreed. Revised to S2-2005910. | Hyunsook (LGE) has a comment. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) has same view with LGE Josep (DT) comments. Xiaowan (vivo) share the view to wait for SA1's inputs Fei (OPPO) has same view with LGE and MTK. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to original, r01 and provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and accepts r02 with a question on whether to also refer to 23.122. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the r03 to correct the reference to TS 23.122 Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that is not clear yet whether r02 or r03 is the correct revision to be approved Hualin(Huawei) also have problem to know which version will be accepted. R02 and R03 are different way. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005910 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2266R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Human readable name for SNPN | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: Revision r03 of S2-2004863 with an added reference to 22.261 . This CR was approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005573 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on human-readable network name (HRNN) | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2005051. CC#2: S2 2005573r02 was agreed. This was revised to S2-2005911 | Xiaowan (vivo) request to wait for SA1's inputs Hyunsook (LGE) has the same view with vivo. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) is ok with r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005911 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on human-readable network name (HRNN) | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005573. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.7.3 | - | - | - | Other CRs | - | - | Docs:=21 | - | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2004864 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2267R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Human readable name for CAG-ID | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of (noted) S2-2002848 from S2#139E. Noted | Hyunsook (LGE) has a comment. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) has same view with LGE Josep (DT) comments. Fei (OPPO) has same view with LGE and MTK. Xiaowan (vivo) share the view to wait for SA1's inputs Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that the role of SA2 in this topic is one of alignment since the core specs are in SA1 and CT1 so we have to wait for SA1 response at least before discussing this CR Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Haris. Haris (Qualcomm) asks technical justification on the proposal Haris (Qualcomm) sees no technical justification on the proposal and objects Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Qualcomm. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note this as also agreed by Peter. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005189 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2412 (Rel-16, 'F'): UE with an empty CAG list but CAG only is allowed to register the CAG cell | China Mobile, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Josep (DT) asks questions for clarification. Hyunsook (LGE) has a comment on requirement for this CR. Dan(China Mobile) replies Josep's question Josep (DT) replies to Dan Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provided r01 Josep (DT) points out that Docomo's revision is not valid (uploaded a Word document) Josep (DT) comments and proposes r02 with a much simpler formulation. Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concerns on the CR and its revisions. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Dan (China Mobile) provides reply to Peter's comments. Josep (DT) proposes a way forward. Dan (China Mobile) provide r03 based on DT's suggested way forward Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provide r04 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r05 and comments. Hualin (Huawei) provide r06. Dan (China Mobile) provide r07, changed based on r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR (all revisions) Dan (China Mobile) reply to Sebastian's question, and suggest the paper is value and let's try to give some suggestions when deploy it, please further think about it. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005192 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2413 (Rel-16, 'F'): Supplement for Manual Selection | China Mobile, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Covered by S2-2005607 (noted) | Josep (DT) asks question for clarification. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) propose to note this CR Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to merge this with S2-2005607 Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the CR Dan (China Mobile) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2005607 Devaki (Nokia) also believes this CR is not FASMO, rather a copy/paste from Stage 3 (RAN2/CT1 agreements). ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005465 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2422 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification to RAN sharing options involving NPNs | Intel | Rel-16 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2005905. CC#2: This was then noted and the allocated revision in S2-2005905 was withdrawn. | Xiaowan (vivo) provide comment and r01. Josep (DT) comments and proposes r02. Saso (Intel) comments and provides r03. Josep (DT) comments and provides r04 with extended cover sheet Saso (Intel) ok with r04. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r05 and a question on including ASN.1 content in cover sheet. Josep (DT) comments on r05 and provides r06. Irfan (Cisco) provides r08 Saso (Intel) is OK with r07 from Irfan (Cisco) Irfan (Cisco) comments, provides r07 Haris (Qualcomm) shares the views from Nokia. This CR is not FASMO as the 'consequences if not approved' field indicate. We propose to note it. This CR is not FASMO, the problem is already in TS 38.300 section 4.6. Nokia does not see the need to copy/paste the text from RAN2/3 specs to TS 23.501. In fact, r05 shows that the update is simply a reference and addition of Note again with a reference. This is not FASMO. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005905 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2422R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification to RAN sharing options involving NPNs | Intel | Rel-16 | Revision r08 of S2-2005465. WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005531 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2429 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on RRC Resume procedure when considering CAG information | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Lalith (Samsung) requests for clarification Hualin(Huawei) response to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith (Samsung) responds to Hualin(Huawei) Haris (Qualcomm) indicates the CR is not FASMO and objects Hualin(Huawei) response to Haris (Qualcomm) and provide r01. Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. Also in our view the stage 2 text is fine and this is not a FASMO CR. Hence we object that CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005535 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2430 (Rel-16, 'F'): 23.501: Revision on PNI-NPN CAG Configuration Update | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005722 and S2-2005328, to S2-2005906 | Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification. Hualin(Huawei) response to Fei (OPPO). Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for clarification. Hualin(Huawei) response to Guanzhou (InterDigital). Hualin(Huawei) provide S2-2005535r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to InterDigital. Fei (OPPO) is OK with r01 . Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r02; objects to r00 and r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005906 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2430R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): 23.501: Revision on PNI-NPN CAG Configuration Update | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson, OPPO | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005535, merging S2-2005722 and S2-2005328. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005536 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2377 (Rel-16, 'F'): 23.502: Revision on PNI-NPN CAG Configuration Update | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005903 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR and mark it as merged into S2-2005329 Hualin(Huawei) is ok to merge S2-2005536 to S2-2005329 based on offline discussion. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005571 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2382 (Rel-16, 'F'): Alignment with RAN specification on adding PLMN+CAG information in paging message | China Telecom | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005574 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2309R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of MRL with updated CAG information | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision of (noted) S2-2003602 from S2#139E Merged into S2-2005903 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR and mark it as merged into S2-2005329. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005603 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2432 (Rel-16, 'F'): NPN clarifications to align with CT WG1 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005908 | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r01 Josep (DT) proposes to merge this CR with the structure from Josep (DT) clarifies that the last comment refers to S2-2005854 (missing TDoc number in the comment) Qianghua (Huawei) OK to merge with S2-2005854 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005604 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2386 (Rel-16, 'F'): GUTI clarification for UE registration in an SNPN | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2005907 | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r01 Qianghua (Huawei) asks clarification. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides clarification Fei (OPPO) provides r02 . Qianghua (Huawei) replies. Qianghua (Huawei) thinks r02 OK. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r04 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 Fei (OPPO) is OK with r05. Youngkyo(Samsung) support r04&r05 and provide r06. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r05. Devaki (Nokia) supports r04 and provides r05. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r07. Xiaowan (vivo) is OK with r07. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r07 Fei (OPPO) is OK with r07. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005907 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2386R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): GUTI clarification for UE registration in an SNPN | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r07 of S2-2005604. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005605 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Reporting of CAG ID list per cell over N2. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005606 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2433 (Rel-16, 'F'): Report of CAG ID list per cell over N2 | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR Peter Hedman (Ericsson) objects to the CR. Devaki (Nokia) objects to the CR. This is adding new functionality, not FASMO. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005607 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2434 (Rel-16, 'F'): Manual CAG selection clarification | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Noted. CC#2:There were objections to this CR and it remained noted. | Xiaowan (vivo) request merge S2-2005607 and S2-2005192 Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Qianghua and provide r01 Qianghua (Huawei) is OK with R01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Devaki (Nokia) comments that this CR is not FASMO, no need to copy all RAN2 (and other WG) agreements into TS 23.501. Objects to the CR and its revisions. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 and responses. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and supports r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides comments Dan (China Mobile) provides comments and support r03 Dan (China Mobile) provides r04 to reflect the Sebastian's suggestion Qianghua (Huawei) suggests r04 as way forward ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005722 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2445 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of MRL with updated CAG information | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2005906 | Fei (OPPO) comments. Hualin(Huawei) response to Fei (OPPO) comments and provide comments to Peter(Ericcson). Fei (OPPO) provides reply to Hualin (Huawei). Hualin respond to Fei (OPPO). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and a way forward. Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification. Xiaowan (vivo) asks question for clarification for option2. Fei (OPPO) provides response to Peter (Ericsson) . Fei (OPPO) provides responses to Xiaowan (vivo) and Devaki (Nokia). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to note the CR and mark it as merged into S2-2005535 and answers Sebastian. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005724 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2302R2 (Rel-16, 'F'): Include NID in NSSF services | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision of (noted) S2-2003212 from S2#139E. CC#2: Noted | Patrice (Huawei) objects to the CR. Devaki (Nokia) responds to HUA objection. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Patrice (Huawei) replies. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Patrice (Huawei) replies and provides r02 based on Nokia's comments, objects to r00 and r01. Devaki (Nokia) proposes that r02 goes beyond the scope of Vertical_LAN, also not NBC for non-roaming scenarios. Proposes that we shall bring up this discussion to SA2#140E CC#2 for plenary's attention. Patrice (Huawei) replies and provides r03. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei and agrees with Nokia that r02 goes beyond scope of Vertical_LAN. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply that Huawei has not replied to the technical comments given and objects to r03. Patrice (Huawei) proposes then to note the CR. Irfan (Cisco) asks question for clarification and proposes to go with original CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Patrice (Huawei) comments further. Josep (DT) would like to reflect on the issue and comments. Irfan (Cisco) provides comments. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005854 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2455 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of network sharing for NPN | Cisco Systems | Rel-16 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005603, to S2-2005908 | Qianghua (Huawei) provides a merged version of S2-2005854 and S2-2005603. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r06 and comments. Xiaowan (Ericsson) provides r07. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r08 Sebastian (Qualcomm) can only accept r08; objects to other versions ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.7.3 | S2-2005908 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2455R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification of network sharing for NPN | Cisco Systems, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson, vivo | Rel-16 | Revision r08 of S2-2005854, merging S2-2005603. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | - | - | - | Enhancements to the Service-Based 5G System Architecture (5G_eSBA) | - | - | Docs:=26 | - | |
| 7.8 | S2-2004802 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | CT WG4 (C4-203429) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2005384 and S2-2005703. Final response in S2-2006480 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.8 | S2-2005384 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS response clarification on SCP registration and discovery | Huawei,HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004802 Merged into S2-2006480 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this LS into 5703 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2005703 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | Nokia; Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Response, merging S2-2005384, to S2-2004802. r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006480. | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 based on agreements of SA2 CC1, suggest using this as basis for a merged LS Fenqin(Huawei) comments and provides r02 Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to r02 Thomas(Nokia) provides r03 Josep (DT) objects to r00, is generally concerned with how A3 is written and provides r04. Josep (DT) provides r05 correcting a typo in his proposed sentence (my use -> may use) Magnus H (Ericsson) OK with r05 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006480 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r05 of S2-2005703, merging S2-2005384. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.8 | S2-2004827 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2384 (Rel-16, 'F'): SCP domain in NF profile | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006484 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this contribution into 5712 Uri (Oracle) provides a comment. Uri (Oracle) provides r01. Jinguo(ZTE) agree to merge with 5712 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2004828 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2327 (Rel-16, 'F'): SCP domain in NF profile | ZTE | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006485 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this contribution into 5718 Uri (Oracle) provides a comment. Uri (Oracle) provides r01. Jinguo(ZTE) agree to merge with 5718 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2005145 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2409 (Rel-16, 'F'): Routing Binding indication without delegated discovery | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006481 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Magnus H (Ericsson) we accept r01 Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Magnus H (Ericsson) responds. Thomas (Nokia) responds to Fenqin. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006481 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2409R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Routing Binding indication without delegated discovery | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005145. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005146 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2349 (Rel-16, 'F'): Routing Binding indication without delegated discovery | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006482 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 and r02 and asks to ignore r01 Magnus H (Ericsson) we accept r02 Magnus H (Ericsson) comments. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Fenqin Fenqin (Huawei) comments Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006482 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2349R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Routing Binding indication without delegated discovery | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005146. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005382 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2418 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update to SCP Profile and NF profile | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006484 | Thomas (Nokia) comments Josep (DT) agrees with Nokia's view. Fenqin (Huawei) responds Josep (DT) comments on Fenqin's reply. Magnus H (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia and DT Thomas (Nokia) responds to Fenqin Josep (DT) comments on Fenqin's reply (last email went to wrong thread). Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging the CR into 5712 Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Fenqin (Huawei) comments and upload r01 Josep (DT) asks for clarification regarding 'Interconnected SCP Domain(s)' Thomas(Nokia) objects to version 0 and 1 and again suggest merging Antoine (Orange) objects to all versions. Fenqin(Huawei) responds. Uri(Oracle) responds. Fenqin(Huawei) responds and agree to merge to 5712. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2005383 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2360 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update to SCP discovery | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006485 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging the CR into 5718 Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Fenqin (Huawei) agree to be merged to 5718 Thomas (Nokia) again suggest to consider this CR merged into 5718 and objects agreeing this CR as it covered by multi-company contribution 5718. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2005545 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2431 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction for NF instance set | China Mobile, | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006483 | Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments. Dan (China Mobile) changes the coverpage and provides r01 Sangsoo (Samsung) ok with r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006483 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2431R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction for NF instance set | China Mobile, | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005545. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005712 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2444 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | Nokia; Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005775, S2-2005382 and S2-2004827, to S2-2006484 | Antoine (Orange): objects. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 based on agreements of CC, suggest using this as basis for a merged CR, asks Antoine if his objection also applies for r01 Fenqin (Huawei) comments and suggest to merge into 5382 Antoine (Orange) confirms that Orange's objection only applies to r00. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02, and explains differences to 5382 and why he prefers the present CR Magnus H (Ericsson) don't see the need for r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 Fenqin(Huawei) provides r04 Thomas(Nokia) accepts r04 Uri(Oracle) accepts r04 Uri(Oracle) asks that Oracle be added as a source company Jinguo(ZTE) cosign this contribution Fenqin(Huawei) cosign this contribution Thomas(Nokia) asks if more companies want to be added Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) accepts r04 and co-signs this contribution. Josep (DT) corrected a small typo in the definition (provides r05). Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to r02-r05 Fenqin (Huawei) provides r06 Thomas (Nokia) provides r07 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r08 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006484 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2444R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | Nokia; Nokia Shanghai-Bell, Huawei, ZTE,Oracle, Tencent, Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r08 of S2-2005712, merging S2-2005775, S2-2005382 and S2-2004827. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005718 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2389 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | Nokia; Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | r16 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005785, S2-2005383 and S2-2004828, to S2-2006485 | Antoine (Orange): objects. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 and r02 based on agreements of CC, Asks to ignore r01 suggest using r02 this as basis for a merged CR, asks Antoine if his objection also applies for r02 Jinguo(ZTE) provide r03 and r04 Jinguo(ZTE) asks to ignore r03 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provide r06 Uri (Oracle) provide r05 Sangsoo (Samsung) provides r07. Josep (DT) objets to NOTE 4 and provides r08 without it based on r07 Jinguo(ZTE) ask question to Sangsoo (Samsung) Sangsoo (Samsung) responses to Jinguo (ZTE) Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r09 Jinguo (ZTE) ask for further clarification from Sangsoo (Samsung) Josep (DT) comments and proposes r10. Thomas (Nokia) comments Sangsoo (Samsung) provides further clarification to Junguo (ZTE) Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Josep (DT) replies to Magnus (Ericsson). Fenqin (Huawei) comments and upload r11 Magnus H (Ericsson) cannot accept r11 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r12 Thomas (Nokia) provides r13 Fenqin (Huawei) One correction, the upload version is r14 Thomas (Nokia) corrects that Huawei uploaded r14 and comments Antoine (Orange) confirms that Orange's objection only applies to r00. Jinguo (ZTE) can cosign this paper. Jinguo (ZTE) comments Thomas (Nokia) asks if more companies desire to cosign. Sangsoo (Samsung) can live with r14 and wants to co-sign. ? Fenqin (Huawei) We support r14 version. Uri (Oracle) responds to Thomas (Nokia)'s question. Thomas (Nokia) provides r15 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r16 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006485 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2389R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarifications on SCP registration and discovery procedures | Nokia; Nokia Shanghai-Bell, Tencent; Ericsson, Huawei, Oracle, ZTE, Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision r16 of S2-2005718, merging S2-2005785, S2-2005383 and S2-2004828. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005761 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2447 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SCP selection to support multi-SCPs | Tencent | Rel-16 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006486 | Josep (DT) proposes to note this CR. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) replies and provide r01. Josep (DT) is OK with r01 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006486 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2447R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Clarification on SCP selection to support multi-SCPs | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2005761. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005769 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2394 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Nnrf_NFManagement_NFStatusSubscribe service operation | Tencent | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006487 | Josep (DT) comments and provides r01 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) comments. Thomas (Nokia) prefers r02. Fenqin (Huawei) can live with r02. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) prefers r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006487 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2394R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Nnrf_NFManagement_NFStatusSubscribe service operation | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005769. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005775 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2450 (Rel-16, 'F'): Update of NF profile and SCP profile to support multi-SCPs | Tencent | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006484 | Uri baniel (Oracle) provides r1. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) replies. Josep (DT) comments and suggests to wait until after the Wednesday CC. Thomas (Nokia) comments Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) comments Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this contribution into 5712 Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) agrees with Thomas to merge this contribution into 5712 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.8 | S2-2005780 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2395 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Nnrf_NFManagement_NFStatusNotify service operation | Tencent | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006488 | Josep (DT) comments and provides r01 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.8 | S2-2006488 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2395R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction on Nnrf_NFManagement_NFStatusNotify service operation | Tencent | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005780. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.8 | S2-2005785 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2397 (Rel-16, 'F'): Nnrf service operation correction | Tencent | Rel-16 | Merged into S2-2006485 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging the CR into 5718 Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) agrees with Thomas to merge this contribution into 5718 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 7.9 | - | - | - | Architecture enhancements for the support of Integrated access and backhaul (IABARC) | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 7.9 | S2-2004773 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS to SA2 on QoS requirements for OAM traffic on IAB | SA WG5 (S5-202458) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2003559 from S2#139E. Response drafted in S2-2005828. Final response in S2-2006489 | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Replied to |
| 7.9 | S2-2005828 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on QoS requirements for OAM traffic on IAB | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004773. r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006489. | Paul (Ericsson) provides r01 of the [DRAFT] Reply LS on QoS requirements for OAM traffic on IAB. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments. Alessio (Nokia) provides comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides a response. Mehrdad(Samsung) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. Paul (Ericsson) provides r04. Wanqiang (Huawei) support r04. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r04. Mehrdad(Samsung) is OK with r04. Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r04. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.9 | S2-2006489 | LS OUT | Approval | Reply LS on QoS requirements for OAM traffic on IAB | SA WG2 | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005828. Approved | Approved | |
| 7.9 | S2-2005825 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2452 (Rel-16, 'C'): New 5QIs for OAM traffic over IAB | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006490 | Haiyang (Huawei) asks for clarification and comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides question for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) response to Haiyang (Huawei). Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. Given absence of the use case, we object to this CR. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. Mehrdad comments on r02. Haiyang (Huawei) is OK with r03. Haiyang (Huawei) supports r02. Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r03. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.9 | S2-2006490 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2452R1 (Rel-16, 'C'): New 5QIs for OAM traffic over IAB | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2005825. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.9 | S2-2005827 | CR | Approval | 23.203 CR1131 (Rel-16, 'C'): New QCIs for OAM traffic over IAB | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) asks for clarification and comments. Paul (Ericsson) provides question for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Haiyang (Huawei). Paul (Ericsson) provides comments. Given absence of the use case, we object to this CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10 | - | - | - | Other Rel-16 WIDs | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 7.10.1 | - | - | - | Enhancement of URLLC supporting in 5GC (5G_URLLC) | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2004809 | LS In | Action | LS from RAN WG3: LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | RAN WG3 (R3-204325) | Rel-16 | Responses drafted in S2-2005011, S2-2005131, S2-2005370 and S2-2005859. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005371 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2416 (Rel-16, 'F'): TSCAI update during Handover procedure | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) provides r01. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the paper and continue the way proposed in S2-2005370 r01. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005372 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2358 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS related parameters to be updated during Handover | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-16 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) provide r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provide r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the paper. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005858 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2401 (Rel-17, 'F'): Clarifying the QoS parameters that can be updated in Path switch request, RAN WG3 LS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Confirm CR Number - CR number missing! Covered by S2-2005372 (noted) | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this as merged with S2-2005372. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005011 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004809. Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE the paper and continues the discussion with S2-2005370. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine to note this one and continues the discussion with S2-2005370. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005131 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004809. Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005370 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS to RAN WG3 for clarification of QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004809. Postponed | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment about answer for Q2. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Hui NI (Huawei) replies. Jinguo (ZTE) comment Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments and questions Hui Ni (Huawei) replies and asks for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provide comments. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to simplify the LS. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Nokia's comment. Qian Chen (Ericsson) proposes the way forward and provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and object r02 and the original, accepts only r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports r02. Devaki (Nokia) also supports r02. Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to postpone the LS. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and propose to go with r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) objects r01 and can only live with r02. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok to postpone the paper. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005859 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Response LS on QoS Parameters Update at Xn Handover | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Response to S2-2004809. Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the paper and continue the discussion on S2-2005370. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2004933 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG3: LS on Support of Dual Connectivity end to end Redundant User Plane Paths | CT WG3 (C3-203678) | Rel-16 | Response dafted in S2-2005120. CC#2: Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005121 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2408 (Rel-16, 'F'): Indication of redundancy transmission | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: This CR was noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) comments, Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Devaki (Nokia) provides revision 01. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Hui Ni (Huawei) comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies. Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to postpone this tdoc. Belen (Ericsson) wants to raise for the chariman notes that Huawei just asked for clarifications without providing any counter proposal or revisions. Ericsson ask not to pospone this topic. Huawei can always come back with new CRs if needed, Hui Ni (Huawei) proposed a revision that we can accept for this meeting. Hui Ni (Huawei) clarifies postpone request was sent before deadline and should be considered as valid. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Gerald (Matrixx) ask for clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) reply to Huawei with a suggestion. Jinguo(ZTE) don't think there is over charge issue ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005122 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2347 (Rel-16, 'F'): Indication of allowed redundancy transmission in the subscriber profile | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: This CR was noted. | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to postpone this tdoc per comments to the related 501 CR S2-2005121. Belen (Ericsson) wants to raise for the chariman notes that Huawei has not send comments to this document so far. Also that Huawei has not expressed concerns before nor propose any revision, but just asked questions. Ericsson ask not to pospone this topic. Belen (Ericsson) states that no comments were received before 'Revision by', so ask to approve this document following E-meeting process. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005123 | CR | Approval | 23.503 CR0483 (Rel-16, 'F'): Policy control for redundant transmission for URLLC | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: This CR was noted. | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to postpone this tdoc per comments to the related 501 CR S2-2005121. Belen (Ericsson) wants to raise for the chariman notes that Huawei has not send comments to this document so far. Also that Huawei has not expressed concerns before nor propose any revision, but just asked questions. Ericsson ask not to pospone this topic. Belen (Ericsson) states that no comments were received before 'Revision by', so ask to approve this document following E-meeting process. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005120 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply to LS on Support of Dual Connectivity end to end Redundant User Plane Paths' | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004933. Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to postpone this tdoc per comments to the related 501 CR S2-2005121. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2004867 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2387 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction for URLLC GTP-U Path Monitoring | China Mobile, | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005132 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2348 (Rel-16, 'F'): QoS parameter update at Xn HO | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Covered by S2-2005372 (noted) | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to consider this as merged with S2-2005372. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.1 | S2-2005877 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG5: LS Reply on QoS Monitoring for URLLC | SA WG5 (S5-204537) | Rel-16 | Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | - | - | - | Enhancement of Network Slicing (eNS) | - | - | Docs:=21 | - | |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004800 | LS In | Information | LS from CT WG4: LS Reply on SNSSAI support in N4 Session Establishment | CT WG4 (C4-203215) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005485. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005485 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Reply on SNSSAI support in N4 Session Establishment | Samsung | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004800. Noted | Patrice (Huawei) expresses concerns. The fate of the LS should depend on the outcome of the discussion in 5491. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes that the draft LS needs to be updated to reflect the CR changes. Hoyeon (Samsung) is fine with the suggestion by Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the LS. Tao (Chair) checks people view on way forward on this as well as the LS in 4800. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hoyeon (Samsung) is OK to note the draft LS as the related CR is postponed to the next meeting. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004794 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG1: LS on secure that a UE does not wait indefinitely for completion of NSSAA procedure | CT WG1 (C1-203895) | Rel-16 | Response drafted in S2-2005321. Noted | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005321 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on secure that a UE does not wait indefinitely for completion of NSSAA procedure | LG Electronics | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004794. Noted | Fei (OPPO) proposes to NOTE this draft reply LS. Hyunsook (LGE) replies to Fei (Oppo) and provides r01. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Hyunsook (LGE) replies to Hoyeon (Samsung). Fei (OPPO) still does not see any need to send the LS. Hyunsook (LGE) asks a question to Alessio (Nokia) and comments Alessio(nokia) responds Hyunsook (LGE) accepts your suggestion. It can be noted Tao (Chair) propose to NOTED LS in, i.e., S2-2004794 (C1-203895) ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004786 | LS In | Action | LS from CT WG4: LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address | CT WG4 (C4-203452) | Rel-16 | Revision of postponed S2-2004635 from S2#139E. Responses drafted in S2-2004879 and S2-2005477. Postponed | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004879 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS Response on Clarification on AAA-Server address | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004786. CC#2: Noted | Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note this LS reply and use 5477 instead as the basis for the reply. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Patrice (Huawei) replies, and clarifies that the proposal is not FASMO, therefore does not comply to the meeting rules regarding Rel-16. Also, the incoming LS is about discrepancy between the text and the figure of the procedure, not about asking to change anything. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005477 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] Reply LS on Clarification on AAA-Server address | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Response to S2-2004786. CC#2: This LS was noted. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to decide which LS out to use dependent on the resolution of the topic, and objects to the current version of the LS. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004829 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2328 (Rel-16, 'F'): Missing N2 SM information from initial AMF to target AMF | ZTE | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004851 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2331 (Rel-16, 'F'): Removal of editor's note | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, Telecom Italia | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004877 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2389 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of AAA-S address in NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: Noted | Patrice (Huawei) objects to the CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Patrice (Huawei) comments further to Ericsson. CR is not FASMO and should be noted. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004878 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2332 (Rel-16, 'F'): Handling of AAA-S address in NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-16 | CC#2: Noted | Patrice (Huawei) objects to the CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Huawei. Patrice (Huawei) comments further to Ericsson. CR is not FASMO and should be noted. Jinguo (ZTE) comments Patrice (Huawei) replies to ZTE. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2004880 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2333 (Rel-16, 'F'): GPSI for NSSAA | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006491 | Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Samsung. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides following comments. Alessio(nokia) provides response to Samsung Hoyeon(Samsung) replies to Nokia Alessio(nokia) responds to Samsung and agrees no guidance on which GPSI to use is needed. Hoyeon(Samsung) prefers not to capture the guidance on which GPSI to be used as we have no clear requirements. Alessio(Nokia) provides R01 Alessio(Nokia) provides R02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) ok with r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006491 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2333R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): GPSI for NSSAA | Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2004880. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005380 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2417 (Rel-16, 'F'): Reactivation of previously rejected S-NSSAI due to NSSAA failure | Apple | Rel-16 | Noted | Fei (OPPO) provides r01. Dan(China Mobile) provides comment for r01 and seems the change is not correct. Fei (OPPO) provides response to Dan's comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and question whether the 23.501 CR is needed. Fei(OPPO) provides clarification. Alessio(Nokia) objects to any revision of this CR Alessio (Nokia) provides comments and agrees we need no 23.501 CR Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the CR. Krisztian (Apple) provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) objects to all revisions Krisztian (Apple) responds to Nokia. Alessio( Nokia) provides r03 Krisztian (Apple) objects to r03. Alessio(nokia) please reconsider as it is now clear that we have a dependency on a non 3GPP entity to make your proposal work... the AMF today if it ignores the request from the UE based on a previous status may not enable the UE to gain access again. This CR fixes that with no dependency on AAA-S behaviour. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005398 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2363 (Rel-16, 'F'): Reactivation of previously rejected S-NSSAI due to NSSAA failure | Apple | Rel-16 | Noted | Dan (China Mobile) provides a comment and propose another big change on UE side is needed otherwise this paper can not work. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r01. Fei (OPPO) provides comments and asks question. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and revision r02. Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r03 . Alessio(Nokia) objects to any revision of this CR Jinguo (ZTE) comments . Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Jinguo (ZTE) provides comment. Patrice (Huawei) proposes to note the CR. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and r04. Krisztian (Apple) provides comments and r05. Alessio (Nokia) reiterates the step of removing the S-NSSAI from rejected S-NSSAIs is NOT needed as the stage 3 cause code used to reject the S-NSSAIs allows the UE to request the S-NSSAI again based on local policy. There is no FASMO to fix hence this CR cannot be agreed. Alessio(Nokia) objects to all revisions Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia. Alessio(Nokia) reminds it is FASMO TIME so on that ground the nice to have features should be subject of TEI-17 or beyond work. So this is not something we can endorse for rel-16. Patrice (Huawei) comments. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Huawei and Nokia and provides r06. Alessio (Nokia) comments Krisztian (Apple) responds to Nokia. Alessio( Nokia) responds Patrice (Huawei) comments further. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Huawei. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) responds to apple. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005491 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2423 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI in N4 Session Modification | Samsung | Rel-16 | Postponed | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01. Dan (China Mobile) provides a comment Hoyeon (Samsung) responds to Dan. Dan (China Mobile) provides a further question Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Malla. Alessio(Nokia) asks question for clarification Patrice (Huawei) asks questions for clarification, and expresses concerns at the original proposal and its revisions until now. Hoyeon(Samsung) replies to Alessio and Patrice. Patrice (Huawei) answers the comment, tries to understand whether something is missing. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) and Patrice. Patrice (Huawei) further comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides two alternatives (r03 vs. r04). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) proposes to go with r03, if a CR is needed. Tao (Chair) asks can we go with either r03 or r04?. Any clear indication of way forward? Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Patrice (Huawei). Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to go with r03. Dan (China Mobile) provide comments Patrice (Huawei) asks to postpone to a later release. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Hoyeon (Samsung) can postpone it to the next meeting, but can't agree with that this is a new feature. Patrice (Huawei) further comment. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005505 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2369 (Rel-16, 'F'): S-NSSAI in N4 Session Modification | Samsung | Rel-16 | Noted | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments for clarification. Hoyeon (Samsung) responds to Malla. Patrice (Huawei) expresses concerns. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Hoyeon replies to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and propose to NOTE the CR. Hoyeon (Samsung) is fine to NOTE the CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005576 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2383 (Rel-16, 'F'): NSAAA re-authentication by AAA-S | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Noted | Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Alessio(Nokia) provides comment and agrees with Samsung we need to clarify whether a new status value is required or we use the 'pending' value. Patrice (Huawei) objects to the CR. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and asks a question. Hoyeon (Samsung) shares our view. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks a question. alessio(Nokia) comments Genadi (Lenovo) replies to NTT DoCoMo. Patrice (Huawei) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments and r01. Patrice (Huawei) comments, maintains objection. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia and Huawei and r02. Patrice (Huawei) comments, maintains the objection to all versions. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005597 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2385 (Rel-16, 'F'): Add a scenario of two serving AMFs for NSSAA procedures | CATT | Rel-16 | Noted | Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to NOTE the CR. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks questions for clarification. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies and provides r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and proposes to NOTE the CR as not FASMO. Hyunsook (LGE) has the same view with Ericsson. Yunjing (CATT) further clarifies but is fine to note the CR. Stefano (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification to Yunjing on issue of uniqueness of GPSI. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Hoyeon. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comment and questions about the interaction between the NSSAAF and AMF. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Stefano. Alessio(Nokia) We are not ready to accept this CR, we thing the NSSAAF can initiate a re-auth in all the PLMNs or just in one depending on what AMF addresses the UDM returns. This is enough Hoyeon (Samsung) proposes to NOTE the CR. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Nokia and provides r02 based on Nokia's comment. Alessio(Nokia) this CR is not FASMO so cannot proceed. Yunjing(CATT) thinks both the NSSAAF and AMF are impacted in any solution already discussed. It fine for us to stop working on the solution, but it is still unclear how does the NSSAA procedure work in two AMF scenarios based on the current specification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Ericsson. Yunjing(CATT) is fine to note the CR. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2005749 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2392 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of NSSAI in the Registration procedure and Service Request procedure | China Telecom | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006492 | Patrice (Huawei) provides r01. Alessio(Nokia) provides rev02 Alessio(Nokia) By the way shouldn't this CR be for TEI-16, 5GS-Ph1. There is nothing eNS about it! Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r03. Alessio(Nokia) accepts rev03. Still the WI code should be fixed? Can you provide r04 with the right WI code? Guillaume provides comments and r04. Patrice (Huawei) is OK with r04. Fei (OPPO) is fine with r04 . PInghui (China Telecom) accepts r04. Alessio(Nokia) we are ok with r04 also ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.2 | S2-2006492 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2392R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction of NSSAI in the Registration procedure and Service Request procedure | China Telecom | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2005749. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.3 | - | - | - | Optimisations on UE radio capability signalling (RACS) | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2004818 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2383 (Rel-16, 'F'): Signalling of UE Radio Capability ID in Registration procedure | Qualcomm Incorprorated | Rel-16 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006493 | Lalith(Samsung) provides r01. Qian Chen(Ericsson) provides comments and prefer original revision. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Qian Chen(Ericsson). Haris (Qualcomm) indicates r01 is not FASMO Qian Chen(Ericsson) responds to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith(Samsung) clarifies about FASMO. Lalith (Samsung) responds to Qian Chen(Ericsson) Lalith (Samsung) provides r02 Alessio(Nokia) provides comment Haris (Qualcomm) provides comment to r02 Lalith (Samsung) responds to the comments on r02 Lalith(Samsung) responds to Nokia Haris (Qualcomm) responds to the comments from Lalith and asks questions Lalith (Samsung) provides rev03 Alessio(nokia) provides comment and r04 Haris (Qualcomm) ok with r04 but does not solve the problem Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and ok with r04 Haris (Qualcomm) prefers r03 Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r03, but please tick 'impacts CN' on cover sheet during clean up. Lalith (Samsung) prefers r03, based on offline discussion. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r03. Wanqiang (Huawei) ask question for clarification regarding rev3. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Wanqiang (Huawei). Alessio(Nokia) yes we also agree rev 03 with CN ticked and UE unticked is to go for approval Chris (Vodafone) says UE box needs to be kept ticked. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2006493 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2383R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Signalling of UE Radio Capability ID in Registration procedure | Qualcomm Incorprorated, Samsung | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2004818. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2004819 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2326 (Rel-16, 'F'): Registration procedure across ePLMNs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r03 agreed in CC#2. Revised to S2-2006494 | Lalith(Samsung) provides r01. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Haris (Qualcomm) explains rationale for updating step 2 and provides revision with coversheet changes in r02 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r03 Lalith (Samsung) is fine with both r02 or r03 ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2006494 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2326R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Registration procedure across ePLMNs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r03 of S2-2004819. This CR was approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2004820 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3605 (Rel-16, 'F'): Mobility procedure across ePLMNs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | r01 agreed in CC#2. Revised to S2-2006495 | Chris (Vodafone) requests that we revise (to align) this 23.401 CR when the debate on the 23.501 CR in S2-2004819 is concluded. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 that align with related changes for 5GS in S2-2004818r03 and S2-2004819r01 ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.3 | S2-2006495 | CR | Approval | 23.401 CR3605R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Mobility procedure across ePLMNs | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-16 | Revision r01 of S2-2004820. This CR was approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.4 | - | - | - | Enhanced IMS to 5GC Integration (eIMS5G_SBA) | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2004882 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1234 (Rel-16, 'F'): HSS Selection Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006496 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Leo (Deutsche Telekom) provides r02 Yi (China Mobile) provides r03 Thomas (Nokia) provides r04 Yi (China Mobile) is fine with r04. George (Ericsson) We are OK with 04 ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2006496 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1234R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): HSS Selection Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r04 of S2-2004882. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2004883 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2391 (Rel-16, 'F'): HSS Selection Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006497 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 George (Ericsson) accepts r01 Yi (China Mobile) provides r02. Thomas (Nokia) prefers r01 but can accept r02 George (Ericsson) accepts r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2006497 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2391R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): HSS Selection Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2004883. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.4 | S2-2005808 | CR | Approval | 23.228 CR1235 (Rel-16, 'F'): Error correction for imsSubscriber Data Management Service and acquistion of an 5GS IP address for | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.5 | - | - | - | User Data Interworking and Coexistence (UDICoM) | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 7.10.5 | S2-2004881 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2390 (Rel-16, 'F'): HSS NF profile Update | Ericsson | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.6 | - | - | - | Enhancing Topology of SMF and UPF in 5G Networks (ETSUN) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 7.10.6 | S2-2005150 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2351 (Rel-16, 'F'): Modify the CN tunnel allocation step for SR procedure | ZTE | Rel-16 | Covered by S2-2005386 (approved) | Stefan (Ericsson) proposes to merge this into 5386 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 7.10.6 | S2-2005386 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2362 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections on link local address and CN tunnel info provision | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Approved | ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Agreed |
| 7.10.7 | - | - | - | 5GS Transfer of Policies for Background Data Transfer (xBDT) | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 7.10.7 | S2-2005068 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2344 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to the procedure for future background data transfer procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006498 | Belen (Ericsson) comments and asks for updates. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Haiyang (Huawei) responses. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02. ==== 4.X, 5.X, 7.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 7.10.7 | S2-2006498 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2344R1 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction to the procedure for future background data transfer procedure | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-16 | Revision r02 of S2-2005068. Approved | Agreed | |
| 7.10.8 | - | - | - | Single radio voice continuity from 5GS to 3G (5G_SRVCC) | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8 | - | - | - | Rel-17 SID/WID | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | Study on Enablers for Network Automation for 5G - phase 2 (FS_eNA_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=166 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005342 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Miscellaneous corrections for TR 23.700-91. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006226 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides revision r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006226 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Miscellaneous corrections for TR 23.700-91. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005342. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | Use Case Update | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2004822 | P-CR | Decision | 23.700-91: Update Use Case #7: Adding examples for the use case. | Sandvine, SKT, Spirent, Affirmed | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification Manuel (Sandvine): Sandvine provides comments to Yannick comments/questions. Ulf (Ericsson) provide concerns and comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia object to this proposal. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 1: Logical decomposition of NWDAF and possible interactions between logical functions | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005012 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update of solution #6: NWDAF decompose architecture. | Qualcomm Incorperation | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006227 | Soohwan (ETRI) asks for clarifications. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies ETRI's comment. Soohwan (ETRI) asks further clarification. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a few questions. David (Samsung) provides comments. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01 and replies comments. Aihua (China Mobile) provides comment. Yang Xu (OPPO) further comments on ML designer. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r02 to reply OPPO's comment. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments from Samsung and CMCC. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r03 to address Nokia and Samsung's comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r03. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r04 based on Nokia's comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r05 according to Samsung and ETRI's comments. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments on r04. David (Samsung) provides comments on r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to OPPO. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia ask for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies to Yannick. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to Qualcomm. Comment is resolved. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006227 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update of solution #6: NWDAF decompose architecture. | Qualcomm Incorperation | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005012. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005357 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to clarify the solution. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006228 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. David (Samsung) provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) provides clarifications and r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. David (Samsung) comments on r01. Aihua (China Mobile) responses to Yannick (Nokia) and David (Samsung), and provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r02. Aihua (China Mobile) responses to Yannick (Nokia), and provides r04. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r04. Aihua (China Mobile) responses to Yannick (Nokia), and provides r05. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r05. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006228 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol #7: Update to clarify the solution. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005357. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005437 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol #8: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006229 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies and provides r01. David (Samsung) provides comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to David (Samsung). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r02. David (Samsung) comments on r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006229 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol #8: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005437. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005346 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, #2, #11, New Sol: Service alternatives for NWDAF-to-NWDAF data collection interactions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006230 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) has question for clarification Soohwan (ETRI) asks for clarifications. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarifications. Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarification Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Ericsson. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Lenovo. Dimitris (Lenovo) asks whether S2-2005346 can be merged in S2-2005377 Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Dimitris (Lenovo). Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Soohwan(ETRI). Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Samsung. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Xiaobo and asks a clarification on r01 Soohwan (ETRI) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Dimitris (Lenovo), Soohwan (ETRI), and Yannick (Nokia) and revision r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r03. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides answers to Yannick (Nokia) and revision r04. Yannick (Nokia): r04 resolves Nokia's comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006230 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, #2, #11, New Sol: Service alternatives for NWDAF-to-NWDAF data collection interactions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005346. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005355 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1, Sol Evaluation, Conclusions: Key Concepts for NWDAF Functional split. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005470 | Dimitris (Lenovo) comments David (Samsung) agrees with Lenovo to postpone conclusions. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Dimitris. David (Samsung) provides comments. David (Samsung) provides comments, suggests to merge with S2-2005470. Xiaobo(Huawei) responds to David (Samsung) and OK to merge with S2-2005470. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005399 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Overall Evaluation on KI #1. | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005470 | David (Samsung) provides comments, suggests to merge with S2-2005470. Aihua (China Mobile) agree to mark S2-2005399 as merged. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005470 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#1 overall evaluation proposal. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | David (Samsung) would like to hear views from companies on way forward for KI#1. Xiaobo(Huawei) responds to David (Samsung) and support to take S2-2005470 as basis to perform interim evaluation. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia ask what the status is for this contribution. David (Samsung) replies. David (Samsung) provides r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments for clarification David (Samsung) is OK to postpone evaluation, provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports Yannick (Nokia) and requests to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI#1 to the next meeting Yannick (Nokia): Nokia propose to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI #1 to next meeting and to note S2-2005470r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 2: Multiple NWDAF instances | - | - | Docs:=47 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005116 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #1,#2 & #11 sol #9: Updates regarding authorization. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006329 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Magnus H (Ericsson) clarifies Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Nokia Magnus H (Ericsson) we are OK with this approach Yang (OPPO) requests clarification for Nokia's note proposal. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to OPPO. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia understand this pCR can be marked as merged with S2-2005789. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005789 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Updates to Solution #9. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T, Verizon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005116 and S2-2005798, to S2-2006329 | Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Lenovo. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01 as a merge proposal with S2-2005798. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide answers to Lenovo. Aihua (China Mobile) provide comments and r02. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r03 based on r01 which includes updates and comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia ask clarification to China Mobile. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r04 based on r01 which includes updates and comments. R03. Aihua (China Mobile) provides clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r06. Aihua (China Mobile) provides r05. Magnus H (Ericsson) recommends r05, can for now live with r06, and comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia recommends r06, object to r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006329 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Updates to Solution #9. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T, Verizon, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005789, merging S2-2005116 and S2-2005798. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005108 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11, Sol #10: Update to remove ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006231 KI #2, KI #11 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Ulf (Ericsson) provides revision r01 and answer Nokia comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Ulf (Ericsson) replies both Nokia and Samsung ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006231 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11, Sol #10: Update to remove ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005108. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005109 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11,13, Sol #10: Update to introduce Suppression of Notification. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006232 KI #2, KI #11, KI#13 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Ulf (Ericsson) answer comments from Nokia Yannick (Nokia): Nokia answer to Ericsson. Ulf (Ericsson) provides revision r02 Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r02. Ulf (Ericsson) clarifies Samsung's comments Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 to remove typo Mehrdad (Samsung) provided r04 Mehrdad (Samsung) provided r05 Ulf (Ericsson) is OK with r05 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006232 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11,13, Sol #10: Update to introduce Suppression of Notification. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005109. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005110 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11, Sol #10: Update to clarify how DCCF can be incorporated. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006233 KI #2, KI #11 | Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarifications. Ulf (Ericsson) answer and clarifies. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Ulf (Ericsson) clarifies comments from Nokia and provides a new revision r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Ulf (Ericsson) provide r02 and answer Samsung Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r02. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r03 and answers Nokia Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006233 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2,11, Sol #10: Update to clarify how DCCF can be incorporated. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005110. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005227 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update of solution 11. | CATT, OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005243, to S2-2006234 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and request for clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO)requests for clarification. Hucheng(CATT) replies to Nokia and NTT DOCOMO. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to CATT. Hucheng(CATT) replies to Nokia and provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006234 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Update of solution 11 . | CATT, OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005227, merging S2-2005243. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005243 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol#11: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006234 | Hucheng (CATT) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2005227. Jaehyu (LGE) agrees to Hucheng's suggestion to merge this paper into S2-2005227. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005002 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#12: Updated NWDAF profile for inter-NWDAF instance cooperation. | ETRI, UANGEL | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006235 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments. Seungik (ETRI) replies to Nokia and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarification Seungik (ETRI) responds to Samsung, Ericsson, Nokia; and provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides comments on r02. Seungik (ETRI) responds to Nokia; and provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006235 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#12: Updated NWDAF profile for inter-NWDAF instance cooperation. | ETRI, UANGEL | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005002. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005173 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol #13: Update to Time coordination for Multiple NWDAFs. | Samsung, AT&T | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006236 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006236 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol #13: Update to Time coordination for Multiple NWDAFs. | Samsung, AT&T | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005173. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005174 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol #14: Update to flexible Analytics data aggregation for multiple NWDAFs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006237 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Nokia and CATT Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT Yannick (Nokia): Nokia highlight that Samsung provided r02 on Tuesday. Mehrdad (Samsung) confirms r02 is provided Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides additional comments on r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03 and answers Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r04. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006237 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol #14: Update to flexible Analytics data aggregation for multiple NWDAFs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005174. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005349 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, #11, Sol #16: Updates to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006238 KI #2, KI #11 | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments and asks for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to LGE. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Yannick(Nokia)/Mehrdad(Samsung) and revision r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to clarifications from Huawei in r01 and provide further comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides further clarifications to Yannick(Nokia) and revision r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to comments and questions from Huawei. R02 is fine. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006238 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, #11, Sol #16: Updates to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005349. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005350 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #17: Update to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006239 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide further comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provide clarifications to Nokia questions and revision r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r02. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006239 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #17: Update to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005350. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005339 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #18: Updates to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006240 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006240 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #18: Updates to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005339. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005351 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #19: Update for removing ENs and clarification of concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006241 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006241 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #19: Update for removing ENs and clarification of concepts. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005351. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005343 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol#20: | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006242 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia) and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia) and provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006242 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol#20: | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005343. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005360 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #24: Resolving the ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006243 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01. Soohwan (ETRI) asks for clarification. Aihua (China Mobile) provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006243 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #24: Resolving the ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005360. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005554 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#24: Update to clarify Federated Learning in 5GC. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006244 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides answers. Soohwan (ETRI) asks the further clarifications Yang (OPPO) replies to ETRI and provides r02 Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments on r02 Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r03 per Soohwan's comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r03. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r04 according to Yannick's comment. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006244 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2, Sol#24: Update to clarify Federated Learning in 5GC. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005554. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005253 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol#26: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006245 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification for this solution. Yannick (Nokia): S2-2005253 and S2-2005653 change the same solution and have colliding changes. Can a merge be done? ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005653 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #26: Update to remove ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005253, to S2-2006245 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Jungshin (Samsung) provides answers to Nokia questions Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung. Yannick (Nokia): S2-2005253 and S2-2005653 change the same solution and have colliding changes. Can a merge be done? Jungshin (Samsung) replies to Nokia question Jungshin (Samsung) provides r01 Jaehyu (LGE) is OK with r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Jungshin (Samsung) replies to Nokia comments and provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006245 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol #26: Update to remove ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005653, merging S2-2005253. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005347 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, KI #11: Merge Solutions for Data Collection Coordination. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006246 KI #2, KI #11. Merge solutions #15, #22, #35 | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Hucheng(CATT) provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Hucheng(CATT) comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to CATT. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. Jaehyu (LGE) provides replies to CATT. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia)/Hucheng(CATT)/Jaehyu (LGE)/Mehrdad(Samsung). Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick and provides revision r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006246 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, KI #11: Merge Solutions for Data Collection Coordination . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005347. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005359 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Sol: Supporting re-selection of serving NWDAF due to UE mobility. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006247 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment for clarification Aihua (China Mobile) provides clarifications to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Aihua (China Mobile) provides clarifications. Aihua (China Mobile) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to comments from Yannick(Nokia) and provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006247 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Sol: Supporting re-selection of serving NWDAF due to UE mobility . | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005359. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005791 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Solution: Analytics handover. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006248 | Hucheng (CATT) provides a comment. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Manuel (Sandvine) provide comments Dimitris (Lenovo) asks for clarification Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide replies to questions raised and uploaded r01. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments and one concern Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) ok with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006248 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Solution: Analytics handover. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005791. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005793 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Solution: Distributed NWDAFs deployment and Aggregation Function. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006249 | Hucheng (CATT) provides a comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to CATT. Hucheng (CATT) replies to Nokia. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Seungik (ETRI) asks for clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides reply. Hucheng (CATT) requests for clarifications Ulf (Ericsson) comments and asks for clarifications Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide answer to questions raised by Ericsson and CATT, and provide r01. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification from Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide answer to questions raised by Samsung and Ericsson. Nokia provide r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some changes from Nokia. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung's comments and provides r03 with requested changes. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006249 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, New Solution: Distributed NWDAFs deployment and Aggregation Function. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005793. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005175 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Interim Evaluation - Flexible Analytics Aggregation. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggest to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI#2 to October SA2 meeting, and to note this contribution. Mehrdad (Samsung) agrees with Nokia proposal as far as it applies to all evaluation and conclusion PCRs for KI 2. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agree with Samsung. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005352 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #2, Sol Evaluation: Classification of Solutions for Multiple NWDAFs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to postpone this to the next meeting. Xiaobo (Huawei) agree to postpone all evaluations for KI#2. Ulf (Ericsson) concur Samsung and Huawei Aihua(China Mobile) concur on postponing evaluation work for KI#2. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005560 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Support Feature List for KI#2. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Mehrdad (Samsung) comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005683 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#2: Interim Evaluation - Mobility / Reselection Aspects. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggest to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI#2 to October SA2 meeting, and to note this contribution. Jungshin (Samsung) agrees with Nokia proposal to postpone ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 4: Remaining aspects on how to ensure that slice SLA is guaranteed | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005469 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4, Sol#2: Removal of ENs on slice load analytics. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005595 and S2-2005632, to S2-2006250 | David (Samsung) provides r01: merger with S2-2005632 (NTT DOCOMO) and S2-2005595 (CATT) Belen (Ericsson) provides comments. Yunjing (CATT) comments that the link for r01 is wrong. David (Samsung) provides the correct link for r01. David (Samsung) replies to Belen, suggests to use S2-2005634 for enforcement issues. Yunjing (CATT) provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) replise to comments and clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. David (Samsung) provides clarifications and comments before providing new revision. Peretz (Spirent) asking for clarification and/or text addition to clause 6.2.1.2 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung. David (Samsung) provides r04 and set of comments/replies. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r04. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides clarifications to Yannick (Nokia) and provided r05. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r06. David (Samsung) provides r07. Peretz (Spirent) agrees to r07. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006250 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4, Sol#2: Removal of ENs on slice load analytics. | Samsung, NTT DOCOMO, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005469, merging S2-2005595 and S2-2005632. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005595 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #3, Sol#2: Update the solution to remove ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006250 (KI#3) | David (Samsung) informs this contribution has been merged into S2-2005469. Yunjing (CATT) is ok to merge into S2-2005469. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005632 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#4, Sol#2: update to address the editor's note. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006250 | David (Samsung) informs this contribution has been merged to S2-2005469. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is ok to merge into S2-2005469. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005634 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key Issue #4 solution evaluation and interim conclusion. | NTT DOCOMO, Samsung | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006251 | David (Samsung) provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r02. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03. David (Samsung) provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) replies David (Samsung) clarifies. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r04. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006251 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key Issue #4 solution evaluation and interim conclusion . | NTT DOCOMO, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005634. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 7: Adding Application attributes and KPIs as the Input data in some services described in TS 23.288 [5] | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2004974 | P-CR | Decision | 23.700-91: KI #7 New Sol: Adding Application attributes and KPIs as the input data in some services. | Sandvine, SKT, Spirent | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Manuel (Sandvine): provides r01, responds to comments and question from Nokia Manuel (Sandvine): provides r02 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia object to r01 and initial version. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005770 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol Z: Update to add the component of improves the QoS Sustainability Analytics ID. | Sandvine | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006330 | Belen (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification. Manuel (Sandvine) provides r01, answers questions from Ericsson. Belen (Ericsson) requests clarifications on r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Manuel (Sandvine): provides r02, responds to comments and question from Ericsson and Nokia Belen (Ericsson) provides comments to r02 Manuel (Sandvine) provides r04 Manuel (Sandvine) provides r03, responds to comments and question from Ericsson Manuel (Sandvine) Manuel (Sandvine) provides r06 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments and ask for revision if possible Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r05. Manuel (Sandvine) is also ok with r05 Andy (Convener) indicates r06 was after the revision deadline. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r05, cannot accept r06 which was provided after the deadline. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006330 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #7, Sol Z: Update to add the component of improves the QoS Sustainability Analytics ID . | Sandvine | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005770. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 8: UE data as an input for analytics generation | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005115 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on method for collection of data from the UE | Ericsson | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005559, to S2-2006292 | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments and provides r03. Yang Xu (OPPO) replies and provides r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Oppo and provides r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised | |
