CC1: 260001 Mike P presents E//: coversheet as CR, or shold it be living document, should be cat F T-Mo: ok Vicechair: cat F, purpose of meeting is pre R20, so needs to be CR Oppo: update also revision to 1 -> revise 260002 Stavros presents Nokia: also upstate JSON E//: trying to remove "procedure and execution steps" heading, otherwise ok, also Huawei updates template Nokia: in GSMA NESAS the template has this heading QC: clauses affected need to fixed in any way E//: to 4.2.2.9.1: reference K.2.10 does not include this threat, either new threat needs to be inlcuded, or different reference Oppo: add reference number Nokia: check which clause is referenced to E//: has a CR to 33.926 could follow similar approach -> revise 260014 Markus presents Huawei: keep the heading procedure and execution steps Mitre: good to have extra rows, but keep procedure and execution steps Nokia: agree, was like that in all the SCASs, so not delete procedure and execution steps, keep preconditions Nokia: technically nothing is added, in 117, everywhere there is procedure and execution steps, otherwise we have to open everything, not pursue TMo: all SCAS already have this, what is the big concern E//: the aim is to bring inline that the test cases already are written like that. No updates are required, just avoid one sentence and execution steps. Huawei: support as proposed by David, align this with how it is used in majority of test cases. -> discussion continues 260003 Stawros presents remove duplicate and, cat F E//: is this to be converted to pCR vicechair: title needs to be adapted accordingly Huawei: change chould be in R20, not impact R19 anymore, changes are against rel 19, but make it R20 pCR Mitre: there is no living doc for 516 at the moment Huawei: correct, TMo: procedure issue, easier for tracking under working item code it is Vicechair: agenda is limited to pre R19 Chair: R20 can be pre-agreed, but then can be agreed in Goa very quickly -> continue on email 260004 Stawros presents Huawei: content ok, but should be in R20 -> continue on email 260005 Stawros presents same as 0003/0004 -> continue on email 260006 Stawros presents Huawei: in this meeting mainly on content, merge into living CR, can be submitted to Goa meeting E//: 4.2.5: threat reference has been updated, which specific threat under 5.3 is applicable Oppo: is SCAS in scope for Goa? Chair: yes E//: 4.2.3.5.1: reference to industry best practice, would there be something available Nokia: this format has been used before Mitre: ensuring sufficient random identifiers could be applicable discussion on template for all documents in 260014 discussion on procedure "pCR and living document" vs CR in email thread on document 260002 offline call at UTC 13:00 on Tuesday