| 8.1 | S2-2006292 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on method for collection of data from the UE | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005115, merging S2-2005559. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005559 | LS OUT | Approval | KI#8: [DRAFT] LS on using 5G Media Streaming architecture for UE data reporting | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006292 | Belen (Ericsson) see no need to send the LS, given the discussion so far in S2-2005562 Yang Xu (OPPO) replies and provides r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) prefer to use the update of S2-2005115 and note this one. Yang Xu (OPPO) is fine to note this draft LS, as we expressed only one LS is needed. Yang Xu (OPPO): Mark it as 'Merged with 5115' is better, but 'NOTED' is also fine for me. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005107 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8 - Solution#27- UE data as an input for analytics generation. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006252 | Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a question for clarification Yang Xu (OPPO) asks for clarification Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some clarifications and suggest some changes Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments from Samsung. Belen (Ericsson) replies to OPPO comments Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments for clarification Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) replies to OPPO comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments fron OPPO. Yang (OPPO) replies to answers from Ericsson . Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some clarifications and suggest more changes over r01. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Samsung to check if responses to comments are okay for them. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson. Yang (OPPO) provides further commetns. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Samsung. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) replies that thre is an LS to SA4 in S2-2005115 Yang Xu (OPPO) suggests to use S2-2005559 for the LSout to SA3/4 which covers two possibilities for UE data reporting to MNO owned AF via application layer. Belen (Ericsson) replies to OPPO and comments Yang Xu (OPPO) replies to Ericsson Belen (Ericsson) asks Samsung and OPPO if comments were addresssed as expected. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r02 Yang (OPPO) is ok to r02. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006252 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8 - Solution#27- UE data as an input for analytics generation . | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005107. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005561 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Update to solution#28 for clarification. | OPPO, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006253 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Yang (OPPO) provides answers. Dimitris (Lenovo) asks for clarifications Yang (OPPO) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo) Dimitris (Lenovo) responds and has concerns with the solution Yang (OPPO) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) Yang Xu (OPPO) provides replies Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments. Yang (OPPO) provides r01 Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and has concerns in the solution. Yang (OPPO) replies to Ericsson and provides r03 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r03. Belen (Ericsson) is ok with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006253 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Update to solution#28 for clarification . | OPPO, Convida Wireless | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005561. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005176 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol #29: Update to UE Input data for CP load balancig analytics. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006254 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and updates to the contribution. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for further clarification from E/// Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Belen (Ericsson) replies and notices that no revision has been provided, so still asking for a revision. Mehrdad (Samsung) responds to Nokia. Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies further E/// and provides r03 and r04. Belen (Ericsson) prefers r03, r04 will be okay as well as starting point. However we have additional request for updates to this contribution. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r05. Belen (Ericsson) comments to r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Ericsson. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r06. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is okay with r06. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006254 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol #29: Update to UE Input data for CP load balancig analytics. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005176. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005341 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#29: Update to add an Application Status for the application data from UE. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006255 | Jaehyu (LGE) asks for clarification. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) support LG's comment and provide more comments Yang (OPPO) asks for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies Jaehyu (LGE), Juan Zhang (Qualcomm), Yang (OPPO) and provides S2-2005341r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request clarifications. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick(Nokia). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comment. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Juan (Qualcomm). Xiaobo (Huawei) further provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006255 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, Sol#29: Update to add an Application Status for the application data from UE. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005341. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005257 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, New Sol: Analytics for WLAN performance and WLANSP using UE Data. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006256 | Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and requests updates to the contribution. Jaehyu (LGE) asks for clarifications about the questions. Belen (Ericsson) replies to question from LGE. Jaehyu (LGE) replies to questions and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on the proposal. Jaehyu (LGE) replies to comments from Nokia. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Jaehyu (LGE) replies to Qualcomm's questions and provides r02. Peretz (Spirent) is asking for clarifications. Jaehyu (LGE) replies to Spirent's questions and provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides some comments. Peretz (Spirent) is asking for further clarifications. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides technical comments Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Jaehyu (LGE) replies to questions from Ericsson, OPPO, and Spirent Belen (Ericsson) wants to indicate that some comments are not addressed. Jaehyu (LGE) replies to Spirent and Ericsson, and provides r06. Peretz (Feder) incorporated a few more comments into r05. Peretz (Spirent) replies to r06 changes with a recommendation. Jaehyu (LGE) accepts Spirent's recommendation, and provides r07. Peretz (Spirent) accepts r07. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r07. Yang Xu (OPPO) is ok with r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006256 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, New Sol: Analytics for WLAN performance and WLANSP using UE Data. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005257. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005562 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, New sol: | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006291 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) supports Docomo's comment. Yang Xu (OPPO) repies. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments.. Yang (OPPO) replies. Belen (Ericsson) agrees with NTT DOCOMO and QC comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and asks a question. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r01. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) objects to the r01 and original pCR. Yang Xu (OPPO) asks Malla (NTT DoCoMo) reconsider the view because some other impact is also involved in the solution. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r02 and ask for approval in Tue's CC. Andy (Convener) indicates that he needs to hear if r02 is OK before adding to CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006291 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, New sol: | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005562. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005567 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, New Sol, Providing UE Analytics to the NWDAF. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia express concerns, don't see the need for any of the two solutions. Belen (Ericsson) support Nokia´s view and don't see the need of these two solutions. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to the comments and provides r01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments on r01. Belen (Ericsson) provides comments, raise objections to the solution that defines UPF reporting data is out of scope in our view. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) objects r01 since lots of comments raised before. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005709 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, New Sol: UE data as an input for service experience analytics. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006257 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) has questions for clarification Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to the comments and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment on r01. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Yannick(Nokia) comments and provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Yannick(Nokia) comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia can live with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006257 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#8, New Sol: UE data as an input for service experience analytics. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005709. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005795 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, KI#13, New Solution: Triggers for data collection from the UEs. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#4: r02 (with removal of notes 1 and 2, adding and editor's note) agreed. Revised in S2-2006041 | Zhuoyi (China Telecom) asks for clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to China Telecom. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) provides some clarifications on solution#27, and asks questions to this solution. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia respond to Ericsson, CATT, Qualcomm and Samsung, and provides r01. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia prefer r01. Belen (Ericsson) ask Nokia to propose a way forward Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02, and objects to 501 and initial version Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02, and objects to r01 and initial version Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification on r01 and r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia comment. Belen (Ericsson) provide a revision for the EN, and is okay with the proposal Mehrdad (Samsung) replies on Nokia proposed way forward. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia would like to propose a new revision r03 as way forward, and would like to ask if this can be discussed during Tuesday's CC. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006041 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #8, KI#13, New Solution: Triggers for data collection from the UEs. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r02 (with removal of notes 1 and 2, adding and editor's note) of S2-2005795. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 9: Dispersion analytic output provided by NWDAF | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2004988 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Solution Completion: Dispersion Analytic Output Provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Comm., AT&T, Convida Wireless, Sandvine | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006258 | Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarifications. Peretz (Spirent) replies to Xiaoyan's requested clarifications. Xiaoyan (CATT) requests further clarification. Peretz (Spirent) addressing Xiaoyan clarification requests and provides version r01 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r02. David (Samsung) provides comments. Peretz (Spirent) provided r03 Belen (Ericsson) comments Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r03. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Spirent question. Peretz (Spirent) asking Belen to clarify her question Peretz (Spirent) provided r04 addressing Belen's questions Belen (Ericsson) provides r06. Peretz (Spirent) provided updated version 07 addressing Belen's request Peretz (Spirent) asking Belen for clarification on her comment Belen (Ericsson) provides one more comment, mainly okay with r06 Peretz (Spirent) provided r06 with changes on top of Belen's r05 Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r06 Belen (Ericsson) does not think that 4988 r07 address our comments. r06 or r07 are acceptable for us. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006258 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #9, Solution Completion: Dispersion Analytic Output Provided by NWDAF. | Spirent Comm., AT&T, Convida Wireless, Sandvine | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2004988. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005111 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9, Dispersion analytics as Expected UE Behavior. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revised, adding 2 editor's notes, in S2-2006042 | Xiaoyan (CATT) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) provides some responses. Xiaoyan (CATT) thanks for the response and replies. Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to S2-2005111 and proposes a way forward. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01 and request to keep the document open for CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006042 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9, Dispersion analytics as Expected UE Behavior. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision of S2-2005111. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 10: NWDAF Assisted UP Optimization | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005344 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #10, KI#16, Sol# 31: Update solution 31 for NWDAF Assisted UP Optimization for edge computing. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006259 KI#10, KI#16 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and question for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick and provides revision r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia asks for clarification and revision. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick (Nokia) and provide r02. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia thanks for the clarifications and requests a revision. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Yannick (Nokia) and provide r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006259 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #10, KI#16, Sol# 31: Update solution 31 for NWDAF Assisted UP Optimization for edge computing . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005344. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005089 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, New solution on user plane optimization. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005288, to S2-2006260 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications David (Samsung) replies LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. David (Samsung) is OK with r01. Malla (NTT DOCOM) comments. Ulf (Ericsson) comment r01 David (Samsung) provides replies to Ulf's comments, asks for clarification. Peretz (Spirent) comment on S2-2005089r01 Ulf (Ericsson) reply on earlier comments from Samsung David (Samsung) provides r02, answers comments from Ericsson and Spirent. Ulf (Ericsson) is Ok with r02 Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. David (Samsung) provides clarification. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006260 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, New solution on user plane optimization. | Samsung, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005089, merging S2-2005288. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005288 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, New Sol: UE Communication Analytics for UP Optimization. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006260 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) can be merged with S2- 2005089 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005089 as Malla (NTT DOCOMO) suggested. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005327 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, New Sol: NWDAF assistance to support UP optimization. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006261 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Hyunsook (LGE) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01 David (Samsung) provides comments Manuel (Sandvine) asks for clarifications Peretz (Spirent) is asking a clarification question Hyunsook (LGE) clarifies. Manuel (Sandvine) responds to LGE Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Hyunsook (LGE) replies, and provides r03 (on top of r02 from Peretz). Peretz (Spirent) followed up on Hyunsook's request for proposed changes and provided r02 Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r04 and r05 Hyunsook (LGE) prefers r04. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r06 Hyunsook (LGE) can live with r06 at this meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006261 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#10, New Sol: NWDAF assistance to support UP optimization. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005327. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 11: Increasing efficiency of data collection | - | - | Docs:=25 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005798 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#9: Updates to remove ENs. | NTT DOCOMO, Verizon, Spirent, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006329 | Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides a response Aihua (China Mobile) comments. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) this pCR is merged into S2-2005789. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005340 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, Sol #32: Update to remove EN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006262 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications to Nokia and revision r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006262 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, Sol #32: Update to remove EN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005340. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005320 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#34: Update Solution Impact and remove EN. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006263 | Ulf (Ericsson) comments Song Zhao (China Telecom) replies Ulf (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Ulf (Ericsson) is OK with r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments on r01. Song Zhao (China Telecom) replies Yannick (Nokia) comments on r01 and provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006263 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Sol#34: Update Solution Impact and remove EN. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005320. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005705 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution 35 update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006264 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Malla and provides r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provide comments Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provide r03 Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r04 with minor editorial corrections Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r04 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006264 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution 35 update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005705. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005862 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, KI#13, Sol #37: Update to resolve ENs, include reduction of volume, and detail the triggers. | Orange, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006265 | Zhuoyi (China Telecom) asks for clarifications. Soohwan (ETRI) asks for clarifications. Antoine (Orange) provides r01 and requested clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Antoine (Orange) provides clarification and r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006265 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, KI#13, Sol #37: Update to resolve ENs, include reduction of volume, and detail the triggers. | Orange, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005862. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005374 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11 and #18, Sol#38: update to remove ENs with further clarifications. | ETRI | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2004853 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: TR23700-91_KI#11_Solution on storing high frequency behaviours and related important information in NWDAF | China Telecom Corporation Ltd. | Rel-17 | Revision of (noted) S2-2003847 from S2#139E. Noted | Antoine (Orange): objects. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia concur with Orange. Jungshin (Samsung) agrees with Orange and Nokia Liu Liu (China Telecom) response Antoine (Orange), Yannick (Nokia) and Jungshin (Samsung) Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply. Liu Liu (China Telecom) replies Yannick (Nokia) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005097 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Sol: NWDAF associated to the User-plane. | Sandvine, SKT, Spirent, Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006266 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and questions for clarifications. Manuel (Sandvine) provides r01, answers comments from Nokia. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comment and clarification Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide further comments on r01 and on Ericsson and Sandvine replies. Ulf (Ericsson) respond to question from Nokia Manuel (Sandvine) provides r02, respond to question from Nokia Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r03. Manuel (Sandvine) is ok with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006266 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Sol: NWDAF associated to the User-plane. | Sandvine, SKT, Spirent, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005097. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005112 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Persistent data collection subscriptions. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006267 (New solution) | Dimitris (Lenovo) asks for clarifications Ulf (Ericsson) provides answers to Lenovo Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Ulf (Ericsson) answer to Nokia's request for clarification Yannick (Nokia): Nokia responds to Ericsson and provides r01. Ulf (Ericsson) is OK with r01 Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Ulf (Ericsson) provides r02 and answer CATT's question Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006267 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, Persistent data collection subscriptions. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005112. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005377 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Sol: Solution for increasing efficiency of data collection. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | Dimitris (Lenovo) has concerns with the solution Malla (NTT DOCOMO) agrees with Dimitris (Lenovo). Yannick (Nokia): Nokia also express concerns on the proposal. Ulf (Ericsson) also has concerns Aihua (China Mobile) replies to the comments and provides r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) requests clarification on DCCF behaviour in this solution Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to comments from Malla (NTT DOCOMO) . Ulf (Ericsson) give comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia express concerns on the proposal. Aihua (China Mobile) responds to Yannick(Nokia) and Ulf(Ericsson) and provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) object to all revisions and original pCR. Aihua (China Mobile) disagrees and responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Ulf (Ericsson) objects to original pCR and all revisions and give comments Dimitris (Lenovo) objects to r02 and r01. Can live with original pCR Aihua (China Mobile) provides r03 based on comments from Ulf (Ericsson) and Dimitris (Lenovo) and request to keep the document open for CC#4. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on r03 Andy (Convener) indicates that he needs to hear if r03 is OK before adding to CC#4. Ulf (Ericsson) can live with r03 and gives comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Malla (NTT DOCOMO) comments on r03 Aihua (China Mobile) responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2005564 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11, New Solution: Consumer authorization for data collection from DCCF. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to NOTE Yang (OPPO) asks a question Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides response Yang (OPPO) replies Yannick (Nokia): Nokia express concerns on the proposal. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Yang Xu (OPPO) is fine to note this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005790 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Solution: Representative UEs sampling for data collection. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006268 | Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Ericsson. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments and some concerns Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Ericsson and provide r01. David (Samsung) requests clarifications. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Samsung and provide r02. David (Samsung) provides r01. Previous comment should be discarded, tdoc number in email subject/body is wrong. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments and ask for further clarification Ulf (Ericsson) provides r04 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006268 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Solution: Representative UEs sampling for data collection. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005790. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005792 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Solution: Efficient Analytics Transfer in mixed Deployments. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006269 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification Ulf (Ericsson) asks for clarifications and provides comments Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to NTT DOCOMO and Ericsson. Song Zhao (China Telecom) asks for clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) further clarification Song Zhao (China Telecom) asks for clarification for r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides answers and r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006269 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, New Solution: Efficient Analytics Transfer in mixed Deployments . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005792. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005325 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#11: Evaluation on solutions. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Noted | Antoine (Orange) comments. Song Zhao (China Telecom) replies comments from Antoine(Orange) and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggest to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI#11 to October SA2 meeting, and to note this contribution. Song Zhao (China Teleocom) provides reply to Yannick(Nokia)'s comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to China Telecom and request to note this document. Song Zhao (China Teleocom) provides reply to Yannick(Nokia)'s comments and provides r02. Dimitris (Lenovo) proposes to postpone evaluation of solutions addressing Key Issue ##11 to the next meeting and note S2-2005325 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agree with Lenovo and propose to note this evaluation. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005353 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #11, Sol Evaluation: Classification of Solutions. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia suggest to postpone evaluation of solutions for KI#11 to October SA2 meeting, and to note this contribution. Ulf (Ericsson) concur with Nokia Xiaobo (Huawei) concur with Nokia and Ericsson and ok to postpone. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005711 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation of solutions introducing a data collection function for Key Issue #11. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to postpone. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agree on NTT DOCOMO proposal to postpone this evaluation. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds Yannick (Nokia): Nokia reply to Lenovo. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine to NOTE. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005714 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Conclusion on solutions introducing a data collection function for Key Issue #11. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to postpone. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia agree on NTT DOCOMO proposal to postpone this conclusion paper. Antoine (Orange): agree with Nokia. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is fine to NOTE. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 12: NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005113 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key issue #12: NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy - proposal to merge. | Ericsson, China Telecom, Huawei | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006270 Merge solution #4 and #43 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Belen (Ericsson) replies to QC Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments. Belen (Ericsson) replise to QC and ask China Telecom and Huawei to comment if appropiated. Yifan (China Telecom) provides r01 Peretz (Spirent) asking for clarification Yifan (China Telecom) replies to Peretz and provides r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides comments Peretz (Spirent) is ok with r02 Belen (Ericsson) objects to r01 and r02 and initial version Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02. No objections raised. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is okay with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006270 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Key issue #12: NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy - proposal to merge. | Ericsson, China Telecom, Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005113. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005291 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12, Solution#42: Update to Clarify Analytics ID and Clean Up. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Lei (Tencent) provides r02. Lei (Tencent) confirms prefer r02 and doesn't accept r01. Belen (Ericsson) objects to intial revision and r02. Ericsson can only accept r01 Lei (Tencent) objects r01 and fine to NOTE the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2004929 | WID NEW | Approval | KI#12_Solution Evaluation and Interim Conclusion for NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed (Not a new WID!) | Belen (Ericsson) suggests to merge this evaluation and conclusions into S2-2005013, since it contains contradictory statements. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies and provide r2. Jungshin (Samsung) provides r03 Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies. Andy (Convener) asks if r01 has been provided. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) answers no r01 is provided. Belen (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this document. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) requests to keep the document open for CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2005013 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Interim conclusion for Key issue #12: NWDAF-assisted RFSP policy. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2004929. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this document. Not ready for conclusions Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK to note this one. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 13: Triggering conditions for analytics | - | - | Docs:=8 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005284 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#13, Sol#44: Update to remove EN. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006271 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answers. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006271 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#13, Sol#44: Update to remove EN. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005284. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2004930 | WID NEW | Approval | KI #13, New Sol: Trigger Procedures for Requesting Analytics. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006272 (Not a new WID!) | Jaehyu (LGE) responses to Zhuoyi's clarification. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) provides clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. David (Samsung) provides comments. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies to David. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia do not see what the solution is. Belen (Ericsson) don't see the need for this contribution. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) replies and provides R02. Andy (Convener) asks if r01 has been provided. Zhuoyi (China Telecom) answers no r01 is provided. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006272 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, New Sol: Trigger Procedures for Requesting Analytics. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004930. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005345 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, New Sol: AF influencing NF triggers for interactions with NWDAFs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: r04 (+ 3 ENs) agreed. Revised in S2-2006043 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01 and request for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Malla(NTT DoCoMo) and Yannick(Nokia) and provides r02. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides comments. Belen (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia would like to better understand the proposal. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides clarifications for Malla (NTT DOCOMO), Belem (Ericsson), Yannick (Nokia) and revision r04. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) can for now live with r04. Belen (Ericsson) accepts r03 and objects to all other revisions and initial version. Xiaobo (Huawei) propose to reintroduce in r04 the all ENs proposed by Ericsson in r03 and accept r04. Xiaobo (Huawei) requested to mark it as open and for discussion at CC#4 as Belen is ok with the compromise proposed. Xiaobo (Huawei) provides r05 based on discussion outcome with Belen (Ericsson)and request to keep the document open for CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006043 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, New Sol: AF influencing NF triggers for interactions with NWDAFs . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r04 (+ 3 ENs) of S2-2005345. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005438 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, New Sol: Trigger configuration for data collection and analytics. | CATT | Rel-17 | CC#4: r02 (with some ENs) agreed. Revised in S2-2006028 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r01 to address Yannick (Nokia)'s comments. Belen (Ericsson) objects to this contribution. Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) thanks for the clarifications and replies below Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies. Belen (Ericsson) asks questions for clarifications Xiaoyan (CATT) thanks for Belen (Ericsson)'s comments and provides further clarification. Belen (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this contribution. Xiaoyan (CATT) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and propose a way forward. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006028 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #13, New Sol: Trigger configuration for data collection and analytics. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r02 (with some ENs) of S2-2005438. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 14: NWDAF-assisted application detection | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005379 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#14, Sol#46: Removing FFS on how to determine App ID for new PFD. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | CC#4: This was postponed. | Aihua(China Mobile) provides feedback to Jaehyu (LGE). Jaehyu (LGE) asks for a clarification. Jaehyu (LGE) provide comments. Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jaehyu (LGE), Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r01. Jaehyu (LGE) provides comments. Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments and expresses concern. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jaehyu (LGE), Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r02. Jungshin (Samsung) provides r03. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications, and comments to document. Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification and further revision. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Belen (Ericsson). Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Jungshin(Samsung) and provides r06 (merged with 4817) and r07. Linghang (NEC) provides clarification to Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r08. Jungshin (Samsung) can accept r07 Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments on r08. Linghang (NEC) provides r09. Belen (Ericsson) provides r10. Aihua(China Mobile) provides r11 and replies to comments from Belen(Ericsson). Aihua(China Mobile) provides r12 to resume the IP 5-tuple. Aihua(China Mobile) can live with r13. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r13. Jungshin (Samsung): Samsung can accept r09 and r11, but object to r 10, r12, and r13. Belen (Ericsson) objects to r09 and r11, can live with r12 or r13 or r10, okay to postpone this topic. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to Belen and suggest to approve r11. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2004817 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#14 New Sol: NWDAF-assisted new application detection. | NEC | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005379 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Dimitris (Lenovo) asks for clarifications Linghang (NEC) provides clarification to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) Linghang (NEC) provides clarification to Dimitris (Lenovo) Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications. Linghang (NEC) provides clarification to Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) replies to NEC and again asks for clarifications. Belen (Ericsson) replies and objects to this contribution. Jungshin (Samsung) asks for clarification Linghang (NEC) replies to Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r01. Jungshin (Samsung) provides comments on r01 Belen (Ericsson) objects to r01 and initial revision. Linghang (NEC) replies to Jungshin (Samsung) and provides r02. Belen (Ericsson) asks NEC to reply to comments from Ericsson Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Linghang (NEC) replies to Belen (Ericsson) and provides r03. Linghang (NEC) replies to Yannick (Nokia) and provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) proposes to merge this document into S2-2005379 from China Mobile, since we believe both propose the same type of solution to this KI,. China Mobile solution is aligned with base line, while this solution is not and cannot be accepted. Linghang (NEC) agrees to merge S2-2004817 into S2-2005379 from China Mobile. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 15: User consent for UE data collection/analysis | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2004854 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution update for Solution#3: User consent for UE data collection. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005092, to S2-2006273 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01. Iskren (NEC) suggest to merge with S2-2005092 and provides r02. Yifan (China Telecom) agree with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006273 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution update for Solution#3: User consent for UE data collection . | China Telecom, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004854, merging S2-2005092. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005092 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#15 Sol#3: Updates to Solution #3 User consent for UE data collection. | NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006273 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments and suggest to merge with S2-2004854. Iskren (NEC) - As suggested by Yannick (Nokia), part of his pCR is merged to S2-2004854 r02. Iskren (NEC) answers Mehrdad (Samsung). S2-205092 was merged to S2-2004854 r02 Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for clarification from NEC and Nokia ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005794 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #15, New Solution: User consent revocation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006274 | Iskren (NEC) asks questions. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide reply to NEC. Iskren (NEC) asks for some further clarification. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia replies to NEC questions. Iskren (NEC) provides r01 with added Editor's note: Coordination with SA3 is required. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006274 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #15, New Solution: User consent revocation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005794. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005093 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#15 - Evaluation and conclusion for KI#15 User consent for UE data collection/analysis. | NEC | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006275 | Belen (Ericsson) request to have interim conclusions until SA3 feedback is received. Iskren (NEC) addresses the comment from Belen (Ericsson) and provides r01. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r02. Iskren (NEC) provides r03. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r03. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006275 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#15 - Evaluation and conclusion for KI#15 User consent for UE data collection/analysis. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005093. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 16: UP optimization for edge computing | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005317 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16, Sol#31: update for Improving analysing accuracy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006276 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Song Zhao(China Telecom) replies comments from Yannick(Nokia) and provide r01 Song Zhao(China Telecom) is OK with r02 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006276 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#16, Sol#31: update for Improving analysing accuracy. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005317. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005710 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Solution 49 update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.1 | S2-2005376 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #6, Sol #51: Update to clarify additional step between NEF and MEC. | China Mobile, KDDI | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006277 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provides r01 with minor changes. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006277 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #6, Sol #51: Update to clarify additional step between NEF and MEC. | China Mobile, KDDI | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005376. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005717 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation of solutions of Key Issue#16. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006278 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Yannick (Nokia): Nokia is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006278 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: Evaluation of solutions of Key Issue#16 . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005717. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 17: Definition of accuracy levels | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 18: Enhancement for real-time communication with NWDAF | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005187 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.700-91: KI #18, Sol# 54: Update to remove ENs. | China Unicom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006279 | Chi (China Unicom) proposes to merge S2-2005187 into S2-2005348. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.1 | S2-2005348 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#18, Sol#54: Update to define the Real-time communication capability information. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005187, to S2-2006279 | Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question on the concept of this solution Chi (China Unicom) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo). Chi (China Unicom) provides r01. Soohwan (ETRI) asks for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei) replies Soohwan (ETRI) and provides r02. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Chi (China Unicom) Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification. Xiaobo (Huawei): Huawei responds to Dimitris(Lenovo) and Yannick(Nokia) and further provide r03. Dimitris (Lenovo) has a follow-up question for r03 Xiaobo (Huawei) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo) and provide r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006279 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#18, Sol#54: Update to define the Real-time communication capability information. | Huawei, HiSilicon, China Unicom | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005348, merging S2-2005187. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005292 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#12, Solution#55: Update to Clarify Definition and Resolve EN. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006280 | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request clarification. Lei(Tencent) respond to Yannick (Nokia) and provide comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide r01. Lei(Tencent) respond to Yannick (Nokia) and can accept r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006280 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#18, Solution#55: Update to Clarify Definition and Resolve EN. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005292. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 19: Trained data model sharing between multiple NWDAF instances | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005354 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #19, Sol #56: Update to further clarify ML Model sharing between NWDAF instances. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yang Xu (OPPO) comments and asks for clarification David (Samsung) provides comments Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments and questions Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Soohwan (ETRI) asks questions about Yannick's comment Xiaobo (HW) provides feedback to the received comments and revision v01. Soohwan (ETRI) asks to merge this pCR into S2-2005375. Qing Wei (HW) rejects the merge suggestion of S2-2005354 into S2-2005375. Qing Wei (HW) provides response and r02, r03. Soohwan (ETRI) provides comments on r01. Soohwan (ETRI) proposes to postpone Qing Wei (Huawei) provides response to ETRI comments and propose to approve revision 01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | S2-2005375 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#19, Sol#56: Update to add model update service. | ETRI | Rel-17 | Postponed | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. Soohwan (ETRI) replies to the comments from Nokia. Soohwan (ETRI) provides r01 and r02 to merge S2-2005354. Qing Wei (HW) provides comments and rejects the merging of S2-2005354 into S2-2005375 Soohwan (ETRI) replies to Huawei Qing Wei (HW) replies to ETRI Soohwan (ETRI) is okay with r00, and if Huawei agrees to merge S2-2005354 into S2-2005375, ETRI is also okay with r02. Qing Wei (HW) proposes to postpone this as the related S2-2005354. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 20: NWDAF assisting in detecting anomaly events for the user plane | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005040 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #20, New Sol: NWDAF assisting in detecting anomaly events for the user plane. | III, | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification and express concerns. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments and express concerns Aihua(China Mobile) request for clarification. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects to this solution ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | - | - | - | KI 21: NWDAF assisting in user plane performance | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.1 | S2-2005030 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #21, New Sol: NWDAF assisting in user plane performance. | III | Rel-17 | Noted | Yannick (Nokia): Nokia request for clarification and express concerns. Ulf (Ericsson) provide comments and express concerns Tzu-Ya (III) response the concerns ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Tzu-Ya (III) ask to postpone this paper ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.1 | S2-2005289 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#21, New Sol: NWDAF assisted Per Access Network Performance. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006281 | Dimitris (Lenovo) has question for clarification Apostolis (Lenovo) requests clarifications. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Q from Dimitris (Lenovo). LaeYoung (LGE) answers to questions from Apostolis (Lenovo). Apostolis (Lenovo) makes further comments and suggests modifications. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.1 | S2-2006281 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#21, New Sol: NWDAF assisted Per Access Network Performance. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005289. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | Study on enhanced support of Non-Public Networks (FS_eNPN) | - | - | Docs:=141 | - | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - LSs | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005919 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Use Cases for providing IMS services to SNPN | Ericsson | - | Generated during CC#3. For CC4. CC#4: r03 agreed Revised in S2-2006029 | George (Ericsson) provides first draft for LS with input from several companies. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r01 Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. Nokia cannot accept original version nor r01 as they require SA1 to evaluate SA2 solutions (for which there is no consensus, setting a bad precedence), also evaluate whether service requirements fit in SA2 SID!. George (Ericsson) In the spirit of progressing, Ericsson will accept r03. I will not engage in academic arguments as this does not progress the work, which is my only objective. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03 George (Ericsson) provides r01x in CC4. Please see below Saso (Intel) is ok with r03. Just one question. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2006029 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Use Cases for providing IMS services to SNPN | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005919. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004965 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: [Draft] KI#1: LS on network selection when credentials are owned by an entity separate from the SNPN. | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006030 | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to note pCR (should be marked as NOTED), merged with S2-2005841, DT objects to be approved as is Daniel (Ericsson) comments Sebastian agrees with Dieter and objects to this document Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments Daniel (Ericsson) ask question to Sebastian (Qualcomm) Saso (Intel) supports sending out this LS. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Daniel Saso (Intel) provides r01. Marco (Huawei) provides r02 Saso (Intel) replies to Marco (Huawei) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) -> the text of this LS has been merged into 5841, i.e. this pCR can be NOTED. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005080 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on SNPN selection for UEs using a PLMN subscription | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006030 | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to note pCR (should be marked as NOTED), merged with S2-2005841, DT objects to be approved as is ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005807 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on SNPN selection for UEs using a PLMN subscription | Intel | Merged into S2-2006030 | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to note pCR (should be marked as NOTED), merged with S2-2005841, DT objects to be approved as is ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005841 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on extending PLMN selection to include SNPN selection for UEs with a PLMN subscription | Deutsche Telekom AG | Rel-17 | CC#4: r17 agreed Revised, merging S2-2004965, S2-2005080 and S2-2005807, in S2-2006030 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Daniel (Ericsson) provides r02 Daniel (Ericsson) provides r03 Marco (Huawei) ask confirmation that is this merging of 4965, 5807, 5080 in 5841? Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r04 Saso (Intel) supports r03 Daniel (Ericsson) prefers r03 Walter (Philips) provides r05 including service continuity aspects Marco (Huawei) comment Saso (Intel) replies to Marco (Huawei) Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r07 Marco (Huawei) provide r08 on top of r07 Marco (Huawei) replies to Saso (Intel) Walter (Philips) provides r13 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r11 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r12 (r11 is uploaded but has no content) Saso (Intel) provides r10 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) responds to Walter Marco (Huawei) provides r09 Walter (Philips) responds to Dieter and Marco Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) responds to Marco Marco (Huawei) comments on session continuity Guillaume (MediaTek): r11 was corrupt (this happened many times last week). Not sure how to put a new rev now. Guillaume (MediaTek) put a draft update of R13 in DRAFTS Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r01 and objects to all other revisions Saso (Intel) notes that the LS is structured along four distinct blocks (issues) and proposes to see which blocks are agreeable. Marco (Huawei) we object original and r01, and questions for clarification on issue 4 in R13?. Sebastian (Qualcomm) clarifies there are two r15 it seems; Sebastian referred to r15 under Inbox Revisions which removes 'to analyze the proposed solutions' Devaki (Nokia) is fine with r15. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Marco; proposes to use r15 which removes 'to analyze the proposed solutions' Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Marko (Huawei) on issue 4 and provides r15 in drafts. Devaki (Nokia) shares the same view as QCOM. We are fine with r01 limiting the questions to service requirements for SP = PLMN scenarios, object to other revisions. Walter (Philips) responds to Daniel (Ericsson)'s objection Marco (Huawei) reply to Sebastian (QC) For Sebastian (Qualcomm) only Issue 1 is acceptable (as documented in r01) Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r14 Marco (Huawei) comment Guillame (MedaTek) on issue 4. Saso (Intel) provides r14 in DRAFTS folder. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides clarification to Marco (Huawei) on issue 4. Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with issue 1 and 2 i.e., the original, r1, r2 and r3 and objects to the other revisions ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with r15 and respond to Walter (Philips) ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2006030 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on extending PLMN selection to include SNPN selection for UEs with a PLMN subscription | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r17 of S2-2005841, merging S2-2004965, S2-2005080 and S2-2005807. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=16 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005082 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update to Solution #2: Splitting solution 2 into SNPN and PLMN subscription aspects. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005925. | Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r02 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r02 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) objects to all versions of this contribution Sebastian (Qualcomm) assumes a misunderstanding and suggests Xiaobo Yu to take back this objection Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) is Ok with the r02 based on the offline discussion and kindly provide some suggestions for consideration in the evaluation and conclusion phase ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005925 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Update to Solution #2: Splitting solution 2 into SNPN and PLMN subscription aspects. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005082. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005094 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #1 - Solution update to address ENs. | Intel | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2005926. | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r01. Saso (Intel) OK with r01. Saso (Intel) provides r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments and provides r03 Saso (Intel) provides r04 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05 Saso (Intel) provides r06 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r07 Saso (Intel) is ok with r07 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005926 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #1 - Solution update to address ENs. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005094. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005621 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #1, 2: update to specify the support of roaming-based or N3IWF-based architecture for mobility scenarios. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2005927. | Daniel (Ericsson) asks for updates in the solution Qianghua (Huawei) replies and provides r01; Daniel (Ericsson) provides more questions on Huawei replies Qianghua (Huawei) responds and provides r02 Daniel (Ericsson) comments Qianghua (Huawei) responds and asks for clarification Daniel (Ericsson) answer Qianghua (Huawei) Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) asks question for clarification. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04; ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005927 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, New Sol: update to specify the support of roaming-based or N3IWF-based architecture for mobility scenarios. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005621. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005095 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #9 - Solution update to correct erroneous reference to Sol#1. | Intel | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005179 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #10: Updates for additional clarifications and add impacts. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005930. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Qianghua (Huawei) and provides revision r01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 to complete the impacts ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005930 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #10: Updates for additional clarifications and add impacts. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005179. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005533 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol #12: Update to clarify the solution with detailed procedure. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005566 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#11: Update to add an update mechanism for NPN information for UE. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005931. | Genadi (Lenovo) looks for clarifications. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarifications. Marco (Huawei) provides comments . Fei (OPPO) comments. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Marco (Huawei) and provides r01. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides response to Fei. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r01 and r00 and provides r02 Fei (OPPO) asks questions on r02. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to the objection from Sebastian and provides r03 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r03 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides response to Sebastian Sebastian (Qualcomm) I also ok with r00 (which is indeed the same as r02); Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) see no valid suggest or question from Lars and regards the final comment as invalid Sony (Sony) Why is my comment invalid? Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) see this comment as a invalid comment and ask not to be considered Lars (Sony) comments on Xiaobo WF Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) will provide final version based on Sebastian's comments on r03 and asks for review in the CC#4 if necessary Sebastian (Qualcomm): Based on offline discussions, r03 with removing 'The UE can use the new UE policy to select network according to certain application' (for now) would also be agreeable ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005931 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, Sol#11: Update to add an update mechanism for NPN information for UE. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005566. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005719 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Solution #11, address Editor notes. | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | CC#4: r01 was agreed. Revised in S2-2006031 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide response to Qualcomm and r02 Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide r03 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r01 and objects to the other revisions Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) provide response to Qualcomm's comments to reconsider the objection for r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2006031 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Solution #11, address Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005719. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005619 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #4, 8, 10: update to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2005932. | Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and revision r01. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Daniel (Ericsson) provides r02 Qianghua (Huawei) responds and is OK with r02. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. Daniel (Ericsson) comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Daniel (Ericsson). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005932 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Sol #4, 8, 10: update to address the ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005619. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004967 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, New solution: Shared SP identities. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005933. | Hualin (Huawei) have problem to understand the solution and asks questions. Daniel (Ericsson) provide answer to Hualin (Huawei). Fei (OPPO) asks questions. Daniel (Ericsson) answers Fei (OPPO) Hualin (Huawei) response to Nilsson(Ericsson). Daniel (Ericsson) provides answers to QC and Huawei Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to merge into solution 2 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005933 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, New solution: Shared SP identities. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004967. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005500 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1, New Sol: Network Selection for UE using Home SP subscription to access a supported SNPN. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Approved | Jianning (Xiaomi) asks questions for clarification. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the responses Jianning (Xiaomi) provides furhter comments Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides further clarification Jianning (Xiaomi) provides one more comment ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005569 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 Solution X: UE external subscription data management in the SNPN. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005934. | Genadi (Lenovo) looks for clarifications. Jianning (Xiaomi) responses the comments from Genadi (Lenovo) and provides r01 Marco (Huawei) asks clarification Jianning (Xiaomi) replies the comment from Marco (Huawei) Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Jianning (Xiaomi) and provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005934 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 Solution X: UE external subscription data management in the SNPN. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005569. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005572 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 Solution X: Steering of Roaming for SNPN. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005935. | Fei (OPPO) provides comments . Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides comments Jianning (Xiaomi) responses the comments from Chia-Lin(MediaTec) and Fei (OPPO) and provides r01 Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) provides r03 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005935 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1 Solution X: Steering of Roaming for SNPN/PLMN. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005572. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004966 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1: Evaluation and conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Kisuk (Samsung): Objection to this pCR. Saso (Intel): Comments to Samsung's objection. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide comments and r02 Marco (Huawei): MOCN is not a KI#1's solution. Daniel (Ericsson) asks for clarification on changes in r01 provided by Orange. Saso (Intel) asks clarifications on changes in r01 provided by Orange. Daniel (Ericsson) provides r04. Fei (OPPO) provides r06 . Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask which paper is used for KI#1 evaluation and conclusion Daniel (Ericsson) answers Marco (Huawei) Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05 Marco (Huawei) comments r04. Saso (Intel) supports Dieter's proposal to use different names e.g. HSNPN and HPLMN. Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to consider this paper MERGED in the baseline document S2-2005837 as proposed by the Rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2004995 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#1: Interim conclusions. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to note 4995 and only progress conclusions for KI#1 in 5837 (as recommended by Peter). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005096 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): objects. Kisuk (Samsung): provides comments. Saso (Intel): follows-up on comments from Antoine and Kisuk. Saso (Intel) replies to Kisuk (Samsung). Kisuk (Samsung) comments to Saso (Intel). Marco (huawei) asked clarification. Saso (Intel) replies to Marco (huawei). Marco (Huawei) further comment. Fei (OPPO) comments. Daniel (Ericsson) tries to answer comments from Marco (Huawei) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) disagrees to have the conclusion on 'under-configured UE' unless it has a clear definition Saso (Intel) agrees with Daniel (Ericsson) in answering comments from Marco (Huawei) Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides comments about 'under-configured UE' Saso (Intel) asks clarification from Chia-Lin (MediaTek) Saso (Intel) replies to Fei (OPPO). Saso (Intel) replies to Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) supports the Oppo's comments and ask the definition of 'under-configured UE' Saso (Intel) replies to Chia-Lin (MediaTek). Marco (Huawei) comments. Saso (Intel) proposes to consider this paper MERGED in the baseline document S2-2005837 as proposed by the Rapporteur. marco (Huawei) my comments will be valid also if merged. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides comments. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) proposes to ask SA1 on the right interpretation of the requirement. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r01 based on the previous comments. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to all revsions of this documents in order to ensure we are working only on one documents for conclusions Saso (Intel) proposes this document to be considered merged into the baseline 5837. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005501 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1: Evaluation and interim conclusion on Under-configured UE. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): supports. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom): supports the conclusion in this pCR. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) comments on the objection Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Chia-Lin (MediaTek) considers this paper can be merged into S2-2005837 and provide the response to Sebastian (Qualcomm) Fei (OPPO) basically supports the conclusion in this PCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005502 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1: Evaluation and interim conclusion on the usage of Home SP SIB indication. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the paper; let's focus on a single paper for conclusion as proposed by Peter Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask this can be merged to S2-2005837 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005620 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, evaluations and conclusions regarding AAA-based architecture. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Qianghua (Huawei) responds and suggests one single conclusion paper S2-2005837 for discussion ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005622 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, evaluation and conclusion for mobility scenarios. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to note 5622 and only progress conclusions for KI#1 in 5837 (as recommended by Peter). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005731 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1: way forward proposal. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): objects. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Daniel (Ericsson) proposes to note 5731 and only progress conclusions for KI#1 in 5837 (as recommended by Peter). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005857 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Cisco Systems | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005943 | Antoine (Orange): objects. Irfan (Cisco) provides r01 Saso (Intel) proposes to consider 5857 for merger into the baseline paper 5837; then note 5857. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005042 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Sol #14: Update to address EN. | Sony | Rel-17 | CC#4: r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005936. | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with Marco and objects to the PCR Lars (Sony) provides r01 and ask for WF Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and ok with r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r01; I would be ok if changes to clause 6.14.1 were removed from r01 Lars (Sony) replies to Sebastian Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r02 in the draft folder Lars (Sony) provides r02 in the draft folder Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Lars ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005936 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Sol #14: Update to address EN. | Sony | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005042. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005568 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol#14: Update to enable selective UEs being released to RRC-Inactive. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Noted | Lars (Sony) comments and suggest to Note the pCR. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to the comments from Lars (Sony). Lalith (Samsung) changed subject of the mail. AI from 8.10 to 8.2 Lars (Sony) comments. Marco (Huawei) comments in CN impact. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Marco (Huawei) and Lars (Sony) Marco (Huawei) commented Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provide response to Lars and r01 Lars (Sony) comment on r01 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Lars and provides r02 Lars (Nord) provides further comments Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Lars and provides r03 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Sebastian and asks to remove the rejection Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides response. Lars (Sony) reply Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provide response to Lars and asks to withdraw the objection Lars (Sony) comments and objects to all versions Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to go with r03 without the change in 6.14.2. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005330 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, solution 18: Update to the solution for unicast traffic. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005937 | Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide comments and revision 01 Fei (OPPO) provides comments on r01 . Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide replies to OPPO's comments and suggest this contribution to merge with S2-2005723 as part of RAN impact analysis Fei (OPPO) provides reply to Amanda (Futurewei) and asks for clarification. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provides reply to OPPO Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) suggest to note this contribution because it can be considered being merged into the revision of S2-2005723r01 Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark merged. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005723 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Solution #18, address Editor notes. | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005330, to S2-2005937. | Fei (OPPO) provides r01 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) is ok with r01 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) is ok with r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005937 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Solution #18, address Editor notes . | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005723., merging S2-2005330. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005583 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2: Update to solution 13. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005938. | Marco (huawei) ask clarification. Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005938 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2: Update to solution 13. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005583. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005796 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, Sol #1,#2,#11 Update to remove ENs on isolated networks. | Philips. | Rel-17 | Noted | Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) objects to this pCR. Walter (Philips) responds to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom). Walter (Philips) requests Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) to indicate if he agrees with the pCR to remove the editor's notes or prefers to send liaison. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) replies to Walter (Philips). Walter (Philips) replies to Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) and requests liaison to SA1. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005124 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, new solution, policy based control. | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005939. | Xiaobo Yu(alibaba) provides comments. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask the question for clarification Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Belen (Ericsson) provides r01, replies to questions as well. Belen (Ericsson) replies to LGE. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the comments Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification from LG and MediaTek Belen (Ericsson) replies to MediaTek. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) responds Myungjune (LGE) responds to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides comments. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) ask for clarification of new text in r01 Fei (OPPO) asks for clarifications. Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments from MediaTek, LGE, OPPO, Alibaba, Futurewei Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides the comments Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification on the way forward Belen (Ericsson) replies to MediaTek, Chia-Lin (MediaTek) replies to Ericsson Marco (Huawei) commented Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei. Marco (Huawei) comments. Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications to Huawei. Fei (OPPO) comments Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Marco (Huawei) commented. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Belen (Ericsson) provides r05 Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r05 Malla (NTT DOCOMO) is okay with r05 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r05. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r05 Fei (OPPO) is fine with r05 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005939 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, new solution, policy based control. | Ericsson, NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005124. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005296 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: Simultaneous communication using N3IWF. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005940. | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask the question for clarification Myungjune (LGE) responds to Chia-Lin (MediaTek). Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Daniel Nilsson (Ericsson) ask question Myungjune (LGE) responds to Daniel (Ericsson) Daniel (Ericsson) provides r02 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005940 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: Simultaneous communication using N3IWF. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005296. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005532 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, New Sol: Mobiltiy between SNPN and PLMN using application layer service continuity. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification on this solution Marco (Huawei) provides clarifications ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005538 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: MBS solution for eNPN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) propose to note this pCR Hualin(Huawei) response to Chia-Lin (MediaTek). Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides response Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Chia-Lin (MediaTek) response to Hualin (Huawei). Devaki (Nokia) replies. Proposes to discuss addition of NID for SNPN case as part of CC#4. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides to Nokia. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia Devaki (Nokia) asks which KI# does this solution really address and why is 5G_MBS in scope of eNPN? Nokia objects to studying 5G_MBS under two SIDs. This paper is not in scope of eNPN SID. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Hualin(Huawei) response to Devaki (Nokia). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005570 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Solution for the KI#2: Service Continuity triggered by Application. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005941. | Marco (Huawei) asks clarifications Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarifications to Marco (Huawei) Marco (Huawei) comments Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r01 for addressing the issue from Marco and clarification to Myungjune. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides response to Myungjune and provide r02 Myungjune (LGE) asks a question on r01. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005941 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Solution for the KI#2: Service Continuity triggered by Application. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005570. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005617 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: a consolidated solution. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask the question Qianghua (Huawei) responds ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005672 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, New Sol: Enabling a UE to receive paging message from another network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Marco (Huawei) asks clarification Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Kisuk (samsung) answers to qualcomm Kisuk (Samsung) answer the question. Kisuk (Samsung) objects to Qualcomm's objection. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005721 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, new Solution #X, QoS notification between SNPN and PLMN. | Futurewei, Philips, | Rel-17 | Approved | Qianghua (Huawei) points out that the comments are not captured in chairman's note ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005728 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, New Sol: Solution for offering QoS - simultaneous access to services by PLMN and SNPN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Futurewei | Rel-17 | Noted | Myungjune (LGE) provide questions and comments. Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) fine with r02. Marco (Huawei) is the Sol in KI scope? Daniel (Ericsson) provides r03 Marco (Huawei) commented Daniel (Ericsson) answers Marco (Huawei) Marco (Huawei) commented. Devaki (Nokia) answers Marco and Daniel. Daniel (Ericsson) comments Marco (Huawei) proposes to note since QoS solution and not in SID scope Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm): please ignore the previous comment; there was a revision clash; r03 seems to already address my comments Daniel (Ericsson) answers Marcos (Huawei) request to note the paper Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) share the same view as Nokia and Ericsson that some QoS aspects are in the scope of KI #2 Devaki (Nokia) shares the same view as Ericsson's answer and requests Marco to reconsider. Marco (Huawei) confirms objection Marco (Huawei) already commented several times in this 2 weeks the QoS sync between networks is not in eNPN SID scope nor stated as issue to be solved.. Devaki (Nokia) asks HUA for technical reasons behind objection. Devaki (Nokia) comments no technical reason was provided by HUA for objection, so far. Devaki (Nokia) requests this document to be added for discussion during CC#4. Huawei rationale for objection 'not in scope' is not consistent with the solutions that are already documented in the TR (e.g. solution #13, New policy control solution (S2-2005124) for VIAPA services). This solution proposal is addressing the same exact scenario reusing existing concepts. SA2 should have a consistent decision on whether QoS / policy control for VIAPA services are in scope or not. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005772 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, New Sol: Enabling service continuity with pre-established backup connection. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005942. | Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r01 Myungjune (LGE) provide r01. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Zhenhua (Vivo) and Myungjune (LGE) comments. Marco (Huawei) comments & clarification. Marco (Huawei) comments from Monday not addressed, please consider them also for revision or we may not support approval. Guanzhou (InterDigital) corrects the link of r02. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Marco(HW) comments and provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with both r01 and r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005942 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2, New Sol: Enabling service continuity with pre-established backup connection. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005772. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005297 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#2. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006032 | Myungjune (LGE) proposes to merge this paper into baseline paper S2-2005582. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005331 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Evaluation and Conclusion for the KI#2. | OPPO, MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006032 | Myungjune (LGE) proposes to merge this paper into baseline paper S2-2005582. Fei (OPPO) is fine to mark merged. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005539 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2: Evaluation and Conclusion for eNPN about MBS support. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) objects to the conclusion proposed due to procedural and technical comments Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and ok to note conclusion for 5MBS at this meeting. Hualin(Huawei) response to Haris (Qualcomm). Hualin(Huawei) indicate the objection is to the conclusion, but not to the evaluation part. We can keep the evaluation part. Also response to Peter(Ericsson). Haris (Qualcomm) is ok with r01 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to note this paper. This is dependent on the discussion why 5G_MBS is even being proposed as part of eNPN SID work . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005582 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2: Evaluation and conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: r17 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005720, S2-2005297, S2-2005331, S2-2005618 and S2-2005732, in S2-2006032 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and comments. Lars (Sony) comments and ask questions. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide comments and r04 Fei (OPPO) comments and provides r05. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Chia-Lin and Lars. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions to Futurewei. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question to OPPO. Fei (OPPO) provides r06 to re-insert the dual radio option Marco (Huawei) provides r07 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) answer questions from Ericsson and provide r07 Marco (Huawei) Futurewei R07 is OK Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Marco (Huawei) provides comment. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides comments and revision of r08. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r09 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r10 Lars (Sony) objects to r10 Marco (Huawei) objects to r10 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and will provide revsion dependent on answer. Hualin (Huawei) provide r11 based on r09. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) support to keep the evaluation and notes Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone the conclusion papers for KI#2. Do not see much consensus in a meaningful conclusion due to varying views and new solutions being considered. The revisions are diverging already. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r12 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r13 and comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r14 Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone as commented earlier. If at all, this is progressed I wish to propose an editor's note to show VIAPA services, voice/emergency service QoS is supported in the underlay network with N3IWF architecture. Hualin(Huawei) cosign this paper as r15. Devaki (Nokia) provided r16 (including the proposed EN). Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r14 or r15 and objects to r16 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r15 with EN as proposed by Devaki (as mentioned in the notes) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r13 to r16 Devaki (Nokia) comments that it is also OK to note the paper. Other revisions are simply re-stating what is supported in Rel-16 anyhow. It translates to 'do nothing' for KI. Devaki (Nokia) objects to original and other revisions (other than r16) as they are pretty much 'do nothing' and we can conclude the same in future meeting if there is no consensus for any solution. Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with Marco Marco (Huawei) replies to Peter&Sebastian and proposes 3rd EN's version Sebastian replies to Peter and proposes a way forward Devaki (Nokia) is fine with Peter (Ericsson)'s proposed revision for the EN in r16. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question on proposes a way forward based on r16. Fei (OPPO) prefers r13 to r15 and can live with r16. Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) is ok with both rev r15 and r16 for this meeting, but prefer r16. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2006032 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#2: Evaluation and conclusion. | Ericsson, Huawei, HiSilicon, Futurewei | Rel-17 | Revision r17 of S2-2005582, merging S2-2005720, S2-2005297, S2-2005331, S2-2005618 and S2-2005732. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005618 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2: interim agreements. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006032 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the paper; let's focus on one conclusion paper Qianghua (Huawei) OK to merge this into S2-2005582 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005720 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2, evaluation and conclusion. | Futurewei, Philips | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006032 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper as is; proposes to merge into 5582 as proposed by the rapporteur Peter Hedman (Ericsson) support that it should be marked NOTED and merged into 5582. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005732 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #2: way forward proposal. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006032 | Marco (Huawei): objects . Marco (Huawei) proposes to note since QoS solution and not in SID scope Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the conclusion as is; proposes to merge with 5582 as proposed by the rapporteur Peter Hedman (Ericsson) support that it should be marked NOTED and merged into 5582. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005837 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: ENPN KI #1 & K2 discussion and proposals for evaluations and conclusions. | Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | r13 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005857, S2-2005731, S2-2005622, S2-2005620, S2-2005502, S2-2005501, S2-2005096, S2-2004995 and S2-2004966 to S2-2005943. CC#4: Postponed | Antoine (Orange): supports. Kisuk (Samsung): provides comments. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom): answers to Kisuk (Samsung). Kisuk (Samsung) provides comments DT. Daniel (Ericsson) provides r01 Antoine (Orange) provides r02. Daniel (Ericsson) provides comments on r01 Saso (Intel) provides r03. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 to merge the conclusion from S2-2005622 and S2-2005620 Antoine (Orange) provides r05. Saso (Intel) objects to r05. Have a nice weekend! Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the comments and r06. S2-2005501 and S2-2005502 from MediaTek can be merged into S2-2005837 Marco (Huawei) commented Daniel (Ericsson) provides r07 Devaki (Nokia) provides r08. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r09 Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with r08 and provides answers to Devaki (Nokia) Daniel (Ericsson) ask question to Sebastian (Qualcomm) Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification from Sebastian (Qualcomm) Marco (Huawei) commented to Sebastian (Qualcomm) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification Daniel (Ericsson) answers Chia-Lin (MediaTek) Devaki (Nokia) asks question for clarification regarding the latest version. Marco (huawei) provides r11. Marco (Huawei) replies to Devaki. Devaki (Nokia) provides r12. Daniel (Ericsson) provided r10 Daniel (Ericsson) provides r13 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment that next revision can change H-SNPN to HSNPN Marco (Huawei) provides 14 Daniel (Ericsson) comments Saso (Intel) provides r15 Irfan (Cisco) provides r16 Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r13 or 09 and objects to the other versions Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r15 and objects to r16 Daniel (Ericsson) is ok with r13, r14 and r15 but objects to R16 Irfan (Cisco) is OK to go with r15 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2005943 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: ENPN KI #1 & K2 discussion and proposals for evaluations and conclusions. | Deutsche Telekom | Rel-17 | Revision r13 of S2-2005837, merging S2-2005857, S2-2005731, S2-2005622, S2-2005620, S2-2005502, S2-2005501, S2-2005096, S2-2004995 and S2-2004966. For CC4. CC#4: withdrawn | Withdrawn | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Key Issue Update | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005429 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Update on Key Issue #3. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004886 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Update of solution#20 - Removal of Editor's Notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2004888 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: Update to solution 19. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005944. | Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 and asks to ignore r01 that was also uploaded by mistake George (Ericsson) asks a question ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005944 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: Update to solution 19. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004888. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004889 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: Update to solution 25. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) disagrees with the essence of the pCR and proposes to NOTE it George (Ericsson) provides response Haris (Qualcomm) comments George (Provides) response George (Ericsson) resend previous response George (Ericsson) provides a response. Hualin(Huawei) has the similar feeling as Qualcomm and don't think this paper is needed. Hualin(Huawei) propose to note the paper since we don't see the issue on this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005099 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, Solution #21 - Solution update to clarify procedures. | Intel, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005463 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, sol#22, clarify the sol#21 and sol#22. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005427 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, Sol #26: Updates on solution #26 to remove ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005945. | George (Ericsson) provides r01. Changes are highlighted in yellow. Yi (China Mobile) ask for clarification for the editor's note added. George (Ericsson) provides response. Yi (China Mobile) responds. Yi (China Mobile) provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005945 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, Sol #26: Updates on solution #26 to remove ENs. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005427. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005585 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: Solution #23: Resolve ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004887 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, New Sol: Providing IMS voice and emergency services for SNPN subscribers using credentials generated during access level authentication. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2005946. | Zhenhua (vivo) comments George (Ericsson) provides r01. See additional comments. Megha (Intel) provides comments and couple questions for clarification George (Ericsson) provides a response. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 George (Ericsson) providers r3 and ask question. On this text 'This solution has no impact on the configuration of SNPN UEs as such the UE can only derive IMPI/IMPU from the SUPI which means that the SNPN and IMS Core are be owned by the same entity' This is not correct : The UE can derive IMPI and a temporary IMPU from a SUPI, the IMS Core can be provisioned with the SUPI, and equally derive the same IMPI and temporary IMPU. So, assuming that IMS core can be provisioned with the SUPI of the UE. So such a restriction is not correct. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for r03 George (Ericsson) provides r04. Haris (Qualcomm) provides a response. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005946 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, New Sol: Providing IMS voice and emergency services for SNPN subscribers using credentials generated during access level authentication. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2004887. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004890 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: New Solution: Providing IMS services using SNPN NAI-based Identifiers. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005947. | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to merge with solution proposed in S2-2004887 George (Ericsson) provide comments. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question George (Ericsson) provides response Haris (Qualcomm) comments George (Ericsson) provides r01 Megha (Intel) provides r02 and some comments. George (Ericsson) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005947 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3: New Solution: Providing IMS services using SNPN NAI-based Identifiers . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004890. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005332 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3, New solution: solution on top of solution #24. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Haris (Qualcomm) proposes to note since the solution is not possible with the current assumptions Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) supports the proposal to note the pCR Fei (OPPO) provides clarification and fine to note this PCR for now. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004891 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: intermediate conclusion for KI#3. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005948 | Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that this paper should be marked as NOTED and merged in S2-2005428 Qianghua (Huawei) points out this needs to mark 'merged' ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005100 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #3, Evaluation and interim conclusion. | Intel, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005948 | George (Ericsson) objects to solution 24. Please see additional comments. Megha (Intel) provides clarification and some comments. George (Ericsson) provides response and seek clarification. Megha (Intel) provides further clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) proposes r01 George (Ericsson) seek clarification. Curt (Charter) provides a response. George (Ericsson) provides a response.. Curt (Charter) seeks clarification from George (Ericsson). George (Ericsson) provides response. George (Ericsson) provide comment Megha (Intel) seeks clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) indicates that this paper should be marked as NOTED and merged in S2-2005428 Megha (Intel) proposes to consider this paper merged with 5428. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005428 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Interim conclusion on KI#3. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005100 and S2-2004891, to S2-2005948. | Haris (Qualcomm) provide comment and provides r01 George (Ericsson) provides comment. Yi (China Mobile) provides comment and provides r02. Yi (China Mobile) provides comment and object to r01. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r02 Haris (Qualcomm) provides comment. Antoine (Orange) comments. Antoine (Orange) provides r03. Curt (Charter) provides a comment. Haris(Qualcomm) is ok with r03 George (Ericsson) would propose sending an LS to SA1 to request clarification on the scope of use cases to consider given the deadlock on this issue. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on the Ericsson proposal Yi (China Mobile) is fine with r03. Yi (China Mobile) responds to Haris. Yi (China Mobile) responds to Saso. George (Ericsson) accepts r03 Devaki (Nokia) provides r05 Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Megha (Intel) can accept r03,r05 though we have a slight preference to r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005948 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#3: Interim conclusion on KI#3. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005428, merging S2-2005100 and S2-2004891. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - LSs | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004779 | LS In | Action | LS from SA WG1: Reply LS on Questions on onboarding requirements | SA WG1 (S1-202266) | Rel-17 | Revision of postponed S2-2004318 from S2#139E. Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005534 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on security issue for on-boarding | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005708, to S2-2005949. | Hualin(Huawei) provide r01 for S2-2005534 which is the LS to SA3 about KI4. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a comment Haris (Qualcomm) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Fei (OPPO) provides r04 Hualin(Huawei) response to Youngkyo(Samsung). Youngkyo (Samsung) provide answer to the Hualin's question. Hualin(Huawei) response to Youngkyo (Samsung). Hualin(Huawei) is ok with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005949 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on security issue for on-boarding and remote provisioning | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005534., merging S2-2005708. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005708 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on UE onboarding and remote provisioning security aspects | Qualcomm Incorporated | Merged into S2-2005949 | Haris (Qualcomm) propose this LS version to be marked as noted, merged with S2-2005534 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=30 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005098 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Solution #5 - Solution update. | Intel | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005950. | Kisuk (Samsung): provides comments. Megha (Intel) provides clarification. Megha (Intel) replies to Mike's comments. Mike (Convida) provides r01. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) provides comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005950 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Solution #5 - Solution update . | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005098. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005333 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Solution #5: Resolve Editor's note for DCS. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005674 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #5: Update to clarify how the UE discovers and selects the onboarding network. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Megha (Intel) provides comments and proposes to NOTE the pCR Kisuk (Samsung) provides comments and revision. Megha (Intel) seeks further clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a question. Megha (Intel) cannot accept r00,r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Kisuk (Samsung) provides answers to Intel and Ericsson. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | S2-2005729 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#5: Update to Sol#5, UE onboarding and provisioning for an SNPN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Devaki (Nokia) comments. Megha (Intel) provides r01 and comments Megha (Intel) asks additional questions. Devaki (Nokia) answers the questions. Megha (Intel) can live with r00. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to progress r00 based on Intel's feedback. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005180 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #38: Update to clarify the solution. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005951. | Genadi (Lenovo) provides r01 to correct a mistake in step 8. Haris (Qualcomm) provides comments and questions Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Haris (Qualcomm) and asks follow-up questions. Genadi (Lenovo) provides revision r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005951 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #38: Update to clarify the solution. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005180. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005334 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, solution#32: Resolve Editor's note for storage of provisioning data. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005431, to S2-2005952. | Haris (Qualcomm) comments on the resolution of EN Fei (OPPO) provides reply to Haris (Qualcomm). Haris (Qualcomm) comments further Fei (OPPO) provides revision r01 . Yi (China Mobile) comments. Yi (China Mobile) provides r02. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r01 and r02 Fei (OPPO) provides r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005952 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, solution#32: Resolve Editor's note for storage of provisioning data. | OPPO, China Telecome, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005334., merging S2-2005431. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005430 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update on credential protection. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005953. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and dependent on answer wil propose a revision. Yi (China Mobile) reply Ericsson's comments and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005953 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update on credential protection. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005430. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005431 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update on credential storage in UE. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005952 | Yi (China Mobile) the author asks to merge this contribution into S2-2005334. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005432 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update to avoid unnecessary UE provisioning for PNI-NPN. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005954. | Haris (Qualcomm) asks question on proposed solution Yi (China Mobile) responds and provides r01. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) proposes to merge part of S2-2005696 with S2-2005432, and provides r02: ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005954 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#32: Update to avoid unnecessary UE provisioning for PNI-NPN. | China Mobile, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005432. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005696 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #32: Update to clarify the trigger for provisioning procedure and remove ENs. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005955. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments and will provide a revision dependent on answer. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) response to Peter (Ericsson). Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) proposes to merge parts of S2-2005696 with S2-2005334 and S2-2005432, and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005955 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #32: Update to clarify the trigger for provisioning procedure and remove ENs. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005696. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005453 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol. 40 update: Updates to Sol#40 on support for Onboarding of UEs without any credentials. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Approved | Megha (Intel) asks question for clarification Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to Megha (Intel) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005530 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#34: Update to clarify PLMN assisted onboarding procedures. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Xiaobo Yu(alibaba) asks for clarification. Hualin (Huawei)response to Xiaobo Yu(alibaba). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005684 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #34: Update for UP based PLMN assisted On-boarding Procedures. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005956. | Xiaobo Yu(alibaba) provides comments and suggests to merge 6.34.3.2 to 6.34.3.1. Lalith (Samsung) responds to Xiaobo Yu(Alibaba). Xiaobo Yu(alibaba) is OK with r01 and happy to co-sign this paper. Lalith(Samsung) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005956 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #34: Update for UP based PLMN assisted On-boarding Procedures. | Samsung, Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005684. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005540 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#4, Sol#35 Update to clarify the solution, and remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005541 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#4, Sol#7 Update to Clarify the solution and remove several ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005957. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments. We are ok with r01 provided by Peter Hedman (Ericsson). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005957 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: 23.700-07 KI#4, Sol#7 Update to Clarify the solution and remove several ENs . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005541. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005584 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Update to Solution #27. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005958. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005958 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Update to Solution #27. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005584. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005624 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #27: update the UP or CP decision. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005959. | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005959 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #27: update the UP or CP decision. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005624. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005730 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Sol#36: Update to Solution#36 for providing provisioning details to UE using local provisioning server and central provisioning server. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.2 | S2-2005863 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #39: Update to resolve Editor's Notes. | Orange, Telecom Italia, China Mobile, Deutsche Telekom, AT&T | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005960. | Haris (Qualcomm) asks question for clarification Antoine (Orange) clarifies. Haris (Qualcomm) comments that the NOTE should be removed Antoine (Orange) provides r01 to remove the Note. Antoine (Orange) replies and provides r02. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides some questions. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Antoine (Orange) replies. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005960 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Sol #39: Update to resolve Editor's Notes. | Orange, Telecom Italia, China Mobile, Deutsche Telekom, AT&T, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005863. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005565 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4 Solution X: UE onboarding and provisioning for SNPN with 3rd party's credentials. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Jianning (Xiaomi) provides r01 Kisuk (Samsung) provides comments Josep (DT) agrees with Samsun's view and proposes to not this pCR. Jianning (Xiaomi) responses to Josep(DT) and Kisuk (Samsung) Josep (DT) comments further and still proposes to note this pCR. Jianning (Xiaomi) provides further reply to Josep (DT). Antoine (Orange) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.2 | - | - | - | KI#4 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004823 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Interim Conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson | Rel-17 | r26 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005865, S2-2005818, S2-2005733, S2-2005713 and S2-2004996, to S2-2005961. | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments to Orange. Kisuk (Samsung) provides comments. Haris (Qualcomm) proposes revision 02 merging conclusion pCRs for KI#4 component 2 (remote provisioning) Fei (OPPO) supports to keep CP option for the remote provisioning. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) support Ericsson view to keep CP option. Josep (DT) does not support to have CP option for remote provisioning Youngkyo (Samsung) support to keep CP option. Josep (DT) comments on UEs not supporting UP and lack of support for NB-IoT in SNPNs. Haris (Qualcomm) comments Qianghua (Huawei) supports the CP option. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) supports the CP option. Rainer (Siemens) provides comments on SNPN conclusions for KI#4. Megha (Intel) provides r02 and comments Megha (Intel) provides r03 and comments Yi (China Mobile) comments on PNI-NPN provisioning and provides r07. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 Antoine (Orange): provides r06. Antoine (Orange): provides r05. Rainer (Siemens) provides further comment on avoiding mixed CP/UP provisioning method. Megha (Intel) provides r04 and further comments Rainer (Siemens) provides comment and proposal for updated formulation. Josep (DT) replies to Haris' comment regarding S2-2005818 belonging to component 1. Rainer (Siemens): clarifies comment, misunderstood by Antoine. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r08 with updates related to the provisioning for PNI-NPN. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the comments Qianghua (Huawei) provides r09, merging the related parts from S2-2005623 Fei (OPPO) provides r10 and re-inserts the CP option . Josep (DT) disagrees with r09 and proposes a way forward for this meeting regarding CP remote provisioning of credentials for SNPN Hualin (Huawei) support CP option and provides r11. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on a change in r11. Hualin(Huawei) response to Haris (Qualcomm). Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the comments and r13 Haris (Qualcomm) provides r14 Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) provides r15. Devaki (Nokia) provides r16. Hualin(Huawei) provides r17. Fei (OPPO) asks questions on r16. Josep (DT) supports the approach with CP provisioning from Nokia's r16 Haris (Qualcomm) asks questions on r15, r16, r17 Fei (OPPO) supports this assumption on the CP provisioning. Josep (DT) replies to Haris. Genadi (Lenovo) provides reply to Shuyi Tian (China Telecom). Genadi (Lenovo) supports proposal by Haris (Qualcomm) to explicitly mention 'CP based on existing UPU procedure'. Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) comments. Hualin(Huawei) also support to explicitly mention 'CP based on existing UPU procedure'. Josep (DT) comments that even if we end up agreeing on having 'CP based on existing UPU procedure' in the conclusions, this does not mean that SA3 need not be consulted. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) also supports the CP provisioning based on existing UPU procedure Hualin(Huawei) provides r22. Hualin(Huawei) response to Megha (Intel). Fei (OPPO) provides comments to Genadi (Lenovo). Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) responses to Genadi (Lenovo). Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments to Shuyi Tian (China Telecom). Devaki provides r20. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r19 Megha (Intel) provides r18 and multiple comments clarification. Devaki (Nokia) comments that we should finalize the procedure for CP provisioning to be used based on SA3 feedback. Fei (OPPO) provides r23. Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) and Fei (OPPO). Josep (DT) comments to Fei (OPPO) regarding 'When user plane is used for UE Onboarding (as in component 1)'. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r24 Fei (OPPO) provides r24. Josep (DT) asks whether r24 belong to Peter (Ericsson) or Fei (OPPO)... Fei (OPPO) please ignore my following email since Peter has provided the r24. Fei (OPPO) clarified that r24 is provided by Peter(Ericsson). Megha(Intel) replies to Fei. Megha (Intel) provides r25 and provides clarification Hualin(Huawei) cosign this paper as r26. Hualin(Huawei) respond to Megha (Intel). Josep (DT) objects revisions before r19, can live with r26. Antoine (Orange) objects to r23, r24, r25 and r26. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment and proposed to bring up r26 to CC#4. Antoine (Orange) replies. Antoine (Orange) no longer objects to r26. Haris (Qualcomm) clarifies the intention of the text Fei (OPPO) comments and supports to bring this to CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005961 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4, Interim Conclusions. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Intel, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r26 of S2-2004823, merging S2-2005865, S2-2005818, S2-2005733, S2-2005713 and S2-2004996. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2004876 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Partial Evaluation and Conclusion on the O-SNPN discovery aspects. | Convida Wireless LLC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005962 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Mike (Convida) objects to r01 and comments. Antoine (Orange) objects to r00. Mike (Convida) comments and provides r02. Mike (Convida) suggests marking this document as merged with S2-2005101. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2004996 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI#4: Interim conclusions. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005961 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Rainer (Siemens) provides comments. Haris (Qualcomm) this pCR should be marked as NOTED, merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101, Qualcomm objects to be approved as is ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005075 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Conclusions regarding using USIM containing default credentials. | Deutsche Telekom, Orange | Rel-17 | Revised in S2-2005818 | Revised | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005818 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Conclusions regarding using USIM containing default credentials. | Deutsche Telekom, Orange, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005075 Merged into S2-2005961 | Haris (Qualcomm) this pCR should be marked as NOTED, merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101, Qualcomm objects to be approved as is Josep (DT), author, indicates that this pCR can be marked as merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101 (KI#4 conclusions). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005101 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Evaluation and interim conclusion - User plane solutions. | Intel | Rel-17 | CC#4: r41 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004876, S2-2005623, S2-2005503 and S2-2005335, to S2-2005962. | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Kisuk (Samsung): provides comments. Megha (Intel) provides r02 for KI#4 component 1 (UE onboarding). Mike (Convida) provides r06 and comments Megha (Intel) provides r05 and some comments Antoine (Orange): provides r04. Antoine (Orange): provides r03. Haris (Qualcomm) comments and proposes r03 Rainer (Siemens) supports the position that support for onboarding using O-SNPN it to be supported. Antoine (Orange) provides r07. Haris (Qualcomm) asks question on r07 Fei (OPPO) asks questions on the SUPI . Qianghua (Huawei) provides R08 on top of R06. Marco (Huawei) asks clarification. Antoine (Orange) replies and provides r09. Marco (Huawei) comments Haris (Qualcomm) comments on inclusion of solution number in the conclusions Antoine (Orange) provides r10. Megha (Intel) provides r11 and some comments Mike (Convida) provides r12 and comments Marco (Huawei) replies and some comments Mike (Convida) objects to r13 and provides r14. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments and provides r13. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification on User plane onboarding Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification on RRC indication Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment and suggestion. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provide comment Qianghua (Huawei) provides responses to Megha (Intel) and r15 based on r14 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to NTT DoCoMo Haris (Qualcomm) provides r16 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r17 and comments/questions. Irfan (Cisco) asks for clarification Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) ask Ericsson for Clarification Megha (Intel) provides r18 and addresses multiple questions and comments Youngkyo (Samsung) provides a comment. Genadi (Lenovo) asks 2 questions and provides r19. Megha (Intel) provides comments. Megha (Intel) provides some comments. Antoine (Orange) provides r20. Devaki (Nokia) provides r21. Hualin (Huawei) provides r22. Youngkyo(Samsung) provide comment. Josep (DT) comments and provides r23 based on r22. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides r24 (based on r23). Haris (Qualcomm) provides r25 Hualin(Huawei) response to Josep (DT). Hualin(Huawei) respond to Haris (Qualcomm) and provides r26 Josep (DT) replies to Hualin (Huawei). Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the revision of r27 Mike (Convida) provides r28 Youngkyo (Samsung) provides r34. Devaki provides r33. Devaki (Nokia) asks Orange, question for clarification Antoine (Orange) provides r31. Mike (Convida) provides r30 Megha (Intel) provides r29 and multiple comments clarification. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r35, questions and comments. Hualin(Huawei) object r29 and later revision(r30, r31, r32, r33, r34) which inherit the changes in r29. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides response Hualin(Huawei) response to Peter Hedman (Ericsson). Hualin(Huawei) provide r36. Josep (DT) comments and provides r37 Rainer Falk (Siemens) provides comment. Haris (Qualcomm) provides comment Josep (DT) comments with Haris' proposal to reach an agreeable conclusion. Josep (DT) corrects that he meant 'agrees with Haris' proposal to reach an agreeable conclusion' Josep (DT) provides r38 based on Hualin (Huawei's) r36. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question whether r36 was based on r35 or some previous versio. Hualin(Huawei) provide r39. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r40 Hualin(Huawei) respond to Megha (Intel). Megha (Intel) comments. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Josep (DT) objects to r30 and everything before. Would prefer to go with r40 Haris (Qualcomm) asks question about text in r37 onwards that contain in EN procedures for authentication with default credentials Antoine (Orange) objects to r36, r37, r38, r39 and r40. Josep (DT) replies to Haris. Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Orange's objection and hope the answers address your concerns. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question to Orange, DT and Qualcomm. Antoine (Orange) replies to Peter. Josep (DT) can accept the changes proposed by Peter (Ericsson). Haris (Qualcomm) responds Hualin(Huawei) can accept the changes proposed by Peter (Ericsson). Megha (Intel) provides r41 in DRAFT folder to reflect the changes proposed by Peter which is agreeable as way forward. To be opened in CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.2 | S2-2005962 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Evaluation and interim conclusion - User plane solutions . | Intel, Ericsson, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r41 of S2-2005101, merging S2-2004876, S2-2005623, S2-2005503 and S2-2005335. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.2 | S2-2005335 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Partial evaluation for SNPN in KI#4. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005962 | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005503 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4: Evaluation and interim conclusion. | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005962 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) propose this pCR to be merged into S2-2005101 and S2-2004823 Josep (DT) proposes to either postpone or merge into S2-2005101 and S2-2004823 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005623 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, evaluations and conclusions on boarding and provisioning for SNPN subscription. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005962 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) as the source company, confirms that Devaki is correct, this is merged into 5101 and 4823. Devaki (Nokia) comments that this should be marked as Merged into 5101 and 4823. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005537 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4: Evaluation and conclusion for PNI-NPN on-boarding. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hualin(Huawei) provide r01 for S2-2005537 to remove the conclusion part and only keep the evaluation part. Josep (DT) proposes to merge this pCR with S2-2005101 (agreed way forward for KI#4 Component 1) and objects to be approved as is. Hualin(Huawei) don't think this paper should be merged and response to Josep (DT). Josep (DT) replies to Hualin (Huawei). Offers to postpone this pCR instead to note. Josep (DT) retracts his objection but still proposes to postpone this pCR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.2 | S2-2005713 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, evaluation and conclusion for PNI-NPN remote provisioning. | China Telecom, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005961 | Haris (Qualcomm) this pCR should be marked as NOTED, merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101, Qualcomm objects to be approved as is Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) agrees that this pCR can be marked as merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005733 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4: way forward proposal. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Siemens | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005961 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Haris (Qualcomm) this pCR should be marked as NOTED, merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101, Qualcomm objects to be approved as is Devaki (Nokia) agrees that this P-CR can be marked as merged with S2-2004823 and S2-2005101. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.2 | S2-2005865 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: KI #4, Proposed way forward. | Cisco Systems | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005961 | Antoine (Orange): provides r01. Kisuk (Samsung): provides comments. Josep (DT) proposes to note this pCR. Josep (DT) corrects his last comment. I overlooked 'for SNPN'. I am OK with r01. Irfan (Cisco) suggest to consider this merged into 4823. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | Study on enhancement of support for Edge Computing in 5GC (FS_enh_EC) | - | - | Docs:=129 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005294 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Conclusion on Sol#17. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong(Intel) provides comments. Changhong(Intel) objects to this paper and any further revision. Jicheol (Samsung) requests Changhong(Intel) to re-consider the objection. LaeYoung (LGE) asks Changhong (Intel) about the reason of the objection. Changhong(Intel) answers to Jicheol and LaeYoung's questions. Stefano (Qualcomm) supports Intel objection. LaeYoung (LGE) asks Changhong (Intel) for clarification. Changhong(Intel) answers to LaeYoung's questions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005918 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on checking security concern of option 2 & 3 for Solution 22 in TR 23.748 | China Mobile, CATT | Rel-17 | Generated during CC#3. Noted. CC#4: r03 without attachment agreed. Revised in S2-2006033. | Dan (China Mobile) provides the LS out S2-2005918 in inbox Changhong (Intel) objects to this LS and any further revision. Dan (China Mobile) reply to Intel's objection and suggest the interesting company can focus on this part John (Futurewei) replies to Dan (China Mobile) Dan (China Mobile) reply to John(futurewei) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2006033 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on checking security issue for Solution 22 in TR 23.748 | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005918. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | LS | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004937 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Solution to handle SA WG6 requirements expressed in S6-200947. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to note according to the CC#3 conclusion on SA6 LS. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005778 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on application layer impact of FS_enh_EC solution #16 | Qualcomm Technologies Int | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004862, to S2-2005963. | Mike (Convida Wireless) provides r01. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks for r01 and agrees with simplifying the questions. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) provides S2-2005778 r02 Laurent (Nokia) provides S2-2005778 r03 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r04 Jicheol Lee (Samsung) accepts r00, r01, comments on r02, r03 and r04, and provides r05 for a way forward. because r02,r03,r04 include the sentense that cannot be considered as SA2' view. Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) agree with r02,r03, r04 and objects to r05 Mike (Convida) replies to Lyu (vivo) and provides an attempt at compromise text in r06 Yang (OPPO) asks Mike (Convida) for calrification Mike (Convida) replies to Yang (OPPO) Lyu (vivo) provides rev. 08 with editorial corrections. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 07 with editorial corrections. Mike (Convida) provides rev. 09 with an additional correction. Lyu (vivo) provides rev. 10 with little change. Lyu (vivo) support rev. 10 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005963 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on application layer impact of FS_enh_EC solution #16 | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005778, merging S2-2004862. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004862 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Edge Configuration Server Based Discovery | Convida Wireless LLC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005963 | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into S2-2005778. Mike (Convida Wireless) agrees that this document can be merged with S2-2005778. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2004862 in order to keep discussion on a potential LS to SA6 about Edge Configuration Server within revisions of Tdoc S2-2005778 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=38 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004830 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1,Sol#1, solution update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005973 | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005748. Jinguo (ZTE) agree to merge this tdoc into S2-2005748 Laurent (Nokia) objects to 4830 that is merged into S2-2005748 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2004831 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1,Sol#7, solution update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Jinguo (ZTE) reply Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks clarification Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks further clarification Jinguo(ZTE) response to Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Laurent (nokia) objects to this document Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2004832 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1,Sol#22, solution update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005970 | Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2004832 in order to keep discussion on sol 22 only in revisions tdoc of Tdoc 5364 Jinguo(ZTE) agree to merge with 5364 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2004848 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: Update to Solution #13. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005964. | Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks clarification and provides comment Laurent (Nokia) provides clarification Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks further clarification Hui Ni (Huawei) provide r01. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Hui. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides awesome comment. Changhong (Intel) provides comments. Jicheol Lee (Samsung) asks questions for clarification Laurent (Nokia) provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) asks questions for clarification Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification Magnus H (Ericsson) asks question for clarification Laurent (Nokia) provides r03 Fenqin(Huawei) responds. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05 and answers Fenqin(Huawei) responds and provides r04. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04 and answers Laurent (Nokia) is OK with Fenqin proposal. Thanks!! Fenqin(Huawei) comments and provides r06. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005964 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: Update to Solution #13 . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2004848. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004865 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol Update - UE DNS Behaviour and OAM measurements EN | Futurewei Technologies, ITRI | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005965. | John (Futurewei) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia) provides r02 Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00 and prefers r02 (candidate for approval) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005965 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol Update - UE DNS Behaviour and OAM measurements EN. | Futurewei, ITRI | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004865. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004956 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol 10 Update: Removal of Editor's Note. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2004957 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, KI#2, KI#5, Sol #12: Updates to extend the solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004958, to S2-2005966. | Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks clarification Magnus H (Ericsson) clarifies. John (Futurewei) requests clarification on DNS behavior in UE. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks further clarification Hui Ni (Huawei) asks to conclude this solution in KI#5. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r01, and answers Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02 Jinguo (ZTE) clarified that evaluation of 6.12.2.4 in sol#12 has been added in S2-2004836r03 Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r03 Hui Ni (Huawei) prefers to r02, and asks why the added part is needed. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04. Magnus H(Ericsson) provides r05. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00 r01 r02, r03, can live with r04 and r05. Lth comments Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005966 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, KI#2, KI#5, Sol #12: Updates to extend the solution . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2004957, merging S2-2004958. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004958 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #12: Update to remove ENs and editorial updates. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005966 | John (Futurewei) requests clarification on DNS behavior in UE. Hui Ni(Huawei) asks to merge this contribution into S2-2004957. Magnus H (Ericsson) accept to merge this contribution into S2-2004957. Laurent (nokia) based on 'accept to merge this contribution into S2-2004957' objects to any revision of the Tdoc. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2004963 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22 Update: Additions based on LDNSR for the Pre-established ULCL/Local PSA insertion scenario. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks clarification and provides comment Magnus O (Ericson) provides clarification to comments and r1 to handle the editorial comment. Laurent (Nokia) based on the output of CC3 I object to any revision of this paper to keep only S2-2005364 as a description of solution 22. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005004 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol#17: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005967. | Changhong(Intel) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02 and answers to comment from Hui (Huawei). Hui Ni (Huawei) questions how the solution coordinates with URSP and Allowed NSSAI. Jicheol (Samsung) provides comments and provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers and r04. Changhong (Intel) raises concern on this solution. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Jicheol (Samsung) pointed out that Changhong's concern is not consistent with the TR 23.748. LaeYoung (LGE) thanks to Jicheol (Samsung) for the clarification and thinks Changhong (Intel)'s concern on UE awareness is not valid and this solution is in the study scope. Hui NI (Huawei) comments that previous comments on allowed NSSAI issue is not resolved yet. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Hui (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q to Hui Ni (Huawei). Hui Ni (Huawei) replies to LaeYoung. Hui Ni (Huawei) replies. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00, r01 and r02 that lack important information to understand the solution; Ok with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005967 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol#17: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005004. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005045 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #9: Update to resolve EN. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005968. | Dan(China Mobile) provides r01 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) is ok with r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005968 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #9: Update to resolve EN. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005045. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005047 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22: Impact. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005970 | Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2005047 in order to keep discussion on sol 22 only in revisions of Tdoc S2-2005364 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) merges this paper to S2-2005364 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005048 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #22: Update to resolve ENs. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005970 | Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides comments Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Tingfang's comments Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2005048 in order to keep discussion on sol 22 only in revisions of Tdoc S2-2005364 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) merges this paper to S2-2005364 Jicheol Lee (Samsung) shows the preference on LDNSR as a standalone NF. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005049 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #9: clarification on the scope of the solution. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005193 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Key issue1: A merged solution of session breakout scenario with UPF based for key issue1. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to note this tdoc. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005249 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol#16: Updates to add impact. | Vivo, OPPO, Xiaomi | Rel-17 | CC#4: r05 with an additional editor's note agreed. Revised to S2-2005969. | Mike (Convida) provides r01. Laurent (Nokia) provides r02. Mike (Convida) asks questions about r02. Laurent (Nokia) answers to Mike and provides r03. Mike (Convida) replies to Laurent. Mike (Convida) provides r04. Lyu (vivo) provides r05. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00, r01, r04 and r05; r03 is better than r02 Mike (Convida) objects to r00, r02, and r03. Lyu (vivo) accept r00,r05 Laurent (nokia) answers: Hui Ni (Huawei) fine with r05, and asks for clarification on HR issue. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005969 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Sol#16: Updates to add impact. | Vivo, OPPO, Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Revision r05 (with an additional editor's note) of S2-2005249. For CC4. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005250 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol #16: evaluation and conclusion. | Vivo, OPPO, Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into S2-2004860. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2005250 in order to keep discussion on sol 16 update and evaluation only in rev of Tdoc S2-2004860. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2005250 in order to keep discussion on sol 16 evaluation and conclusion only in rev of Tdoc S2-2004860. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005362 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update solution #6 to support multi-homing PDU session. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005363 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update solution#28 and solution #32. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005364 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update solution #22 to resolve ENs and support multi-homing PDU session. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r15 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005048, S2-2005047 and S2-2004832, to S2-2005970. | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. John (Futurewei) provides r02 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r03 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04 Laurent (Nokia) asks Riccardo for a clarification Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Laurent Jie Liu(Chinatelcom) doubts no the need of deriving the GPSI from the UE IP address. Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to resolve LDNSR placement issue before concluding how to update solution 22. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05 and comments Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) comments on the LDNSR placement issue. Hui Ni(Huawei) comments on the LDNSR placement issue. Hui Ni (Huawei) comments on the proposed option 4. John (Futurewei) comments on the LDNSR placement. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments on the LDNSR placement issue. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for clarification on the 4th option. Magnus H (Ericsson) clarifies on the 4th option. Magnus H (Ericsson) answer comments on the proposed option 4. Jinguo(ZTE) comments on the option 4. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses. Laurent (Nokia) asks further clarifications Laurent (Nokia) provides an update for the CC slides Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides an update for the CC slides Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides an update for the CC slides Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides an update for the CC slides (v7) Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides r07 to solve Editor's Note A Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r08. Dan(China Mobile) provide r09 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) provides r10 Hui NI(Huawei) replies Jinguo's comments Hui Ni (Huawei) comments on r10. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Hui's comments on r10. Hui Ni (Huawei) continue comments. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r11 John (Futurewei) supports changes in revision r11. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) replies to Hui. Laurent (Nokia) provides r12 John (Futurewei) responds to Laurent (Nokia), provides r15 John (Futurewei) responds to Laurent (Nokia), provides r14 Laurent (Nokia) provides r13 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) asks a clarification on r12 (not r13) Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) asks a clarification on r13 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005970 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Update solution #22 to resolve ENs and support multi-homing PDU session. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r15 of S2-2005364, merging S2-2005048, S2-2005047 and S2-2004832. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005365 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update Solution#38 to support simultaneous change of UL CL and local PSA. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005481 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Update to solution 31 on Application Relocation with UE assistance. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005786 and S2-2005417, to S2-2005971. | Huazhang (vivo) : objection to the declare. Fenqin (Huawei) : Comments. . Lyu Huazhang (vivo) : Reply to the Comments. . Fenqin (Huawei) : Responds Fenqin (Huawei) : Provides r01 Yuan (CATT) is fine with r01 Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) we are OK with rev. r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005971 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Update to solution 31 on Application Relocation with UE assistance. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005481, merging S2-2005786 and S2-2005417. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005747 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol 14: Update to solve the EN. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005972. | Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005972 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol 14: Update to solve the EN. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005747. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005748 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Solution 1: Removal of EN, clarification. | NTT DOCOMO, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004830, to S2-2005973. | Jinguo (ZTE) merge 4830 into 5748r01. Laurent (Nokia) provides r02. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects r02. Laurent (Nokia) comments: Solution 13 does not rely on Nnef_TrafficInfluence, it does not care of which actual API is used Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03 LaeYoung (LGE) prefers r00, r01, r03 while cannot accept r02. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides comments on all the revisions. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r03 to remove the sentence as requested by Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Jinguo(ZTE) provide r04 to remove the sentence as requested by Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Jari (NTT DOCOMO) is fine with r04 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005973 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Solution 1: Removal of EN, clarification. | NTT DOCOMO, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005748, merging S2-2004830. Approved. WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005750 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Sol 15: Update to solve ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005847 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Solution#19, solution update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005782 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #21: 'Provisioning URSP configuration to the UE to establish PDU Sessions for edge applications based on Provisioning Domains'. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2004861 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Solution 16 Update. | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#1 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005248 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, New Sol: Discovery of EAS based on pre-configuration in Edge Enabler Client. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to note this tdoc. Jicheol Lee (Samsung) agree to note this paper with explanation. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=24 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004834 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, KI#2 Solution analysis. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Susana (Vodafone) proposes to note this tdoc Shubhranshu (Nokia) proposes to note this tdoc Jinguo (ZTE) agree to note this tdoc ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2004833 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way forward on KI#1. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r01. Susana (Vodafone) cannot accept r01 or original version. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r02. Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to solution #7 to be used for normative work Laurent (Nokia) objects also to solution #7 to be used for normative work and object to any version of S2-2004833 Jinguo(ZTE) response to Laurent(Nokia) Laurent (Nokia) answers to Jingo that the concern is still there ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2004849 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 1: partial conclusions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) is ok to merge as proposed by Hui ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2004868 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#1, Way forward: Selecting EAS with encrypted DNS Resolver | Futurewei Technologies, ITRI | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2005974. | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. John (Futurewei) merges Q10, session breakout part into S2-2005366. John (Futurewei) updates with only privacy aspects. Hui Ni (Huawei) comments. John (Futurewei) agrees with Hui's comments. John (Futurewei) provides r03. Laurent (Nokia) provides r04. Hui NI (Huawei) comments on r04. Laurent (Nokia) provides r05. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r06. John (Futurewei) provides r07 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) is fine with r08 John (Futurewei): revision 08 is acceptable for Futurewei. Hui Ni(Huawei) provides r08 Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00, r01, r02, r03 . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005974 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#1, Way forward: Selecting EAS with encrypted DNS Resolver . | Futurewei, ITRI, Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r08 of S2-2004868. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004869 | P-CR | Agreement | 23.748: KI#1, Conclusion for Pre-established Session Breakout | Futurewei Technologies | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. John (Futurewei) merges text into S2-2005366. Dan(China Mobile) merges text into S2-2005366, and provide r05 Lyu Huazhang(vivo) agree with S2-2005366r05 Dan(China Mobile): using wrong email list,please ignore the previous email Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc (merged) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2004949 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: Distributed Anchor connectivity model. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r19 agreed. Revised to S2-2005975. | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r03. Hui Ni(Huawei) fine with r03. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides a great revision in S2-2004949r04. Susana (Vodafone) provides r05. John (Futurewei) requests clarification on DNS based re-anchoring Magnus H (Ericsson) ask for clarification Susana (Vodafone) replies to Magnus H and asks for clarification on the clause 6.12.2.1 referred to in the last revision submitted by Magnus O Magnus H (Ericsson) answers Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r06 Laurent (Nokia) provides r07 John (Futurewei) requests further clarification. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r09 John (Futurewei) provides r08 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r10 Laurent (Nokia) provides r11 Hui Ni (Huawei) comments. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r12 John (Futurewei) provides r13 Jinguo (ZTE) provides r14 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r14 Jinguo(ZTE) suggest Hui Ni (Huawei) to provides r15 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r15 Laurent (Nokia) provides r16 Hui(Huawei) fine with r16 John (Futurewei) agrees with r16 and would like to co-sign. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r17 Laurent (Nokia) provides r19 (clean up). Magnus H (Ericsson)) provides r18 and objects to r16 and r17. We don't object to the delta provided in r17 compared to r16. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) is fine with r19 and would like to co-sign this contribution. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005975 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: Distributed Anchor connectivity model. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated, Huawei, Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r19 of S2-2004949. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004950 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: URSPs for Multiple Sessions connectivity model. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r22 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005416 and S2-2005307, to S2-2005976. | Jinguo (ZTE)proposes r02. Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes r01. Yuan (CATT) merges S2-2005416 into S2-2004950 per rapporteur (Hui)'s suggestion, and provides r03. Changhong (Intel) provides r04. Huazhang Lyu (vivo) merge ursp parts in 5251 to 4950 provides r05. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r06. Susana (Vodafone) request clarification on r06. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) does not agree with removing Solution #21. Sol#21 offers additional functionality not considered in the evaluation. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) comments and provides r11 Susana (Vodafone) replies to Magnus O and provides r10 Laurent (Nokia) proposes r09 Magnus O (Ericsson) does not agree with retaining Solution #21 and proposes r08 (small update of r06). Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) supports Susana's comments Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r12 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r13 Ulises Olvera (InterDigital) provides r14 Susana (Vodafone) provides r15 and comments Jinguo(ZTE) provides r16 and comments Changhong (Intel) provides r17 and raises concern on concluding solution #13 at this meeting, proposes to focus on the conclusion of Sol#1 at this meeting. Laurent (Nokia) provides r18 that just refer to solution 1 and to the need to improve NEF API. Susana (Vodafone) provides r19 with editorial update. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r20 with editorials and reinstating parts of the URSP conclusion. Changhong (Intel) asks questions. Laurent (Nokia) answers. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r21. Laurent (Nokia) provides r22. Laurent (Nokia) ok with r22 proposed for approval, objects to any version from r00 to r08 both included, and to any version from r14 to r17 both included Changhong (Intel) is fine with r22. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005976 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: URSPs for Multiple Sessions connectivity model. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r22 of S2-2004950, merging S2-2005416 and S2-2005307. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004955 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: LDNSR placement. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any version of S2-2004955 in order be able to only discuss S2-2005366 . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2004962 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: Session Breakout excluding solutions for Dynamic ULCL/Local PSA insertion by DNS response. | Ericsson, Qualcomm incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any version of S2-2004962 in order be able to only discuss S2-2005366 . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005046 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Way Forward: LDNSR placement. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) agrees to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc (merged) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005195 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Interim agreement for session breakout scenario of Key issue1. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Dan(China Mobile) OK to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc (merged) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005251 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Solutions evaluation and conclusions. | vivo | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Huazhang Lyu (vivo) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r02. Lyu (vivo) agree the merge Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc in order to discuss these points only in one document S2-2004950 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005307 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Conclusion on AF Influencing URSP. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005976 | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into S2-2004950. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any version of S2-2005307 in order be able to only discuss S2-2004950 . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005366 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1: Evaluation of solutions and conclusions. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r03. John (Futurewei) provides r04. Dan(China Mobile) provide r05 Lyu Huazhang(vivo) agree with S2-2005366r05 Jicheol Lee (Samsung) provides r06 with minor correction on r05. Dan(China Mobile) provides r07 with correction on r06. Dan (China Mobile) reply to Tingfang's comment Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments on r5, r6 and r7 Dan (China Mobile) reply to DOCOMO's comment and provide r08 Riccardo (NTT DOCOMO) comments on r5, r6 and r7 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) replies to Dan and provides revision. Laurent (Nokia) comments Laurent (Nokia) objects to any version of the tdoc that does not clarify 'ULCL part of Sol#2' so to r06, r07, r08, r09 Dan (China Mobile) provide r10 to refelct the Nokia's comment Dan (China Mobile) provide r10 link Dan (China Mobile) reply to Nokia's comments Changhong (Intel) provides comments, objects to r05, r06, r07, r08, r09, r10 and any further revision concluding clause 6.2.3.2. Dan (China Mobile) reply to Intel's proposal and object to any revision without including 6.2.3.2 Changhong (Intel) replies to Dan (CMCC). Susana (Vodafone) provides r11 Hui NI (Huawei) provides r12 Dan (China Mobile) provides r13 Susana (Vodafone) provides r14 Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r15 Magnus H provides r17 (r16 wrong). Hui Ni(Huawei) provides r18. Laurent 5nokia objects to r18; provides r19. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) provides r20. John (Futurewei) provides r21. Susana (Vodafone) objects to r19, r20 and r21 and reinstates the idea to resolve at the LDNSR in r22 Laurent (Nokia) objects to r22 and to anything that mandates LDNSR to be a full DNS. Provides r23 Dan (China Mobile) comments to Futurewei reply. Susana (Vodafone) provides r26 reinstating the EN regarding security. Vodafone objects to all revisions except r11 r12, r13, r14, r22 or as a compromise r26 Laurent (Nokia provides r25 with formatting claen up and a small additioj. John (Futurewei) comments to clarify. Dan (China Mobile) comments further. Dan(China Mobile) objects to r24 John (Futurewei) comments for r21. As commented earlier, Changhong (Intel) provides r24 and objects to r05 to r23 which concluding clause 6.2.3.2 and includes security concern on option 2 and 3. Dan (China Mobile) comments for r21. Dan(China Mobile)object to r24,r25,r26. We can accept r22 and r23. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses to Dan. Dan (China Mobile) provides comments to John and Tingfang and please confirm whether my understanding correct John (Futurewei) replies to clarify. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) provides comments and clarifications. John (Futurewei) provides response. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) can accept r22 or r23, and objects the other revisions. Zhuoyun Zhang(Tencent) is fine with r25 and r26. Hui Ni(Huawei) proposes a drafted r27. Dan(China Mobile) reply to Nihui's r27 and do not agree with this version . we can only accept r22 and r23 Laurent (Nokia) makes a proposal for a way forward Laurent (Nokia) makes a proposal for a way forward (wording update) Dan (China Mobile) makes a proposal for a way forward (changing conclusion part) Dan (China Mobile) r28 is provided in draft John (Futurewei) clarifies to Dan on security Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is fine with r28. Changhong (Intel) can live with r27, objects to r25, r26 and r28. John (Futurewei) responds to Dan. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) is fine with r28. John (Futurewei) can agree to r28 partial conclusion with addition in editor note below Susana (Vodafone) can agree with way forward in draft r28 for CC4 Dan (China Mobile) responds to Hui Hui Ni (Huawei) replies to Susana. Susana (Vodafone) asks what is the process to apply for these drafts John (Futurewei) can live with proposed way forward from Hui. Dan (China mobile) responds to John Hui Ni (Huawei) provides another way forward. Dan (China Mobile) object r27 and r29. And we have provide r28 as compromise, we can also accept r22 and r23 John (Futurewei) responds: section 6.22.1.4 does not apply for pre-established. John (Futurewei) prefer r22 or r26 (version at deadline). r27 (Hui's) is fine, but object to r28. As a compromise, we can offer draft r29 attached. Dan(China Mobile) responds to John and there is misunderstanding desciption in 5364r15 for option3A, so we can not agree option3A ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Dan (China Mobile) also can agree to r28 partial conclusion Changhong (Intel) cannot accept r28 and proposes postponing the conclusion on this part to next meeting. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005416 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, sol #1: Evaluation. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005976 | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into S2-2004950. Yuan (CATT) is fine to merge S2-2005416 into S2-2004950 per rapporteur (Hui)'s suggestion. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005442 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Principles for evaluation. | Vodafone, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Approved | Hui Ni (Huawei) propose to note this paper. Susana (Vodafone) replies to Hui Hui Ni (Huawei) fine to include the content in TR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005766 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Evaluation of solutions. | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2005855 | Revised | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005855 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#1, Evaluation of solutions. | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005766. Postponed | Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for clarification on the open issue. Susana (Vodafone) replies to Hui. Hui Ni (Huawei) replies to Susana. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) replies to Hui and Susana. Mike (Convida) provides r02. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to consider this tdoc as merged into 2005366. Susana (Vodafone) comments that not all evaluations to be merged into S2-2005366. Some others apply. Hui Ni (Huawei) request to confirm whether the paper is merged in S2-2005366. Hui Ni(Huawei) objects any revision of the tdoc, this should be considered as merged into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia) provides r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005757 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1: Evaluation and Conclusion on LDNSR for Session Breakout Model. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) agrees with the proposal to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366. Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of S2-2005757 in order to keep discussion on sol 16 update and evaluation only in rev of Tdoc S2-2005366 Zhuoyun Zhang (Tencent) proposes to merge this tdoc into S2-2005366 as suggested by Hui. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2004860 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Evaluation: Partial Evaluation for Discovery of Edge Application Server. | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised to S2-2005977. | Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r01. Changhong (Intel) provides r02. Lyu (vivo) merge 5251 to 4860 to get r3 Mike (Convida) objects to r03. Is fine with r02. Farooq comments on 4860 r3 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is fine with r01. Lyu Huazhang(vivo): reply to Farooq comments on 4860 and updated r4. Farooq comments on r4 for 4860 Mike (Convida) comments Lyu Huazhang (vivo) reply Farooq Lyu(vivo) can't agree with r6 and insists merge all of content and evaluation of solution16 from 5250 to 4860 . Jicheol (Samsung) is fine with r06 and provides comments. Mike (Convida) provides r06 and objects to r05. Susana (Vodafone) provides r05 and objects to all previous versions (including the original one) Jicheol (Samsung) replies to Lyu(vivo). Susana (Vodafone) requests clarification to Mike regarding the provisioning by the operator of an ECS FQDN and change what IP address the FQDN resolves to if the operator wants to send the UE to a different ECS. Mike (Convida) replies to Susana (Vodafone) and Lyu (Vivo), agrees with Jicheol (Samsung), and proposes a compromise in r07 Susana (Vodafone) disagrees with r07 and provides r08 Lyu (vivo) provides r09 based on r08 and disagree with r07 Mike (Convida) replies to Lyu (vivo) Lyu (vivo) replies to Mike Hui Ni (Huawei) provide r10. Lyu (vivo) reply to NiHui. Mike (Convida) comments. Lyu (vivo) object to r13 and insist r09 Lyu (vivo) object to r11 and r12 Laurent (nokia) provides r13. Mike (Convida) provides r12. Laurent (nokia) provides r11. Lyu (vivo) comments. Laurent (Nokia) comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005977 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #1, Evaluation: Partial Evaluation for Discovery of Edge Application Server. | Convida Wireless LLC, AT&T, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r09 of S2-2004860. For CC4. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=22 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004960 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 KI#2 update solution #24. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005467, to S2-2005978. | Jicheol (Samsung) provides r01 with comments. Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for clarification on the differences between new clauses and solution #23. Magnus H (Ericsson) answer Jicheol (Samsung) indicates that r01 was provided and received no comment. And objects to r00 due to the absense of the reference for ICMP security aspect. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005978 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2 KI#2 update solution #24. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004960, merging S2-2005467. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004961 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol 23 Update: Correction of references to other solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005245 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#33: Update to add impacts. | vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005979. | Jicheol (Samsung) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005979 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#33: Update to add impacts. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005245. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005246 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#39: Update to add impacts. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005982 | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to merge the tdoc into S2-2005801. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) agree to merge the tdoc into S2-2005801. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005247 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#41: Update to add impacts. | vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005308 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Update Solution #30: UE Agnostic EAS IP address replacement for traffic subject to edge computing. | Intel, Tencent, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005324 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#28: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2005980. | Shubhranshu (Nokia) asks for clarification and provides Comment Hyunsook (LGE) clarifies. Hyunsook (LGE) provides r01 to fix the typo. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) provides S2-2005324 r01 Hyunsook (LGE) asks Lyu Huazhang (vivo) to provide the revision again. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) provides S2-2005324 r02 Hyunsook (LGE) provides r03. Lyu Huazhang (vivo) provides r04. Hyunsook (LGE) can live with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005980 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#28: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005324. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005464 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol #34 Update for clarifications. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005466 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol #36: Update for clarifications. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005467 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol #24 Update for correction of reference (ICMP security). | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005978 | Jicheol (Samsung) comments that this paper can be merged with S2-2005467. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005417 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, Sol #31: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005971 | Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to merge this paper into 5481 Yuan (CATT) is fine to merge S2-2005417 into 5481. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005587 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#39: Update to enable AF-based PSA change. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005981. | Huazhang Lyu (vivo) provides comments to S2-2005587 Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides r01 and response to comments from Huazhang ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005981 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Sol#39: Update to enable AF-based PSA change. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005587. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005784 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #37: 'AF-based EAS End-Point-Address update via External Parameter Provisioning'. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005786 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #31: 'Application Relocation with UE assistance'. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005971 | Lyu Huazhang (vivo) comments on KI#2 Solution31 of new parameters Lyu Huazhang(vivo) : comments on KI#2 Solution31 of new parameters Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) : reply to Vivo (Lyu Huazhang) Fenqin (Huawei) comments and suggest to merge this paper to 5481. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005801 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #39: EAS relocation coordinated with PSA change. | Huawei, HiSilicon, InterDigital Inc., Apple, ITRI | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005246, to S2-2005982. | Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) r01 is uploaded to reflect offline comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005982 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #39: EAS relocation coordinated with PSA change. | Huawei, HiSilicon, InterDigital Inc., Apple, ITRI | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005801., merging S2-2005246. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005834 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Solution#29, solution update. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005835 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Solution#37, solution update using session management procedure. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#2 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004952 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New Sol: Generic Edge Relocation for all connectivity models. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005983. | Hui Ni (Huawei) provide comments. Magnus O. (Ericsson) answers to Hui's comments and provides new revision (r01). Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r02 Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r01 to clarify the relation between the solutions in S2-2004954, S2-2004953 and S2-2002952. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005983 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New Sol: Generic Edge Relocation for all connectivity models. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004952. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004953 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New sol: Service Continuity at EAS relocation with PSA coexistence in session break-out scenarios. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005984. | John (Futurewei) requests clarification on migrating to new EAS. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides answers to John. John (Futurewei) responds to Magnus. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r01 to clarify the relation between the solutions in S2-2004954, S2-2004953 and S2-2002952. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005984 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New sol: Service Continuity at EAS relocation with PSA coexistence in session break-out scenarios. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004953. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004954 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New sol: Service Continuity at Edge Relocation with DNS triggered insertion of BP/ULCL and Edge PSA. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2005985. | John (Futurewei) requests clarification on DNS for new EAS. Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for clarification on the differences between this and 4952 and 4953. Magnus O. (Ericsson) provides clarification on the differences between 4954 and 4952 and 4953 and answers to questions. Hui Ni (Huawei) requests to merge S2-2004954 into S2-2004953 and s S2-2002952. Magnus O (Ericsson) provides r01 to clarify the relation between the solutions in S2-2004954 into S2-2004953 and s S2-2002952. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005985 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, New sol: Service Continuity at Edge Relocation with DNS triggered insertion of BP/ULCL and Edge PSA . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004954. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005387 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: EAS relocation for SSC mode 3. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005986. | Shubhranshu (Nokia) asks for clarification Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01. Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments to S2-2005387r01 Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005986 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2: EAS relocation for SSC mode 3. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005387. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005851 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, New Solution: Multiple AF Scenarios. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2005987. | Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for clarification. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides clarification to Hui (Huawei) Hui Ni (Huawei) replies. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r01 and replies to Hui (Huawei) Hui Ni(Huawei) comments on r01. Hui Ni(Huawei) provides r02. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r03 Hui (Huawei) prefers to r02 and comments on r03. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r05. Shubhranshu (Nokia) provides r04 and replies to Hui (Huawei) Shubhranshu (Nokia) proposes to agree r04 Hui Ni (Huawei) fine with r04 with the agreement that context transfer is not in SA2 scope. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005987 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #2, New Solution: Multiple AF Scenarios. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005851. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005856 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Solution for KI#2: Session continuity in edge relocation scenario. | Cisco Systems | Rel-17 | Noted | Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for differences from this solution and existing ULCL mechanisms. Shubhranshu (Nokia) comments for clarification Hui Ni (Huawei) objects to the tdoc since the concern was not addressed. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Aeneas (Cisco) Replying to Hui Ni (Huawei)'s comments Hui Ni (Huawei) think the comments are not resolved. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004951 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Way Forward: Edge Relocation. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005326 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#2, Evaluation and Conclusion for KI#2. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. Shubhranshu (Nokia) suggest to postpone S2-2005326. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005367 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | KI#2 Comparison of solutions for KI#2 and way forward. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. Jicheol agree Changhong(Intel) to postpone this paper. Hui Ni(Huawei): fine to postpone KI#2 evaluation. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005836 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | KI#2, Way forward on KI#2. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is fine to postpone this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004846 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 3: Update to Solution #42. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005988. | Hui Ni (Huawei): Objects to r00 but can live with revision if all details on SA5 interfaces/entities are removed from the solution. Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 that indicates existing SA5 interface with, 'This step is meant to reuse SA5 R16 specifications. Any information on this step is only indicative (to show how the solution works) and is not meant for any 3GPP specification change Hui NI (Huawei) repeats objects to any revision that assume NEF acts as a SA5 NF. Laurent (Nokia) the solution has the EC AF NOT the NEF acting as a SA5 NEF; how can you object to introducing a solution that is in scope and fulfils non challenged requirements of the key ISSUE. Hui NI (Huawei) provide r02. Hui NI (Huawei) provide r03. Laurent (nokia) provides r04. Hui NI (Huawei) provide r05. Laurent (nokia) comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provides r06. Yang Xu (OPPO) agrees with Lenovo's comments needs to be further clarified and provides more questions unclear in the revision Laurent (Nokia) answers to the late revisions and comments Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses, can live with r05 and proposes the update next meeting based on the agreed points. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) responses. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005988 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI 3: Update to Solution #42. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2004846. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005225 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3, Sol #47: Update to remove ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | CC#4: r05 (removing note text) agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005468, to S2-2005989. | Jicheol Lee (Samsung) provides r01 with comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r02. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r03 and confirms Chunshan's correction of URL for r01. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r04. Jicheol Lee (Samsung) provides r05. Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r05. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) further clarification. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments and provides r06. Laurent (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc Chunshan (Tencent) can delete these network related information and provide new version for CC#4. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r06 and proposes to be discussed in CC#4. Laurent (Nokia) provides r07 in drafts that alleviates his objections and proposes this to be discussed in CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005989 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3, Sol #47: Update to remove ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r05 (removing note text) of S2-2005225, merging S2-2005468. For CC4. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005244 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, Sol#49: Update to support L-NEF selection and relocation. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005990 | Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to merge this contribution with 5389. Lyu (vivo) agree to merge 5244 to 5389 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005468 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, Sol#47: Update for correction of reference (ICMP security). | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005989 | Chunshan (Tencent) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2005225 or to be noted. zhendong (ZTE), it is a wrong AI. Jicheol (Samsung) confirms this paper is merged into S2-2005225. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005556 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, Sol#45 update to remove EN. | OPPO | Rel-17 | CC#4: The original document S2-2005556 was acceptable and was approved | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Yang (OPPO) concerns the action to provide revision with EN in the last minute without any comments before. Replies to no need for the EN. Yang (OPPO) propose to agree r0 as we don't see to need for r01. Laurent (Nokia) asks for clarification: what is new in this solution with regard to R16,? Yang (OPPO) replies Laurent (Nokia) replies ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005590 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3, Sol#48: Update the solution to remove ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005389 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Resolve the FFS in solution#49. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005244, to S2-2005990. | Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01. Laurent) provides r04. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) comments to r03/r04 for clarification. Fenqin(Huawei) responds. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) is OK with the clarification. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005990 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Resolve the FFS in solution#49. | Huawei, HiSilicon, vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005389., merging S2-2005244. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2005755 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3, Sol#44: Update to Remove ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | S2-2005788 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Update to Solution #46: 'Local NEF Deployment for network information exposure to Local AF with Low Latency'. | InterDigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#3 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004835 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3, New Sol: RAN node information exposure in AMF. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to r00 Jinguo (ZTE) ask clarification to Magnus H (Ericsson) Laurent (Nokia) objects to the solution Jinguo (ZTE) response Hui Ni (Huawei) asks for clarification. Jinguo (ZTE) response to Hui Ni (Huawei) Laurent (Nokia) asks for clarification. Magnus H (Ericsson) ask for clarification Jinguo(ZTE) response to Magnus H (Ericsson) Jinguo (ZTE) response to Laurent (Nokia) Jinguo (ZTE) response to Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for clarification. Jinguo (ZTE) response and provides r01 Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for further clarification. Magnus H (Ericsson) comments Magnus H (Ericsson) objects to the solution, i.e. all revisions Jinguo(ZTE) OK to note this paper for the time being ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.3 | S2-2005586 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Solution for the KI#3: Edge NEF based Network Information Provisioning. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | CC#4: r05 with corrections to step 7 agreed. Revised to S2-2005991. | Laurent (Nokia): Objects to r00 but agrees that updates can be made to alleviate my issues Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) replies to the issues provided by Laurent(Nokia)and provides r01 Fenqin (Huawei): ask question for clarification Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarification Fenqin (Huawei): responds. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Fenqin (Huawei). Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) requests clarification. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarification to Ulises. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides clarification to Ulises and provides r02. Ulises Olvera (InterDigital Inc.) requests further clarification. Fenqin (Huawei): comments. Fenqin (Huawei): provides r05. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) requests further clarification and provide r04. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides responses to Fenqin and provide r03. Laurent (Nokia): comments Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides response to Laurent and ask to consider the final version to CC#4 Laurent (Nokia): provides (after discussion Xiaobo Yu) a revision 6 in drafts that he asks to be reviewed in CC4 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2005991 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Solution for the KI#3: Edge NEF based Network Information Provisioning. | Alibaba Group | Rel-17 | Revision r05 (with corrections to step 7) of S2-2005586. For CC4. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004959 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#3 Way forward for KI#3. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. Laurent (Nokia) asks to postpone this paper and thus objects to any revision of this paper. Hui Ni(Huawei) fine to postpone the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | S2-2005368 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: Evaluation of solutions for KI#3. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Changhong(Intel) asks to postpone this paper. Laurent (Nokia) asks to postpone this paper and thus objects to any revision of this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004836 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5,Sol#50, solution update and evaluation. | ZTE, CATT, Apple | Rel-17 | CC#4: r15 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004964 and S2-2005388 in S2-2006034 | Jinguo (ZTE) provide r01. Laurent(Nokia) provide r02 and objects to any previous version Jinguo(ZTE) response and ask clarification to Laurent(Nokia) Jinguo(ZTE) receives no response and objects r02, prefer r01 or original version. Laurent(Nokia) answers to Jinguo(ZTE) Jinguo(ZTE) answers to Laurent(Nokia) Jinguo(ZTE)answers to Laurent(Nokia) Yuan (CATT) rejects r02 and provides comments. Dan (China Mobile) also rejects r02 and provides clarification for this case Krisztian (Apple) agrees with China Mobile's comments and objects to r02. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) asks for clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r03 Jinguo (ZTE) clarify to add evaluation of sol12 not sol22. Jinguo(ZTE) response to Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) that option 2 is removed in r03. Jinguo(ZTE) provide r04. Laurent (Nokia) redirects to the correct thread and makes a mail proposal for a way forward Yuan (CATT) provides r05. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r03 and r04 and provides r05 (removes conclusions) and comments Jinguo(ZTE)provide r06 to remove the conclusion part. Magnus (Ericsson) provides r06. Magnus H (Ericsson) ask for clarification Magnus O (ZTE) provide r07 to add small missing piece from merge. Fenqin (Huawei) comments. Tingfang Tang (Lenovo) reply and comments on the latest r07. Laurent (Nokia) objects to r00,r01,r02,r03,r04 Laurent (Nokia) objects to r05 ,r06 ,Ro7 also to but could live with a r07 revised by small changes (r08 proposed in draft) Jinguo (ZTE) agree with r08 in draft folder Magnus O (Ericsson) proposes a small change in revision r08 in draft folder Jinguo (ZTE) is ok with Magnus proposal and provide r09 in draft folder Laurent (Nokia) provides r10 in draft folder And comments Magnus O (Ericsson) is fine with r10 Jinguo (ZTE) is fine with r15 Laurent (Nokia) provides r15 and asks this tdoc to be discussed at CC4 for agreement. Jinguo(ZTE) provides r14 and asks this tdoc to be discussed at CC4 for agreement. Magnus H (Ericsson) provides r13 in draft and asks this Tdoc to be discussed at CC4 for agreement Laurent (Nokia) provides r12 in draft and asks this Tdoc to be discussed at CC4 for agreement Fenqin (Huawei) comments and provides r11 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.3 | S2-2006034 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5,Sol#50, solution update and evaluation . | ZTE, CATT, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision r15 of S2-2004836, merging S2-2004964 and S2-2005388. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004964 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5, Sol #50: Updates to the solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006034 | Jinguo(ZTE) provides r01 Laurent (Nokia) provides r02 Fenqin(Huawei) comments Jinguo(ZTE): suggest to merge into S2-2004836 Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of this Tdoc in order to keep only S2-2004836 and proposes a way forward for KI 5 Magnus O (Ericsson): It's fine to consider this merged with S2-2004836 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | S2-2005388 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI#5: Support of multiple AF influence traffic steering control request in solution#50. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006034 | Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Jinguo(ZTE): suggest to merge into S2-2004836 Laurent (Nokia): objects to any revision of this Tdoc in order to keep only S2-2004836 for solution 50 and proposes a way forward for KI 5 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.3 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.3 | S2-2004847 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI5: conclusions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Jinguo (ZTE) proposes to note it. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | - | - | - | Study on Enhancement of Network Slicing Phase 2 (FS_eNS_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=96 | - | |
| 8.4 | S2-2004825 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Network Slice Quota Exemptions. | Perspecta Labs, AT&T | Rel-17 | CC#4: r03 (+ note) agreed. Revised in S2-2006047 | Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification. Robert (Perspecta Labs) responds to Patrice (Huawei). Patrice (Huawei) replies and provides r01. Robert (Perspecta Labs) agrees with r01. Robert (Perspecta Labs) proposes rev 02. Gerald (Matrixx) suggest a refinement. Robert (Perspecta Labs) withdraws agreement to r01, responds to Gerald (Matrixx), and proposes r03. Patrice (Huawei) provides r04, disagrees with r03. Tricci (ZTE) cannot accept r04 but can accept r03. If no agreement, proposed to postpone this PCR. Patrice (Huawei) responds to Tricci (ZTE), unfortunately has to sustain objection to r00, r03. Tricci (ZTE) thanks to Patrice's (Huawei) detailed response and suggests a compromise. Patrice (Huawei) comments further. Patrice (Huawei) is also OK with the proposed way forward. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006047 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Network Slice Quota Exemptions. | Perspecta Labs, AT&T | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r03 (+ note) of S2-2004825. Approved | P | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2004837 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 New Sol#X: Support registration for incompatible network slice(s) in UE's current serving RA or different one. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006519 | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarifications Tricci (ZTE) responded to Malla (NTT DOCOMO) and provided a new revision. Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 with proper convention of the revision title. Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Patrice (Huawei) Alessio(Nokia) this solution contains two aspects: only the second is specific to KI#6. The first aspect is irrelevant to the KI. The second does not work in basic cases. We object to considering this a suitable solution to KI#6. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Alessio (Nokia) on his incorrect understanding of the proposal. George ( Ericsson) request clarification Tricci (ZTE) responds to George (Ericsson) Dan(China Mobile) provide some comments for update Tricci (ZTE) corrects previous response to Dan (China Mobile), however, r02 is still correct. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Dan (China Mobile) and provides r02 to address CMCC and other previous comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides question on scenario 2. Tricci (ZTE) provides r03 based on Peter's (Ericsson) comment and some minor corrections. George (Ericsson) requests additional clarification. Jinguo(ZTE) response Tricci (ZTE) requests Alessio (Nokia) if he would accept r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006519 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 New Sol#X: Support registration for incompatible network slice(s) in UE's current serving RA or different one. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004837. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2004838 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1#2#4#5, sol#18, solution update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006500 | Fenqin(Huawei) comments. Jinguo(ZTE) produce r01 as suggested by Fenqin(Huawei). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006500 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1#2#4#5, sol#18, solution update. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004838. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2004856 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5: solution 6.25 update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2004857 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6: Sol. Update: Solution 6.28 update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Telecom Italia…. | Rel-17 | Noted | Patrice (Huawei) comments, asks for revision (cannot accept the original version). George (Ericsson) does not agree with this statement in the updated solution: ' The need of standardization is based on the standardised compatibility classed defined in GSMA NG.116 and these need to be provided to the UE and the AMF by the UDM (both in roaming or in non-roaming case).' These classes is just a way to specify the constrains to the O&M system. Alessio(Nokia) rebuts what Ercisson and Huawei say Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments/questions. Alessio(nokia) repsonds: Patrice (Huawei) confirms the objection to the contribution as no update answering the concerns has been provided. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) also likes to open this in CC#4 for uniformity with the position by Patrice on 4859. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2004858 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: Arch assumption: reconfirmation of assumption of cells of a TA support the same S-NSSAIs. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to postpone this PCR Alessio(nokia) does not agree we need a LS response. We may also not need to send the LS. Patrice (Huawei) objects to the contribution. Dan(China Mobile) objects to the p-CR and suggest some correponding solutions for key 7 with adding ENs to show the RAN impact. Alessio(Nokia) comments. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Patrice (Huawei) further comments on logical fallacy. Alessio(Nokia) provides response to Patrice Patrice (Huawei) keeps his objection, will not further respond on this thread. Alessio(nokia) records the baseless objection but also notes that this was not possible to be understood as basis of the objection 'The requirement is per UE, and only on the S-NSSAIs provided in the Allowed NSSAI. This requirement cannot be extended to all S-NSSAIs and globally for all UEs in the network regardless of their subscription and what is provided to them when they register. Therefore, the proposed constraints on the deployment go far beyond the requirement.' ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2004859 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: solution 29 update. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: Approved | Tricci So (ZTE) requests the following PCRs to be discussed in a block - S2-2004859, S2-2004873, S2-2005073 Nokia disagrees. Alessio(Nokia) request this tdoc to be approved as it received no comment. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2004873 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Solution 29 Update. | Convida Wireless LLC, Telecom Italia | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci So (ZTE) requests the following PCRs to be discussed in a block - S2-2004859, S2-2004873, S2-2005073 Alessio(nokia) objects to this CR Mike (Convida) replies to Patrice. Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification. Changhong (Intel) comments. Mike (Convida) comments. Alessio(Nokia) comments on Intel statement. Nokia disagrees. Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question for clarification. Mike (Convida) replies to Hoyeon (Samsung). Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comment that solution lacks a flow and is related to disagreement regarding basic architecture assumption. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2004874 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Evaluation. | Convida Wireless LLC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to postpone or to note this PCR. Mike (Convida) is fine to postpone or note the pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2004875 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Conclusion. | Convida Wireless LLC | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to NOTE this PCR. Mike (Convida) is fine to note or postpone the pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2004892 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1: Proposed Conclusion on KI#1. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to NOTE this PCR. George (Ericsson) provides a response Tricci (ZTE) responded to George (Ericsson). Gerald (Matrixx) enhance the list of available solutions which needs to considered. George (Ericsson) provides a response. Jinguo (ZTE) comments Fenqin (Huawei) comments and suggest to postpone this paper to next meeting. Alessio(Nokia) comments and suggest to postpone this paper to next meeting. George(Ericsson) provides response. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2004893 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1-7: Proposed Conclusion on handing of Quotas related to N3GPP access. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Postponed | Tricci (ZTE) provided r01 Hyunsook (LGE) asks the clarification on GSMA LS. Tricci (ZTE) responded to LG George (Ericsson) provides a response. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides a comment. Alessio(Nokia) clarifies what the GSMA LS says Hoyeon(Samsung) replies to Alessio Alessio(Nokia) by all means we should discuss solutions at this meeting. Alessio(Nokia) provides a response. Requests to postpone this paper Hoyeon (Samsung) agrees with Alessio(Nokia) and Requests to postpone this paper Dan(China Mobile) provides a comment for N3GPP access Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Dan(China Mobile). Alessio(nokia) repsonds. George (Ericsson) GSMA will definitely propose these attributes. That's why I am trying to de-couple quotas for 3GPP vs N3GPP. Each attribute can have different setting for both accesses and may be roaming partner as well. So we have to flexible in our solutions Tricci (ZTE) supports r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2004894 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1-7: Proposed Conclusion on handing of S-NSSAI subject to Quota while roaming. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to NOTE this PCR. George (Ericsson) provides a response Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to note this pCR. Gerald (Matrixx) provided comment in respect of affected KI's. George (Ericsson) responds. Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this paper Alessio(Nokia) responds George (Ericsson) Single values does not mean it applies to both. This is one interpretation. So there has to be a way to allow it to apply to roamer or non-roamer individually as well. Having a policy is a simple way to accommodate both cases. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to note this paper ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2004895 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #2: Proposed Conclusion on KI#2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to NOTE this PCR. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to postpone the conclusion. Fenqin (Huawei) agree to postpone the conclusion and NOTE this PCR. Alessio(Nokia) agree to postpone the conclusion and NOTE this PCR. Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to postpone the conclusion and NOTE this PCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2004896 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6: New Solution Using Associated-Identifiers. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006520 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications. George (Ericsson) provides comments Tricci (ZTE) asked for further clarifications. George (Ericsson) provides answers. Tricci (ZTE) asked further clarification. George (Ericsson) provides r01, to clarify terminology and address comments received so far. George (Ericsson) asks for clarifications. George (Ericsson) provides comment. Tricci (ZTE) provided r02 based on Ericsson's reply. George (Ericsson) provided r01 one more time. Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests edits. Hoyeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Patrice (Huawei) is confused, asks for clarifications and shows concerns. George (Ericsson) provides response. George ( Ericsson) provides response George (Ericsson) provides a response Tricci (ZTE) withdraws r02 and thank you for Ericsson's reply. Alessio(Nokia) is not happy to accept this solution for inclusion in the TR (objects) Patrice (Huawei) replies, maintains concerns, and objects to r00/r01, asks for a revision. George ( Ericsson) When genuine questions are asked, responses have been provided, but so far neither Patrice nor Alessio seemed to have read r1, and instead of asking questions for clarifications as others who read did, they made broad statements about concerns, etc.., and which they have the burden to proof; before throwing them out. Patrice (Huawei) objects the CR, questions have not been answered, and the solution does not work as presented. George (Ericsson) so finally I have a specific question and I am glad to provide an answer below. George (Ericsson) provides r02 to add NSSAI Configuration aspects. Hoyeon (Samsung) thinks that the solution doesn't address the key issue. George (Ericsson) The key issue is for the network to ensure that the UE does not use some slices simultaneously. That is clear in the KI and GSMA NG.116. No other conditions are mentioned. So what U are stating below is not based on any input from anyone, nor even considered by any solution, nor justified by anything. It is irrelevant to the KI. The key issue reads in part: 1) How to enforce the constraints related to simultaneous usage of Network Slices in the UE and in the network, both in roaming and non-roaming scenarios. Patrice (Huawei) comments, OK with r02. Patrice (Huawei) comments further. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006520 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6: New Solution Using Associated-Identifiers. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004896. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005019 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Sol #1: Updates to enhance the solution. | Institute for Information Industry(III) | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications. Samsung (Samsung) asks for clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to postpone this paper Sangsoo (Samsung) suggests to postpone this paper Tricci (ZTE) proposed to Note this PCR given that none of the questions were responded ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Ming-Chun(III) response some questions as the attachment. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005022 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Sol #7: Updates to enhance the solution. | Institute for Information Industry(III) | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications. Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to postpone this paper Sangsoo (Samsung) suggests to postpone this paper Tricci (ZTE) proposed to Note this PCR given that none of the questions were responded ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005071 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Update to Solution 22 to resolve the EN. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for clarifications. Alessio(Nokia) provides r01 Haiyang (Huawei) replies to Sangsoo (Samsung) and asks for clarifications to Alessio(Nokia). Alessio(Nokia) responds Jinguo(ZTE) supports the serving PLMN can adjust the SMBR Haiyang (Huawei) prefers r00 (the original version) Chair (Tao) ask: can we live with r00 then? ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005072 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation on Solutions of KI#3. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006509 | Hoyeon(Samsung) asks a question for clarification. Belen (Ericsson) propose to merge this contribution into S2-2005127. Haiyang (Huawei) responses to Hoyeon(Samsung) and Belen (Ericsson). Belen (Ericsson) replies to Huawei comments. Alessio(Nokia) it seems we cannot reach a conclusion of this is subject to LS exchanges. So we propose to postpone this paper also. Belen (Ericsson) asks Nokia, if you can state which LSs you are taling about since you object to send LSs to SA5 on this. Hoyeon (Samsung) thinks that charging is not the main evaluation criteria for this KI, but seems OK to send an LS to SA5 to get feedback on this aspect. Similar to the other KI conclusion PCRs, we propose to postpone this to the next meeting Belen (Ericsson) provides r02, note that r01 is uploaded but with erros so no valid for revisions. Alessio (nokia) proposes that a single document evaluates KI#3. At present we have an Ericsson and HuaweI evaluation document. Cannot really work this way. Belen (Ericsson) suggest to merge both evaluations after the meeting. I don't see the issue, as long as those are not contradictory. Asking for views from other companies Alessio(Nokia) please indicate which document is the baseline and the other shall be noted. Haiyang (Huawei) suggests a way forward and provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) is okay and provides r04. Haiyang (Huawei) is OK and provides r05 for editorial. Alessio(Nokia) is ok with rev 05 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006509 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation on Solutions of KI#3. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005072. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005073 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7: Update Solution #29 to add location information for operating band information. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci So (ZTE) requests the following PCRs to be discussed in a block - S2-2004859, S2-2004873, S2-2005073 Alessio(nokia) does not agree to this P-CR (objects) Mario (Telecom Italia): I agree with Alessio's comment. Haiyang (Huawei) has questions on Alessio's comment. Mike (Convida) has the same concerns as Alessio's and Mario. Nokia disagrees. Alessio(nokia) reiterates objection and also clarifies that CAN means that if the UE tries to use it will work. Otherwise we should write 'can , depending on location, use'. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005079 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1 Sol#2: Updates to Solution #2 Max number of UEs per Network Slice control at registration. | NEC | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006503 | Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for clarifications. Iskren (NEC) answers to question from Sangsoo (Samsung). Alessio(Nokia) I conditionally can accept this paper on condition you create a revision removing the self-evaluation of the solution. Iskren (NEC) considers the comment from Sangsoo (Samsung) and provides r01 Iskren (NEC) answers Alessio(Nokia) that the solution evaluation section is removed in the already provided r01. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Gerald (Matrixx). Gerald (Matrixx) ask for clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) with comments on quota management. Iskren (NEC) replies to a comment from Gerald (Matrixx). Fenqin (Huawei) ask question on Quota management Iskren (NEC) answers Fenqin (Huawei). Gerald (Matrixx) replied to Huawei question. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006503 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1 Sol#2: Updates to Solution #2 Max number of UEs per Network Slice control at registration . | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005079. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005081 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2 Sol#10: Updates to Solution #10 Max number of PDU Sessions per Network Slice control. | NEC | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(Nokia) this paper only adds self-evaluation and a cause value 'name ' that is needless to add here as it is obvious. We object consistently with the position take on the other papers. Iskren (NEC) agrees for this pCR to be noted as it only adds a solution evaluation section which appears to have been removed from the template. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Gerald (Matrixx) Gerald (Matrixx) ask for clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) with comments on quota management. Iskren (NEC) replies to a comment from Gerald (Matrixx). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005083 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4 Sol#23: Updates to Solution #23 Network slice quota event notification. | NEC | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006514 | Alessio(Nokia) this paper only adds self-evaluation of the solution. We object to adding self evaluations. Iskren (NEC) removes the solution evaluation section as requested by Alessio (Nokia) and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006514 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4 Sol#23: Updates to Solution #23 Network slice quota event notification. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005083. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005086 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#27: Updates to Solution #27 Network slices simultaneous usage incompatibility support. | NEC | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006518 | Iskren (NEC) removes the solution evaluation section as it is not required and provides r01. Iskren (NEC) replies to comments from Patrice (Huawei) and explains his comments are of evaluation type. Patrice (Huawei) comments, asks for update (cannot accept r00). Alessio(nokia) agrees with NEC Iskren (NEC) addresses comments from Patrice (Huawei) and provides r02. Patrice (Huawei) comments on Alessio's comment Patrice (Huawei) comments, OK with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006518 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#27: Updates to Solution #27 Network slices simultaneous usage incompatibility support. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005086. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005091 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#31: Updates to Solution #31 Steering the UE to a network slice in a different frequency band. | NEC | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006524 | Mike (Convida) comments and ask questions. Changhong (Intel) comments. Patrice (Huawei) comments and requests an update. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Mike (Convida) and Patrice (Huawei) and provides revision r01. Iskren (NEC) provides r02 with removed evaluation section as requested by Chan Hong (Intel). Alessio(nokia) provides r03. This is to agree to document a wrong solution by example and stat it is wrong so people can refer to it as example of wrong solution. Iskren (NEC) answers comments from Alessio (Nokia) and provides r04. Alessio(nokia) observes Ericsson and NEC are updating the same solution independently Iskren (NEC) answers a question from Alessio (Nokia). Alessio (Nokia) responds to NEC and sustains objection till a technical correct solution is described Iskren (NEC) resolves the conflicting statements based on feedback from Alessio (Nokia) and provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006524 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#31: Updates to Solution #31 Steering the UE to a network slice in a different frequency band. | NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005091. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005125 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 Sol#13: removing Editor`s note. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) comments and seeks for clarification. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this P-CR Belen (Ericsson) replies that this solution resolves Editor´s note on UPF selection. Ericsson kindly ask Nokia on the reason why Nokia raises objections to solutions that are technically possible, and as such please go to evaluatin to see the merits of the solutions. Alessio(nokia) this solution adds a requirement to do in SA2 performance monitoring. We shall not step into the remit of SA5. So we retain the objection . Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia, that your comments are for evaluation purposes, so I cannot accept them for the reason that you don't think it is a good solution. Alessio(Nokia) I can accept the solution if you remove the monitoring aspect as it is irrelevant to enforcement. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia that in this solution the enforcement DL MBR is done in the PCF, Alessio (Nokia) responds the enforcement of a rate of data can only be done in the UP entities, we object this solution is technically correct ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005126 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 Sol#20 - resolving Editor´s notes on roaming aspects. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006511 | Haiyang (Huawei) comments and provides r01 Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for further clarification Belen (Ericsson) clarifies as requested and asks for confirmation on the response. Haiyang (Huawei) confirms the response from Belen(Ericsson) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006511 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#3 Sol#20 - resolving Editor´s notes on roaming aspects . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005126. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005127 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Evaluation and conclusion for KI#3. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Haiyang (Huawei) has concerns. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this paper Hoyeon(Samsung) asks a question for clarification on reason of concerns/objection. Haiyang (Huawei) clarifies. Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments from Huawei and Nokia. Propose to send an LS to SA5. Alessio(Nokia) we object to the paper and sending the LS. The UE AMBR has been deployed in live network and not sure if Ericsson now says this is an operational issue. This is a rate limitation and it is not even sure it causes dropped packets, just buffering... in any event queueing related losses at the RAN DL are always possible even with no ue-ambr (e.g. congestion). So not sure where Ericsson wants to take us now.... Belen (Ericsson) explains that the DL traffic is counted for charging in the UPF and then RAN performs DL Slice MBR limitation that causes dropping packets. This has nothing to do with buffering, it is quite basic and simple scenario. Alessio(Nokia) still objects Belen (Ericsson) provides r01. Conclusions removed and evaluation updated. Alessio(nokia) asks question Haiyang (Huawei) suggests a way forward and provides r02. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Haiyang (Huawei) provides r05. Belen (Ericsson) provides r05. Haiyang(Huawei) points out that Belen (Ericsson) does not provide r05 because r05 is already existing before Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r05. Belen (Ericsson) asks Nokia to send comments if any, with explanation. Alessio(Nokia) provides r06 Belen (Ericsson) comments and objects to r06. Alessio(Nokia) objects to all revisions except r06 and proposes to postpone if this is not ok the discussion as it seems we need more time to discuss. Belen (Ericsson) cannot accept rr06 provided by Nokia, if no other revision is acceptable better to note it ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005164 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Cell Configuration within TA/RA to Support Allowed NSSAI | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2006526 | Tricci (ZTE) provided revised r01 based on CC#1 outcome. Alessio(nokia) provides revised r02 based on CC#1 outcome. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r03. Alessio(nokia) Objects to adding Q-3 and so also rev-03 Mike (Convida) provides r04 Mario (Telecom Italia): revision 4 is fine, revision 3 is not acceptable. Alessio(Nokia)): revision 4 is fine, if we really NEED to send this LS. Patrice (Huawei) comments and proposes r05. Alessio(Nokia) provides r06. Fei (OPPO) provides r07. Nokia ok with rev 7. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Alessio(nokia) agrees with peter and provides rev08 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006526 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Cell Configuration within TA/RA to Support Allowed NSSAI | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r08 of S2-2005164. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005177 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | KI#7: Moderated Discussions and Way Forward. | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005178 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7, New Sol: Steering the UE towards the 5G-AN during PDU session Establishment. | ZTE, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | CC#4: There was no consensus on this and it was postponed. | Tricci (ZTE) provided a new revision rev1 for to clarify the solution's motivation. Mario (Telecom Italia): as it stands the solution is not clear and not acceptable. Jinguo(ZTE) response to Mario (Telecom Italia) Mario (Telecom Italia) replies to Jinguo answer. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Mario's comment Mario (Telecom Italia) replies to Tricci answer. Alessio(Nokia) comments Tricci (ZTE) responded to both Nokia and Telecom Italia Tricci (ZTE) responded to Telecom Italia Alessio(Nokia) clarifies how to read a spec based on 21.801 Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the technical views expressed by Alessio (Nokia) and Mario (TIM). Serge (T-Mobile USA) asks a question. Mike (Convida) comments and asks questions. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Mike, Patrice and Guillaume comments. Patrice (Huawei) adds two cents to the story. Also shares concerns expressed on the degradation of the functionality. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Telecom Italia to indicate his objection against the wrong key issue. Mario (Telecom Italia) still objects to this P-CR, unless it is added the condition that all the S-NSSAIs in the Allowed NSSAI are supported in all the cells in the RA, or (to use the same terminology in the PCR) supported by all the 5G-ANs in the RA. Tricci (ZTE) provides r02 based on Telecom Italia's suggestion. Tricci (ZTE) provides r03 for further update. Mario (Telecom Italia) provides revision 4. Alessio(Nokia) proposes to note this paper and all its revisions Tricci (ZTE) provides r05 to clarify the solution and to respond to Alessio's (Nokia) incorrect understanding of this solution. Tricci (ZTE) corrects the file's name suffix r05 without space and also to correct some typos in the previous responses to Alessio's (Nokia). Alessio(Nokia) comments and motivates why the solution is not needed based on the assumptions in this paper. Rel-15/16 operation is already excellent under the assumptions. Tricci (ZTE) thanks Alessio's (Nokia) responses to r05, but such feedback is evaluation comments. Alessio(Nokia) comments that there is no waste of resources Tricci (ZTE) responds to Alessio (Nokia). Alessio (Nokia). responds Tricci (ZTE) rejects Alessio (Nokia) objection until we see the proof to support Alessio's argument. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments e.g. question that AMF and SMF are impacted. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Peter to clarify his understanding of ZTE's proposal. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005181 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, New Sol: Allowed NSSAI containing S-NSSAIs operating in different frequency bands. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Heng(China Telecom) ask for clarification on how could AMF decide the allowed NSSAI based on UE radio capabilities. Genadi (Lenovo) replies to the questions from China Telecom. Further r01 is provided to fix a missing impact to RAN. Patrice (Huawei) comments. Genadi (Lenovo) replies to Patrice (Huawei) and provides r02. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this paper (even more) Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments to Alessio (Nokia). Alessio(Nokia) provides a comment substantiating the objection Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides questions. Genadi (Lenovo) provides answers to Alessio (Nokia) and Peter (Ericsson). Alessio(nokia) provides more comments Changhong (Intel) asks chairman to put all KI#7 related papers with single objection from Alessio to CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005182 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, Sol #30: Update to remove Ed. Notes. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005211 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Solution 6.6 updates with considering EPS/5GS interworking. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | George (Ericsson) provides a comment Dan(China Mobile) provides reply George (Ericsson) provides a response Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comment. Dan (China Mobile) provides reply Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. George (Ericsson) provides comment. Tricci (ZTE) provides comment and suggests to defer this interworking support consideration. Alessio(nokia) Dan(China Mobile) reply to the previous comment from Ericsson, ZTE, LGE, Nokia Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments and asks for clarifiations George (Ericsson) the solution for IWK when it comes to quota must be policy driven as well. This will depend on operator settings Malla (NTT DOCOMO) agree with Tricci to defer this interworking support consideration. Dan (China Mobile) reply to George (Ericsson) Dan (China Mobile) reply to Malla and Tricci's comment and suggest to further consider this aspect, only solution6 update not conclusion Sangsoo (Samsung) ok with r00 in this meeting Hyunsook (LGE) can live with r00 at this meeting. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) propose to discussion on tomorrow's CC on slice quota requirement from GSMA is applicable for the EPC or not. George (Ericsson) I don't understand what can be decided without requirements. This IWK can safely wait. Dan (China Mobile) reply to Malla and George and we can discuss in CC#4 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005213 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Solution update for KI#3 on limitation of data rate per network slice in UL and DL per UE. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006508 | Belen (Ericsson) asks for clarifications. Michelle (China Telecom) response to clarifications. Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to comments. Michelle (China Telecom) replies for clarifications Belen (Ericsson) thanks for clarifications and asks to update the contribution. Michelle (China Telecom) update the contribution and thanks for comments Belen (Ericsson) os okay with Haiyang (Huawei) reminds that please mention the revision in notes Haiyang (Huawei) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006508 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Solution update for KI#3 on limitation of data rate per network slice in UL and DL per UE. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005213. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005283 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7, New Sol: RAN configuration based UE steering during PDU session establishment. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Noted | Tricci (ZTE) proposed LG's to merge with ZTE's S2-2005178 Mike (Convida) asks a question. Patrice (Huawei) further comments and shows concerns. Tricci (ZTE) responds to both Patrice (Huawei) and Mike (Convida Wireless). Mario (Telecom Italia): if you cannot accept (and proposes to postpone) the architectural assumption in S2-2004858 in order to wait for RAN reply, I do not see why we should accept this P-CR, that is based on the opposite assumption 'It is assumed that some cell(s) in the tracking area(s) do not support all of the slices in the Allowed NSSAI.' I propose to postpone this P-CR. Mike (Convida) asks follow up questions. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Mike (Convida Wireless) and agreed that LG's assumption is different than ZTE's one Mario (Telecom Italia) proposes to note this P-CR. Seokjung (LGE) provides r01. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this PCR and all revisions. Alessio(Nokia) objects to this paper as we have the same exact wrong solution as NEC paper. As an alternative a revision could be provided indicating 'NOTE : this solution shall not be pursued, it is documented only to show a technical approach that is flawed' but I prefer noting the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005309 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Key Issue #7, new solution: RAN Assisted Allowed NSSAI Generation. | Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications and expresses concerns. Changhong (Intel) provides r01 to address Stefano's (Qualcomm) concern. Changhong (Intel) replies to Stefano (Qualcomm). Changhong (Intel) further responds to Stefano's (Qualcomm) comments and concerns. Patrice (Huawei) comments and asks questions. Fei (OPPO) comments and asks for clarification. Alessio(Nokia) same comments and also what is the problem we are trying to solve? Misconfiguration of the RAN to not support really the S-NSSAIs in the TA that is it saying it supports? The precondition, use case and necessity of this solution is missing. And it is unreliable for the reasons explained by patrice. Changhong (Intel) replies to questions and comments. Alessio(nokia) comment and objects to this solution Patrice (Huawei) would like to request an update based on the comments. Changhong (Intel) asks chairman to put all KI#7 related papers with single objection from Alessio to CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005322 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, New Sol: Operator quota control policy on the number of PDU session. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005337 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, KI#2: new solution: Operator controlled UE behaviour. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, AT&T | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | George (Ericsson) provides r01 Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarification on this solution. Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns and conditionally objects. Sangsoo (Samsung) also expresses concerns on this pCR. Alessio(nokia) clarifies Alessio(Nokia) responds to Samsung Tricci (ZTE) responded to Nokia Serge (T-Mobile USA) also expresses concerns on this pCR. George (Ericsson) provides response Serge (T-Mobile USA) responds to George (Ericsson) George (Ericsson) provides a comment Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to the explanations and object due to the complexity and risk of misconfiguration due to yet another set of policies in the UE. Patrice (Huawei) shares the concerns expressed by Qualcomm and others. Alessio(Nokia) comments and responds to qualcomm, Huawei and TMO Dan (China Mobile) support this paper Alessio(Nokia) provides r02 Hyunsook (LGE) provides a comment. Alessio (Nokia) responds Patrice (Huawei) express further his concerns, proposes to note. Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to note or postpone this pCR Alessio(Nokia) proposes to discuss this on CC#4 as the scope is the only reason for objection and we disagree the scope is a valid reason as I explained extensively why the scope applies. I will prepare a small slideset for CC#4 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005390 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 Sol#16: Update to Solution #16 for roaming support. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006515 | Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for clarifications. Fenqin (Huawei) responds Alessio(Nokia) I can live with this document only if the evaluation clause is removed. Please provide revision Fenqin(Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006515 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#5 Sol#16: Update to Solution #16 for roaming support. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005390. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005391 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Sol #1: Updates of Solution #1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006501 | Fenqin(Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006501 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Sol #1: Updates of Solution #1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005391. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005392 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Sol #7: Updates of Solution #7. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006507 | Fenqin(Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006507 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Sol #7: Updates of Solution #7. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005392. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005393 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4, A new solution for KI#4. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Fenqin(Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005394 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Sol #1: Updates of Solution #1 on NSSAA related procedures. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006502 | Sangsoo (Samsung) asks for clarifications Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01 Sangsoo (Samsung) ok with r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006502 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Sol #1: Updates of Solution #1 on NSSAA related procedures. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005394. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005395 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | General: Key Aspects of Solutions for Architectural Requirements. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision of (noted) S2-2004131 from S2#139E. Postponed | Tricci (ZTE) proposed to NOTE this PCR Fenqin (Huawei) responds Tricci (ZTE) responded to Huawei Fenqin(Huawei) responded and provides r01 Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments Fenqin(Huawei) responds Sangsoo (Samsung) responds Sangsoo (Samsung) proposes to postpone this pCR Tricci (ZTE) proposes to either Note or to Postpone this pCR Fenqin (Huawei) responds and suggest one way forward. Tricci (ZTE) responds to Fenqin (Huawei) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005478 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6, New Sol: Simultaneous use of network slices via Configured NSSAI. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006521 | Iskren (NEC) provides comments and expresses strong concern for this solution. Alessio(nokia) expresses concerns George (Ericsson) agrees with the view that these SUGs require support in roaming agreements. Also this observation in the solution 'observed that the simultaneous use of the network slices is constrained due to the network slices deployment in networks which result in there is no common AMF Set to serve network slices' has no basis. A single AMF or multiple AMFs can be deployed to solve this. Clearly GSMA rationale for this requirement had no connection to this observation whatsoever. George (Ericsson) requests additional clarification Patrice (Huawei) answers George's comments. Patrice (Huawei) replies Alessio's comment Patrice (Huawei) answers Iskren's comments. Alessio ( Nokia) objects you this paper Patrice (Huawei) responds to Ericsson, Nokia. Patrice (Huawei) answers. Patrice (Huawei) comments and provides r01. George (Ericsson) requests additional clarification. Patrice (Huawei) seems to see that George should be OK with my answer. George (Ericsson) provides answer Alessio(Nokia) provides answer ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Alessio ( Nokia) as a reminder we objected to this paper so not sure why it is listed as agreed as there was no answer to our concerns. We need to change the status of this paper to NOTED. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006521 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6, New Sol: Simultaneous use of network slices via Configured NSSAI. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005478. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005479 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7, New Sol: S-NSSAI-aware 5G-AN selection based on UE Radio capability. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Alessio(Nokia) objects to this P-CR Changhong (Intel) proposes comments and expresses concern. Mario (Telecom Italia): same comments as Alessio. Patrice (Huawei) answers comments and invalidates the objection from Nokia. Alessio(Nokia) sustains objection Patrice (Huawei) indicates that S2-2005479 has now been merged in S2-2005800r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005517 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, New Sol: Registration via multiple access networks. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | Fenqin(Huawei) ask question for clarification. Malla (NTT DOCOMO) ask question for clarification. Fenqin(Huawei) suggest to postpone this paper. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Fenqin(Huawei) and Malla(NTT DOCOMO). And can we live with r00 and work further in the next meeting. Fenqin(Huawei) responds and suggest again to postpone to next meeting. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Fenqin(Huawei). Malla (NTT DOCOMO) can live with original pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005519 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #2, New Sol: Handover of a PDU session. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006506 | George (Ericsson) provides a comment Alessio(Nokia) asks George is it really the same issue? George (Ericsson) responds that although handover between different accesses in 5GS and EPS/5GS interworking are different it is expensive to kill an established session for quota related reasons. At least this should be subject to operator policy. Alessio(nokia) provides comment Hoyeon (Samsung) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006506 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #2, New Sol: Handover of a PDU session . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005519. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005521 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, New Sol: Data rate control per network slice per UE. | Samsung, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006513 | Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Haiyang (Huawei). Haiyang (Huawei) further comments and provides r02. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Haiyang (Huawei) and provides r03. (forgot to mention that I provided r01 in the previous email) Haiyang (Huawei)is ok with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006513 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, New Sol: Data rate control per network slice per UE. | Samsung, SK Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005521. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005522 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #4, New Sol: AF interaction for event notification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005524 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6, New Sol: Interworking support. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Malla (NTT DOCOMO) asks clarification Patrice (Huawei) expresses concerns and probably will object. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Malla (NTT DOCOMO). Hoyeon (Samsung) asks Patrice (Huawei) to provide the technical comments so that I can response. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) and provides r02. (forgot to mention that I provided r01 in the previous email.) Patrice (Huawei) further comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Patrice (Huawei). Malla (NTT DOCOMO) further comments. George (Ericsson) would like to postpone this. Hoyeon (Samsung) comments. Patrice (Huawei) responds to the comment. George (Ericsson) Ericson also believes this is out of scope. At minimum, some clear requirements are required. We propose to note this pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005550 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, Update on solution #15. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005551 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #2, New Sol: Quota enforcement considering service type. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.4 | S2-2005553 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Partial conclusion on KI #1 and KI #2. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed | George (Ericsson) provides r01. Malla (NTT DOOCMO) propose to postpone this paper. Sangsoo (Samsung ) asks to Malla (Docomo): can we go with r01 in this meeting? ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005577 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#31 - resolving Editor´s notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006525 | Alessio(Nokia) objects to this paper. Mario (Telecom Italia) objects as well. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments. Alessio (nokia) provides R02. Alessio (nokia) provides right link to R02. Iskren (NEC) expresses support for this new solution. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to NEC. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r03 and highlights that from r01 the proposal is to create a new solution instead of updating existing Sol#31 Hoyeon (Samsung) asks a question for clarification Alessio(nokia) asks question Mike (Convida) comments Tricci (ZTE) asked for clarifications. Alessio(Nokia) provides r04 and objects to r03 Alessio(Nokia) OK with r06 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply and r06. Alessio(Nokia)responds Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a reply to Nokia that comments were based on mail and not the actual content of r05. Alessio(Nokia) can accept R04 but not r05 Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Convida. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Samsung. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia and and ZTE and provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006525 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 new solution - resolving Editor´s notes. | Ericsson, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005577. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005578 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#17 - resolving Editor´s notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006523 | Mike (Convida) ask a question. Changhong (Intel) comments. Patrice (Huawei) asks for clarification Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r01 and replies to received comments. Alessio(Nokia) provides comments and still believes the editor's notes are not resolved Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides reply to Nokia. Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides r02. Alessio(nokia) R02 is fine. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006523 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#7 Sol#17 - resolving Editor´s notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005578. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005579 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#26: Addressing ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006517 | Patrice (Huawei) comments, asks for update. Alessio (nokia) will probably object Divya (Ericsson) provides clarifications and revision r01. George (Ericsson) provides an answer. Alessio(Nokia) comments Patrice (Huawei) thanks Divya (Ericsson) for the answers and update, and provides a further update r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006517 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#6 Sol#26: Addressing ENs . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005579. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005588 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, 2 &5, Sol#19: Update the solution to remove ENs and add quota event notification procedure. | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006505 | Sangsoo (Samsung) asks a clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) provide comments for the revision. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 based on comments from Samsung and Matrixx. Fenqin (Huawei) Comments Yunjing (CATT) provides r02 based on comment from Fenqin (Huawei). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006505 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #1, 2 &5, Sol#19: Update the solution to remove ENs and add quota event notification procedure. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005588. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005589 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol#22: Update the solution to add SMBR event notification procedure. | CATT | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006512 | Haiyang (Huawei) seeks for clarification. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 to align with GSMA LS IN. Jinguo(ZTE) comments Haiyang (Huawei) comments to r01 and seeks for further clarification. Yunjing (CATT) replies to Jinguo(ZTE) and Haiyang (Huawei). Haiyang (Huawei) further comments and suggests a way forward Yunjing (CATT) provides r02 based on the comment from Haiyang (Huawei). Jinguo (ZTE) further comment. Yunjing (CATT) replies. Yunjing(CATT) replies Yunjing(CATT) provides r03. Jinguo(ZTE) suggest to add as new solution Haiyang (Huawei) agrees that a new solution is better and provides r04 Yunjing (CATT) provides r05 and also ok with r04 from Haiyang. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006512 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol#22: Update the solution to add SMBR event notification procedure. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005589. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005630 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Solution#4: Updates to remove ENs. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006504 | Fenqin(Huawei) ask one question for clarification Malla (NTT DOCOMO) provides clarification to Fenqin(Huawei) and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006504 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Solution#4: Updates to remove ENs. | NTT DOCOMO | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005630. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005800 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, New Sol: Compatibility of S-NSSAIs operating frequency bands with UE Radio Capabilities. | Qualcomm Incorporated, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | CC#4: There was no consensus on this and it was postponed. | Changhong (Intel) proposes to merge this paper into S2-2005479. Changhong (Intel) provides comments. Alessio(Nokia) Still objects to this paper as we did last time Stefano (Faccin) thanks for the objection and challenges the technical motivation, providing rev. 01. Alessio(Nokia) asks simple questions Alessio(Nokia) since the questions were not answered Nokia sustains objection to this paper insofar as it is not underpinned by justified and compelling scenarios to not uniformly support a slice in a TA nor by a GSMA requirement to not uniformly support a S-NSSAI in a TA. This is outside the scope of our study. Patrice (Huawei) addresses the simple questions from Nokia. Alessio(Nokia) makes Patrice notice he has not understood the questions Patrice (Huawei) says that if the purpose of the study were to fix Rel-15/16, then it would have been a study on Rel-15/16. Changhong (Intel) asks chairman to put all KI#7 related papers with single objection from Alessio to CC#4. Alessio(Nokia) the purpose of the study is not to keep us busy either if something is unnecessary and especially does not work when the cell that does not support the slice in allowed NSSAI is the only availabe TA for the UE. Alessio(Nokia) we propose this is discussed on CC#4 as we need to understand the scenario and the relationship with the KI ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.4 | S2-2005802 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #7, New Sol: NG-RAN initiated steering during PDU Session establishment procedure. | Apple, T-Mobile USA | Rel-17 | Revision of (noted) S2-2003733 from S2#139E. Noted | Mario (Telecom Italia) expresses doubts about the compatibility of the proposal with existing standards. Serge (T-Mobile USA) asks Telecom Italia for more clarification. Mario (Telecom Italia) replies to Serge comment. Serge (T-Mobile USA) responds to Mario (Telecom Italia) and Mike (Convida) Patrice (Huawei) expresses concerns. Mike (Convida) comments. Alessio(Nokia) comments that DC is supposed to work since rel-15/16 so not sure why we need to do work now. NOKIA wants to stop any discussion about not making certain slices work in a TA because the operator wants to use DC for certain slices in the TA! This is NOT necessary. Mario (Telecom Italia) comments. Alessio (Nokia) objects to this CR Patrice (Huawei) asks a question to Mario regarding the comment of CP (N1) being slice specific. Vijay (Apple) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005804 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6, New Sol: UE handling of constraints on simultaneous use of network slices based on network assistance. | Apple | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006522 | Peter Hedman (Ericsson) provides a question. George (Ericsson) In addition to the question below, Ericsson include r01 which has additional editors notes Patrice (Huawei) comments, asks for update. Vijay (Apple) responds to George (Ericsson) Vijay (Apple) responds to Patrice (Huawei) and provides r03 George (Ericsson) responds to Apple George (Ericsson) provides a response. Vijay (Apple) responds to George (Ericsson) and seeks clarification regarding the added editor's notes Vijay (Apple) responds to Peter Hedman (Ericsson) and provides r02 Patrice (Huawei) is OK with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006522 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #6, New Sol: UE handling of constraints on simultaneous use of network slices based on network assistance. | Apple | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005804. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005826 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Network slice quota control and enforcement provided by CHF based solution for KI#1, KI#2, KI#3 and KI#5. | Matrixx, AT&T, Deutsche Telekom, Telecom Italia, Telstra, Verizon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006516 | George (Ericsson) pCR needs to be updated. Please see comments. Tricci (ZTE) partially agree with Ericsson's comment Gerald (Matrixx) provided rev1 to cover the comments. George (Ericsson) provided rev2. Alessio(nokia) this paper addresses way too many aspects... if should focus on quota management (KI1, KI2), rate per UE/slice is like UE AMBR today... very unlikely to be requiring charging subsystem involvement... we propose to note this paper also because the CHF is not in SA2 scope. Tricci (ZTE) provides comments and responds to Alessio (Nokia)'s suggestions. Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments and expresses concerns on this pCR. Fenqin (Huawei) Comments. Gerald (Matrixx) replies to Samsung. George (Ericsson) Gerald, please include the link when U provide an update. Also the quotes 'Start, end' for capturing comments are being messed up with, so the scripts may not capture anything. Gerald (Matrixx) confirmed the improvement with rev2. Gerald (Matrixx) provided clarifications to comments from Huawei. Gerald (Matrixx) provided rev3 which covers the solution to KI#1-2 and all other comments. https://www.3gpp.org/ftp/tsg_sa/WG2_Arch/TSGS2_140e_Electronic/INBOX/Revisions/S2-2005826r03.zip Gerald (Matrixx) provided more clarification on charging to Huawei comment. Fenqin (Huawei) Comments and provides r04. Gerald (Matrixx) acknowledged Huawei comments with editorial fine tuning in r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006516 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: Network slice quota control and enforcement provided by CHF based solution for KI#1 and KI#2 . | Matrixx, AT&T, Deutsche Telekom, Telecom Italia, Telstra, Verizon | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005826. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005852 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol#21: Updates to Solution #21, Limitation of data rate per network slice in UL and DL per UE without RAN involvement. | Apple | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006510 | Alessio(nokia) provided r01 removing the self evaluation ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.4 | S2-2006510 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #3, Sol#21: Updates to Solution #21, Limitation of data rate per network slice in UL and DL per UE without RAN involvement. | Apple | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005852. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.4 | S2-2005860 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #5, Sol#12: solution evaluation. | Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Sangsoo (Samsung) provides comments. Tricci (ZTE) responded to Samsung. Alessio(nokia) to be consistent with NEC, we object to this paper that contains only self-evaluation Sangsoo (Samsung) supports Nokia to note this pCR ? ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.4 | S2-2005861 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI #5, Sol#24: solution evaluation. | Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Alessio(nokia) to be consistent with NEC papers, we object to this paper that contains only self-evaluation Sangsoo (Samsung ) also suggests to note this pCR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | Study on enhanced support of Industrial IoT - TSC/URLLC enhancements (FS_IIoT) | - | - | Docs:=78 | - | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | General, LS | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004921 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: General: Change Timing Domain to Time Domain. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.5 | S2-2005745 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Use of Survival Time for Deterministic Applications in 5GS | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Postponed | Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for the clarification on this LS Yuan (CATT) clarifies. Sebastian (Qualcomm) comments Chia-Lin (MediaTek) propose to postpone this LS Devaki (Nokia) states that the terminology used is well known as quoted by Yuan (CATT) thus the rationale quoted by Mediatek is not fully true. There seems to be majority preference to send the LS to hear RAN2 preference for survival time format. Devaki (Nokia) states that postponing the LS would delay survival time work. Sang-Jun (Samsung) agrees with Devaki (Nokia) on sending the LS. Chia-Lin (MediaTek) provides the response to Devaki (Nokia) Chia-Lin (MediaTek) points out 'well known' does not mean 'well understood' as the meaning of 'time' is abstract in the definitions - IEEE raised the same issue. Proposes r01 in draft folder. Shabnam (Ericsson) needs more time to review as did not check in the Drafts folder for revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.5 | S2-2004934 | LS In | Information | LS from IEEE 802.1: Response to LS on the need for survival time | IEEE 802.1 (liaison-response-3GPP-SA2-survival-time) | Postponed | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004918 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to handle ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006035 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes that the updates (in section 6.1.3.3) can be merged with S2-2005734. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to consider this paper merged with 5734 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2004999 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: update to fix EN. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006035 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge this paper with S2-2005734. Sebastian (Qualcomm) also propose to merge with 5734 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005000 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#2: Update to correct the impacts. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) Objects to the pCR and this assumption of two port behind DS-TT, no need for such assumption or verification. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Shabnam and requests clarification for the restriction to the port number of DS-TT Sang-Jun comments and supports Xiaowan (vivo). Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the PCR Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm) and provides R01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) shares same view as expressed by Qualcomm in the comments and also Objects to this pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005156 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, sol#1, Update the solution 1. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005992. | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to remove the newly added EN. It is already resolved by another paper in S2-2005734. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. zhendong (ZTE), is fine with r01 Dan (China Mobile) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005992 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, sol#1, Update the solution 1. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005156. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005506 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: Update for resolving ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006035 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to have one baseline (5734) (as agreed) for solution #1 updates. Sang-Jun (Samsung) agrees to have one base line (5734) for solution #1 updates, and to merge 5506 to 5734. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005627 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, Sol #1: clarify for BMCA support. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006035 | Qianghua (Huawei) this is merged with S2-2005734 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005734 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: Updates to Solution #1 for Uplink Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT Docomo | Rel-17 | CC#4: r12 with some text changes agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004918, S2-2004999, S2-2005506 and S2-2005627, in S2-2006035 | Shabnam (Ericsson) provided a merger with S2-2005734 of S2-2004918. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02, which updates 5734 with texts from 5506. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03, merging S2-2005627 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r04, merging S2-2004999 Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r05 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r06 Devaki (Nokia) raises a question. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r08, and replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). Qianghua (Huawei) provides r07 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r09 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r10. zhendong (ZTE), provides r11 Devaki (Nokia) wonders if Method 3 can be removed from the paper? zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Xiaowan (vivo) provide r35 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r12 (clarify previous r35 is wrong) Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers r10, can agree also r11, r12 György (Ericsson) can only accept any revision if we remove the following sentences below; we object to any revision if these sentences are not removed. 'The forwarding process is done according to N4 rules configured by the SMF. Packet replication and detection carry on information attributes within the Packet Detection Rules (PDRs) support multicast traffic forwarding preventing the UPF from sending the multicast packets back to the source UE or source N19/N6.' György (Ericsson) gives clarification about which sentences to remove, as shown in r13 in green highlight. We can only accept any revision if we remove the sentences in green highlight in r13, also copied below; we object to any revision if these sentences are not removed. 'The forwarding process is done according to N4 rules configured by the SMF. Packet replication and detection carry on information attributes within the Packet Detection Rules (PDRs) support multicast traffic forwarding preventing the UPF from sending the multicast packets back to the source UE or source N19/N6.' 'For traffic forwarding, dedicated Packet Detection Rules (PDRs) can include packet replication and detection carry on information to control the multicast forwarding functionality of the UPF (i.e. avoid play back to the source UE).' Qianghua (Huawei) can accept r10, r11, r12 Sebastian (Qualcomm) prefers r10; can also live with r09, r11, r12; objects to other revisions. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is fine to remove the sentences suggested by György (Ericsson) from any of these revisions to make them agreeable. zhendong (ZTE), prefer with r12 Devaki (Nokia) comments the statements removed by Ericsson are actually in current stage 3 Rel-16. Thus I fail to understand the justification to remove the statement that is simply referring to existing mechanism. Qianghua (Huawei) shares with Devaki's understanding and propose we can go with r10/r11/r12. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Devaki (Nokia) asks if we can go with r13, in the interest of progress? Many papers merged to this (and many companies worked on this), would be a pity not to progress at this point. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r10 to r13 in the interest of progress ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Xiaowan (vivo) is OK with r10/r11/r12/r13 in the interest of progress, also share the technical view with Jari. Sang-Jun (Samsung) is OK with r08~r13. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006035 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, Sol#1: Updates to Solution #1 for Uplink Time Synchronization . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT DOCOMO, Ericsson, Samsung, vivo, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r12 (with some text changes) of S2-2005734, merging S2-2004918, S2-2004999, S2-2005506 and S2-2005627. CC#4: Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#1 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005160 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, new sol, new solution to support the BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005993. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Jari (NTT DOCOMO) responds to Zhendong zhendong (ZTE), provides the r01 zhendong (ZTE), propose the seperate the solution. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to document the updates on top of existing solution that is similar to this. More specifically, consider merging with 5734. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r04; also questions if there is a need to document this as a separate solution Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r05, replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005993 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1, new sol, new solution to support the BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005160. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005323 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, #3B New Sol: Supporting announce messages for BMCA. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005994. | Devaki (Nokia) comments that this can be merged to an existing solution #1. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Devaki (Nokia). Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to note the paper or to make it much shorter as an minimalistic update to solution 1 Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r02, and replies to Sebastian (Qualcomm). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005994 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1, #3B New Sol: Supporting announce messages for BMCA . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005323. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005845 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2005995. | Xiaowan (vivo) provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 zhendong (ZTE), provides the r03 Chia-Lin (MediaTek) ask for clarification on the EN related to 10 ms in IEEE 802.1AS Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Devaki (Nokia) provides r04. Agrees with Chia-lin (Mediatek) and Sang-Jun (Samsung) that EN for 10msec is not needed. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r05, with two changes. Chunshan (Tencent) provides comments and asks for co-sign this paper. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05 Chia-Lin (MediaTek) is ok with r05 zhendong (ZTE), r05 is fine ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005995 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #1: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005845. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=10 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004914 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol 10: Updates on static forwarding solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005996. | Dan (China Mobile) comments György (Ericsson) responds to China Mobile. Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) provides responses to Huawei comments. Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to make a revision so we can see how to go forward with the revision, and we hold the strong concerns on the original György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and provides r01. György (Ericsson) provides r04. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02/03, prefer r02. György (Ericsson) provides r03 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Qianghua (Huawei) prefers r0, but can live with r04, 03 Qianghua (Huawei) prefers r02, but can live with r04, 03 György (Ericsson) proposes to go ahead with r03. Qianghua (Huawei) responds ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005996 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, sol 10: Updates on static forwarding solution. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004914. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005159 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, sol#12, resolve the EN in the solution#12. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | György (Ericsson) sees problems with the proposal. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response György (Ericsson) responds to ZTE. Yoohwa (ETRI) provides S2-2005159r01 to merge S2-2005447. György (Ericsson) objects to r01 and also to the original CR. zhendong (ZTE), response to ericsson zhendong (ZTE), provides the r02 Yoohwa (ETRI) responds to Ericsson comments. György (Ericsson), responds to ZTE. György (Ericsson) objects to r02. György (Ericsson) responds to ETRI. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005221 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #12: Update to include MAC Address Learning and Static Filtering Updating. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005159 | György (Ericsson) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. zhendong (ZTE), propose this paper merged to 5159 György (Ericsson) responds to Tencent. Chunshan (Tencent) supports solution#12 and agrees this paper to be merged into 5159. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005447 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #12: Update to clarify UE-UE TSC communication. | ETRI | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005159 | György (Ericsson) comments. Yoohwa (ETRI) responds to Ericsson comments. György (Ericsson) responds to ETRI. zhendong (ZTE), propose this paper merged to 5159 Yoohwa (ETRI) provides S2-2005159r01 to merge S2-2005447 into S2-2005159. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005518 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update for resolving ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2005997 | György (Ericsson) comments. zhendong (ZTE), proposes this pCR is merged to S2-2005626 Devaki (Nokia) supports ZTE proposal to merge this with S2-2005626. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts the proposal to merge the this pCR with 5626. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005626 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the Editor notes. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005518, to S2-2005997. | György (Ericsson) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) responds György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 György (Ericsson) provides r02 and responds to Huawei Qianghua (Huawei) provides r03 György (Ericsson) objects to r03 and proposes to go ahead with r02. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02, and responds to objection to r03 György (Ericsson) OK with r02, and responds to Huawei ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005997 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, Sol #3: Update to clarify the Editor notes. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005626., merging S2-2005518. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005735 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2005998. | György (Ericsson) comments. Devaki (Nokia) responds to Ericsson comments. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) shares most of Ericsson View and provides R01 György (Ericsson) provides r02. Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. György (Ericsson) is ok with r03. Qianghua (Huawei) is OK with r03; ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005998 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2, Sol#4: Updates for Deterministic QoS for UE-UE TSC communication. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005735. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#2 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004915 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: Delay model for UE-UE communication. | Ericsson, China Mobile | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2005999. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02/r01, prefer r01; György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei and provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01, one EN and a NOTE are added to reflect the technical concerns. György (Ericsson) proposes to go ahead with r02. Qianghua (Huawei) sustains our opinions: prefer r01, but can live with r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2005999 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: Delay model for UE-UE communication. | Ericsson, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004915. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004916 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: VLAN configuration. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006000. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) provides responses. György (Ericsson) provides r02. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01, several ENs are added to reflect the technical concerns. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r02, r01 György (Ericsson) proposes to go ahead with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006000 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, New sol: VLAN configuration. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004916. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005821 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2, New Sol - Co-existence of Traffic forwarding information provided by CNC with PDR/FAR. | Intel | Rel-17 | Noted | György (Ericsson) asks basic questions about the proposal. Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005625 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005736, to S2-2006001. | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone this paper proposing KI#2 conclusion considering new solutions for this meeting. Xiaowan (vivo) support Devaki (Nokia) to postpone the conclusion for KI#2. Qianghua (Huawei) suggests making some progress on aspects that are stable. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01, merging S2-2005736. György (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia and Vivo to postpone the paper since it is too early to draw conclusions, but provides comments to progress the discussion. Qianghua (Huawei) responds Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Devaki (Nokia) propose to postpone KI#2 conclusion. Qianghua (Huawei) asks questions Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 György (Ericsson) provides r03 György (Ericsson) responds to Samsung. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r04 György (Ericsson) ok with r04, responds to Huawei. Devaki (Nokia) proposes to postpone this paper as for KI#2, we have many new solutions and solution updates to consider. György (Ericsson) responds to Nokia. Qianghua (Huawei) OK with r05; Devaki (Nokia) cannot accept r06 as AF does not know about PDU Sessions in 3GPP system, it brings back convoluted bullet from r04. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r06 Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. Devaki (Nokia) responds. Qianghua (Huawei) responds and think the new solutions don't impact the r04 conclusion György (Ericsson) objects to all revisions except r04. Qianghua (Huawei) asks can we accept r05 if we remove the 'may'? Devaki (Nokia) is OK to change 'may send' to 'sends'. Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r04, objects to all other revisions Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to go with the R05x which change 'may send' to 'sends' György (Ericsson) is OK with r05 if we change 'may send' to 'sends' Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05x Qianghua (Huawei) proposes to consider r05x as the way forward, r05x addresses your concerns ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006001 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005625., merging S2-2005736. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005736 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #2: Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006001 | Qianghua (Huawei) suggests merging this with S2-2005625 and take S2-2005625 as baseline. Xiaowan (vivo) request to postpone the conclusion for KI#2. György (Ericsson) agrees with Nokia and Vivo that we should postpone this conclusion paper. But some high level comments are provided to progress discussion and understanding. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the eval/conclusion paper as is Qianghua (Huawei) clarifies that this should be merged with S2-2005625 or postponed. Sebastian (Qualcomm): paper should be marked 'noted' since there was no rev and Qualcomm objected to r00 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004919 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to clarify monitoring events. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006002. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01, with single overlap removed which is the new EN, see comment. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Devaki (Nokia) provides r03. Belen (Ericsson) is okay with r02 Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Belen (Ericsson) replies to Nokia and ask for confirmation to be able to implement comments if needed. Devaki (Nokia) replies. Belen (Ericsson) replies. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006002 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #5: Update to clarify monitoring events. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2004919. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005084 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: Update to Solution #5: On the need for hold and forward buffers. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Atsushi (NTT Docomo) asks a question. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Devaki (Nokia) comments. Atsushi (NTT Docomo) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Dan (China Mobile) propose to NOTE this paper Sebastian (Qualcomm) disagrees with CMCC Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Nokia Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Chunshan Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Athushi Devaki (Nokia) replies to Qualcomm. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Qianghua (Huawei) shares Nokia understanding Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments Dan(China Mobile) reply to Sebastian previous question and also support Nokia Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Huawei Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Dan Devaki (Nokia) objects to remove the EN and the paper, proposes to note this time and revisit the H&F buffer next time. Sebastian (Qualcomm) suggests to not mix requirements for automation and VIAPA and clarifies that there are no requirements that justify HnF buffers for VIAPA Devaki (Nokia) responds with the SA1 requirements for VIAPA services that warrant the need for H&F buffers. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005163 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, Sol #13: Update to clarify impact related to jitter measurements. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.5 | S2-2005737 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Sol #5: Update to Solution #5 for Capability Reporting. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006003. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Shabnam (Ericsson) states they are addressing separate issues and asks questions for clarification on this pCR. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the CR Devaki (Nokia) asks QCOM whether the objection is really for the right P-CR? If the objection is against H&F buffering, this P-CR is not the one addressing H&F buffering. This P-CR is about 5GS reporting capability towards AF. Answers Ericsson's questions. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02 based on discussions with Belen (Ericsson) regarding 4919. Belen (Ericsson) provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006003 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Sol #5: Update to Solution #5 for Capability Reporting. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005737. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005738 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, Sol #5: Update to Solution #5 to Resolve Editor's Notes. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Devaki provides r01. Qianghua (Huawei) responds and agrees this should be considered Devaki (Nokia) replies to Huawei. Belen (Ericsson) asks questions for clarifications and comemnts. Devaki (Nokia) answers Ericsson's questions. Belen (Ericsson) provides r02. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004917 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, New sol: TSN stream information provisioning from CNC to 5GS. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006004. | Qianghua (Huawei) provides comments György (Ericsson) responds to Huawei questions. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 György (Ericsson) is fine with r01. Devaki (Nokia) wonders if this solution is really in 3GPP scope, KI#3A/FS_IIoT scope? It seems to be in IEEE scope. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) asks for clarification. György (Ericsson) responds that there are multiple ways for standardization. György (Ericsson) responds to DoCoMo. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006004 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A, New sol: TSN stream information provisioning from CNC to 5GS. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004917. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005161 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, new sol, solution proposal on the burst spread. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006005. | Devaki (Nokia) proposes r01 Sang-Jun (Samsung) ask a question for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that the solution is not addressing the Key Issue 3A as defined, and as such should be noted/not considered, see comment. zhendong (ZTE), provides r01 zhendong (ZTE), provides r02 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Qianghua (Huawei) points out that r01 is already provided by Devaki(Nokia), and we think this solution works Shabnam (Ericsson) asks if r02 to be considered since no one posted email for it? Can not agree to this if an EN says it is not known yet how how it is determined? zhendong (ZTE), provides the r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006005 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, new sol, solution proposal on the burst spread. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005161. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005242 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, New Solution: Transmission Delay Measurement on N6. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006006. | Shabnam (Ericsson) comments that the solution is not addressing the Key Issue 3A as defined, and provides additional technical concerns as comments. Dan (China Mobile) reply Shabnam's comments and suggest adding a EN and provide r01 György (Ericsson) asks a question. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r02 Dan(China Mobile) provides r03 with editorial update György (Ericsson) responds to Dan. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006006 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A, New Solution: Transmission Delay Measurement on N6. | China Mobile, | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005242. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005739 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3A: New Sol: Solution for Synchronizing Hold and Forward Buffers and RAN with Burst Arrival. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3A - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005740 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3A: Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to note this pCR, there are new solutions and quite extensive changes to the existing solutions. see comments. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Sebastian (Qualcomm) agrees with Shabnam and objects to the conclusion Devaki (Nokia) agrees that it is challenging to conclude on 3A, proposes to postpone this paper and conclusion for 3A. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3B - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2004920 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update Exposure of Time Synchronization. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2005741. Noted | Qianghua (Huawei) suggests to consider merging of the following PCRs Shabnam (Ericsson) provides merger into S2-2005741r06. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005157 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, sol#7, Update the solution to resolve the EN. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006039 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes that this contribution is merged to S2-2005741 ideally. However, if it remains separate I propose r01. Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes this paper to be merged into 5741 zhendong (ZTE), is fine to be merged to 5741 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005158 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, sol#9, Update the solution on BMCA. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the PCR zhendong (ZTE), provides the response zhendong (ZTE), response to the comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005222 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Update the KI#3B to include the time requirement. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Chunshan (Tencent ) as the source company proposes this paper to be NOTED. Chunshan (Tencent) proposes to merge the S2-2005223r01 into this paper and r01 is provided. Qianghua (Huawei) points out the link is incorrect Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to the paper Chunshan (Tencent) has proposed this paper to be noted before, so let us stop comments on this paper. | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005223 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to support the time requirement. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006039 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Devaki (Nokia) comments, same view as Jari. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification. Yuan (CATT) provides comments. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects original revision, responds to Chunshan Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects r01 Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to this paper (all revisions) for the same reasons as stated Jari Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and proposes to be merged into S2-2005741. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005224 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update to support the time requirement. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006007. | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r01 Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r02. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r03. Chunshan (Tencent) asks for clarification for the r03. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r04. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r05 Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and object r05. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r06. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Sebastian (Qualcomm) is ok with r05 and objects to other versions Chunshan (Tencent)provides clarification. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006007 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #8: Update to support the time requirement. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005224. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005373 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: Update Solution#7 for PTP supporting. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006008. | Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r01 Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Hui Ni (Huawei) fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006008 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: Update Solution#7 for PTP supporting . | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005373. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005418 | P-CR | Approval | 23.748: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006039 | Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge with S2-2005741 as they are addressing the same call flow and steps. Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge this paper into S2-2005741. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005520 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Sol #7: Update for resolving ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006039 | Jari (NTT DOCOMO) proposes to merge the document with S2-2005741. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accepts Jari (NTT DOCOMO)'s proposal to merge 5520 to 5741, with one clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Jari (NTT DOCOMO). Devaki (Nokia) proposes to merge acceptable parts from this paper to 5741, consider this paper as merged. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accpet proposal to merge this paper with 5741. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005741 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Updates on Solution #7 for Exposure of Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT Docomo, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r06 (with editor's note and updating step 0) agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005157, S2-2005223, S2-2005418 and S2-2005520, in S2-2006039 | Chunshan (Tencent) proposes to merge the S2-2005223r01 into this paper and r01 is provided. Chunshan (Tencent) corrects the typo and proposes to merge S2-2005223 into this paper. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r03. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. Yuan (CATT) agree to merge s2-2005418 into this paper and provides r04. Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies to Chunshan Jari (NTT DOCOMO) comments Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r05, replies to Chunshan Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r06 incorporating 4920 as recommended. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r07. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) prefers r06 Chunshan (Tencent) objects r06 and any updates including the future PDU session without EN. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r07 Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) objects to r07 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) provides r10. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006039 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B: Sol#7: Updates on Solution #7 for Exposure of Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT, Ericsson, ZTE | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r06 (with editor's note and updating step 0) of S2-2005741, merging S2-2005157, S2-2005223, S2-2005418 and S2-2005520. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005742 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#3B, Sol#9: Updates on Solution #9 for Time Synchronization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated, NTT Docomo | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#3B - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005419 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: overall evaluation. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006036 | Xiaowan (vivo) request to merge this paper into S2-2005473 Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge this paper into S2-2005473. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005628 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B, Evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006036 | Qianghua (Huawei) OK merging this one into S2-2005743 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005743 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | CC#4: r10 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005419 and S2-2005628, in S2-2006036 | Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r01. Devaki (Nokia) comments. Qianghua (Huawei) suggests merging S2-2005743, S2-2005419, S2-2005628 Qianghua (Huawei) OK merging with S2-2005743 as the baseline. Comments for R01. Chunshan (Tencent) agrees with the merge proposal and has provided r01. Devaki (Nokia) agrees with the merge proposal, proposes to merge 5419, 5628 with paper. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r02 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r03 Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments Qianghua (Huawei) suggests continuing with r02 Devaki (Nokia) prefers to go with r02. Wonders regarding Vivo's technical concerns with r02? Chunshan (Tencent) asks for clarification. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) provides r04, prefers r02 or r04, responds to Chunshan. Chunshan (Tencent) provides concern on r04. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r06. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r05. Sebastian (Qualcomm) objects to r06; Sebastian (Qualcomm) would be ok if EN was revised to 'Editor's note: It is FFS whether and how to establish the PDU Session to support the TSN time synchronization before the AF requesting time synchronization.'. Alternatively the conclusion can also be postponed given that Solution 7 updates are anyway still up in the air. Devaki (Nokia) provides r07 using Sebastian's suggested updates for EN. Chunshan (Tencent ) replies Sebastian (Qualcomm) replies Chunshan (Tencent) objects the r09 and supports r08 or r06, or postpone this paper . Shabnam (Ericsson) asks if the latest revisions proposed today means the pCR is for CC#4? Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r09 Chunshan (Tencent) provides r08. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Devaki (Nokia) asks if an updated EN is acceptable? Sang-Jun (Samsung) supports Devaki (Nokia)'s way forward proposal. Jari (NTT DOCOMO) can accept the EN as proposed by Devaki. Devaki (Nokia) provides r10. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006036 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #3B: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, NTT DOCOMO, Huawei, HiSilicon, ZTE, Samsung | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r10 of S2-2005743, merging S2-2005419 and S2-2005628. Approved. BMC detail may be further specified at future meetings | Approved | |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005162 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#5, solution#16, Update the key issue and solution on survival time. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.5 | S2-2005220 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5, Sol #16: Update to include Survival Time Granularity and Aggregation. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005420, to S2-2006009. | Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification zhendong (ZTE), question for clarification zhendong (ZTE), provides r03 Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and object the r03. Yuan (CATT) comments on the r03. zhendong (ZTE), provides the clarification Hui Ni (Huawei) support r02. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r04 and provides comments. zhendong (ZTE), is fine with r04 Chunshan (Tencent), is fine with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006009 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5, Sol #16: Update to include Survival Time Granularity and Aggregation. | Tencent, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005220., merging S2-2005420. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005234 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#5, Sol#16: Update with introducing notification control for Survival Time. | China Mobile | Rel-17 | Noted | Devaki (Nokia) raises technical questions regarding survival time guarantee. Hui Ni (Huawei) provides r01. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) shares Nokia concerns and do not agree that such control function is needed. Dan (China Mobile) reply to the previous comment and try to discuss with a way forward Sebastian (Qualcomm) shares the view of Nokia and Ericsson Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to introduction of Notification control in the context of survival time, not sure what the proposed revision is. Dan (China Mobile) OK this paper can be noted ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.5 | S2-2005420 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5, sol #16: updates. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006009 | Chunshan (Tencent) and CATT agree to merge this paper into Tencent paper S2-2005220. Chunshan (Tencent) reminds that this email is sent to the wrong email line. Devaki (Nokia) provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005523 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5, Sol #16: Update for clarification. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.5 | - | - | - | KI#5 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.5 | S2-2005421 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5: evaluation and conclusion. | CATT | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006010 | Sebastian (Qualcomm) proposes to merge the paper into 5744 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.5 | S2-2005744 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5: Evaluation and conclusion. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005421, to S2-2006010. | Chunshan (Tencent) provides comments and r01. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification. Yuan (CATT) agrees to merge S2-2005421 into this paper and provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides the further comments and asks if S2-2005421 can be considered merged into this. Sang-Jun (Samsung) comments. Sebastian (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification Shabnam (Ericsson) agrees with Sebastian/Qualcomm reflected in an EN now and also shortens the content, r03 provided. Devaki (Nokia) answers the questions. Shabnam (Ericsson) Devaki I am fine if we can reach consensus, but we still have to decide which format? That is why I thought RAN2 feedback would be useful as well. Devaki (Nokia) clarifies. Devaki (Nokia) provides r05. Sebastian (Qualcomm) provides r04 Shabnam (Ericsson) Yes Devaki, your proposal is acceptable for us. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides update r06 to the description of the Survival time to better understand. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.5 | S2-2006010 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI #5: Evaluation and conclusion . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005744., merging S2-2005421. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | Study Extended Access Traffic Steering, Switch and Splitting support in the 5G system architecture (FS_eATSSS) | - | - | Docs:=33 | - | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2004793 | LS In | Information | LS from IETF: Re: LS on need for Multi-Path QUIC for ATSSS | IETF (LS_from_IETF) | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005185 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on ATSSS Phase 2 Requirements to IETF QUIC Working Group | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006331 | Tricci (ZTE) provides r01 based on some offline feedback that I have missed. Spencer (Tencent) provides r02 with feedback on question about encryption. Tricci (ZTE) provides r01 based on some offline feedback that I have missed. Rainer (Nokia) comments to r02. Spencer (Tencent) comments to r02. Spencer (Tencent) provides comments on changes made in r01 and carried forward in r02. Tricci (ZTE) provided minor editorial update r03. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Paul (Tencent). Rainer (Nokia) provides r04. Florin (Broadcom) provides editorial updates in r05. Rainer (Nokia) agrees with r05. Spencer (Tencent) replies to Rainer (Nokia). Spencer (Tencent) provides comments on the deletion of a question about various steering modes, made in r01 and carried forward in subsequent revisions, and suggests replacement text. Tricci (ZTE) would like to propose r06 to address Spencer (Tencent) concern. Chunshan (Tencent) requests for clarification. Spencer (Tencent) comments on question about multipath and steering in r06. Spencer (Tencent) corrects a typo in comments on question about multipath and steering in r06. Rainer (Nokia) responds to Spencer (Tencent). Spencer (Tencent) agrees with Rainer (Nokia). Tricci (ZTE) provides r07 to reflect the latest comments from Tencent et al. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r08. Susan (Huawei) provides comments that Q3 should be removed. Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to remove Q3 Rainer (Nokia) agrees wih r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006331 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on ATSSS Phase 2 Requirements to IETF QUIC Working Group | SA WG2 | - | Revision r07 of S2-2005185. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2004938 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #1: QUIC-LL steering functionality. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005762, to S2-2006282 | Susan (Huawei) raised some questions and comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan (Huawei) and provides r01. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis and provides further comments and questions. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan (Huawei) and provides further clarifications. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and asks questions Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Stefan's (Ericsson) questions. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Myungjune (LGE). Stefan (Ericsson) reponds to Apostolis and Myungjune Susan (Huawei) provides further comment. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Stefan. Apostolis (Lenovo) agrees that reliable RTT measurements are more accurate when taken under load conditions. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis. Stefan (Ericsson) follows up on earlier questions/answers from Apostolis Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Stefan (Ericsson). Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r02. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Apostolis Apostolis (Lenovo) provides further clarifications. Chunshan (Tencent) provides comments and some suggestions. Apostolis (Lenovo) agrees that some comments from Chunshan (Tencent) are good and will be incorporated in a r03. Susan (Huawei) continues to raise earlier questions/comments since r02 does not address them, and asks to add ENs if not being able to solve them for this meeting. Apostolis (Lenovo) responds to Susan (Huawei). Apostolis (Lenovo) provides further clarifications and provides r03. Susan (Huawei) raises objection to this paper, including all the revisions and the original version. Apostolis (Lenovo) apologies for missing Susan's last comments and her proposal to add an EN in the document. The proposed EN from Susan is fair and will be considered. We commit that the loss-rate related steering modes (and, actually, all steering modes) proposed in the document will be evaluated at the next meeting. Susan (Huawei) responds and agrees to withdraw her objection and move forward with latest version of the paper, i.e. r03, considering the clarification from Apostolis. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006282 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #1: QUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004938, merging S2-2005762. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005102 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, Solution #2 - Solution update. | Intel | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006283 | Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions Megha (Intel) provides r01 and some comments. Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and questions. Megha (Intel) provides additional comments. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and expresses concerns Stefan (Ericsson) OK with r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006283 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, Solution #2 - Solution update . | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005102. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005471 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, Sol #2&Sol #4: Update on steering modes. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Stefan (Ericsson) asks for clarification Susan (Huawei) responds to Stefan. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | S2-2005103 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, Solution #3 - Solution update. | Intel | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | S2-2005472 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, Sol #3 - Update on loss ratio and jitter measurement. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | S2-2005105 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2: KI#1, New sol: UE assisted traffic steering mode. | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006284 | Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r01 Pavan (Google) comments and provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised | |
| 8.6 | S2-2006284 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: FS_ATSSS_Ph2: KI#1, New sol: UE assisted traffic steering mode. | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005105. Approved | Approved | ||
| 8.6 | S2-2005529 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, New Sol: | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Megha (Intel) provides comments and expresses concern on the justification. Marco (Huawei) reply. Megha(Intel) comments and expresses the same concern on the justification for new steering mode. Marco(Huawei) how can we achieve without new steering method?. Marco (Huawei) provides comments Megha (Intel) is fine with r00 and provides comments ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | S2-2005681 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, New Sol: New steering mode - Duplicating GBR flows. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Myungjune (LGE) comments and proposes to note. Megha (Intel) asks few questions for clarification Rainer (Nokia) providing answers to Intel questions. Susan (Huawei) provides comments to Nokia. Rainer (Nokia) answers LGE. Rainer (Nokia) answering to Huawei. Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns on the justification and use case. Rainer (Nokia) replies to Qualcomm. Stefano (Qualcomm) re-expresses concerns on the justification and use case. Stefano (Qualcomm) having heard no more responses justifying the use case, and given the previous discussions in SA1 about this, we join LG's proposal to note. Myungjune (LGE) objects this pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.6 | S2-2005286 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #1, New Sol: steering mode with location attribute. | Charter Communications | Rel-17 | Noted | Curt (Charter) provides a response. Myungjune (LGE) comments and proposes to note. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Curt (Charter). Susan (Huawei) provides comments and raises questions. Rainer (Nokia) asks a question for clarification. Dieter (Deutsche Telekom) agrees with Myungjune (LGE) that the pCR should be noted as is does not describe a steering mode and is therefore out of scope of this KI. Curt (Charter) provides few responses. Myungjune (LGE) proposes to note again. Curt (Charter) replies Myungjune (LGE). Myungjune (LGE) replies Curt (Charter). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.6 | S2-2005184 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#1: Rapporteur correction for wrong editorial implementation. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=12 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005762 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#1: Update to Remove some ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006282 | Chunshan (Tencent) propose this paper to be merged into S2-2004938. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2005763 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, Sol#6: Update to Remove some ENs. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006285 | Chunshan (Tencent) propose this paper to be merged into S2-2004939. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.6 | S2-2004939 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #6: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005763, to S2-2006285 | Susan (Huawei) raised some questions and comments. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides r01. Susan (Huawei) raises objection to this paper, including r01 and the original version. Apostolis (Lenovo) apologies for missing Susan's last comments and her proposal to add an EN in the document. The proposed EN from Susan is fair and will be considered. We commit that the loss-rate related steering modes (and, actually, all steering modes) proposed in the document will be evaluated at the next meeting. Susan (Huawei) responds and agrees to withdraw her objection and move forward with latest version of the paper, i.e. r01, considering the clarification from Apostolis. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006285 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update of Solution #6: MPQUIC-LL steering functionality . | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Broadcom, Tencent, Deutsche Telekom, Apple, Interdigital, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004939, merging S2-2005763. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005474 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Sol #7: Update MP-QUIC solution to solve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006286 | Florin (Broadcom) asks questions for clarification and requests multiple updates. Florin (Broadcom) asks questions for clarification and requests multiple updates based on feedback received for comments on S2-200573. Susan (Huawei) responds to Florin and provides r01. Florin (Broadcom) responds to Susan indicating that both the original submission as well as r01 do not address his previous comments. He requests for ENs to be provided to address the missing functionalities. Susan (Huawei) provides r02. Apostolis (Lenovo) states that r02 is not available. Susan (Huawei) clarifies the changes in r03 are marked in green. Susan (Huawei) provides r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006286 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Sol #7: Update MP-QUIC solution to solve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005474. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005473 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Sol #8: Update QUIC solution to solve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006287 | Florin (Broadcom) asks questions for clarification and requests multiple updates. Susan (Huawei) responds to Florin. Florin (Broadcom) responds to Susan and continues to request the updates. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions for clarification. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides on additional question. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis. Florin (Broadcom) responds to Susan indicating that both the original submission as well as r01 do not address his previous comments. He requests for ENs to be provided to address the missing functionalities. Susan (Huawei) responds to Florin and raises quite a few questions to Florin, and provides r02. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis and provides r03. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions on r02. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis and provides r04. Apostolis (Lenovo) makes comments on r04. Susan (Huawei) responds to Apostolis and provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006287 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #2, Sol #8: Update QUIC solution to solve ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005473. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2004922 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, New Sol: Proxy based solution using QUIC. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006288 | Rainer (Nokia) asks questions for clarification. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Rainer and provides r01 Rainer (Nokia) is fine with r01. Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Myungjune Apostolis (Lenovo) asks questions for clarification. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Apostolis Apostolis (Lenovo) provides further comments and request for clarifications. Apostolis (Lenovo) provides an additional question. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Apostolis and provides r02 Apostolis (Lenovo) recommends some further changes in r02. Apostolis (Lenovo) asks a few more questions. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Apostolis and provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006288 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, New Sol: Proxy based solution using QUIC. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004922. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2004923 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, New Sol: Proxy based solution using MP-QUIC. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006289 | Stefan (Ericsson) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006289 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#2, New Sol: Proxy based solution using MP-QUIC. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004923. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005768 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#3, Sol#5: Update to remove ENs. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006290 | Laurent (Nokia): provides Comments Laurent (Nokia): provides r01 Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK with r01. Myungjune (LGE) asks a question for clarification Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.6 | S2-2006290 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI#3, Sol#5: Update to remove ENs. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005768. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.6 | S2-2004850 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #3 New Solution: Supporting a PDN connection in EPC as a 3GPP access leg of MA-PDU Session. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | S2-2005298 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: KI #3, New Sol: Extension of 5G RG solution to support Ethernet PDU Session types. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.6 | - | - | - | Evaluation | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.6 | S2-2005186 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | KI#1, 2 & 3: Rapporteur prepared evaluation criteria for each key issue. | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | - | - | - | Study on supporting UAS Connectivity, Identification, and Tracking (FS_ID_UAS_SA2) | - | - | Docs:=57 | - | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005034 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r10 agreed. Revised to S2-2006527 | Chen (OPPO) seeks clarifications. Runze (Huawei) comments on newly added NOTE 5. Dan (China Mobile) has the same comments for NOTE5 Pallab (Nokia) replies to Chen (OPPO). Dimitris (Lenovo) suggests to postpone discussion on support of non-3GPP access Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on Pallab (Nokia)'s response and provides r01. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provided comments and provides r02. Chen (OPPO) responding to Pallab (Nokia) suggested changes. Stefano (Qualcomm) responding to multiple comments and provides rev. 03. Apostolis (Lenovo) requests clarification about 'using only 3GPP access'. Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarification to Florin Stefano (Qualcomm) answer Apostolis question. Florin (Broadcom) also requests clarification about 'using only 3GPP access' and objects to all revisions which consider non-3GPP access out of scope. Florin (Broadcom) answers to Stefano agreeing on his proposal. Pallab (Nokia) provides rev 05. Chen (OPPO) provides rev r06. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Chen and is OK with rev. 06. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r07. Runze (Huawei ) replies to Shabnam. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification, applies to all versions I believe. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Sherry and proposes rev. 08. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Pallab (Nokia) thanks Chen, Stefano and Sherry and OK with r08 Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Sherry. Runze (Huawei) agrees to r09. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r09 and comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) we are ok with r10, we can surely discuss more. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r10. Chris (Vodafone) provides r10. Pallab (Nokia), we are ok with r10. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006527 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to Architectural Assumptions . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm, OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r10 of S2-2005034. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005035 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to Reference Architecture. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006528 | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r01. Pallab (Nokia) agrees to the changes proposed in r01. Runze (Huawei) asks clarification on the term 'NRID'. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments on the content being too solution specific and provides r03. Runze (Huawei) accepts r02. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r04. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006528 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Updates to Reference Architecture . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005035. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005036 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #2, #7, Sol #3: Updates to remove ENs. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005037 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, #3, #5, #6, #7, New Sol: UAV authentication/authorization and C2 communication link establishment. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006533 | Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Qianghua (Huawei) provides r02 Pallab (Nokia) informs Qianghua (Huawei) that file name for r02 is incorrect Qianghua (Huawei) corrects the filename Pallab (Nokia) replies to Qianghua (Huawei) and Dimitris (Lenovo) and provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006533 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, #3, #5, #6, #7, New Sol: UAV authentication/authorization and C2 communication link establishment . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005037. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005038 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #1, #2, #3, #7, Sol #4: Updates to remove ENs. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications Pallab (Nokia) provides clarification and revision r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, with comments below. Shabnam (Ericsson) did not receive any confirmation if r02 will be a new solution or not, we object to the pCR if not documented as a new solution separate from Soln#4. Pallab (Nokia) withdraws Tdoc 5038. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Withdrawn |
| 8.7 | S2-2005118 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7: Update of solution #4. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006529 | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r01 with some clarifications Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification Stefano (Qualcomm) addresses Pallab's questions Shabnam (Ericsson) addresses Nokia questions, OK with QC r01. Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks for clarifications. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response to Interdigital questions and provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006529 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Key Issues #1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7: Update of solution #4 . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005118. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005119 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Way forward for User Plane and Control Plane based solutions. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Pallab (Nokia) objects to any revision of this Tdoc. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2005319 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #2, Sol #12: Update to Mobility Restriction Information for Flight Path Authorization. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006534 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests moving the changes to solution 5 into document 5840, if acceptable. Also proposes some changes in r01. Pallab (Nokia) asks clarification. Sang-Jun (Samsung) appcepts Stefano (Qualcomm)'s suggestion of moving the changes to solution 5 into document 5840 and changes in r01. Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Pallab (Nokia). Pallab (Nokia) seeks further clarification from Sang-Jun (Samsung). Dimitris (Lenovo) comments Stefano (Faccin) comments Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine wih r02 provided by Stefano (Qualcomm). Sang-Jun (Samsung) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006534 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #2, Sol #12: Update to Mobility Restriction Information for Flight Path Authorization . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005319. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005497 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #1,2,3,7, Sol #5: Update for resolving ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006531 | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01 Sang-Jun (Samsung) is fine with r01 Stefano (Qualcomm) provides. Sang-Jun (Samsung) provides r03, and replies to Shabnam (Ericsson). Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, removing colocation aspects as it is irrelevant. Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests to consider 5497 merged into 5840 since similar text is already in 5840, and normative decisions on which NF are joint or separate are premature. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accept Stefano (Qualcomm)'s suggestion to consider 5497 merged into 5840. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005563 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1, #2, #5 New Sol: UAV identification and authentication by RID USS. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006532 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications and proposes merger with 5840 and solution 5. Pallab (Nokia) Clarifies on the queries raised. Chen (OPPO) raise further queries and seeks clarifications Stefano (Qualcomm) Clarifies that UAS A&A, per current agreed architectural assumptions in the TR, is performed in the 3GPP system with the 3GPP system support. Pallab (Nokia) clarifies to Chen (OPPO) Stefano (Qualcomm) provides revision 02. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks questions, applies to all revisions. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Shabnam and Stefano and provides r03 Stefano (Qualcomm) cannot accept rev. 03 due to the editor's notes being removed. Pallab (Nokia) provides r04 and requests if this can be used for approval. Pallab (Nokia) OK to go with r02. Stefano (Qualcomm) given r04 is after revision deadline (by two days), if the change wrt r03 is the re-instertion of the notes, we would recommend going with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006532 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1, #2, #5 New Sol: UAV identification and authentication by RID USS . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005563. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005591 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 2&3, New Sol: UAV Re-authentication and Re-authorization. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | Yunjing (CATT) clarifies and provides r01. Stefano (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications. Pallab (Nokia) provides further comments. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Nokia. Pallab (Nokia) responses/clarification to Yunjing (CATT) Pallab (Nokia) correcting typo in previous email Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns with this soln as described in the current available versions, see comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005592 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 1&4, Sol#9: Update the solution to clarify unknown UAV tracking. | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006530 | Pallab (Nokia) Requests for clarification. Stefano (Qualcomm) address questions. Shabnam (Ericsson) questions the update and UDM role proposed, asks clarification. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses strong concerns and asks Ericsson if theirs is an objection. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides responses and also objects to the original version, willing to consider if a revision is provided. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 based on comment from Ericsson. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 based on the comment from Shabnam (Ericsson). Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r02 to clarify a couple of aspects. Chen (OPPO) seeks further clarifications. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006530 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI # 1&4, Sol#9: Update the solution to clarify unknown UAV tracking. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005592. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005593 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #4, Sol#14: Update the solution to remove ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses strong concerns and objects, since this is bringing Air Traffic Management functionality into the 3GPP system and goes against the working assumptions. Yunjing (CATT) responses to Stefano. Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 based on comment from Stefano. Stefano (Qualcomm) responds to Yunjing and cannot accept R01 (and we objected to R00) since it is now a completely different solution with most aspects belonging to application layer and does not match the aviation industry flight plan data. Rev. 01 does not address the issues we objected to in the original paper and introduces even more issues. Yunjing (CATT) is fine to note the pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2005594 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #4, Sol #15: Update the solution to remove ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006536 | Yunjing (CATT) provides r01 to merge part of S2-2005661 and remove the description of relative distance calculation. Stefano (Faccin) is utterly confused: 5661 is now merged into 5693, so what is 5594 R01 and how does it merge in 5661? Can the authors of 5693 let us know what was merged into 5693 of 5594? Can the author of 5594 tell us what is left and what to do with it? Qianghua (Huawei) thinks 5594r01 now address the ENs in solution 15, which mainly solves the overlapping with 5661 on address these ENs of sol#15. I guess 5594 is kept separate, is not going to merge into 5561 or 5693. Yunjing (CATT) clarifies. Chen (OPPO) answers to Stefano's (Qualcomm) request for clarifications on what is merged to 5693. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006536 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #4, Sol #15: Update the solution to remove ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005594. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005654 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI# 6, Sol #20: Update to remove ENs. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005660 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #4, Sol #1: Update for resolving ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Approved | Pallab (Nokia) requests for technical clarification Steve (Huawei) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005661 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #4, Sol #15: Update to clarify distance calculation between UAV and UAVC. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006539 | Yunjing (CATT) proposes to merge part of the solution into S2-2005594 and expresses concerns. Qianghua (Huawei) replies. Yunjing (CATT) replies. Qianghua (Huawei) merges this into S2-2005693 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005662 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #6: evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes to note this paper, the conclusions are too ambitious for this meeting. Qianghua (Huawei) OK to postpone Shabnam (Ericsson) supports Qualcomm view of noting the document and postponing them from this meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005663 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #7: evaluation and conclusion. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006542 | Chen (OPPO) cannot agree with conclusion for Sol#13, 20 and 21. Details for Sol#13 exist in S2-2005692. Qianghua (Huawei) provides r01 and responds Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to postpone KI#7 conclusion and Note this. Qianghua (Huawei) asks for clarification Qianghua (Huawei) comments back to Ericcson and this should merge into S2-2005853 Shabnam (Ericsson) proposes to NOTE the paper and postpone evaluation/conclusion until next meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005664 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | PDU Sessions and QoS flows. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Noted. Included in S2-2006531 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggest noting it and marking it as merged into 5840 Steve (Huawei) is ok to note. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005665 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5, Sol#5: Merging existing Sol#6, Sol#7 and Sol#8 into Sol#5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006531 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggest noting it and marking it as merged into 5840 Runze (Huawei) agrees to merge texts of S2-2005665 into S2-2005840, not noting it. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005666 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Update Sol#17: network-assisted UAV verification and monitoring. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006538 | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides comments for clarification Runze (Huawei) replies to Qualcomm and Ericsson, and provides r01. Stefano (Qualcomm) having seen neither replies nor clarifications to the questions, and other companies concerns, we propose noting this paper since we cannot accept it Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns with restricted zone, asks same clarification as Qualcomm and provides comments. Stefano (Faccin) cannot accept r01, provides r02. Runze (Huawei) replies to Stefeno, and agrees to r02.. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006538 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Update Sol#17: network-assisted UAV verification and monitoring. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005666. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005667 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5: Update Sol#18: handling of PDU session establishment by UAV. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006537 | Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Runze (Huawei) agrees to r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006537 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5: Update Sol#18: handling of PDU session establishment by UAV. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005667. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005668 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Clarification on UAS concept. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r01. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) cannot accept R01. Sherry (Xiaomi) restates that the added texts overlaps with the existing texts, thus this pCR can be noted. Runze (Huawei) is OK with r02. Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK with r02 and objects to original version. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02. Guanzhou (InterDigital) asks Stefano(Qualcomm) to clarify his comments. Runze (Huawei) replies to Sherry. Sherry (Xiaomi) confirms to postpone this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005669 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2: Evaluation on key issue 2. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Pallab (Nokia) objects to the conclusion and any further revision of this paper Runze (Huawei) agrees to postpone the paper. Shabnam (Ericsson) postponing all evaluation and conclusion is appropriate way forward at this meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005670 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5: Evaluation on key issue 5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed | Pallab (Nokia) objects to the conclusion and any further revision of this paper Runze (Huawei) agrees to postpone the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005690 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol#10: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006535 | Stefano (Qualcomm) kindly requests clarifications and modifications. Chen (OPPO) provides r01 and respond to Stefano's (Qualcomm) queries. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies and requests further clarifications, we cannot accept rev. 01. Chen (OPPO) provides r02 and respond to Stefano's (Qualcomm) queries. Stefano (Qualcomm) re-re-expresses concerns and conditionally objects to the original and the revision since the technical concerns have not been addressed. Shabnam (Ericsson) shares Qualcomm concerns and additional technical questions. Chen (OPPO) provides r03 and respond to Stefano's (Qualcomm) and Shabnam's (Ericsson) queries. Stefano (Faccin) provides r04. Chen (OPPO) provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006535 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol#10: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005690. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005691 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#2, Sol#11: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005692 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Sol#13: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005693 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Merge of Solution 1, 13, 14, 15,16. | OPPO, Interdigital, Huawei | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005661, to S2-2006539 | Qianghua (Huawei) provides an update to merge S2-2005661 into S2-2005693. Pallab (Nokia) provides rev 02 with some updates and editor's notes. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev 03 with some clarifications. Chen (OPPO) provided r04 and response to Pallabl(Nokia) and Stefano(Qualcomm). Qianghua (Huawei) provides r05 Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification Qianghua (Huawei) responds to Pallab Pallab (Nokia) provides clarification to Qianghua (Huawei) Guanzhou (InterDigital) has concerns on r04 and r05 and provides r06. Chen (OPPO) provides r07 to cover to Guanzhou's (Interdigital) concerns. Pallab (Nokia) responds to Chen (OPPO) Stefano (Qualcomm) kindly requests a meaningful title for the solution Guanzhou (InterDigital) provides r08. Chen (OPPO) provides r09 with title for solution. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Chen. Chen (OPPO) acknowledges Stefano's (Qualcomm) acceptance of title change of the solution. Shabnam (Ericsson) so do we consider then the Soln#1, 13, 14, 15, 16 are no longer to be considered and we use this merged soln for next meeting? I am also a bit confused with now 'partial' merger. Chen (OPPO) answers Shabnam indicating that in SA2#140e, revisions to some of these solutions have in part changed those solutions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006539 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#4, Merge of Solution 1, 13, 14, 15,16. | OPPO, Interdigital, Huawei, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r09 of S2-2005693, merging S2-2005661. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005694 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#5, Sol#5: Update for EN on 3GPP registration when UUAA fails. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006531 | Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests marking this as merged into 5840, since we believe 5840 already addresses these points, even if with slightly different language. Chen (OPPO) responding to Stefano's (Qualcomm's) suggestion of merging 5694 into revision of 5840 Stefano (Qualcomm) asks Oppo if we can consider this merged in 5840. Chen (OPPO) agrees that S2-2005694 to be merged into revision of S2-2005840. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005699 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions for KI#1, KI#2 and KI#3. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006542 | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes rev. 01 Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 Guanzhou (InterDigital) proposes to merge this into S2-2005853. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.7 | S2-2005700 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions for KI#4. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefano (Qualcomm) proposes rev. 01 with minor changes. Guanzhou (InterDigital) points out the email thread title is not correct Pallab (Nokia) provides rev. 02. Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Pallab(Nokia) and provides r03. Chen (OPPO) propose to postpone this evaluation paper and any of its revisions, as many sols for this KI#4 and even new sols are in flux. Stefano (Qualcomm) also suggests to postpone the evaluation of KO#4 and note this paper Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r04 and also fine to postpone this conclusion paper. Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK to postpone this. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports postponement of this conclusion paper (all its revisions). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005701 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Conclusions for KI#6 and KI#7. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stefano (Qualcomm) expresses concerns about some of the conclusions Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) ask for clarification on some of the conclusions Guanzhou (InterDigital) responds to Stefano (Qualcomm) and Amanda (FutureWei) comments. Stefano (Qualcomm) suggests to note this conclusion paper, too many questions still open. Sherry (Xiaomi) suggests to note this conclusion paper. Guanzhou (InterDigital) is OK to postpone this. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports postponement of this conclusion paper (all its revisions). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.7 | S2-2005774 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI# 6 & #7, Sol #21: Update to address ENs. | InterDigital | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.7 | S2-2005817 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Solution on handling of C2 connectivity due to authorization revocation. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev. 01. Chen (OPPO) provides rev r02 and supports this solution with changes. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides rev r03. Stefano (Qualcomm) cannot accept the original and rev. 01 and rev. 02 because of the concerns written in previous emails. Qualcomm cannot accept rev. 03 because in step 3 the behavior is not defined. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Stefano and provides r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to the current version of the pCR as it is unclear how the soln works, see comments. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Shabnam. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies Sherry explaining how the authors' reply just killed the solution. We support Ericsson objection. Sherry (Xiaomi) further replies to Shabnam. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Stefano. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2005819 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Solution on UAV controller and UAV association management. | Xiaomi | Rel-17 | Noted | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications and conditionally objects. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides clarifications and revision 1. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies and repeats the concerns not addressed. Guanzhou (InterDigital) shares the concern of Stefano (Qualcomm). Stefano (Qualcomm) clarifies that Qualcomm cannot accept the original proposal and revision 01 since the concerns have not been addressed. Sherry replies to Stefano. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.7 | S2-2005840 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, Sol. 5: Update to eliminate editor's notes, clarify additional aspects, and merge in other solutions. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Interdigital | Rel-17 | r11 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005497, S2-2005694 and S2-2005665, to S2-2006531 | Chen (OPPO) provides r01 and raise some questions. Runze (Huawei) provides r02, by merging texts from S2-2005665. Chen (OPPO) provides r03, reinstating the inputs of r01 that Runze (Huawei) dropped in 02. Stefano (Faccin) provides r04, addressing Chen's question. Chen (OPPO) indicate acceptance that r04 to cover his questions and text in S2-2005694. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r05 merging the first part of 5319. Sang-Jun (Samsung) accpets r05 provided by Stefano (Qualcomm). Shabnam (Ericsson) questions some of the proposal and asks either removal or resolution of other form. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Shabnam and provides rev. 6. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r07 addressing changes made by Runze (Huawei) that includes text from S2-2005665 Given the merge of 5694 into revisions of 5840, Chen (OPPO) request Stefano (Qualcomm) to add OPPO as co-source. Stefano (OPPO) provides rev. 08 adding OPPO as co-source. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r09, not for approval but rather asking questions and pointing to some ambiguities within the document, expect a r10 from the authors to address them or add ENs. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r10 to address Ericsson's questions. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r11. Stefano (Qualcomm) provides r11 due to text that was mistakenly lost when rev. 09 was created. Shabnam (Ericsson) OK with r11. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006531 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI#1, KI#2, KI#3, KI#7, Sol. 5: Update to eliminate editor's notes, clarify additional aspects, and merge in other solutions . | Qualcomm Incorporated, Futurewei, Lenovo, Motorola Mobility, Interdigital, Huawei, Oppo | Rel-17 | Revision r11 of S2-2005840, merging S2-2005497, S2-2005694 and S2-2005665. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005844 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: UAV establishing user plane connectivity for remote identification & tracking for UAV operations. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006540 | Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 Pallab (Nokia) requests for technical clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Pallab (Nokia) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006540 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: UAV establishing user plane connectivity for remote identification & tracking for UAV operations. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005844. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005853 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: FS_ID_UAS: Way forward for Various Open Issues. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r12 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005699 and S2-2005663, to S2-2006542 | Pallab (Nokia) requests for clarification/update of some conclusions in clause 8 Stefano (Qualcomm) addresses questions and provides rev. 01 Pallab (Nokia) accepts the changes in rev 01 Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) provide comments and rev r02 Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Amanda and provides rev. 03, since in the meanwhile there have been discussions to merge with other papers. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and provides r03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) points out Shabnam(Ericsson) indicated wrong revision number r03 which should be r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) comments and provides r04 (main message same but resending revision from r03 to r04). Amanda Xiang ( Futurewei ) reply to Qualcomm and provide Rev r05 Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Amanda, Guanzhou, and Shabnam, and provides revision 7. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei) replies to the question from InterDigital Guanzhou (InterDigital) further questions changes in r05 and r06. Amanda Xiang (Futurewei ) reply the comments from InterDigital and provide r06 Guanzhou (InterDigital) questions and comments on changes in r05. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Stefano, provide r08 to clarify a few things. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks Shabnam, r09 is provided. Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks Stefano for taking into account most of the comments, the one you left out is based on information contained in Soln #5, unless we misunderstood? Dimitris (Lenovo) provides rev10 Stefano (Qualcomm) provides rev11 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r12. Stefano (Qualcomm) thanks, rev12 is fine. Guanzhou (InterDigital) OK with r12. Pallab (Nokia) OK with r12. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006542 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: FS_ID_UAS: Way forward for Various Open Issues . | Qualcomm Incorporated, Interdigital | Rel-17 | Revision r12 of S2-2005853, merging S2-2005699 and S2-2005663. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.7 | S2-2005864 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #6, New Sol: Replacement of the UAV Controller of a UAS. | Orange | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006541 | Stefano (Qualcomm) asks clarifications Antoine (Orange) provides r01, which becomes an update to Sol#5. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to rev. 01, disagree on having it as an update of solution 5 that addresses other aspects. Antoine (Orange) replies to Stefano. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Antoine and requests technical clarifications. Antoine (Orange) answers to Stefano and provides technical clarifications. Stefano (Qualcomm) replies to Antoine. Antoine (Orange) provides r02. Sherry (Xiaomi) comments and provides r03. Guanzhou (InterDigital) would like to co-sign. Antoine (Orange) thanks Stefano. Stefano (Faccin) provides r04 and cosigns. Sherry (Xiaomi) provides r05. Pallab (Nokia) requests for technical clarification. Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on Pallab(Nokia) question. Pallab(Nokia) seeks further clarification from Guanzhou (InterDigital). Guanzhou (InterDigital) replies Pallab(Nokia)'s question. Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Pallab(Nokia). Guanzhou (InterDigital) comments on Pallab(Nokia)'s concern. Pallab(Nokia) replies to Sherry (Xiaomi) and Guanzhou (InterDigital). Raises concern on introducing 'new interface' and seeks further clarification Guanzhou(InterDigital) further replies Sherry's question. Sherry (Xiaomi) requests clarification from Guanzhou. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Sherry (Xiaomi) replies to Guanzhou. Pallab (Nokia) thanks Sherry and Guanzhou. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.7 | S2-2006541 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: KI #6, New Sol: Replacement of the UAV Controller of a UAS. | Orange, Qualcomm, InterDigital | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005864. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Study on system enhancement for Proximity based Services in 5GS (FS_5G_ProSe) | - | - | Docs:=137 | - | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | General | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005310 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Update UE definition related to Relay. | Intel | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005239, to S2-2006583 | Hong (Qualcomm) comments and agree with Adrian. Adrian (vivo) proposed to NOTE this paper. Changhong (Intel) replies to Hong and Adrian and provides r01. LaeYoung provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r04. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006583 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Update UE definition related to Relay. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005310, merging S2-2005239. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005647 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Issues and way forward on AQP compatibility on PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006543 | Hong (Qualcomm) ask for clarifications on why AQP does not work for L3 relays. Steve (Huawei) comments. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006543 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Issues and way forward on AQP compatibility on PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005647. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=24 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005166 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, New Sol: ProSe group discovery. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised to S2-2006544 | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks questions for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to NOTE the solution. Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies for CATT. Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and asks two clarifying questions. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to HHI Wen (vivo) asks questions for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to vivo. Hao Dong (ZTE) raises questions. Adrian (vivo) asks if Samsung is producing a new revision. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to vivo and ZTE. A revision comes soon. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02 Adrian (vivo) provides a draft based on r01 in drafts folder as it contains lots of questions. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to vivo and provides r03. Adrian (vivo) replies to Samsung and provides r03-vivo in the drafts. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to vivo and LG Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04 Hao Dong (ZTE) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies LG and ZTE Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r05 Deng Qiang (CATT) comments to r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies CATT and provides r06. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q to r06. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LG Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r07. Runze (Huawei) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r07. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r08 and also answers Huawei. Runze (Huawei) can accept r08. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r08. Adrian (vivo) is fine with r08. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006544 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, New Sol: ProSe group discovery. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r08 of S2-2005166. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005165 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, Sol #3: Update to ProSe 5G Direct Discovery using PC5. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006545 | Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 Deng Qiang (CATT) comments to r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer. Mehrdad (Samsung) thanks LG and agrees with LG. Hong (Qualcomm) is OK with r01.. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006545 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, Sol #3: Update to ProSe 5G Direct Discovery using PC5 . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005165. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005143 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1,2: Update of Solution #37 for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005172, to S2-2006546 | Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and asks a clarifying question. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) and provides r02 (r01 is discarded due to upload failure). Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge S2-2005172r01 into S2-2005143r02 Judy (Ericsson) agrees with the proposal from Mehrdad (Samsung) to merge S2-2005172r01 into S2-2005143r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) merged S2-2005172r01 into S2-2005143r02 and provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006546 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1,2: Update of Solution #37 for groupcast mode communication for commercial services and public safety. | Ericsson, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005143, merging S2-2005172. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005172 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1,#2, Sol #37: Update to Groupcast mode communication. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006546 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to NOTED this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies that understanding of CATT and OPPO is not correct. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) merged S2-2005172r01 into S2-2005143. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005279 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1&2, Sol#4: Update to simplify the solution. | LG Electronics, ZTE | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006547 | Wen (vivo) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 with answers. Adrian (vivo) asks some questions. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hao Dong (ZTE) comments on r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Q from Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some further clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LG ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006547 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1&2, Sol#4: Update to simplify the solution. | LG Electronics, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005279. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005290 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, Sol#1: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005813, to S2-2006548 | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) proposes r01 with cosigning LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q. Jianhua (OPPO) answers LaeYoung. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006548 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1, Sol#1: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO, Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005290, merging S2-2005813. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005806 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Sol 1, 2, 3, 18, 22: Layer 2 addressing clarifications + other issues. | vivo Communication Technology | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006549 | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Adrian (vivo) provides r01 inline with LaeYoungs request. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006549 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Sol 1, 2, 3, 18, 22: Layer 2 addressing clarifications + other issues. | vivo Communication Technology | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005806. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005813 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to remove ENs on metadata. | Interdigital | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006548 | Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to Note or merge into S2-2005290 Hong (Qualcomm) propose to mark 5813 as merge into S2-2005290 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees to merge 5813 into S2-2005290. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2004984 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1:Overall evaluation and interim conclusion for KI #1. | OPPO, CATT | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006550 | Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides comments and r01. Walter (Philips) requests some clarifications. Jianhua(OPPO) response and provides r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03 and requests to merge DDNMF part into S2-2005650. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment on r03. Runze (Huawei) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05 Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r04. Jianhua(OPPO) provides r06. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides r07. Hong (Qualcomm) can ONLY accept r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006550 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1:Overall evaluation and interim conclusion for KI #1. | OPPO, CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2004984. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005167 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion- Group discovery. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006551 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes it is merged into S2-2005281. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005281. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks the paper can be merged into S2-2005281 because the changes by Mehrdad (Samsung) to 5281 (i.e. r02) are agreeable. Mehrdad (Samsung) confirms S2-2005167 is merged into S2-2005281 based on r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005281 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1 Conclusion on group discovery/management to support group communication for commercial services. | LG Electronics, ZTE | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005167, to S2-2006551 | Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks on possibility of merging with S2-2005167 Adrian(vivo) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers. Adrian (vivo) is happy with LaeYoungs proposal to resolve issues with S2-2005279 first. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments to r01. Jianhua(OPPO) asks question for r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) further comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006551 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1 Conclusion on group discovery/management to support group communication for commercial services. | LG Electronics, ZTE, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005281, merging S2-2005167. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005650 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Evaluation on key issue 1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006552 | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 and propose to capture all DDNMF related evaluation in this paper. Runze replies. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r02. Runze (Huawei) comments and provides r04. Runze (Huawei) comments on r03. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r05. Runze (Huawei) thanks Hong (Qualcomm) and agrees to r05. Runze(Huawei) replies to Jianhua. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r06 and responds to Runze Jianhua(OPPO) replies to Runze. Runze (Huawei) replies to Jianhua. Judy (Ericsson) comments and ask Q. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Judy. Runze (Huawei) replies to Judy. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006552 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#1: Evaluation on key issue 1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005650. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005833 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#1. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Noted | Jianhua(OPPO) proposes to merge into S2-2004984. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to merge into S2-2004984. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) comments. Changhong (Intel) proposes to merge it into S2-2004984. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02 and requests to merge DDNMF part into S2-2005650. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q Runze (Huawei) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) propose not to pursue this contribution. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine to NOTE the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005839 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Key Issue#1: Interim conclusions on message contents. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006553 | Jianhua(OPPO) provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. Adrian (vivo) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees to leave Metadata issue open. Hong (Qualcomm) response to Xiaoyan (Interdigital) and Jianhua (OPPO). Walter (Philips) provides r05. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r06 and responds to Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Mehrdad. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r07 and remove overlapped part with other contribution. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r07. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) support r06 and object r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006553 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Key Issue#1: Interim conclusions on message contents. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005839. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005651 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2 Sol#21: Update to QoS Support for NR PC5 ProSe communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006554 | Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Jianhua (OPPO). Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01. Jianhua (OPPO) supports the paper and provides r01 Steve (Huawei) comments Steve (Huawei) provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Jianhua(OPPO) replies. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006554 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2 Sol#21: Update to QoS Support for NR PC5 ProSe communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005651. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005144 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2: Evaluation of groupcast aspects of solutions for commercial services and public safety. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) is also wondering which part of Sol#37 needs to be considered for normative work. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as it is not clear what needs to be standardized. Judy (Ericsson) agrees to note the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005198 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2, Conclusion: Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | CATT, OPPO, Huawei, HiSilicon, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005236, to S2-2006555 | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01 that merged S2-2005236. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006555 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2, Conclusion: Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | CATT, OPPO, Huawei, HiSilicon, Qualcomm Incorporated, vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005198, merging S2-2005236. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005236 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#2: Solutions evaluation and conclusion. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006555 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes S2-2005236 to be merged into S2-2005198. Wen (vivo) responses. Deng Qiang (CATT) confirms S2-2005236 is merged into S2-2005198. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=54 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004940 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: Network Controlled Remote UE authorization for UE-to-Network Relay. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006556 | Wen (vivo) provide comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comment. Adrian (vivo) provides comment. Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r01 with answers for questions. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r02 with answers. Weijun (Huawei) comments. Jicheol provides r03 with answer to Weijun (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Weijun (Huawei) asks for further clarification. Jicheol (Samsung) replies provides r04 with answers to Weijun(Huawei) and LaeYoung (LG) LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r04. Jicheol (Samsung) thanks LaeYoung(LGE). Jicheol (Samsung) comments to LaeYoung's comment. LaeYoung (LGE) can live with r04 and the aspect 'how the PCF (PCF for Relay or PCF for Remote UE) generates and provides PCC rules e.g. related to newly added QoS Flows later' needs to be investigated in the next meeting. Hong (Qualcomm) can live with r04, provided that the Remote UE ID verification aspect is also added to the virtual EN, as secondary authentication is not always available and not owned by SMF. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006556 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: Network Controlled Remote UE authorization for UE-to-Network Relay. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2004940. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004982 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: New solution for Layer-2 based UE-to-Network Relay discovery and selection based on PLMN selection. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006557 | Wen (vivo) provides comments. Adrian (vivo) provides additional comments. Jianhua(OPPO) responds to Wen and Adrian Jianhua(OPPO) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) comments. Adrian (vivo) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) responds Adrian and Steve and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) comments further Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Steve. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006557 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: New solution for Layer-2 based UE-to-Network Relay discovery and selection based on PLMN selection. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004982. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004983 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: New solution for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay PDU Session establishment. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006558 | Hao Dong (ZTE) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Xiaoyan and Hao Dong. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments on the Jianhua's reply. Steve (Huawei) comments. Steve (Huawei) comments, on the correct document this time... :) Steve (Huawei) withdrawns previous comment , wrong document. Jianhua (OPPO) responds Steve Jianhua(OPPO) responds to Xiaoyan's further comments. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Jianhua. Steve (Huawei) clarifies comment Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Steve. Jianhua (OPPO) responds Xiaoyan and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments. Jianhua(OPPO) responds and provides r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments and provides r03. Walter (Philips) provides comment. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r04 and responds.. Walter (Philips) provides r05. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Walter. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006558 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: New solution for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay PDU Session establishment. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2004983. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005199 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: PC5 connection establishment for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay without Relay discovery. | CATT | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006559 | Wen (vivo) provides comments and provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Wen (vivo) responds. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r03. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04. Hong (Qualcomm) asks for clarifications of r04. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r04 and replies to Hong. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006559 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: PC5 connection establishment for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay without Relay discovery. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005199. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005200 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: Service continuity for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay. | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006560 | Dimitris (Lenovo) asks for clarification LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees LaeYoung's comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and objects r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment and is fine with r01. Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification on the proposal Deng Qiang (CATT) responds. Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) clarifies. Roya (Fraunhofer HHI) comments. Lars (Sony) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006560 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#6: Service continuity for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005200. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005237 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New sol: QoS handling for layer-2 relay. | vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006561 | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and proposes to Note the paper Wen (vivo) provides response to Jianhua. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q for clarification. Wen (vivo) answer the question from LaeYoung (LGE). Jianhua(OPPO) responds to Wen. Deng Qiang (CATT) ask question for clarification. Wen (vivo) answers question from Deng Qiang . Wen responds to Jianhua. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Wen (vivo) responses to Deng Qiang. Steve (Huawei) comments. Wen (vivo) responses to Steve. Steve (Huawei) objects to r00. r01 is better than r02, but not ideal. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006561 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New sol: QoS handling for layer-2 relay. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005237. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005451 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: A merged solution for solution 24 and 25. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) asks clarification from Jianhua (OPPO). Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to keep solution 24 and 25 separate as before. Jianhua (OPPO) responds Hong and Mehrdad, and provides r01. Walter (Philips) asks for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) replies to Walter. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) propose to NOTE this solution as it will not work and objects to original version and all revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Jianhua (OPPO) replies that Mehrdad commented on the evaluation aspect, not solution feasibility aspect. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005495 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS solution for 5G ProSe L3 UE-to-Network relaying. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006562 | Dimitris (Lenovo) comments on the solution Hannu (Nokia) answers to Dimitris (Lenovo) Dimitris(Lenovo) provides r01 Myungjune (LGE) provides r02. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Dimitris (Lenovo) and Myungjune (LGE) and supports r02. Hannu (Nokia) proposes r03. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006562 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Sol: QoS solution for 5G ProSe L3 UE-to-Network relaying. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005495. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005496 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, New Solution: Solution for UE-to-Network Relay authorization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006563 | Myungjune (LGE) provide comments. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Myungjune (LGE). Myungjune (LGE) requests to add AUSF impact. Hannu (Nokia) agrees with comment from Myungjune (LGE) and provides r01. Steve (Huawei) asks a question for clarification Hannu (Nokia) answers to Steve. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r01. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006563 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, New Solution: Solution for UE-to-Network Relay authorization. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005496. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005555 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: New solution to authorize a UE to access 5GC via a 5G UE-to-Network Relay. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006564 | Myungjune (LGE) ask a question for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments Jicheol (Samsung) asks questions. Judy (Ericsson) responds. Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) provides r02 with cosigning. Judy (Ericsson) thanks Myungjune (LGE) and Xiaoyan Shi (interdigital) for the support and is fine with r02. Jicheol (Samsung) provides r03 and co-signed this version if acceptable with minor comments. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006564 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: New solution to authorize a UE to access 5GC via a 5G UE-to-Network Relay. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated, LG Electronics, Interdigital Inc, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005555. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005752 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Solution: Fetching slice information based on Relay Service Code. | Philips. | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask for clarification. Walter (Philips) provides r01 to address the received comments and questions. Deng Qiang (CATT) further comments. Walter (Philips) provides r02 to address comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Walter (Philips) responds to Deng Qiangs objection. Hong (Qualcomm) asks for clarification. Walter (Philips) responds to Hong's question. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005756 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, New Solution: Network assisted relay selection. | Philips International B.V. | Rel-17 | Noted | Wen (vivo) asks for clarification. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Xiaoyan (Interdigital) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments.. Walter (Philips) provides revision r01 to address the received comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) further comments. Walter (Philips) provides r02 to address comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Walter (Philips) responds to Deng Qiangs objection. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2004986 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#19: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2005638. Noted | Wen (vivo) provide comments. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to merge with S2-2005638 Steve (Huawei) thinks its sensible to consider it merged into 5638. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005139 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3: Solution#23, update to clarify procedure for IP address preservation. | Ericsson, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Approved | Hui Ni (Huawei) proposes to note this tdoc. Hui Ni (Huawei) withdraw the previous comments to S2-2005139. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005171 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #24: Update to End-to-End QoS support for L3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Samsung | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revised (+ 2 editor's notes) in S2-2006048 | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and questions. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to OPPO. Jianhua(OPPO) replies to Mehrdad. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies further to OPPO. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Jianhua (OPPO) provides further comments. Steve (Huawei) question for clarification Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Huawei and OPPO and provides r02. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to POSTPONE the paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) kindly asks Tao to consider original version as approved as no objection raised on that version and Qualcomm is OK with that version Hong (Qualcomm) is OK with original version. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks Qualcomm (Hong) to clarify whether original version is OK as no objection raised on that. Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Mehrdad. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to Qualcomm we agree on a revision or asks Tao/ Chairman to keep this open for CC#4 Mehrdad (Samsung) clarifies they did not receive any request for revision from Qualcomm during revision period. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Jianhua (OPPO) provides further information for approving a revision. Jianhua (OPPO) comments Mehrdad (Samsung) asks Oppo to reconsider original version or r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) agreed with Oppo on original version with two ENs. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006048 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #24: Update to End-to-End QoS support for L3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Samsung | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision (original + 2 editor's notes) of S2-2005171. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005210 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #1,3, Sol #19: Update to Include DNN information in Relay Selection. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005238 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#25: Updates with an alternative procedure about QoS handling for Layer-3 relay. | vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005252 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#7: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006568 | Wen (vivo) provides comments for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) provides the response Steve (Huawei) comments. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Jianhua (OPPO) requests to merge into S2-2005644. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005449 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #24: Update to clarify how to use the configured mapping. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005450 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol #25: Update to add more details. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Wen (vivo) provides a question for clarification. Hong (Qualcomm) comments.. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on original version. Jianhua responds and provides r01. Walter (Philips) asks for clarification. Jianhua (OPPO) replies to Walter. Walter (Philips) responds to Jianhua (OPPO). Walter (Philips) is ok with r02 Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02 to clarify Walter's question Mehrdad (Samsung) propose to NOTE this solution as it will not work and objects to original version and all revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Jianhua (OPPO) replies that Mehrdad commented on the evaluation aspect, not solution feasibility aspect. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005636 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#6: Additional considerations on L3 U2N Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006565 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Steve (Huawei) does not agree to note. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper. Steve (Huawei) disagress with noting. Hannu (Nokia) supports noting the document and replies to Steve (Huawei). Judy (Ericsson) comments. Judy (Ericsson) provides additional comments and also proposes to note the paper. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006565 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#6: Additional considerations on L3 U2N Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005636. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005638 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#19: Update for L2 Relay discovery and selection. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005639 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#23: Additional considerations on L3 U2N Relay with N3IWF. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006566 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Steve (Huawei) confused by request to note, does not agree. Provides r01 to clarify. Deng Qiang (CATT) further comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006566 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#23: Additional considerations on L3 U2N Relay with N3IWF. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005639. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005640 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#24, 25: Additional considerations for QoS handling in Layer 3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006567 | Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01 and comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006567 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#24, 25: Additional considerations for QoS handling in Layer 3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005640. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005644 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#7: Update to address ENs on U2N Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005810 and S2-2005252, to S2-2006568 | Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) provides r01 merged with S2-2005810. Steve (Huawei) The merge of 5810 is good, thank you. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to LaeYoung. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02, and try to merge S2-2005252 into S2-2005644 LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r04 to reflect LaeYoung's comment and ask question for clarification to Jianhua. Wen(vivo) comments. Jianhua(OPPO) responds to Xiaoyan Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r05 that merges part of S2-2005838. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r06. Steve (Huawei) provides r07 and comments to questions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006568 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, Sol#7: Update to address ENs on U2N Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek, Interdigital Inc., OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005644, merging S2-2005810 and S2-2005252. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005809 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to clarify Mobility Restrictions. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006569 | Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Jianhua's comments Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes to note the original version of this pCR. A new solution should be drafted instead (r01?) Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Guillaume. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Guillaume and provides r01 to reflect Guillaume's concern . Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Xiaoyan (Interdigital) and recommends this be handled as a separate solution. I.e. 5809 should be noted. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r02 Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) thanks Guillaume and is fine with r03. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006569 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to clarify Mobility Restrictions . | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005809. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005810 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to remove ENs on Connection Management state. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006568 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005644 (Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek). Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine to merge 5810 to 5644 Steve (Huawei) merging is good. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005811 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to clarify Congestion Control. | Interdigital | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006570 | Wen (vivo) provides comments. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and r01 Hong (Qualcomm) provides r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r02 LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r04 Steve (Huawei) provides r05 Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) thanks Steve and is fine with r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006570 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #7: Update to clarify Congestion Control. | Interdigital | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005811. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005812 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #16: Update to remove ENs. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005637, to S2-2006571 | Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Jianhua and provides r01 in which S2-2005637 is merged. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006571 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #16: Update to remove ENs . | Interdigital Inc., Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005812, merging S2-2005637. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005814 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #6: Update to remove ENs on MBS traffic relay. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Deng Qiang. Jianhua (OPPO) comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments and proposes to NOTED. Xiaoyan (Interdigital) replies to Deng Qiang. Xiaoyan (Interdigital) replies to Deng Qiang and provides r01 Hong (Qualcomm) comments on r01, and propose to NOTE. Jianhua comments and proposes again to Note. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies and provides r02. Judy (Ericsson) comments and supports the proposal to postpone the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2005815 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #28: Update to remove ENs. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006572 | Jianhua(OPPO) provides comments Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaoyan Shi(Interdigital) replies to Hong, Jianhua and provides r01 Steve (Huawei) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Steve. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Jianhua and provides r03. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r04. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) can live with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006572 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, Sol #28: Update to remove ENs . | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005815. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005816 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #3, New Sol: Support for UE-to-Network Relay mobility state. | Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Dengqiang' comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Xiaiyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong (Qualcomm). Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong, Deng Qiang. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper as 'mobile' or 'stationary' cannot be defined. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005830 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Relay discovery additional information support. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Approved | Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions for clarification ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005831 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: N3IWF selection for Layer-3 UE-to-Network Relay. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Postponed | Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) answers the questions and provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) ask questions for clarification. Hongkun (Convida Wireless) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) answers Mehrdad (Samsung). Mehrdad (Samsung) asks for some clarifications. Hong (Qualcomm) provides answers to HongKun (Convida Wireless). Mehrdad (Samsung) suggest to postpone this PCR to the next meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2005838 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3 Sol#7 Update to clarify Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay solution. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006573 | Jianhua (OPPO) comments and provides r01 Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02 that moves the procedure into S2-2005644r05. Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006573 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3 Sol#7 Update to clarify Layer-2 UE-to-Network Relay solution. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005838. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005141 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Support Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay to Handle Non-IP Traffic. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006574 | Jianhua (OPPO) asks questions for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) sorry I missed your question, can you please clarify which step of the procedure you mean? Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01. Jianhua (OPPO) is OK with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006574 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, New Solution: Support Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay to Handle Non-IP Traffic. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005141. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005645 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, New Sol: Negotiated UE-to-UE Relay Reselection. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006575 | Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to merge into S2-2005142. LiMeng (Huawei) thinks it is hard to merge these two papers. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides r01 with Interdigital cosigning. LiMeng (Huawei) clarifies. Hong (Qualcomm) asks for clarification on the scope. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006575 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, New Sol: Negotiated UE-to-UE Relay Reselection. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Interdigital Inc. | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005645. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005142 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Solution#32: Update to Handle Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay Switching. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006576 | Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) comments and asks question for clarification. Shabnam (Ericsson) apologies for missing the emails, please see in line my response. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Shabnam. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 addressing Interdigital comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006576 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Solution#32: Update to Handle Layer-3 UE-to-UE Relay Switching. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005142. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005452 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol #31: Update for more clarifications. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005642 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#31: Update for L2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006577 | Jianhua (OPPO) comments. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02 and thanks for providing the previous revision. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and provides r01. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006577 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#31: Update for L2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005642. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005643 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, Sol#9: Update on protocol stacks for Layer 2 UE-to-UE Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) replies to Hong and can live with r01 IF the new EN is removed. Hong (Qualcomm) does not accept original version. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) object r01. Xiaoyan can live with r01 ONLY if the new EN is removed from r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005773 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7, Sol#13: Updates to ProSe charging. | Apple | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper. Gerald (Matrixx) ask for clarification. Sudeep (Apple) responds to Matrixx's question. Hong (Qualcomm) maintains the view to NOTE this paper, as it is in SA5's scope to address.. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#5 | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005201 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, New Sol: Provisioning policy based path selection between PC5 and Uu. | CATT | Rel-17 | Noted. CC#4: r01 agreed. Revised in S2-2006049 | LaeYoung (LGE) propose to NOTE this paper because capturing the proposal as a separate solution is not needed for KI#5 and redundant with the existing solutions for other KIs (e.g. KI#8). Deng Qiang (CATT) provides clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks CATT to clarify what is missing from Solution #12 instead of a new solution. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to LaeYoung (LGE) and Mehrdad (Samsung). Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to LaeYoung (LGE). Mehrdad (Samsung) comments Deng Qiang (CATT) responds. Changhong (Intel) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments and provides r01 Mehrdad (Samsung) objects to original version of this PCR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006049 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, New Sol: Provisioning policy based path selection between PC5 and Uu. | CATT | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r01 of S2-2005201. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005168 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005212, to S2-2006578 | Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LG. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) provides r02 which merges part of content from S2-2005212. LaeYoung (LGE) asks a Q. Changhong (Intel) comments. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Changhong (Intel). LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006578 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol #12: Update to Policy based network-assisted Path Selection. | Samsung, ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005168, merging S2-2005212. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005212 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI #5, Sol #12: Update to Clarify Solution Impacts and Analytics Notification. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006578 and S2-2006579 | Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge part of S2-200512 into S2-2005648r03 and the rest into S2-2005168r01. Hao Dong (ZTE) confirms merging the content of S2-2005212 into S2-2005648r03 and S2-2005168r01 separately. Steve (Huawei) agrees with the impacts clause merge into S2-2005648 Changhong (Intel) asks the chairman to mark it being merged into S2-2005168. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005648 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol#12: Update of Impacts on services, entities and interfaces. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006579 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Steve (Huawei) comments lets not be hasty and work on wording. Provides r01. Hong (Qualcomm) asks questions for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments on r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) suggests to merge S2-2005648 into S2-2005168. Steve (Huawei) provides r02, merging is ok. Mehrdad (Samsung) merges part of S2-2005168 into S2-2005648 and provides r03. Steve (Huawei) merge from S2-2005168 looks good and S2-2005212 looks covered as well. Changhong (Intel) proposes to merge it into S2-2005168. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Changhong. There are only two baseline PCRs now. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04 and r05. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r06 and r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006579 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol#12: Update of Impacts on services, entities and interfaces. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005648. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005771 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol#12: Updates to ProSe policy provisioning. | Apple | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006580 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. Sudeep (Apple) responds to CATT. Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and questions Sudeep (Apple) responds to OPPO's questions. Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Sudeep (Apple) accepts r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments and shares concerns Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r03. Sudeep (Apple) responds to Samsung. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to Apple Sudeep (Apple) accepts r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r03 but objects to original version or other revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006580 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Sol#12: Updates to ProSe policy provisioning. | Apple | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005771. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005169 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5: Evaluation and Interim Conclusion- Direct communication path selection. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) requests for more clarification from CATT Deng Qiang (CATT) responds to Samsung. LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept the evaluation/conclusion in this paper and objects to this paper. Changhong (Intel) share LaeYoung's concern. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies Mehrdad (Samsung) provided r01. Steve (Huawei) thinks understanding what is acceptable is a good way to go LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept all versions of this paper. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED or Postponed this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005240 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5: Solution#12 evaluation and interim conclusion. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006581 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) propose to merge this paper into S2-2005698. Mehrdad (Samsung) propose to merge this paper into S2-2005169. Wen (vivo) responses, Steve (Huawei) suggests merging with S2-2005169 Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005698 if the author of this paper (Wen) is fine. Wen (vivo) agrees with LaeYoung's proposal. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postpone this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this solution already merge into S2-2005698r06. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005448 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#5, Evaluation for solution 12. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Postponed | Hong (Qualcomm) propose to merge this with other KI#5 papers, e.g. S2-2005698. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) also propose to merge this paper into S2-2005698. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with Hong proposal. Mehrdad (Samsung) propose to NOTE this paper. Jianhua( OPPO) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) comments Steve (Huawei) suggests closing the discussion here Changhong (Intel) asks to postpone this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005698 if the author of this paper (Jianhua) is fine. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postpone this paper. Jianhua responds to Deng Qiang and LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Jianhua(OPPO) response. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) responds. Mehrdad (Samsung) objects to including S2-2005201r01 in evaluation of KI#5 at this stage. Mehrdad (Samsung) assumes this evaluation already merged into S2-2005698r06 or postponed. Samsung objects to original version of S2-2005448. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | S2-2005698 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Conclusion on KI#5. | LG Electronics, Intel | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005240, to S2-2006581 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postpone this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) prefers to keep this paper open and see whether we can conclude KI#5 in this meeting. Mehrdad (Samsung) propose to NOTE this paper. Jianhua (OPPO) proposes to NOTE the paper. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Steve (Huawei) suggests noting this paper Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02 Mehrdad (Samsung) requests clarification and shares concern. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r05. Mehrdad (Samsung) did not provide r05. LaeYoung (LG) provided r05. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r06 Mehrdad (Samsung) proposed r04 and r06 and is OK only with this two versions. Samsung cannot accept the rest of versions. Jianhua (OPPO) ok with r05 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r06. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r06. Mehrdad (Samsung) is happy with r06 and happy to co-sign it but will object to original version and all other revisions. Mehrdad (Samsung) is happy to OK with r06 and happy to co-sign but will object to original version and all other revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006581 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Conclusion on KI#5. | LG Electronics, Intel, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005698, merging S2-2005240. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#7 | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004816 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | NEC | Rel-17 | Noted in parallel session | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks question for clarification. Linghang (NEC) provides clarification to Deng Qiang (CATT). Gerald (Matrixx) provide a comment on KI#7 evaluation. Linghang (NEC) provides r01 and agrees to merge the provisioning related part into the revision in 4985r01. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and suggest to merge the provisioning part to 4985r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes this paper be marked merged into S2-2005140. Linghang (NEC) agrees to merge S2-2004816 into S2-2005140 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2004985 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Overall evaluation and interim conclusion for KI #7. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Adrian (vivo) provide comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01. Judy (Ericsson) comments and do not accept r01. Hong (Qualcomm) response. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005140 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#7: Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks question for clarification. Gerald (Matrixx) provided comments to the Conclusions. Jianhua (OPPO) provide r01 and so-sign. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Deng Qiang (CATT), Gerald (Matrixx) and Jianhua (OPPO), and provided r02. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and provides r03. Jianhua (OPPO) provide r04. Judy (Ericsson) comments and do not accept the changes in r03. Judy (Ericsson) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) response to Judy. Judy (Ericsson) can only accept r00 and r02. Hong (Qualcomm) can only accept r03 and r04. Judy (Ericsson) objects to r04 as the concluded solution has not been discussed. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005829 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Interim conclusion for Key Issue#7. | Qualcomm Incorporated, Convida, Matrixx | Rel-17 | Postponed | Deng Qiang (CATT) asks question for clarification. Mehrdad (Samsung) asks question for clarification Hong (Qualcomm) replies to Mehrdad (Samsung). Gerald (Matrixx) suggest a refinement on Conclusions. Hong (Qualcomm) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to postponed this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | Solutions for KI#8 | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005170 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Sol #17: Update to ProSe Authorization and Parameter Provisioning. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006582 | Changhong (Intel) proposes to NOTE it. Hong (Qualcomm) provide comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to NOTED this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) also proposes to NOTE this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to LG, Intel and QC Adrian (vivo) replies to Samsung Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to vivo Deng Qiang (CATT) comments. Mehrdad (Samsung) replies to CATT Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01 Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r03 and objects to r02. Changhong (Intel) provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) comments on r03 Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r04 Changhong (Intel) is fine with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006582 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Sol #17: Update to ProSe Authorization and Parameter Provisioning . | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005170. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005239 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4&8, Sol#36: Updates to the authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006583 | Wen (vivo) is fine with Deng Qiang's (CATT) proposal. Changhong is fine with Deng Qiang's (CATT) proposal. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes first change (definition) merged into S2-2005310, other changes merged into S2-2005311. Weijun (Huawei) asks a question for clarification. Wen (vivo) responses to Weijun (Huawei) . Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and proposes to remove 6.36.2.2. Changhong (Intel) comments. Wen (vivo) takes Changhong's proposal and provide r01. Wen (vivo) responses to Jianhua. Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Wen (vivo) responses to Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Changhong (Intel) asks to mark it being merged into S2-2005310 and S2-2005311 and stop the discussion on this thread. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005311 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4 and 8, Update Solution #36: Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service. | Intel | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.8 | S2-2005312 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Update Solution #17: ProSe Authorization Policy and Parameter for Direct Discovery and Communication. | Intel | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006584 | Adrian (vivo) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006584 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Update Solution #17: ProSe Authorization Policy and Parameter for Direct Discovery and Communication. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005312. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005637 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#8, Sol#16: Update for service authorization of L2 U2N Relay. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006571 | Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes to be merged into S2-2005812. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) agrees Dengqiang's proposal to merge this contribution into S2-2005812. LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Xiaoyan and Dengqiang, and is fine to merge if S2-2005812 clarifies the scope of it is same as S2-2005637. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.8 | S2-2005641 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, #8, Sol #35: Update for Relay service authorization. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006585 | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides comments. Xiaoyan Shi (Interdigital) provides comments. Hong (Qualcomm) comments and provides r02. Steve (Huawei) provides r03 Hong (Qualcomm) is fine with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006585 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, #8, Sol #35: Update for Relay service authorization. | Huawei, HiSilicon, MediaTek, Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005641. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005646 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#3, #8, Sol#30: Update on Authorization for Indirect Network Communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) asks to move S2-2005646 under KI#3, this paper is not much relevant to KI#8. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Steve (Huawei) not sure sure why to note or postone. Hong (Qualcomm) propose to NOTE the paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005649 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: KI#4, #8, Sol#36: Update on Authorization for 5G ProSe UE-to-UE Relay Service. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Covered by S2-2005311. Noted | Changhong (Intel) is fine with Deng Qiang's (CATT) proposal. Deng Qiang (CATT) proposes it be merged into S2-2005311. Weijun (Huawei) is fine with Deng Qiang's (CATT) proposal and give some clarification to Changhong (Intel). Changhong (Intel) asks session chairman to mark this paper being merged into S2-2005311. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.8 | S2-2005313 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Conclusion for Key Issue#8 on non-Relay related. | Intel | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006586 | Mehrdad (Samsung) proposed to NOTE this paper. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r01. Deng Qiang (CATT) cannot open r01. Mehrdad (Samsung) provides r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) comments to r03. Changhong (Intel) provides r03. Mehrdad (Samsung) prefers to keep these based on r03 Mehrdad (Samsung) is OK with r03 but will object to original version and all other revisions. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006586 | P-CR | Approval | 23.752: Conclusion for Key Issue#8 on non-Relay related. | Intel | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005313. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | - | - | - | LSin & LSout | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004981 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on SA WG2 Situation of UE-to-Network Relay and UE-to-UE Relay | OPPO | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006587 | Jianhua (OPPO) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to postpone this LS. Jianhua (OPPO) replies to LaeYoung and provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) prefers to postpone this LS. Steve (Huawei) checks RAN schedule. Jianhua (OPPO) responds and provide r03. Steve (Huawei) provides r04 and comments LaeYoung (LGE) thinks the LS contents do not reflect the outcome of this meeting. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to postpone the LS. Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Mehrdad Mehrdad (Samsung) Jianhua (OPPO) provides r07. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 Jianhua responds to Hannu. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r05 and address the comments. LaeYoung (LGE) can live with r07. Hannu (Nokia) can live with r07. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006587 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on Direct Discovery and Relay in SA2 | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2004981. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2004987 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on new PQI support for PC5 communication | OPPO | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006588 | Jianhua (OPPO) provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006588 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on new PQI support for PC5 communication | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004987. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005202 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on security issues for 5G ProSe | CATT | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006589 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE or postpone this LS. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Deng Qiang (CATT) is fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.8 | S2-2006589 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on security issues for 5G ProSe | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005202. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.8 | S2-2005203 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Charging information reporting for 5G ProSe | CATT | Rel-17 | Postponed | Gerald (Matrixx) with comments. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks question for clarification. Hannu (Nokia) asks a question. Gerald (Matrixx) with answer to the question. Deng Qiang (CATT) responds. Deng Qiang (CATT) asks to postpone this LS out. Hong (Qualcomm) supports to POSTPONE the LS. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | Study on architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services (FS_5MBS) | - | - | Docs:=130 | - | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | LSs | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004973 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on RAN feedback on 5MBS aspects | Ericsson | Noted. Covered by S2-2005415 | Hans (Ericsson) merged two draft LS proposals into one. Revision with merge of 5414 & 4973 provided in S2-2004973r01. Thomas (Nokia) prefers S2-2005415 as baseline for a merge, and objects against r00 and r01. LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2004973 into S2-2005415, or note this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005415 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: [DRAFT] LS on RAN impact of FS_5MBS Study. | [Huawei to be] SA WG2 | Rel-17 | CC#4: r37 agreed. Revised in S2-2006044 (Should be LS OUT) | Hans (Ericsson) merged two draft LS proposals into one. Revision with merge of 5414 & 4973 provided in S2-2004973r01. LiMeng (Huawei) appreciates the merging effort, prefers to use 5415 as the baseline, and provides S2-2005415r01. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03. zhendong (ZTE), provides the r04 Thomas (Nokia), provides the r05 zhendong (ZTE), provides r06 Thomas(Nokia) replies to zhendong Hans (Ericsson) provides r07. Jianhua (OPPO) provides r08. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r09. Zhenhua (Nokia) provides r12. zhendong (ZTE), provides the r13 Thomas (Nokia) provides r11 and asks Miguel why he removed the broadcast related question. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r10. Zhenhua (vivo), ask for reconsider r13 based on r12 Zhenhua (vivo), comments on r13 zhendong (ZTE), provides the response zhendong (ZTE), provides r14 which based on r12 Zhenhua (vivo) provides clarification Zhenhua (vivo), provides r15 Thomas (Nokia), provides r16 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r17. Thomas (Nokia) provides r18. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r19. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r20. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r20. zhendong (ZTE), ask question for clarification Zhenhua (vivo) provide r23 based on r19~r22 and ask Thomas to check again and confirm the objected text. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r22 based on r21. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Miguel Thomas (Nokia) replies that r19 is fine and earlier versions will be checked later. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r21 Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) asks Thomas (Nokia) to clarify which revisions he objects to. Miguel (Qualcomm) responds to Thomas regarding broadcast Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r24. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r25. LiMeng (Huawei) comments r25. Zhenhua (vivo) comments r24 and r25. Hans (Ericsson) provides r26. Miguel (Griot) objects to r24, r25, and r26, and objects to any LS that uses r24, r25 or r26 as basis, please start again from r21, r22 or r23 Zhenhua (vivo) object r26 and provides r27. Miguel (Qualcomm) objects to r27, and any revision using r24, r25, r26 or r27 as basis Thomas (Nokia) provides r29 based on r26 and comments on the changes proposed by Hans Zhenhua (vivo) provides r28 based on r27 Zhenhua (vivo) object r34. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r35 (based on r30, r32, r33). Hans (Ericsson) comments and provides r34. Ericsson objects to r32, r33 and r30 and earlier. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r34 (based on r30, r32, r33). LiMeng (Huawei) provides r33 (based on r30). Thomas (Nokia) provides r30 based on r23. Zhenhua (vivo) object r31 (based on r23) and provide r32 (based on r23, r26, r28). Hans (Ericsson) provides r31 (based on r23) . Zhenhua (vivo) object r29 and suggest to have a new revision based on r28 Jianhua (OPPO) comments on r34 and r31. Zhenhua (vivo) confirms the objection on r34. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r31 and suggest taking this issue to CC#4. All remaining versions (also r31) will need modifications due to text marked as 'depending on SA2 outcome' Suggest using r30 as basis Zhenhua (vivo) suggest to use r35 as a baseline for working out the final revision to CC#4. Hans (Ericsson) comment to Vivo. Hans (Ericsson) responds to OPPO. Hans (Ericsson) objects to Vivo's r35 version. R35 by the way was uploaded to the 3GPP server 19:06:00 which is 6 min late compared to the 1700UTC deadline. Zhenhua (vivo) responses to Hans (Ericsson). Hans (Ericsson) objects to Vivo's r35 version. R35 by the way was uploaded to the 3GPP server 19:06:00 which is 6 min late compared to the 1700UTC deadline. Shabnam (Ericsson) actually SA plenary has concluded as per Rel-17 scope discussion it is excluded. And reconfirmed at the last meeting no change in scope of MBS Rel-17 compared to what was agreed in SA#86. Miguel (Qualcomm) responds regarding broadcast LiMeng (Huawei) comments and is fine to discuss this issue in CC#4. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides some comments Hans (Ericsson) comments to Thomas, Zhenhua. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Thomas(Nokia) replies to Shabnam that SA plenary decision related to enTV, and not to broadcast in general. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006044 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on RAN impact of FS_5MBS Study. | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r37 of S2-2005415. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | General/Cross-KI | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004972 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Specific architectural requirements and principles, update. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006293 | Thomas (Nokia) objects against this CR Judy (Ericsson) do not agree with Thomas (Nokia)'s reasoning of objection, and provide r01 as an alternative and ask Nokia to reconsider the position. Thomas (Nokia) object r00, can accept r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006293 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Specific architectural requirements and principles, update . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004972. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005293 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on Baseline Functionalities. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006294 | LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Lei (Tencent) provides clarifications to LiMeng (Huawei) and provide r01. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r02. Hans (Ericsson) provides r03. Thomas (Nokia) provides r04. Lei (Tencent) provides comments. LiMeng (Huawei) prefers r04. Lei(Tencent) confirms ok with r04 and all other revisions including r00:-) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006294 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on Baseline Functionalities. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005293. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005295 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on Multicast/Broadcast Communication Service and EN Resolving. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006332 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Lei(Tencent) responds to Thomas (Nokia) and ok with r01. Lei(Tencent) respond to Judy(Ericsson) and provide r03. Judy(Ericsson) responds to Lei(Tencent). Lei(Tencent) responds to Judy (Ericsson) and provide comments. Ask Judy(Ericsson) to further update r02 w.r.t. editorial changes. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r02 Thomas(Nokia) objects to r02 and r03 Lei(Tencent) confirms fine with r01 and can live with r02, r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006332 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Clarification on Multicast/Broadcast Communication Service and EN Resolving. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005295. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005258 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Add new term of PDU Session for unicast fall-back. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhenhua (vivo) provides clarification Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR Hans (Ericsson) objects to 5258. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2004824 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | Only use multicast transport to RAN. | Juniper Networks | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) asks for clarifications. zhendong (ZTE), agree with huawei, not preclude other option. Jeffrey (Juniper) provides clarifications. Thomas (Nokia), comments that this is a PCR to update solution 3 and objects against it. Miguel (Qualcomm) objects to this PCR. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Jeffrey (Juniper) reiterates clarification Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to zhendong (ZTE) zhendong (ZTE), provides the response to Juniper ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2004872 | DISCUSSION | Agreement | CP- vs UP-based join/leave requests. | Juniper Networks | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) asks question for clarification. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Limeng. Thomas (Nokia) comments and suggests noting this discussion paper Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r01 and responds to Thomas. Judy (Ericsson) questions the proposals, and suggests to note this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005259 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Update mapping table for solutions. | vivo | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006295 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. David (Samsung) notices r01 is not in the server . Thomas(nokia) confirms that r01 is now uploaded . Zhenhua (vivo) provide r02. Thomas (Nokia) accepts r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006295 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Update mapping table for solutions. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005259. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005260 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: New architecture proposal for 5G MBS. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005409 | Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge with S2-2005409. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005409 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: New architecture for MBS. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated, CATT | Rel-17 | CC#4: Postponed | Zhenhua (vivo) proposes to merge S2-2005409 with S2-2005260 and provides r01 zhendong (ZTE), provides the r02 zhenhua (vivo), comments on r02 Youngkyo (Samsung) comments on r01 and r02 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r03 Youngkyo (samsung) provides further comment. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r04. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r05. Youngkyo(Samsung) provide response to the comments from Zhenhua (vivo). Zhenhua (vivo) comments to r06. Youngkyo (samsung) provides r06. Zhenhua (vivo) provide r07. Hans (Ericsson) provide r08. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r09. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r12. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r11. Thomas(Nokia)) provides r10. Youngkyo(Samsung) has concerns and object r09~r11. LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Youngkyo (Samsung) and clarifies. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r13. Sudeep (Apple) seeks a clarification on r13. Zhenhua (vivo) clarify. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Sudeep Hans (Ericsson) provides feedback and proposal for way forward. A r14 is provided. Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification to Hans (Ericsson) and prefers a merged architecture as the way forward. Thomas(Nokia) has concerns with r14 and prefers a merged architecture as the way forward. Zhenhua (vivo) prefers a merged architecture as the way forward. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) is ok with r15 Thomas (Nokia) replies to Miguel and provides r15 Miguel (Qualcomm) comments on r14, and fate of this document in general LiMeng (Huawei) supports r15. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r16 with some minor changes. Hans (Ericsson) provides r17. Ericsson objects to revision r16 and all earlier revisions of 5409. Thomas (Nokia) objects against r17. Suggest bringing this issue into the CC Zhenhua (vivo) objects against r17. Hans (Ericsson) proposes to note 5409. It is premature to agree on a converged architecture in this meeting. Several companies have already expressed that. The best we can do is to postpone architecture conclusions until next meeting. LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r00, r05, r10~r13, r15 and r16, objects to other versions (including r14 and r17), and suggests to discuss the document in CC#4. Shabnam (Ericsson) it is unfortunate that after prolonged discussion at CC#3 about not to include a converged architecture, there were no attempts made to compromise and continued insistence to push for such architecture. We propose to NOTE this paper and we come back next meeting with all solutions included in the TR. No need for CC#4 discussion again as we are not listening to each other's views constructively. Miguel (Qualcomm) is OK with r16, objects to r17 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.9 | S2-2005475 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: MBS architecture functional entities. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005409 | Thomas (Nokia) suggests consider this contribution merged into 5409 David (Samsung) agrees with Thomas' suggestion to merge into 5409 David (Samsung) is OK not to merge for now. Hans (Ericsson) propose not to merge into 5409. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Miguel that he still prefers 5409 and that r00 and r01 are only preparatory steps as content would need to be shifted Miguel (Qualcomm) asks what's the goal of this? Thomas (Nokia) comments that only one converged architecture can be agreed and provides r01 David (Samsung) comments, is OK to merge with 5409 or note. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005261 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | Discussion on delivery method efficiency considering UE moving. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes the way forward of the document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005266 | DISCUSSION | Endorsement | Summary of feature list for 5MBS evaluation and conclusion. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) provides the way forward of the related conclusions. Hans (Ericsson) please note this paper, it's a discussion paper. LiMeng (Huawei) agree Ericsson on the NOTE proposal. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005272 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#2, KI#5, KI#8, and KI#9. | vivo | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006296 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006296 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#2, KI#5, KI#8, and KI#9. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005272. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005278 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#2, KI#5, KI#8, and KI#9. | vivo | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006297 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r01. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006297 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#2, KI#5, KI#8, and KI#9. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005278. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#1 | - | - | Docs:=43 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005214 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1:Update to KI#1 to associate S-NSSAI/DNN with the MBS Session. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) further comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification.. Chunshan (Tencent) provide clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) provides comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) objects against this CR (all revisions). Chunshan (Tencent) provides the clarification. Judy (Ericsson) supports the proposal to consider DNN and S-NSSAI in 5MBS and believes this is a must if MC IP address is used as 5MBS ID. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005215 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1:Update to KI#1 to clarify whether I-(MB-)SMF and I-(MB-)UPF is used for a MBS Session. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) asks for clarification. Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR. Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01. Chunshan (Tencent) is OK with r01. Fenqin (Huawei) Comments and propose to Note this CR. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR (all revisions). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2004968 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Update to Sol#2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: r06 (+ editor's note + AMF -> MBS-SMF) agreed. Revised in S2-2006045 | Zhenhua (vivo) comments for clarification LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Judy (Ericsson) responds to LiMeng (Huawei) and Zhenhua (vivo), and provide r01. Zhenhua (vivo) furthur comments. Jeffrey (Juniper) comments on Zhenhua's comments, and on EN about unicast transport Thomas (Nokia) comments. Judy (Ericsson) responds further and provide r02. Zhenhua (vivo) asks for further clarification. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Judy (Ericsson) Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r04 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 and comments about further required changes Judy (Ericsson) responds to Jeffrey (Juniper) and Thomas (Nokia) and provide r05. Xiaoyan (CATT) asks for clarification. Jeffrey (Juniper) disagrees with Judy (Ericsson) response Thomas (Nokia) provides r06 Judy (Ericsson) responds to Jeffrey (Juniper) that the reason of disagreement is not relevant. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan (CATT), and accept r06 from Thomas (Nokia). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides a comment. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan (CATT). Xiaoyan (CATT) objects to all current revisions of S2-2004968 and requests a new revision. Zhenhua (vivo) ask for a new revision to address whether HL MC can be used by PSA-UPF. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Xiaoyan (CATT) and Zhenhua (vivo) and provides r07 in CC#4 folder, addressing also one EN from Thomas (Nokia). Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r07 Thomas (Nokia) with draft r07 Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r08 and asks if CATT can accept r08. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Xiaoyan (CATT) provide r09. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006045 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Update to Sol#2. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r06 (+ editor's note + AMF -> MBS-SMF) of S2-2004968. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004978 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#3: Update to remove ENs. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006299 | Thomas (Nokia) comments. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides comments, proposes to merge into S2-2005411 Jianhua (OPPO) responds to Thomas and Miguel. Thomas (OPPO) Nokia replies to Jianhua ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005397 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Update of Sol. 3: resolving open issue(s) for UE leaves MBS. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006298 | Hans (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006298 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Update of Sol. 3: resolving open issue(s) for UE leaves MBS . | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005397. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005411 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI1: Update of Sol. 3: resolving open issue(s). | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004978 and S2-2005633, to S2-2006299 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 to merge the contents of S2-2005633 Thomas (Nokia) prefers r01 and answers the question of Judy. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r02. Judy (Ericsson) responded to Thomas (Nokia) and prefers r02. Jianhua (OPPO) comments and asks questions. LiMeng (Huawei) replies. Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006299 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI1: Update of Sol. 3: resolving open issue(s). | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005411, merging S2-2004978 and S2-2005633. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005631 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Update of Solution #3 to detail mission critical service activation. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Hans (Ericsson) asks question for clarification. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Hans. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005633 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution #3 to detail PCC interactions. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006299 | Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this PCR into S2-2005411. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005263 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: resolve ENs and update. | vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006300 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006300 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#4: resolve ENs and update. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005263. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005635 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution 5 for broadcast session management. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006301 | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for further clarification to the changes proposed and questions if it is correct soln to update? Without further clarification we do not see the updates as correct. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam and provides r01 Jianhua (OPPO) provides comments and asks questions. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Jianhua Youngkyo(Samsung) provides comments and asks questions. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Youngkyo Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam and provides r02 Shabnam (Ericsson) provides comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006301 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution 5 for broadcast session management. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005635. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005306 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update to solve ENs. | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006302 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides reply to the comments and revision r01 . LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006302 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, solution#6: update to solve ENs . | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005306. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005358 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #8: Clarification on MBS Solution. | China Mobile, Huawei, CATT, Academy of Broadcasting Science | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006303 | Judy (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) answers the questions from Judy (Ericsson). Judy (Ericsson) asks further questions. Aihua (China Mobile) replies to the comments and provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006303 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #8: Clarification on MBS Solution. | China Mobile, Huawei, CATT, Academy of Broadcasting Science | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005358. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005315 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, solution#9: update to solve ENs. | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006304 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides reply to the comments. Youngkyo (Samsung) provides revisionr02. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification. Thomas (Nokia) comments Youngkyo(Samsung) provide revision r03 Thomas(Nokia) accepts revision r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006304 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, solution#9: update to solve ENs. | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005315. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005458 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol 10, Update solution to resolve the EN. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005459 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol 10, adding leaving procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006305 | Hans (Ericsson) provides comment. zhendong (ZTE), provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006305 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol 10, adding leaving procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005459. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005460 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, sol 10, adding stop procedure. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2004979 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#13: Update to address the ENs and further clarify. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005219 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #14: Update to include the MBS Deactivation and Stop procedure. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006306 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. LiMeng (Huawei) is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006306 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #14: Update to include the MBS Deactivation and Stop procedure. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005219. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005264 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#15: Update. | vivo | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006307 | Thomas (Nokia) comments Zhenhua (vivo) provides r01 Thomas (Nokia) provides r02 Zhenhua (vivo) response Thomas(Nokia) replies to Zhenhua ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006307 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Sol#15: Update. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005264. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005433 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #1, Sol #16: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005482 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: New Solution for MBS Session (activate, deactivate). | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006308 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006308 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: New Solution for MBS Session (activate, deactivate) . | Huawei, HiSilicon, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005482. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005652 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 New Solution for broadcast session management. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for further clarification what is the difference with this pCR and pCR in 5635 with same title and identical flow? Shabnam (Ericsson) thanks, so I assume this document to be noted and focus on 5635. Thomas (Nokia) requests to note the CR, as proposal is covered in 5635 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005655 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Key issue 1 new solution for interactions between MBSF and MBSU. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006309 | Youngkyo(Samsung) propose to object this PCR. Thomas(Nokia) replies to youngkyo Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r01. Thomas (Nokia) accepts r01. Youngkyo(Samsung) is okay with the revision r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006309 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Key issue 1 new solution for interactions between MBSF and MBSU. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005655. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004976 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Evaluation and conclusion on MBS Session deactivation and activation. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to postpone this contribution. Thomas (Nokia) supports to postpone this contribution. Andy (Convener) comments on proposed disposition. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Andy that he is open either to note or to postpone. Hans (Ericsson) proposes to just say 'noted' the paper. Anyone is free to submit papers on this in the next meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005413 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Principles for categorization of Solutions for KI1. | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | CC#4: r17 (+ editor's note) agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005273, in S2-2006046 | Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge with S2-2005273. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) propose to use present contribution as basis. Judy (Ericsson) proposes to merge this paper with S2-2005273 and continue the discussion there focusing on evaluation principles. Youngkyo(samsung) provide a comment. Zhenhua (vivo) ask Youngkyo for clarification of the term 'MBS session' and 'MBS distribution session'. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Judy. Hans (Ericsson) provides a r02 with updates, e.g. modified to evaluation principles, plus some merged bullets from Vivo 5273r05. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Thomas Thomas (Nokia) provides r08 Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r07 Youngkyo(Samsung) provides r06 Youngkyo(Samsung) replies to Zhenhua (vivo) Thomas(Nokia) provides r05 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r04, but also asks why are these in evaluation, they look more like requirements and conclusions. Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r03 Zhenhua (vivo) provides r09 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r10 Hans (Ericsson) provides update in r11. Jeffrey (Juniper) disagrees with removing 'controversial' bullet Thomas (Nokia) provides r12 Thomas (Nokia) provides r13 based on r11. Prefers r12 but can live with r13 Miguel (Qualcomm) cannot find r12 in the server (?) Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r14 LiMeng (Huawei) provides r17 Jeffrey (Juniper) provides r16 Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r15 Jeffrey (Juniper): Chair's note in 08-31-1000 seems to be wrong? Anyway, request this to be discussed in CC#4. Juniper objects to any revision that removes the evaluation consideration of whether a solution requires application to be aware 5GS specific/internal information. Thomas(Nokia) objects against merging 5413 into 5273 Rather suggest consider 5273 merged to 5413. Suggest agreeing r17 of 5413 LiMeng (Huawei) tries to explain the current situation. Can someone please clarify what's happening now since both papers cannot progress at the same time. Thomas, is your suggestion to note 5413 instead of merged status? Thomas(Nokia) objects against merging into 5273 about merging wrongly to 5413. Suggest agreeing r17 Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Shabnam Thomas(Nokia) comments that chairs´macro seems to have imported some emails for 5273 about merging wrongly to 5413. Suggest agreeing r17 Shabnam (Ericsson) would like Juniper to be more precise in what they want, too vague to interpret what is meant. Also can authors clarify if this is for Clause 7 or clause 8? Clause 7 is evaluation and I assume that is the target for now. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006046 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1: Principles for categorization of Solutions for KI1. | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r17 (+ editor's note) of S2-2005413, merging S2-2005273. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005461 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Interim conclusion on KI#1 - the MBS service/context identifier. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) asks to postpone this contribution. Thomas (Nokia) objects to this contribution. zhendong (ZTE), is fine to postpone this paper ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005462 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Interim conclusion on KI#1 - the efficient transport and join method. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted. Covered by S2-2005413 | Zhenhua (vivo) propose to merge with S2-2005273. Thomas (Nokia) propose to merge with S2-2005413. zhendong (ZTE), is fine to merged to 5413 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005267 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#1. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) suggest postponing this contribution LiMeng (Huawei) agrees Nokia. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005273 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#1. | vivo | Rel-17 | CC#4: Merged into S2-2006046. | zhenhua (vivo) proposes way forward for conclusion of KI#1, merge S2-2005273, S2-2005413, and S2-2005462, provides r01 for the merge Zhenhua (vivo) provide r03 and propose to revise this document as it may be able to achieve more agreements. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02, asks Rapporteur to please confirm which document we should be using for conclusions. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides comment and its revision r04. Thomas (Nokia) support focusing on evaluation principles. A r06 is provided. Nokia prefers 5413 as basis. Hans (Ericsson) proposes to instead use some of the bullets as evaluation principles. A r05 is provided. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Hans (Ericsson) proposes to note this paper. Zhenhua (vivo) has proposed to merge with S2-2005413. LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to mark this document as merge into S2-2005413. Thomas(Nokia) suggests merging this into S2-2005413. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#2 | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005216 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #2, Sol #1:Update to include the Protocol Stack for the Basic Service Level. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR. Hans (Ericsson) share Thomas' view. This PCR should be noted. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) agrees with Thomas protocol stack should not be defined as part of KI#2, and supports noting this P-CR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005659 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#2 Update of Solution #1. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) suggests to postpone. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#3 | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005414 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #3: Update to KI#3 to clarify the way forward. | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006310 (Update of the KI) | zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r01 with further clarification of the new NOTE. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006310 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #3: Update to KI#3 to clarify the way forward. | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005414. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004821 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: 5MBS receiver join request and authorization by ASP. | Juniper Networks | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006311 (KI#3, new solution) | LiMeng (Huawei) asks for clarifications. Jeffrey (Juniper) provides clarifications. Jeffrey (Juniper) provides further clarifications related to 5358. Fenqin(Huawei) comments Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Fenqin(Huawei)'s comments, and provides r01. LiMeng (Huawei) explains. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Jeffrey (Juniper) responds to Thomas (Nokia); ok with r02 but may provide r03 after hearing back from Thomas. Thomas(Nokia) prefers r02. Jeffrey (Juniper) provide r03 based on his assumption of Thomas' rational for adding the EN. Prefers r03 but ok with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006311 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: 5MBS receiver join request and authorization by ASP. | Juniper Networks | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004821. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005268 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#3. | vivo | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006312 | Fenqin (Huawei)Comments. Zhenhua (vivo) response. LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone the evaluation paper. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01. Zhenhua (vivo) OK with r01. LiMeng (Huawei) withdraws the postpone proposal and is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006312 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#3. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005268. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005274 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#3. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#4 | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005412 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #17: Update to remove ENs. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006313 | Judy (Ericsson) asks questions for clarification. LiMeng (Huawei) answers. LiMeng (Huawei) agrees with Judy (Ericsson). Judy (Ericsson) assumes this paper merged to S2-2005434 according to info from LiMeng (Huawei). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005434 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #17: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005412, to S2-2006313 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01. Xiaoyan (CATT) is fine with r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006313 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, Sol #17: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005434, merging S2-2005412. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004971 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4, AF specific priority for 5MBS group member. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006314 (New solution) | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Youngkyo(samsung) provides comments. Hans (Ericsson) responds to comments. Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Hans (Ericsson) responds to Zhenhua. Youngkyo(Samsung) provide further comment. Zhenhua (vivo) reponse to Hans (Ericssion). Hans (Ericsson) asks Youngkyo for clarification. Hans (Ericsson) provides r01 with AT&T cosign. Youngkyo (Samsung) replies to Hans's question. Thomas (Nokia) comments and objects against an update of the key issue Paul (Ericsson) provides a response. Thomas(Nokia) explains r03 and object against r00 to r02 Thomas (Nokia) provides r03 Hans (Ericsson) reponds to comments . Hans (Ericsson) provides r02 with clause 5 (key issue) update removed as requested by Thomas. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006314 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#4, AF specific priority for 5MBS group member . | Ericsson, AT&T | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2004971. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005218 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, New Sol: MBS QoS Control. | Tencent | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006315 | Judy (Ericsson) comments and questions the need of new QoS parameters. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification. Judy (Ericsson) responds to Chunshan (Tencent). Chunshan (Tencent) responds to Ericsson. Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r02. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r01. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r03 and clarification. Chunshan (Tencent) provides r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006315 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #4, New Sol: MBS QoS Control. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005218. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004826 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Solution for Key Issue #4: QoS level support for Multicast and Broadcast communication services. | TCL Communication Ltd. | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006316 | LiMeng (Huawei) asks to clarify the justification of the proposal. Judy (Ericsson) comments and proposes to note the paper. Ahmed (TCL Communication Ltd.) responds and provides r01. Judy (Ericsson) comments. LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Thomas (Nokia.) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006316 | DISCUSSION | Approval | Solution for Key Issue #4: QoS level support for Multicast and Broadcast communication services. | TCL Communication Ltd. | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004826. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005269 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#4. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone this document. Judy (Ericsson) comments and proposes to postpone this paper. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005275 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#4. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone this document. Judy (Ericsson) comments and proposes to postpone this paper. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 Zhenhua (vivo) ask for reconsideration on whether the items are acceptable or not. Zhenhua (vivo) proposes to merge with S2-2005409. Zhenhua (vivo) proposes to merge with S2-2005413. Zhenhua (vivo) has already said merge with S2-2005413. Chunshan (Tencent) supports Ericsson to postpone this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#6 | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005217 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6: Update the KI#6 to clarify the service continuity. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Shabnam (Ericsson) objects to the pCR as it completely rewrites the concept of local service. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification and r01 Shabnam (Ericsson) clarifies in the comment that the objection was for both bullet points introduced. Chunshan (Tencent) clarifies the bullet2. Chunshan (Tencent) provides the r02. Chunshan (Tencent) provides clarification.. Shabnam (Ericsson) does not understand the change where local MBS service is being redefined to be normal MBS service, disagrees with r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) cannot accept r02 or any version so we object to all versions, please see comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2004970 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6, Sol #19, Update to address editor's notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006317 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. LiMeng (Huawei) replies to Shabnam. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides response in line below. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006317 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6, Sol #19, Update to address editor's notes. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004970. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005003 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#20: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005027, to S2-2006318 | LiMeng (Huawei) asks for clarifications. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers to Q from LiMeng (Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 just adding III. TingYI (III) response from LaeYoung (LGE) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006318 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#20: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics, III | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005003, merging S2-2005027. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005026 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#20 Updates to multicast service area information. | III | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. LiMeng (Huawei) replies. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and proposes to NOTE this paper. Thomas (Nokia) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer to Thomas (Nokia). LaeYoung (LGE) confirms she proposes to NOTE this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005027 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, Sol#20 Updates to enhance the solution. | III | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006318 | LiMeng (Huawei) agrees the proposal from LGE and suggests to Merge S2-2005027 into S2-2005003. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005003 (LGE). TingYi (III) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to question from TingYi (III). TingYi (III) response from LaeYoung Kim (LG) LaeYoung (LGE) confirms this paper can be merged into 5003. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005318 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, solution#21: update to cover missing scenarios. | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks some questions for clarification. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides reply to the comments. Thomas(Nokia) objects about changing solution 21 in the proposed manner. Suggest converting the contribution to a new solution. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005657 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6 Update of Solution #21. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005410, to S2-2006333 | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks some questions which soln being proposed to be updated and how to resolve conflict. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Shabnam Suggest to merge contents of S2-2005410 into this contribution. Provides r01 Zhenhua (vivo) ask clarification Youngkyo(Samsung) provides question/comment for clarification. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Youngkyo. Thomas (Nokia) replies to Zhenhua LiMeng (Huawei) tries to answer the question from YoungKyo (Samsung). Youngkyo(Samsung) provide further question. Youngkyo(Samsung) continues question for clarification. Thomas(Nokia) replies to Youngkyu. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006333 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6 Update of Solution #21. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell, Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005657, merging S2-2005410. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005316 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, new solution: Move to Local MBS services. | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006319 | LiMeng (Huawei) asks for clarification. Youngkyo(Samsung) provides reply to the comments. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006319 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#6, new solution: Move to Local MBS services . | SAMSUNG | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005316. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005410 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #6, New Sol: On Local MBS Support. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006333 | LiMeng (Huawei) is OK to merge this document into S2-2005657 to simplify the evaluation. Thomas (Nokia) suggest merging this into S2-2005657 and thus into solution 21. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005270 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#6. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone. Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR. Thomas (Nokia) provides r01. Would also be fine to postpone PCR. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to postpone this paper. Thomas (Nokia) asks to disregard email with objection ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005276 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#6. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone. Thomas (Nokia) objects against this PCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#7 | - | - | Docs:=23 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004969 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Update to Sol#11 & 12. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006320 | LiMeng (Huawei) provides comments. Zhenhua (vivo) provides comments. Hans (Ericsson) responds to comments and provides r01. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Hans (Ericsson) comments. Fine with R01 Thomas(Nokia) asks Hans (Ericsson) if he meant Fine with R02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006320 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Update to Sol#11 & 12. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2004969. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005435 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #18: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006321 | Judy (Ericsson) comments and provide r01 Thomas (Nokia) provide r02 Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies and provide r03. Thomas(Nokia) objects against r00 to r03 and provides r04. Xiaoyan (CATT) requests Thomas (Nokia) to upload r04 again (as r05). Xiaoyan (CATT) clarifies to Thomas (Nokia). Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r06. Thomas (Nokia) accepts r07 Xiaoyan (CATT) provides r07 and r08. Thomas(Nokia) provides r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006321 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #18: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Revision r07 of S2-2005435. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005106 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Updates introducing multicast to unicast switch. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006322 | Zhenhua (vivo) comments. Hongkun (Convida Wireless) comments. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments David (Samsung) provides r01, answers comments Thomas (Nokia) propose to object this PCR David (Samsung) asks Thomas to reconsider an objection without having expressed any concern with the solution until last day of meeting David (Samsung) provides r02 Thomas (Nokia) accepts r02 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006322 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Updates introducing multicast to unicast switch. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005106. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005758 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Removal of ENs on unicast to multicast switch. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006323 | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006323 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#24: Removal of ENs on unicast to multicast switch. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005758. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005456 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, sol 25, update solution on different SMF issue. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Noted | Thomas (Nokia) questions the assumptions of this PCR zhendong (ZTE), provides the response Thomas (Nokia) suggest noting the CR. zhendong (ZTE), provides the response. Thomas (Nokia) replies and maintains objection ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005457 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Key issue#7, sol 26, update solution on stop sending the forward data. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2004980 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#27: Update to remove ENs and further clarify. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006324 | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to merge S2-2004980 into S2-2005483. Thomas (Nokia) provides comments and suggest merging into S2-2005483 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005483 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Update of Sol. 27: resolving open issue(s) for Inter-RAN node MBS session Handover. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004980 and S2-2005658, to S2-2006324 | Zhenhua (vivo) ask for clarification. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r01 Zhenhua (vivo) ask for further clarification Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Thomas (Nokia) provides r02. Zhenhua (vivo) further comments. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r03. Fenqin (Huawei) ok to go with r02. Thomas (Nokia) prefers r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006324 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Update of Sol. 27: resolving open issue(s) for Inter-RAN node MBS session Handover. | Huawei, HiSilicon, Qualcomm, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005483, merging S2-2004980 and S2-2005658. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005658 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7 Update of Solution #27. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006324 | Fenqin (Huawei) suggest to merge to 5483 Thomas (Nokia) agrees to merge to 5483 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.9 | S2-2005262 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#28: resolve ENs and update. | vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005265 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, Sol#29: Update. | vivo | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005436 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #7, Sol #31: Update to resolve ENs. | CATT | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2004977 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7, New Sol: Unicast and multicast switching. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.9 | S2-2005020 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Reliable delivery mode switching within single RAN/dual RANs. | Shanghai Jiao Tong University | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006325 (KI#7, new solution) | Thomas (Nokia) provides r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006325 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Reliable delivery mode switching within single RAN/dual RANs. | Shanghai Jiao Tong University | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005020. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2004975 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#7: Evaluation and conclusion of MBS service continuity. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005271 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Evaluation for 5MBS KI#7. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | S2-2005277 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Conclusion for 5MBS KI#7. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LiMeng (Huawei) proposes to postpone this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.9 | - | - | - | KI#9 | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005396 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #9: Mobility between MBMS and 5G MBS. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006326 (New solution) | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Fenqin (Huawei) responds. Youngkyo (Samsung) proposes to postpone this PCR. zhendong (ZTE), provides the comments Youngkyo (Samsung) provides comment. Shabnam (Ericsson) supports the position that we need to make room for Key Issue #9 soln for October or even November, depending on when we conclude the other Key issues mentioned. LiMeng (Huawei) comments. Fenqin (Huawei) provides r01 Hans (Ericsson) comments and provides r02. Fenqin (Huawei) responds and provides r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006326 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI #9: Mobility between MBMS and 5G MBS. | Huawei, Hisilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005396. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005776 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution to KI#9: Switching to unicast transport for mobility to E-UTRAN/EPC. | Qualcomm Incororporated | Rel-17 | Revision of (postponed) S2-2004224 from S2#139E. r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006327 (New solution) | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Miguel Griot (Qualcomm) provides r01, responds to LaeYoung LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r01. Miguel (Qualcomm) provides r02 based on LaeYoung's (LGE) comments to r01. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r02. Hans (Ericsson) provide comment and revision r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006327 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution to KI#9: Switching to unicast transport for mobility to E-UTRAN/EPC. | Qualcomm Incororporated | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005776. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.9 | S2-2005777 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution to KI#9: Service layer continuity between E-UTRAN/EPC MBMS and NR/5GC MBS. | Qualcomm Incororporated | Rel-17 | Revision of (postponed) S2-2004229 from S2#139E. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006328 (New solution) | Hans (Ericsson) provides comments and revision r01 . ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.9 | S2-2006328 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: Solution to KI#9: Service layer continuity between E-UTRAN/EPC MBMS and NR/5GC MBS. | Qualcomm Incororporated | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005777. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | Study on system enablers for multi-USIM devices (FS_MUSIM) | - | - | Docs:=74 | - | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - LSs | - | - | Docs:=7 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2004992 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Potential RAN impact for support of Multi-USIM devices | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006037 | Saso (Intel) proposes this document to be considered MERGED into the baseline document S2-2005689. Alessio(nokia) makes a comment on sol 11. Saso (Intel) invites Alessio (Nokia) to comment on the baseline document (5689). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005016 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device | QUALCOMM Europe Inc. - Italy | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006037 | Saso (Intel) proposes this document to be considered MERGED into the baseline document S2-2005689. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005689, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005689 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on System support for Multi-USIM devices | Intel | Rel-17 | CC#4: r40 (with some editorial corrections) agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004992. S2-2005016 and S2-2005754, in S2-2006037 | Xiaowan (vivo) comments and provides r01 Saso (Intel) provides r02 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03. Lars (Sony) provides r04. Saso (Intel) OK with r03. Comments on r04. Proposes r05. Lalith (Samsung) proposes r07. Lalith (Samsung) proposes r08. Saso (Intel) OK with r08. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r09. Lars (Sony) provides r10. Curt (Charter) asks a question to Lar (Sony). Alessio(Nokia) provides r11 Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on r11. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) askes comments for r11. Alessio (Nokia) responds and points out S2-2005671 (Samsung) proposes paging cause multiplexing Alessio(nokia) provides r12. Steve (Huawei) provides r13 Lars (Sony) provides r14 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to the new added Q by HW for clarification Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r15. Lars (Sony) ask question to Guilluame on r15. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on r15. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Saso (Intel) Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Lars. Lars (Sony) replies to Guilluame. Alessio(nokia) provides r16 Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Lars (Sony). Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok with r16 Lars (Sony) replies to Guillaume. Saso (Intel) provides r17 Steve (Huawei) provides r18 Curt (Charter) asks a question w.r.t BUSY_IND (Q6) Xiaowan (vivo) objects to r21, because it not only remove issues but also make the issue blur and reject the refinement for clarifying the existing issue. Lalith (Samsung) supports 21. Lars (Sony) comments and provide 21. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r20 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r19 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r22 based on r20. Lars (Sony) provides r23 Saso (Intel) provides r24 and questions to Huawei Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments Lalith (Samsung) provides r25 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r26 Alessio(Nokia) provides rev28 Saso (Intel) asks Alessio (Nokia) to track the document changes Xiaowan(vivo) provides r30 Lalith(Samsung) provides rev31 Steve (Huawei) provides r32 Lars (Sony) objects to r32 Lars (Sony) objects to r30 Steve (Huawei) does not understand the reason for objection Lars (Sony) reply to steve Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Steve (Huawei) Xiaowan replies to Lars (Sony) Steve (Huawei) provides r33 Lars (Sony) propose r33 Alessio (nokia) responds the changes have been mostly accepted and cut and past from R27 from Guillaume. So please just read what is in R28 (if you want accept all changes) Alessio(Nokia) can live with R32 Lars (Sony) propose r34 Xiaowan(vivo) object to r31 & r32 Lalith(Samsung) responds to Xiaowan(vivo) Alessio (nokia) can live with r34 Xiaowan (vivo) provide r35 Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with r34, objects to r35 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) agrees with r34. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides clarification Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Qian Chen (Ericsson) Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Guillaume Guillaume provides r37 Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Saso (Intel) Saso (Intel) reply to Xiaowan; proposes r36 Guillaume replies to Xiaowan Xiaowan reply to Saso (Intel) Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek) Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on Xiaowan' objection to r34 Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Xiaowan (vivo) Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Lalith(Samsung) Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek); and only accept r35/r30 and object to the original version and all the other revisions Saso (Intel) finds r34 in pretty good shape. Xiaowan(vivo) object to r36, r37; replies to Qian Chen (Ericsson); and provides compromise r37plus1 Guillaume (MediaTek) recommends to proceed with r36 or r37. Genadi (Lenovo) objects to 'r37plus1' revision and proposes to proceed with r37. Saso (Intel) proposes r38 in DRAFTS folder. Xiaowan(vivo) recommends Guillaume (MediaTek) and all to proceed with r35. Xiaowan (vivo) questions for clarification for r38. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Genadi and gives comments. Steve (Huawei) provides multicoloured comments. r35 is good for a baseline. r36/r37 discuss aspects which are not clear and need work. Lars (Sony) comments on r35 and r37. We can live with either of the two revisions. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Saso (Intel) can live with r35; also replies to Xiaowan (vivo). Qian Chen (Ericsson) can live with either r35 or r37. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to xiaowan (vivo) Xiaowan(vivo) replies Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Genadi (Lenovo) answers comments from Xiaowan(vivo) and Steve (Huawei). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) can not agree with r35, can only accept r37. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) replies comments to vivo (xiaowan) Yang (OPPO) prefer r35 to be approved Steve (Huawei) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Steve (Huawei) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) can live with r39 (with a minor edit @CC4) Xiaowan (vivo) uploads r40 and flags it for CC#4. Saso (Intel) uploads r39 and flags it for CC#4. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with either Saso or xiaowan's compromise. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Saso (Intel) and give a compromise. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with Saso's new proposal. Saso (Intel) discusses a way forward. Chris (Vodafone) comments that (while not perfect) r35 seems OK to approve Shuyi Tian (China Telecom) prefers r35. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006037 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on System support for Multi-USIM devices | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r40 (with some editorial corrections) of S2-2005689, merging S2-2004992. S2-2005016 and S2-2005754. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005695 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on System support for Multi-USIM devices | Intel | Rel-17 | CC#4: r11 (+ editorial fix) agreed. Revised to S2-2006011. | Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Myungjune (LGE) provides r01. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r02. Yang (OPPO) comments and provides r03. Yang (OPPO) provides resend the revision as r04. Since r03 cannot be open Lars (Sony) provides r05. Xiaowan (vivo) provides r06 Saso (Intel) provides r07 Alessio(Nokia) provides r08 Myungjune (LGE) provides r09. Lalith(Samsung) provides r10. Saso (Intel) provides r11. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r11. Lars (Sony) is ok with r11. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r11. Saso (Intel) provides a cleaned up version in DRAFTS folder. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006011 | LS OUT | Approval | LS on System support for Multi-USIM devices | SA WG2 | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r11 (+ editorial fix) of S2-2005695. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005754 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on RAN impact for support Coordinated leaving for Multi-USIM device | China Telecommunications | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006037 | Saso (Intel) proposes this document to be considered MERGED into the baseline document S2-2005689. PInghui (China Telecom) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005689, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=13 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005005 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to clarify. | Sony, Samsung | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised to S2-2006012. | Curt (Charter) requests for clarification. Lars (Sony) Provides clarification. Lars (Sony) provides a response. Curt (Charter) provides a response. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Lars (Sony) responds to Juan and provide r01. Curt (Charter) provides a comment. Lalith (Samsung) provides a comment. Lars (Sony) provides a comment. Ouyang(Huawei) request clarification . Lars (Sony) Answers Ouyang Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lars (Sony). Lars(Nord) replies to Ouyang. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comment. Lars (Sony) provides further comment. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides comments Lalith (Samsung) provides comments Lars (Sony) provides comment. Saso (Intel) comments. Lars (Sony) provides r02. Ouyang(Huawei) has concern on 'The UE will stop monitoring the paging' . Ouyang provides additional comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Lars. Lars (Sony) responds to Guillaume and Ouyang Guillaume (MediaTek) misses f2f discussions. Alessio(nokia) comments that the mechanism for stop paging may reuse the network based filtering findings: the filter may indicate stop all paging. Then the UE in a subsequent Registration can lift or modify the filter. So stop paging can be an instance of network based filtering. R02 by Last seems to clarify that. Lars (Sony) provides r03 Qian Chen (Ericsson) asks one more question. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Lars (Sony) asks one more question. Alessio(Nokia) in the end we will end up with a full RRC connection establishment, a NAS message to CN (SR) and an accept (with release indication to RAN in N2 layer). The accept may include a new GUTI if needed. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) provides comments and disagrees with the first NOTE in r03. Lars (Sony) comments. Lalith (Samsung) comments. Lars (Sony) provides r04 Lars (Sony) provides r05 Alessio(nokia): Asks curt whether integrity protection is not good enough in the 3GPP system. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 Lars (Sony) We are ok with r06 Lars (Sony) reply to Xiaobo, and hope you start acting serious in 3GPP. Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) objects to all version of this contribution ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Xiaobo Yu (Alibaba) reply to Lars, and very surprise about the personal attack without any sound reason Alessio(Nokia) supports Lars (Sony) ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006012 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #3: Update to clarify. | Sony, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005005. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005299 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to resolve EN. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006016 | Myungjune (LGE) answer to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei): ask a question for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) accepts merging this paper into S2-2005697r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005300 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #10: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r12 agreed. Revised to S2-2006013. | Lalith(Samsung) requests for clarification. Myungjune (LGE) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment Myungjune (LGE) responds to Juan (Qualcomm). Ouyang(Huawei) requests clarification. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Ouyang (Huawei). Myungjune (LGE) responds to Ouyang (Huawei) and provides r02. Ouyang(Huawei) asks for clarification again. Alessio(nokia) provides R03 Myungjune (LGE) prefer r02 but can live with r03. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments on r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006013 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #10: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r12 of S2-2005300. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005301 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #12: Update to remove ENs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.10 | S2-2005549 | DISCUSSION | Discussion | KI#1, Discussion on paging cause solution#1. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) proposes to note the discussion paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2005552 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, Sol#11 Update to clarify UE can accept paging when timer expires. | OPPO | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006014. | Lalith(Samsung) requests for clarification. Yang (OPPO) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification Yang (OPPO) replies to Steve (Huawei) Alessio(Nokia) provides R01 Yang (OPPO) provides comments to r01 Alessio(Nokia) provides r02 Lalith(Samsung) provides comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides r03 with an editorial updating Alessio(Nokia) is fine with r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006014 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, Sol#11 Update to clarify UE can accept paging when timer expires. | OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005552. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005671 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify the UE and Network impacts. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006015. | Ouyang (Huawei) comments on the paging causes. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lalith(Samsung) . Lalith(Samsung) replies to Ouyang(Huawei). Saso (Intel) comments and proposes WF. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso and Lalith.. Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) Myungjune (LGE) responds to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith (Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) Alessio(nokia) provides r01 Lalith(Samsung) responds to Alessio(nokia) and Myungjune(LGE) Laltih(Samsung) responds to Myungjune (LGE) and indicates OK with rev01. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment Lalith(Samsung) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Alessio(nokia) responds Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r02. Saso (Intel) comments. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Saso (Intel). Ouyang(Huawei) add FFS on Annex and provide r03. Xiaowan(vivo) comments and provides r04. Lalith(Samsung) provides r05 and Merges Paging cause details in S2-2005697 Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Juan . Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r05. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is ok with r05. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006015 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1: Update to clarify the UE and Network impacts. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005671. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005697 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1 - Solution update to address ENs. | Intel | Rel-17 | r08 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005299 and S2-2004993, to S2-2006016. | Myungjune (LGE) provides comment. Saso (Intel) replies. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel). Saso (Intel) provides r01. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r01. Ouyang(Huawei) add EN's on paging causes and provide r02. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to r02. Saso (Intel) provides r03. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is fine with r03. Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provide r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r05. Lalith(Samsung) supports comments from Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Saso (Intel) comments. Xiaowan(vivo) provide 06 to merge 2004993. Ouyang(Huawei) replies and provides 07 Saso (Intel) provides 08 on top of r07 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r08 and wants to cosign. Saso (Intel) acks adding supporting companies. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) is OK with r08. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006016 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Sol #1 - Solution update to address ENs. | Intel, LG Electronics, vivo, Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r08 of S2-2005697, merging S2-2005299 and S2-2004993. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=6 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005486 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1 KI#3, New Sol for Annex: N3GPP for MUSIM Service Concurrency. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006017. | Lars (Sony) requests for clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) is as confused as Lars (Sony) Lars (Sony) comments Steve (Huawei) comments Steve (Huawei) comments. Steve (Huawei) provides r01 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment Alessio(Nokia) asks the rapporteur how to handle this solution. Saso (Rapporteur) prefers to note the document as it has already been discussed in SA2#139E (S2-2003975). Alessio(nokia) we second the Rapporteur Steve (Huawei) asks for clarifications on what is in scope for this meeting. Nothing technical is being discussed here. Saso (Intel) points to the status report in S2-2004754 presented on the Q3-Q4 work planning conference on July 8th. Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification (again, sorry). Saso (Intel) replies. Proposes r02. Steve (Huawei) is ok with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006017 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1 KI#3, New Sol for Annex: N3GPP for MUSIM Service Concurrency. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005486. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005673 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Informing network two USIMs belongs to same device. | Samsung, NEC, Airtel, InterDigital, Apple | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006018. | Curt (Charter) provides a comment. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Curt (Charter) and Qian Chen (Ericsson) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments Lalith(Samsung) responds to the comments from Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comment. Lalith(Samsung) provides rev03 Saso (Intel) seeks clarifications. Lalith (Samsung) responds to Saso (Intel). Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarifications. Saso (Intel) replies to Lalith (Samsung). Lalith (Samsung) provides rev04. Guillaume responds to Lalith (Samsung) Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006018 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Informing network two USIMs belongs to same device. | Samsung, NEC, Airtel, InterDigital, Apple | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005673. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005799 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, New Sol: Using Non-3GPP access to deliver NAS Notification message. | Apple, Samsung, Interdigital, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of (noted) S2-2003651 from S2#139E. r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006019. | Qian Chen (Ericsson) asks for clarification. Lalith(Samsung) responds to Qian Chen (Ericsson). Alessio(nokia) proposes to not this document Lalith resonds to Alessio(nokia) Saso (Intel) thinks this paper should be noted. Curt (Charter) provides an opinion. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Saso (Intel) and provides r01. Krisztian (Apple) responds to Alessio (Nokia). Krisztian (Apple) responds to Qian (Ericsson). Saso (Intel) provides r02. Krisztian (Apple) is OK with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006019 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, KI#3, New Sol: Using Non-3GPP access to deliver NAS Notification message. | Apple, Samsung, Interdigital, NEC | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005799. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#1 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=15 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2004989 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1: RAN assistance analysis and interim evaluation/conclusion. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-2004989 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. Alessio(nokia) comments: Alessio(Nokia) comments. Saso (Intel) invites Alessio (Nokia) to comment on the baseline document (5487). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2004993 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, Sol#1: update the handling of paging cause. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006016 | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment Lalith (Samung) provides comment Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Lalith Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Juan Lalith(Samsung) replies to Xiaowan (vivo) Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Lalith Lalith(Samsung) proposes r01. Alessio(nokia) the remark by Samsung needs to be considered. Shall we in SA2 assume all the RAN in the PLMN supports paging cause? Or do we want to enable non homogeneous support in the RAN? Provides r02 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comment. Guillaume (MediaTek) agree with Juan (Qualcomm) Alessio(nokia) well at least the network has to know the UE is actively using the paging cause. Then, the UE has to know the network is actively using the paging code. Then if non uniform support in PLMN is possible, the UE should know if the paging cause is supported in the RA... this non uniform vs uniform support needs to be resolved before we can go normative and decide the solution viability. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Alessio (Nokia). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek). Add EN's on the paging cause. Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Ouyang (Huawei) Xiaowan(vivo) replies to All and provides r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Lalith (Samsung) provides comment. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Xiaowan (vivo). Yang (OPPO) supports the solution provided by Xiaowan (vivo). Saso (Intel) comments and proposes to consider merging into 5697. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Guillaume (MediaTek) to clarify the misunderstanding. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) and provides r05. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Saso (Intel) and Lalith (Samsung) Myungjune (LGE) proposes to merge this pCR into S2-2005697. Xiaowan(vivo) confirms that this pCR is merged into S2-2005697. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005006 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Evaluation of Solution #3. | Sony, Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Lars (Sony) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005487 and S2-2005685, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005007 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Interim Conclusion of Solution #3. | Sony, Samsung | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Lars (Sony) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005685, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2005014 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Evaluation and Conclusion for Key issue #1: Handling of Mobile Terminated service with Multi-USIM device. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-S2-2005014 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005487 and S2-2005685, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005104 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: FS_MUSIM: KI #1, Sol #13: Evaluation and conclusion. | Google, vivo Mobile Communications Ltd | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-2005104 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005135 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, Evaluation and way forward for avoiding undesirable operations. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005487 and S2-2005685. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005136 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1, Evaluation and way forward for avoiding unnecessary interruptions of service in the current system. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005487 and S2-2005685. Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-2005136 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005302 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Evaluation and conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-2005302 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005487 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1 Interim Evaluations. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: r18 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2004989, S2-2005006, S2-2005014, S2-200510,4 S2-2005135, S2-2005136, S2-2005302, and S2-2005682, in S2-2006038 | Steve (Huawei) provides r01. Lars (Sony) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r03 and comments on r02. Steve (Huawei) comments. Lars (Sony) provides r04 Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification Lars (Sony) responds to Guillaume and provides r05 Alessio(nokia) provides r06 Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments to Sol#2 and r07. Pavan (Google) provides r08. Myungjune (LGE) provides r09. Lars (Sony) provides r10. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r11. Saso (Intel) provides r12. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio. Pavan (Google) provides comments on r12. Saso (Intel) replies to Pavan (Google). Myungjune (LGE) provides r14. Steve (Huawei) provides r13 Saso (Intel) provides r15. Pavan (Google) comments on r15. Pavan (Google) agrees with r16 Saso (Intel) replies to Pavan (Google). Provides r16. Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r16. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r16. Lars (Sony) is ok with r16. Alessio (Nokia) is ok with any revision between R06 and R11. Saso (Intel) proposes r17 in DRAFTS folder. Saso (Intel) is OK with r18 in DRAFTS folder for CC#4. Alessio(Nokia) proposes r18 in DRAFTS folder for CC#4. Saso (Intel) proposes r18 in DRAFTS folder for CC#4. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006038 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1 Interim Evaluations. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r18 of S2-2005487, merging S2-2004989, S2-2005006, S2-2005014, S2-200510,4 S2-2005135, S2-2005136, S2-2005302, and S2-2005682. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005490 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#1: Conclusion on Key Issue #1. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Postponed in parallel session | Saso (Intel) proposes this document to be merged in the baseline 2005685. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2005682 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006038 | Lalith (Samsung) indicates fine to Merge this tdoc into 5487, 5685, which is used as a baseline to discuss KI#1 evaluation and conclusion. Steve (Huawei) it is proposed that S2-2005682 is merged into S2-2005487, as per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005685 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #1, Proposed way forward. | Intel | Rel-17 | CC#4: r19 still received objections from Nokia and Huawei. This was postponed. | Saso (Intel) provides r01. Lars (Sony) provides r02. Myungjune (LGE) ask a question for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies and provided r03. Guillaume (MediaTek) asks for clarification. Saso (Intel) replies and provided r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Saso (Intel) replies to Juan. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r05. Saso (Intel) OK with r05. Yang Xu (OPPO) comments to r05. Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provides r06. Lars(Sony) comments r06 and ask for clarification. Alessio(Nokia) provides r07. Saso (Intel) comments on r06. Pavan (Google) asks for a clarification. Saso (Intel) cannot accept the changes in r07. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Lars and Saso. Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang (Huawei). Xiaowan(vivo) provides r08. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso (Intel). Saso (Intel) provides r09. Alessio(Nokia) Objects to rev 09 as we disagree the paging filtering is not suitable for KI#3. Also it is not acceptable to remove the Editor's note on Sol#1. Lars (Sony) provides r10 Alessio(Nokia) provides r11 Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) can agree either r09 or r10 and reject r11. Alessio(Nokia) comments that an agreement on a interim conclusion looks unfeasible after the comments by qualcomm Saso (Intel) is ok with r10; objects to r11; provides r12. Nokia objects to rel-12 Guillaume (MediaTek) is ok with r10 and r12, objects r11. Curt (Charter) is ok with r10 and r12, objects r11. Myungjune (LGE) provides r13. Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r12 or r10, objects r11. Alessio(Nokia) provides R14 Saso (Intel) objects r14; provides r15 Yang (OPPO) asks a question for clarification Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provide r16 . Alessio(Nokia) objects to rev 15 and anything different from R14. Ouyang(Huawei) provide r18 based on r14. 1) Huawei will object any version consider paging cause for voice is agreed in this meeting. 2) Ouyang (Huawei) request Alessio(Nokia) for clarification. Saso (Intel) objects to r18; provides r19; proposes to raise r19 for show-of-hands in CC#4. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio(Nokia). Guillaume (MediaTek) supports the view from the Rapporteur. Alessio(Nokia) objects to anything but r14 Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments Saso (Intel) replies to Ouyang(Huawei); points to S2-2003635r10, provided in SA2#139E by Ouyang, that deletes all Paging Cause values except 'voice'. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Saso(Intel). Saso (Intel) proposes to flag r19 for show-of-hands on CC#4. Alessio(Nokia) reminds he can accept only R14. Or any revision that does not take out the paging filtering as an option for the 'Handling of Mobile Terminated service with Multi-USIM device' ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) asks what is the show of hand on: we have clear rules and I did not see a technical justification on why paging filtering is not handling MT services. We disagree an interim conclusion should be subject to show of hands the first time out of the bat and excluding technically valid solutions when the interim conclusion spells out even the paging cause needs further evaluation and frankly it is still immature. As I said interim conclusion can also not be agreed as w have time till December to conclude and we are not convinced paging cause be considered the only game in town right now. Alessio(Nokia) asks what is the show of hand on: [saso] On S2-2005685r19 as is. we have clear rules and I did not see a technical justification on why paging filtering is not handling MT services. [saso] There is no consensus that paging filtering can be used for KI#1. As you know, there was a proposed conclusion to study paging filtering as part of KI#3, to which you objected. We disagree an interim conclusion should be subject to show of hands the first time out of the bat and excluding technically valid solutions when the interim conclusion spells out even the paging cause needs further evaluation and frankly it is still immature. [saso] r19 does not exclude other solution principles in future. There is an opening EN stating that further conclusions can be made. As you may have noticed, there is currently no interim conclusion on any of the Notification-based solutions either. Honestly I don't understand why you think that paging filtering deserves some special handling. As I said interim conclusion can also not be agreed as w have time till December to conclude [saso] That is fine. I still think a show of hands would be useful so that we see where companies stand. and we are not convinced paging cause be considered the only game in town right now. [saso] Not sure why you say it is 'the only game in town' when the conclusion proposes two other solution principles (Short Absence and Busy indication). [saso] There is no consensus that paging filtering can be used for KI#1. As you know, there was a proposed conclusion to study paging filtering as part of KI#3, to which you objected. Dear Saso: if a solution is agreed to address KI#1 (MT services handling) in the TR table (check it out), and filtering paging is MT services handling, how come paging filtering is now resolving indication a UE is leaving? Any show of hand shall be on the principle that paging filtering resolves MT service handling. It cannot be used to indicate the UE is leaving. This is about being intellectually honest. So we object to any show of hands on adopting any paper till we first record a list of companies that subscribe to the notion that paging filtering resolves indicating the UE is leaving (KI#3) the system and not MT services handling (KI#1). [saso] There is no consensus that paging filtering can be used for KI#1. As you know, there was a proposed conclusion to study paging filtering as part of KI#3, to which you objected. Dear Saso: if a solution is agreed to address KI#1 (MT services handling) in the TR table (check it out), and filtering paging is MT services handling, how come paging filtering is now resolving indication a UE is leaving? [saso] Sol#10 (proposed for KI#1) uses RR or SR to provide 'MUSIM Assistance Information' (MUSIM AI) indicating for which MT service it wishes to be paged. Sol#5 (proposed for KI#3) uses 'MUSIM Release Assistance Information' (MUSIM-RAI) indicating the following in the SR: - PDU sessions, services or both that the UE want network to trigger (or not trigger) MT service delivery indication (the services indicated by the UE is corresponding to the services related to paging causes in solution 1). The UE may also indicate to the network that no MT data shall be delivered at all (e.g. due to specific service in another network and can't answer paging request). - The time period expected by the UE that will be away from this serving network. Obviously, MUSIM-AI and MUSIM-RAI contain the same information. Moreover, they are provided in at least Service Request (for both Sol#5 and Sol#10). The difference is that Sol#5 uses it exclusively within the context of KI#3 (i.e. instructing the network how to handle MT data during coordinated leave), whereas Sol#10 uses it in general i.e. outside of any MUSIM-related situation. I proposed to take the common part in the conclusion; you objected because you wanted paging filtering for the general (not MUSIM related) to be included, for which there is no consensus. Any show of hand shall be on the principle that paging filtering resolves MT service handling. It cannot be used to indicate the UE is leaving. [saso] Please see above. Sol#5 indicates how paging should be filtered during coordinated leave. This is about being intellectually honest. [saso] I beg your pardon? So we object to any show of hands on adopting any paper till we first record a list of companies that subscribe to the notion that paging filtering resolves indicating the UE is leaving (KI#3) the system and not MT services handling (KI#1). [saso] I just explained above. ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.10 | S2-2005504 | DISCUSSION | Approval | FS_MUSIM: Way Forward | MediaTek Inc. | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Guillaume (MediaTek) proposes S2-2005504 be merged into revisions of: 5487+5685, 5137, 4991+5158. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005008 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Sol #15: Update to clarify no RAN impact. | Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless, NEC | Rel-17 | Approved | Steve (Huawei) asks for clarification on which RATs will no longer be impacted Lars (Sony) responds to Steve ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.10 | S2-2005133 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, Sol#16, Updates covering 5GS. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#2 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005043 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2,3: new solution: notification via UDM to secondary registration in other USIM PLMN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) ask questions. Steve (Huawei) asks questions too Alessio (Nokia) responds questions Steve (Huawei) comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) comments. Saso (Intel) comments and proposes to NOTE the document. Alessio(Nokia) the only impact is a normal roaming agreement. Alessio(Nokia) provides R01 Saso (Intel) seeks further clarification. Alessio(Nokia) responds to Saso Saso (Intel) seeks clarification on non-roaming scenarios. Alessio(Nokia) comments Saso (Intel) objects to this pCR and all revisions. Alessio(Nokia) disagrees on the interpretation by intel Saso (Intel) reiterates objection to this pCR. Alessio (nokia) provides a response to qian ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2005044 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, KI#3: new solution: notification via other USIM UDM. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) ask questions. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose to NOTE the paper. Alessio(Nokia) responds Saso (Intel) supports Qian Chen (Ericsson) and proposes to NOTE the paper for the same reasons as for S2-2005043 (i.e. coordination requirement between operators). Saso (Intel) objects to S2-2005044. Saso (Intel) replies to Alessio (Nokia) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Alessio(Nokia) rejects the objection and wants still discussion of this on CC#4 ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2005183 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, New Sol: MT service delivery when multiple USIMs are registered in the same serving PLMN. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006020. | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments. Saso (Intel) comments and seeks clarification. Genadi (Lenovo) responds to comments from Saso (Intel), Qian Chen (Ericsson) and Juan Zhang (Qualcomm). Revision r01 is provided. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006020 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, New Sol: MT service delivery when multiple USIMs are registered in the same serving PLMN. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005183. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#2 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=9 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2004990 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2: RAN assistance analysis and interim evaluation/conclusion. | vivo | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Alessio(Nokia) comments that this paper wrongly reports solution 15 does not work for EPS as there are EUTRA impacts. This is false. Saso (Intel) invites Alessio (Nokia) to comment on the baseline document (5137). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005009 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Evaluation of paging avoidance solutions. | Sony, Convida Wireless, NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Lars (Sony) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005010 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Interim Conclusion. | Sony, Nokia, Convida Wireless, NEC | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Lars (Sony) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005015 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Evaluation and Conclusion for Key issue #2: Enabling Paging Reception for Multi-USIM Device. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Alessio(Nokia) ask questions. Saso (Intel) replies. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005137 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, Evaluation and way forward proposal. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r09 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005686, S2-2005488, S2-2005303, S2-2005015, S2-2005010, S2-2005009, S2-2004990 and S2-2005504 to S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Lars (Sony) provides r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) says the update in r02 is ok. Myungjune (LGE) provides r03. Lars (Sony) ask for clarification Myungjune (LGE) responds to Lars (Sony) and provides r04. Saso (Intel) prefers r02 for future updates. Myungjune (LGE) responds to Saso (Intel). Myungjune (LGE) provides r05. Steve (Huawei) provides r06 Lars (Sony) comments on r06 Lars (Sony) we object to r06 Saso (Intel) proposes r07. Lars (Sony) proposes r08. Steve (Huawei) provides r09 Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with r09 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r09. Lars (Sony) is ok with r09. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006021 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, Evaluation and way forward proposal . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r09 of S2-2005137, merging S2-2005686, S2-2005488, S2-2005303, S2-2005015, S2-2005010, S2-2005009, S2-2004990 and S2-2005504. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005303 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Evaluation and conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005488 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2 Interim Evaluations. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005686 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #2, Proposed way forward. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006021 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revision of S2-2005137, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Solution Update | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2004994 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Sol#22: update to clarify the timer handling. | Vivo, China Telecom | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006022. | Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment Xiaowan ke (vivo) replies to Juan Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides further comments. Xiaowan (vivo) provided r01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006022 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Sol#22: update to clarify the timer handling. | Vivo, China Telecom | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2004994. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005134 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Sol#5, Update to remove ENs. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Noted | Xiaowan (vivo) provides comments. Alessio(Nokia) also believes that this is a needless effort. We can note this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | S2-2005832 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Sol#5: Update to clarify the timer handling. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comment and question. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Qian Chen. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comment. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Genadi (Lenovo) provides comments and propose to NOTE the paper. Xiaowan (vivo) provides replies to all. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#3 - New Solutions | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005018 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: New solution: Notification on user plane of a master PLMN. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Approved | Steve (Huawei) asks a question Alessio (nokia) responds ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.10 | S2-2005023 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, KI#2: new solution on providing additional info of UE availability. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006023. | Qian Chen (Ericsson) ask for clarification. Steve (Huawei) comments Alessio(nokia) responds Saso (Intel) comments. Qian Chen (Ericsson) comments Alessio(Nokia) provides feedback Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides further comments Saso (Intel) is OK with r01. Alessio(Nokia) provides R01 as update of solution 17 as requested Saso (Intel) proposes to NOTE this pCR. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006023 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, KI#2: new solution on providing additional info of UE availability. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005023. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | - | - | - | KI#3 - Evaluation and Conclusion | - | - | Docs:=11 | - | |
| 8.10 | S2-2004991 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Interim evaluation and conclusions. | vivo | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005751, to S2-2006024. | Xiaowan(vivo) provides r01 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01 and comments Steve (Huawei) provides r03 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r04 Saso (Intel) provides r05 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r06 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r06. Qian Chen (Ericsson) can live with r06 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006024 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3: Interim evaluation and conclusions. | vivo | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2004991., merging S2-2005751. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005017 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Evaluation and Conclusion for Key issue #3: Coordinated leaving for Multi-USIM device. | Qualcomm Incorporated | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005138 and S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2004991 and S2-2005138, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005138 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Evaluation and way forward proposal. | Ericsson | Rel-17 | r22 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005282, S2-2005687, S2-2005680, S2-2005489, S2-2005304, and S2-2005017, to S2-2006 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r01. Saso (Intel) seeks clarification. Lars (Sony) ask question and provide r02. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comments and provides r03. Saso (Intel) provides r04. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides r05. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r06. Xiaowan(vivo) provides r08. Myungjune (LGE) provides r07. Lalith(Samsung) provides comments on r08. Xiaowan(vivo) replies to Lalith. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments on r08. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides comment. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r09. Myungjune (LGE) provides comments. Xiaowan (vivo) replies to Myungjune. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) provides comments to r08 Xiaowan (vivo) provides r10 based on r8. Ouyang(Huawei) prefers AS level solution on NR/5GS access . Lalith (Samsung) provides comments. Genadi (Lenovo) provides r11. Guillaume (MediaTek) provides comments. Yang Xu (OPPO) provides comments Saso (Intel) provides provides r12. Alessio (Nokia) provides R-13 Curt (Charter) provides R-14 Saso (Intel) provides r15. Alessio (Nokia) provides r16 Ouyang(Huawei) comments and provide R17. Juan Zhang (Qualcomm) objects to remove the acknowledgement procedure. Qian Chen (Ericsson) provide comments and r018. Krisztian (Apple) provides r19. Alessio(Nokia) provides r20 Qian Chen (Ericsson) provides r21 Guillaume (MediaTek) provides r22 Alessio(Nokia) objects to R21 Alessio(Nokia) can live with R22 Qian Chen (Ericsson) is ok with R22 Myungjune (LGE) is ok with r22. Lars (Sony) is ok with r22. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.10 | S2-2006025 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3, Evaluation and way forward proposal . | Ericsson | Rel-17 | Revision r22 of S2-2005138, merging S2-2005282, S2-2005687, S2-2005680, S2-2005489, S2-2005304, and S2-2005017. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.10 | S2-2005282 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Interim conclusion proposal. | Charter Communications, Comcast, CableLabs | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Curt (Charter) proposes this document to be considered MERGED into the future version of document S2-2005138. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005304 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Evaluation and conclusion. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005138 and S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005489 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#3 Interim Evaluations. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005138 and S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005680 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Evaluation and Interim conclusion. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Lalith (Samsung) indicates fine to Merge this tdoc into 4991, 5138, which is used as a baseline to discuss KI#3 evaluation and conclusion. Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005138 and S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005687 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI #3, Proposed way forward. | Intel | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006025 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2005138 and S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.10 | S2-2005751 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: Discussion and Comparison of solution to KI#3 for MUSIM. | China Telecom | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006024 | Qian Chen (Ericsson) propose this paper to be merged into the revisions of S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. Pinghui (China Telecom) proposes this document to be considered MERGED into the baseline document S2-2004991, per the discussion from the rapporteur. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.11 | - | - | - | Architecture aspects for using satellite access in 5G (5GSAT_ARCH) | - | - | Docs:=20 | - | |
| 8.11 | S2-2004839 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Selection of CN node by NG-RAN node providing satellite access across multiple countries | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Postponed | DongYeon (Samsung) comments and asks one clarifying question. Stephen (Qualcomm) objects to the CR for multiple reasons Hannu (Nokia) is not sure how to handle the comment from Stephen (Qualcomm) but provides a revision anyway Stephen (Qualcomm) clarifies objection to R00 and R01 Chris (Vodafone) believes that Qualcomm has not understood the problem. Stephen (Qualcomm) acknowledges a new problem but suggests it is not resolved by the CR Fei (OPPO) asks for clarification . Chris (Vodafone) answers OPPO's question. Hannu (Nokia) asks a followup question Chris (Vodafone) responds to Qualcomm. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Chris (Vodafone) answers. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and proposes to postpone CR Hannu (Nokia) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2004840 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Intra NG-RAN handover via CN for NR satellite access | Vodafone | Rel-17 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) objects to R00 and R01 Chris (Vodafone) believes that Qualcomm has not understood the problem. Please see the discussion on S2-2004839. Hannu (Nokia) asks a question from Stephen (Qualcomm) Stephen (Qualcomm) answers question from Hannu Chris (Vodafone) prefers r0 to r1 (as r1 is really not correct). Hannu (Nokia) still believes r01 is more correct but can also live with the initial version expecting that multi-national CN is solved later. Stephen (Qualcomm) reaffirms objection to R00 and R01 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005052 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Addition of new values to RAT type IE | TNO, THALES | Rel-16 | Noted | Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 and proposes just one place for AMF RAT Type detection. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r02 Hannu (Nokia) supports r02 from Stefan (Ericsson) Fei (OPPO) provides r03. Dong (Xiaomi) provides r04 by merging S2-2005191. Jean Yves (Thales) comments r04 after merging S2-2005191. Hannu (Nokia) supports r04 and proposes to refer to new clause 5.4.X for AMF detection of NR satellite access. Relja (TNO) performed minor (editorial) changes. Hannu (Nokia) agrees r05. Hucheng(CATT) comments and provides r06. Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r06 Hucheng (CATT) replies to Qualcomm Haris (Qualcomm) comments that r06 without sentence: For NR satellite access, the AMF determines the corresponding Core Network RAT Type Is acceptable Hannu (Nokia) comments. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Haris. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005054 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Impact of NR(LEO), NR(MEO, NR(GEO) and NR(OTHERSAT) on 5GS procedures | TNO, THALES | Rel-16 | r07 agreed. Revised to S2-2006590 | DongYeon (Samsung) provides comments and one clarifying question. Stephen (Qualcomm ) provides comments Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) sustains part of our previous comment for the R01 Yi (China Mobile) provides comments on r01. Hannu (Nokia) proposes to isolate the problem to single CR and using references to progress the other CRs. Hannu (Nokia) replies to Yi (China Mobile) and provides r03. Relja (TNO) replies to Yi (China Mobile), Hannu (Nokia) and provides r04. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r05 Hannu (Nokia) prefers r04 over r05 that removes the NR satellite access RAT Type from UE context in AMF Stefan (Ericsson) replies to Hannu Hannu (Nokia) accepts the explanation from Stefan and can agree r05.. Haris (Qualcomm) provides r07, objects to all version using RAT type for 5QI determination Chris (Vodafone) provides r06. R05 wrongly bans other RAT types from influencing 5QI selection. Chris (Vodafone) is OK with r07 as a draft CR (but not as a CR) Haris (Qualcomm) comments on r07 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2006590 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Impact of NR(LEO), NR(MEO, NR(GEO) and NR(OTHERSAT) on 5GS procedures | TNO, THALES | Rel-16 | Revision r07 of S2-2005054. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2005055 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Procedures of utilizing backhaul related information during the PDU session establishment procedure | TNO | Rel-16 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Yi (China Mobile) provides comments and provides r01. Hannu (Nokia) comments. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Hucheng(CATT) provides a general comment Hannu (Nokia) agrees with Hucheng. Relja (TNO) created new revision (r2), answers to Hucheng(CATT), Stefan(Ericsson) and Hannu(Nokia). Relja asks a question. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r02 and disagrees with the creation of satellite specific PDU session modification procedure in TS 23.502 Relja (TNO) accepts Haris' (Qualcomm) objections to r02. In line with Stefan (Ericsson) comments any satellite specific PDU session modification procedure, if needed, could be specified in TS 23.501 (clause 5.X: Support for integrating satellite access into 5GS ) and TS 23.503. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005063 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Procedures of utilizing backhaul information during the PDU session modification procedure | TNO | Rel-16 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Stefan (Ericsson) comments Hannu (Nokia) comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005190 | DRAFTCR | Approval | General description for NR based on satellite constellations | XiaoMi | Rel-17 | r05 agreed. Revised to S2-2006591 | DongYeon (Samsung) provides one comment and one question. Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments aimed at revising the CR Hannu (Nokia) responds to Stephen's (Qualcomm) comment 3 Hannu (Nokia) provides r01. Stephen (Qualcomm) repeats previous comments which apply to the R01 Dong (Xiaomi) answers questions and provide comments and r02. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Stephen (Qualcomm) answers questions from Dong and Stefan Dong (Xiaomi) asks a question. DongYeon (Samsung) asks a question on r02. Stefan (Ericsson) comments and provides r03 Jean Yves (Thales) comments Stephen (Qualcomm) answers question from DongYeon Dong (Xiaomi) answers questions and provides r04. Jean Yves (Thales) requests clarifications Stephen (Qualcomm) can accept R03, R04 or R05 (preferred) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2006591 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Access restrictions for NR RAT for Satellite Access | XiaoMi | Rel-17 | Revision r05 of S2-2005190. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2005191 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Access restrictions for NR RAT for Satellite Access | XiaoMi | Rel-17 | Noted in parallel session | DongYeon (Samsung) suggests to merge texts of S2-2005191 into S2-2005052. Dong (Xiaomi) agrees to merge texts of S2-2005191 into S2-2005052. Jean Yves (Thales) agrees also to merge texts of S2-2005191 into S2-2005052. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005228 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Support of new RATs in 5GS integrating satellite access | CATT | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006592 | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Hannu (Nokia) provides r01 and proposes to use this document as the template for high level functionality for NR satellite access Yi (China Mobile) provides comment. Hannu (Nokia) supports the comment from Yi (China Mobile) on the wrong WI and Release on the cover page. Hucheng(CATT) responds to all comments and provides r02. Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions and comments Hannu (Nokia) agrees with comment from Stefan (Ericsson) and provides r03. Stefan (Ericsson) provides r04 and comments Stephen (Qualcomm) supports R04 Hannu (Nokia) joins the supporters of r04. Jean Yves (Thales) agrees on r04. Hucheng(CATT) is fine with r04. Hannu (Nokia) proposes a compromise. Hucheng(CATT) points out that r04 is as expected by Hannu and already supported by Nokia. Jean Yves (Thales) supports r04 also ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.11 | S2-2006592 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Support of new RATs in 5GS integrating satellite access | CATT, Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005228. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.11 | S2-2005229 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Support of using satellite to provide backhaul connection | CATT | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments DongYeon (Samsung) provides comments Hucheng (CATT) replies to Qualcomm and SAMSUNG DongYeon (Samsung) provides comments. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Jean Yves (Thales) comment and propose to start thinking to an LS to RAN3 Hucheng(CATT) provides calrifications. Stephen (Qualcomm) supports postponement Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to postpone ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2005230 | DRAFTCR | Approval | QoS control based on the backhaul information | CATT | Rel-17 | Postponed | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments DongYeon (Samsung) provides comments Stefan (Ericsson) comments and asks questions Hucheng (CATT) responds to all comments Stefan (Ericsson) replies Hucheng (CATT) provides further clarifications. Stephen (Qualcomm) supports postponement Stefan (Ericsson) also proposes to postpone ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Postponed |
| 8.11 | S2-2005336 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Descriptions for satellite backhaul connected UPF selection | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Stefan (Ericsson) provides comments and agrees with Stephen DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Stephen (Qualcomm) for clarifications. Stefan (Ericsson) replies to DongYeon Relja (TNO) asks DongYeon (Samsung) for clarification. DongYeon (Samsung) replies all comments from Relja and Stefan and provides r01. DongYeon (Samsung) provides r02, with updated cover sheet. DongYeon (Samsung) provides r03 ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005338 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Procedures for satellite backhaul connected UPF selection | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments Stefan (Ericsson) comments DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Stephen (Qualcomm) for clarifications. DongYeon (Samsung) replies all comments in the S2-2005336 thread, and providing r01. DongYeon (Samsung) provides r02, with updated cover sheet. DongYeon (Samsung) provides r03 Stefan (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this draft CR. Further discussion is needed. Haris (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions of this draft CR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005476 | DRAFTCR | Approval | N4 Node Level procedures for satellite backhaul connection | Samsung | Rel-17 | Noted | Stephen (Qualcomm) provides comments DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stephen (Qualcomm) Stefan (Ericsson) comments DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Stefan (Ericsson) and Stephen (Qualcomm). Stefan (Ericsson) replies to DongYeon and still has concerns with this proposal Haris (Qualcomm) object to the approval of the draft CR DongYeon (Samsung) replies to Haris and Stefan while providing r01. Hucheng(CATT) clarifies to Ericsson's comments. DongYeon (Samsung) provides r02. Stefan (Ericsson) objects to all revisions of this CR Haris (Qualcomm) objects to all revisions of this CR ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005494 | DRAFTCR | Approval | Introduction of 5GSAT_ARCH solution #13 to NAS procedure | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Noted | DongYeon (Samsung) provides comments for clarification. Hannu (Nokia) replies to DongYeon (Samsung). Stephen (Qualcomm) objects to R00 Hannu (Nokia) responds to Stephen (Qualcomm) Jean Yves (Thales) make comments and ask a question Stephen (Qualcomm) adds to earlier comments DongYeon (Samsung) comments on previous reply from Hannu (Nokia). Hannu (Nokia) replies to DongYeon (Samsung), Stephen (Qualcomm) and Jean-Yves (Thales). DongYeon (Samsung) comments and have similar view with Stephen (Qualcomm). Fei (OPPO) comments. DongYeon (Samsung) repeats the comment which mistakenly dropped out of the thread. Jean Yves (Thales) provides rev1 Hannu (Nokia) proposes r02. Jean Yves (Thales) agrees on rev2 Stefan (Ericsson) asks questions Stephen (Qualcomm) proposes to postpone the CR Hucheng(CATT) asks a question. Jean Yves (Thales) provides rev3. Stefan (Ericsson) comments Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Stefan and proposes to approve (as draft CR) Hannu (Nokia) thanks Jean-Yves for revision and support. Nokia agrees r03. Hannu (Nokia) answers to Hucheng. Haris (Qualcomm) asks a question and wonders how this solution overall works with the latest RAN2/3 assumptions that assume also earth moving cells (CGI) Chris (Vodafone) says that this draft CR does not solve the LI problem. Stephen (Qualcomm) objects to all versions DongYeon (Samsung) objects to all versions of this paper. Hannu (Nokia) asks if Samsung and Qualcomm see the need to support regulatory requirements? Hannu (Nokia) replies to Chris (Vodafone) that just like Vodafone CR, it's based on the principle of forcing the UE to register in the right country. Jean Yves (Thales) responds to Stephen objections Hannu (Nokia) supports the comment from Jean Yves (Thales) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.11 | S2-2005656 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on new NR RAT types for SAT coding | THALES | WITHDRAWN | Jean Yves (Thales) propose to withdrawn this LS out to CT4 as CT4 chairman confirmed that stage 2 is mandatory first, even in this case. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Withdrawn | |
| 8.11 | S2-2005759 | DRAFTCR | Approval | NAS timer for GEO | OPPO | Rel-17 | Noted | DongYeon (Samsung) asks a question. Fei (OPPO) replys to DongYeon(Samsung). Stefan (Ericsson) comments Hannu (Nokia) comments and provides r01 Jean Yves (Thales) agrees that we need a placeholder for the NAS timer text Stephen (Qualcomm) comments on R00 and R01 Dong (Xiaomi) agrees that SA2 describes the general description and CT1 defines the exact value for the NAS timer. Fei (OPPO) provides responses and r02. Hannu (Nokia) can live with r02 from Fei (OPPO) Haris (Qualcomm) objects to r02 and all the previous revisions Stefan (Ericsson) agrees with Haris Fei (OPPO) provides clarification. DongYeon (Samsung) suggest postponement on this paper. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Study on architecture enhancements for 3GPP support of advanced V2X services - Phase 2 (FS_eV2XARC_Ph2) | - | - | Docs:=32 | - | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | Definitions, Architectural Assumptions & Requirements | - | - | Docs:=4 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005194 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Add Pedestrian UE Definition. | ZTE, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006593 | Ouyang(Huawei) asks a question. Adrian (vivo) responds. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments and objects r01. Adrian (vivo) provides r01 LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept r01. Lei (Tencent) provide comments and prefer original version. Guillaume (MediaTek) suggests to note the CR. Hao Dong (ZTE) resoponds to Guillaume. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Guillaume (MediaTek) responds to Hao (ZTE) Adrian (vivo) is nice and good and is happy with r02. Changhong (Intel) prefers to have a definition for P-UE, but can also live with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006593 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Add Pedestrian UE Definition. | ZTE, LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005194. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005024 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Architectural Assumptions. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.12 | S2-2005025 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Architectural Requirements. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | KI#1 updates | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005285 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1: Update to KI#1 to Clarify Power Saving Scenarios. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Adrian (vivo) propose to merge into S2-2005805 Lei(Tencent) respond to Adrian(vivo) and provide comments. LaeYoung (LGE) does not think that the proposed changes are needed, so proposes to NOTE this paper. Lei (Tencent) provide comments. The added texts are not restricted to application layer solution. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Lei(Tencent) provides comments. Shabnam (Ericsson) I fail to see how the updates relate to power saving or other 3GPP related aspects, seems more application layer. Agree we should note the document. LaeYoung (LGE) confirms that this paper can be NOTED. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005402 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Update the KI#1 on DRX and Configuration issues. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006594 | Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision 01. Adrian (vivo) propose to merge into S2-2005805 LaeYoung (LGE) does not think that the proposed changes are needed. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung, Adrian and Apostolos. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r02. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03. Ouyang(Huawei) provide r04 along the suggestion from LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r04. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for clarification in comments. Ouyang(Huawei) request LaeYoung(LGE) for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Ouyang(Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Shabnam and LaeYoung(LGE). R05 is provided. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r05. Ouyang(Huawei) clarifies to LaeYoung(LGE) . Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer. Ouyang(Huawei) corrects the question for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) is wondering what needs to be clarified. :) Ouyang(Huawei) requests for clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) can accept ONLY r03 and all other versions including r00 are NOT acceptable. LaeYoung (LGE) is still wondering what needs to be clarified, anyway provides answer. :) Chair (Tao) ask to check whether r03 agreeable? LaeYoung (LGE) confirms only r03 is agreeable. Ouyang(Huawei) requests LaeYoung to clarify her question. Ouyang(Huawei) has to live with r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) can accept with r03. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006594 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Update the KI#1 on DRX and Configuration issues. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005402. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | New KI proposals | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005403 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: New KI: Power efficient transmission. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies. Shabnam (Ericsson) has concerns with the wording of this pCR and adding new key issue when no more new solns are allowed next meeting, asks questions. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with LaeYoung (LGE). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005805 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: New KI - Turning V2X communications on and off. | vivo Communication Technology | Rel-17 | Noted | Apostolos (Nokia) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hong(QC) . Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Lei(Tencent) provide comments and respond to Apostolos (Nokia) . Adrian (vivo) responds. LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept this and proposes to NOTE this paper. Dimitris (Lenovo) supports having a separate Key Issue Adrian(vivo) provide comments. Ouyang(Huawei) provide r01 and ask Adrain(vivo) for clarification . Lei(Tencent) is fine with the way to further revise 5805 as extending KI#1 is not 'feasible'. LaeYoung (LGE) does not accept all versions of this paper. Shabnam (Ericsson) in addition to same comment on new key issue as for S2-2005403, asks additional questions and do not agree to the issue. Guillaume (MediaTek) agrees with Shabnam (Ericsson). This should be noted. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | KI#1 – Solution updates | - | - | Docs:=3 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005033 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#1: Adding Idle DRX aspect. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006595 | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification on the new addition of in RRC_IDLE state or RRC_INACTIVE state. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Hoyeon (Samsung) express concerns about alignment between Uu DRX and PC5 DRX. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answer and r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006595 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#1: Adding Idle DRX aspect. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005033. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005197 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, Sol#1: Update Procedure for New Application DRX Schedule. | ZTE | Rel-17 | Approved | Shabnam (Ericsson) asks clarification on the number of DRX schedule in the UE. Hao Dong (ZTE) answers question from Ericsson. Apostolos (Nokia) asks for clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) replies Apostolos (Nokia). Apostolos (Nokia) asks for further clarification. Hao Dong (ZTE) responds to Apostolos (Nokia). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | KI#1 – New solutions | - | - | Docs:=18 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005032 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: QoS support for V2X messages sent by pedestrian UEs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | r03 agreed. Revised to S2-2006596 | Apostolos (Nokia) comments. Adrian (vivo) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01 and answers. Apostolos (Nokia) agrees with r01. Shabnam (Ericsson) provides r02, clarifying that implementation of cluster is outside of 3GPP work. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r03 for editorial. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006596 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: QoS support for V2X messages sent by pedestrian UEs. | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision r03 of S2-2005032. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005065 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, new solution: PC5 DRX configuration for QoS-aware and power-efficient communication. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | r04 agreed. Revised to S2-2006597 | Dimitris (Lenovo) has a question for clarification Apostolos (Nokia) provides clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions for clarification. Apostolos (Nokia) provides clarification and asks for feedback. Ouyang(Huawei) requests clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Apostolos (Nokia) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hao Dong (ZTE) asks question for clarification Dimitris (Lenovo) had an additional question for clarification Apostolos (Nokia) agrees with the changes in r02. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Dimitris (Lenovo). Apostolos (Nokia) provides clarification to Hao Dong (ZTE). Apostolos (Nokia) provides revision 03. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r03. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks some questions for clarification. Apostolos (Nokia) responds to Shabnam (Ericsson) and provides revision 04. LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r04. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006597 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, new solution: PC5 DRX configuration for QoS-aware and power-efficient communication . | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | Revision r04 of S2-2005065. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005235 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: Network assisted power efficient PC5 communication for Pedestrian UEs. | vivo | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Ouyang(Huawei) request for clarification. Wen(vivo) responses to the questions from LaeYoung (LGE) and Ouyang . LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on this solution and asks further question. Wen (vivo) provides some clarifications for LaeYoung (LGE) questions. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Wen (vivo) responses to LaeYoung's comments. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment and cannot accept all versions of this paper. Wen (vivo) responses and provides r03. LaeYoung (LGE) provides comment to r03 and cannot accept all versions of this paper. Ouyang(Huawei) comments and consider necessary FFSs should be added. Shabnam (Ericsson) Supports LGE position, does not believe this proposal is reasonable that extra Uu communication is used to create dynamic DRX on PC5 from network entities that are not aware of PC5 communication. Wen(vivo) responses to comments and provide r04. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept r04 as well. Ouyang(Huawei) provides ENs suggestion. Ouyang(Huawei) proposes to capture this P-CR in the TR even though it is not 'perfect'. Then it can be developed and evaluated in next meeting. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept all versions and proposes to NOTE this paper. Wen (vivo) can accept Ouyang's suggestions and provide some clarifications to LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) thinks this solution is NOT needed. Wen(vivo) provides more clarifications. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005287 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: Reduction of RX and TX for Pedestrian UEs Over PC5. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | Lei (Tencent ) provide comments and respond to Adrian (vivo). Hong (Qualcomm) comments. LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on this solution and proposes to NOTE this paper. Lei (Tencent) responds to Hong(Qualcomm) and LaeYoung (LGE) and provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) does not understand what this solution proposes in r01. Lei (Tencent) provides comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) asks clarification. Guillaume (MediaTek) proposed to note this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005400 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: negotiate a PC5 DRX for Unicast communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006598 | LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). LaeYoung (LGE) provides r01. Ouyang(Huawei) is fine with r01 . Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hong(Qualcomm) and provide r02. Hong(Qualcomm) comments and fine with r02. LaeYoung (LGE) is also fine with r02. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006598 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: negotiate a PC5 DRX for Unicast communication. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005400. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005401 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution for PC5 Tx/Rx mode configuration based on the sensed assistant information. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LG) LaeYoung (LGE) comments and does not accept r00 and r01. Guillaume (MediaTek) requests clarifications. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) and provide r02. LaeYoung (LGE) comments to r02 and is difficult to understand how this solution works. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Guillaume(MediaTek). Guillaume (MediaTek) replies to Ouyang. LaeYoung (LGE) still thinks it is difficult to understand how this solution works. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Guillaume . LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Guillaume (MediaTek) proposed to note this document. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005405 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, New Solution: V2X Layer assisted DRX over PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | CC#4: (Orig - contentious text + editor's note) agreed. Revised in S2-2006050 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung . LaeYoung (LGE) has doubt about how this solution can guarantee safety for VRU. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) . LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions to Ouyang (Huawei). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE). Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to Hong(Qualcomm) and provide r03. Please neglect r02. LaeYoung (LGE) has big doubt how this solution work. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE) and provide r04. . LaeYoung (LGE) asks why we need to handle the solution which all/main decisions are made in Application Layer. Ouyang(Huawei) replies LaeYoung. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung( LGE). 1) An FFS has address you concern. 2) Whether it is useful or not, should be part of the evaluation, which will be hopefully performed next meeting. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept all versions because the proposed Wake Up Notification is considered not needed. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE) and consider the solution is feasible. LaeYoung (LGE) cannot accept all versions because the concern was not resolved and proposes to NOTE this paper. LaeYoung (LGE) has additional concern related to the privacy issue on the SRC L2 ID used for Incomplete RX Announcement message and also doubt on VRU's safety. Wen (vivo) agrees with r04. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE) 1) doesn't spot any 'privacy' issue; . 2) request LaeYoung(LGE) to clarify her doubt on 'VRU's safety' LaeYoung (LGE) clarifies questions from Ouyang(Huawei). LaeYoung (LGE) objects to all versions. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks also to postpone this pCR, since we need sometime to understand these new states introduced and its relation to NAS layer as indicated at step 0. Key Issue change is being discussed in parallel so best to address them together at next meeting. Ouyang(Huawei) reminds Shabnam (Ericsson) that her comment is on S2-2005404, not this email thread Ouyang(Huawei) requests this contribution to be discussed in CC#4. R05 is provided to address ENs to address concerns from some company. R06 is provided to further remove the description that some company has concern. Ouyang(Huawei) requests this contribution to be discussed in CC#4. R05 is provided to add ENs to reflect concerns from some company. R06 is provided to further remove the description that some company has concern. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006050 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, New Solution: V2X Layer assisted DRX over PC5. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Revision (Orig - contentious text + editor's note) of S2-2005405. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005443 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution for Key Issue #1: Solution for applying PC5 DRX configuration for pedestrian UEs. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | r06 agreed. Revised, merging S2-2005444, to S2-2006599 | Yang Xu (OPPO) asks a question. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 including aspects of S2-2005444 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r03 LaeYoung (LGE) provides r04. Hong (Qualcomm) provides comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Hong (Qualcomm) and provides r05 Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r06 with additional clarifications LaeYoung (LGE) is fine with r06. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006599 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution for Key Issue #1: Solution for applying PC5 DRX configuration for pedestrian UEs. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Revision r06 of S2-2005443, merging S2-2005444. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005444 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution for Key Issue #1: Solution for PC5 DRX configuration via NAS signalling. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Merged into S2-2006599 | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005443 (Lenovo, Motorola Mobility). Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to LaeYoung LaeYoung (LGE) still thinks the proposal in this paper can be part of S2-2005443 (Lenovo, Motorola Mobility). Dimitris (Lenovo) agrees to merge S2-2005444 into S2-2005443 LaeYoung (LGE) thanks to Dimitris (Lenovo) for merging this paper to 5443. :) ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Merged |
| 8.12 | S2-2005445 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: Solution for Key Issue #1: Solution for PC5 DRX synchronisation. | Lenovo, Motorola Mobility | Rel-17 | Noted | Wen (vivo) provides comments for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Wen Ouyang(Huawei) ask questions for clarification. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to Ouyang Adrian (vivo) asks for some clarification Hong (Qualcomm) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies. LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on this solution and comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) responds to LaeYoung Dimitris(Lenovo) responds to Ouyang Adrian (vivo) comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) comments LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r01 LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions to r01. Dimitris (Lenovo) provides r02 to address comments from LaeYoung (LGE) LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on r02 as well and provides comment. LaeYoung (LGE) confirms that this paper should be NOTED. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | S2-2005602 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, New Sol: V2P parameter provisioning. | Samsung | Rel-17 | r02 agreed. Revised to S2-2006600 | LaeYoung (LGE) comments and proposes to merge this paper to S2-2005443 (Lenovo, Motorola Mobility). Lei (Tencent) comments. Changhong (Intel) raises concern on Geographical area information for P-UE and provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) provides r02. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies and provides r03. Lei (Tencent) provides comments to r02. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to Lei (Tencent). LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) and probably Changhong (Intel) as well. Lei (Tencent) share the view with Hoyeon (Samsung). Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) and provides r04. LaeYoung (LGE) can accept only r02 and objects to r00, r01, r03, r04. Hoyeon (Samsung) replies to LaeYoung (LGE) and asks a question for LGE' objection. LaeYoung (LGE) provides answers. Hoyeon (Samsung) can live with r02 for now and come back next meeting. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 8.12 | S2-2006600 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI #1, New Sol: V2P parameter provisioning. | Samsung | Rel-17 | Revision r02 of S2-2005602. Approved | Approved | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005767 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI#1, New Sol: Triggering of Pedestrian UEs for Power Saving. | Tencent | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper. Lei (Tencent) respond to LaeYoung(LGE) and think part of 5767 is similar to 5602 on geographical area. LaeYoung (LGE) answers to Q from Lei (Tencent). Lei (Tencent) provide comments. Changhong (Intel) shares same view with LaeYoung. Leo (Deutsche Telekom) objects this solution. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | New solution for new KI | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005404 | P-CR | Approval | 23.776: KI x: New solution: Enhance Uu RRC inactive state to optimize PC5 transmission. | Huawei, HiSilicon | Rel-17 | Noted | LaeYoung (LGE) has concern on this solution and comments. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung and provide r01. LaeYoung (LGE) asks some questions for clarification. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung and provide r02. Shabnam (Ericsson) asks for some clarification. LaeYoung (LGE) comments and has concern on new indication/info over NAS as well as new information to NG-RAN without clear justification. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because her concern is not just about new information to NG-RAN but also about new indication/info over NAS. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung(LGE). The concern from LGE is reflected in the EN's. Huawei request justification on 'mode 1 in RRC_INACTIVE is not scope of RAN WI (NRSL_enh)'. LaeYoung (LGE) proposes to NOTE this paper because she still has concern on new indication/info over NAS as well as new information to NG-RAN without clear justification. In addition, mode 1 in RRC_INACTIVE is not scope of RAN WI (NRSL_enh). Ouyang(Huawei) request LaeYoung(LGE) to provide details question for the 'new indication/info over NAS' . LaeYoung (LGE) responds. Ouyang(Huawei) replies to LaeYoung (LGE). ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 8.12 | - | - | - | LS Out | - | - | Docs:=1 | - | |
| 8.12 | S2-2005041 | LS OUT | Approval | [DRAFT] LS on PC5 DRX operation | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Noted | Changhong (Intel) provides r01. LaeYoung (LGE) comments. Ouyang(Huawei) consider it's too early to send the LS to RAN. Ouyang(Huawei) proposes to postpone this LS. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 9 | - | - | - | Project Planning and Management | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | New and Revised Work Items, Cover sheets for completed work items | - | - | Docs:=17 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2005872 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Presentation of TR TR 23.700-20 for information to TSG SA. (FS_IIoT) | Nokia (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Approved | Devaki (Nokia) announces TR cover page that was uploaded. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 9.1 | S2-2005873 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.757 for information to TSG SA. (FS_5MBS) | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | CC#4: Noted. The rapporteur was asked to submit this directly to TSG SA. Revised to S2-2006053. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006053 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.757 for information to TSG SA. (FS_5MBS) | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005873. Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 9.1 | S2-2005915 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.754 for information to TSG SA (FS_ID_UAS_SA2) | Qualcomm (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Generated during CC#3. Approved. Revised to S2-2006054. | Stefano (Faccin) submits first version of the document, as suggested in CC#1. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006054 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.754 for information to TSG SA (FS_ID_UAS_SA2) | Qualcomm (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005915. Revised to S2-2006064. | Stefano (Faccin) submits first version of the document, as suggested in CC#1. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006064 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.754 for information to TSG SA (FS_ID_UAS_SA2) | Qualcomm (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2006054. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | S2-2006056 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page for presentation of TR 23.700-40 to TSG SA for information | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | S2-2006057 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page for presentation of TR 23.700-93 to TSG SA for information | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | S2-2005916 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.761 for information to TSG SA (FS_MUSIM) | Intel (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Generated during CC#3. r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006027. | Saso (Intel) provides the initial TR 23.761 cover page, as suggested in CC#1. Saso (Intel) provides r01. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006027 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.761 for information to TSG SA (FS_MUSIM) | Intel (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005916. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | Revised SID/WID | - | - | Docs:=2 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2005558 | SID REVISED | Approval | Revised SID: Architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services. | Huawei | Rel-17 | r01 agreed. Revised to S2-2006026. | Puneet (Chairman) Please provide r01 to also update the timelines of the SID. LiMeng (Huawei) provides r01 with updating the timelines of the SID. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006026 | SID REVISED | Approval | Revised SID: Architectural enhancements for 5G multicast-broadcast services. | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision r01 of S2-2005558. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.1 | - | - | - | TR Coversheet | - | - | Docs:=5 | - | |
| 9.1 | S2-2005581 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Presentation of Report to TSG: TR 23.700-07 | Ericsson (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006052. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006052 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover sheet for presentation of TR 23.700-07 to TSG SA#89 | Ericsson (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005581. Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 9.1 | S2-2005361 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover page of TR 23.748 | Huawei | Rel-17 | Approved | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Approved |
| 9.1 | S2-2005423 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover Sheet for TR 23.700-91 for Information to TSG SA | Huawei Technologies France | Rel-17 | Approved. CC#4: r01 agreed. Revised in S2-2006040 | David (Samsung) provides comments. Yannick (Nokia): Nokia provide comments. ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== Xiaobo(Huawei) provides r01 for coversheet per comments from Yannick(Nokia) and David(Samsung) ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.1 | S2-2006040 | TS OR TR COVER | Approval | Cover Sheet for TR 23.700-91 for Information to TSG SA | Huawei Technologies France | Rel-17 | CC#4: Revision r01 of S2-2005423. Approved | Approved | |
| 9.2 | - | - | - | Review of the Work Plan | - | - | Docs:=19 | - | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005867 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_IIoT Status report | Nokia (Rapporteur) | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005868 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eNS_Ph2 Status Report | ZTE Wistron Telecom AB (Rapporteur) | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005869 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_ID_UAS_SA2 Status Report | Qualcomm (Rapporteur) | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005870 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_eNA_Ph2 Status Report | Huawei (Rapporteur) | Duplicate allocation. WITHDRAWN | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Withdrawn | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005871 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_ATSSS_Ph2 Status Report | ZTE (Rapporteur) | Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted | |
| 9.2 | - | - | - | Rel-17 SID Status Report | - | - | Docs:=14 | - | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005843 | WI STATUS REPORT | Approval | FS_MUSIM Status Report | Intel (rapporteur) | Revised to S2-2006055. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised | |
| 9.2 | S2-2006055 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_MUSIM Status Report | Intel (rapporteur) | - | Revision of S2-2005843. Noted | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Noted |
| 9.2 | S2-2004931 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006058. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006058 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eV2XARC_Ph2 status report | LG Electronics | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2004931. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005204 | WI STATUS REPORT | Information | FS_5G_ProSe Status Report | CATT. OPPO | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006061. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006061 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_5G_ProSe Status Report | CATT. OPPO | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005204. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005356 | REPORT | Information | FS_eNA_ph2 Status Report | Huawei, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006063. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006063 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eNA_ph2 Status Report | Huawei, China Mobile | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005356. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005369 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | Report of FS_enh_EC status | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006059. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006059 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | Report of FS_enh_EC status | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005369. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005557 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_5MBS status report | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006060. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006060 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_5MBS status report | Huawei | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005557. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.2 | S2-2005580 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eNPN Status Report | Ericsson (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2006062. | ==== 4.2, 8.X, 9.X Final Deadline ==== ==== Close of meeting ==== | Revised |
| 9.2 | S2-2006062 | WI STATUS REPORT | Endorsement | FS_eNPN Status Report | Ericsson (rapporteur) | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005580. Noted | Noted | |
| 9.3 | - | - | - | Planning future meetings | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 11 | - | - | - | Close of the meeting | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| CC#1 | - | - | - | S2#140E CC#1 | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| CC#2 | - | - | - | S2#140E CC#2 | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| CC#3 | - | - | - | S2#140E CC#3 | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| CC#4 | - | - | - | S2#140E CC#4 | - | - | Docs:=0 | - | |
| 99 | - | - | - | Withdrawn and reserved documents | - | - | Docs:=456 | - | |
| 99 | S2-2004866 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2386 (Rel-16, 'F'): Correction for URLLC GTP-U Path Monitoring | China Mobile | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005209 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, Solution #1 updating with introducing spare slice when the number of UEs exceeds the quota | China Mobile | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004925 | CR | Approval | 23.502 CR2339 (Rel-16, 'F'): Corrections for PDU Session Release Procedure in 5GC | Ericsson | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005425 | CR | Approval | 23.288 CR0180 (Rel-16, 'F'): Location event filter for trusted AF | Samsung, Ericsson | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005114 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI#9, Dispersion analytics as Expected UE Behavior | Ericsson | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005715 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-07: Solution for KI#2: Enabling service continuity with pre-established backup connection | InterDigital | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004997 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#1: Interim evaluation and conclusions | vivo | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004998 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-20: KI#2: Interim evaluation and conclusions | vivo | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005716 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-93: Update to Solution #5 | InterDigital | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005707 | P-CR | Approval | 23.754: Update to Solution #21 | InterDigital | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005598 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1, Update of Solution #3 to detail mission critical service activation | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revised to S2-2005599 WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005599 | P-CR | Approval | 23.757: KI#1 Update of Solution #3 to detail PCC interactions | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai-Bell | Rel-17 | Revision of S2-2005598 WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004855 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#1, KI#2: new solution: Operator controlled UE registration behaviour. | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005031 | P-CR | Approval | 23.761: KI#2, KI#3: new solution: notification via UDM to secondary registration in other USIM PLMN | Nokia, Nokia Shanghai Bell | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005085 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#4 Sol#23: Updates to Solution #23 Network slice quota event notification | NEC | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004852 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: TR23700-91_KI#11_Solution on storing high frequency behaviours and related important information in NWDAF | China Telecom Corporation Ltd. | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2004870 | CR | Approval | 23.501 CR2388 (Rel-16, 'F'): Supplement for TSN QoS information | China Mobile | Rel-16 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005001 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-91: KI #21, New Sol: NWDAF assisting in user plane performance. | III | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn | |
| 99 | S2-2005021 | P-CR | Approval | 23.700-40: KI#2, Sol #7: Updates to enhance the solution | III | Rel-17 | WITHDRAWN | Withdrawn |